Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Portfolio Management and Financial Analysis: Chapter 16 - Managing Bond Portfolios 1
Portfolio Management and Financial Analysis: Chapter 16 - Managing Bond Portfolios 1
So far, we stated…
► longer TTM implies a higher interest rate sensitivity
► higher coupon implies lower interest rate sensitivity
However, is this actually correct and how can we put both into perspective?
Duration
► Measure of the price sensitivity to changes in market yield rates
► A measure of the effective maturity of a bond.
► Incorporates timing and size of a securities cash flows.
► is shorter than maturity for all bonds except zero coupon bonds.
► is equal to maturity for zero coupon bonds.
Duration is a weighted average of the time until the expected cash flows from a
security will be received, relative to the security’s price.
If we want to measure the sensitivity of the price (PB) to changes in interest rate (r), we have to take the first
order derivative of PB with respect to r:
dPB T
− t CFt
=
t =1 (1 + r )
t +1
dr
1
When the value of r is small, which is usually the case, it is fair to say, that the fraction (1 + r ) equates to 1.
Subsequently we can state the fraction separately and set it equal to 1:
dPB 1 T
− t CFt T
− t CFt
= 1
dr (1 + r ) t =1 (1 + r ) t
t =1 (1 + r )
t
What is left is PB, which is the sum of the cash flows present values multiplied by –t:
T T
dPB CFt
= −t = − t ( PV ) CF
(1 + r ) t =1
t
dr t =1
According to Macaulay (1938) duration is defined as: „…total weighted average time for recovery of the
payments and principal in relation to the current market price of the bond.” So we have to divide by PB:
− t CFt
− t ( PV ) CF (1 + r )
t
T
Duration = =
t =1 PB PB Chapter 16 – Managing Bond Portfolios 7
Practice Questions
1. What is the duration of a bond with a face value of $1,000, 10% annual coupon payments, 3
years until maturity and 12% YTM? The bond price is $951.96.
100 1 100 2 100 3 1,000 3
+ + +
(1.12) 1 (1.12) 2 (1.12) 3 (1.12) 3 2,597.6
D= 3
= = 2.73 years
100 1000 951.96
(1.12) t + (1.12) 3
t =1
2. What is the duration of a bond with a face value of $1,000, 10% coupon, 3 years until
maturity and YTM of 5%? The bond price is $1,136.16.
100 * 1 100 * 2 100 * 3 1,000 * 3
1
+ + +
(1.05) (1.05) 2 (1.05) 3 (1.05) 3 3,127.31
D= = = 2.75 years
1136.16 1,136.16
3. What is the duration of a bond with a face value of $1,000, 10% coupon, 3 years until
maturity but the YTM is 20%? The bond’s price is $789.35.
100 * 1 100 * 2 100 * 3 1,000 * 3
1
+ + +
(1.20) (1.20) 2 (1.20) 3 (1.20) 3 2,131.95
D= = = 2.68 years
789.35 789.35
P (1 + y )
D* = −
D P
= −D (1 + y ) = − D * y
P 1+ y P
Note: y = ( 1 + y )
► Normally the second equation (in the middle) is preferred to the first equation on the left-
hand side.→ Modified Duration (D*) → the percentage change in bond price is just the
product of the modified duration and the change in the bond’s yield to maturity.
► Because the percentage change in the bond price is proportional to modified duration,
modified duration is a natural measure of the bond’s exposure to changes in interest rates
BUT: This is only an approximation and not valid for large changes in the bond‘s yield. In case of
very small interest changes, the approximation becomes precise
► By now we know that duration is a measures the sensitivity of a bond to interest changes
► Bonds with high (low) duration will lose (gain) more in value when rates increase (decrease)
► Modified duration helps to express the percentage change in the bonds value according to the percentage
change in the interest rate
D
D* = − Let's look at an example:
► Modified Duration: y
1+ Semi-annual coupon bond with annual rate of 6%, TTM
k of 3 years, Macaulay duration of 2.777 and a market rate
► Using modified duration, we can of 10%.
approximate the %-change in bond value Modified duration = 2.777 / (1+0.05)= 2.644
for a respective %-change in the yield:
Let us assume market rates increase by 0.05%.
