Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

"Three Types of Outdoor


Activities" and "Life Between
Buildings"
from Life Between Buildings:
Using Public Space (1987)

Jan Gehl

Editors' Introduction

In the same vein as William Whyte, Jan Gehl uses direct observation, time-lapse photography, and spatial
mapping to understand how people use public spaces and how Ihe physical qualities of places might impact
behavior - not in a deterministic way but in terms of likely possibilities. His concern is with the e)(perience 01
everyday life in the public realm and how the design of buildings and spaces can enhance that experience.
Analyzing spaces in Copenhagen, l1e concluded that certain places were conducive to public social life while
others were not; those thai were, such as central Copenhagen's main street, the pedestrianized Slroget, had
"high quality~ environments, meaning they were pedestrian friendly and comfortable. Gehl's seminal book, Life
Between Buildings: Using Public Space, documents these findings and articulates a vision of traffic-calmed
Cities. The chapters from that book reprinted here. &Three Types of Outdoor Activities· and ~ Life Between
Buildings,· outline his theoretical arguments and present eVidence for the relationship between urban
environmental quality and the amount and type of social activities tha t occur.
For years, Gehl's presentations of his common'sense findings, illustrated with revealing and often humor-
ous images of people stoiely or perilously negotiating poorly des1gned urban environments and happily inhab-
iting well-designed ones, have inspired citizen'S groups to press for changes in their own cities_ Gehl's research,
along with his professional activism, has influenced public policy directed toward increasing the pedestrian
realm and limiting private automobiles, partICularly in Copenhagen, but in many other European cities as welt.
A strong bicycle advocate, Gehl has also championed the expansion of bicycle networks, in the form of
bikeways distinctly separate from pedestrian paths or vehicle lanes.
Gehl's direct observation and mapping research methods offer models that urban designers can easily use
to find out about people's behavior in urban contexts and effectively communicate findings as a basis for
design initiatives.
Gehl has long taught urban design at the School of Architecture in Copenhagen, and also practices urban
design through his firm Gehl Architects. A professional project by the firm which 111ustrates the MGehl" method
is Public Spaces and Public Lile: City 01 Adelaide 2002. Another book, Public Spaces, Public Life, co-authored
with Lars Gemz08 (Copenhagen: Danish Architectural Press, 1996), documents the incremental changes made
to Copenhagen over forty years that turned it from a car-domina ted city into a pedestrian-oriented one. His
most recent book New City Spaces, co-authored with lars Gemz0e (Copenhagen: Danish Architectural Press.
200 1), identifies four types of cities based on how automobiles are accommodated - the Traditional City, the
" THREE TYPES OF OUTDOOR ACTIVIT I ES' ED
klvaded City, the Abandoned City, and the Reconquered City - and presents illustrated case stud ies of good
fMlbhc spaces and well-connec ted public open space systems recently buill in cities around the world .


THREE TYPES OF OUTDOOR ACTIVITIES invite them. This relationship is particularly import-
ant in connection with physical planning because
An ordinary day all an ordinary street. Pedestrians most of the recreational activities that are especially
pass on the sidewalks, children play near fro nt doors, pleasant to pursue outdoors are fou nd precisely
people sit on benches and steps, the postman makes in this category of activities. These activities are
his rounds with the mail, two passersby greet on especially dependent on exterior physical conditions.
the sidewalk, two mechanics repair a car, groups When outdoor areas are of poor quality, only
engage in conversation, This mix of outdoor act· strictly necessary activities occur.
ivilies is inftuenced by a number of conditions. When outdoor areas are of high quality, neces-
Physical environment is one of the factors: a fac tor sary activities take place with approximately the
that influences the activities to a varying degree and same frequency - though they clearly tend to take
III many different ways. Outdoor activities, and a a longer time, because the physical conditions are
number of the physical conditions that influence better. In addition, however, a wide range of
them, are the subject of this book. optional activities will also occur because place and
Greatly simplified, outdoor activities in public situation now invite people to stop, sit, eat, play,
spaces can be divided into three categories, each and so on.
of which places very different demands on the In streets and city spaces of poor quality, only
physical environment: necessary activities, optional the bare minimum of activity takes place. People
aaWities, and social activities. hurry home.
Ntemary activities include those that are more In a good environment, a completely different,
or less compulsory - going to school or to work, broad spectrum of human activities is possible
shopping, waiting fo r a bus or a person, running [Figure 1].
errands, distributing mail - in other words, all Social activities are all activities that depend
aclivities in which those involved are to a greater on the presence of others in public spaces. Social
or lesser degree required to participate.
[n general, everyday tasks and pastimes belong
Qual ity ollhe phy Sical enviroment
10 this group. Among other activities, this group
Poo r Good


