Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Volume 8, Part 4, November 1994

THE USES OF 'GASTEROMYCETES'


THOMAS LJESS0E & BRIAN SPOONER
Herbarium, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew TW9 3AE

This paper complements an earlier one on the Earthballs (Scleroderma spp.) have been used
folklore of gasteromycetes (Spooner & Lessee, as adulteration for truffles and as a condiment
1994). but, nevertheless, are known to contain toxins
(Lincoff & Mitchell, 1977). They should never be
Culinary Uses consumed in more than the tiniest quantities.
Puffballs, especially the Giant Puffball (Calvatia Stinkhorns and their allies have little culinary
gigantea) , have long had culinary value, despite value. However, the unexpanded eggs and the
the comment by Gerard (1597) that 'Fusse-balls spongy stipes of some species of Phallus are edible
are no way eaten'. They were, for example, and have been used in salads. In places, the eggs
evidently well known to the Greeks and Romans are pickled, and in Germany they are incorpor-
(Buller, 1915), and unsuccessful attempts at ated into sausages and are also sold as a kind of
cultivation were carried out in Denmark more truffle (Dickinson & Lucas, 1979). Similarly, in
than 150 years ago (Ramsbottom, 1953). Most North America several species are regarded as
species are edible in their young stages before the edible in the egg stage (McIlvaine, 1990). In
spores develop, and their use in this condition China, Lysurus mokusin is eaten (Berkeley,
remains widespread. Fries (1986), for example, 1857), and is said to be a great delicacy (Dickinson
recommends Lycoperdon gemmatum (= perlatum, & Lucas, 1979). Perhaps the most important
Fig 1), amongst others, for drying and serving species in this respect is P. indusiatus. This is
with oil, salt and pepper. Indeed, the Giant considered an excellent edible fungus by the
Puffball came 7th in a recent poll of 'Your Top Chinese (Liu, 1984b; Boa, 1988), and is cultivated
Twenty Fungi' (Legg, 1990). However such use is for this purpose, both indoors and outdoors, in
not universal. The North American Iroquois, for parts of China. Dictyophora rubrovolvata is also
example, according to one source, referred to considered an excellent edible fungus in China
puffballs as 'Devil's bread' (Burk, 1983). Accord- (Liu, 1984b).
ing to Smith (1951), some species of Calvatia and In New Zealand, the gelatinous volva of species
Lycoperdon have been implicated in 'violent of Ileodictyon is eaten (Berkeley, 1857), the
gastrointestinal upsets', though this may result fungus being called by the Maoris 'Thunder dirt'
from eating specimens which are nearing (Steele, 1888). Clathrus ruber (Fig 2) is also said
maturity. to be edible in the egg stage (Marchand, 1976),
In Central Africa, at least in Zambia and although an early account by Barla (1858) de-
Malawi, puffballs are recognised and have scribes a case of poisoning by this species. Cooke
received folk names but they have no particular (1862) also gives an alarming report of the
significance (Piearce, 1981; Morris, 1984). How- development of violent convulsions and loss of
ever, various species of Calvatia, Langermannia, speech in a young girl after eating this fungus. It
Lycoperdon and Vascellum are used as food items reportedly took 'some months' before she was fully
in some areas (Rammeloo & Walleyn, 1993). In recovered. Several species of phalloid, including
North America, puffballs were apparently an P. rubicundus and Dictyophora multicolor, are
important food commodity amongst Indian tribes. also regarded as poisonous (Liu, 1984a, b). It is
For example, the Zuni used large quantities of also reported by Oso (1976) that the Nigerian
puffballs, both fresh and also dried for use during people in general regard stinkhorns as poisonous.
the winter months (Burk, 1983). They were also
generally popular used in soups. In Mexico, a Medical Uses
species of Lycoperdon is eaten by the Tepetuan of Uses for puffballs and stinkhorns, and other
Durango (Gonzalez, 1991). gasteroid fungi, in medicine are many and wide-


