Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

892 BOOK REVIEWS

Herpetological Review, 2021, 52(4), 892–895. Jorge da Silva, Jr., Louis W. Porras, Steven D. Aird, and Ana Lúcia
© 2021 by Society for the Study of Amphibians and Reptiles
da Costa Prudente.
Advances in Coralsnake Biology: with an The book is divided into six parts, including: 1) Systematics
and Taxonomy (Chapters 1–5), 2) Natural History and Ecology
Emphasis on South America (Chapters 6–11), 3) Cephalic Glands and Venoms (Chapters
Da Silva, Nelson Jorge, Jr., Louis W. Porras, Steven D. Aird, and Ana 12–15), 4) Biological Activities of Venoms (Chapters 16–18),
Lúcia da Costa Prudente (eds.). 2021. Eagle Mountain Publishing LC, 5) Accidents involving Coralsnakes (Chapters 19–21), and 6)
Eagle Mountain, Utah (www.eaglemountainpublishing.com). xxxiv + Supporting Activities (Chapter 22). The first chapter deals
775 pp., 459 figures, >100 maps, >700 photographs and illustrations, with species delimitation and integrative taxonomy. Sites et
>700 drawings. Hardcover. US $125.00. ISBN 978-0-9720154-6-2. al. conclude in 36 pages that species delimitation should be
conservative, leading to an underestimation of species diversity
LARRY DAVID WILSON rather than an overestimation, and that it is best to employ
Centro Zamorano de Biodiversidad, techniques of integrative taxonomy to allow for consideration of
Escuela Agrícola Panamericana Zamorano, multiple lines of evidence in support of any particular taxonomy.
Departamento de Francisco Morazán, Honduras; Godoy Pires et al. discuss the historical and taxonomic
1350 Pelican Court, Homestead, Florida 33035, relevance of Coluber lemniscatus, the first formally described
USA; e-mail: bufodoc@aol.com coralsnake, in the second chapter. After a substantial historical
LYDIA ALLISON FUCSKO overview, the authors provide a redescription of Micrurus
Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, lemniscatus and a taxonomic revision of the five species of the
Swinburne University of Technology, Melbourne, lemniscatus group recognized. Several important taxonomic
Victoria, Australia; changes are made in this chapter, including status changes for
e-mail: lydiafucsko@gmail.com M. lemniscatus, M. carvalhoi, and M. frontifasciatus.
A lovely photograph of the coralsnake mimic Anilius
Coralsnakes are endlessly fascinating, stunningly colorful, scytale fronts the third chapter, which deals with the origin
and, yes, seriously venomous snakes confined to the New World. and evolution of elapids, including the New World coralsnakes.
Advances in Coralsnake Biology, comprising 22 chapters by a Zaher et al. present a new phylogenetic hypothesis for the
combination of 60 authors, is an unparalleled achievement family, which recovers a family with 57 genera, including 36
that does considerable justice to a hugely important group of polytypic and 17 monotypic genera, of which seven were not
snakes. We believe that readers will be immediately attracted recovered as monophyletic. The authors acknowledge that even
to the outstanding design of the book, which is a hallmark of given the advances in the study of coralsnake evolution, the
the publications of Eagle Mountain Publishing. The dust cover available evidence does not support the monophyly of Asiatic
of the volume is graced by a painting of a Blue-Crowned or coralsnakes and provides ambiguous support for the monophyly
Amazonian Motmot (Momotus momota) attempting predation of the American coralsnakes; therefore, additional work remains,
