Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TPM - 5 Countermeasures To Achieve Zero Breakdown
TPM - 5 Countermeasures To Achieve Zero Breakdown
TPM - 5 Countermeasures To Achieve Zero Breakdown
TPM
Hand Book
By
Jayant Kumar
(TPM Expert)
1
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
4.
5 Countermeasures to
Achieve Zero Breakdown
2
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
Basic
equipment
condition
neglected
Usage Insufficient
condition operating &
not maintenance
observed 5 skills
Countermeasures
Inharent
Deterioration weakness in
overlooked equipment
design
3
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
1. Establish the Basic Equipment Condition :
4
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
5
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
simply combining vendor’s operating manual without a careful study. On the shop
floor, frontline managers and engineers are always pressed to resolve current
breakdowns and quality defects, and as a result, do not have enough time either to
remedy equipment or to revise given standards in order to facilitate lubrication under
actual operating conditions.
Maintenance personnel are also very busy with too many jobs for repair. Operators,
too, are always attending to changeovers and a large number of minor stoppages
which leave them with insufficient time to follow given lubricating standards.
Everyone hopes that no severe breakdown will occur in their shifts. Moreover, the
number of lubricating points is skyrocketing in accordance with the increase of
automation in the repetitive manual workshop. If no serious response is made, the
burden on operators and maintenance technicians will increase and the situation will
get worse day by day.
Tightening : Almost all equipment is put together with fasteners such as nuts and
bolts. Damaged, loose or lost fastening parts cause vibrations, misalignments or
defective actuations in equipment, as a result, minor stoppages and breakdowns. It
is not rare for a plant handling highly flammable materials to have serious accidents
involving fires or explosions. These are often consequences of leaked flammable
agents caused by loose bolts at flanges.
When one of several bolts is loose, it does not necessarily result in to immediate
leakage. Repeated expansion and contraction as a result of temperature change and
vibration can allow one loose bolt to loosen other bolts. The resulting play then
becomes larger and larger until it eventually exceeds a limit in tolerance. A minor
defect, such as one loose bolt, if neglected, grows in to a moderate and finally a
major defect which sometimes results in a sudden breakdown or at worst,
catastrophic failure.
According to a very detailed survey on the causes of breakdowns made in one plant,
60 percent of them involved, to some extent, defective nuts & bolts. In another plant,
an overall inspection revealed even more astonishing results : that is, 1091 out of
2273 bolts were loose or lost, for an amazing 48 percent incidence of defects. In
addition, various troubles frequently occur due to over-, under-, or uneven tightening
of nuts and bolts on die and jigs assemblies. Improper tightening also occurs due to
poor skilling in tooling during changeover.
6
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
7
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
3. Restore Deteriorated Parts :
When a breakdown does occur, attempts to remedy the problem often are of a
symptomatic nature. In other words, only a broken are repaired or replaced without
sufficient follow up on the possible deterioration of related parts.
For example, a shaft breaks at a notch. Prior to simple replacement with a spare
parts or design change to reinforce it, it is more important to investigate, first of all,
whether usage conditions were closely adhered to and whether overall balance of
equipment continues exist. After a detailed survey of nearby related parts has been
made, the shaft must be replaced. Only when such survey concludes, however, that
a design change is absolutely necessary, will required action be taken to alter the
shape, material, or thermal treatment of the existing shaft.
In an actual case of a factory, the real cause of breakage did not exist in the shaft. It
was, to the contrary, excessive vibration resulting from abrasion in a keyway that
produced the break at the weakest notched portion of the shaft.
Many companies are eager to encourage any improvement (Kaizen) focussed on
equipment and work methods. In spite of the successful progress in the beginning, it
usually fades after a while, because there are not many situations that can be
handled by those who have little technical expertise, few remarkable results can be
anticipated. In other words, such attitudes reflects slipshod managerial attitudes and
a lack of leadership in expecting productive suggestions from frontline personnel
who have not received adequate education.
When a basic equipment conditions are well established and usage conditions are
simply followed, a considerable number of breakdowns are eliminated. There must
be expected, nevertheless, a certain number of design or installation mistakes
resulting from technical demands facing engineers in charge of plant engineering
and construction. Most of these relatively early mistakes can be resolved easily
through test runs and commissioning.
When a breakdown occurs in a piece of equipment that already has entered in to the
chance breakdown period, partial restoration or improvement approached only in
terms of broken parts, and without proper attention to deterioration in related parts
will lead to similar breakdown in the same equipment. When deterioration in
adjoining parts is neglected and remains hidden, it is safe to say that related parts
must have deteriorated when a certain part was broken. In most case, the
deterioration barely remained within safe tolerance and was simply overlooked.
Equipment normally deteriorates gradually as the time passes. The most
deteriorated or weakened parts are broken by one another. Before deciding on
piecemeal improvement, one should return to the original drawings and
specifications to recognize all possible instance of deterioration. Although, this
regimen, which restores overall balance in equipment, may seem to be lengthy, it is,
in reality, the shortest path to Zero Breakdown.