Volume 8, Part 4, November 1994

spread. Use of the fruitbodies themselves has a et al ., 1987). The use by the North American
long history, but drugs and other active com- Paiute of Battarraea and other puffballs to treat
ponents have comparatively recently been iso- swellings and sores is also given by Burk (1983).
lated from some species. In China, Battarraea species are used in a similar
way, and also to 'relieve internal heat or fever'
(Ying et al., 1987). In Namibia, the spores of a
Folk-medicine: puffballs, earthstars and species of Battarraea are used by the Topnaar
bird's-nests people (Van den Eynden et al., 1992). These are
The most frequent use of puffballs is probably as a rubbed on the skin to treat burns, and are mixed
wound dressing. The giant puffball has been used with oils to form a protective skin ointment and a
to form a surgical dressing (Rolfe & Rolfe, 1925), cosmetic.
and the powdery spore mass of many species is a Other uses to which giant puffballs have been
useful and effective styptic. Such use was wide- put include treatment of diarrhoea in calves in
spread in Europe and North America but also Finland (Dickinson & Lucas, 1979) and Germany
found in India (Rai et al ., 1993). According to (Brendegaard, 1987), and a similar and current
Swanton (1917), larger puffballs were at one time use for Bovista graveolens in southern Bohemia
commonly kept in farmhouses and cottages in was reported by Kotlaba (1955). In North
West Sussex, and the custom still lingered on in America, the Potawatomi Indians use Morganella
the season of 1916. The dried and powdered young subincarnata as a cure for headaches and refer to
fruitbodies were used in a similar way by some it as the 'headache berry' (Smith, 1933; Burk ,
North American Indians (Burk, 1983). It should 1983). Some puffballs , including several Mexican
also be noted that the inhalation of thes spores of species of Lycoperdon and Va scellum, have also
puffballs can cause a lung disease known as been reported to have hallucinogenic properties.
lycoperdonosis (Henriksen, 1976). Heim (1978) discusses two species of Lycoperdon
In China , many puffballs and related fungi, which have ritual use in the Tlaxiaco region, and
including species of Battarraea, Tulostoma, are also considered to have therapeutic properties.
Bovista, Bovistella, Calvatia, Lycoperdon , Myce- However , despite being used for such purposes ,
nastrum, Astraeus, Geastrum, Pisolithus, Sclero- these fungi appear to have no active principles
derma, and Cyathus are considered as medically (Ott et al., 1975 ).
important (Liu, 1984a, b; Ying et al., 1987). These Puffballs and earthstars were used by some
are mostly used as a styptic, many also being North American Indians to prevent infection after
commonly considered to reduce swelling and to severing of the umbilical cord. Another strange
detoxify. Some species are used for throat ail- use of the spores of earthstars noted by Burk
ments, and others to reduce fever and coughing, as (1983) was to cure discharges from the ear, and
a painkiller or for stomach ache. Some are puffball spores were similarly used as a remedy
believed effective against cancer in mice; indeed, for ear ache. Another use of puffballs, as a cure for
a 100% success rate has been demonstrated for sprains, was evidently practised in Himalayan
Lycoperdon pyriforme against two forms of cancer areas such as eastern Nepal by the Lepchas
in white mice (Ying et al., 1987). In Nigeria, (Hooker, 1854). Smouldering fruitbodies were
Calvatia cyathiformis is used by the Yoruba applied directly to the skin. The Lapps have a
people as a cure for leucorrhoea or 'pneumaturia' similar use for Fomes [omentarius, the burnt flesh
[sic]. Fruitbodies are ground up with other then being covered with a piece of dried puffball
ingredients, either herbs or fungi, or 'African (Lysebraate, 1993).
black soap', and applied orally or as a wash (Oso, Some tribes from Madhya Pradesh, India, use
1977). species of Cyathus (Fig 3) to soothe sore eyes (Rai
The use of Tulostoma in North America by the et al., 1993), but there appear to be no other known
Ramah Navaho to cure leg bone fractures in medical uses for bird 's-nest fungi. These tribes
sheep, by application either as a poultice or as an also employ Astraeus to treat burns, mixing the
infusion, was given by Burk (1983). Species of spore mass with mustard seed oil to form an
Tulostoma are also employed in China to control ointment (Rai et al., 1993). A similar use for this
swellings and bleeding, and to allay fever (Ying fungus is found in China (Ying et al ., 1987).

III
Volume 8, Part 4, November 1994

part of a preparation to treat leprosy (Oso, 1976).


