Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Obesity and Women's Health: An Evidence-Based Review
Obesity and Women's Health: An Evidence-Based Review
Obesity and Women's Health: An Evidence-Based Review
Obesity negatively impacts the health of women in many ways. Being overweight or obese increases the
relative risk of diabetes and coronary artery disease in women. Women who are obese have a higher
risk of low back pain and knee osteoarthritis. Obesity negatively affects both contraception and fertility
as well. Maternal obesity is linked with higher rates of cesarean section as well as higher rates of high-
risk obstetrical conditions such as diabetes and hypertension. Pregnancy outcomes are negatively af-
fected by maternal obesity (increased risk of neonatal mortality and malformations). Maternal obesity
is associated with a decreased intention to breastfeed, decreased initiation of breastfeeding, and de-
creased duration of breastfeeding. There seems to be an association between obesity and depression in
women, though cultural factors may influence this association. Obese women are at higher risk for mul-
tiple cancers, including endometrial cancer, cervical cancer, breast cancer, and perhaps ovarian cancer.
(J Am Board Fam Med 2011;24:75– 85.)
The prevalence of obesity is rising. The World Table 1 provides a classification for overweight
Health Organization estimates that more than 1 and obesity based on BMI.3 Waist circumference
billion people are overweight, with 300 million can also be used to classify overweight and obesity.
meeting the criteria for obesity.1 Twenty-six per- In women, a waist circumference of ⬎35 inches (88
cent of nonpregnant women ages 20 to 39 are cm) is high risk, whereas in men the level is ⬎40
overweight and 29% are obese.2 This article will inches (102 cm). Research varies in the measure-
review the wide-ranging effects that obesity has on ments of obesity used to classify participants in each
both reproductive health and chronic medical con- study.
ditions in women.
A PubMed search was performed using the key Obesity and Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
words “obesity,” “overweight,” “body mass index” The risk of diabetes mellitus (DM) increases with the
(BMI), “gender,” “women’s health,” and the con- degree and duration of being overweight or obese and
dition reviewed. The most recent evidence-based with a more central or visceral distribution of body
articles were included in the review. The evidence fat. Increased visceral fat enhances the degree of in-
level of each article was determined by the authors sulin resistance associated with obesity.4 In turn, in-
based on the type of study, randomization, the sulin resistance and increased visceral fat are the
number of participants, and loss to follow-up. hallmarks of metabolic syndrome, an assembly of
risk factors for developing diabetes and cardiovas-
cular disease.4 – 6
This article was externally peer reviewed. The Nurses’ Health Study followed 84,000 fe-
Submitted 24 March 2010; revised 12 July 2010; accepted
19 July 2010. male nurses for 16 years and found that being
From Department of Family Medicine, University of overweight or obese was the single most important
Wisconsin, Madison.
Funding: none. predictor of DM.7 An increased risk of DM was
Conflict of interest: none declared. seen in women with BMI values ⬎24 and a waist-
Corresponding author: Sarina Schrager, MD, MS, Depart-
ment of Family Medicine, University of Wisconsin, 777 S. to-hip ratio ⬎0.76.8 After adjusting for age, family
Mills St., Madison, WI 53715 (E-mail: sbschrag@wisc.edu). history of diabetes, smoking, exercise, and several
*All odds ratios (OR) and relative risk (RR) are compared to women with body mass index (BMI) ⬍25, unless otherwise noted.
†
Back pain.
‡
Disability.
The data supporting the link between obesity ercise effectively led to significant improvements in
and knee OA in women is even more staggering. pain and physical function in women with knee OA
The factors underlying the association of obesity over 18 months in the Arthritis, Diet, and Activity
with knee OA have not been entirely elucidated. Promotion Trial.34 A separate, randomized clinical
Obesity leads to an excess load on the joint, in- trial evaluating rapid weight loss found that a 10%
creased cartilage turnover, increased collagen type weight reduction improved function by 28%, with
2 degradation products, and increased risk of de- a number needed to treat of ⬍4 patients (95% CI,
generative meniscal lesions. Although all of these 2–9 patients) to achieve a 50% improvement in the
have been theorized to lead to knee OA no causal WOMAC score, which is a measure of joint pain,
relationships have been demonstrated to date.25,26 stiffness, and function.35
Studies have shown that women with a diagnosis
of knee OA have an average BMI that is 24% Obesity and Infertility (Including Polycystic
higher than women without OA.27 For every 2 Ovary Syndrome)
units of BMI gain, the risk of knee OA increases by Obesity affects fertility throughout a woman’s life.
