Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CPWD Building Management
CPWD Building Management
ENGINEERS’
D.KRISHNA KUMAR
CPWD, MUMBAI
CHAPTER – I
INTRODUCTION
Introduction
B
uilding Management Systems or BMS as they are popularly
known have recently gained huge popularity amongst the
building industry in general and CPWD in particular. This book
is basically meant for the engineers who are expected to provide
and / or maintain BMS in a building. An attempt is being made to
incorporate all the parameters required right from initial concept to
final commissioning. This is not meant to substitute the CPWD
Specifications for HVAC works 2005, which contains BMS, but rather
to supplement the book from the point of execution of the BMS
work. This covers BMS relating not only to HVAC but to most other
services like electrical panels, standby power sources, lifts, water
supply pumpsets, lighting, STP etc. This booklet does not attempt to
go deep into every component of the BMS, but rather look at the
broad concept behind the philosophy.
A few of the above services mentioned can fall into both the
categories. Providing a BMS primarily depends on factors like the
functionality of the building, the comfort level that the client has
for automation, the necessity for complete automation etc.
Observe that cost has not been quoted as a primary factor. This
is because once it has been decided to implement BMS in a
building, adding additional services for the BMS to control and /
or monitor can be done at a nominal incremental cost on the
BMS. Of course, the services to be implemented under BMS
should be compatible with BMS protocols and the BMS itself
should have sufficient spare capacity. And last but not the least,
the agency implementing the BMS should be willing to do the
additional work, especially if the other services are being added
after the BMS work is awarded.
There are a number of well known companies offering Building
Management Systems. The popular are “Enterprise Building
Solutions” (EBI) from Honeywell Automation India Limited,
“Building Integration System (BIS) from Bosch, “Unitron” from
Cylon Controls, “Metasys BACnet System Integrator” from
Johnson Controls Limited, “Desigo” from Siemens Ltd etc.
The Experience
SEBI Bhavan, for which the building construction started in
October 2004 and inaugurated by the Hon. Prime Minister, Shri
Manmohan Singh, on 6th October 2006, is a (recent) example of
a BMS installation in the CPWD. The services of Internal Electric
Installations, Substation, HVAC, Fire Alarm System and Fire
fighting system were a part of composite tender.
A separate tender was floated for “Integrated Building
Automation System”. The IBAS system apart from the basic BMS
also includes CCTV, Access control system and digital public
address system. BMS monitoring and / or control is being done
for all the services mentioned on the previous page.
In the ensuing pages that follow, where relevant, the
methodology adopted in SEBI shall be mentioned. Also each
chapter in this book before its conclusion shall have a section on
the particular approach used in SEBI. This section entitled “The
SEBI Experience” shall include the methods adopted in SEBI, the
pitfalls that were encountered and rectified in course of providing
the BMS in SEBI. This is being put in black & white so that
engineers who are installing or interested to have a BMS in their
works can have an idea of how they can execute the work and
improve on the SEBI design. This will also bring to the fore the
errors that occurred in the SEBI project and to learn from the
SEBI experience. However, the chapter titled “Typical Control
Logics” is wholly, related to SEBI.
CHAPTER – II
BASICS
Basics
T
his chapter describes the fundamental of the BMS. The
Building Management System is meant for performing on a
real time basis. That means the data is transmitted, necessary
control logic applied and the appropriate control applied, all in real
time basis by the Building Management System.
The main components of a BMS can be broadly divided into
Sensors, Control logic and the controller. Each of these is described
in the pages that follow. The various modes of communication
between these and other related equipment is also described.
Sensor:
The sensor is a very important part of the control system and can
be the first, as well as the major, weak link in the control system
chain. The sensors are used to measure various parameters like
temperature, relative humidity, current, voltage, power, air flow,
lighting level, CO2 levels, air quality etc. Other values may be
measured that enable the controller to take appropriate action
depending on data values. These include fire status, time-of-day
etc. The various sensors are described in Chapter 4 (Sensors)
Control:
What is control? Any basic
control loop will have three
Controller
components, a sensor, a
controller and a controlled
device. For example in a 2 way valve
HVAC system the
temperature is to be
measured, the data AHU Temperature
obtained is processed with Sensor
the other parameters like
time, chilled water flow Controlled Medium
etc., and finally corrective (Conference Room)
action is taken like
operating the valve for Basic Control Loop
increasing or decreasing
the chilled water flow. The above figure shows a basic control loop
for temperature control.