Some other phalloids are considered to have
medical significance in various parts of the world.
In China, Lysurus mokusin is reputed to be a cure
for gangrenous ulcers (Maclvlillan, 1861; Dickin-
son & Lucas, 1979) and, according to Ying et al.
(1987), it has anticancer properties. Also in
China, Simblum gracile is used for oesophageal
cancer and gastritis (Ying et al., 1987). In France,
clathrus ruber has, quite without foundation, been
suspected of causing cancer, skin lesions, sick-
ness, convulsions and delirium (Dring, 1980;
Dickinson & Lucas, 1979). It is referred to in
France as 'Cancrou' or Cancer (Badham, 1863).

Modern studies
The anti-tumour drug 'Calvacin' has been
extracted from the giant puffball (Beneke, 1963)
and other species, notably Bovistella radicata, B.
Fig 1 Lycoperdon perlatum. A common puffball,
long recognised as a good edible fungus when young. sinensis, Pisolithus tinctorius and Scleroderma
From Fries, Sveriges titliga och giftiga svampar, cepa (Ying et al., 1987). This compound is present
1861: pI. 73. only in young fruitbodies and in very tiny quanti-
ties, but higher yields are reported from cultures.
Folk-medicine: stinkhorns
Stinkhorns appear to have had little medical
significance in Britain, although in 1865 they
figured prominently in discussions in 'The Times'
newspaper as a possible cause ofcholera and other
epidemics (Brendegaard, 1983). However, else-
where in Europe, and in India and China, stink-
horns have been used in a variety of ways. In the
Middle Ages, especially, they were used to treat
epilepsy, rabies, kidney problems, gout, rheuma-
tism and bleedings. The effectiveness of Phallus
impudicus is also noted by Ying et al. (1987).
Phallus rubicundus is reported by Rai et al.,
(1993) to be used in Central India against typhoid,
and also to ease labour pains. This species is also
used in China, but as a treatment for 'sores,
subcutaneous ulcers, scabies, carbuncle and fis-
tula' (Ying et al., 1987), and to promote healing
(Liu, 1984a). The dried and powdered gleba is
mixed with oil and applied as an ointment.
Species of the closely-related genus Dictyophora
are used in China as a treatment for dysentery,
and dried fruitbodies of D. multicolor, immersed
in 70% alcohol and applied externally, are
employed as a treatment for athlete's foot. In
Fig 2 Clathrus ruber - a striking species once
Nigeria, Phallus aurantiacus and other stink- wrongly reported as toxic and a causer of cancer.
horns are used by traditional Yoruba doctors as

..
(Photo: Thomas Leessee)
Volume 8, Part 4, November 1994

More recently, calvatic acid, another active factor mare of our dreams in which we lie stretched upon
with antibiotic and anti-tumour properties, has the funeral bier, sensible to the weeping of
been isolated from another species, Calvatia friends, aware of the last screw being fixed in the
craniiformis (Umezawa et al., 1975). Another drug coffin, and the last clod clapped down upon us in
complex, cyathin, has been extracted from the the churchyard, and are yet unable to move a
bird's nest fungus Cyathus striatus (Fig 3) and hand or a lip for our own deliverance'! Use of the
others. This complex includes seven different smouldering fruitbodies in Germany to smoke
compounds (Brodie, 1975) and is antibiotic and chests used for storage of grain is also reported by
bacteriostatic. Brendegaard (1987).
The North American Indians had a variety of
Other Uses other uses for puffballs, summarised by Burk
Puffballs have been put to a variety of practical (1983). These include use as a dusting powder or
uses other than the medical and culinary aspects baby talc (Smith, 1923; 1933), as a rattle by
discussed above. It was suggested by Watling medicine men, as necklaces, 'prized because of the
(1975) and by Watling & Seaward (1976) that the delicate odor they gave off, and for children's
presence of Bovista nigrescens in prehistoric games. The flesh of some species was used as a pin
dwellings in Orkney, Scotland and other sites in cushion in parts of Denmark (Brendegaard, 1987).
England could indicate their use as insulation
against draughts in buildings. The latter authors
also speculated on the use of puffballs in early
times as kindling for fires. This use as tinder was
given by Cooke (1962) for Calvatia gigantea, and,
indeed, for puffballs generally according to
Gerard & Johnson (1633). Their fruitbodies were
also useful for transferring fire from place to
place, for which use they were known as 'Lucer-
narum Fungi' (Gerard, 1597; Gerard & Johnson,
1633). Addition of saltpetre to dried fruitbodies of
Handkea utriformis (Fig 4) to produce Amadou is
also reported by Cooke (1862). Amadou, tradi-
tionally prepared from the flesh of Fornes {omen-
tarius, is used either as tinder, or in medicine as
a haemostatic or for packing under nail margins. Fig 3 Cyathus striatus - one of several bird's-nest fungi which
One of the main uses for puffballs, especially C. yield the drug-complex cyathin. (Photo: Gordon Dickson)
gigantea, was in beekeeping. Fumes, from the
smouldering fruitbody placed beneath the hive,
calm the bees to facilitate access. Puffballs have
been so used in Europe, including the British Isles
(Swanton, 1917; Dickinson & Lucas, 1979), and
throughout North America (Burk, 1983), and it is
a long established practice. The tranquillising
properties of the fumes are actually due to an
excess of carbon dioxide rather than to any special
anaesthetic properties. However, puffballs were
at one time employed more generally as an
anaesthetic, being successfully used in operations
according to Berkeley (1860). MacMillan (1861)
states in prosaic fashion that they deprive 'the
patient of speech, motion and sensibility to pain,
while he is still conscious of everything that
.
Fig 4 Handkea (Caluatia) utriformis - an edible puffball, also
happens around him; thus realising that night- once used to produce amadou. (Photo: Gordon Dickson)