P What is the effect on the bond value?
= − D * y %-change in PB = -2.644 * 0.05 = -1.322%
P
New price = 904.17 – (904.17 * 0.01322) = 892.22
Based on the exact excel calculation we get:
► The duration is a good approximation
Price Duration
for small interest changes, however, for longer TTM 10.5% 892.855 2.775
and larger interest rate changes the differences 10.0% 904.167 2.777
get more significant. The difference is because the Macaulay formula assumes
Figure
a linear bond value curve, although it is convex.
( Pi- - Pi + ) / P0
ED =
(i + - i - )
Pi- = Price if rates fall
Pi+ = Price if rates rise
P0 = current market price
i+ = initial rate plus the increase in rate
i- = initial rate minus the decrease in rate
Consider a 3-year, 9.4 percent semi-annual coupon bond, which is selling for $10,000 (par-value). The YTM
is 9.4%
► Macaulay’s Duration for the option-free version of this bond is 5.36 semiannual periods, or 2.68 years.
► If rates fall, the price will not rise much above the par value since it will likely be called.
► If rates rise, the bond is unlikely to be called and the price will fall.
► rates rise 30 basis points to 5% semiannually, the price will fall to $9,847.72.
► rates fall 30 basis points to 4.4% semiannually, the price will remain at par
► The duration of a portfolio is the weighted average duration of all bonds in the portfolio
► Portfolio Managers can change the portfolios interest rate risk by changing duration
► Duration can be reduced by: (1) shorter maturities and (2) higher coupons
► Duration can be increased by: (1) longer maturities and (2) lower coupon bonds
► We can differentiate between active and passive investment management
► Passive, e.g. index tracker, where duration matches the benchmark
► Active, e.g. increasing (decreasing) portfolio duration to 105% (95%) of the benchmark in
times of falling (rising) interest rates
Portfolio Weight
Market Value Duration
Bond weight Duration
A $100'000 0.1 4 0.4
B $200'000 0.2 7 1.4
C $300'000 0.3 6 1.8
D $400'000 0.4 2 0.8
$1'000'000 1.0 - 4.4
► Maturity is the point in time when you receive back your principal, which makes up the main
part of your payments
► Duration is the time it takes to recover your initial investment
► Therefore, the longer TTM and the lower the coupon → the higher the duration
► The following points have an impact on duration:
− The longer the maturity, the higher the duration
− The lower the coupon payment (i.e. interest rate) the higher the duration
→ the more cash you receive back, and the faster you receive it back, the lower the
duration.
► Duration combines the impact of both
components: maturity and coupon
► TTM is not a sufficient measure of interest rate
sensitivity, as instruments with the same
time-to maturity have different interest rate
sensitivity (e.g. zero-coupon vs. annual coupon)
Source: California Debt and Investment Advisory Commission
► Changes in the value of a bond are inversely related to changes in the rate of return
► Long-term bonds have greater interest rate risk than short-term bonds
► Low coupon bonds have greater interest rate sensitivity than high coupon bonds
► As maturity increases, duration increases and the bond’s price becomes more sensitive to
interest rate changes
► As the bond coupon increases, its duration decreases and the bond becomes less sensitive to
interest rate changes
► As interest rates increase, duration decreases and the bond becomes less sensitive to further
rate changes
► Duration allows bonds of different maturities and coupon rates to be directly compared
► The higher the duration, the higher the risk of price changes as interest rates change
► So far, we have estimated the sensitivity of fixed income instruments to interest changes
through the first derivative of the present value.
► Duration is a precise approximation for small interest changes. Estimation error increases
when interest rate changes raise.
