Professional Documents
Culture Documents
We Hear You: Attended The ABR Annual Banquet
We Hear You: Attended The ABR Annual Banquet
We Hear You
Editors
survivors of such catastrophes recovered the bodies of the dead to give them a proper burial, as
we do today.
Were these people really giants?
– Remains for the cemetery would suggest that the people of Jericho were of normal stature.
Do you believe that the Israelite forces were more than the forces of Jericho?
– A recent estimate of the population of Jericho placed it at 3,000. This would have been the
number of people in the city under normal conditions. In time of danger, however, many more
from the surrounding villages would have taken refuge inside the city walls. Even so, the
Israelites would have far outnumbered the people of Jericho. I hope this helps.
Dear ABR team,
Firstly I would like to thank you for your excellent work. Secondly, I would like to ask about some
details related to the website article “Carbon 14 Dating at Jericho.” What was the mistake of the
British Museum with the calibration? Why exactly 150 years? Interestingly, that is the exact
amount of years to disqualify the Bible and enthrone K. Kenyon again. What about the Italian
dates? Are they a possible proof for 1400 BC or are they definitely proof that C14 is not
trustworthy at all?
– Siarl
A Response From The ABR Staff:
What was the mistake of the British Museum with the calibration?
– Errors were made in the operation of the liquid scintillation counters.
Why exactly 150 years? Interestingly, that is the exact amount of years to disqualify the Bible
and enthrone K. Kenyon again.
– If you are referring to the 100-150 year offset between radiocarbon dates and historical dates
in the mid-second millennium BC, that is an approximate range which seems to be dependent
upon location. For a recent study of radiocarbon dates for Egypt, see the Shortland and Ramsey
reference below.
What about the Italian dates? Are they a possible proof for 1400 BC or are they definitely proof
that C14 is not trustworthy at all?
– In 1998 an Italian team obtained radiocarbon samples from a burnt fill in the tower of Building
A1. Building A1 is located at the base of the south side of the tell. It was in existence prior to the
construction of the final phase of the rampart fortification system, as the foundation trench for
the retaining wall for the earthen embankment cut through Building A1, ca. 1500 BC. The
samples are carbonized fragments of poplar wood, undoubtedly from the floor or ceiling of the
upper story of the tower (Marchetti and Nigro 2000: 200, 206-207, 330, 332). Thus, the samples
are unrelated to the destruction of Jericho in 1406 BC.