Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Therapeutic Value of Psychedelics: Indigenous Wisdom, Colonization, and The Modern Psychedelic Healing Movement
The Therapeutic Value of Psychedelics: Indigenous Wisdom, Colonization, and The Modern Psychedelic Healing Movement
The Therapeutic Value of Psychedelics: Indigenous Wisdom, Colonization, and The Modern Psychedelic Healing Movement
The Therapeutic Value of Psychedelics: Indigenous Wisdom, Colonization, and the Modern
Jeanne Porges
November 4, 2021
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
2
Abstract
Until the early-mid 1900’s, there was little to no interest in psychedelics or hallucinogens in
Western society. Historically, many indigenous populations have incorporated psychedelic plants
into their healing and spiritual rituals, but despite this, knowledge of the value of plant medicine
in Western society did not develop until the synthesis of LSD by Albert Hoffmann in 1938. This
discovery changed the way that psychedelics were perceived in Western culture. When other
scientists like Timothy Leary started using LSD in experiments to explore its therapeutic value,
this influenced an influx of research regarding psychedelics being used in a therapeutic context.
Leary also played a major role in causing psychedelic culture to go mainstream, which increased
the risk of abuse, eventually leading Nixon to categorize psychedelics in Schedule One. Schedule
One is supposed to indicate that a substance does not have any therapeutic value, but despite this
politically driven action, research shows that psychedelics do have therapeutic value. When
discussing the therapeutic value of psychedelics, many ignore the history of indigenous
populations and their knowledge of the therapeutic value of psychedelics. For this reason, this
paper will accurately synthesize the history of both indigenous history of psychedelic use, and
Western psychedelic use in the context of healing and therapeutic value. In addition to this, I will
be analyzing the colonization of psychedelics and describe how we can learn and grow from
colonization today.
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
3
The Therapeutic Value of Psychedelics: Indigenous Wisdom, Colonization, and the Modern
When one thinks of psychedelics, they typically think of the United States in the 60’s,
when the hippie movement was flourishing and psychedelics like LSD and magic mushrooms
went mainstream. When people think of psychedelic culture, they typically think of tie-dye and
the Grateful Dead. Many people regard psychedelics as recreational drugs that fry the brain and
make individuals go crazy. The way in which most Westerners conceptualize psychedelics is
ethnocentric however, and only takes into account the history of psychedelic use in the United
States. Furthermore, those who conceptualize psychedelics in this way are ignorant of the
therapeutic value of psychedelics, and are unaware that psychedelic culture stems from the
therapeutic use of psychedelics. When the therapeutic value of psychedelics is discussed, many
people ignore indigenous history and knowledge regarding the therapeutic value of psychedelics.
This paper will synthesize the history of both indigenous history and Western history of
psychedelic use, in the context of healing and therapeutic value. In addition to this, it is
important to describe the neurology and pharmacology of classic psychedelics, analyze the
describe how we can learn and grow from colonization today, in an era where
When did humans start using psychedelic plants and fungi for their healing and
therapeutic value? Most Western historians would identify the synthesis of LSD in 1938 as the
ethnocentric and it is white washed as well. Western historians, politicians, and citizens alike
tend to ignore, and when they don’t ignore, they tend to demonize the indigenous tradition of
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
4
psychedelic healing and spiritual rituals. Despite the stigma of the indigenous use of
psychedelics, Westerners colonized psychedelics, capitalizing off of them, which is against the
core values of many indigenous populations (Ens, 2021). In addition to this, Western historians
and politicians have historically attempted to misinterpret, revise, and suppress the history of
psychedelics used as medicine for healing within indigenous populations (Ens, 2021). For this
reason, when analyzing the history of psychedelics used in a therapeutic context, it is imperative
to explore different indigenous populations and the way in which they utilized psychedelic plants
and fungi for psychological and spiritual healing. Before analyzing the indigenous history of
To begin with, LSD, psilocybin, and DMT are all considered classic psychedelics and
they are all considered tryptamines, which is according to Michael Pollan, “A type of organic
compound (an indole to be exact) distinguished by the presence of two linked rings, one of them
with six atoms and the other with five” (p. 291, 2019). Tryptamines are found in plants, animals,
and fungi, and they typically serve as a signaling molecule between cells (Pollan, 2019). For
example, the most commonly found tryptamine in the human body is Serotonin, or 5-HT. It just
so happens that all classic psychedelics have an affinity for 5-HT2A receptors, which means that