Controller:
The controller receives its inputs from various sensors, applies the
logic of the control and then causes a corrective action to be
generated. The signal may be sent direct to the device or to other
logical functions and ultimately to the device. The function of the
controller is to compare the input from sensor, apply logic and then
send an appropriate output signal. This is the control logic which
consists of a control response for a specific application. The control
response is how the controller functions. Typical control responses
consist of either of the following:
• Two Position
• Floating
• Proportional (P)
• Proportional plus Integral (PI)
• Proportional plus Integral plus Derivative (PID)
Controlled Devices:
A controlled device is a device that can respond to a signal from the
controller and causes a device to operate. Devices include valves,
dampers, relays, fans, pumps, compressors, variable speed drives,
actuators etc.
The Experience
Sensors:
In SEBI the following sensors have been used. The applications for
each of them are given against each.
1. Temperature sensor - Wall mounted : AHU RA Monitoring,
Auto switching of Atrium Exhaust fans, Kitchen
Exhaust Fans, Lift pressurisation Fans, FCU
Monitoring for 24x7 areas like hub rooms, UPS
rooms, BMS room, Fire Control Room.
2. Temperature sensor – Duct mounted : AHU RA Monitoring
(only in ducted return AHUs)
3. Differential Pressure Sensor (Air): Dirty Filter Status,
AHU Blower / Fan Belt Status.
4. Differential Pressure Sensor (Water): Chilled water
pumps’ and Condenser water pumps’ status
5. Air Quality Sensor: AHU Fresh air damper control,
Basement Ventilation fans auto switching, STP
Room ventilation auto switching.
6. Temperature & Relative Humidity Sensor: Outside air
temperature and relative humidity.
7. Liquid Flow Sensor: Pump status, Chiller status, Cooling
tower status.
8. Flow Meter: Quantity of flow thro piping
9. Water Level switch: For auto switching of pumpsets
10. Fuel Level switch: DG Set fuel level (Flame proof switch)
Controllers:
The controllers in SEBI had all or a few of the controls (two position,
floating etc.) depending the equipment being monitored/controlled.
Controlled Devices:
The list of controlled devices/equipment in SEBI includes the
following:
1. 3 nos 200 TR and 1 no 90 TR Screw chillers
2. Chilled water pumps operating on Variable Frequency drive
3. Condenser water pumps with fully automatic star delta
starters
4. Cooling towers with 2 speed motors and DOL starters
5. Various valves for above equipment
6. Air handling units of varying capacities from 5 TR to 35 TR
totalling 31 nos.
7. Fan Coil Units with control / monitoring totalling 55 nos.
8. Double speed ventilation fans (in basements) totalling 8 nos.
9. Ventilation fans for Atria, Kitchens, Service rooms etc.
10. Pressurisation fans for Lift lobbies, basement staircases
11. Electrical Panels
12. Motorised valves for water supply
The list of monitored devices in SEBI included the following:
1. DG Sets
2. Sewage treatment plant
3. 6 nos. Passenger lifts and 1 no. service lift
4. Electrical parameters of main panels
5. Pumpsets
6. Temperature in Hub rooms
7. Water level in drinking water tanks
CHAPTER – III
DDCs
D
DCs or Direct Digital Controllers are the nerve centres of a
Building Management System. These collect data, correlate
logic and control equipment for maintaining the environment
as it was designed for. These are 16 bit or 32 bit transistor / PCB
called as Direct Digital Controllers or simply DDCs.
The DDC receives the signal from the sensor, compares it with other
parameters and then issues the command for operating the
controlled device. For facilitating this, the DDC has to have various
input / output terminals. These are available for both analog and
digital type. The commonly used acronyms in the BMS arena AI, DI,
AO and DO stand for Analog Input, Digital Input, Analog Output and
Digital Output respectively and more recently UI – Universal Input.
Note: Most of the examples or references made in this chapter
relate to HVAC. This is because BMS has been, and still is, basically
meant for HVAC applications. But BMS can be easily adapted to any
other service with considerable ease.
