Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León Facultad de Filosofía y Letras Colegio Ciencias Del Lenguaje
Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León Facultad de Filosofía y Letras Colegio Ciencias Del Lenguaje
Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León Facultad de Filosofía y Letras Colegio Ciencias Del Lenguaje
PIA DRAFT
Group: i66
1
Due May 18th 2021
Contents
ABSTRACT 3
KEY WORDS 3
INTRODUCTION 4
PROBLEM STATEMENT 5
PURPOSE STATEMENT 5
SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY 5
RESEARCH QUESTIONS 6
OBJECTIVES 6
METHODOLOGY 7
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH 7
RESEARCH DESIGN: NAME OF THE DESIGN 8
POPULATION AND SAMPLE 8
INSTRUMENT 9
DATA COLLECTION PROCEDURES 9
ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA 10
CATEGORY 1: EMOTIONS 10
CATEGORY 2: ISSUES WHEN TEACHING ONLINE 10
CATEGORY 3: EFFECTS OF ONLINE TEACHING 11
CATEGORY 4: HARDEST SITUATIONS WHILE TEACHING ONLINE 11
CATEGORY 5: EMOTIONS CAUSED BY THE PANDEMIC 12
CATEGORY 6: ISSUES OF THE NEW MODALITY 12
CATEGORY 7: TEACHERS DEVELOPMENT 12
FINDINGS 13
CONCLUSION 14
REFERENCES 15
APPENDICES 16
APPENDIX 1. INSTRUMENT 16
APPENDIX 2. RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND INSTRUMENT QUESTIONS OBJECTIVES. 16
APPENDIX 3. TRANSCRIPTIONS 16
APPENDIX 4. DEMOGRAPHIC INFORMATION GRAPHS 16
2
ABSTRACT
Burnout is characterized as a state of physical and emotional exhaustion caused by working
conditions. In this study, we are acknowledging the syndrome in teachers, specifically
during the recent pandemic, with the purpose of knowing if the teachers at FFYL are going
through this problem. Burnout syndrome is a problem that is now common between
teachers because of exhausting hours of work. In this research, a case study approach was
used, with a narrative instrument in order to get as much experience as possible from the
teachers. As the main goal of this research is finding how teachers are coping with the
recent pandemic, and the change of modalities from face to face classes to online classes,
the instrument helped with the cause. Various teachers from FFYL have been reached to
participate in the study, there were demographic questions to know about them, and the
burnout related ones. The theory of the burnout phases by Veninga and Spradley's (1981)
was used to compare data, and the results showed how most of the teachers were going
through all the symptoms. It also showed how the emotions were different from every
teacher, and how the online teaching modality has managed to change the whole game for
them, some of them for the better, and others for the worse.
Key words
Burnout Syndrome, teachers, stress, education.
3
INTRODUCTION
Currently, as we all are aware, there is a global pandemic halting and limiting
the world as we normally know it. Just as many people have lost their jobs because it is
now considered risky to leave our homes. It is known that both students and teachers
have had to change the style and pace of teaching and learning, all this brought different
consequences, including the controversy of whether or not teachers are doing their job
properly.
The reality is that both students and teachers suffer from the difference that online
school brings, the drastic change from teaching in a classroom, to be seen through a
webcam. There is a big difference with respect to the students, although at the beginning
the idea of not attending classes was tempting, today it has become a martyrdom, it has
Now, if we focus on teachers, it is known that they have taken away the merit of
teaching, while many teachers are not doing their job, the reality is that many teachers
are suffering the ravages of online classes. Most teachers are suffering from the
consequences of covid-19, and their potential is the most affected with this situation.
In this study, we are going to talk about the struggles teachers have due the recent
pandemic, especially, the burnout syndrome that is the result of chronic work stress. In
this case, we are focusing on teachers having trouble with technology, pressure from the
4
PROBLEM STATEMENT
shortness of breath. The burnout syndrome is a problem that is now common between teachers
because of exhausting hours of work. If the teacher is having a difficult time because of the
working conditions, they are now able to develop issues regarding their personal life. This
situation brings many problems. This syndrome again begins to decrease the workers
competence and along with this, they begin to feel emotionally exhausted which eventually
PURPOSE STATEMENT
The purpose of this research is to describe the burnout syndrome effects in the
lives of Language Science teachers form the FFYL. As well as this, this research aims to
identify the main causes that contribute to the development of this syndrome based on
teachers’ experiences and how they have coped up with the challenges.