when the chemical enters the brain, it binds to these serotonin receptors, acting as serotonin
agonists or partial agonists (Pollan, 2018). LSD has an even stronger affinity for this serotonin
receptor than other psychedelics, and when it binds to the receptors, it is, according to Pollan,
“stickier than serotonin itself, making this an instance where the simulacrum is more convincing,
chemically, than the original” (p. 292, 2018). This strong affinity is what makes
scientists to speculate that the human body must produce some other, more bespoke chemical for
the express purpose of activating the 5-HT2A receptor” (p. 292, 2018). Many scientists speculate
that DMT may have served to activate the 5-HT2A receptor in human brains long ago, based on
evidence that shows tiny amounts of DMT in the pineal gland of rat brains (Pollan, 2018),
however there has been no research done involving the measurement of DMT in a human brain,
and in order to strengthen this theory, more research needs to be done, on human participants
In addition to this, the default mode network (DMN) has been found to regulate
conscious experience and sense of self. When under the influence of psychedelics, the DMN is
interrupted, which can create a sense of “ego dissolution” (Polla, 2018), also known as “ego
death” within the psychedelic community. When the DMN is interrupted, one’s sense of self is
also interrupted, causing ego dissolution and out of body experiences. This can be experienced in
a variety of ways, from extrasensory perceptions of the self, to a complete loss of bodily
perception. Many describe this feeling as a sense of unity or oneness with consciousness and the
universe. The DMN also regulates the limbic system, specifically regarding emotion and
memory. When it is interrupted, repressed memories and feelings are once again available to
recall (Pollan, 2018). Perhaps it is this neurological function that allows trauma to resurface and
be processed while under the influence of psychedelics. Pollan references Carhart-Harris saying,
“Psychedelics alter consciousness by disorganizing brain activity” (p. 314, 2018). Pollan goes on
to explain that psychedelics trigger primary consciousness, an older mental system where the ego
is disrupted and the unconscious becomes observable (2018). Another way to conceptualize this
lack of organization in the brain is to frame it as neurogenesis. Pollan explains that the Imperial
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
6
College lab measured neurogenesis in a sober brain versus a brain under the influence of
The specialized neural networks of the brain—such as the default mode network and the
visual processing system— each become disintegrated, while the brain as a whole
becomes more integrated as new connections spring up among regions that ordinarily
kept mainly to themselves or were linked only via the central hub of the DMN (p. 316,
2018).
To put this in simpler terms, when under the influence of psychedelics, the DMN network
is interrupted, and due to this, neurogenesis occurs, which allows parts of the brain to
influence the development of new neural networks and rewire the brain. This may also be a
reason individuals under the influence of psychedelics are able to recall repressed memories,
emotions, and trauma, which is then able to be processed and worked through in a therapeutic
capacity. Neurogenesis also influences visual processing and perception, which can create
increases plasticity in the brain, which makes it easier for individuals to change their brain
Now that the neurology of psychedelics is clear, the focus will shift to the indigenous
history of psychedelic use in a therapeutic context. The first indigenous population of focus is the
Mesoamericans, which include Aztec and Mayan tribes, in what would be modern day Mexico
and Guatemala, as well as other parts of Central America. For example, Sayin provides images in
his article that illustrate Maya mushroom stones in Guatemala (p. 212, 2017), which support the
idea that psilocybin mushrooms were used in Mayan rituals. Sayin also provides images
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
7
depicting a statue in Mexico City that represents the Aztec god of Flowers and dance. The statue
of the Aztec god and the base of the statue are covered in images of mushrooms and other
psychedelic plants (p. 212, 2017). This once again suggests the use of mushrooms as well as
other entheogenic plants in Aztec and Maya culture. In addition to this the author states,
“Hundreds of other archeological items of evidence came out in Mexican, Maya, and Aztec
cultures that psilocybin, peyote, cannabis, and some other psychoactive plants were used during
shamanic and religious rituals” (Sayin, p. 223, 2017). Bourzat, a specialist in indigenous plant
medicine, supports the idea of psychedelics being used in rituals when she says the following:
practices from nearly every place where humans have lived on this planet. Carved
stone mushroom effigies have been found throughout Mexico and Central
Bourzat’s statement is profound in more ways than one. First, the evidence of psilocybin
mushroom use in a healing context dates back to 1000 B.C.E., which predates modern religion
and the birth of Christ. In addition to this, the author highlights an important consideration,
which is the fact that psychedelic plants and fungi seem to historically exist anywhere that