on a Langdorff’s Coralsnake (Micrurus langsdorffi), as depicted which is acknowledged by the authors.
against a background of lowland rainforest, by the remarkable The da Silva et al. 26-page fourth chapter provides an
biological artist Carel P. Brest van Kempen. Beyond the title overview of the 85 species of American coralsnakes and is graced
page, readers will encounter the first of the many stunning with an introductory photograph of the “arrestingly beautiful”
color photographs of coralsnakes that decorate this volume and recently-described Micrurus tikuna from Amazonian
throughout, including the South American Coralsnake, Micrurus Colombia. The chapter deals with the external and internal
lemniscatus, taken by William W. Lamar, along with many morphology, osteology, and karyology of these snakes, as well
others distributed throughout this book. The book is dedicated as character limitation and taxonomic instability. The last
to the memory of Dr. Aníbal Rafael Melgarejo Giménez, an portion of this chapter deals with the identification of groups
accomplished Brazilian herpetologist who passed away during of New World coralsnakes, emphasizing the characterization
the production of this book. of the three New World coralsnake genera Leptomicrurus (four
The Preface discusses the contentious relationship between species), Micruroides (one species), and Micrurus (80 species).
snakes and humans, the origin of the name "coralsnake", Readers familiar with the vagaries of coralsnake systematics
and the inexhaustible amount of work that remains to be will note that the authors recognize the genus Leptomicrurus
accomplished for us to understand the biology, natural history, based on structural features, which some other authors would
taxonomy, and phylogeny of these fascinating snakes, as well as combine with Micrurus.
their toxinology. Although this book deals with coralsnakes of the In the 112-page fifth chapter, da Silva et al. present the
genera Micrurus, Micruroides, and Leptomicrurus throughout diversity of Brazilian coralsnakes, which given the size of the
their combined ranges, the principal focus of the book is on country can be expected to be considerable. The authors
those species distributed in Brazil, Argentina, Paraguay, and recognize 38 species of coralsnakes. da Silva et al. recognize three
Uruguay. The next section of the book consists of a three-page species of Leptomicrurus in Brazil and make a range of changes
introduction that addresses background information leading up in support of their taxonomy. Within Micrurus, the species are
to the production of the present volume. Thereafter, 18 pages are divided into three groups, i.e., the monadal species (12 species),
devoted to short sketches of each of the 60 contributors. the bicolored species (one), and the triadal species (21). Many
There were understandable challenges associated with color photographs of preserved specimens and live individuals,
the book’s production, especially regarding the difficulties of along with distribution maps for each species, accompany the
producing a book in English when the majority of the authors species accounts. The authors conclude with an identification
are native speakers of Portuguese and Spanish. In our opinion, key for Brazilian coralsnakes of 11 pages. Also included is an
these challenges were addressed well by the four editors, Nelson identification key for all coralsnake species accompanied by