S C O S C O
C – Controller
S – Sensor
S C O O – Output
Inter
face C – Controller
S – Sensor
O – Output
S C O
S C O
S C O
C – Controller
S – Sensor
O – Output
Inter
S C O face
S C O
S C O
S C O
S C O
Inter
S C O face
S C O
S C O
S C O
S C O
Figure 4: Communication Interface Device
The communication interface device may be standalone or built into
another device (Figure 5).
CI
C
CI – Communication Interface
I – Interface
C – Controller I
C C C
CI
C
CI – Communication
CI Interface CI
I – Interface
Site PC C – Controller Site PC
CI CI
C C
Subnet PC Subnet PC
I I
C C C C C C
C CI
C
CI
M
CI
C
M AA/AD M M
I
CI CI CI
C C C
C C C
Local I I I
PC
C C C
C C C C C C
Site PC C M
Global PC
CI
CI M
C CI – Communication
Interface
I – Interface,
C – Controller,
I
M - Modem
CI
C
C C
M M
Site PC
CI
C
CI
I CI – Communication
Interface
GW I – Interface,
C C – Controller,
C C M – Modem
GW- Gateway
SENSORS
T
he sensor is a very important part of the control system and
can be the first, as well as major, weak link in the control
system chain. Sensors are used to measure the parameters
like temperature, relative humidity, current, voltage, power, air
flow, lighting level, CO2 levels, air quality etc. Other values may be
measured that enable the controller to take appropriate action
depending on data values. These include fire status, time-of-day
etc.
RTD Sensors
Solid state sensors are available for space, duct and pipe
applications. A milli-volt signal proportional to the temperature is
generated for use by the DDC.
RTD Resistance • Linear resistance simplifying electronics • Small resistance with temperature
• Good stability • Response slower
• Wide range of operating temperatures • Subject to self heating
• Interchangeable over wide temperature • 3 wire / 4 wire required for lead resistance
range compensation
• Some types damaged by shock and vibration
• External power source required
IC Sensor Voltage / • Linear high level with temperature • Limited operating temperature range
Current • Low cost • External power source required
• Subject to self heating
• New technology, lack of standardization
Some differential pressure based flow sensors include PLCs that can
provide an analog value of the velocity flow by extracting the
square root of the measured pressure whereas other flow sensors
provide an analog sensor that is proportional to the pressure and
the DDC performs the calculations to obtain the average velocity.
Once the velocity is known the flow can be obtained by multiplying
it with the cross section of the duct. The velocity range is limited by
the range and resolution of the pressure transmitter used. Most
differential pressure transmitters are limited to a minimum velocity
in the range of 400 – 600 feet per minute. Maximum velocity is
however limited by the durability of the sensor.
Venturi tube
Flow nozzles
The turndown ratio (ratio of the full range of the instrument to the
minimum measurable flow) of differential pressure devices is
generally limited to 4:1. This can be extended to upto 16:1 by using
low range transmitter and high range transmitter / high turndown
transmitter and appropriate signal processing. Benefits of
differential pressure instruments are their relatively low cost,
simplicity and long and proven performance. However permanent
pressure loss and associated energy cost are its definite
disadvantage. Here too, the orifice plate device has the highest
pressure loss and the lowest pressure loss is in a venture type
device.
Turbine and propeller type meters operate on the principle that fluid
flowing through the turbine or propeller will induce a rotational
speed that can be related to the velocity of the fluid. Turbine and
propeller type flow meters are available in full bore, line mounted
versions and insertion types where only a portion of the flow being
measured passes over the rotating element. Full bore turbine and
propeller meters generally offer medium to high accuracy and
turndown capability at reasonable permanent pressure loss. With
electronic linearization, turndowns to 100:1 with 0.1% linearity are
available. Insertion types of turbine and propeller meters represent
a compromise in performance to reduce cost. Typical performance is
1 percent accuracy at 30:1 turndown. Turbine flow meters are
commonly used where good accuracy is required for critical flow
control or measurement for energy computations. Insertion types
are used for less critical applications. Insertion types are often
easier to maintain and inspect because they can be removed for
inspection and repair without disturbing the main piping. Some
types can be installed through hot tapping equipment and do not
require draining of the associated piping for removal and inspection.
