Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 25

Periodontology 2000, Vol.

60, 2012, 15–39  2012 John Wiley & Sons A/S


Printed in Singapore. All rights reserved PERIODONTOLOGY 2000

The global burden of periodontal


disease: towards integration with
chronic disease prevention and
control
P O U L E. P E T E R S E N & H I R O S H I O G A W A

Chronic diseases are the leading causes of death and diabetes mellitus and this number is predicted to
disability worldwide. Disease rates from these con- increase by about 50% by year 2030 (32). Figure 1
ditions are accelerating globally, advancing across indicates that the incidence of diabetes will rise
every region and pervading all socioeconomic clas- considerably in the near future, and this may increase
ses. According to the World Health Organization the burden of periodontal disease and tooth loss.
(WHO) (85, 90, 91, 93), the major chronic diseases Much of this increase will occur in developing
currently account for about 40% of the global bur- countries and will be caused by population growth,
den of disease and by year 2020, their contribution ageing, unhealthy diets, obesity and sedentary life-
is expected to rise to 60% of the global burden of styles. The 40–59 years age-group currently has the
disease. The most rapid increase in the burden of greatest number of people with diabetes (132 million
chronic diseases is occurring in developing coun- in 2010), more than 75% of whom live in developing
tries (33). Four of the most prominent chronic dis- countries (32).
eases – cardiovascular diseases, cancer, chronic Available data suggest that the prevalence of diag-
obstructive pulmonary disease and type 2 diabetes – nosed and undiagnosed diabetes mellitus in older
are linked by common and preventable biological subjects approaches 20% (49). In the child popula-
risk factors, notably high blood pressure, high blood tions of many countries, diabetes also adds to the
cholesterol and being overweight, and by related burden of disease, and Type 2 diabetes mellitus has
major behavioral risk factors. An unhealthy diet and been described as a new epidemic (85). In 1992, the
poor nutrition over a prolonged period of time, incidence of Type 2 diabetes was rare in most child
physical inactivity, tobacco use, excessive use of populations, whereas during recent years it was
alcohol and psychosocial stress are the important found to range from 8% to 45%, depending on geo-
lifestyle components (18). graphic location (32, 37).
Diabetes mellitus is a heterogeneous group of dis- Tobacco use is a most important risk factor for
orders with different causes, but all are characterized chronic disease. In the WHO European and Western
by hyperglycemia. Type 1 (insulin-dependent diabe- Pacific Regions, the prevalence rates of tobacco use
tes mellitus) is caused by destruction of the insulin- are high among adults, particularly men (Fig. 2A,B)
producing cells. Type 2 (noninsulin-dependent (95). During recent years, the global pattern of to-
diabetes mellitus) is the result of insulin resistance bacco consumption has changed dramatically. Pre-
coupled with relative beta-cell failure (32). It has viously, the consumption of tobacco was prevalent
recently been reported that Type 2 diabetes accounts in high-income countries; however, a decline of to-
for ca. 90% of all cases of diabetes mellitus in the bacco use in these countries is now taking place. In
populations of several countries (32, 85). Approxi- contrast, the consumption of tobacco in middle-
mately 285 million people worldwide suffer from and low-income countries shows a dramatic

15
Petersen & Ogawa

Fig. 1. Global projection for the number of people with diabetes. From International Diabetes Foundation, Diabetes Atlas
(32).

increase, which may have a significant bearing on disease, in which breakdown of the supporting tis-
the burden of chronic disease, including periodontal sues of the teeth occurs. Clinical signs of the disease
disease. include deepening of periodontal pockets and loss of
The entire population is at risk because of the attachment, progressively leading to loosening of
presence of many elevated risk factors in which teeth and ultimately to tooth loss. Periodontal
individual susceptibility is affected by culture, destruction may be caused by local factors, such as
socioeconomic factors and the environment. Action dental biofilm, or it may reflect an inadequate im-
to prevent the major chronic diseases should focus mune response. Gingivitis and periodontitis can also
on these upstream social determinants and on con- be manifestations of certain systemic diseases, for
trolling the behavioral risk factors in a well-integrated example, in people with general infection or among
manner. The population risks are amenable to people infected with HIV (45). In addition to the
change through community-wide strategies. Com- chronic form of periodontal disease (i.e. gingivitis
munity interventions use education or environmental and periodontitis), periodontal disease may manifest
change to promote and facilitate lifestyle and in acute forms, such as necrotizing ulcerative gingi-
behavior changes needed to address a particular vitis with painful infection, which may destroy the
problem. gingival tissue, or as necrotizing ulcerative peri-
odontitis in which the bone beneath the gingival
tissue becomes infected or exposed. Aggressive
Periodontal disease forms of periodontitis may be found in young indi-
viduals, but the prevalence of this condition is low.
Periodontal disease is one of the two most important The aim of the present report was to highlight the
oral diseases contributing to the global burden of global burden of periodontal disease. The ultimate
chronic disease (12); the disease is highly prevalent burden of periodontal disease – tooth loss – and the
worldwide and therefore represents a major public periodontal health status are described from WHO
health problem to countries. There are different epidemiological data. In addition, the importance of
clinical manifestations of periodontal disease, and it key risk factors and oral health systems are empha-
may be acute or chronic (45). Gingivitis refers to the sized, and essential national approaches for the
inflammation of gingiva caused by bacteria accu- effective control and prevention of periodontal dis-
mulating along the gingival margin. Periodontitis is a ease are considered from a public health perspec-
more advanced inflammatory form of periodontal tive.

16
Global periodontal health

Fig. 2. Percentage of male (A) and female (B) tobacco users worldwide. From World Health Organization (95).

The global burden of tooth loss may manifest in the complete loss of natural teeth,
particularly at old age. The burden of complete tooth
Periodontal disease, along with severe dental caries, loss was highlighted in the recent World Health
is a major cause of tooth loss, which directly affects Survey (WHS) (60, 88). The WHS is a global survey
the quality of life of people in terms of reduced covering the adult population and it was designed to
functional capacity (e.g. chewing or biting), self-es- collect national representative data on the state of
teem and social relationships. Experience of severe health and on the performance of health systems. In
periodontal disease over the course of life ultimately all, 72 countries took part in the survey and data were

17
Petersen & Ogawa

collected by standardized personal interviews. The ence of problems with mouth ⁄ teeth among the
participating countries were finally categorized into elderly (Fig. 3). In low-income countries, about
low-, middle- and high-income countries based on 40% of 65- to 74-year-old subjects reported health
their gross national income according to the World problems, whereas the corresponding value for
Bank criteria (81). Figure 3 provides an overview of high-income countries was about 30%. Around the
the global burden of tooth loss among older people world, social inequality in oral illness was also
(65–74 years of age) according to national income manifest within countries, particularly when
level. A high prevalence rate (35%) of edentulism is education was used as an indicator of social
found in upper middle-income countries, whereas position.
the prevalence rate at the time of writing was low To ascertain whether national health systems
(10%) for low-income countries. In high-income actually met the dental care needs of older people,
countries somewhat lower figures for edentulism are participants in the WHS were asked whether they
found when compared with upper middle-income received care for their dental health problems. Some
countries. In several high-income countries older 48% of all age groups received medication for control
people often have had their teeth extracted early in of infection; this was the case for 80% of people living
life because of pain or discomfort, leading to reduced in low-income countries vs. 25% of people living in
quality of life. Remarkably, in many of these coun- high-income countries. In all, 40% of people had
tries there has been a positive trend of a significant instruction in oral hygiene and counseling on dental
reduction in tooth loss among older adults during care.
recent years owing to changing lifestyles and the As illustrated in Fig. 4, the global social inequality
effective use of preventive oral health services in health care was profound because fewer people
(14, 60). living in poor countries received care for their teeth
or mouth problems. In addition to the inequalities
across the world, the WHS data revealed huge dis-
Self-reported oral health problems parities within countries; in particular, the poor and
and care less educated older people were noticeably under-
served and without any natural teeth. Moreover, for
The WHS (88) also incorporated information on low- and middle-income countries the survey dem-
perceived mouth problems and the capacity of – onstrated that people living in rural areas were less
including the responsiveness of – national health likely to have oral health care. This is in contrast to
systems. At the global level, the evidence of social high-income countries where equal proportions of
inequality was documented regarding the experi- older people living in urban and rural areas reported
having such care.

50 Edentulous Problems with mouth/teeth


during the past year
80
Urban
40
Rural
Value (percentage)

Value (percentage)

60
30

20 40

10
20

0
Low Lower Upper High Total 0
middle middle Low Lower Upper High Total
Income category of country middle middle
Fig. 3. Percentage of 65- to 74-year old subjects in low-, Income category of country
middle- and high-income countries with no natural teeth Fig. 4. Percentage of 65- to 74-year-old subjects in low-,
(edentulous) and percentage of people having experi- middle- and high-income countries who received health
enced problems with mouth ⁄ teeth during the past year care related to problems with mouth and teeth, stratified
(60, 88). by urbanization (60, 88).