humans existed. For example, Siberian tribes in the Arctic Circle like the Nenets (Kaur, 2021),
Koryaks (Lee, et al., 2018) and the Inuit historically consumed amanita muscaria mushrooms,
which acted as a deliriant and entheogen (Nyberg, 1992). These mushrooms were historically
consumed orally and tribes would prepare them by drying the mushrooms, then boiling them to
remove ibotenic acid which is the toxic component of the mushroom. There are also records of
shamans drinking the urine of reindeer, which would eat the mushrooms and secrete the
psychoactive chemical muscimol in their urine (Nyberg, 1992). The Nenet tribe has records
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
8
which provide support that amanita muscaria or fly agaric mushrooms were used during their
shamanic rituals. According to the author, “The consumption of fly agaric is supposed to help the
shaman get into the necessary trance, during which he communicates with the spirits and gets
answers to his questions” (Kaur, p. 10, 2002). In addition to this, the Shamans had songs that
were intended to be sung while under the influence of the mushroom, and “According to one
tradition the shaman used to sing these songs during the performance, standing on one leg and
imitating thus the external aspect of the mushroom” (Kaur, p. 10, 2002). These examples all
support the fact that Siberian tribes used psychedelics for healing and spiritual purposes. Now
that the Mesoamerican and Siberian histories of psychedelic healing have been explored, it is
The Amazon region nurtures several species of plants that contain the psychoactive
chemical DMT. The most common plant containing DMT in this region is B. Caapi vine, which
is used to make a brew called ayahuasca (Sayin, 2017). This brew, sometimes referred to as a tea,
is traditionally consumed orally during shamanic rituals. According to Sayin, “The name
Ayahuasca comes from the Napo Runa people of the Upper Amazon” (p. 203, 2017). The
ayahuasca experience is described as a healing ritual, which is reinforced when Sayin describes
“icaros” as sacred healing songs that are sung by shamans who are under the influence of the
brew (2017). Sayin describes the Ayahuasca ceremony further when he introduces the idea of
purging, or throwing up, which is prone to happen after ingesting Ayahuasca. This throwing up is
interpreted by shamans as the purging of negative energy, which acts as a cleansing experience,
ultimately bringing healing and peace (2017) to individuals. In addition to this, DMT is known
as the “spirit molecule,” (Sayin, 2017) due to the way in which many individuals perceive spirits
while under the influence of Ayahuasca. Sometimes these spirits appear as plant spirits, deities,
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
9
or even loved ones or ancestors who have died (Sayin, 2017). Many individuals report receiving
messages from these spirits, which tends to give individuals a sense of peace and understanding,
as well as a sense of oneness with the Universe. It is this peace, understanding, and oneness that
offers healing to individuals who undergo these journeys. Ultimately, these tribes believe that the
Ayahuasca experience and sense of community are what allows one to heal both psychologically
and spiritually.
After discussing the history of psychedelics used for healing in Mesoamerican tribes,
Siberian tribes, and Amazonian tribes, it will be easier to conceptualize the contrasting values of
Western society, which led to the colonization of psychedelics. The colonization of psychedelics
began when many primary sources relating to psychedelics were written by white male
researchers in the West who, according to Ens, “exotisized, omitted, misunderstood, and/or
downplayed the importance of indigenous people in their own historical movement” (p. 3, 2021).
Due to these misrepresentations, indigenous populations are not given credit for their rich history
misinterpreted. Ens offers an example of white Western men’s revisionist tendencies when she
describes Aldous Huxley’s book Doors of Perception, which misinterprets the spiritual
significance of peyote rituals among indigenous participants. Specifically, Huxley did not
understand that the significance of the peyote experience lies in the communal experience and
instead he wrongfully assumed that the significance lies in the individuals’ sensation and
perception changes during the peyote experience (Ens, 2021). This misinterpretation ultimately
Hallucinogenic Fungi of Mexico: An Inquiry into the Origins of the Religious Idea Among
Primitive Peoples,” which served to identify contrast between Western norms and the norms of
that in Mexico, where these psychedelic rituals took place. To reinforce this belief, Wasson
stated, “We view this anthropological trait with amused detachment… Confident that it will long
remain unchanged for future students to examine at their leisure” (Ens, p. 4, 2021). When
Wasson states this, he is not only regarding the psychedelic healing rituals of Mexico with
humor, but he also regards the tribes as something for students to examine at their leisure, like
specimens, rather than humans. In saying this, Wasson is dehumanizing indigneous peoples and
in doing so, he is elevating himself to a position of superiority and power. It is this power that he
ultimately uses in order to influence the colonization of psychedelics and their history.