SIGNIFICANCE OF STUDY
The importance of this research is to point out the problems and the causes of
burnout syndrome in teachers, and with that data propose a solution to the problem.
With nowadays; the online classes only, without the face to face interaction, it is
difficult to know the effects this may cause to online learning and teaching, the gathering
and interpretation of data this research is going to collect, is helping out the people stuck
in this situation and the psychological effects this may have in a person.
5
It will also prevent teachers from stressing out in their work, and have a more
calm approach to their jobs and a way to find more joy in their work.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
● What are FFYL teachers’ feelings towards their profession during the new teaching
modality?
● How does the new teaching modality have affected FFYL teachers' professional life
and responsibilities?
● How has the recent Pandemic caused exhaustion and burnout syndrome on
teachers?
OBJECTIVES
● This research is trying to remark the problems that burnout might cause in teachers
● To look at the source of what is causing burnout syndrome and present a way to
6
METHODOLOGY
The qualitative research includes a wide range of approaches and methods that
were found within different research disciplines. A number of writers have attempted to
Denzin and Lincoln, 2011; Flick, 2009; Hammersely and Atkinson, 2007; Holloway and
Wheeler, 2010; Silverman, 2011). At general, the qualitative research is often described
interior"
naturalistic approach to its subject matter. This means that qualitative researchers study
things in their natural settings, attempting to make sense of, or interpret, phenomena in
empirical materials – case study, personal experience, introspective, life story, interview,
observational, historical, interactional, and visual texts, that describe routine and
problematic moments and meanings in individuals’ lives. (Denzin and Lincoln 2005:2)
account a certain group of individuals, considering the experiences they have had
7
CHARACTERISTICS OF QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
Mays 1995; Denzin & Lincoln, 1994) “Qualitative Research is intended to deeply
explore, understand and interpret social phenomena within its natural setting, it is known
that this research has the use of non-standardised, adaptable methods of data generation
that are sensitive to the social context of the study” This methodology matches the
researchers, because they are the only key to the study (Creswell, 2013). In research, as
it was mentioned before, experiences and stories are the main source of information, the
objectives are directed to the different experiences given, that is the reason why
Qualitative researchers generally choose to collect the required data from various
sources such as interviews, documentation, and observations, rather than relying only on
RESEARCH
social relations.
8
Qualitative research works with the universe of meanings, motives, aspirations,
( Maxwell, 2013)
Focus on understanding the context of the problem. Qualitative studies have been
used in a wide range of domains. Moriarty (2011) describes how qualitative research has
Mori & Nakayama (2013) perform a bibliometric analysis study to identify the
academic impact of qualitative studies in healthcare. In this research for example, we are
focusing on a healthcare topic, especially the teachers mental and physical health
Now some limitations can be that qualitative research is heavily dependent on the
individual skills of the researcher and more easily influenced by the researcher's personal
biases and idiosyncrasies. Rigor is more difficult to maintain, assess, and demonstrate.
The volume of data makes analysis and interpretation time consuming. In our research
this might be one of the limitations or difficulties when doing the research, the analysis,
and the interpretation of data happens to be quite hard. Having many answers but all of
them being kinda similar, we find it hard to interpret the data. dklfjgkdfmkd,fmvdf,vm
d,fmv dThe researcher's presence during data gathering, which is often unavoidable in
qualitative research, can affect the subjects' responses. Findings can be more difficult and
global pandemic, which means we are not able to go outside as we usually did before.
With this research, we needed to make questionnaires, but we were not able to face the
9
participants. The result of this was the making of an online instrument, and the limitation
was the lack of responses at the beginning, eventually it increased but it was difficult to
approaches typically focus on the lives of individuals as told through their own stories
narrative research:
or descriptions of a series of events. These researchers usually embrace the assumption that
the story is one if not the fundamental unit that accounts for human experience. But what
counts as stories, the kinds of stories they choose to study, or the methods they use for
study vary
In this research we decided to use this method since it goes according to what
we want to find. Experiences and stories from people who have been through the problem
we are exposing.