18
Global periodontal health

Score 2 = LA 6–8 mm; Score 3 = LA 9–11 mm; Score


The global burden of periodontal 4 = LA ‡ 12 mm; Score X = excluded; and Score
disease 9 = not recorded.
The CPI databank is updated continuously and the
The prevalence and severity of chronic periodontal population data available in the WHO Global Oral
disease have been measured in population surveys Health Data Bank are summarized in Figs 5–9,
undertaken in countries with a wide range of according to WHO region, as follows: the African
objectives, designs and measurement criteria (39). Region (AFRO), the Americas Region (AMRO), the
The Community Periodontal Index (CPI) (64, 84) was Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMRO), the Euro-
introduced by the WHO as a tool with which coun-
tries may produce profiles of their periodontal health
status and plan intervention programs for effective 100

control of periodontal disease. In addition, the CPI


population data may be helpful in oral health sur- 75
veillance at country and intercountry levels. While Score 4
this index has certain shortcomings as a stand-alone Score 3

Percentage
means of assessing the extent and severity of peri- 50 Score 2
odontal disease (53), it has been widely used for Score 1
descriptive periodontal epidemiological studies and Score 0
25
for needs assessment in both developed and devel-
oping countries. The major advantages of the CPI
are simplicity, speed, reproducibility and interna- 0
tional uniformity. In 1997, the WHO suggested AFRO AMRO EMRO EURO SEARO WPRO
WHO region
including information on loss of periodontal
Fig. 5. Maximal Community Periodontal Index (CPI)
attachment in oral health surveys (84). However,
scores of 15- to 19-year-old subjects, expressed as a per-
data on loss of attachment are scarce as, to date, centage and stratified according to World Heath Organi-
only a few countries have carried out such system- zation (WHO) region (89). AFRO, the African Region;
atic surveys. According to the WHO experience, the AMRO, the Americas Region; EMRO, the Eastern Medi-
recording of loss of attachment is often considered terranean Region; EURO, the European Region; SEARO,
the South-East Asia Region; WPRO, the Western Pacific
difficult to carry out in the field and time-consum-
Region.
ing.
Certain indicator age groups have been chosen by
the WHO for intercountry comparisons of oral health 100
status and oral health surveillance. The essential
age-groups relevant to periodontal health are 15–19,
35–44 and 65–74 years. Over the past decades several 75
countries have provided CPI data for warehousing in Score 4
Score 3
the WHO Global Oral Health Data Bank (89).
Percentage

Score 2
These are displayed through a component of the so- 50
Score 1
called WHO Country ⁄ Area Profile Programme (http:// Score 0
www.dent.niigata-u.ac.jp/prevent/perio/contents.
html). The standard parameters for presentation 25

of CPI data (84) are percentage of persons by


their maximal CPI score (prevalence rate) and the
mean number of sextants (severity) with certain CPI 0
AFRO AMRO EMRO EURO SEARO WPRO
scores: Score 0 = healthy periodontal conditions; WHO region
Score 1 = gingival bleeding; Score 2 = gingival Fig. 6. Maximal Community Periodontal Index (CPI)
bleeding and calculus; Score 3 = shallow periodontal scores of 35- to 44-year-old subjects, expressed as a per-
pockets (4–5 mm); Score 4 = deep periodontal pock- centage and stratified according to World Heath Organi-
ets (‡ 6 mm); Score 9 = excluded; and Score X = not zation (WHO) region (89). AFRO, the African Region;
AMRO, the Americas Region; EMRO, the Eastern Medi-
recorded or not visible. The extent of loss of attach-
terranean Region; EURO, the European Region; SEARO,
ment (LA) is recorded for sextants using the following the South-East Asia Region; WPRO, the Western Pacific
codes: Score 0 = LA 0–3 mm; Score 1 = LA 4–5 mm; Region.

19
Petersen & Ogawa

6 pean Region (EURO), the South-East Asia Region


(SEARO) and the Western Pacific Region (WPRO).
5
Mean number of sextants The CPI data are expressed as the mean percentage of
4 X subjects with certain CPI scores. In addition, country-
Score 4 specific data are given in Table 1. The most severe
Score 3
3 score or sign of periodontal disease (CPI Score = 4)
Score 2
Score 1
varies worldwide, from 10% to 15% in adult popu-
2
Score 0 lations; however, the most prevalent score in all WHO
1
Regions is a CPI Score of 2 (gingival bleeding and
calculus), which primarily reflects poor oral hygiene.
0 For a few countries, sufficient data over time are
AFRO AMRO EMRO EURO SEARO WPRO
WHO region
available for surveillance and this may allow assess-
ment of the impact of oral health programs. The
Fig. 7. Distribution of certain Community Periodontal mean number of sextants with CPI scores is pre-
Index (CPI) scores, shown as mean numbers of sextants, sented for the three age-groups of adults and by
in 35- to 44-year-old subjects according to World Health
WHO region. Poor periodontal health is particularly
Organization (WHO) region (89). AFRO, the African Re-
gion; AMRO, the Americas Region; EMRO, the Eastern reported at old age. For older people of both devel-
Mediterranean Region; EURO, the European Region; SE- oping and developed countries the severe CPI scores
ARO, the South-East Asia Region; WPRO, the Western are profound; this pattern is also observed for coun-
Pacific Region.

100
90
80
Value (percentage)

70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
lia dia ile ina ng ark bia dia an ao car ar nd rea bia nia SA
s tra bo Ch Ch g ko nm am In Jap L gas anm eala Ko Ara nza U Fig. 8. Maximal Community Peri-
Au Cam a y Z f i
on De G ad M ew lic o aud R T
a
odontal Index (CPI) scores, ex-
a -H M N u b S U
in p pressed as a percentage, of 65- to
Ch Re 74-year-old subjects in selected
CPI 0 CPI 1 CPI 2 CPI 3 CPI 4 CPI X CPI 9 countries (89).

6.0
Mean number of sextants

5.0

4.0

3.0

2.0

1.0

0.0
di
a
in
a
on
g
ar
k
pa
n n ar d
re
a ia ia A
bo Ch k m Ja ano asc a lan o rab z an US
m ng en Leb ag Ze o fK iA an Fig. 9. Distribution of Community
Ca Ho D ad w ic ud T
na
- M Ne ub
l Sa UR Periodontal Index (CPI) scores,
i p
Ch Re shown as mean numbers of sextants,
among 65- to 74-year-old subjects in
CPI 0 CPI 1 CPI 2 CPI 3 CPI 4 CPI X CPI 9 selected countries (89).

20
Table 1. Community Periodontal Index (CPI) data, stratified by specific age-group(s) within countries, as reported to the World Health Organization (WHO) (89)

Country Age-group No symptoms Gingival bleeding Gingival bleeding + Shallow periodontal Deep periodontal Others
(years) (Score 0) (Score 1) calculus pockets: 4–5 mm pockets: ‡6 mm (Score X or 9)
(Score 2) (Score 3) (Score 4)

AFRO
Algeria 15–19 16 15 56 13 0

35–44 10 6 26 45 13
Benin 15 46 1 53 0 0

35–44 37 1 61 1 1
Burkina Faso 18 16 8 58 13 5

35–44 3 2 49 36 10
Cape Verde 15–19 1 2 92 4 1

Central African Republic 35–44 1 1 14 52 32


Comoros 15–19 8 1 90 0 0

33–49 2 0 84 0 0 14
Djibouti 15 77 8 13 1 1

Ethiopia 15 0 36 54 9 0
Gambia 15–19 7 8 56 20 9

35–44 1 0 25 28 46
Ghana 15 9 16 72 2 1

35–44 4 9 49 32 5
Kenya 15 1 52 40 6 2

35–44 1 4 31 49 14
Lesotho 15 15 30 49 6 0

35–44 8 3 55 28 6
Madagascar 18 19 6 66 3 0 6

35–44 8 5 67 17 3
65–74 1 0 17 5 2 75
Global periodontal health

21
22
Table 1. (Continued )

Country Age-group No symptoms Gingival bleeding Gingival bleeding + Shallow periodontal Deep periodontal Others
(years) (Score 0) (Score 1) calculus pockets: 4–5 mm pockets: ‡6 mm (Score X or 9)
Petersen & Ogawa

(Score 2) (Score 3) (Score 4)


Malawi 15–19 41 2 56 1 0

35–44 4 1 86 7 2
Mauritius 15 1 20 41 33 5

35–44 0 1 19 48 32
Namibia 15–19 0 1 90 9 0

35–44 0 0 83 15 2
Niger 18 0 0 99 0.3 0.3

35–44 0 0 87 8 5
Nigeria 15–19 1 3 46 42 8

35–44 1 0 15 45 39
Seychelles 17 1 4 93 0 0
Sierra Leone 15 0 3 44 44 9
35–44 0 1 5 42 53
South Africa 15–19 0 0 28 69 3
35–44 0 0 13 58 29
Tanzania 15–19 3 5 84 8 0
35–44 6 3 81 9 1