Similarly to the way that indigenous populations haven’t historically received credit for
their contributions relating to psychedelic healing, women haven’t received credit for their
contributions either. For example, Dr. Valentina Wasson, R. Gordon Wasson’s wife contributed
significantly to the fields of mycology and psychedelic sciences. Historically, R. Gordon Wasson
received credit for being “the father of ethnomycology” (Williams et al., 2020), even though
Valentina Wasson arguably had more influence regarding bringing awareness to psilocybin
mushrooms in the U.S (Williams et al., 2020). In addition to this, despite the fact that Valentina
Wasson was the lead author in a text called Mushrooms, Russia, and History, R. Gordon Wasson
was falsely cited as the lead author, when he was actually a secondary co-author (Williams et al.,
2020). Lastly, journals wrote pieces on R. Gordon Wasson’s article “Seeking the Magic
Mushroom,” however, these same journals ignored a publication regarding Dr. Valentina
Wasson’s personal account with psilocybin mushrooms. After examining these examples, it’s
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
11
clear that marginalized groups as a whole are suppressed by the White Western male majority in
regards to academic and historical recognition. When marginalized groups fail to be recognized
for their historical contributions for generations, colonization is the result. Colonization
inherently influences the Western perception of psychedelics and impacts the application of
psychedelic-assisted therapy.
“Modern” will refer to the synthesis of LSD in 1938 up until the present day. As mentioned,
Albert Hoffman synthesized LSD in 1938, but he did not intentionally dose himself until April of
1943 (Nichols et al., 2020), which is called Bicycle Day, due to Hoffman having to ride his
bicycle home while under the influence of LSD. After this discovery, the therapeutic value of
LSD was heavily explored and LSD-assisted psychotherapy was even incorporated into the
psychiatric field for the treatment of alcoholism and addiction. By 1951, there were over 100
articles published on LSD in medical journals and by 1961, there were over 1000 articles
published (Nichols et al., 2020). After World War II ended, LSD was used in order to treat “shell
In addition to this, between 1953 and 1969, over 7,000 patients were treated for
addiction with LSD-assisted psychotherapy, with between ten and twenty drug sessions, and two
drug-free sessions per week (Nichols, et al., 2020). It is clear from this minimal amount of data
that LSD showed promise in its therapeutic value. So what changed? It is noted that only five out
of five thousand participants committed suicide (Nichols, et al., 2020), which is a significantly
low rate. Why is it then, that the narrative changed to advocate against psychedelics? When
psychedelics became mainstream with the help of Timothy Leary, the Nixon administration
cracked down on all psychedelics, categorizing them in Schedule One. The Drug Amendments
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
12
of 1962 also mandated that a drug show safety and effectiveness before its approval (Nichols, et
al., 2020). This amendment prevented any new clinical research trials on psychedelic-assisted
therapy from being approved by the FDA. This ultimately led to the end of psychedelic use
Since then, the field of psychiatry has been relying on psychotropic drug therapy to treat
individuals who are diagnosed with mental disorders. Although individuals in drug therapy are
encouraged to recieve talk therapy in conjunction, many choose not to, due to the stigma around
psychotherapy. Even in conjunction with talk therapy, some individuals have disorders that
cannot be treated effectively with drug therapy and talk therapy. These individuals have
diagnoses that are referred to as “treatment-resistant.” It is these individuals who would primarily
benefit from psychedelic-assisted therapies, however this population has been virtually ignored
by the psychiatry field for decades, all due to this amendment from 1962. Despite the fact that
the field of psychiatry withdrew from studying the effects of psychedelics, other researchers took
it up in the 1980s and 1990s. In 1984, the non-profit Multidisciplinary Association for
Psychedelic Studies (MAPS) was created by Rick Doblin with the intention of, according to
MAPS, “Developing medical, legal, and cultural contexts for people to benefit from the careful
uses of psychedelics and marijuana” (Doblin, 2021). This organization has pushed for the ability
to do clinical trials on psychedelics for over three decades and they have had a large part in the
initiative to legalize psychedelics and plant medicine through education and research initiatives
that aim to prove to the FDA that psychedelic-assisted therapy is effective and safe enough to be
legalized.
