Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sieve Analysis Taking A Close Look at Qu
Sieve Analysis Taking A Close Look at Qu
s e
ve bl
ie a
S T
Te is l.
r ar nc
st on
fo mp i
o
C
Copyright © 2015 by RETSCH GmbH Haan.
All rights reserved, including the right to copy, distribute and
translate this text. No part of this document may be reproduced in
any way without written consent of RETSCH GmbH nor may be
modified, copied or distributed with the help of electronic systems.
Page
Introduction 4
To guarantee a high degree of reproducibility and reliability, sieve shakers and acces-
sories have to fulfill the requirements of national and international standards. This
means that test sieves, sieve shakers and all other measurement instruments (e.g.
scales) which are used for the characterization of particle distributions have to be
calibrated and subjected to test agent monitoring as part of the quality management
system. Apart from that, it is absolutely necessary to carry out the sample prepara-
tion with great care. Only then is it possible to achieve sieving results which allow a
reliable characterization of a product.
We all know the term “quality”. It is widely used to describe a product of particularly
high value. However, the exact definition of quality is as follows:
Quality is the compliance of defined properties with the detected properties
of a product as determined by performing tests.
A product can be described as high-quality if a test measurement ascertains that the
desired properties lie within a given tolerance. If the measured values deviate too
much, the quality is lower.
Many materials, whether natural or artificial, occur in dispersed form (material which
does not form a consistent unity but is divided into elements which can be separated
from each other, e.g. a pile of sand). The particle sizes and their distribution within a
material quantity - i.e. the fractions of particles of different sizes – have a crucial influ-
ence on physical and chemical properties.
These examples clearly show how important it is to know the particle size distribution,
particularly within the context of quality assurance of bulk goods for production pro-
cesses. If the particle size distribution changes during the production process, the
quality of the product will change as well.
Some examples taken from everyday life show how closely the particle size
distribution is linked with product properties:
n If the particles of ground filter coffee are too coarse, the contained flavors
cannot dissolve completely in hot water. This is due to the fact that only the
flavors contained in the particle surface are washed out. Thus, the taste of the
coffee cannot fully develop. Moreover, the water runs too quickly through the
spaces between the particles and the filter. If the coffee is ground too fine, too
many flavors, acids and bitter aromas are dissolved which impair the taste.
Another disadvantage is the blocking of the fine-pored filter paper by ultra-fine
particles which can even cause overflowing of the filter.
n Abrasive papers and grinding pastes need abrasive agents with a very nar-
row particle size distribution. Consequently, the particle sizes should not vary
too much. Substantial deviations from the required size range may result in
uneven surfaces: if the particles are too coarse, the paper/paste can leave deep
grooves in the treated surface; if the particles are too fine, the grinding effect
is reduced.
2. Sieving Methods
Single sieving is carried out with one test sieve of a defined mesh size and is used to
determine the percentages of undersize and oversize. It is used to get a general
idea of the sample characteristics (sieve cut). A particle size distribution in the
actual sense is not obtained with this method.
If more fractions are required, a set of sieves is used. The sieves are arranged in a
stack with the mesh size increasing from bottom to top. The sample is then placed
on the top sieve.
The appropriate sieving method depends on the degree of fineness of the sample
material (fig. 1). Dry sieving is the preferred method for the size range between
40 µm and 125 mm. However, the measurement range is limited by properties of
the sample such as a tendency to agglomerate, density or electrostatic charging.
Wet sieving extends the measurement range to 20 µm. If wet sieving is not permit-
ted, air jet sieving is an alternative which provides acceptable results down to 10 µm.
Measurement range
Fig. 1:
Measurement ranges of
different sieving methods
The sample is thrown upwards by the vibrations of the sieve bottom and falls back
down due to gravitation forces. The amplitude indicates the vertical oscillation height
of the sieve bottom.
Due to this combined motion, the sample material is spread uniformly across the
whole sieve area. The particles are accelerated in vertical direction, rotate freely and
then fall back statistically oriented. In RETSCH sieve shakers, an electromagnetic
drive sets a spring/mass system in motion and transfers the oscillations to the sieve
stack. The amplitude can be adjusted continuously to a few millimeters.
RETSCH “control” sieve shakers allow the digital setting of amplitude and sieving
time. During the sieving process, a built-in measuring system and control unit per-
forms a continuous comparison between the set and actual amplitude values which
ensures a high degree of reproducibility.
Fig. 2:
Principles of 3-dimensional throwing motion (left),
horizontal sieving (middle) and tap sieving (right)
In a horizontal sieve shaker the sieves move in horizontal circles in a plane (fig. 2,
middle). Horizontal sieve shakers are preferably used for needle-shaped, flat, long
or fibrous samples. Due to the horizontal sieving motion, hardly any particles change
their orientation on the sieve.