65–74 2 2 53 38 5
Togo 35–44 35 3 35 21 6

Zaire 35–44 0 0 39 45 16
Zimbabwe 15–19 23 21 47 8 1

35–44 9 9 59 19 4
Table 1. (Continued )
Country Age-group No symptoms Gingival bleeding Gingival bleeding + Shallow periodontal Deep periodontal Others
(years) (Score 0) (Score 1) calculus pockets: 4–5 mm pockets: ‡6 mm (Score X or 9)
(Score 2) (Score 3) (Score 4)
AMRO
Argentina 34–45 3 14 43 26 14
Brazil 15–17 48 40 10 3 0
35–44 1 4 13 63 20

Canada 35–44 5 6 16 52 21
Chile 15–19 5 15 70 10 1

35–44 1 3 5 50 41
65–74 0 0 0 29 71

El Salvador 35–44 4 1 40 39 16
Jamaica 15 0 9 20 34 37

Mexico 15–19 49 36 14 1 0
Saint Vincent, the Grenadines 15–19 12 5 83 0 0
Uruguay 15–19 1 8 26 55 10
35–44 6 4 29 38 23
USA 15–19 17 13 33 32 5
35–44 4 10 27 38 20

65–74 5 8 24 31 32
West Indies 15–19 12 5 83 0 0

EMRO
Bahrain 15–19 18 8 71 2 0
Cyprus 15 35 34 30 0 0
35–44 9 9 61 19 1
Egypt 17 0 36 47 16 1
35–44 0 8 36 40 16
Global periodontal health

23
24
Table 1. (Continued )
Country Age-group No symptoms Gingival bleeding Gingival bleeding + Shallow periodontal Deep periodontal Others
(years) (Score 0) (Score 1) calculus pockets: 4–5 mm pockets: ‡6 mm (Score X or 9)
(Score 2) (Score 3) (Score 4)
Petersen & Ogawa

Iran 15–19 11 12 46 30 0

35–44 1 6 40 43 10
Iraq 35–44 1 11 41 37 11

Jordan 15 1 3 85 11 0
Lebanon 15 24 30 42 3 1

35–44 8 20 51 14 8
65–74 6 17 47 11 19
Libyan Arab J. 15 0 5 80 15 0
35–44 0 0 13 53 34
Morocco 16–20 3 40 34 17 5
35–44 3 5 31 40 16

Oman 15 26 3 69 2 0
Pakistan 15–19 26 20 52 2 0 5

35–44 9 8 53 24 6
Saudi Arabia 15–19 32 12 37 17 1

35–44 20 35 36 8 0
65+ 9 25 40 17 9

Slovenia 65+ 2 1 31 45 21
Somalia 15 43 43 14 0 0
Sudan 15–19 0 1 0 95 4
35–44 0 0 3 71 26
Syrian Arab Republic 15 14 26 53 6 0
35–44 6 6 67 9 12

Yemen 15–19 7 16 70 5 2
Table 1. (Continued )
Country Age-group No symptoms Gingival bleeding Gingival bleeding + Shallow periodontal Deep periodontal Others
(years) (Score 0) (Score 1) calculus pockets: 4–5 mm pockets: ‡6 mm (Score X or 9)
(Score 2) (Score 3) (Score 4)
EURO
Armenia 15–19 11 7 74 8 0
Belarus 15 2 9 76 14 0
35–44 0 0 23 45 31

Belgium 35–44 1 5 30 34 30
Bulgaria 65–74 10 5 21 45 19
Croatia 15–19 16 20 52 12 0
35–44 6 6 41 32 15

65+ 0 0 17 48 35
Denmark 35–44 8 16 41 29 6

65–74 2 9 23 46 20
Estonia 15 2 16 78 4 0

35–44 0 0 34 53 13
65–74 0 1 4 26 69
Finland 15–19 34 40 26 0 0
35–44 2 7 56 29 6

65–74 2 2 37 32 27
France 15–19 45 3 51 1 0

35–44 9 6 63 13 10
65–74 17 12 39 29 3
Germany 15–19 7 11 11 62 9
35–44 1 12 14 52 21

65–74 1 4 7 48 40
Greece 15–19 30 30 33 7 0

35–44 6 29 39 20 6
Global periodontal health

25
Table 1. (Continued )

26
Country Age-group No symptoms Gingival bleeding Gingival bleeding + Shallow periodontal Deep periodontal Others
(years) (Score 0) (Score 1) calculus pockets: 4–5 mm pockets: ‡6 mm (Score X or 9)
(Score 2) (Score 3) (Score 4)
Hungary 35–44 11 5 57 22 6
Petersen & Ogawa

65–74 7 10 46 26 11
Ireland 15 43 21 35 1 0
35–44 6 8 71 13 2
Israel 15–19 40 48 12 0 0
35–44 1 3 24 50 22
Italy 15–19 39 10 48 3 0
35–44 3 4 45 36 12
Kyrgyzstan 15 1 5 92 2 0
35–44 0 0 23 46 31

65–74 0 0 1 8 91
Lithuania 15 6 18 75 2 0

Malta 35–44 0 1 78 17 2
the Netherlands 15–19 6 47 29 16 1

35–44 4 6 34 48 7
65–74 1 10 32 42 15

Norway 35 1 19 13 58 8
Poland 35–44 9 8 58 19 6

65–74 10 15 52 19 4
Portugal 15 21 16 63 0 0

35–44 3 0 47 38 8
Russian Fed. 15 1 10 80 9 1

35–44 0 1 15 54 29 4
San Marino 15–19 45 25 28 2 0

35–44 8 23 37 25 7
Table 1. (Continued )
Country Age-group No symptoms Gingival bleeding Gingival bleeding + Shallow periodontal Deep periodontal Others
(years) (Score 0) (Score 1) calculus pockets: 4–5 mm pockets: ‡6 mm (Score X or 9)
(Score 2) (Score 3) (Score 4)
Slovakia 18–19 23 24 51 2 0
34–49 8 5 44 29 15

64–76 63 4 18 11 4
Slovenia 15 8 66 23 3 1

35–44 1 4 68 5 22
65–74 0 0 12 45 43
Spain 35–44 4 7 75 13 1
65–74 3 8 65 20 4
Tajikistan 15 0 0 70 30 0
35–44 0 0 20 50 30
Turkey 15–19 26 51 21 2 0
35–44 3 24 38 29 6
Turkmenistan 15 2 4 86 7 0
35–44 0 0 21 39 40

65–74 0 0 3 13 84
UK 15–19 12 36 49 3 0

35–44 4 1 20 62 13
65–74 3 1 19 60 17
The former 15–19 6 29 51 13 1
Yugoslavia
35–44 1 1 34 48 16

SEARO
Bangladesh 18 5 5 66 22 1

35–44 3 1 36 40 21
Bhutan 15–19 6 14 75 6 0
Global periodontal health

27
28
Table 1. (Continued )
Country Age-group No symptoms Gingival bleeding Gingival bleeding + Shallow periodontal Deep periodontal Others
(years) (Score 0) (Score 1) calculus pockets: 4–5 mm pockets: ‡6 mm (Score X or 9)
(Score 2) (Score 3) (Score 4)
Petersen & Ogawa

India 15–19 6 11 79 5 0

35–44 2 2 37 40 19
65–74 0 3 25 38 16
Indonesia 15 0 3 54 41 2
35–44 1 0 56 36 6 18

Maldives 15–19 37 20 42 0 0
Myanmar 35–44 0 0 63 35 2

65–74 0 0 34 45 14
Nepal 15–16 26 8 61 5 0

35–44 0 0 28 38 34 7
Sri Lanka 35–44 5 1 55 27 10
Thailand 18 3 3 87 7 0
35–44 1 0 53 35 11

WPRO
Australia 18 0 2 58 38 2

35–44 6 10 47 24 13
65+ 7 13 36 31 14
Cambodia 15–19 41 0 59 0 0
35–44 3 1 92 4 0

65–74 0 0 54 41 5
China 35–44 0 0 64 32 4

65–74 0 1 55 37 7
Cook Islands 15–19 0 4 80 15 0

35–44 0 0 34 57 9
Table 1. (Continued )
Country Age-group No symptoms Gingival bleeding Gingival bleeding + Shallow periodontal Deep periodontal Others
(years) (Score 0) (Score 1) calculus pockets: 4–5 mm pockets: ‡6 mm (Score X or 9)
(Score 2) (Score 3) (Score 4)
Fiji 15–19 28 14 58 1 0
35–44 6 6 74 13 1
French Polynesia 15–19 82 3 13 2 0
35–44 17 1 45 31 6
Hong Kong 15–19 2 2 70 26 1
35–44 0 0 26 57 17

65–74 0 0 34 51 15
Japan 15–19 34 25 36 5 0

35–44 18 10 45 23 4
65–74 9 7 27 43 15
Korean Republic 15–19 35 17 39 8 1
35–44 30 4 48 15 3

65–74 20 2 28 34 17
Lao P.D. Republic 15–19 9 8 83 0 0

35–44 0 0 94 4 2
65–74 0 0 70 17 13
Malaysia 15–19 17 10 69 4 0
35–44 5 3 61 23 9
New Zealand 15–19 58 21 16 5 0
35–44 11 3 38 44 4

65–74 10 2 45 36 7
Niue 35–44 1 1 94 1 1
Papua New Guinea 15–19 4 25 55 14 2
35–44 1 2 39 33 25
Global periodontal health

29
Petersen & Ogawa

tries with advanced oral health systems, reflecting the


fact that systems may have only a modest impact on

(Score X or 9)
periodontal disease control at the population level.