10
POPULATION OF SAMPLE
The population were the FFYL teachers at UANL, however, we decided to
work the sample with 15 teachers; also the Maximal Variation Sampling was used, as the
population has different perspectives about the classes online in this recent pandemic.
Demographic information
Male 7 53,8%
Female 6 46,2%
30-35 2 14%
36-40 4 29%
41-45 0 0%
46-50 6 43%
51+ 2 14%
9- 1 8%
10-20 6 46%
21-30 5 38%
11
30+ 1 8%
Masters 9 69%
Ph. d 4 31%
INSTRUMENT
The research instrument we decided to use is a questionnaire; is a research
instrument that consists of a set of questions or other types of prompts that aims to collect
information from a respondent. The main characteristic of this instrument is the open
question. There are 8 open questions, where we ask about the experience teaching online.
Since we are looking for detailed answers, the questions are focused on the feelings the
teachers developed during the pandemic, their difficulties and their improvements right
We choose this instrument since we are taking a narrative approach, we are
looking for an anecdote-like answer where the teacher can give their experiences, and share
their feelings so we can give to our research a more human point of view that takes into
teachers via WhatsApp where we asked them for their participation. Then the instrument
was made and sent to the teachers via email. We waited a couple days and since we got
12
little response, we sent it to more teachers. One of those teachers helped by sending the
questionnaire to some of her colleagues which was really helpful since this led us to get
more answers. The participants gave us detailed answers mostly, while some of them gave
shorter ones.
For this research we decided to carry out the collection of data according to
what the professors answered; first we downloaded the data in an Excel sheet so we could
transcribe the information in a word document, which means that we did not use
answers. Once we had all the information arranged, we took a look into our research
questions in order to make the categories. As a result we found 6 categories, and for each
category we had at least 3 different codes, giving us a total of 5 codes, the ones we will
CATEGORIES
1. Feelings caused by teaching during the pandemic
An emotion is a natural instinctive state of mind deriving from one's circumstances,
mood, or relationships with others. With this category it was intended to find the emotions
teachers went through while teaching online since the pandemic demanded it. Among the
answers, we were able to find 4 codes that were positive and negative, as well as two main
feelings that were stress and depression. The following is the graphic representation of the
13
CATEGORIES CODES
Stress 10
Depressed
As it is presented in the table, we can deduce that stress was the most common
feeling among the teachers while teaching online, since they had to adapt to a new
modality, they began to feel the stress, as participant 7 said “When I was told about
teaching online I felt overwhelmed because there were many things I had to learn and
This shows how at the beginning of the pandemic the teachers did not know what to
expect, which led to the early development of stress. It is noticeable how most of the
participants were expectants of the modality, some of them did not feel prepared, just as
participant 4 said “At the beginning I felt uncomfortable and not really prepared to deal
with it”. Another thing we can notice here, is how almost all the answers were negative, all
for the drastic change they all had, participant 8 mentioned “I was scared about it. I don't
like using computers at all so I AM not good at working with them.” We know that all of
the feelings that the teachers developed during their online teaching experience, are some of
the burnout syndrome symptoms, and that they clearly might not be aware of it.
14
2. Effects of online teaching
We know that as well as students, teachers have changed in its entirety the way of
living they used to have. The category we used for this situation is the effects of online
teaching; Here, we are aiming to know what were the repercussions this modality brought
up for the educators, within the responses, we came across two main codes, professional
life and personal life, the next table shows the representation of those codes and the
Personal: 4
profession: 7
With the answers gathered, the most mentioned aspect of change in teachers' life
because of the pandemic is professional life. Along with this, we found that the most
mentioned subcode was work, which gives us an idea of the struggle teachers have while
teaching.
Time was one of the aspects mentioned before, having to teach online meant a new
challenging, as well as the teachers, students were having also problems, which became a
struggle in their work, as participant 1 said, “It was time consuming: preparing classes,
checking classes, talking to students who were having problems” it is noticeable how small
aspects such as students having difficulties to get in class, were becoming a challenge for
the educators, as well as this, the personal area was also present, having to work online,
they would have to take care of their families and obviously, this cause more work and
15
exhaustion, as participant 7 said, “I think that online teaching has caused me to feel more
tired, I would say even exhausted. I sometimes feel stressed and even demotivated”
In this category we found another code, which led us to know more about the
experience teachers had; We found that some teachers got positive effects while teaching
online, as an example we have the participant 8 said, “ I feel very proud of myself. I think I
can do things I believed I could not. As a person, this situation helped me become more
empathic and patient.” but not only this kind of feeling and effects were showing, there
were some teachers who got mixed feelings and at the beginning, and then realize how
much they could improve, participant 6 gave an example on this, “Online teaching made
also realize that I can improve myself on different aspects, because if I was able to carry
out my profession as teacher on this situation (facing new challenges) I might be able to
face with different and/or problematic situations that I may face on my personal life.
