Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Zoogeography, Genetic Variation and Conservation of The Callicebus Personatus Group
Zoogeography, Genetic Variation and Conservation of The Callicebus Personatus Group
Zoogeography, Genetic Variation and Conservation of The Callicebus Personatus Group
net/publication/280780056
CITATIONS READS
12 372
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Strategic Planning for Brazilian Primates Conservation - Planejamento Estratégico para a Conservação de Primatas Brasileiros View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Andre Hirsch on 09 August 2015.
Evolutionary Biology and Conservation of Titis, Sakis and Uacaris, eds. Liza M. Veiga, Adrian A. Barnett, Stephen F. Ferrari and Marilyn A. Norconk.
Published by Cambridge University Press. © Cambridge University Press 2013.
43
Zoogeography, genetic variation and conservation
the Cerrado, a drier more open habitat which extends from the probably ranges no further west into Minas Gerais than Mon-
Araguaia–Tocantins and Paraguai–Taquari Novo river systems, tes Claros (Printes 2007). To the north, the main obstacle to
in the west, to the São Francisco and Paraná–Paraíba in the east the dispersal of C. melanochir appears to be the Paraguaçu
(see Hershkovitz 1988). Hershkovitz believed that, in the past, River. It is likely that C. melanochir once occurred in the
riparian forest along Cerrado river systems would have provided Pardo–Jequitinhonha interfluvium, but the forests of this
suitable habitats for Callicebus, facilitating dispersal between the region have now been replaced by cattle pasture and our
Amazonian and Atlantic Forest biomes. He proposed that these surveys found no Callicebus there. Callicebus melanochir does
Cerrado-dwelling titis disappeared during the climatic changes of occur in the Pau Brasil National Park, south of the Jequitin-
the Quaternary, which caused the biome to become even drier, honha. More surveys are needed, but it is possible that the
restricting riparian forests to small, isolated valleys. With this, the species may reach the Rio Doce, some 300 km further south.
Cerrado became an ecological barrier for the titis. Current distri- To the south of the Jequitinhonha, C. melanochir is restricted
butions reflect this, with members of the personatus group being to remnant coastal forests. To the west, it is replaced by
restricted to the right bank of São Francisco River, in north- C. personatus.
eastern Brazil, and to the right bank of Tietê River, in the
southeast. Callicebus barbarabrownae (Hershkovitz, 1990)
Until the survey of Printes (2007), this species was known from
Distribution of the personatus group species only four localities, but C. barbarabrownae has now been
confirmed at no less than 37 sites. The species appears to be
Callicebus personatus (Geoffroy, 1812) endemic to the state of Bahia, where it inhabits upland areas
This species occurs in the state of Espírito Santo, northwestern between 241 and 908 m above sea level (Printes & Rylands
Minas Gerais and northern Rio de Janeiro (van Roosmalen et al. 2008; Printes et al. 2011). Using the minimum polygon convex
2002). Oliver and Santos (1991) indicated that the region of the approach (IUCN 1994), its total range is believed to cover an
Itaúnas and Mucuri rivers might be a zone of intergradation area of some 252,546 km2, although actual occupancy is esti-
between C. personatus and C. melanochir. Callicebus personatus mated at 2636 km2 (Figure 5.1).
occurs on the right bank of the Jequitinhonha River, but it No titis were recorded in the region west of Araci and
remains unclear whether this species or another titi occurs to Nova Soure (Figure 5.1), which is dominated by the Cerrado.
the northwest of this river (van Roosmalen et al. 2002). The However, C. barbarabrownae was recorded in the Caatinga of
range of this species extends westwards along the Rio Doce the moister uplands northeast of Araci (Mandacaru, Miran-
valley into Minas Gerais as far as the Mantiqueira Mountains. dela and Serra Branca). The species was also recorded in
It is possible that the distribution of C. personatus is more Caatinga habitat further north as far as the Salitre River,
restricted than previously supposed, as C. nigrifrons and not 170 km from Juazeiro, but titis were not recorded west of
C. personatus was recorded at the frontier between Minas Gerais the Chapada Diamantina, which supports Hershkovitz’s
and Espírito Santo, an area formerly considered to be within the (1988, 1990) conclusion: that topographic relief, or the shifts
range of C. personatus. in vegetation associated with it, limit the dispersal of titis in
this region.