The air jet sieve is a sieving machine for single sieving, i.e. for each sieving process
only one sieve is used. The sieve itself is not moved during the process.
The material on the sieve is moved by a rotating jet of air: A vacuum cleaner which
is connected to the sieving machine generates a vacuum inside the sieving chamber
and sucks in fresh air through a rotating slit nozzle. When passing the narrow slit of
the nozzle the air stream is accelerated and blown against the sieve mesh, dispers-
ing the particles. Above the mesh, the air jet is distributed over the complete sieve
surface and is sucked in with low speed through the sieve mesh. Thus the finer par-
ticles are transported through the mesh openings into the vacuum cleaner or,
optionally, into a cyclone.
The sieve analysis starts with the smallest mesh size; the undersize is determined
by weighing the material before and after sieving. If a size distribution curve is
required, this procedure is continued with increasing mesh sizes. The oversize on
the finer sieve is put on the sieve next in size and is sieved again.
Air jet sieving is used, for example, for the continuous and quick control of classify-
ing processes.
Most sieve analyses are carried out with dry materials. However, there are many
applications in which wet sieving cannot be avoided, e.g. if the material to be tested
is a suspension or if a very fine sample (< 45 µm) that tends to agglomerate has to
be sieved. Dry sieving would lead to blockage of the sieve.
As in dry sieving, a sieve stack is assembled on a sieve shaker. The sample is placed
on the top sieve in the form of a suspension. The sieving process is supported by
water from a spray nozzle located above the uppermost sieve. Rinsing is carried out
until the sieving liquid leaving the sieve stack outlet is no longer clouded with solid
particles. If this finest fraction is required for analysis, it has to be recovered with
the help of a very fine filter and can be weighed after drying (see also chap-
ter 3.3.3.).
Important note: The water should not alter the sample in any way, i.e. the parti-
cles should not swell, dissolve or react with the liquid.
During wet sieving it may occur that air cushions are formed between the sieves.
This effect is caused by the fact that the sieves form a dust- and liquid-tight stack
which helps to avoid material loss and cross-contamination. The mesh sizes below
100 microns are particularly affected by this. By placing RETSCH’s venting rings
between the sieves, this effect can be avoided. With these rings the air cushions can
expand without loss of liquid or sample material.
Besides the actual sieve analysis, the sieving process also includes preparatory
steps such as sampling, sample division (if necessary), and the selection of test
sieves. After the sieving process, the data is evaluated, the sample material is
recovered and the sieves are cleaned and dried. To obtain reproducible sieving
results, it is essential that all steps of the sieving process are carried out with pre-
cise and reliable instruments (sieve shaker, scales). An evaluation software greatly
reduces the time needed for recording and evaluating the data and also helps to
minimize data transfer errors.
Fig. 3:
Random sampling Q3 [%] Random Sampling Silica sand
Fig. 4:
Qualitative sampling
A: Rotary Sample Divider PT 100 errors (standard
B: Sample Splitter deviations) of the
A C: Cone and Quartering different sampling
methods
D: Random Sampling
B
1 5 [%]
Standard Deviations
max. permitted
mesh size max. batch
sieve oversize
25 µm 14 cm3 7 cm3
45 µm 20 cm3 10 cm3
63 µm 26 cm3 13 cm3
125 µm 38 cm3 19 cm3
250 µm 58 cm3 29 cm3
500 µm 88 cm3 44 cm3
1 mm 126 cm3 63 cm3
2 mm 220 cm3 110 cm3
4 mm 346 cm3 173 cm3
8 mm 566 cm3 283 cm3
After that, the sample material can be recovered from the sieves.
The retrieval of the individual fractions is a significant advan-
tage of sieve analysis in contrast to most optical measurement
systems. The fractions are not only analytical values but are
physically available.
Usually, sieving processes are carried out with dry material. How-
ever, when dry sieving cannot produce an adequate degree of sep-
aration between the individual fractions and the sieving quality
cannot be improved by sieving aids, wet sieving is called for.
Agglomerated particles
Fluid bridges
Van-der-Waals forces
Electrostatic forces
Fig. 7:
Adhesive forces among particles which may affect the sieving result
When the sieving is done, the fractions are taken from each
sieve. Near-mesh particles, which are trapped in the sieve
mesh, can be removed by turning the sieve upside down and
tapping it lightly on a table. If not all particles can be recov-
ered like that, it is also possible to sweep a fine hair pencil
over the outer side of the fabric. Coarser fabrics with mesh
sizes > 500 microns can be effectively cleaned dry or wet
with a hand brush with plastic bristles. Possible damage of
the wire gauze by these tools is highly unlikely.