36%,28 and 1 category shift downward in BMI from The impact of obesity and Polycystic Ovary Syn-
obese to overweight may avoid 19% of new cases of drome (PCOS) on reproductive function can be
severe knee pain29 (Table 3). The importance of attributed to multiple endocrine mechanisms. Ab-
prevention of knee OA is highlighted by the sub- dominal obesity is associated with an increase in
sequent burden of surgery. An estimated 69% of circulating insulin levels. This results in increased
knee replacements in middle-aged women in the functional androgen levels (caused by suppression
United Kingdom have been attributable to obes- of sex hormone– binding globulin synthesis and in-
ity.33 Dietary weight loss in combination with ex- creased ovarian androgen production). Chronic el-
Abbate et al (30) BMI: heaviest quartile vs Increased diagnosis of knee OA 5.27 (3.05–9.13)
lowest quartile
Weight: heaviest quartile vs Increased diagnosis of knee OA 5.28 (3.05–9.16)
lowest quartile
Grotle et al (31) BMI ⬎30 Increased diagnosis of new knee OA 2.81 (1.32–5.96)
within 10 years
Holmberg et al (32) BMI increase from 23 to 25 Increased radiograph diagnosis of 1.6 (0.9–3.1)
knee OA
Liu et al (33) BMI ⬎30 vs BMI ⬍22.5 Increased rates of knee replacement 10.51 (7.85–14.08)
Patterson et al (12) BMI ⬎35 Increased rates of knee replacement 11.7
*All odds ratio (OR) and relative risk (RR) are compared to women with body mass index (BMI) ⬍25, unless otherwise noted.
OA, osteoarthritis.
Triphasic oral contraceptive (eg, Ortho Tri Cyclen, Increased body weight and surface area are associated with decreased
Ortho-McNeil-Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc., hormone concentration (overweight is not listed as a precaution).
Raritan, NJ)
Monophasic Oral Contraceptive (eg, Loestrin 24 No weight-specific comments.
Fe, Warner Chilcott, Rockaway, NJ)
Progesterone-only contraceptive (eg, Ortho No weight-specific comments.
Micronor, Ortho-McNeil-Janssen
Pharmaceuticals, Inc.,
Raritan, NJ)
Transdermal contraceptive (eg, Ortho Evra, Consider decreased effectiveness ⬎90 kg (this is listed as a
Ortho-McNeil-Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc., precaution).
Raritan, NJ)
Intravaginal ring (eg, Nuva ring, Schering-Plough No weight-specific comments.
Corp., Kenilworth, NJ)
Implantable progesterone (eg, Implanon, Effectiveness not defined because women with ⬎130% of ideal body
Schering-Plough Corp., Kenilworth, NJ) weight were not studied. However, the hormonal concentration is
inversely related to body weight and thus may be less effective in
overweight patients.
Injectable progesterone (eg, Depo-provera, Pfizer, No weight-specific comments.
Inc., New York, NY)
Hormonal intrauterine device (eg, Mirena, Bayer No weight-specific comments.
HealthCare Pharmaceuticals, Montville, NJ)
*All odds ratio (OR) and relative risk (RR) are compared to normal weight pregnant women (body mass index 关BMI兴 18 –25). Values
in parentheses indicate 95% CI.
†
BMI 25–30.
‡
BMI 30 –35.
§
BMI ⬎35.
㛳
BMI ⬎30. GDM, gestational diabetes mellitus. PIH, pregnancy-induced hypertension.
metabolic and hormonal effects of adipose tissue suckling in the first week compared with normal-
(ie, decreased milk supply). However, obesity may weight women.71 There is also evidence that excess
also be related to some confounders such as more body fat may impair mammary gland development
pregnancy complications, which also have negative before conception and during pregnancy by hor-
effects on breastfeeding rates. monal and metabolic effects.72
A large study in the United Kingdom asked Maternal obesity is also associated with a short-
approximately 11,000 women at 32 weeks’ gesta- ened duration of breastfeeding.64,69,70,73,74 A Dan-
tion about their level of concern regarding their ish study of nearly 38,000 women observed that the
shape and weight. After adjusting for multiple vari- greater the prepregnant BMI, the earlier the ter-
ables, those with “marked concern” for both were mination of breastfeeding.73 There is no data look-
significantly less likely to intend to breastfeed.65 ing at future breastfeeding rates with subsequent
Another smaller study done in the United States pregnancies after weight loss.
among 114 women found that obese women in-
tended to breastfeed for a significantly shorter pe- Obesity and Depression
riod of time than other women.66 Population-based studies looking at the association
Several studies have demonstrated decreased between obesity and depression have yielded incon-
breastfeeding initiation rates among obese women sistent results, with only some finding an associa-
compared with normal-weight women.64,67–70 One tion.75–78 The difference between sexes is similarly
chart review of 1109 white mother-baby dyads found inconsistent. Some studies found an association be-
that the overweight and obese mothers were more tween obesity and higher rates of depression in
likely to quit breastfeeding at the time of discharge women but not in men79,81; others reported inverse
from the hospital compared with mothers who associations between obesity and depression in
were normal weight (12.2% vs 4.3%).67 both women and men.81
Obese women are at greater risk of a delay in Most recently, data from the third National
milk production, which may be related to decreased Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (1988 –
rates of breastfeeding initiation. One study found 1994) showed that obesity was associated with past-
that obese women had lower prolactin responses to month depression in women (OR, 1.82; 95% CI,