V is the velocity
All airflow sensors work best in sections of ducts that have uniform
and a fully developed flow. All airflow sensing devices should be
installed in accordance with the manufacturers recommended
straight runs of upstream and downstream duct in order to provide
reliable measurement.
Similar to airflow, all liquid flow sensors work best when fully
developed, uniform flow is measured. To attain fully developed,
uniform flow sensors should be installed in accordance with the
manufacturers recommended straight runs of upstream and
downstream pipe in order to provide the most reliable
measurements.
Hydrostatic
Magnetostrictive
Capacitance
Ultrasonic
Capacitance
Variable Resistance
Piping
Current Transducers
Energy Measurement
With the increased interest in indoor air quality and the need to
monitor potentially dangerous gases, gas concentration
measurements have become increasing more important in DDC
system design. Many devices are currently available for use in HVAC
applications.
There are many types of gas measuring devices available for use
with DDC systems. By far, the three most common gases measured
in HVAC applications are carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and
refrigerant gases.
Carbon Monoxide
Carbon Dioxide
Refrigerant Gas
Position sensors
The Experience
TYPICAL
CONTROL LOGICS
I
read, I remember
see, I understand
do, I Know
How much ever we keep reading all the matter on a particular
subject, we all know that hands-on experience is second to none in
understanding a subject. Likewise in BMS, how much ever effort has
been taken in drawing upon the best sources available on the
subject, the invaluable experience gained in implementing the BMS
system in the SEBI Building has its own lessons. The complete
process of implementation of the BMS system of SEBI building is
given in the pages that follow.
Note: In SEBI, the BMS was part of the Integrated Building
Automation System (IBAS). The IBAS also included security related
equipment like Closed Circuit Television System, Access Control
System, Intrusion detection and the Digital Public Address System.
The matters relating to other packages are not discussed due to
security reasons.
Brief Introduction:
SEBI: The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) was set
up under the SEBI Act 1992. SEBI was set up by the Govt. of India
as a regulatory body to protect the interests of the investor and
detect and track market frauds. SEBI was earlier having offices
scattered over Mumbai. In order to have better coordination
between the various departments and reduce the huge rental costs,
it was decided to go for a single office in Mumbai resulting in SEBI
Bhawan.
SEBI awarded the work to the CPWD, against stiff competition from
NBCC, IRCON, LIC etc based on its track record and excellent
engineering skills backed by an able audit and vigilance support
services. CPWD took the work as a challenge and completed the
work in record time, without any cost or time overrun. The project
was executed by a dedicated Project Team comprising the SEBI
Project Civil Division and the SEBI Project Electrical Division. A few
packages on the civil side were also executed by another division,
the Navi Mumbai Central Division.
A composite contract with E&M services of Internal EI, Sub station,
HVAC, Fire alarm and Fire fighting system was operated. Other E&M
services were handled as separate contracts with different agencies.
Building: SEBI Bhavan is a multi storeyed building with two
basements, ground plus eight floors.
BUS CONTROLLER
CPWD
B.M.S GENERAL
SPECIFICATIONS
CPWD
has recently come out with a publication
titled “CPWD General Specifications
for HVAC Works 2005”. The book
contains, among other specifications, a chapter on Building
Management System (BMS). The relevant chapter from the
publication relating to Building Management System is reproduced
below with the kind permission of the Specifications Committee,
Central Public Works Department, New Delhi. For more details on
the CPWD please visit http://www.cpwd.gov.in. Copies of the HVAC
specifications and other books published by the CPWD can be had
from Jain Book Depot, New Delhi.
i) Integrated
The system shall provide an integrated Maintenance
Management function. The Maintenance Management
function shall use specified breakdown alarms,
equipment run hours or analog values from the BMS.
18.4.1 General
i) Level Switches
a. Level switches shall be directly vessel mounted type
either top mounted or side mounted as required.
b. These shall be float type unless specified. Process
connection shall be flanged c) Wetted parts shall be
SS316.
ii) Level Sensors
a. Level sensors shall be capacitance probe type.
b. It shall be possible to mount the transmitter unit
integral to the probe on the vessel or field mounted
away from the probe
c. Unless specified probe insulation shall be of PTFE and
probe rod material SS316
d. Process connection shall be flanged or BSP connections
as specified.