includes the great majority of those related to
walking.
Because the activities in this group are neces·
sary, their incidence is influenced only slightly by the
Necessary activities

physical framework These activities will take place
throughout the year, under nearly all conditions,
and are more or less independent of the exterior Optional activities •
environment. The participants have no choice.
Optional activities - that is, those pursuits that are
participated in if there is a wish to do so and if time
and place make it possible - are quite another
matter.
This category includes such activities as taking
a walk to get a breath of fresh air, standing around
enjoying life, or sitting and sunbathing.
~Result ant " act ivities
(Soc ial activille$) •
Figure 1 Graphic representation of the relationship

These activities take place only when exterior between the quality of outdoor spaces and the rate of
conditions are optimal, when weather and place occurrence of outdoor activities.
_ JAN GEHL

activities include children at play, greetings and con- architects and planners can affect the possibilities
versations, communal activities of various kinds, and for meeting, seeing, and heari ng people - possibil·
finally - as the most widespread social activity - ities that both take on a quality of their own and
passive contacts, that is, simply seeing and hear- become important as background and starting point
ing other people. for other forms of contact.
Different kinds of social activities occur in many This is the background for the investigation in
places: in dwellings; in private outdoor spaces, this book of meeting possibilities and opportunities
gardens, and balconies; in public buildings: at to see and hear other people, Another reason for
places of work; and so on; but in this context only a comprehensive review of these activities is that
those activities that occur in publicly accessible precisely the presence of other people, activities,
spaces are examined. events, inspiration, and stimulation comprise one
These activities could also be termed "resultant" of the most important qualities of public spaces
activities, because in nearly all instances they evolve altogether.
from activities linked to the other two activity If we look back at the street scene that was
categories. They develop in connection with the the starting point for defining the three categories
other activities because people are in the same of outdoor activities, we can see how necessary.
space, meet, pass by one another, or are merely optional. and social activities occur in a finely
within view. interwoven pattern, People walk, sit. and talk
Social activities occur spontaneously, as a direct Functional, recreational, and social activities inter·
consequence of people moving about and being in twine in all conceivable combinations. Therefore,
the same spaces. This implies that social activities this examination of the subject of outdoor activities
are indirectly supported whenever necessary and does not begin with a single, limited category of
optional activities are given better conditions in activities. Life between buildings is not merely
public spaces. pedestrian traffic or recreational or social activities.
The character of social activities varies, depend- Life between buildings comprises the entire spec-
ing on the context in which they occur. In the res- trum of activities, which combine to make communal
idential streets, near schools, near places of work, spaces in cities and residential areas meaningful and
where there are a limited number of people with attractive.
common interests or backgrounds, social activities Both necessary, functional activities and optional.
in public spaces can be quite comprehensive: greet- recreational activities have been examined quite
ings, conversations, discussions, and play arising from thoroughly over the years in different contexts.
common interests and because people uknow" each Social activities and their interweaving to form a
other, if fo r no other reason than that they often communal fabric have received considerably less
see one another. attention.
In city streets and city centers, social activities This is the background fo r the following, more
will generally be more superficial, with the major- detailed examination of social activities in public
ity being passive contacts - seeing and hearing spaces.
a great number of unknown people, But even this
limited activity can be very appealing.
Very freely interpreted, a social activity takes LIFE BETWEEN BUILDINGS
place every time two people are together in the same
space. To see and hear each other, to meet. is in It is difficult to pinpoint precisely what life between