Callicebus nigrifrons (Spix, 1823) In eastern Bahia, the Agreste forests of the coastal range
Callicebus nigrifrons is restricted to the states of São Paulo and probably supported large populations of C. barbarabrownae in
Minas Gerais. It has the most ample distribution of any perso- the past, although this type of vegetation is rare in the present
natus group species (van Roosmalen et al. 2002), and occurs in day. We nevertheless recorded populations in five municipal-
both mature rainforest and disturbed fragments. It is found ities (Cícero Dantas, Antas, Sítio do Quinto, Jeremoabo and
north of the Tietê and east of the Paraná and Paranaíba rivers, Pedro Alexandre).
and on both margins of the São Francisco. The species also
occurs east of the Mantiqueira and Espinhaço ranges, where it Callicebus coimbrai (Kobayashi and Langguth, 1999)
meets C. personatus (see above). Kobayashi and Langguth (1999) originally restricted the distri-
bution of C. coimbrai to the coastal rainforests between the
Callicebus melanochir (Wied-Neuwied, 1820) mouths of the São Francisco River in Sergipe and the Itapicuru
Hershkovitz (1990) placed the geographic distribution of in Bahia. Nevertheless, Printes (2007) recorded the species at
C. melanochir between the Mucuri River, in Espírito Santo Lamarão do Passé (Figure 5.1), extending its range some 200
and the Paraguaçu, in Bahia. However, van Roosmalen et al. km further south. Kobayashi and Langguth (1999) also believed
(2002) considered the possibility of an overlap zone with that C. coimbrai was restricted to primary rainforest, although
C. personatus in the valleys of the Itaúnas and Mucuri rivers, more recent surveys have shown that the species also occurs in
in the north of Espírito Santo. fragments of seasonal forest and forests with a Caatinga influ-
As noted above, the Cerrado proper acts as a barrier to the ence, along the border between the states of Sergipe and Bahia
distribution of modern-day titi taxa, and C. melanochir (Sousa 2003; Jerusalinsky et al. 2006). However, further west,
44
Distributional limits in the Brazilian northeast
ci s
MA PI co
Capital Cities
AL
10°S
10°S
PALMAS Brasil State Division
Hydrography - rivers
SE
TO Hydrography - water bodies
ARACAJU
R i o I t a p i cur u Species Records
Callicebus barbarabrownae
C. barbarabrownae
Callicebus coimbrai
cisco
C. coimbrai
guaçu Callicebus melanochir
MT BA ara
Ri o P Callicebus nigrifrons
an
SALVADOR Callicebus personatus
ã o Fr
Geographic Distribution
C. barbarabrownae
Rio S
C. coimbrai
15°S
15°S
C. melanochir
? C. melanochir C. nigrifrons
GO DF C. personatus
? ? qu
itinh
onha
GOIÂNIA Je
io
R Rio Mucuri
C. personatus
anaíba
Pa r R. Doce
Ri o MG R . i o
S . ntôn R. D
A oce Atlantic Ocean
ES
20°S
20°S
Study Area
MS C. nigrifrons VITÓRIA N
Rio
Tie Cartographic Base:
tê í ba d o S u
W E
BDGEOPRIM, 2002;
a ra
oP IBGE, 2003; ESRI, 2001
Ri S
R i o Pa
ra n a
p an e SP RJ 1:10,500,000 Geoprocessing:
ma
André Hirsch
SAO RAULO 0 100 200 400
RIO DE JANEIRO Department of Zoology / ICB
PR km Federal Univesity of Minas Gerais
Belo Horizonte, March 2007
the species is replaced by C. barbarabrownae in more typical The lower Paraguaçu forms the limit between the geo-
Caatinga ecosystems (Printes et al. 2011). The species distri- graphic ranges of C. coimbrai, restricted to the left or north
bution covers little less than 30,000 km2 (Jerusalinsky 2008), bank, and C. melanochir, found on the right bank. Further west,
and our surveys confirmed its presence in at least 35 forest in the region of Feira de Santana, C. barbarabrownae occurs on
remnants (Sousa 2000, 2003; Jerusalinsky et al. 2006; Printes both banks of the Paraguaçu. This suggests to us that C. barbar-
et al. 2011). The largest of these fragments is a 3000 ha tract in abrownae dispersed prior to the formation of the Paraguaçu
São Francisco do Paraguaçu, Bahia, whereas the smallest is a river system, and that the process was influenced by regional
3 ha fragment in Arauá, Sergipe (Jerusalinsky et al. 2006). phytogeography, rather than physical barriers. There does