► Problem: present value curve is convex and therefore the linear approximation (tangent) is
not appropriate
► Convexity is the second order derivative of bond price with respect to yield divided by price
► Illustration shows the actual bond price movement on the red line and the duration
approximation sensitivity on the blue line
(t 2
+ t ) ( PV ) CF
t ( PV ) CF (1 + r )
T 2
CF
Pr ice =
T T
Duration = Convexity =
(1 + r )
t
t =1 P P
t =1 t =1
► Given is a 6-year annual coupon bond with a coupon rate of 4% and par value of
$1‘000. The market interest rate is 4%. You are expected to calculate the following:
a) Price of the bond (P)
b) Duration (D)
c) Modified Duration (MD)
d) Convexity (C) Present
Period Payment Value Weight Duration Convexity
0 -1000
1 40 38.46 0.038 0.038462 0.07692
2 40 36.98 0.037 0.073964 0.22189
3 40 35.56 0.036 0.10668 0.42672
4 40 34.19 0.034 0.136769 0.68384
5 40 32.88 0.033 0.164385 0.98631
6 1040 821.93 0.822 4.931563 34.52094
SUM 1000.00 1.00 5.452 36.917
Duration = 5.452
Modified Duration = 5.242
Convexity = 34.1315
► Investor Behavior: Convexity is generally considered a desirable trait. Bonds with greater curvature
gain more in price when yield falls than they lose less when yields rise; see chart: A and B have the
same duration at the initial yield. The plots of proportional price changes as a function of interest
rate changes are tangent, meaning that their sensitivities to changes in yields at that point are equal.
Convexity = 17.109
P
► We recall the following relationship: = − D * y
P
► This implies, that the percentage price change is directly proportional to the change in bonds
yield
► However, this would mean that the change in yield would plot as a straight line (duration)
► We know that this is not true, therefore we correct for convexity, which yields the revised
relationship:
P 1
= − D * y + C o n v e x ity ( y )
2
P 2
See Bodie, Kane & Marcus (2011) page 520 – Example 16.2
► Negative convexity implies that if market yields decrease, duration decreases as well.
► In the chart, the callable bond behaves like an option-free bond at a rate above yield Y*.
► Positive convexity because, when interest rate > Y* bonds won’t be called, otherwise
issuer would have to refinance at higher rate.
► The prepayment risk gives MBS the undesirable property of "negative convexity.“
► when market rates move, MBS prices adjust less favorably than prices of alternative securities
► MBS entail a similar property to callable bonds, since the mortgage lenders can pre-pay their
credit and take advantage of lower current market rates
► However, they are not as sensitive to a decline in interest rates, because homeowners do not
refinance their loans as soon as rates drop (e.g. plan to move soon, not worth the hustle, etc.)
2. Suppose you invest in zero coupon bonds. One matures in 1 year, paying $100, and its price is
$56.93. The other matures in 2 years, paying $1100, and its price is $943.07.
a) Compute the yield of each bond.
b) Compute the duration of each bond.
c) What is the weighted-average duration of a portfolio comprising each of these two
bonds. (Hint: for each bond, its portfolio weight is the fraction of the portfolio’s value
that is made up by each bond’s price)
d) Compute the duration of the portfolio composed of the two bonds.
If the average duration of a portfolio equals the investor’s desired holding period, the investor’s
total return remains constant regardless of whether interest rates rise or fall.
Example:
► Assume we are interested in a $1,000 par value bond that will mature in two years.
► The bond has a coupon rate of 8 percent and pays $80 in interest at the end of each year.
► Interest rates on comparable bonds are also at 8 percent but may fall to as low as 6 percent
or rise as high as 10 percent.
► The buyer knows he will receive $1000 at maturity, but in the meantime, he faces the
uncertainty of having to reinvest the annual $80 in interest earnings at 6%, 8%, or 10%.
► The bond will earn $80 in interest payments for year one, $80 for year two, and $4.80 ($80 x 0.06) when
the $80 interest income received in year 1 is reinvested at 6% rate during year 2.
How much will the investor earn over the two years?
► First year’s interest earnings + Second year’s interest earnings + Interest earned by reinvesting the first
year’s interest earnings at 6% + Par value of the bond at maturity.
► The bond will earn $80 in interest payments for year one, $80 for year two, and $8.00 ($80 x 0.10) when
the $80 interest income received in year 1 is reinvested at 10% during year 2.
How much will the investor earn over the two years?