itself a form of contact, a social activity, The actual buildings means in relation to the need for contact.L
meeting, merely being present, is furthermore the Opportunities for meetings and daily activities
seed for other, more :omprehensive forms of social in the public spaces of a city or residential area
activity. enable one to be among, to see, and to hear others,
This connection is important in relation to to experience other people functioning in various
physical planning, Although the physical frame- situations.
work does not have a direct influen ce on the These modest "see and hear contacts" must be
quality, content, and intensity of social contacts, considered in relation to other forms of contact and
" LIFE BETWEEN BUILDINGS " lID
Table 1 detour along a main street on the way home or
pause at an inviting bench near a front door to be
High intensity Close friendships among people for a short while. One can take a long
Friends bus ride every day, as many retired people have
Acquaintances been found to do in large cities. Or one can do daily
Chance contacts shopping, even though it would be more practical
Loll' intensity Passive contacts to do it once a week. Even looking out of the
("see and hear" contacts) window now and then, if one is fortunate enough
to have something to look at, can be rewarding.
Being among others. seeing and hearing others,
as part of the whole range of social activities, from receiving impulses from others, imply positive
very simple and noncommittal contacts to complex experiences, alternatives to being alone. One is
and emotionally involved connections. not necessarily with a specific person, but one is,
The concept of varying degrees of contact nevertheless, with others.
intensity is the basis of the simplified outline of As opposed to being a passive observer of
various contact forms [shown in Table 1]. other people's experiences on television or video
In tenns of this outline life between buildings rep- or film, in public spaces the individual himself is
resents primarily the low-intensity contacts located present, participating in a modest way. but most
at the bottom of the scale. Compared with the other definitely participating.
contact forms, these contacts appear insignificant, Low-intensity contact is also a situation from
yet they are valuable both as independent contact which other fonns of contact can grow. It is a
forms and as prerequisites for other, more complex medium for the unpredictable, the spontaneous, the
interactions. unplanned .
Opportunities related to merely being able to T hese opportunities can be illustrated by exam-
meet, see, and hear others include: ining how play, activities among children get started.
Such situations can be arranged . Formalized
• contact at a modest level play occurs at birthday parties and arranged play
• a possible starting point for contact at other groups in schools. Generally, however, play is not
levels arranged. It evolves when children are together,
• a possibility for maintaining already established when they see others at play, when they feel like
contacts playing and "go out to play" without actually
• a source of information about the social world being certain that play 'Nill get started. The fi rst pre-
outside requisite is being in the same space. Meeting.
• a source of inspiration, an offer of sti mulating Contacts that develop spontaneously in con-
experience. nection with merely being where there are others
are usually very fteeting - a short exchange of words,
The possibilities related to the low-intensity con- a brief discussion with the next man on the bench,
tact forms offered in public spaces perhaps can best chatting with a child in a bus, watching somebody
be described by the situation that exists if they are working and asking a few questions, and so forth.
lacking. From this simple level, contacts can grow to other
If activity between buildings is missing, the levels, as the participants wish. Meeting, being
lower end of the comact scale also disappears. The present in the same space, is in each of these cir-
vaned transitional fOnTIS between being alone and cumstances the prime prerequisite.
being together have disappeared. The boundaries The possibility of meeting neighbors and co-
between isolation and contact become sharper - workers often in connection with daily comings and
people are either alone or else with others on a goings implies a valuable opportunity to establish
relatively demanding and exacting level. and later maintain acquaintances in a relaxed and
Life between buildings offers an opportunity to undemanding way.
be with others in a relaxed and undemanding way. Social events can evolve spontaneously. Situ-
One can take occasional walks, perhaps make a ations are allowed to develop. Visits and gatherings
_ JAN GEHL