not appear to be a physical barrier between the eastern limit
Distributional limits of Callicebus in the of the range of C. barbarabrownae and the western limit of
C. coimbrai, although there may be an association with altitude
Brazilian northeast and related humidity gradients, with the latter species typically
The recent surveys of C. barbarabrownae and C. coimbrai occurring at lower, and relatively more humid altitudes.
have provided a number of insights into the factors limiting We also recorded C. coimbrai in areas of Caatinga with a
the distribution of Callicebus species in northeastern Brazil. strong rainforest influence (e.g. Nossa Senhora da Glória,
For example, C. melanochir replaces C. barbarabrownae in Sergipe). Coimbra-Filho and Câmara (1996) suggested that
the region known as the “Recôncavo Baiano” (south of the anthropogenic disturbance over the past 450 years has favored
Paraguaçu River in the municipality of Igrapiuna). The indi- the expansion of the more xeric Caatinga vegetation into areas
viduals observed in this area presented the unmistakable once covered by Atlantic Forest. If this is true, C. barbara-
C. melanochir color pattern of uniform gray trunk with brownae may now occupy areas that were inhabited by
chestnut-brown tail. C. coimbrai in recent times.
45
Zoogeography, genetic variation and conservation
46
Acknowledgments
An additional current problem is the Agrarian Reform Federal Environment Institute’s Centre for the Protection of
Program, which has stimulated the growth of political organ- Brazilian Primates (ICMBIO/CPB) to create an interinstitu-
izations such as the Movimento dos Sem Terra (Landless Agri- tional working group for the conservation of C. barbara-
cultural Workers’ Movement), which are able to exert brownae and C. coimbrai, and to coordinate proposals for
considerable pressure on governments for the occupation of the creation of federal reserves aimed at the protection of
large rural properties throughout the Atlantic Forest. Some these species. These species, together with C. personatus and
settlements have resulted in effective and well-integrated pro- C. melanochir (and Cebus xanthosternos and Cebus robustus)
grams of sustainable development, but more often than not, have been included in the portfolio of the International
the primary objective of these groups is the occupation of Committee for the Conservation and Management of Primates
forested areas. This is partly because these areas are considered of the Northern Atlantic Forest and Caatinga, established in
to have more productive soils, but also because landowners are 2006 with the objective of assisting the Federal Institute in
more likely to relinquish forested land than that already under strategic decision-making for in situ and ex situ conservation
cultivation. Ultimately, government agencies will also often (MMA 2006).
prioritize the areas because they are considered to be “unpro- In the specific case of C. coimbrai, privately owned reserves –
ductive” and as such, less valuable for the assessment of com- known as Reservas Particulares de Patrimônio Natural or
pensation due to the landowner on confiscation. RPPNs – may play an especially important role in the conser-
Despite increasing attempts in recent decades to integrate vation of the species. While they may protect only relatively
conservation efforts with economic development, the protec- small areas of forest, and proportionately small populations
tion of natural populations in conservation units, such as parks of titis, such areas may nevertheless represent a substantial
and reserves, still seems to be the most effective approach. In contribution to the conservation of the species, especially for
this light, the five species of personatus group face widely the development of metapopulation management strategies,
differing scenarios. Considering only federal- and state- in combination with an eventual network of public reserves.
