Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Turn-Taking Patterns in The Characters' Dialogue in The Help (2011) Movie
Turn-Taking Patterns in The Characters' Dialogue in The Help (2011) Movie
ABSTRACT
This study aims to examine the turn-taking patterns and the possible
factors influencing turn-taking in The Help (2011) movie. Particular
conversations were used as the data, namely the conversations between
Miss Celia and Minny (M1) as well as the conversation between Miss
Hilly and Minny (M2). Using the turn-taking theory from Levinson
(1983) as set out by Sacks, Schegloff, and Jefferson (1974), this study
found three turn-taking patterns that occurred in both conversations;
they are self-selection (SS), current speaker selects the next speaker
(CS2TNS), and current speaker continues (CSC). Factors influencing
turn-taking were also found in the conversations; they are social status
and discourse topic. Regarding the turn-taking patterns, self-selection
(SS) is the most common pattern that emerged in M1, meanwhile
current speaker selects the next speaker (CS2TNS) is the dominant used
in M2. The use of SS in M1 indicates that the participants have a close
relationship which is portrayed through the topic being discussed. On
the contrary, in M2, CS2TNS which occurs mostly in the form of
command shows the power of the maid’s master. This suggests that the
use of CS2TNS pattern is mostly influenced by social status.
114
Rifati Hanifa
Turn-Taking Patterns in the Characters’ Dialogue in The Help (2011) Movie
115
Passage 2019, 7(3), 114-128
116
Rifati Hanifa
Turn-Taking Patterns in the Characters’ Dialogue in The Help (2011) Movie
reason of using movie conversations as patterns and the possible factors that
the data are because they can represent the influence the occurrences of turn-taking.
reality of a society through language in
The data were taken from the
which its function reflects meaning.
movie conversations of The Help (2011).
Through the findings of this study, Certain scenes were selected that related
theoretically, it might contribute to the to the turn-taking rules. There were two
development of a turn-taking theory in conversations selected; namely, the
social interaction discourse. Meanwhile, conversation between Minny and Miss
the findings are expected to give a new Celia which was labeled using the initial
perspective on how people with different code M1, and also the conversation
social class communicate in everyday between Minny and Miss Hilly that was
interaction. Furthermore, practically, this labeled using the initial code M2. Then,
pattern of turn-taking can be applied in the data were transcribed using transcript
social interaction to gain successful symbol as proposed by Jefferson (2004, as
communication and contribute to give a cited in Forrester, 2010).
deep understanding on how to interpret
After the data were compiled, they
meaning embedded in the interaction.
were analysed by using the turn-taking
theory from Sacks, Schegloff, and
METHODOLOGY Jefferson (1974) which involved several
This study used a descriptive qualitative steps. First, identifying the utterances in
method supported by a simple terms of turn-taking. Second, categorizing
quantification to show the frequency of the turn-taking patterns found in the data.
turn-taking which in the form of tables. Then, calculating the turn-taking patterns
According to Berg (2001) a qualitative to obtain the percentage of the
research method refers to non-numerical occurrences of turn-taking. Lastly,
data such as description of things, interpreting the results and drawing
meanings, metaphors, concepts conclusions.
definitions, symbols, and characteristics.
Furthermore, to discover the
Thus, this research design suits this study
possible factors influencing turn-taking,
since the data of the study were in the form
this stage focused on investigating the
of conversation in which the turn-taking
social relations among the characters by
117
Passage 2019, 7(3), 114-128
SS 53.16 42
CS2TNS 31.64 25
CSC 15.2 12
Total 100 79
CS2TNS 81.48 22
SS 14.82 4
118
Rifati Hanifa
Turn-Taking Patterns in the Characters’ Dialogue in The Help (2011) Movie
CSC 3.7 1
Total 100 27
119
Passage 2019, 7(3), 114-128
pattern far less than SS which was be used to assure something through direct
31.64%. Current speaker selects the next questions (Oyeleye & Olutayo, 2012).
speaker occurs when the first speaker
In addition to ensure something,
allocates a turn to the next speaker usually
CS2TNS was also used to get response,
by delivering a question, addressing the
the example is as follows.
next speaker’s name, or asking the next
speaker to do something (Levinson, E4. M: Don’t be taking those woman any
1983). The use of CS2TNS in the more pies, you understand?
conversation can show the interpretation (7.0)
of the utterances as can be seen in the MC: <They made me stand there like
following excerpt as follows. I was the vacum salesman>
(.)Why Minny?
E3. M: Okay. (.)Well, what time you
M: =‘Cause they know about you
want me here?
getting (.) knocked up by Mr.