can be arranged o n short notice, when the mood get the urge to join in, or they get ideas for new
dictates. It is equally easy to "drop by" or ~ loo k in" games by watching other children or adults.
or to agree on what is to take place tomorrow if The trend from living to lifeless cities and resid·
the participants pass by one another's front doors ential areas that has accompanied industrialization.
often and, especially, meet often on the street or segregation of various city func tions, and reliance
in connection with daily activities around the ho me, on the automobile also has caused cities to become
place of work. and so on. duller and more monotonous. This points up anotheJ
Frequent meetings in connection with daily important need, namely the need for stimulation.!
activities increase chances of developing contacts Experiencing other people represents a particu·
with neighbors, a fact noted in many surveys. larly colorful and attractive opportunity for stimu·
With frequent meetings friendships and the contact latio n. Compared with experiencing buildings and
network are maintained in a far simpler and less other inanimate objects, experiencing people, who
demanding way than if friendship must be kept up speak and move about, offers a wealth of sensual
by telephone and invitation. If this is the case, it is variation. No moment is like the previous or the fol-
often rather difficult to maintain contact, because lowing when people circulate among people. The
more is always demanded of the participants number of new situations a nd new stimuli is limit-
when meetings must be arranged in advance. less. Furthermore, it concerns the most important
This is the underlying reason why nearly all chil- subject in life: people.
dren and a considerable proportion of other age Uving cities, therefore, ones in which people can
groups maintain closer and more frequent contact interact with one another, are always stimulating
with friends and acquaintances who live or work because they a re rich in experiences. in contrast
near them - it is the simplest way to stay "in to lifeless citieS, which can scarcely avoid being
touch." poor in experiences and thus dull , no matter how
The opportunity to see and hear other people many colors a nd variations of shape in buildings
in a city or residential area also implies an offer of are introduced.
valuable infonnation, about the surrounding social If life between buildings is given favorable con-
environment in general and about the people one ditions through sensible planning of cities and
lives or works with in particular. housing areas alike, many costly and often stilted
This is especially true in connection with the and strained attempts to make buildings "interest-
social development of children, which is largely ing" and rich by using dramatic architectural effects
based on observations of the surrounding social en- can be spared. Life between buildings is both more
vironment, but all of us need to be kept up to date relevant and m ore interesting to look at in the
about the surrounding world in order to function long run than are any combination of colored con-
in a social context. crete and staggered building fonns.
Through the mass media we are infonned about The value of the many large and small possib-
the larger, more sensational world events, but by ilities that are attached to the opportunity of being
being with others we learn about the more com- in the same space as and seeing and hearing other
mon but equally important details. We discover how people is underlined by a series of observations
others work. behave, and dress, and we obtain investigating people's reaction to the presence of
knowledge about the people we work with, live with, other people in public spaces. l
and so fort h. By means of all this infonnation we Wherever there are people - in buildings, in
establish a confidential relationship with the world neighborhoods, in city centers, in recreational areas,
around us. A person we have often met on the street and so on - it is generally true that people and
becomes a person we ~ know. " human activities attract other people. People are
In addition to imparting infonnation about the attracted to other people. They gather with and
social world outside, the opportunity to see and hear move about with others and seek to place them-
other people can ruso provide ideas and inspiration selves near others. New activities begin in the
for action. vicinity of events that are already in progress.
We are inspired by seeing others in actio n. In the home we can see that children prefer to
Children, for example, see other children at play and be where there are adults or where there are other
"LifE BETWEEN BUILDINGS · Em
ctmn, instead of, for example, where there are Almost without exception cafe chairs throughout the
only toys. [n residential areas and in city spaces, world are oriented toward the most active area
:omparab!e behavior among adults can be nearby. Sidewalks are, not unexpectedly, the very
:ttserved. If given a choice between walking on reason for creating sidewalk cafes.
ldeserted or a lively street, most people in most The opportunity to see, hear, and meet others
~tua!ions will choose the lively street. If the can also be shown to be one of the most import-
croke is between sitting in a private backyard or ant attractions in city centers and on pedestrian
; a semiprivate front yard with a view of the streets. This is illustrated by an attraction analysis
_ people wiU often choose the front of the house carned out on StT0get, the main pedestrian street
where there is more to see. in central Copenhagen, by a study group from the
In Scandinavia an old proverb tells it an: "people School of Architecture at the Royal Danish
rome where people are." Academy of Fine Arts. 7 The analysis was based
A series of investigations illustrates in more on an investigation of where pedestrians stopped
detail the interest in being in contact with others. on the walking street and what they stopped to
Investigations of children's play habits in residen- look at.
tial areas4 show that children stay and play primarily Fewest stops were noted in fron t of banks,
'llilere the most activity is occurring or in places offices, showrooms, and dull exhibits of, for ex-
where there is the greatest chance of something ample, cash registers, office furniture, porcelain, or
happening. hair curlers. Conversely, a great number of stops
Both in areas with single-family houses and in were noted in front of shops and exhibits that had
apanment house surroundings, children tend to a direct relationship to other people and to the sur·
play more on the streets, in parking areas, and near rounding social environment, such as newspaper
me entrances of dwellings than in the play areas kiosks, photography exhibits. film stills outside
designed for that purpose but located in backyards movie theaters, clothing stores, and toy stores.
of single-family houses or on the sunny side of multi- Even greater interest was shown in the various
S!ory buildings, where there are neither traffic nor human activities that went on in the street space
people to look at. itself. All forms of human activity appeared to be
Corresponding trends can be found regarding of major interest in this connection.
where people choose to sit in public spaces. Considerable interest was obselVed in both the
Benches that provide a good view of surrounding ordinary, everyday events that take place on a
activities are used more than benches with less or street - children at play, newlyweds on their way
no view of others. from the photographers, or merely people walking
An investigation of Tivoli Garden in by - and in the more unusual instance - the artist
Copenhagen,' earned out by the architect John Lyle, with his easel, the street musician with his guitar,
shows that the most used benches are along the street painters in action, and other large and small
garden's main path, where there is a good view of events.
!he particularly active areas, while the least used It was obvious that human activities, being able
benches are found in the quiet areas of the park. to see other people in action, constituted the
In various places, benches are arranged back to area's main attraction.
back, so that one of the benches faces a path while The street painters collected a large crowd as
the other "turns its back." In these instances it is long as their work was in progress, but when they
always the benches facing the path that are used. left the area, pedestrians walked over the paintings
Comparable results have been found in invest- without hesitation. The same was true of music.
igations of seating in a number of squares in cen- Music blaring out on the street from loudspeakers
tra! Copenhagen. Benches with a view of the most in front of record shops elicited no reaction, but the
trafficked pedestrian routes are used most. while moment Jive musicians began to play or sing,
benches oriented toward the planted areas of the there was an instantaneous show of lively interest.
squares are used. less frequently. ' The attention paid to people and human activ-
At sidewalk cafes, as well. the life on the side- ities was also illustrated by obselVations made in
walk in front of the cafe is the prime attraction. connection with the expansion of a department
ElZiJ JAN GEHL