Others
Public health: recording of periodontal
disease

AFRO, the African Region; AMRO, the Americas Region; EMRO, the Eastern Mediterranean Region; EURO, the European Region; SEARO, the South-East Asia Region; WPRO, the Western Pacific Region.
The CPI measure was included in the 1987 WHO
Deep periodontal
pockets: ‡6 mm

manual on oral health surveys (83) and since then it


has been widely used in oral health surveys under-
(Score 4)

taken for planning programs and determining the


need for specific intervention. The system has been a

12

25
0

1
0

0
0

3
valuable tool, although it has shown certain limita-
tions. The scoring system is based on the assumption
of conditions following an ordinal scale; this may
Shallow periodontal
pockets: 4–5 mm

be questioned from the current understanding of


mechanisms involved with gingivitis, development of
periodontal pocketing and loss of attachment. An-
(Score 3)

other difficulty relates to the recording of CPI in tooth


loss, particularly regarding the specification of teeth
4

0
6
35

29
58

61

for replacement if indicator teeth are not present.


While the original CPI may have relevance for
Gingival bleeding +

planning health programs, the system has been


shown to be weak in the evaluation of periodontal
disease action programs. For the 5th edition of the
WHO manual for oral health surveys (94), the WHO
(Score 2)
calculus

designed a new, modified CPI system, taking weak-


nesses of the original CPI into consideration while
76

60
59

40
87

58
38

13

ensuring simplicity and reproducibility. The new


system reflects an effort of giving higher public health
Gingival bleeding

priority to periodontal disease as a significant com-


ponent of the burden of oral disease. As is the case for
dental caries, the periodontal status of all teeth pres-
(Score 1)

ent is recorded. Scores relevant to specific disease


conditions are applied to the individual tooth, namely
14
7

7
3

0
1

the presence ⁄ absence of gingival bleeding and the


presence ⁄ absence of periodontal pockets of 4–5 or
No symptoms

‡ 6 mm. Calculus is not recorded because this is not a


(Score 0)

disease condition. Recording of all teeth present will


allow identification of indicator teeth as used in the
previous CPI system. The new modified system has
2

1
0

0
13

26

52

Data are given as percentage of maximal CPI score.

been field tested in several oral health surveys carried


out in countries of different size and of different
Age-group

economies, ranging from Bahrain to China.


(years)

15–19

35–44
15–18

15–19
15–19

35–44
15–19

35–44

Socio-environmental conditions
Table 1. (Continued )

The Philippines

Reviews of the oral health literature (14, 43) indicate


significant intercountry and intracountry variability
Singapore

in the prevalence of periodontal disease, and great


Vanuatu

Vietnam
Tonga
Country

variations are shown in socio-environmental condi-


tions, oral health systems, behavioral risk factors and
in the general health status of people.

30
Global periodontal health

Several epidemiological studies have established a higher than that of White people of the same age
significant relationship between socioeconomic sta- cohort, and studies by Borrell et al. (10) found that
tus and periodontal disease in various age groups, in African-Americans were twice as likely to have
other words poor periodontal disease status is linked periodontal disease as were Caucasian-Americans.
to low income or to low education (2, 11, 14, 19, 53). The effect of ethnic group on periodontal health
For instance, in a study carried out by Drury et al. status was also documented in adults of certain
(19), there was a 10–20% difference in periodontal developing countries in Africa and Asia (31, 40, 59,
disease prevalence and severity between people of 62, 79).
higher and of lower socioeconomic status in the
United States (US) population. The WHO Interna-
tional Comparative Surveys (ICSII, 1997) (14) docu- Behavioral factors in periodontal
mented that this pattern was also found in Germany, disease
Japan, Latvia, New Zealand, Poland and the USA. In
France, however, studies of adult people showed only In addition to poor oral hygiene, the important risk
minor differences in periodontal status when stratified factors for severe periodontal disease relate to the use
by income and education (30). In Denmark, the new of tobacco, to malnutrition, excessive alcohol con-
modified CPI system was used recently in a nation- sumption, stress, diabetes mellitus and certain other
wide survey of subjects in 35–44 and 65–74 years age- systemic disease conditions (27, 52, 65, 67, 74).
groups, and significant social inequalities in indicators
of periodontal disease were found for both age-groups
Tobacco
(i.e. teeth affected by gingival bleeding, pockets 4–
5 mm and pockets of ‡6 mm) (41). Smokers have a high risk of periodontal disease and
The vast majority of epidemiological studies on lesions of the oral mucosa (26, 66). In addition, there
periodontal health have been conducted in high-in- is strong evidence that smokeless tobacco, or tobacco
come countries (14, 64). However, in some low- and chewing, has a significantly adverse effect on peri-
middle-income countries, surveys on social factors in odontal health (1, 46). A dose-response effect of to-
periodontal health have been carried out during re- bacco consumption on periodontal disease has been
cent years, encompassing children, adolescents and documented (13, 38, 75), in which the prevalence
adult population groups. These studies demonstrated rates and severity of periodontal disease increased in
that poor periodontal status was most prevalent relation to the number of cigarettes consumed and
among people living in poverty. For example, in years of smoking. Stopping smoking means a lower
Africa, comparative studies based on use of the CPI risk of periodontal disease. Tobacco consumption
index have been undertaken in Madagascar (62), may also diminish the immune response, aggravate
Tanzania (61) and Burkina Faso (79), and in Asia periodontal disease and thereby lead to the loss of
comprehensive information is available from China natural teeth (38). Studies have shown that smoking
(31). In Lao PDR, the new modified WHO CPI may account for more than half of the cases of
recording system was used in a recent survey of periodontitis among American adults (75). Tradi-
gingival health in children (35) and it was found that tionally, the use of tobacco was frequent in many
the percentage of teeth with gingival bleeding was high-income countries and this may help to explain
relatively high among children living under poor the current levels of poor periodontal health status in
socioeconomic conditions. Socio-environmental fac- middle-aged and older people.
tors are highly responsible for distinct profiles of
periodontal disease observed in populations living in
Diet
certain geographical regions or locations; for
example, there are considerable differences in the Most chronic diseases, such as cardiovascular dis-
occurrence of periodontal disease in urban vs. rural ease, diabetes, cancers, obesity and dental disease,
populations (14). are strongly related to diet (50, 52, 86), and a series of
In addition to intercountry variation, the distri- studies has concluded that this is caused particularly
bution of periodontal disease within countries also by diets rich in saturated fatty acids and nonmilk
differs according to race or ethnic group, regarding extrinsic sugars, and by diets low in polyunsaturated
both prevalence and severity (10, 11, 54). Beck et al. fats, fibre and vitamins A, C and E. Severe vitamin C
(7) showed that groups of Black people in the USA deficiency and malnutrition may result in aggravated
had a risk of periodontal destruction three times periodontal disease (52); however, relatively few re-