protected areas, the three least-threatened species of the group A number of potential sites are currently under study in
are represented by populations in relatively extensive areas of Sergipe, and may also contribute to the conservation of other
forest: C. nigrifrons in seven reserves, totalling more than endangered endemics, such as the yellow-breasted capuchin,
100,000 ha, C. personatus at nine localities, with a combined Cebus xanthosternos, and the maned sloth, Bradypus torquatus.
area of more than 100,000 ha, and C. melanochir in four areas
with more than 50,000 ha of forest.
At the opposite extreme, neither C. barbarabrownae nor Acknowledgments
C. coimbrai – the two most endangered taxa of this group – are We would like to thank Drs. Anthony Rylands, Stephen Ferrari
known to occur in any kind of official reserve. Jerusalinsky and Júlio César Bicca-Marques. Roberto Groehs, Luisa
et al. (2006), for example, estimated that the total remnant Lokschin and André Alonso assisted in the surveys of
population of C. coimbrai comprises some 500–1000 individ- C. barbarabrownae. Fieldwork was supported by Conservation
uals, occupying a total area of 100–150 km2, pulverized into International, Critical Ecosystem Partnership Fund, Fundação
numerous unprotected forest fragments, most of which cover Biodiversitas, Margot Marsh Biodiversity Foundation, Insti-
less than 100 ha. Surveys of the 100,000 ha Raso da Catarina tuto de Estudos Sócio-Ambientais do Sul da Bahia, CODE-
Ecological Station have failed to confirm the presence of VASF, Universidade Federal de Sergipe, and Programa
C. barbarabrownae in this potentially important federal reserve Macacos Urbanos (UFRGS–INGA). We are also grateful to
(Printes 2007). These and other findings have led the Brazilian André Hirsch for Figure 5.1.
Rio de Janeiro: Fundação Brasileira para a Futuyma, D.J. (1996). Biologia Evolutiva.
References Conservação da Natureza. São Paulo: Sociedade Brasileira de
Ab’Saber, A.N. (1977). Os domínios Genética/CNPq.
morfoclimáticos da América do Sul – Cunha, E. (1901). Os Sertões. Rio de Janeiro:
primeira aproximação. Geomorfologia, Otto Pierre Editores (1979 edition). Hershkovitz, P. (1963). A systematic and
52, 1–23. De Boer, L.E.M. (1974). Cytotaxonomy of zoogeographic account of the monkeys of
the Platyrrhini (Primates). Genen en the genus Callicebus (Cebidae) of the
Bonvicino, C.R., Penna-Firme, V., Amazonas and Orinoco river basins.
Nascimento, F.F., et al. (2003). The lowest Phaenen, 17, 1–115.
Mammalia, 27, 1–80.
diploid number (2n ¼ 16) yet found in Defler, T.R. (2004). Primates de Colômbia.
any primate: Callicebus lugens Bogotá: Conservación Internacional. Hershkovitz, P. (1977). Living New World
(Humboldt, 1811). Folia Primatologica, Monkeys (Platyrrhini) with an
Dumas, F., Bigoni, F., Stone, G., et al. (2005).
74, 141–149. Introduction to Primates. Vol. 1. Chicago,
Mapping genomic rearrangements in titi
IL: University of Chicago Press.
Coimbra-Filho, A.F. & Câmara, I.G. (1996). monkeys by chromosome flow sorting
Os Limites Originais do Bioma Mata and multidirectional in-situ hybridization. Hershkovitz, P. (1988). Origin, speciation,
Atlântica na Região Nordeste do Brasil. Chromosome Research, 13, 85–96. and distribution of South American titi
47
Zoogeography, genetic variation and conservation
monkeys, genus Callicebus (Family Machado, A.B.M., Martins, C.S. & Primates) and comparison with C. m.
Cebidae, Plathyrrhini). Proceedings of The Drummond, G.M. (2005). Lista da Fauna moloch. Cytobios, 105, 137–145.