In addition to MAPS research, Rick Strassman was one of the first researchers to resume
clinical studies of psychedelics in 1994, specifically in relation to intravenous DMT. The first
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
13
study carried out to determine the therapeutic value of psychedelics was done by Moreno and
colleagues in 2006, but their research did not have conclusive results. A more accurate research
study was done by Charles Grob in 2011, regarding the therapeutic value of psilocybin. The
results suggested that when a “modest” dose of psilocybin was given to a participant with
anxiety and cancer, there was a statistically significant decrease in anxiety three months after
treatment and participants also experienced an improved mood that reached significance at six
After reviewing the history of psychedelics used in the U.S. for therapeutic value, it is
clear that between the 1990’s and the present year, a new wave of research has developed, with
the goal of legalizing psychedelic-assisted therapy. The goal isn’t just to legalize this
intervention, but to do so through reinforcing evidence based practice and empiricism. The idea
that the psychedelic experience can be empirically quantified is still developing and will
phenomenologically, it is clear from all that has been observed and recorded in history that
psychedelics inherently have therapeutic value. Now that the therapeutic value of psychedelics is
fully understood, it is essential to discuss the present psychedelic healing movement in regards to
moving forward with the initiative to legalize psychedelics-assisted therapy while being mindful
As mentioned previously, MAPS has played an integral role in pushing for the
psychedelic-assisted therapy into Western culture, but they want this integration to be led by
approved by the FDA for use in the United States by 2023. Oregon has already legalized
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
14
psilocybin for therapeutic purposes, and California is considering doing the same. Chicago has
Ketamine-assisted psychotherapy has also been legalized in 27 states for the treatment of
depression, although there are accessibility challenges related to ketamine treatment due to
insurance not covering this intervention. How can the United States move forward with the
initiative to legalize psychedelic-assisted therapy, in a way that honors and respects the
There are a couple considerations that need to be made from social and financial lenses.
For example, when psychedelic substances are developed there will be profits gained from those
substances, and according to indigenous culture, plant medicine and non-plant psychedelics are
not to be profited off of. For this reason, MAPS Public Benefit Corporation, who are producing
MDMA, are using their income from MDMA to prioritize public benefit over profit. This model
should be used in the future when legalizing other psychedelic-assisted therapies, in order to
protect psychedelics from being capitalized off of, ultimately preventing further colonization of
be implemented in a way that benefits both the individual and Western society, as well as protect
may benefit from it, due to insurance not covering this treatment. It will be imperative that
policies be put in place that hold insurance responsible for covering psychedelic-assisted therapy.
Even with policies in place, there are still many people without insurance, who would not be able
to receive psychedelic-assisted therapy. For this reason, scholarships and grants should be
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
15
available to those who are low income, do not have insurance, or who are otherwise needing
financial assistance. When these structures are implemented, psychedelic-assisted therapy will
psychedelic use for healing purposes, the colonization of psychedelics, and the psychedelic
movement today, it is clear that when all of this information is synthesized, it can be used in
order to inform and guide the United States through the process of legalizing and integrating
psychedelic-assisted therapy into Western culture. Through this psychedelic healing movement,
it is essential to above all, lift up the voices of indigenous populations and let them guide us in
the direction of healing. Indigenous folks were the first known to consume psychedelics and the
wisdom indigenous populations hold is essential to the future of psychedelic-assisted therapy and
entheogens, and Expanded states of consciousness for healing and growth. North Atlantic
Books.
Ens, A. (2021). Silencing indigenous pasts: critical Indigenous theory and the history of
https://doi.org/10.1080/09518398.2021.1942297
Kaur, M., & Toulouze, E. (2002). On Forest Nenets Shaman Songs. Retrieved October 25, 2021,
from https://hal-inalco.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01284702/document.
Lee, M. R., Dukan, E., & Milne, I. (2018). Amanita muscaria (fly agaric): From a shamanistic
hallucinogen to the search for acetylcholine. Journal of the Royal College of Physicians
Nyberg, H. (1992). Religious use of hallucinogenic fungi: A comparison between Siberian and
Doblin, R. (2021). MAPS: About. MAPS. Retrieved October 31, 2021, from
https://maps.org/about.
symbols & figures in myths & religions . SexuS Journal . Retrieved October 9, 2021, from
https://www.academia.edu/38276606/Psychoactive_Plants_Consumed_In_Religious_Rit
uals_Common_Archetypal_Symbols_and_Figures_in_Myths_and_Religions_SAYIN_Ps
THE THERAPEUTIC VALUE OF PSYCHEDELICS
17
ychoactive_Plant_Religious_Ritual_summer_2017_Vol_2_No_5_pdf.
Williams, M. T., Bartlett, A., Michaels, T., Sevelius, J., & George, J. R. (2020). Dr. Valentina