31
Petersen & Ogawa

ports are available on the role of diet and nutrition in cultures, the tradition of oral hygiene is weak or
the etiology of periodontal disease (86). Hence, it is mouth cleaning is ritual, for example, the use of
necessary to investigate further the evidence of an Miswaki, and oral cleaning by the use of fingers and
association between dietary factors and periodontal charcoal or salt is common in some settings (4, 34). It
disease. As a result of reduced oral functioning, tooth is worth noting that modern oral hygiene measures,
loss often has a negative impact on dietary habits and such as the use of manufactured toothbrushes, are
therefore also has an adverse effect on nutrition sta- now being adopted in middle- and low-income
tus. This has been reported particularly in older countries; however, the use of affordable fluoridated
people (36, 63). toothpaste is still an important challenge.
Knowledge and attitudes in relation to periodontal
disease have been studied in populations of several
Alcohol
countries (55). Most people are aware of the impor-
High alcohol consumption aggravates the risk of a tance of bacteria and the importance of preventing
wide variety of conditions, such as increased blood periodontal disease by oral hygiene. However, the
pressure, liver cirrhosis, cardiovascular disease, dia- relevance of tobacco and diet is seldom emphasized.
betes and cancers of the mouth (86). Recent research In certain settings people may have a rather diffuse
also indicates that excessive alcohol consumption is understanding of the prevention of periodontal dis-
associated with increased severity of periodontal ease; for example, the importance of using fluoride is
disease (65, 74). People who use tobacco are more reported along with relevant answers. In general,
likely to drink alcohol and eat a diet high in fats and knowledge about the causal factors and the preven-
sugars but low in fibre and polyunsaturated fatty tion of periodontal disease is lower than for dental
acids, and those with a heavy consumption of to- caries (55).
bacco and alcohol are thus more likely to be at higher
risk of severe periodontal disease.
Periodontal health and diabetes
Stress mellitus
It is well known that cardiovascular disease, diabetes
Of the associations observed between oral health
and other chronic diseases are related to psychoso-
status and chronic systemic diseases, the link
cial factors (42, 47), but there is also evidence that
between severe periodontal disease and diabetes
stress is linked to periodontal disease (27). Moreover,
mellitus is the most consistent (28, 48, 69, 70). It is
significant life events are associated with periodontal
widely documented that people with diabetes have a
disease, possibly through physiological responses,
higher risk of periodontal disease, and periodontal
which increase susceptibility (17).
disease has been considered as the sixth complica-
tion of diabetes (29, 70, 72). Extensive studies have
Oral hygiene reported significant associations between diabetes
and the severity of periodontal disease (28, 69, 71).
Oral hygiene habits fluctuate by culture across the Taylor (71, 73) concluded, from his literature review
world. In general, people of high-income countries of severe periodontal disease and diabetes mellitus,
have adopted healthy lifestyles, including regular tooth that not only was there a greater prevalence of peri-
brushing and use of fluoridated toothpaste (3, 76). Oral odontal symptoms in patients with diabetes mellitus
hygiene aids, in terms of dental floss and toothpicks, but the progression of periodontal disease was also
are widely used. However, oral hygiene habits show more aggressive or rapid.
substantial variation within countries in relation to One epidemiological study has been conducted
personal income, level of education and place of resi- among the Pima Indians (51). Significantly poorer
dence (14). In particular, education is a strong deter- periodontal health was reported in patients with Type
minant of oral hygiene practices as reported by the 2 diabetes, and the relative risk of periodontal disease
WHO International Collaborative Studies II (14) and in subjects with diabetes was 2.6 after controlling for
other studies carried out in different countries (55). confounding factors such as age and sex. In studies of
Meanwhile, regular oral hygiene practices are less subjects with Type 2 diabetes, the odds of destructive
frequent in middle- and low-income countries but loss of attachment were about three times higher
are linked to social status indicators (5, 44). In certain than among nondiabetic subjects (8, 20).

32
Global periodontal health

of South-East Asia where people have little access to


HIV ⁄ AIDS and periodontal health oral health care, including periodontal care.
Noma (debilitating oro-facial gangrene) is an
The HIV ⁄ AIDS pandemic has become a human, so- important disease burden in certain developing
cial and economic disaster, with far-reaching impli- countries, particularly among young children in
cations for individuals, communities and countries Africa and Asia (21–25). Severe acute periodontal
(Fig. 10). No other disease has so dramatically high- disease manifests at the onset of noma. Noma pri-
lighted the current disparities and inequities in marily starts as a localized gingival ulceration and
healthcare access, economic opportunity and the spreads rapidly through the oro-facial tissues,
protection of basic human rights. Sub-Saharan Africa establishing itself with a blackened necrotic centre.
has been most severely affected, with an estimated About 70–90% of cases are fatal in the absence of
22.5 million people living with HIV (78). In South- care. Fresh noma is seen predominantly in the 1–
East Asia there are more than 4 million people in- 4 years age-group, although late stages of the dis-
fected, and further spread could lead to millions ease occur in adolescents and adults. Poverty is the
more becoming infected in the coming decade. The key risk condition for development of noma; the
epidemic in Latin America is well established with environment inducing noma is characterized by
nearly 2 million people infected, and rapid growth severe malnutition and growth retardation, unsafe
has been observed in recent years in Eastern Europe drinking water, deplorable sanitary practices, resi-
and central Asia. Globally, the major mode of HIV dential proximity to unkempt animals and a high
transmission is through sexual intercourse, injecting prevalence of infectious diseases, such as measles,
drug use, mother-to-child transmission and through malaria, diarrhea, pneumonia, tuberculosis and
contaminated blood in healthcare settings. The rela- HIV ⁄ AIDS.
tive importance of the different modes of transmis-
sion varies between and within regions of the world.
A number of studies have demonstrated the nega-
tive impact on oral health of HIV infection (16). Periodontal problems among
Because of the compromised immune system and a people with disabilities
poor oral hygiene status, infected people are vulner-
able to periodontal disease. In addition to severe The oral health of people who are physically or
chronic gingivitis, poor periodontal health may mentally disabled is often impaired (6, 68). They may
manifest as acute necrotizing gingivitis, which is of- have limited capacity to detect and recognize early
ten seen in children and adolescents, and as necro- symptoms of disease. They may have limited ability
tizing periodontitis, which is mostly seen among to cope with everyday tasks related to personal hy-
adults (16). In particular, such disease conditions are giene, including oral hygiene, which are critical to
observed in Sub-Saharan Africa and in remote areas the maintenance of an independent existence. Oral

Western & Eastern Europe


Central Europe & Central Asia
820 000 1.4 million
[720 000 – 910 000] [1 3 million – 11.66 million]
[1.3
North America
1.5 million
[1.2 million – 2.0 million] East Asia
770 000
[560 000 – 1.0 million]
Middle East & North Africa
Caribbean
460 000
[400 000 – 530 000]
240 000
[220 000 – 270 000] South & South-East Asia
4.1 million
[3
[3.77 million – 44.66 million]
Sub-Saharan Africa
Central & 22.5 million
South America [20.9 million – 24.2 million]
1.4 million Oceania
[1.2 million – 1.6 million] 57 000
[50 000 – 64 000]

Fig. 10. Global estimates of adults


and children living with HIV/AIDS,
Total: 33.3 million [31.4 million – 35.3 million] 2009 (78), UNAIDS, 2010.

33
Petersen & Ogawa

disease – including periodontal problems – is often


given low priority, especially among disadvantaged The need for public health
people and people with disabilities in developing intervention: global perspectives
countries. Several studies reported that such popu-
lation groups have higher levels of periodontal Periodontal disease and its ultimate consequence –
problems and that they are more likely to experience tooth loss – are important public health problems in
oral pain and discomfort (9, 15, 40, 77). countries around the globe. The intention of the
present report was to outline the global pattern of
periodontal disease based on WHO epidemiological
Oral health systems data and to highlight key risk factors. The health
impact of periodontal disease on individuals and
The availability of oral health manpower varies communities is considerable as a result of pain and
greatly across countries, which has a bearing on the suffering, impairment of function and reduced quality
delivery of oral health care. For example, in several of life. The greatest burden of periodontal disease is on
developing countries of Africa, the dentist to popu- the disadvantaged and poor populations, and the so-
lation ratio is 1:150,000 or more, in contrast to 1:2,000 cial inequality exists not only within countries but
in industrialized countries. In low- and middle-in- between countries around the world. The current
come countries, the shortage of dentists is critical pattern of periodontal disease reflects distinct risk
and service is primarily confined to tackling pain or profiles related to living conditions, environmental
discomfort through radical care, such as tooth and behavioral factors and oral health systems, and the
extraction. Periodontal care is highly neglected in implementation of preventive oral-health schemes.
these countries. Meanwhile, most high-income
countries have private systems for oral health care;
Social determinants
third-party payment systems involving private health
insurance or public reimbursement schemes are of- Causal factors involved in chronic diseases are
ten implicated, whereas in some countries oral health specified in Fig. 11 (85); the underlying socioeco-
services are based on high public or government nomic, cultural, political and environmental deter-
participation. The Second WHO International Col- minants are important. To reduce the burden of
laborative Study (14) was undertaken to measure the periodontal disease and the pronounced inequities in
health outcome of oral health systems. In order to periodontal health, action is needed to address the
include different oral health systems, the study underlying social determinants of health. It is vital to
comprised selected countries: France, Germany, Ja- tackle root causes rather than symptoms, focusing on
pan, Latvia, New Zealand, Poland and the USA. structural upstream factors that cause poor health
Periodontal health data were collected in standard and create inequalities. Thus, policies and legislation
population groups by use of the original CPI index. for periodontal health must focus on social circum-
The international comparative data demonstrated in stances such as income, educational attainment,
general that the periodontal health status of people employment and housing. Conversely, measures that
was not related to the use of oral health systems focus on downstream factors only, such as lifestyle
available. Meanwhile, it is worth noting that the lack and behavioral influences, have limited success in
of such an association could be related to limitations reducing the health gap between rich and poor
of the recording system used. populations (43, 80).

