Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Towards Contemporariness of Local Architecture Les
Towards Contemporariness of Local Architecture Les
ness, and solutions for environmental and social problems. This case aims at producing a compatible architecture for
this society. The problem of the paper deals with the absence of the local heritage in contemporary architecture. Most
of our buildings reflect western ideologies, and use the local vocabulary, as has happened in most of the Arab archi-
tecture, that deals directly with a language of shapes to create compatibility with the public. Hence, the aim of the paper
is to link the variables that the contemporary architecture formulated with concepts of local architecture. To meet such
aims, the research is pivot around two themes: Firstly, tackling how to extract the forces that lead to the contemporari-
ness of local heritage and formalize the DNA of any local community (Culture, Community Aspiration, Climate, and
Technology), as well as discussing some experience that dealt with local architecture. Secondly, discussing some recent
trials that learned from the previous attempts through history. The attempts strongly re-activate the local architecture in
the contemporary challenges, namely, the use of heritage forms as is to conform to environmental determinants, devel-
opment of these forms using contemporary materials through the visions of local architecture, and employing high-tech
solutions to achieve contemporary appropriateness within traditional ideologies. In the end, the paper presents new
ideas of the local architecture that learned from the previous experiences in our Arab societies to meet the needs of
today’s Arab societies.
open house international vol.42 No.1, March 2017. Towards Contemporariness of Local Architecture: Lessons learned from Previous Experience.
Figure 1. Concept of the local architecture as a link between Contemporariness of the Local Architecture (CLA), or
the forces of the recruiting process of architecture (Source: the Contemporary Local Architecture (Figure1).
Author, 2015).
could be said that local architecture is the connecting 2/1 THE ORIGINAL MODEL: THE COMPLEX OF SUL-
link among different forces in the process of forming TAN HASAN
the architecture, these forces are: Firstly, the cultural In praise of the complex, al- Maqrizi writes; “There is
heritage (H) of a huge reservoir continuously renewed no sanctuary of the Muslims, known in the lands of
through different ears. Secondly, community aspiration Islam that equals this jāmic and its dome, the likes of
(C), which is a variable and volatile dynamic force. which has not been built-in Egypt, Syria, Iraq, North
These two forces usually interact and are considered Africa, or Yemen.” Both Ibn Taghri Birdi and Ibn
the core of the actions that are intangible and non- Shahin describe it as an edifice with no equal and one
measurable. Thirdly, the climate/ environmental of the wonders of the world. In an elaborate
atmosphere (E), which is a source of imagination and metaphor, Ibn Habib considers it superior to the pyra-
inspiration for any society, and it is involved in creat- mids of Giza and the Iwan of Kisra (H). The monu-
ing the cultural inventory of any nation. Fourthly, tech- mental porch stands four stories tall and is considered
nology (T), which is rapidly changing in architecture. It the largest portal in Cairo (T) (Al- Harithy, 1996). The
intervenes in all construction details and affects the plan of the Sultan Hasan complex distinguishes the
architecture forms all over the world. These two forces public zone (the jāmic, the major teaching āwāns,
are considered the secondary connection that is spe- and the mausoleum) from the private of each of the
cific, measurable and determined. Thus, the main madrasah units and adjusts scale and accessibility (Al-
goal is to combine those four forces in the contempo- Harithy, 1996) (Figure 2).
rary local architecture (Sutton, 2007). We can say that It is clear that the design seems to have
the four basic forces that formulate the DNA of any accommodated the site conditions and the sizes of the
local community are the Cultural Heritage (H), madrasahs in a more of a hierarchical fashion that
Aspirations of the Community (C), Climate/ responded more to the actual following of the four
Environmental Atmosphere (E), and Technology (T). madrasahs in Egypt (C). The educational, social, and
When these forces (HCET) interact, and became religious institutions that constituted the main block of
merged with the concepts and visions of contemporary the building represented the people. Each institution
life variables, we can reach the so-called: fulfilled a community need and referred to a different
social group (C).
Placing the mau-
soleum between
the complex and
the Citadel repre-
sents the Sultan as
standing between
the people and the
Mamluks, (Kahil,
2008) (Figure 3).
Figure 3. The Four Madrasahs, Complex of Sultan Hasan, Cairo Source: H. Al-Harithy. The Complex of
Sultan Hasan, 1996, P. 53-72)
103
Gasser Gamil Abdel-Azim
open house international vol.42 No.1, March 2017. Towards Contemporariness of Local Architecture: Lessons learned from Previous Experience.