8
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
4. Correct Design Weakness :
Equipment manufacturers do not have enough experience in fabricating goods with
equipment they have manufactured themselves. In spite of their best efforts to
respond to the user’s requests, equipment all too frequently is designed based on
engineer’s imagination rather than on experience with past problems in the
operations.
Even if equipment is designed in house, most plant engineers have limited
experience and know how in production & maintenance, because personnel who
design equipment and those who use it have different backgrounds and belong to
different departments, problems are destined to occur at their interface. Correcting
weakness is design therefore, becomes necessary during the commercial production
stage and must usually be initiated by shop floor personnel.
In each step of Autonomous Maintenance programs, frontline personnel focus on
specific pinpointed areas, such as sources of contamination, difficult work areas,
lubrication, tightening, power transmission and so on. After clearly setting out
intentions and targets, they currently tackle equipment malfunctions and design
weaknesses. In particular, they remedy breakdowns and quality defects in
accordance with technical and logical interfaces based on the assessment of current
machine working conditions.
In this way, shop floor people can come up with excellent ideas if they are
adequately educated on how to accomplish improvement with the suitable technical
assistance of specialists.
9
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
Accordingly, many companies apply on-the-job methods for operator training. This
kind of training, however, can be quire ineffective. It often results in nothing being
done because too much reliance is placed on the shop floor. There are few
companies, who provide a skill development program for individual employees, for
example, by implementing a skill evaluation system. Furthermore, a detailed study
shows that there are many incorrect methods of equipment operation, maintenance
and inspection which were viewed as correct.
Therefore a different approach in which techniques applicable to specific types of
machinery or processes are identified and applied, is indicated. Subsequently,
operators and maintenance personnel learn how to apply these particular operation
and maintenance skills. In the meantime, it must be remembered that these essential
techniques are always changing, especially in accordance with progress in
automation technology.
10
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
Skill Evaluation Sheet
Process : Self Evaluation No :
Train fellow Widely utilize Properly utilize Necessary skills Sufficient skills
SKILL operators based proper skills to indispensable not fully acquired not acquired yet
on superior skills routine tasks skills to routine yet (less than 1 year
tasks experience)
*Teach general *Comprehend *Comprehend *Insufficiently *Insufficient
matters of type of lubricants type, comprehend type, comprehend
lubrication & lubricating characteristics & characteristics & lubrication.
materials. usage of usage of
*Revise lubricants. lubricants.
lubricating *Comprehend
standards. lubricants points
*Analyse past & surfaces.
problems caused *Execute colour
by poor lubrication
lubrication. control.
*Know past
breakdowns
LUBRICATION caused by poor
lubrication.
*Analyse and *Detect & remedy *Properly *Properly *Lubricate per
remedy defective parts lubricate following lubricate in a request.
breakdowns during routine lubricating longer time
caused by poor inspection. standards. frame.
lubrication *Suggest better & *Inspect
easier lubricating. lubricating points
*Manage local & surface and
lubricants storage take necessary
corrective
actions.
*Properly manage
lubricants & tools
11
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
Who takes the 5 Countermeasures ?:
5 countermeasures should never be implemented solely by the maintenance
department, even though it is involved to some extent with all matters pertaining to
equipment. It is apparent that manufacturing can not be continued for long without
the functions of both operation and maintenance. These two functions, however,
generally have been separated from each other. To successfully execute the 5
countermeasures, the functions and roles of production and maintenance
departments as given in picture below page.
Accordingly, the production department takes charge of basic routine maintenance in
addition to its conventional tasks relating to production. These supplemental efforts
by operators are referred to as Autonomous Maintenance and consist of these
activities:
Maintaining the basic equipment condition.
Adhering to usage conditions of equipment.
Visually inspecting of external deterioration of equipment to detect signs of
abnormalities by the five senses (Look, Listen, Touch, Feel & Smell) and by
relatively easy machine diagnostic techniques.
Enhancing operating, setup, adjustment and inspection skills.
On the other hand, it is maintenance department that takes charge of more
sophisticated maintenance. These maintenance personnel’s efforts are referred to as
full time maintenance and consist of the following activities:
Technically assisting Autonomous Maintenance.
Definitely restoring defective parts in equipment by inspection, overhaul,
condition monitoring and machine diagnosis.
Identifying appropriate usage conditions of equipment and taking necessary
remedial actions when design weaknesses are discovered.
Enhancing maintenance knowledge and skills.
When the production and maintenance departments fulfil these designated roles,
proper equipment conditions can be established and maintained by the approach of
the five countermeasures.
12
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
5 countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
Production Department
Maintenance Department
13
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
Restructuring the Roles of Production & Maintenance Departments :
Until recently, most Japanese manufacturers, influenced by American style factory
management, clearly separated the roles of production and maintenance
departments. They were convinced that this way of working was the most effective
method to utilize human resources. Operators concentrated on production with little
knowledge about the structure and function of the equipment. Concurrently,
maintenance personnel took an indifferent attitude to work orders. As a result,
operators and maintenance personnel went their own ways instead of following the
path of mutual cooperation.