Causes of chronic diseases

Underlying Common Modifiable Intermediate Risk Main Chronic


Socioeconomic, Risk Factors Factors Diseases
Cultural, Political Unhealthy diet Raised blood pressure Heart disease
and Environmental
Determinants Physical inactivity Raised blood glucose Stroke
Tobacco use Abnormal blood lipids Cancer
Globalization
Urbanization Nonmodifiable Overweight/obesity Chronic respiratory
Risk Factors diseases
Population ageing
Age Diabetes Fig. 11. The chain of causal factors
Heredity and mechanisms in chronic disease
(85).

34
Global periodontal health

disease is a particular challenge in high-income


Tobacco countries; control of excessive consumption of alco-
Cancer, including oro-
pharyngeal hol may have a positive contribution to periodontal
Alcohol Respiratory diseases
health.

Cardiovascular disease

Diet Obesity
General health – periodontal health
Diabetes The rapidly growing incidence of people who are
Stress Oral disease
overweight, obese and with diabetes in several
countries may have a harmful impact on the peri-
odontal health of the population. This is particularly
Hygiene
the case in the regions of Africa and Asia where
Fig. 12. Common risk factors for chronic disease, growth rates of diabetes are very high. National
including oral disease (54, 85). public health programs for the prevention of diabetes
must incorporate concerns to periodontal health; in
particular, the need is high for such an intervention
Lifestyles
in low- and middle-income countries where people
Several chronic and oral diseases and conditions have limited access to oral health services.
have common risk factors related to tobacco use, People with HIV ⁄ AIDS suffer from specific oral
excessive consumption of alcohol, unhealthy diet and lesions; neglect of proper oral hygiene coupled with
personal hygiene (Fig. 12) (54). The fact that these HIV infection has a negative effect on periodontal
factors are modifiable provides several unique health. In addition, pain and restriction in oral
opportunities in population-oriented periodontal functioning may lead to poor dietary habits and poor
disease prevention. National public health programs nutritional status. Prevention of periodontal disease
focusing on risk factor modification must incorporate is essential in the prevention of HIV ⁄ AIDS. Activities
concerns for oral health, including periodontal may also include screening, early detection of oral
health. Periodontal disease is highly prevalent in lesions and referral for special care. This may require
most countries of the world. The trend of reduction in the systematic training of oral health personnel or
tobacco use in several high-income countries may primary health workers if oral health staff are not
help to prevent periodontal disease and tooth loss. In available.
contrast, unless effective tobacco-prevention pro- The key risk factors in noma are severe poverty,
grams are established in middle- and low-income malnutrition, unsafe drinking water, deplorable san-
countries, severe periodontal disease and tooth loss itary practices and infectious diseases (e.g. measles,
may increase dramatically and this development may malaria and HIV ⁄ AIDS). Fighting poverty, improving
subsequently lead to loss of quality of life. Thus, the education and economic growth, and working to-
implementation of the WHO Framework Convention wards providing a healthy environment are impor-
for Tobacco Control (87) may contribute greatly to tant elements for preventing noma; not only the
the achievement of periodontal health. prevention of periodontal manifestations but also
An important strategy for preventing periodontal other symptoms of noma will benefit from commu-
disease is the establishment of tobacco-intervention nity development in the countries affected, particu-
programs, which incorporates concerns for oral larly in Africa and Asia.
health. Wherever oral health professionals are avail-
able, it is the responsibility of the profession to
Self-care: oral hygiene
initiate or maintain efficient tobacco-prevention
programs. In addition, periodontal health concerns National public health authorities have a significant
are essential to integrate when diet and alcohol role to play in improving the personal hygiene of
interventions are organized. Consumption of a bal- people, including oral hygiene. The authorities must
anced diet is essential to ensure a good nutritional ensure that people are aware of the importance of
status and development and maintenance of an good oral health and that oral health-related knowl-
optimal immune system; at present the challenges in edge and attitudes are supportive of health behavior.
diet are particularly high in community settings of Communication on the benefits of oral health and on
low-income countries. On the other hand, reducing proper oral hygiene techniques may need to be de-
the consumption of alcohol as a risk factor of chronic livered by several types of media and channels in

35
Petersen & Ogawa

order to reach the whole population because the in oral health – including periodontal health – is low,
effectiveness of different types of communication or even neglected by public health authorities. The
media vary depending on the socio-cultural condi- situation often reflects a lack of national policy for
tions within countries. In high-income countries, oral health, and the limited resources available are
written communication or e-learning will be useful, primarily allocated to emergency oral care and pain
whereas television and radio are considered powerful relief. Thus, in low-resource communities, advanced
in middle- and low-income countries. In many low- clinical periodontal care is not realistic in the context
income countries, significant proportions of people of public health and therefore low-cost intervention
are illiterate and this may complicate their under- and integrated disease prevention must be strength-
standing of the messages delivered. Therefore, health ened. Capacity building of oral health systems,
messages for oral hygiene will also show country- including the formulation of oral health policies,
specific variation. Manufactured toothbrushes for legislation, relevant action plans, organization of
oral cleaning are readily available in high-income financially fair primary oral health services and pro-
countries; in some middle-income countries manu- vision of oral health personnel or primary health
factured toothbrushes might be produced locally but workers appropriately trained in periodontal care and
they are often of low quality; whereas in low-income health promotion, are important challenges for low-
countries toothbrushes are less available or accessi- and middle-income countries.
ble to people living in poverty. In low- and middle- The Ottawa Health Promotion Charter (1986) (82)
income countries proper sanitary facilities and clean emphasized the high need for orientation of health
water are also important issues, and the public health services towards health promotion and disease pre-
authorities play a vital role in ensuring the appro- vention, and it is still recommended for public health
priate infrastructure for oral hygiene. authorities to implement such an appropriate or-
ientation of oral health services. The WHO World
Health Report 2008 (92) has underlined the signifi-
Oral health systems
cance of outreach primary health care. Across the
In high-income countries, the burden of oral disease world, building capacity for primary oral health care
has been tackled through the establishment of ad- must include mechanisms for outreach care to the
vanced oral health systems, which primarily offer poor and disadvantaged population groups and facil-
curative services to patients. Most systems are based itate the delivery of preventive periodontal care and
on care provided by private dental practitioners, community-oriented health promotion. In all coun-
while organized public oral health systems are in tries, systematic training in periodontal care is
place in a few high-income countries. Some countries important and should be a priority element in under-
have third-party payment systems, which share pa- graduate and continuing education programs for oral
tient costs in dental care. In general, such reim- health personnel. In areas Ôwhere there is no dentistÕ,
bursement schemes focus on restorative dental care specially trained primary health workers can play a
and in some cases on removable dentures, while vital role to cover the underserved population groups.
periodontal care has low priority. Traditional clinical
treatment of periodontal disease by private dental
Surveillance, evaluation and research
practitioners is extremely costly to patients and there
is an urgent need for adjustment of reimbursement Surveillance underpins public health action by linking
schemes in favor of periodontal care. The cost burden data with health policies and programs (58). Surveil-
is particularly high among underprivileged patients lance provides ongoing (continuous or periodic) col-
and older people. It is worth noting that private sys- lection, analysis and interpretation of population
tems do not encompass the whole population be- health data, and the timely dissemination of such data
cause accessibility to services is relatively low among to users. Properly conducted surveillance ensures that
disadvantaged groups. In the case of periodontal countries have the information they need to control
care, poor people are mostly underserved; thus, it is disease now or to plan strategies to prevent disease
emphasized that financially fair healthcare interven- and adverse health events in the future. The goal is to
tion must be introduced in order to tackle the pro- assist governments, health authorities and health
found social inequality in periodontal care. professionals to formulate policies and programs to
In contrast to high-income countries, low- and prevent disease and to measure the progress, impact
middle-income countries have a critical shortage of and efficacy of efforts to control diseases that are al-
dentists and other oral health personnel. Investment ready affecting their populations.