Figure 4. Ramses Wissa Wassef Arts Centre, Giza, Egypt, 1974 (Source: The Aga Khan Award for Architecture, 0291.EGY)
3 LESSONS USING TRADITIONAL FORMS FOR rejection of conventional modern Egyptian architec-
ENvIRONMENTAL APPROPRIATENESS ture, and his studies for ways of developing the tradi-
tional mud-brick architecture to serve a wider range of
These lessons have represented the designs that con- needs. Wassef was firmly resolved never to sacrifice his
form to the social, economic, and political environ- artistic vision for current trends of construction. He
ment. They referred to the traditional, popular forms said, "One cannot separate beauty from utility, the
and the available natural materials, which have form from the material, the work from its job, the man
proved to be environmentally and economically from his creative art". The structural systems, materials,
appropriate. and techniques used are similar throughout, although
they too evolved in response to experience and differ-
3/1 Ramses Wissa Wassef ing users' requirements (The Aga Khan Award, 1983)
Said; "Where I had been struck by the beauty of the (Figure 4).
Nubian houses in the villages of the area, I learned
that it was still possible to find bricklayers who could 3/2 Hassan Fathy
make vaulted roofs for houses”. He resolved to keep He has made many local and popular restorations,
up their presence in his own architectural work for rea- but his works were not without renovation. He added
sons of aesthetics, climate, and economics. He made the old experience and represented newly developed
use of the traditional artisans such as stonecutter, tra- solutions for refined climatic and environmental prob-
ditional carpenters, glass blowers and potters who had lems (E). Therefore, he re-discovered this method to
inherited the techniques and traditions of the Egyptian deal with the architecture not only on the level of the
vernacular heritage (H). The choice of this traditional building detail, or on the climate change, but com-
technology also reflected his wish to transfer the val- patible with the social environment, on the urban
ues of handicraft to succeeding generations in a level. His keenness and study of social aspects for any
rapidly industrializing country. It reflects Wissa Wassef's community are one of the most important influences
Figure 5. Alpha Bianca Palace for Yannick Fu, Ben Jacooper Artists, Majorca, Spanish east coast, Spain, 1979 (Source:
Images from the internet).
104
Gasser Gamil Abdel-Azim
Figure 6. Al-Azhar Park Restaurant, Cairo, 2004, Kafr El-Gouna Resort, Hurghada- Red sea, 1993-2000 (Source:Asfour,
2010, p.80-83)
open house international vol.42 No.1, March 2017. Towards Contemporariness of Local Architecture: Lessons learned from Previous Experience.
before the design (C). Moreover, he takes into account
the economic level using available materials; it is a Another type of lessons tends to understand, re- con-
case of integration and compatibility with nature sider and develop the function of these basic, tradi-
(Serageldin, 2009). The Alpha Bianca palace is one of tional forms. Here, the modern materials are used with
the unique prototypes. It features on the other work of the traditional ones. This combination does not
Hassan Fathy, by using the Andalusian style (H). We breach the environmental compatibility, but it creates
found that he has distinguished stems from respect for a completely new formation that has the spirit of the
the local culture, trying to find the roots of the original contemporary and the essence of the local architec-
architecture while keeping up with the time, and serve ture.
in line with human environment, with the use of avail-
able local material (E). It also adopted thought of the 4/1 Abdel-Halim Ibrahim
cooperative construction, and not as some believe
that, his distinguished creativity and skills are only lim- Said; “It's a community Architecture and not a memo-
ited to the use of mud, domes, and vaults (C) (Fathy, rial one; it is based on the society thought where each
1992) (Figure 5). building is an experience that includes continuing edu-
cation process”. He came up with the form of lan-
3/3 Rami El Dahan and Soheir Farid guage that stems from the heart of a local architectur-
Most of their works are for touristic services. This is al thought based on a set of design principles that
because the success of these forms is to express the explore his vision. These principles include; First,
local heritage (H). Therefore, they used new vocabu- urban condensation to fit the environmental and
lary terms with the aim of giving the last versions of the social conditions of any society benefiting from the
composition by understanding the origin of these func- local architecture. It is a recognition that the real value
tions to use arcades, wooden works, walls, ceil- of this creative legacy is a solution to the problems
ings…etc. They also introduced a case of incorpora- facing the society today and tomorrow. Second, the
tion with the surrounding environment additionally interaction between the user and built environment
provided through the re-use of local forms that have within its orientation, elevations forms, and the avail-
proven throughout history, most compatible environ- able materials used to predict of the awareness. He
mental and climatic conditions (E). The idea of their considers the principle of the interaction as the most
works is to live with it, to live in it, and to enrich spiri- important aspect of the local architecture (Ismail,
tually by it. This is not a new idea, it is a tradition that 2003). It should be conserved using his full con-
comes from a time when men’s lives were tied to the sciousness about the shift in the circumstances, tradi-
land and nurtured by it. Most of his projects were con- tions, and habits that have taken place on our local
sidered an environmentally sound architecture that societies. This shift dispossesses our communities from
belong to the land upon which it has been built. They any means of a mechanism to control the building
adopted the vocabulary of vaults and domes to meet process of their homes. However, he believes in recon-
the function of the buildings. They built their projects sidering and strengthening the concept of the produc-
to show different experience and expressions in a tive community, (Ali, 2011) (Figure7).