All the answers were clear on the message, the teachers were going through rough
moments lately, having to deal with their work and also having to take care of their
personal lives, we can tell it was not easy. On the other hand; Some teachers found the way
and realized how things were getting better, and eventually, their experiences became more
enjoyable.
16
3. Experiences while teaching online
In this category the main focus is on how teachers coped with the drastic change,
regarding their working hours, the relation between teachers and students and
technological issues. Our main codes were Technology, workload, students and family; we
also found three pairs of sucodes, which came from the use of digital platforms, to cope
*Students: 30 computer: 14
*Family: 2 Family: 1
Death: 1
Students: 30
As it is seen on the table, the participants came across different obstacles when
teaching through a computer, we can see that the main code was students. This pandemic
has changed the whole game for all of us, students and teachers are facing a variety of
struggles, ones that we never had before our participants expressed their experiences and
how the students were one of the most difficult aspect to face, as an example, participant 4
said, “dealing with students lack of motivation even when providing them with options and
activities that i thought would be attractive for them” Sometimes is hard to control or to
17
makes students work inside the classroom, now we know how this has become more
difficult. Moreover; some teachers said how they needed to step on the students' shoes,
knowing how they were going through the same changes. About this, participant 6 said, “I
guess it relates to understanding students' feelings, situations and problems on this online
process.”
The second most used code was technology, and as we said before, this an
important point, since the main source of work right now is the internet, many teachers had
to deal with the issues this comes with, for example, participant 8 said, “When I had
problems with the internet I had to ask My neighbors to stay out of her house to use Hers
Paying attention to all of these responses and all of the aspects teachers were going
through, we know how hard it must be for them, dealing with not only their issues, but also
the students' issues. the technological problems, something that goes out of their hands but
As from one day to another, the teachers' modality of work changed, they faced
some difficulties while the pandemic continued and with them their feelings changed a lot.
Not just to some negative feelings but some teachers might feel positive during the
pandemic.
The most common was the negative statement, some teachers felt a little
18
Feelings caused by the * Positive: 1 Scared: 3
pandemic
*Negative: 7 Optimistic: 1
Overwhelmness: 3
Anxiety: 1
While reviewing the statements we found out that there could be some teachers that
felt optimistics at first and after their first encounter with the pandemic and the new
modality, now they might feel different. As the Participant 7 said “At first I was
enthusiastic and felt safe at home”. Another feeling we noticed on them is the anxiety, not
all the teachers mentioned feeling anxious about the pandemic, but we cannot rule out this
pandemic”.
With the new modality, we could encounter many different problems, moments and
issues, such as personal and professional; on the responses we found out that teachers had
most of the issues with the clases and many of the times it is related to the Teams app and
the internet; as Participant 6 said “was having internet issues or TEAMS failure that made
it difficult to be in class.”, it is very common to have so many problems at once and for
19
Professional: 38
Team issues: 7
Internet issues:9
Teaching problems: 7
Another issue some teachers might have is while preparing the lesson plan for the
classes, they’re not used to use the online resources and this caused some difficulties on
some teachers, as Participant 6 also mentions “I had some problems when using online
6. Teachers development
In this category the focus is on how teachers' challenges and difficulties could
provoke a learning process to the teachers' way of adapting to the new teaching modality in
the pandemic. This learning process caused a development on the teachers, some of this
● organization
● found benefits
As a teacher: 5 Overcome: 5
20
Improvement: 4
The different participants explain how this pandemic and online teaching situation
help some of them in some way to improve in different parts of themself or in their
professional life like the Participant 4 said: I have become more skillful and now i am a lot
better than before” different participants said that overcoming the problems the new
modality help them not feel so much frustration, regardless all of the development the stress
There was a lot of improvement in part of the different experiences from the
teachers, which make them feel somewhat better with themself, but like the Veninga and
Spradley's (1981) steps of the burnout syndrome, this might be just part of the balancing
step, because some of them still felt a high sense of frustration towards their technological
issues.