36
Global periodontal health

It is unfortunate that only a few countries have health programs within integrated approaches to
conducted time-series studies on periodontal health; surveillance, monitoring and the prevention and
this is primarily because large-scale oral epidemio- management of chronic noncommunicable diseases.
logical surveys are expensive and time-consuming.
Nevertheless, such epidemiological data may help to
plan action programs for the control of periodontal References
disease and for the sharing of information, on the
evidence of community programs, for periodontal 1. Akhter R, Hassan NM, Aida J, Takinami S, Morita M.
disease prevention and for health promotion. The Relationship between betel quid additives and established
periodontitis among Bangladeshi subjects. J Clin Period-
original CPI index has some limitations for use in
ontol 2008: 35: 9–15.
program evaluation and health systems research but 2. Albandar JM, Tinoco EMB. Global epidemiology of peri-
it is a hope that the new modified CPI system may be odontal diseases in children and young persons. Period-
helpful in this task. The WHO has developed ontol 2000 2002: 29: 153–176.
surveillance procedures for risk factors to chronic 3. Albertsson KW, van Dijken JW. Awareness of toothbrushing
and dentifrice habits in regularly dental care receiving
disease. The system incorporates self-reported
adults. Swed Dent J 2010: 34: 71–78.
information on risk factors for periodontal disease, 4. Al-Khateeb TL, Farsi JM, OÕMullane DM. Relationship be-
including measurements of socioeconomic status, tween attitudes, behaviour and levels of dental caries
oral hygiene, dental attendance, use of tobacco, among 15-year-old Saudi Arabian and Irish children. J Ir
consumption of alcohol, dietary habits and nutri- Dent Assoc 1990: 36: 56–59.
5. Amin TT, Al-Abad BM. Oral hygiene practices, dental
tional status, diabetes and dentate status.
knowledge, dietary habits and their relation to caries
among male primary school children in Al Hassa, Saudi
Arabia. Int J Dent Hyg 2008: 6: 361–370.
Role of the WHO in promotion of 6. Angelillo IF, Nobile CG, Pavia M, De Fazio P, Puca M,
oral health globally Amati A. Dental health and treatment needs in institu-
tionalized psychiatric patients in Italy. Community Dent
Oral Epidemiol 1995: 23: 360–364.
Progress towards a healthier world requires strong
7. Beck JD, Koch GG, Rozier RG, Tudor GE. Prevalence
political action, broad participation and sustained and risk indicators for periodontal attachment loss in a
advocacy. The WHO Global Oral Health Programme population of older community-dwelling blacks and
has worked hard over the years to put oral health high whites. J Periodontol 1990: 61: 521–528.
on the health agenda of policy and decision makers 8. Borges-Yanez SA, Irigoyen-camacho ME, Maupome G. Risk
factors and prevalence of periodontitis in community-
worldwide. Promotion of periodontal health globally
dwelling elders in Mexico. J Clin Periodontol 2006: 33: 184–
is given a high priority. In 2007, the World Health 194.
Assembly agreed on a Resolution (WHA.60.17), which 9. Borrell LN, Beck JD, Heiss G. Socioeconomic disadvantage
reads: ÔOral health: action plan for promotion and and periodontal disease: the Dental Atherosclerosis Risk in
integrated disease preventionÕ (56, 57). This statement Communities study. Am J Public Health 2006: 96: 332–339.
10. Borrell LN, Burt BA, Gillespie BW, Lynch J, Neighbors H.
is a wide-ranging policy that provides direction
Periodontitis in the United States: beyond black and white.
towards achieving better oral health of people in the J Public Health Dent 2002: 62: 92–101.
193 Member States. The WHO statement is an impetus 11. Borrell LN, Burt BA, Neighbors HW, Taylor GW. Social
for countries to develop or adjust national oral health factors and periodontitis in an older population. Am J
programs, including periodontal health and the Public Health 2004: 94: 748–754.
12. Bratthall D, Petersen PE, Stjernswärd JR, Brown J. Oral and
related risk factors. The action plan for oral health
craniofacial diseases and disorders (chapter 38). In: Jami-
promotion and integrated disease prevention includes son DT, Breman JG, Measham AR, Alleyne G, Claeson M,
recommendations on public health, implementation Evans DB, Jha P, Mills A, Musgrove P, editors. Disease
of community-based programs for integrated pre- control priorities in developing countries. New York: World
vention of disease, health promotion and evaluation Bank Health and Oxford University Press, 2006: 723–736.
of such programs through health systems research. 13. Calsina G, Ramón JM, Echeverrı́a JJ. Effects of smoking on
periodontal tissues. J Clin Periodontol 2002: 29: 771–776.
The WHO contributes to raising the awareness of
14. Chen M, Anderson RM, Barmes DE, Leclercq M-H, Lyttle
the global challenges to periodontal health, and the CS. Comparing oral health care systems a second interna-
specific and unique needs of low-income and mid- tional collaborative study. Geneva: World Health Organi-
dle-income countries and of poor and disadvantaged zation, 1997.
population groups; in addition, the WHO provides 15. Clarke M, Locker D, Murray H, Payne B. The oral health of
disadvantaged adolescents in North York, Ontario. Can J
advice and technical support to countries for the
Public Health 1996: 87: 261–263.
development and implementation of periodontal

37
Petersen & Ogawa

16. Coogan MM, Greenspan J, Challacombe SJ. Oral lesions in 36. Kandelman D, Petersen PE, Ueda H. Oral health, general
infection with human immunodeficiency virus. Bull World health, and quality of life in older people. Spec Care Dentist
Health Organ 2005: 83: 700–706. 2008: 28: 224–236.
17. Croucher R, Marcenes W, Torress M, Hughes F, Sheiham A. 37. Kaufman FR. Type 2 diabetes mellitus in children and
The relationship between life events and periodontitis. A youth: a new epidemic. J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab 2002:
case control study. J Clin Periodontol 1997: 24: 39–43. 15: 737–744.
18. Detels R, McEwen J, Beaglehole R, Tanaka H. Oxford text- 38. Kibayashi M, Tanaka M, Nishida N, Kuboniwa M, Kataoka
book of public health, 4th edn. Oxford: Oxford University K, Nagata H, Nakayama K, Morimoto K, Shizukuishi S.
Press, 2004. Longitudinal study of the association between smoking as
19. Drury TF, Garcia I, Adesanya M. Socioeconomic disparities a periodontitis risk and salivary biomarkers related to
in adult oral health in the United States. Ann NY Acad Sci periodontitis. J Periodontol 2007: 78: 859–867.
1999: 896: 322–324. 39. Kingman K, Albandar JM. Methodological aspects of epi-
20. Emrich LJ, Shlossman M, Genco RJ. Periodontal disease in demiological studies of periodontal diseases. Periodontol
non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus. J Periodontol 2000 2002: 29: 11–30.
1991: 62: 123–130. 40. Kruger E, Jacobs A, Tennant M. Sustaining oral health services
21. Enwonwu CO. Epidemiological and biochemical studies of in remote and indigenous communities: a review of 10 years
necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis and noma (cancrum oris) experience in Western Australia. Int Dent J 2010: 60: 129–134.
in Nigerian children. Arch Oral Biol 1972: 17: 1357–1371. 41. Krustrup U, Petersen PE. Periodontal conditions in 35–44
22. Enwonwu CO. Noma: a neglected scourge of children in and 65–74-year-old adults in Denmark. Acta Odontol Scand
sub Saharan Africa. Bull World Health Org 1995: 73: 541. 2006: 64: 65–73.
23. Enwonwu CO, Edozien JC. Epidemiology of periodontal 42. Kune S. Stressful life events and cancer. Epidemiology 1993:
disease in Western Nigerians in relation to socioeconomic 4: 395–396.
status. Arch Oral Biol 1970: 15: 1231–1244. 43. Kwan S, Petersen PE. Oral health: equity and social deter-
24. Enwonwu CO, Falkler WA, Idigbe EO, Afolabi MB, Ibrahim minants. In: Blas E, Sivasankara Kurup A, editors. Equity,
M, Onwujekwe D, Savage KO, Meeks V. Pathogenesis of social determinants and public health programmes.
oro-facial gangrene (noma): confounding interations of Geneva: WHO, 2010: 159–176.
malnutrition and infection. Am J Trop Med Hyg 1999: 60: 44. Lin HC, Schwarz E. Oral health and dental care in modern-day
223–232. China. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2001: 29: 319–328.
25. Enwonwu CO, Phillips RS, Ibrahim CD, Danfillo IS. Nutri- 45. Lindhe J, Lang NP, Karring T. Clinical periodontology and
tion and oral health in Africa. Int Dent J 2004: 54: 344–351. implant dentistry, 5th edn. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2008.
26. Gelskey S. Cigarette smoking and periodontitis: methodol- 46. Ling LJ, Hung SL, Tseng SC, Chen YT, Chi LY, Wu KM, Lai
ogy to assess the strength of evidence in support of causa- YL. Association between betel quid chewing, periodontal
tion. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1999: 27: 16–24. status and periodontal pathogens. Oral Microbiol Immunol
27. Genco RJ, Ho AW, Grossi SG, Dunford RG, Tedesco LA. 2001: 16: 364–369.
Relationship of stress, distress, and inadequate coping 47. Marmot M, Wilkinson R. Social determinants of health.
behaviours to periodontal disease. J Periodontol 1999: 70: Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999.
711–723. 48. Mealey BL, Oates TW; American Academy of Periodontol-
28. Grossi SG, Genco RJ. Periodontal disease and diabetes mell- ogy. Diabetes mellitus and periodontal diseases. J Period-
itus: a two-way relationship. Ann Periodontol 1998: 3: 51–61. ontol 2006: 77: 1289–1303.
29. Grossi SG, Skrepcinski FB, DeCaro T, Zambon JJ, Cummins 49. Meneilly GS, Tessier D. Diabetes in the elderly adults.
D, Genco RJ. Response to periodontal therapy in diabetics J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 2001: 56: 5–13.
and smokers. J Periodontol 1996: 67(Suppl): 1094–1102. 50. Moynihan P, Petersen PE. Diet, nutrition and the preven-
30. Hescot P, Bourgeois D, Berger P. La situation en France tion of dental diseases. Public Health Nutr 2004: 7: 201–226.
pour la période 1993–1995. Londres: FDI World Dental 51. Nelson RG, Shlossman M, Budding LM, Pettitt DJ, Saad
Press, 1996. MF, Genco RJ, Knowler WC. Periodontal disease and non-
31. Hong-Ying W, Petersen PE, Jin-You B, Bo-Xue Z. The sec- insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus in Pima Indians.
ond national survey of oral health status of children and Diabetes Care 1990: 13: 836–840.
adults in China. Int Dent J 2002: 52: 283–290. 52. Nishida M, Grossi SG, Dunford RG, Ho AW, Trevisan M,
32. IDF. Diabetes atlas, 4th edn. Brussels: International Dia- Genco RJ. Dietary vitamin C and the risk for periodontal
betes Federation, 2009. disease. J Periodontol 2000: 71: 1215–1223.
33. Jamison DT, Breman JG, Measham AR, Alleyne G, Claeson 53. Papapanou PN. Epidemiology of periodontal diseases: an
M, Evans DB, Jha P, Mills A, Musgrove P, editors. Disease update. J Int Acad Periodontol 1999: 4: 110–116.
control priorities in developing countries. New York: World 54. Petersen PE. The World Oral Health Report 2003: contin-
Bank Health and Oxford University Press, 2006. uous improvement of oral health in the 21st century – the
34. Jordan RA, Lucaciu A, Fotouhi K, Markovic L, Gaengler P, approach of the WHO Global Oral Health Programme.
Zimmer S. Pilot pathfinder survey of oral hygiene and Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2003: 31(Suppl. 1): 3–23.
periodontal conditions in the rural population of The 55. Petersen PE. Inequalities in oral health: the social context
Gambia (West Africa). Int J Dent Hyg 2011: 9: 53–59. for oral health. In: Pine C, Harris R, editors. Community
35. Jürgensen N, Petersen PE. Oral health and the impact of dent health. London: Quintessence, 2007: 31–58.
socio-behavioural factors in a cross sectional survey of 12- 56. Petersen PE. World Health Organization global policy for
year old school children in Laos. BMC Oral Health 2009: 29: improvement of oral health – World Health Assembly 2007.
1–11. Int Dent J 2008: 58: 115–121.