Fig. 9:
Histogram of the individual fractions
Q3 [%] p3 [%]
90 90
80 80
70 70
60 60
The cumulative curve in figure 11 can
50 50
be interpreted as follows: The corre-
40 40
sponding value of the particle size
30 30
250 µm on the y-axis is 36%. This
20 20
means that 36% of the sample is small-
10 10
er than 250 µm. To determine the medi-
an Q3(50) of the distribution, the corre- 50 100 500 1.000 6.000
sponding grain size (330 µm) can be Particle Size x [µm]
Q3 [%] p3 [%]
90 90
80 80
70 70
60 60
Q (50)
3
50 50
40 Q3 (36) 40
Particle < 250 µm
30 30
20 20
10 10
250 µm
50 100 500
330 µm
1,000 6,000
x [µm]
Particle Size
Fig. 11:
Cumulative distribution curve with exemplary
percentage values
Fig. 12:
Definitions of the Q0 number Q1 length
quantifications Qr of
particle collectives
Q2 area Q3 mass /
(projection or volume
surface area)
Q3 Volume
103 103 103
[mm3]
Q2 Surface
600 6,000 60,000
[mm2]
Q1 Length
10 1 0.1
[mm]
Q0 Number
1 103 106
Fig. 14:
Distribution of surface, length and number of
cube collectives of the same total volume
(equation 1)
Qr
(equation 2)
(equation 3)
Fig. 18:
Cumulative distribution curve Qr(x)
Fig. 19:
The quantity proportions pr (histogram)
of the individual fractions
(equation 4)
(equation 5)
5. RETSCH Instruments
5.1. Test Sieves
For reliable and reproducible results in the context of quality assurance, the use of test
sieves which correspond to the standards ISO 3310 or ASTM E11 is essential. The tech-
nical requirements and monitoring for test sieves are laid down in these standards. If a
laboratory carries out quality control in accordance with ISO 9000 ff, the sieve shakers,
test sieves and all other involved instruments (e.g. scales) have to be subjected to test
agent monitoring.
The standard ISO 3310 stipulates which tolerances are allowed for the wire diameter (d)
of the woven sieve fabric and for the nominal mesh width (w) of the apertures (fig. 20).
For each mesh width w the value y is defined which indicates how much the mean real
mesh width may differ from the nominal mesh width.
ød
w
w ød
Fig. 20:
Schematic of a sieve mesh
Q3 [%]
This can be demonstrated with a 63 µm
sieve (fig. 21). The tolerance y for a
90 sieve with the nominal mesh width
80 63 µm is ±3.7 µm. This means that the
70 mean value of the mesh sizes must lie
60 between 59.3 µm and 66.7 µm.
50
44 %
40 % 40 A look at the graph in figure 21 helps to
36 %
30
63 µm understand why the knowledge of the
20 tolerance ± Y = 3.7 µm
real mesh width is so important for sieve
10
analysis: if the mesh size is 63 µm, 40%
0
40 50 60 70 80 90100 200 300 400
of the sample are smaller than 63 µm. If,
-Y 59.3 +Y 66.7
however, the mean real mesh width is
x [µm]
Particle Size 66.7 µm, 44% of the particles are small-
er than 66.7 µm. If a user does not know
the real mesh width, he would assume
Fig. 21:
Tolerance y of the nominal mesh width that 44% of the sample is smaller than
of 63 µm acc. to ISO 3310-1 and its 63 µm.
consequences
To prove the quality of the RETSCH test sieves, the following reports and
certificates – validated by automated optical testing procedures – are
available:
Optional certificates:
(b) Inspection certificate (for test sieves according to ISO 3310-1 / ASTM E11):
test report plus values of the measured mesh widths for warp and weft
RETSCH offers a range of different sieving machines for reproducible sieve analyses:
Speed: - - - -
Size (W x H x D): 400 x 230 x 350 mm 400 x 230 x 350 mm 400 x 230 x 350 mm 400 x 235 x 400 mm
Net weight: ~ 30 kg ~ 30 kg ~ 30 kg ~ 35 kg
AS 450 basic AS 450 control AS 200 jet AS 200 tap AS 400 control
15 kg 25 kg 0.3 - 100 g 3 kg 5 kg
10 / 7 13 / 9 1 / 2 with cyclone 7 / 13 7 / 9 / 17
50 kg 50 kg - 6 kg 15 kg
digital, digital,
- - -
0 - 2 mm 0.2 - 2.2 mm
digital, 5-55 min-1 digital,
- - -
(nozzle) 50 - 300 min-1
280 min-1 /
- - - -
150 min-1
digital digital digital digital digital
1 - 99 min 1 - 99 min 00:00 - 99:59 1 - 99 min 1 - 99 min
yes yes - - yes
- - 0 - 9999 Pa / 0 - 100 mbar - -
1 9 9 - 9
- no / yes - - yes
(equation 6)
(K = sieve ratio,
A = amplitude,
f = natural frequency,
g = acceleration of gravity,
g’ = sieve acceleration)
Sieving 1 Sieving 1
Sieving 2 Sieving 2
Sieving 3 Sieving 3
AS 200 jet
AS 200 tap
AS 400 control
Sample Dividers
PT 100, PT 200 The rotary tube divider PT 200 is used for the extraction of up
and Sample Splitters to 3 representative sub-samples from a large sample quanti-
ty. The remaining sample material is collected in a 30 liter
vessel.