1&
Volume 8, Part 4, November 1994

Finally, the hygroscopic nature of Astraeus hygro- Fries, E. (1861) Sveriges iitliga och giftiga svampar.
metricus led to the practical use of this species as a Stockholm.
Gerard, J. & Johnson, T. (1633) The Herball or
hygrometer according to Rolfe & Rolfe (1925). generall historie ofplantes. London.
Pisolithus tinctorius is popularly known as 'Dye Gonzalez, E.M. (1991) Ethnobotany of the southern
Ball' due to the abundant yellow and purple dyes Tepetuan of Durango, Mexico: I. Edible mushrooms.
which it contains (Stevens & Kidd, 1953). In J. Ethnobiol. 11: 165-173.
"Gooch, B. (1767) A Practical Treatise on Wounds
Europe, and elsewhere, this species is used for
and other Chirurgical Subjects. Norwich.
dyeing of cotton and wool, and in the Canary Heim, R (1978) Les champignons toxiques et halluci-
Islands and parts of Italy for dyeing silk (Rolfe & nogenes. Ed. 2. Paris.
Rolfe, 1925). "Henriksen, N.T. (1976) Lycoperdonosis. Acta
There are few practical uses to which stink- paediatr. Scand. 65: 643-645.
Hooker, J.D. (1854) Himalayan Journals. vol. 2.
horns have been put. However, in China, the London: John Murray.
boiled liquid from species of Phallus and Dietyo- Kotlaba, F. (1955) Prasivka uherska - Bovista
phora is used as short-term food preservative hungarica Holl. - houba nasich poll. Ceska Mykol. 9:
(Ying et al., 1987). It is also interesting to note 169-171.
Legg, A. (1990) Your Top Twenty Fungi. Bull.
that, although they are not luminescent, accord-
British mycol. soc. 4: 23-24.
ing to Ramsbottom (1953), stinkhorns as well as Lincoff, G. & Mitchell, D.H. (1977) Toxic and
Clathrus ruber are reported to emit sufficient Hallucinogenic Mushroom Poisoning. A handbook
radiation to affect photographic film even through for physicians and mushroom hunters. Van Nos-
cardboard! trand Reinholt.
Liu, B. (1984a) [Medicinal fungi in China]. Ed. 3.
Shansi: People's Press.
Acknowledgements Liu, B. (1984b) The Gasteromycetes of China. Bei-
We thank Yi-J ian Yao for assistance in transla- hefte zur Nova Hedwigia 76. Vaduz: J. Cramer.
Lysebraate, I.-A. (1993) Moksa-brenning i Finn-
tion of Chinese text, Alick Henrici for critically
mark. Blekksoppen 61: 11-12.
reading the manuscript, and Gordon Dickson for MacMillan, H. (1861) Footnotes from the page of
permission to reproduce colour transparencies. nature of first forms of vegetation. Cambridge &