To keep up with recent progress in automation of assembly industries, various types
of machinery are being installed in factories at a rapidly increasing rate. Shop floor
personnel, on the contrary, are gradually decreasing in number and becoming older
in average age. A more serious problem, widely found in many highly industrialized
countries, is the tendency of the younger generation to loose interest in the
manufacturing business. It is quite natural for young men and women who can
choose their own future not to look forward to hard work in a dirty factory with
dangerous equipment and a relatively low income.
In view of these developments, it becomes critical to the survival of companies
competing in the worldwide market place to improve dramatically, over the next
decade, their productivity and quality as well as the working conditions on the shop
floor. In this regard, TPM has rapidly become popular because companies can
succeed in overcoming today’s difficulties by restructuring the roles of the production
and the maintenance departments in accordance with the seven steps of the
Autonomous Maintenance Program.
14
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
Preventive Maintenance :
Routine Maintenance : Maintain the basic equipment conditions and replace
deteriorating parts.
Periodic Maintenance : Periodically inspect equipment and restore defective
parts.
Predictive Maintenance : Correct equipment deterioration by condition
monitoring and machine diagnosis.
Breakdown Maintenance :
Correct equipment deterioration after the occurrence of breakdowns. This becomes
unnecessary when TPM is successfully implemented. Remedial activities extend
equipment life, reduce the time spent for maintenance work and eventually, make
maintenance itself unnecessary.
Reliability Improvement : Prevent breakdowns by improving reliability of
equipment.
Maintainability Improvement : Make maintenance work easier.
All the above activities can be classified in to three major maintenance activities –
Restoration, Inspection & Prevention of equipment deterioration. Maintenance goals
can not be attained if any of the above activities is neglected, even though these
activities differ from each other in terms of methods and effectiveness.
Maintenance Activities for Production Department (Autonomous Maintenance)
The production department focuses on prevention of deterioration and takes charge
of the following:
1. Restoring Deteriorated Parts:
2. Inspecting Deterioration:
3. Preventing Deterioration:
15
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
Among these activities, maintenance of basic equipment conditions and routine
inspection are the most essential one. Conducting them exclusively by the
maintenance department, however, results in and excessive work volume. It might
be feasible if additional maintenance personnel are mobilized as required, but to do
so is usually impossible.
If, on the other hand, operators deal with deterioration, more certain execution and
effective results are expected. Operators, obviously, are always working around their
equipment and should know best about daily equipment conditions and their trends.
However, bringing operators to the point of conducting Autonomous Maintenance
activities requires continuous education and practice for as long as three or four
years. Furthermore, a satisfactory operators maintenance system must be organized
and developed in accordance with detailed concept of the seven step program.
Autonomous Maintenance depends mainly on knowledgeable operators who are
able to assume responsibility for routine aspects of their work by themselves. When
TPM is not fully recognized for what it is, neither Zero Breakdowns nor Zero Defects
will be attained. All TPM activities, including Autonomous Maintenance, preliminary
enhance human capability and change ways of thinking rather than equipment.
Recognizing this point, leadership must incorporate TPM in to mid and long term
managerial plans of the company.
Maintenance Activities for the Maintenance Department (Full Time Maintenance):
2. Inspecting Deterioration:
Preventing Deterioration:
Perform professional maintenance work.
Perform and manage maintenance work to be subcontracted.
Improve equipment reliability and maintainability.
Manage information regarding improvement and maintenance prevention and
submit to the engineering department.
Faithful restoration of deteriorated parts in equipment, which used to be unfeasible
even for maintenance department, is now carried by the operators. The maintenance
department must, instead, be responsible for higher maintenance levels such as
more sophisticated improvement, condition monitoring, machine diagnosis, risk
16
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
management and so on. It also must report to plant engineering department more
detailed information about design weakness discovered in existing extended parts
life – accomplished with the operators efforts – maintenance personnel can now
conduct various routine tasks. To this end, full time maintenance activities must be
developed in close cooperation with autonomous maintenance, as summarized here.
17
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
Record Maintenance Prevention Information to Plant Engg Department :
No matter how considerable the efforts that have been made, improvement of an
existing plant yields very small benefits when the plant’s life cycle costs in terms of
attributes, such as, reliability, maintainability, operability, safety, and economy, are
taken in to account. Those characteristics are almost completely determined in the
engineering, fabrication and installation stages.
Therefore, operating, breakdown and quality defects data, as well as improvement
information regarding such characteristics, must be fed back to the plant engineering
department to impact on the development and design of future plant. This kind of
information is referred to as maintenance prevention information or MP information.
It must be standardized and compiled in to written documents which can be readily
shared by anyone concerned.
In many companies, the maintenance department is frequently not interested in
improvement of maintainability. In other words, no one can comprehend how slowly
maintenance personnel repair or overhaul equipment. The eagerness of
maintenance personnel to tackle work promptly and effectively is much poorer than
that of operators to increase productivity. Maintenance department managers and
engineers must give maximum attention to this point.
18
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown
19
TPM Handbook _ 5 Countermeasures to achieve Zero Breakdown