The RETSCH sample splitters are suitable for the precise man-
ual division of fibrous samples which do not flow freely, such
as secondary fuels or chipped wood. The sample splitters are
available in 6 different sizes.
Ultrasonic Baths
UR 1 and UR 3
The Fluid Bed Dryer TG 200 is used for the gentle drying of up
to 5 test sieves with 200 mm diameter. Air flow and tempera-
ture (40 °C to 150 °C) are continuously adjustable. The
1000 watt blower provides an air volume of 185 m3/h at idle
speed; heater output is 2,000 watts.
Fluid Bed
Dryer
TG 200
CAMSIZER P4 CAMSIZER XT
dry, free-lowing bulk materials:
bulk goods,
Sample material granulates, extrudates, pellets, sugar,
powders & suspensions
salt, sand, etc.
1 µm - 3 mm (dry, compressed air)
Measuring range 20 µm - 30 mm 1 µm - 1 mm (wet)
10 µm - 7 mm (dry, free fall)
Dispersion free fall compressed air, wet dispersion, free fall
Comparable to sieving yes yes
42
6. Digital Image Analysis
Zoom
Basic
43
6. Digital Image Analysis
70 – CAMSIZER 2
60 – CAMSIZER 3 and purchasers. A fast and powerful
– CAMSIZER 4
50 – CAMSIZER 5
alternative to sieve analysis has to take
40 – CAMSIZER 6 this into account and must be able to
– CAMSIZER 7
30
– CAMSIZER 8 deliver fully compatible measurement
20 – CAMSIZER 9
– CAMSIZER 10 results. Therefore the CAMSIZER soft-
10
0
ware is equipped with algorithms which
1 2 3 4 5 x [mm]
Particle size
allow matching sieve analyses. In this
way a vast number of users could
Excellent reproducibility: 10 measurements of
replace sieving by the CAMSIZER sys-
the same sample with 10 different CAMSIZER
systems. The curves perfectly match each other. tem without having to abstain from the
familiar quality characteristics.
Q3 [%]
Due to the automatic measurement and
100
90
wear-free operation the measurement
80 results are more reliable and more
Percent by volume
70
Sample 1 – CAMSIZER reproducible.
60 Sample 1 – Sieving
Moreover CAMSIZER users benefit from
50 Sample 2 – CAMSIZER
40
Sample 2 – Sieving additional information like particle
30 length and width (fibres and extru-
20 dates) or particle shape (e.g. angularity
10
of abrasives) which sieve analysis can-
0
200 400 600 800 1000 x [µm] not deliver.
Particle size
44
7. Summary 8. Annex
7. Summary
8. Annex
45
8.1. Sieve Standards with Comparison Table
ISO 3310-1
Compliance Certiicate
ISO 3310-1
Inspection Certiicate
ISO 3310-1
Calibration Certiicate
ASTM E11
Compliance Certiicate
ASTM E11
Inspection Certiicate
Traceability
With EasySieve® the sieving results can be displayed as diagrams and parameters.
Parameters:
RRSB characteristics:
The RRSB parameters can only be calculated, if the Q3 values of at least two sieve
cuts lie between 5% and 95%.
Speciic surface
Sv surface of all particles
Sv =
volume of all particles
Sauter diameter
If the complete volume of the particles of a bulk was transformed into
spheres of identical size, whose complete surface equalled that of the
XSt
particles, then these spheres would have the Sauter diameter.
6
xSt =
Sv
AFS number
The ASF no. is used to classify foundry or core sand
AFS no.
The sieves have to be a subset of the ASF series 0.020 mm, 0.063 mm,
0.090 mm, 0.125 mm, 0.180 mm, 0.250 mm, 0.355 mm, 0.500 mm,
0.710 mm, 1 mm, 1.4 mm, 2 mm, 2.8 mm, 4 mm, 5.6 mm. Moreover,
between the smallest and the biggest sieve all ASF sieves have to be
included.
RETSCH GmbH
RETSCH-Allee 1-5
42781 Haan ∙ Germany
Phone +49 (0) 21 04 / 23 33-100
Fax +49 (0) 21 04 / 23 33-199
E-Mail info@retsch.com
Web www.retsch.com