London: MacMillan.
References (* not seen) Marchand, A. (1976) Champignons du Nord et du
Bad; .rn, C.D. (1863) A Treatise on the Esculent Midi 4. Perpignan.
Funguses of England. Ed. 2. London: Reeve. McIlvaine, C. (1990) One thousand American Fungi.
"Barla, J.B. (1859) Les Champignons de la Province Indianapolis: Bowen-Merrill Co.
de Nice. Nice. Morris, B. (1984) Macrofungi of Malawi: some
Beneke, E.S. (1963) Calvatia, calvacin and cancer. ethnobotanical notes. Bull. Brit. Mycol. Soc. 18:
Mycologia 55: 257-270. 48-57.
Berkeley, M.J. (1857) Introduction to Cryptogamic Oso, B.A. (1976) Phallus aurantiacus from Nigeria.
Botany. London: Baifliere. Mycologia 68: 1076-1082.
Berkeley, M.J. (1860) Outlines ofBritish Fungology, Oso, B.A. (1977) Mushrooms in Yoruba mythology
London: Reeve. and medicinal practices. Economic Botany 31:
Boa, E. (1988) Edible stinkhorns? Mycologist 2: 367-371.
107-108. Ott, J., Guzman, G., Romano, J. & Diaz, J.L. (1975)
Brodie, H.J. (1975) The Bird's Nest Fungi. Univer- Nuevos datas sobre los supuestos Licoperdaceos
sity of Toronto Press. psicotr6picos y dos casos intoxicaci6n provocados por
Brendegaard, J.V. (1983) Stinksvamp v- ikke for hongos del genero Scleroderma en Mexico. Bol. Soc.
sarte neeser og ejne, Svampe 8: 85-90. Mex. Mic. 9: 67-76.
Brondegaard, J.V. (1987) Folk og flora vol. 1. Piearce, G.D. (1981) Zambian mushrooms - customs
Denmark: Rosenkilde & Bagger. and folklore. Bull. Brit. Mycol. Soc. 15: 139-142.
Buller, A.H. (1915) The fungus lore of the Greeks and Rai, B.K., Ayachi, S.S. & Rai, A. (1993) A note on
Romans. Trans. Brit. Mycol. Soc. 5: 21-66. ethno-myco-medicines from Central India. Mycolo-
Burk, W.R (1983) Puffball usages among North gist 7: 192-193.
American Indians. J. Ethnobiol. 3: 55-62. Rammeloo, J. & Walleyn, R (1993) The edible fungi
Cooke, M.C. (1962) A plain and easy account of of Africa south of the Sahara: a literature survey.
British Fungi. London: Hardwicke. Scripta Bot. Belg. 5: 1-162.
Dickinson, C. & Lucas, J. (1979) The Encyclopedia of Ramsbottom, J. (1953) Mushrooms and Toadstools.
Mushrooms. Orbis. Collins, New Naturalist series.
Dring, D.M. (1980) Contributions towards a rational Rolfe, RT. & Rolfe, F.W. (1925) The Romance of the
arrangement of the Clathraceae. Kew Bull. 35: 1-96. Fungus World. London: Chapman & Hall.