► First year’s interest earnings + Second year’s interest earnings + Interest earned by reinvesting the first
year’s interest earnings at 10% + Par value of the bond at maturity.
► But, if the investor can find a bond whose duration matches his or her planned holding
period, he or she can avoid this fluctuation in earnings.
▪ The bond can have a maturity that exceeds the investor’s holding period, but its
duration has to match.
Case 1 – Let interest rates fall to 6%.
► The bond will earn $80 in interest payments for year one, $80 for year two, and $4.80 ($80 x 0.06) when
the $80 interest income received the first year is reinvested at 6% rate during year 2.
▪ However, the bond’s market price will rise to $1,001.60 due to the decrease in interest rates.
How much will the investor earn over the two years?
► First year’s interest earnings + Second year’s interest earnings + Interest earned by reinvesting the first
year’s interest earnings at 6% + Market price of the bond at the end of the investor’s planned holding
period.
► The bond will earn $80 in interest payments for year one, $80 for year two, and $8.00 ($80 x 0.10) when
the $80 interest income received the first year is reinvested at 10% during year 2.
▪ However, the bond’s market price will fall to $998.40, due to the rise in interest rates.
How much will the investor earn over the two years?
► First year’s interest earnings + Second year’s interest earnings + reinvestment gain of the first year’s
interest earnings reinvested at 10% + Par value of the bond at maturity.
► The investor earns identical total earnings even if interest rates go up or down.
▪ When the duration is set equal to the buyer’s planned holding period, a fall (rise) in the
reinvestment rate is completely offset by an increase (decrease) in the bond’s market price.
► Investors can achieve effective immunization strategies by approximately matching the duration of their
portfolios with their planned holding periods.
► Even if a position is immunized, the portfolio manager must rebalance the position in response to
changes in interest rates.
► Moreover, even if rates do not change, also the passage of time will affect duration and requires
rebalancing.
Of course, rebalancing of the portfolio entails transaction costs as assets are bought or sold, so one
cannot rebalance continuously.
The manager must find an appropriate tradeoff between the desire for perfect immunization, which
requires continual rebalancing, and the trading costs, which dictate less frequent rebalancing.
Dedication Strategy: If an investor follows the principle of cash flow matching, one can
automatically immunize the portfolio from interest rate movements since the cash flow from the
bond and the obligation exactly offset each other.
− The strategy of cash flow matching on a multi-period basis is called dedication strategy. In
this case, the manager either selects zero-coupon or coupon bonds that provide in each
period total cash flows that match a series of obligations.
− Question: How would an increase in trading costs affect the attractiveness of dedication
versus immunization?
→ Dedication more attractive. Dedication does not require rebalancing.
* Homer, S. & Leibowitz, M. 2004. Inside the Yield Book. Bloomberg Press
• Horizon analysis involves forecasting the realized compound yield over various
holding periods of investment horizons
– An analyst selects a particular holding period and predicts the yield curve at
the end of the period
– Given a bond’s time to maturity at the end of the holding period, its yield can
be read from the predicted yield curve and its end-of-period price can be
calculated
b) Find the actual price of the bond assuming that its yield to maturity immediately increases
from 7% to 8% (with maturity still 10 years).
c) What price would be predicted by the duration rule (equation 16.2)? What is the percentage
error of that rule?
d) What price would be predicted by the duration-with-convexity rule (equation 16.4)? What is
the percentage error of that rule?
a) Find the actual price of the bond assuming that its yield to maturity immediately increases from 7% to 8%
(with maturity still 10 years).
If the yield to maturity increases to 8%, bond price will fall to 93.29% of par value, a decrease of 6.71%.
a) What price would be predicted by the duration rule (equation 16.2)? What is the percentage error of that
rule?
The duration rule predicts a percentage price change of:
This overstates the actual percentage decrease in price by 0.31%. The price predicted by the duration rule
is 7.02% less than face value, or 92.98% of face value.
a) What price would be predicted by the duration-with-convexity rule (equation 16.4)? What is the
percentage error of that rule?
The duration-with-convexity rule predicts a percentage price change of:
The percentage error is 0.01%, which is substantially less than the error using the
Duration rule.