Academy of Natural Sciences of brasileira ameaçada de Extinção incluindo
Rodrigues, L.R.R., Barros, R.M.S., Pissinati,
Philadelphia, 140, 240–272. as Listas das Espécies quase ameaçadas e
A., et al. (2004). A new karyotype of an
Hershkovitz, P. (1990). Titis, New World Deficientes em Dados. Brasília: Fundação
endangered primate species (Callicebus
monkeys of the genus Callicebus Biodiversitas & IBAMA/MMA.
personatus) from the Brazilian Atlantic
(Cebidae, Platyrrhini): a preliminary Minezawa, M. & Borda, J.V. (1984). Forests. Hereditas, 140, 87–91.
taxonomic review. Fieldiana Zoology, 55, Cytogenetic study of the Bolivian Titi and Rodrigues, L.R.R., Sousa, M.C., Pieczarka,
1–109. revision of its cytotaxonomic state. Kyoto J.C., et al. (2006). Karyotypic study of
IBGE (2005). Censo Agropecuário. Sistema University Overseas Research Reports on Callicebus coimbrai: a rare and threatened
IBGE da Agricultura (SIDRA). www.ibge. New World Monkeys, 4, 39–45. primate species from Brazil. Caryologia,
gov.br MMA (2006). Portaria N° 26, de 09 de março 59, 248–252.
de 2006. Diário Oficial da União – Seção Rylands, A.B., Rodríguez-Luna, E. & Cortés-
IUCN (1994). Species Survival Commission.
1. www.diario-oficial.com.br/ Ortiz, L. (1996–1997). Neotropical
1994. IUCN Red List Categories. The
World Conservation Union, Gland, Nagamachi, C.Y., Rodrigues, L.R.R., Galetti primate conservation – the species and
Switzerland, 30 November 1994. Jr., P.M., et al. (2003). Cytogenetic studies the IUCN/SSC primate specialist group
in Callicebus personatus nigrifrons network. Primate Conservation, 17,
IUCN (2008). 2008 IUCN Red List of 46–49.
(Platyrrhini, Primates). Caryologia, 56,
threatened Species. Gland: The World
47–52. Schneider, H., Schneider, M.P., Sampaio,
Conservation Union. www.redlist.org
Oliver, W.L.R. & Santos, I.B. (1991). M.I., et al. (1993). Divergence between
Jerusalinsky, L. (2008). Callicebus coimbrai biochemical and cytogenetic differences
Threatened endemic mammals of the
Kobayashi & Langguth 1999. In: Livro in three species of the Callicebus moloch
Atlantic Forest region of south-east
vermelho das espécies da fauna brasileira group. American Journal of Physical
Brazil. Wildlife Preservation Trust, Special
ameaçadas de extinção, ed. A.B.M. Anthropology, 90, 345–350.
Scientific Report, 4, 1–26.
Machado, G.M. Drummond & A.P.
Paglia. Belo Horizonte: Fundação Printes, R.C. (2007). Avaliação taxonômica, Silvano, R.A.M. & Begossi, A. (2005). Local
Biodiversitas, V.II, pp. 769–771. distribuição e status do guigó-da-caatinga. knowledge on a cosmopolitan fish:
Unpublished PhD thesis, Universidade ethnoecology of Pomatomus saltatrix
Jerusalinsky, L., Oliveira, M.M., Pereira, R.F., (Pamatomidae) in Brazil and Australia.
Federal de Minas Gerais.
et al. (2006). Preliminary evaluation of Fisheries Research, 71, 43–59.
the conservation status of Callicebus Printes, R.C. & Rylands, A.B. (2008)
coimbrai Kobayashi & Langguth, 1999 in Callicebus barbarabrownae Hershkovitz Sousa, M.C. (2000). New localities for
the Brazilian state of Sergipe. Primate 1990. In Livro vermelho das espécies da Coimbra-Filho’s titi monkey, Callicebus
Conservation, 21, 25–32. fauna brasileira ameaçadas de extinção, coimbrai, in north-east Brazil. Neotropical
ed. A.B.M. Machado, G.M. Drummond & Primates, 8, 151.