Herpetological Review 52(4), 2021


BOOK REVIEWS 893

color drawings, generally of the anterior section of the body. The to an evolutionary advantage for both mimic and model when
key is accompanied by expanded drawings of dorsal and ventral surviving humans simply live to kill again and teach others to do
patterns of each species. the same?
Logically, the 23-page sixth chapter by Giraudo et al. covers The macroecology and conservation of the coralsnakes in
the eight species of Micrurus that occupy Argentina, Paraguay, South America is the subject of the 20-page ninth chapter by
and Uruguay (although only seven are included in their Table Carina Terribile et al. As noted by the authors, macroecology
1; M. frontalis is missing). The species accounts are set up in a attempts to understand the emergent patterns of biodiversity
fashion similar to those in the previous chapter, and they are and to apply that understanding to the study of biodiversity
illustrated with photographs of mostly preserved specimens, conservation. The authors note that the establishment of
as well as color distribution maps. Interestingly, the first page protected areas often does not follow a systematic approach, but
of this chapter features photographs of six species of putative rather involves areas of interest limited to humans, for example,
coralsnake mimics, which might have been more appropriate to the preservation of water sources for burgeoning populations.
place in the chapter on mimicry (see below). The authors, therefore, promote systematic conservation
The natural history of New World coralsnakes is the subject of planning based on scientific criteria. They also conclude that
a 15-page Chapter 7 by Vuolo Marques and Sazima. The chapter variation in coralsnake species richness is dependent on climate,
is comprehensive but limited, given that it is divided into so as climate changes due to human influences, coralsnakes
sections covering morphology and color patterns, distribution might not be able to “keep up” with the pace of such change. This
and habitat, microhabitat, activity, feeding habits, reproduction, could have serious consequences for ecosystem integrity due to
predators, defensive tactics, mimicry, and conservation. the loss of the ecological roles performed by coralsnakes as mid-
An example of the brevity of the treatment is the section level predators.
on conservation, which mentions the IUCN ratings of only The reproductive strategies of New World coralsnakes are dealt
three species of the 85 species in the three genera recognized. with in the tenth chapter, of 35 pages, authored by de Almeida-
Obviously, this chapter could have been much more detailed Santos et al. The stated purpose of the chapter is to summarize
(and, given the subject matter, should have been more so). The the anatomy of the reproductive system as that information
chapter concludes with a striking photograph of a hatching relates to the reproductive strategies and ecology of coralsnakes.
Micrurus tener. The authors first deal with the gross anatomy of female and male
Rodrigues de Almeida et al. authored a comprehensive reproductive systems, along with studies of male-male combat
examination of coralsnake mimicry in the 25-page Chapter 8, and oviposition. They document new data on reproductive cycles
including discussions of the concepts involved, the evidence and ecology and indicate that such information is necessary for
in support of those concepts, and the criticisms pointing to managing populations that are in decline.
problems of attributing coloration to mimicry. The introduction Seventeen pages are devoted in Chapter 11, written by
provides an explanation of the phenomenon of mimicry and Travaglia Cardoso et al., to the maintenance and reproductive
the distinction between Batesian and Müllerian mimicry. This behavior of Micrurus corallinus in captivity. This coralsnake is
phenomenon in coralsnakes as models and their putative relatively well-known and common in the southeastern region in
mimics makes for absorbing reading, especially given the array which New World coralsnakes occur. Maintenance of this snake
of color patterns seen among various species of coralsnakes as in captivity serves to enhance environmental education and
measured against a similar array seen in potential mimics of a scientific research through the design of biodioramas intended to
variety of non-venomous and non-lethally venomous colubrid simulate its natural habitat. The authors assess the influence of so-
and dipsadid snakes. The authors examine the evidence and called enrichment techniques in the structure of the biodiorama
hypotheses that argue against mimetic relationships between housing M. corallinus on the feeding and reproductive behavior
venomous coralsnakes and their putative mimics, as well as of this snake and conclude that such enclosures better allow for
those in support of such hypotheses. They profess that the natural behaviors than would their maintenance in boxes or small
arguments against the existence of mimetic relationships terraria.
involving coralsnakes, including the deadly model problem, At this point in the book, chapters begin to focus on the
aposematic vs. disruptive coloration, and incompatibility venom apparatus and venoms of coralsnakes. Ten such chapters
between life histories of predators and models, do not hold occupy most of the rest of the book, save for the last chapter
weight when examined closely. (22). Chapter 12, written by de Oliveira et al., encompasses 22
Evidence in support of coralsnake mimicry is drawn pages and deals with the cephalic glands and venom apparatus
from behavioral experiments, plasticine replica experiments, of coralsnakes. As is generally understood, coralsnakes have a
geographic concordance of models and mimics, and proteroglyphous dentition—the fangs are attached to a relatively
phylogenetic and macroevolutionary meta-analyses. The immovable maxilla and, thus, remain permanently erect. The
authors conclude their examination of mimetic relationships authors describe the general morphology and histology of the
involving venomous and non-venomous (or slightly venomous) principal cephalic glands. Of central importance in the study
taxa with a lengthy survey of studies of sympatry between of the cephalic glandular structure and function in coralsnakes
mimics and models. Finally, they offer their opinions on where is, of course, the structure and function of the venom apparatus
future research in the coralsnake mimicry phenomenon should of these snakes, in particular the gland itself, the glandular
lead in attempting to answer outstanding questions about compressor musculature, and the maxillary dentition, all of
this important phenomenon. As is typical of overviews of this which are explored by the authors. Discussions are accompanied
subject, the authors stick closely to the “science” of the subject, by a set of useful photographs and drawings.
but one question we have concerns the interactions these snakes Venom yields in Brazilian coralsnakes are dealt with in the
have with humans. Predators may learn avoidance after non- seven pages of Chapter 13 by Aird and da Silva. Brazil is home
fatal encounters, but can such interactions with humans lead to 34 species of Micrurus and three species of Leptomicrurus.