38
Global periodontal health

57. Petersen PE. Global policy for improvement of oral health 75. Tomar SL, Asma S. Smoking-attributable periodontitis in
in the 21st century – implications to oral health research of the United States: findings from NHANES III. National
World Health Assembly 2007, World Health Organization. health and nutrition examination survey. J Periodontol
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2009: 37: 1–8. 2000: 71: 743–751.
58. Petersen PE, Bourgeois D, Bratthall D, Ogawa H. Oral 76. Tseveenjav B, Suominen AL, Hausen H, Vehkalahti
health information systems – towards measuring progress MM. The role of sugar, xylitol, toothbrushing fre-
in oral health promotion and disease prevention. Bull quency, and use of fluoride toothpaste in maintenance
World Health Organ 2005: 83: 686–693. of adultsÕ dental health: findings from the Finnish
59. Petersen PE, Kaka M. Oral health status of children and National Health 2000 Survey. Eur J Oral Sci 2011: 119:
adults in the Republic of Niger, Africa. Int Dent J 1999: 49: 40–47.
159–164. 77. Uetani M, Jimba M, Kaku T, Ota K, Wakai S. Oral health status
60. Petersen PE, Kandelman D, Arpin S, Ogawa H. Global oral of vulnerable groups in a village of the Central Highlands,
health of older people – call for public health action. southern Vietnam. Int J Dent Hyg 2006: 4: 72–76.
Community Dent Health 2010: 27(Suppl. 2): 257–268. 78. United Nations Programme on HIV ⁄ AIDS (UNAIDS).
61. Petersen PE, Nyandindi U, Kikiwilu EN, Mabelya L, Lem- Global report: UNAIDS report on the global AIDS epidemic
bariti BS, Poulsen VJ. Oral health status and oral health 2010. Geneva: UNAIDS, 2010.
behaviour of school children, teachers and adults in Tan- 79. Varenne B, Petersen PE, Ouattara S. Oral health status of
zania (Technical report). Geneva: World Health Organiza- children and adults in urban and rural areas of Burkina
tion, 2002. Faso, Africa. Int Dent J 2004: 54: 83–89.
62. Petersen PE, Razanamihaja N. Oral health status of chil- 80. Watt RG. From victim blaming to upstream action: tackling
dren and adults in Madagascar. Int Dent J 1996: 46: 41–47. the social determinants of oral health inequalities. Com-
63. Petersen PE, Ueda H. Oral health in ageing societies: inte- munity Dent Oral Epidemiol 2007: 35: 1–11.
gration of oral health and general health. Report of a 81. World Bank. List of economics. New York: World Bank, 2010.
meeting convened at the WHO Centre for Health Devel- 82. World Health Organization. Ottawa charter for health
opment in Kobe, Japan, 1–3 June 2005. Geneva: World promotion: first international conference on health pro-
Health Organization, 2006. motion. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1986.
64. Pilot T. The periodontal disease problem. A comparison 83. World Health Organization. Oral health surveys basic
between industrialised and developing countries. Int Dent J methods, 3rd edn. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1987.
1998: 48(Suppl. 1): 221–232. 84. World Health Organization. Oral health surveys basic meth-
65. Pitiphat W, Merchant AT, Rimm EB, Joshipura KJ. Alcohol ods, 4th edn. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1997.
consumption increases periodontal risk. J Dent Res 2003: 85. World Health Organization. The world health report 2002.
82: 509–513. Reducing risks, promoting healthy life. Geneva: World
66. Salvi G, Lawrence H, Offenbacher S, Beck J. Influence of Health Organization, 2002.
risk factors on the pathogenesis of periodontitis. Period- 86. World Health Organization. Diet, nutrition and the pre-
ontol 2000 1997: 14: 173–201. vention of chronic diseases. Geneva: WHO. WHO Technical
67. Sandberg GE, Sundberg HE, Wikblad KF. A controlled study Report Series No. 916, 2003.
of oral self-care and self-perceived oral health in type two 87. World Health Organization. Framework convention on to-
diabetic patients. Acta Odontol Scand 2001: 59: 28–33. bacco control. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2003.
68. Simon EN, Matee MI, Scheutz F. Oral health status of World Health Assembly, May 2003 (Resolution WHA56.1).
handicapped primary school pupils in Dar es Salaam, 88. World Health Organization. World health survey (WHS).
Tanzania. East Afr Med J 2008: 85: 113–117. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2006. Available at:
69. Soskolne WA, Klinger A. The relationship between peri- (http://www.who.int/healthinfo/survey/en/index.html).
odontal diseases and diabetes: an overview. Ann Period- 89. World Health Organization. The WHO global oral health
ontol 2001: 6: 91–98. data bank. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2007.
70. Taylor GW. Bidirectional interrelationships between dia- Available at: (http://www.who.int/oral_health).
betes and periodontal diseases: an epidemiological per- 90. World Health Organization. World health statistics 2007.
spective. Ann Periodontol 2001: 6: 99–112. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2007.
71. Taylor GW, Borgnakke WS. Periodontal disease: associa- 91. World Health Organization. The WHO global health atlas.
tions with diabetes, glycemic control and complications. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2008.
Oral Dis 2008: 14: 191–203. 92. World Health Organization. The world health report 2008.
72. Taylor GW, Burt BA, Becker MP, Genco RJ, Shiossman M. Primary health care (Now More Than Ever). Geneva: World
Glycemic control and alveolar bone loss progression in Health Organization, 2008.
type 2 diabetics. Ann Periodontol 1998: 3: 30–39. 93. World Health Organization. World health statistics 2009.
73. Taylor GW, Burt BA, Becker MP, Genco RJ, Shlossman M, Geneva: World Health Organization, 2009.
Knowler WC, Pettitt DJ. Severe periodontitis and risk for 94. World Health Organization. Oral health surveys-basic
poor glycemic control in subjects with non-insulin- methods, 5th edn. Geneva: World Health Organization,
dependent diabetes mellitus. J Periodontol 1996: 67(Suppl): 2011 (in press).
1085–1093. 95. World Health Organization. World health statitics 2011.
74. Tezal M, Grossi SG, Ho AW, Genco RJ. The effect of alcohol Geneva: World Health Organization, 2011. (in press).
consumption on periodontal disease. J Periodontol 2001:
72: 183–189.

39

You might also like