community that are all in harmony together (C). Within
the same vocabulary and style, they present a variety Third: the real response of the local environment,
of designs and different scenarios. Although the use of according to Ibrahim, “the obligation of maturing the
local materials contributes to create a local image, it different spatial spaces and their relations to the envi-
does not help to create a local lifestyle, (Asfour, 2010) ronmental factors. The local materials will meet for
(Figure 6). traditional architecture that is naturally in a well cli-
mate treatment. Those spaces have an impact which
4 LESSONS DEvELOPING TRADITIONAL FORMS affects the user and influenced it, thereby creating a
USING CONTEMPORARY MATERIALS highly valuable architecture” (Ismail, 2003). The Nile
Gallery, designed by him attempted to join the new
105
Gasser Gamil Abdel-Azim
open house international vol.42 No.1, March 2017. Towards Contemporariness of Local Architecture: Lessons learned from Previous Experience.
Figure 7. Ministry of Housing competition for designing: One million dwelling units, third prize (Source: Ali, 2011, p.50-53)
modern function into heritage values. His main con- to the everyday activities. Moreover, he offers new
cern was to link the current art movement in Egypt with insights and distinctiveness to such governmental
our cultural heritage. This was psychologically using buildings while maintaining authenticity and prestige.
color, texture, and distinctive intimate masses. The roof Rasem Badran also entered the environmental studies
of the main hall was supported by steel trusses that as one of the important factors influencing the build-
covered by a glass roof for natural lighting purposes. ings forms (E). We see his works as an extension of the
The mix of the use of stones, steel and glass in the legacy of the historic area. Rather, by the spirit of cre-
façade creates another link between local visual ativity and innovation of the forms were not forged by
images and global high-tech (Salama, 1999) to accommodate the building's needs, whether in the
(Figure8). traditional forms, external walls, openings, air move-
ment and the ability to adapt the local material for
4/2 Rasem Badran modern forms (T) (Abdel-Gawad, 2013) (Figure9).
His work involves the full spectrum of the built envi-
ronment, from urban planning to each residence. He 4/3 Tamer El-Gabaly
concentrates on making architecture that meets the He tries to revive the vocabulary of local architecture
social and cultural requirements of the people who derived from the cultural heritage and geographical
use it (C), as well as being place- specific in response climate outstanding prevailing. This imposition of
to environmental conditions. He inspires the ideas of solutions in architecture to reshape the cognitive impli-
his buildings from the architectural heritage of the city cations of the character embodiment in the physical
context, where the buildings are blending tradition spatial framework. In addition to, the respects of the
with the use of modern technology in construction, religious, psychological, ideological and veneration
and where the social and religious dimensions linked for Mashrabiya in Arabic architecture and its implica-
Figure 8. The Nile Gallery, Opera Grounds, Cairo, 1997. An Example of Nationalized Modernism/ Modernized
Regionalism by Abdel Halim Ibrahim (Source: Author, 2015)
106
Gasser Gamil Abdel-Azim
Figure 9. Rasem Badran’s works is representing the com-
patibility between the heritage and contemporary (Source:
http://www.daralomran@daralomran.com, accessed June
open house international vol.42 No.1, March 2017. Towards Contemporariness of Local Architecture: Lessons learned from Previous Experience.