Herpetological Review 52(4), 2021


894 BOOK REVIEWS

As such, it can be easily understood that it is a challenge be accomplished on the neurotoxicology of the venoms of these
to produce an anti-elapidic serum (SAE) for treatment of snakes. This long chapter contains a cornucopia of information
coralsnake envenomation in Brazil, especially since the majority on peripheral nervous system neurotoxicity, central nervous
of the species occur in the most remote (northern) portion of the system neurotoxicity, and pain, and will be most useful, it
country. The serum that is currently available is manufactured seems, to pharmacologists, especially those involved in venom
using the venoms of only three species of coralsnakes, Micrurus research. The authors include a one-page tribute to Prof.
corallinus, M. frontalis, and M. lemniscatus, which happen to be Oswaldo Vital Brazil (1912–2008) as a pioneer in coralsnake
the species that are abundant in populated areas in the country, venom pharmacology.
especially in its southeastern region. Ho et al. deal with the immunology of coralsnake venoms
Aird and da Silva also authored Chapter 14 on the chemistry and antivenom production in a relatively short 15-page
of coralsnake venoms, which is one of the longest in the book Chapter 18. The authors discuss the coralsnake species of
at 89 pages. We note that one of the hallmark features of books medical importance, including Micrurus fulvius in the United
published by Eagle Mountain Publishing is that each chapter States, M. alleni and M. nigrocinctus in Central America,
begins on a right-facing page, so in some cases the left-facing and M. corallinus and M. frontalis in Brazil. Micrurus fulvius
page is left to be occupied by a full-page photograph, in this occurs in the southeastern USA from southeastern North
case, of the startlingly beautiful Micrurus brasilensis, which Carolina to southeastern Louisiana, M. alleni in lower Central
is distributed in central Brazil. Reading this chapter should America from eastern Honduras to Panama, M. nigrocinctus
increase herpetologists’ understanding of venom biochemistry from southeastern Mexico and throughout Central America to
considerably. Still, the authors demonstrate that relatively little extreme northwestern Colombia, M. corallinus in southeastern
work to date has been done on venom chemistry in these snakes. South America, and M. frontalis in southeastern Brazil, Bolivia,
Although venom chemistry might not be within the bailiwick and Paraguay (Wallach et al. 2014). The authors note that the
of many herpetologists, this chapter is so rigorously researched first antivenom for snakes was developed in 1895 by a French
that it will be of significant interest to venom biochemists. scientist, Albert Calmette, against the venom of the cobra Naja
Lomonte et al. present information on coralsnake venomic naja distributed in southern Asia. They record that by 1901, Vital
analysis in a 33-page Chapter 15. The authors indicate that Brazil’s research had demonstrated the specificity of antivenoms
venomic analysis is still in its early stages, given the diversity of in each type of snake venom and led to the development of the
coralsnakes and the limited availability of individuals to study first monovalent and polyvalent antivenoms for Central and
them. They note, however, that the use of transcriptomic and South American Crotalus and Bothrops. Most of the cases of
proteomic methods in snake venom research within the last envenomation in the Americas result from crotaline species, with
10 years has allowed comprehensive analyses of venom gland fewer than 5% of the cases involving coralsnakes. The authors
mRNA transcripts and proteins with the use of only small lament that although major progress toward our understanding