II
Volume 8, Part 4, November 1994

Smith, H .H. (1923) Ethnobotany of the Menomini Swanton , E.W. (1917) Economi c a nd folk lore notes.
Indians. Bull. Publ. Mus . City of Milwaukee T ran s. Brit. mycol. Soc. 5: 408-409.
4: 1-174. *Umezawa , H.T. et al . (1975) A new antibiotic,
Smit h, H .H . (1933) Ethnobotany of the forest cal vatic acid. J . antibiot. 28: 87-90.
Potawatomi indians. Bull. Publ . Mu s. City of Mil- Van den Eynden, V., Vernemmen, P. & Van Damme,
waukee 7: 1-230. P . (1992) Th e Ethnobotany of th e Topnaar. Universit-
Sm ith , A.H. (1951) Puffballs and their allies in eit Gent.
Michigan . Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Watling, R. (1975) Prehistoric Puff-balls. Bull. Br.
Spoone r, B.M. & Leessee, T. (1994) The folklore of mycol. Soc. 9: 112-114.
'Gasteromycete s'. Mycologist 8: 119-123. Watling, R. & Seaward, M.R.D. (1976) Some Obser-
Ste ele, A.B. (1888) Fungus folk-lore. Trans. Edin- vations on Puff- balls from British Archaeological
burgh Field Nats Microsc op. Soc . 2 (2): 175-183. site s. J. Archaeol. Sci. 3: 165-172.
Stevens , E.L. & Kidd, M.M. (1953) Some South Ying, J ., Mao, X., Ma, Q., Zong , Y. & Wen, H. (1987 )
A frican Poisonous and Edible Fungi . Longmans, l eones of Medicinal Fungi from China. Beijing,
Green & Co. Science Press.

British Mycological Society Publications and Reprints


Obtainable from the Society Librarian, c/o The Herbarium, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew , Ri chmond,
Surrey TW9 3AE, al so on sale at forays and some meetings. Prices include postage but pl ease add
£ 1.00 for overseas mailing. Cheques should be payable to 'Br itish Mycological Society'.
British County Foray Lists com piled by G.G. A insworth and Grace Waterhouse. (1989). References
to list s of fungi of the Br itish Isle s. Price £3.00
Guide to the Literature for .the Identification of British Fungi compiled by Margaret Holden.
Edit. 4 (1982). Incl. n ew literature and reprinted classical works. Price £2.00
Keys to British Species of Russula. Edit. 3 (1985) . By R. W. Rayner. The 2nd edition (1974) is
revised to include species recorded in recent years. Price £4.00
Key to the Gasteromycctes of Great Britain. By V . Demoulin and J. V.R . Marriott (1981).
Price £2.00
Keys to Fungi on Dung. By M.J. R icha rd son a nd R . Watling Rev . Edit. (1982 ). K eys dealing wit h
Ascomycetes , Basidiomycetes a nd Mucorales on dung a nd associated debris. Price £2.00
A Tabulation of the Genera of the Agaricales (G ill Fungi and Boletes) based primarily on
Macroscopic Characters. By R. W. Rayner and A .W. Brand (1979). Price £2.00
Non-lichenized Discomycetes. By M.C. Clark (1980). Species recorded in Brita in in r ecent years.
Price £2.00
British Myxomycetes. By B. lng (1968). A census catalogue, fully documented with notes on ecology
and distribution, map and li st of vice-counties. Price £2.00
A Fungus Flora of Warwickshire. By M.G. Clark (E d). (1980). 272pp. Published by BMS for
Birmingham Nat. Hist. Society. Survey with much information on habitats, distribution, etc ., of2600
species, invaluable for su rveys of other areas. Cheques payable to Mrs M.E. Cla rk (Flor a
AlC ), 1 Bittell Lane, Barnt Green, Birmingham B45 8NS. Price £8.00 (B M S Members £7.00)
Guides for the Amateur Mycologist. This ser ies provides an introduction t o various aspects of
mycology of interest to the amateur. Copies available from Dr J.V.R. Marriott at St Swithin's House,
Oldcroft, Lydney, Glouceste r shire GL15 4NF. Plea se add £1.~O for overseas mailing.
Guide for the Beginner. By J .V.R. Marriott (1994). For the complete beginner, with advice on how
best to collect and identify using the pictures and descriptions in popular books. Price £2.00
Guide to Identification with a Microscope. By J. V.R. Marriott (1994). For the person who wi sh es
to progress to using a microscope. Contains detailed a nd illustrated descriptions of the t echniques
used in di ssecting fungi to a llow exa minat ion of t he microscopic characters; also advice on buying an
in strument and setting it up , and much more besides. Price 2.50
Guide to Recording. By J .V .R . Marr iott (1994). Deals with simple recording using pen and paper as
well as the more advanced requirements for inclusion of records in the BMS database on computer.
Price £2.50
Guide for the Kitchen Collector - Preservation and Cooking of Fungi. By Dav e Shorten.
Contains advice on the various ways of preserving fungi and many original r ecipes su pplied by
gou rmet s. Price £3.00

You might also like