store in the area. While excavation and pouring of 2 Ibid,


foundatio ns were in progress, it was possible to see 3 Gehl, Jan. Attraktioner po. S"ogeL
into the building site through two gates facing the Kunstakademiets Arkitektskole. Studyrepon.
pedestrian street. Throughout this period more Copenhagen, 1969; Gehl. Jan. ~Mennesker til
people stopped to watch the work in progress on fods" (Pedestrians). Arkitekten (Danish) 70, no. 20
the building site than was the case for stops in front (1968): 429-46: Jacobs, Jane. The Death and
of all the department store's fifteen display windows Life of Creat American Cities. New York: Random
together. House, 1961; Whyte, William H. The Social
In this case, too, it was the workers and their Life of Small Urban Spaces, Washington D.c.:
work, not the building site itself, that was the Conservation Foundation, 1980.
object of interest. This was demonstrated further 4 Kjcersdam, Finn. Haveboligomradets frellesareal.
during lunch breaks and after quitting time - when Parts I and 2. Part I published by: Den kongelige
no workers were on the site, practically nobody Veterinrer og Landboh0jskole, Copenhagen.
stopped to look. 1974, Part 2 by: Aalborg Universitetscenter,
A summary of observations and investigations ISP, Aalborg, 1976: Morville, Jeanne.
shows that people and human activity are the Planfregning af boms udemil)o i etageboligomrdder
greatest object of attention and interest. Even (Planning for Children in Multistory Housing
the modest fonn of contact of merely seeing and Areas). Danish Building Research Institute,
hearing or being near to others is apparently more report 11. Copenhagen: Teknisk Forlag, 1969.
rewarding and more in demand than the majority 5 Lyle, John. "Tivoli Gardens," Londscape
of other attractions offered in the public spaces of (Spring/Summer \969): 5-22.
cities and residential areas. 6 Gehl. Jan. Atlraktioner po. Slrogel.
Life in buildings and between buildings seems Kunstakademiets Arkitektskole. Srudyreport.
in nearly all situations to rank as more essential Copenhagen, 1969; Gehl, Jan. "Mennesker til
and more relevant than the spaces and buildings fods" (Pedestrians), Arkitekten (Danish) 70, no. 20
themselves. (1968): 429-46: Kao. Louise. "Hvor si dder man
pa Kongens Nytorv?" (Sitting Preferences on
Kongens Nytorv). Arkitekten (Danish) 70, no. 20
NOTES (1968), 445.
7 Gehl, Jan. Allrakiioner po. S/r'0get.
Gehl, Ingrid. Bo-mil)" (Living Environment- Kunstakademiets Arki tektskole. Studyreport.
Psychological Aspects of Housing). Danish Copenhagen, 1969; Gehl, Jan. "Mennesker til
Building Research Institute, report 7l. fods" (Pedestrians). Arkilekten (Danish) 70, no. 20
Copenhagen: Teknisk Forlag. 1971. (1968), 429-46

You might also like