samples. The authors state that their purpose is to review studies of Micrurus venom composition has been made during the last
on micrurine venoms using these modern techniques, pointing decade, both the quality and quantity of antivenom production
out both strengths and weaknesses in exploring coralsnake unfortunately has not improved. In short, this chapter reinforces
venom composition. The authors identify several trends in the point that coralsnake antivenom production will remain a
protein composition of micrurine venoms that can underscore neglected public health problem until and unless financial and
additional research on coralsnake venomics, and they conclude political support is provided.
that in such a new field, more work is needed to support further The subject of the 26-page Chapter 19 by Buononato et
discoveries on venom proteins. al. is coralsnakes of medical interest in Brazil. The authors
Chapter 16 by Gutiérrez et al. comprises a 17-page discussion explain that all coralsnakes are potentially lethal to humans.
of the biological activities and action mechanisms of coralsnake Nevertheless, bite accidents are rare and often do not end
venoms. These authors note that venoms function to render prey in a worst-case scenario. They note that species of medical
immobile, to kill them, and to digest them prior to consumption, interest are those likely to be encountered in the following
as well as to provide defense against potential predators. The environments: 1) urban areas with a high population density,
authors summarize the action mechanisms of micrurine venoms which contact undisturbed areas and 2) the advancing edge of
from both biological and medical perspectives. Coralsnakes agricultural border areas. Micrurus corallinus and M. frontalis,
are well-known for the ability of their venoms to block the which often are encountered in southeastern Brazil, are the
functioning of neuromuscular junctions in the peripheral usual suspects to whom such accidents are attributed. These
nervous system, leading to paralysis and even respiratory arrest are, however, only two of the 38 species of coralsnakes that occur
and death. Details regarding the neurotoxic, myotoxic, and in Brazil. Of these 38, the authors chose 15 species of resident
direct hemolytic actions of coralsnake venoms are provided in coralsnakes of greatest medical importance to characterize
the latter section of this chapter. with a succinct description, drawings of the dorsal, ventral, and
The neuropharmacology of coralsnake venoms is discussed lateral views of the head, a color photograph, and a map showing
in the 102-page Chapter 17 authored by Stuani Floriano et al. the approximate geographic distribution. The authors also
Instead of dealing with the action of drugs on the nervous system, discuss various false coralsnakes, including some 100 species
the chapter deals with the neurotoxicity of coralsnake venoms that mimic venomous coralsnakes to various degrees; such false
and might be more appropriately titled as such. The authors coralsnakes must co-occur with one or more true coralsnakes to
indicate (p. 535) that our understanding of the neurotoxicological some extent to be considered mimics. Some false coralsnakes
diversity of micrurine venoms is at a preliminary stage, given show greater resemblance to venomous species than do others.
that few toxins have been studied in depth. Given the coralsnake Given this situation, much confusion exists in the identification
richness of Brazil (38 of 85 species or 44.7% of the species in the of aposematically patterned snakes, which is especially critical
three coralsnake genera), it is clear that much work remains to in cases where bites are involved. Importantly, this chapter deals