2015) Figure 10. Headquarters of the New Urban Communities
tions (H). It does not only emphasis on the concept of Authority, El- Sheikh Zayed, Egypt, 2010 (Source: Khaled,
Mashrabiya and its characteristics from an environ- et.al., 2011, p.34-37)
mental perspective without blend elements of shading
such as tents and wooden pergolas (E). Moreover, the
architect’s dependence on natural materials that are
locally available such as stone and wood is environ-
ment- friendly. He also mixes between the Arab fea-
tures of the building architecture and the natural envi-
ronment of local vocabulary with its various elements
of palms, plants, fountains and the floor patterns
whether it's the main plaza of the project or the gar-
dens surrounding the building (E) . An integrated Arab
environment in the contemporary image reflects on
the glass of the middle building. He uses sun breakers
and elements of the shading from Mashrabiya manu-
facturer of G.R.C, and all this in the framework of an
integrated perspective to emphasize the design con-
cept of the project (T), (Khaled, et al., 2011)
(Figure10).
108
6 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
open house international vol.42 No.1, March 2017. Towards Contemporariness of Local Architecture: Lessons learned from Previous Experience.
and they make the best use of the technological
advancement.
The paper has shed light on some of the
attempts that take into consideration the four basic
Figure 18. The architects try to compromise between local forces (HCET) that form the architecture DNA of any
and modernity (Source: Author, 2008). local community: inheritance Cultural Heritage (H),
aspirations of the Community (C), Climate/
The character of the project is an expression and an Environmental atmosphere (E), and Technology (T).
understanding of what is behind these traditional for- These attempts try to deal with the traditional forms
mations. It is not a case of calling such forms, and not that characterize their societies in the contemporary
quoting from Western buildings. Thus, the designers reality while producing local tint architecture to fit the
want to produce an architecture that is compatible place, time and comply with the conditions and vari-
with the local environment, and intellectually contem- ables. These lessons have been divided according to
porary for the user culture. The study of the character their achievements of the forces related to the local
simply clarifies the reforming and access to all the architecture as follow:
principles and the ideologies of heritage, through an
architectural vocabulary that does not affect the pro- Some attempts concentrated on the forces of Cultural
ject economics. Several factors identified (derived Heritage (H), and aspirations of the Community (C)
from the basis of the local architecture), to create a through re-using the traditional forms that provided
visual consecutive project to confirm a mental image good solutions to environmental problems to find this
of the public, and respect their culture, (Figure17). connection with local architecture, and ignore the use
We see that the service part shows ally her- of Technology (T). Other architects confirmed that the
itage vocabulary to represent intimacy to the local contemporary technological and scientific variables
community. Traditional materials such as light and should have an impact and changes in the vocabulary
dark strips of stone (Ablque) finished that cluster (H). of architectural form in local architecture. Therefore,
This part of the building makes a clear contrast with they decided to develop this vocabulary through using
the cultural mass, which represents the modernity (that new materials besides the traditional ones that con-
inspired from Abdel- Halim Ibrahim works), that mass serve the environmental compatibility (the Technology
was finished by contemporary materials such as glass, (T) starts to represent here). Other attempts used mod-
stainless steel, and metal sheets. In addition, the dou- ern technology (T), in response to the climate restric-
ble skin is designed to control the lighting (T), and to tions, and as an approach to combine contemporary
show the heritage of traditional and popular symbols variables with the local architecture. They believe that
characterized and known for its culture of community technology cannot be ignored. They see the modern
and place, (Figure18). trends as potentialities that can be used nowadays to
The most important considerations of local produce buildings appropriate to the environment,
architecture were taken into account: regardless of the architectural structure. Here, they
ignore the factors of Cultural Heritage (H), aspirations
Creating internal planted courtyards to fill in some of the Community (C).
spaces in the northern side, without overlooking the The biggest challenge is related to the ques-
amount of the natural light allowed. Increasing the tion of how the inherited civilization, the feeling of
greeneries in front of the noisy sides, and deliberately nostalgia can be used to motivate the creative contri-
using narrow openings as much as possible in the butions of Arab architects to humanity within the cur-
sides exposed to the southern and western. The rent temporal and spatial framework of the second
thought of the functional and philosophical project decade of the twenty -one century. Hence, the Arab
stands in contrast with the idea of a strong challenge architects, have a big responsibility to create spaces
to the future extension of the project. Therefore, the that respect and relate to the distinctive Local archi-
architects adopted horizontal extension thought the tecture, but at the same time, address the present and
vertical direction than in the horizontal direction. explore the future.
109
7 REFERENCES ASFOUR, K. (2013). The Hassan Fathi Award for Architecture,
Gasser Gamil Abdel-Azim
University, pp. 70
110