King, M. (1995). Species Evolution: The Role
A.P. Paglia. Belo Horizonte: Fundação Sousa, M.C. (2003). Distribuição do guigó
of Chromosome Change. Cambridge:
Biodiversitas, V.II, pp. 766–768. (Callicebus coimbrai) no Estado de
Cambridge University Press.
Sergipe. Neotropical Primates, 11, 89–91.
Kinzey, W.G. (1982). Distribution of Printes, R.C., Buss, G., Jardim, M.M., et al.
(2010). The urban monkey program: a Stanyon, R., Consigliere, S., Müller, S., et al.
primates and forest refuges. In Biological
survey of Alouatta clamitans in the south (2000). Fluorescence in situ hybridization
Diversification in the Tropics, ed. G.T.
of Porto Alegre and its influence on land (FISH) maps chromosomal homologies
Prance. New York, NY: Columbia
use policy between 1997 and 2007. between the dusky titi and squirrel
University Press, pp. 455–482.
Primate Conservation, 25, 11–19. monkey. American Journal of
Kinzey, W.G. (1997). Callicebus. In New Primatology, 50, 95–107.
World Primates – Ecology, Evolution and Printes, R.C., Rylands, A.B. & Bicca-
Marques, J.C. (2011). Distribution and Takai, M., Anaya, F., Suzuki, H., et al.
Behavior, ed. W.G. Kinzey. New York,
status of the Critically Endangered blond (2001). A new platyrrhine from the
NY: Aldine de Gruyter, pp. 213–221.
titi monkeys of north-east of Brazil. Oryx, middle Miocene of La Venta, Colombia,
Kobayashi, S. & Langguth, A. (1999). A new and the phyletic position of Callicebinae.
45, 439–443.
species of titi monkeys, Callicebus Anthropological Science (Japan), 109,
Thomas, from north-eastern Brazil Rodrigues, L.R.R. (2006). Estudos 289–307.
(Primates, Cebidade). Revista Brasileira citogenéticos comparativos por
bandeamentos e pintura cromossômica van Roosmalen, M.G.M., van Roosmalen, T.
de Zoologia, 16, 531–551.
(ZOO-FISH) em Callicebus (Platyrrhini – & Mittermeier, R.A. (2002). A taxonomic
Lacy, R.C. (1992). The effects of inbreeding on review of the titi monkeys, genus
isolated populations: are minimum viable Primates). Unpublished PhD thesis,
Universidade Federal do Pará. Callicebus Thomas, 1903, with the
population sizes predictable? In Conservation description of two new species, Callicebus
Biology – The Theory and Practice of Nature Rodrigues, L.R.R., Barros, R.M.S., Pissinati, bernhardi and Callicebus stephennashi,
Conservation, ed. P.L. Fiedler & S.K. Jain. A., et al. (2001). Cytogenetic study of from Brazilian Amazonia. Neotropical
London: Chapman & Hall, pp. 277–296. Callicebus hoffmannsi (Cebidae, Primates, 10, 1–52.
48
Acknowledgments
Veiga, L.M., Printes, R.C., Rylands, A.B., Veiga, L.M., Sousa, M.C., Jerusalinsky, L., Wallace, R.B., Gómez, H., Felton, A., et al.
et al. (2008a). Callicebus barbarabrownae. et al. (2008b). Callicebus coimbrai. In (2006). On a new species of titi monkey,
In 2008 IUCN Red List of Threatened 2008 IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, genus Callicebus Thomas (Primates,
Species, ed. IUCN. Gland: IUCN. http:// ed. IUCN. Gland: IUCN. http://www. Pitheciidae), from western Bolivia with
www.iucnredlist.org/apps/redlist/details/ iucnredlist.org/apps/redlist/details/ preliminary notes on distribution and
39929/0. 39954/0. abundance. Primate Conservation, 20, 29–39.
49