Herpetological Review 52(4), 2021


BOOK REVIEWS 895

with information about how to differentiate between venomous of which involved Micrurus fulvius. Coralsnake envenomation is
coralsnakes and false coralsnakes. The chapter further explains very unlikely to lead to death, which is especially good news.
that colorful snakes in the wild are difficult to identify in a The final 28-page chapter of this sterling volume, by
matter of seconds as being dangerous, either for the layperson Fenolio and Lamar, provides a suitable conclusion to a book
or even for the professional herpetologist. Needless to say, that immediately takes its place on the must-have list for
efforts to protect populations of these venomous snakes and herpetologists and others who have an interest in the natural
their mimics in Brazil, as elsewhere, will depend in large part world. This chapter is entitled “Techniques for Photographing
on the development of environmental educational programs, Coralsnakes,” and is accompanied by a series of outstanding
presumably supported by governmental funding and directed photographs of the snakes, as well as the equipment the authors
toward people living in regions throughout the country. Advances use and recommend to those who might wish to try their hand
in Coralsnake Biology can serve as a basis for the development of at photography. As noted in the legend of the lead photograph
such programs. by the junior author of the spectacular Peruvian Micrurus
The 26-page Chapter 20 by Yamin Risk et al. is concerned with lemniscatus, “Educating via esthetics: exposing the public to the
accidental coralsnake bites and is based largely on information beauty of snakes is an excellent way to influence thinking.” The
housed at the Instituto Butantan. Documentation began in the authors further point out (p. 745) that “photographs of snakes
first decade of the 20th century and continues to the present day. are important for the following reasons: as scientific illustrations
The archive at Instituto Butantan dates to 1902 and allows for that accompany species descriptions; as archival adjuncts to
the summation of data on accidental coralsnake bites by snake museum specimens; for recording color and pattern notes from
genus from that year to 2013. These data indicate that accidental life; and as documented proof of existence for scientific research.”
coralsnake bites account for an average of 0.5 percent of snakebites The authors opine (p. 745) that “additionally, photographs are
annually. The systematic documentation of accidental snakebites critical components of field guides and monographs. Moreover,
was introduced by Vital Brazil when a system was created to snake pictures may have aesthetic and artistic value and can help
allow for the collection of basic data via the Notification Bulletin with education and outreach programs, particularly in dispelling
of the Serum Therapy Institute of the State of São Paulo that myths about this group of vertebrates.”
accompanied each tube of antiserum. Micrurus corallinus is the We feel that we would be remiss were we not to emphasize
most commonly involved coralsnake in accidental bites treated that this book can be enjoyed on multiple levels by people
at the Hospital Vital Brazil, followed by those from M. frontalis, from many different walks of life. Naturally, there is a huge
M. carvalhoi, and M. decoratus. Descriptions of several bites by compendium of well-researched and documented information
coralsnakes are presented. Additional commentary is presented on the systematics, distribution, natural history, and venomics
on cases of micrurine envenomation, which confirms the rarity of coralsnakes of the Americas. The broadest appeal this book
of such accidents, especially when compared to bites involving will have, however, is due to the incomparable beauty of these
crotaline snakes. The authors attribute accidental bites involving creatures, as captured in the many outstanding examples of
coralsnakes to attraction to the snakes’ colors and ignorance photographic art placed throughout, representing the work of
on the part of the people bitten. This conclusion is interesting, many individuals. If we had our preferences, we would have
especially given the oftentimes exhibited ophidiophobia of most appreciated seeing that each of the chapters was provided with
people toward these animals. an abstract, resumo (in Portuguese) and resumen (in Spanish), at
Coralsnake envenomations in Brazil and elsewhere are the beginning and a set of conclusions at the end, which is the
further addressed in the 42-page Chapter 21 by Bucaretchi et al. default format for books such as this. We also think it would have
The majority of the snakebites in the Americas are attributable to been helpful to provide a glossary of technical terms after the
the crotaline viperid genera Bothrops, Crotalus, and Agkistrodon. final chapter to provide definitions of terms relatively unfamiliar
Thus, coralsnake bites are relatively rare as a result of their to readers.
small to medium size, their semifossorial habits, their relatively This is an impressive volume that should reside in the
limited level of aggressive behavior, their small fangs, their library of all herpetologists interested in the herpetofauna of the
relatively restricted gape, and their relatively limited population Western Hemisphere, in snakes from any region of the world,
overlap with those of humans. Only about 20% of the species in venomous snakes worldwide, in coralsnakes in particular, in
of coralsnakes have been involved in human envenomations. venoms and venom chemistry, in medical aspects of coralsnake
The authors collate epidemiological data on coralsnake envenomation, in mimicry throughout the animal kingdom, and
envenomation (Micrurus and Micruroides) from areas outside in the conservation of threatened and endangered animals. This
Brazil during the years 1883 through 2017. Only a single bite was book will sell out quickly given the relatively low price of $125.00.
attributed to Micruroides euryxanthus; the remainder of the bites In conclusion, just about anyone who is curious about the world
were attributed to species of Micrurus. Of the 87 cases reported, in which he or she lives will be appreciative of this thoroughly
the greatest numbers (39 or 44.8%) took place in the United researched and beautifully presented compendium concerning
States, followed by Colombia (32 or 36.8%). The remaining 16 coralsnakes.
(18.4%) happened in eight other countries in Mesoamerica and
South America. Of those in the United States, all but one involved Literature Cited
Micrurus fulvius or M. tener. The authors also collected extensive
information for coralsnake envenomations that occurred in Wallach, V., K. L. Williams, and J. Boundy. 2014. Snakes of the World.
Brazil from 1867 to 2020. The remainder of the chapter (21 pp.) CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida. 1227 pp.
covers general physiopathology, bite complications, differential
diagnoses, complementary clinical tests, clinical classification,
treatment, and fatal cases. Fatalities are reported infrequently. Of
1,965 cases collated, only 17 deaths (0.9%) were reported, most

Herpetological Review 52(4), 2021

You might also like