Categories Codes
Depressed: 1
Anxiety: 2
Sad: 3
21
Positive 3
Tired: 4
Frustration: 3
hardness: 4
Personal: 4
profession: 7
*Students: 30 computer: 14
*Family: 2 Family: 1
Death: 1
Students: 30
Overwhelmness: 3
Anxiety: 1
22
Professional: 38
Team issues: 7
Internet issues:9
Teaching problems: 7
As a teacher: 5 Overcome: 5
Ya esta en proceso
CONECTADA) falta
FINDINGS
Taking into consideration the answer that the research population provided to the
questions: “What are FFYL teachers' feelings towards their profession during the new
teaching modality?” “How does the new teaching modality have affected FFYL teachers'
professional life and responsibilities?” “How the recent Pandemic has caused exhaustion
and burnout syndrome in teachers?” with some of the answers we were able to realize
about the many different circumstances where the professors developed the symptoms of
23
the burnout syndrome towards their job and their personal life, such as depression, stress,
With the answers provided by the participants we can resolve the questions; “How does the
new teaching modality have affected FFYL teachers' professional life and
responsibilities?” “How has the recent Pandemic caused exhaustion and burnout
syndrome in teachers? Most of these answers provide the major causes of the burnout
syndrome symptoms; the pandemic and the technological issues as the professors
The results show that “What are FFYL teachers' feelings towards their profession during
the new teaching modality?” are mostly negative, but there are some positive feelings.
Veninga and Spradley's (1981) stages of the burnout syndrome, call the balancing step as
opposed to the unbridled optimism and positiveness of the honeymoon stage, they now are
clearly aware that some days are better than others regarding how well they are handling
the stress on the job. Most of the positive emotions of the teachers appear to be
accompanied by negative emotions, which shows how some of the teachers are in the
balancing stage and entering the chronic stress stage as some of them said to be depressed
and anxious. And some of the teachers appear to be have the crisis stage symptoms as they
24
This second question can go hand in hand with the question “What are FFYL teachers'
CONCLUSION
This qualitative narrative research, based on the handbook narrative inquiry (2007),
was an intent to make awareness about mental health and the effects of burnout syndrome
in the recent pandemic, affects teachers and their performance in their work.
With the recent pandemic and these new modality there were limitations on reaching some
of the professors, so we concluded that a questionnaire sent to the teachers was the most
Furthermore, with the results obtained, we could correlate most of the teachers are going
through the different Veninga and Spradley's (1981) steps of the burnout syndrome, some
of the professors appeared to be between the crisis and the balancing step, where some of
them appear to be positive , but still appearing to be stressed and frustrated, and others
appeared to have physical illness manifested like headaches and anxiety symptoms of the
crisis step.
So we can conclude that the adaptation of these new teaching modality in a pandemic can
have a negative toll on the professors; so the teachers should be aware of their mental
health in these complicated times. And if a professor feels any symptoms of burnout
syndrome, they should seek professional help. A further investigation, taking basis on the
25
results obtained, could be in the preventive methods of burnout syndrome, or could be a
REFERENCES
Creswell, J. W., & Poth, C. N. (2016). Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing
Among Five Approaches (English Edition) (4.a ed.). SAGE Publications, Inc.
Gastaldi, Francesca Giovanna Maria, & Pasta, Tiziana, & Longobardi, Claudio, & Prino,
Laura Elvira, & Quaglia, Rocco (2014). Measuring the influence of stress and
26
burnout in teacher-child relationship. European Journal of Education and
Psychology, 7(1),17-28
Sclafani, C. (2017). A Case Study Primer: Origins and Basic Principles. Global Journal Of
Stake, R. (1995). The art of case study research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Veninga, R L and Spradley, J P (1981). The Work Stress Connection: How to Cope with
the Burnout?, Boston: Little Brown and Company.
APPENDICES
Appendix 1. Instrument
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1-dG9HJtqk_BZdm_2BMHMPwJxL8ilmkTOJ1heeAdy-
3Y/edit#responses
27
Appendix 4. Demographic information graphs
28
29