MC: After nine (.) and you gotta leave
Johnny (.) Mad you married one a
before four.
they mens. (.) Especially since
M: Okay Now what your husband say
Miss Hilly and Mr. Johnny had
you can pay?
just broke up, too.
MC: Johnny doesn’t know I’m
bringing in help. (The Help, 2011)
M: =That good vanilla from Mexico (.) E5. MC: >Johnny’s grandma left him this
and. something else re:::al special. house when she died< (.) and then
MH: Mmm:: Johnny’s momma wouldn’t let me
(Minny talks to Miss Hilly’s mom) change a thing (.) But if I had my
M : >No no no< Missus Walters, that’s way, this place would have wall to
Miss Hilly’s special pie. wall whi::te carpet with go:ld
(2.0) trim(h) (.) None of this old stuff.
MH: Momma can have a piece. (1.0)
(3.0) MC: Main house has five bedrooms
MH: Take her one! Go get a plate! and baths (.) Then the pool
house has two more beds and
(The Help, 2011)
baths.
In this context, Minny was no M: When y’all gone have some
longer Miss Hilly’s helper since Minny chillin’ (.) start fillin’ up all those
was fired unilaterally. Here, Minny came beds?
to Miss Hilly’s house and brought her pie
(The Help, 2011)
which was known as the best pie in town.
Though she came as a visitor, Miss Hilly’s The excerpt exemplify above
command was rude as if she still work for indicates CSC pattern as it is shown by
her. Moreover, other utterances in M2 Miss Celia who continued her speak after
were interpreted as a prevalent pattern doing self-selection and a slightly pause.
which is to ask and answer questions. In regard to the function of CSC pattern, it
is mostly used to express an explanation in
Current speaker continues (CSC)
detail. It was evident in Miss Celia’s
This pattern appeared the least in utterances, at first, she did self-selection in
both conversations; M1 (15.2%) and M2 talking about parts of her house, as she
(3.7%). Current speaker continues occurs narrated that her house was the inheritance
when there is no pre-selection or self- of Johnny’s grandmother. Then, CSC
selection after a slight or long pause pattern occurred to explain the house in
(Oyeleye & Olutayo, 2012). The example detail, as Miss Celia said, “Main house
of CSC pattern in the data is shown below. has five bedrooms and baths. Then the
pool house has two more beds and baths.”
121
Passage 2019, 7(3), 114-128
122
Rifati Hanifa
Turn-Taking Patterns in the Characters’ Dialogue in The Help (2011) Movie
123
Passage 2019, 7(3), 114-128
124
Rifati Hanifa
Turn-Taking Patterns in the Characters’ Dialogue in The Help (2011) Movie
125
Passage 2019, 7(3), 114-128
well as the overlaps and interruptions used is current speaker selects the
were found more in those episodes. next speaker (CS2TNS). These
They tend to have the floor in the findings affected by two factors
interaction to deliver their points. which are found in the data; they are
Unlike in Olutayo’s (2013) study, this social status and discourse topic.
study found that the social relation
Self-selection occurred in M1
between a master and a maid can be
denote that the participants have a
determined through discourse topic in
close relationship since both
which the topic related to personal life
participants enact as not having more
obtains more turns and involvement,
authoritative role to each other. This
though neither overlaps nor
may be due to discourse topic that
interruptions include.
plays a major role in determining their
CONCLUSION social relation. Meanwhile, CS2TNS
occurred in M2 mostly dominant by
This study revealed the turn-taking one participant which is Miss Hilly. In
patterns occurred in The Help (2011) M2, the use of CS2TNS is mostly in
movie as well as the possible factors the form of command which indicate
influencing turn-taking shown in the the authority of the master towards
conversation between two masters the maid. This turn-taking pattern in
and a maid; namely, the conversation M2 is influenced by social status.
between Miss Celia and Minny (M1)
In conclusion, it can be
and the conversation between Miss
inferred that even though the
Hilly and Minny (M2). The analysis
participants in the conversation
has shown that both conversations
belong to different social status, the
indicate different number of turn-
turn-taking will be intense if the
taking patterns. It is evident that M1
discourse topic involves both of the
gained 79 turns in which self-
participants. Moreover, to gain more
selection is the most dominant pattern
understanding about turn-taking,
occurred, whereas M2 gained 23 turns
future study could conduct turn-
in which the most prevalent pattern
taking analysis using another genre of
126
Rifati Hanifa
Turn-Taking Patterns in the Characters’ Dialogue in The Help (2011) Movie
127
Passage 2019, 7(3), 114-128
128