Point Functions
Sr. No. Description AI BI AO BO Monitor Control Alarm By Contractor By Department
A
HVAC Equipment
HIGH SIDE
1.
Chilling Machines
a. Chiller On/ OFF 1 X Relay Contact Potential Free contact in Chiller
Panel
b. Chiller Run Status 1 X X Potential Free contact in Chiller
Panel
c. Chiller Auto/ Manual Status 1 X X Potential Free contact in Chiller
Panel
d. Chiller-Water Temp Reset 1 X 0-10 VDC signal from chiller
panel
e. Chiller trip/ fault 1 X Potential Free contact in Chiller
Panel
f. Chiller chilled water supply 2 X Immersion type Suitable Insertion provision
temp in (1) + out sensor
n. Ambient Temperature 1 X Outside air temp. & Suitable Installation Provision
o. Ambient RH 1 X RH sensor Suitable Installation Provision
Sub Total 6 19 1 11
2.
Chilled Water Pumps
a. 2 X Relay output Potential Free contact in Pump
Primary Chilled Water Pump Starter Panel
On/ OFF
b. 2 X X Potential Free contact in Pump
Primary Chilled Water pump Starter Panel
run Status
c. 2 X Differential pressure Suitable Insertion Provision
Primary Chilled Water pump switch (water)
flow status
d. 4 X 0-10 VDC signal from Potential Free contact in Pump
Secondary CHW Pump On/ controller Starter Panel
Off
e. 4 X X Potential Free contact in Pump
Secondary CHW pump run Starter Panel
Statue
f. 4 X Differential Pressure
Secondary CHW pump flow switch (water) Suitable Insertion Provision
status
g. 4 Provision of VFD for pumps
Secondary CHW variable
speed control
0 12 4 6
Sub Total
4.
Condenser Water Pumps
a. 2 X Relay output Potential free contact in starter
Condenser pump On/ Off panel
b. 2 X X Air flow switch Suitable Installation provision
Cooling tower air flow status
Point Functions
Sr. No. Description AI DI AO DO Monitor Control Alarm By Contractor By Department
A
HVAC Equipment
HIGH SIDE
1.
Chilling Machines
a. Chiller On/ OFF 1 X Relay Contact Potential Free contact in Chiller
Panel
b. Chiller Run Status MODBUS or any other Potential Free contact in Chiller
open protocol Panel
c. Chiller Auto/ Manual Status MODBUS or any other Potential Free contact in Chiller
open protocol Panel
d. Chiller-Water Temp Reset 1 X 0-10 VDC signal from chiller
panel
e. Chiller trip/ fault 1 X Potential Free contact in Chiller
Panel
f. Chiller chilled water supply MODBUS or any other Suitable Insertion provision
temp in (1) + out open protocol
n. Ambient Temperature 1 X Outside air temp. & Suitable Installation Provision
o. Ambient RH 1 X RH sensor Suitable Installation Provision
Sub Total 2 1 1 1
2.
Chilled Water Pumps
a. 2 X Relay output Potential Free contact in Pump
Primary Chilled Water Pump Starter Panel
On/ OFF
b. 2 X X Potential Free contact in Pump
Primary Chilled Water pump Starter Panel
run Status
c. 2 X Differential pressure Suitable Insertion Provision
Primary Chilled Water pump switch (water)
flow status
d. 4 X 0-10 VDC signal from Potential Free contact in Pump
Secondary CHW Pump On/ controller Starter Panel
Off
e. 4 X X Potential Free contact in Pump
Secondary CHW pump run Starter Panel
Statue
f. 4 X Differential Pressure
Secondary CHW pump flow switch (water) Suitable Insertion Provision
status
g. 4 Provision of VFD for pumps
Secondary CHW variable
speed control
0 12 4 6
Sub Total
4.
Condenser Water Pumps
a. 2 X Relay output Potential free contact in starter
Condenser pump On/ Off panel
b. 2 X X Air flow switch Suitable Installation provision
Cooling tower air flow status