Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HARA Report NACL Unit 2 Ethakota Year 2020
HARA Report NACL Unit 2 Ethakota Year 2020
FOR
EXISTING PRODUCTS
OCTOBER, 2020
Of
NACL INDUSTRIES LTD.
UNIT-II
Andhra Pradesh
Prepared by
Dr. Sudhir Kumar Mittal
EHS & FIRE SAFETY CONSULTANT
E mail: mittalsr@rediffmail.com , mittalsr56@gmail.com
Mobile: 9703211130
EXISTING PRODUCTS
OCTOBER, 2020
INDEX
Section. No. CONTENTS Page No.
PREAMBLE 4
1.0 INTRODUCTION 5-6
2.0 NEED FOR HARA 6-7
3.0 OBJECTIVES OF HARA STUDY 7-8
4.0 SCOPE OF HARA STUDY 8
5.0 METHODOLOGY OF HARA STUDY 8
6.0 ABOUT THE SITE ,SURROUNDING & PLANT FACILITIES 8-15
7.0 LIST OF PRODUCTS FOR HARA STUDIES 15-18
8.0 PROCESS DESCRIPTION & PROCESS FLOW CHART OF EACH PRODUCT 19-24
9.0 LIST OF HAZARDOUS RAW MATERIALS FOR EXISTING HARA PRODUCTS 25-34
10.0 HAZARD ANALYSIS 35-80
10.1 HAZARD 35
10.2 HAZARD ANALYSIS DEFINITION 35
10.3 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION 35-
10.3.1 HAZARDS RELATED TO UNIT OPERATIONS 37-38
10.3.2 HEALTH HAZRDS, FIRE & EXPLOSION HAZARDS, REACTIVITY & STABILITY 38-78
HAZARDS AND TOXICITY HAZARDS OF MATERIALS
10.3.3 CHEMICAL STORAGE HAZARDS 78
10.3.4 EQUIPMENT RELATED HAZARDS 79
10.3.5 OTHER HAZARDS 79-80
11.0 CONTAINMENT FAILURE HAZARDS 80-81
12.0 EXISTENCE OF MORE THAN ONE TYPE OF HAZARD AT A TIME 81
13.0 RISK ASSESSMENT 81-90
13.1 RISK 81
13.2 RISK ASSESSMENT DEFINITION 81-82
13.3 TERMS USED IN RISK ASSESSMENT 82
13.4 FIRE & EXPLOSION INDEX (FEI) 83-
13.4.5 FIRE & EXPLOSION INDEX FOR CIX SOLVENT & CYCLOHEXANE IN TANKS 86-87
13.4.6 FIRE & EXPLOSION INDEX FOR PROPOSED LPG LOT SYSTEM 87-88
13.4.7 MAXIMUM CREDIBLE ACCIDENT ANALYSIS 88
13.4.8 FAILURE MODES ANALYSIS 89
13.4.9 PROBABILITY OF FAILIURE 89-90
14.0 CONSEQUENCES ANALYSIS 91-92
14.1 FIRE CONSEQUENCES 91
14.2 FIRE ACCIDENTS ANALYSIS 92
15.0 TOXICITY ANALYSIS 93-96
16.0 QUALITATIVE IMPACT ANALYSIS WITH DOMINO EFFECT & RISK 97-103
MINIMISATION CONTROLS FOR EXISTING & PROPOSED LPG LOTSYSTEM
17.0 EXISTING SAFETY MEASURES & PROPOSED SAFETY MEASURES FOR 104-113
MITIGATION OF IDENTIFIED HAZARDS BY THE MANAGEMENT
18.0 RECOMMENDED SAFETY MEASURES TO REDUCE CONSEQUENCES OF RISK 114
OR REDUCE OR MINIMISE HAZARDS
19.0 CONCLUSIONS 114
20.0 DISCLAIMER 115
21.0 ANNEXURE-1:Site Lay out drawing 116
ANNEXURE-2:Fire Hydrant lay out drawing 117
PREAMBLE
This HARA study for Products & the NACL-Unit-II site was conducted by Dr. Sudhirkumar Mittal-
EHS & Fire Safety Consultant as entrusted by the Management in October, 2020 and report is
prepared after evaluation of the following aspects:
Study of the manufacturing process of the existing HARA products & proposed LPG LOT
system for HARA Study
Production facilities and equipment earmarked in each production block
Safety equipment integrated to the reactors & other relevant equipment
Hazardous properties of the chemicals used in the reaction
Safety protocols developed to assess the degree of hazards associated with manufacturing
activity
Mitigation measures under practice and those proposed to be followed to assess the inherent
hazards and their mitigation level etc.
As an outcome of the HARA study, besides the existing safe practices followed, few more practices
are recommended to take up as appropriate.
The consultant sincerely thanks for the co-operation received from the Site EHS In-Charge during the
evaluation of the existing & proposed systems.
The statement of facts was made almost based on the details furnished by the Management.
Omissions and misinterpretations expressed in this report, if any are purely inadvertent and un-
intentional.
1.0 INTRODUCTION
M/s NACL Industries Limited, Unit-II is located in survey No .460/1, 2, 3, 4& 5 at D.NO-4-208,
Ethakota village, Near Ganti check post, Ravulapalem Mandal in East Godavari district of Andhra
Pradesh. The plant covers an area of 14.385 Acers and the plant is surrounded by Agricultural fields.
The industry is 9 km away from Ravulapalem. NACL-Unit-II is engaged in manufacturing of
formulation of Pesticides and Insecticides.
The organization is an ISO 9001:2015, ISO 14001:2015 & ISO 45001:2018 Certified Company.
NACL-Unit-II is manufacturing of Formulation of all categories of Pesticides such as Insecticides,
Herbicides, Fungicides, and Nematicides.
The Plant has modern Formulation and Packing Facilities for handling large capacities of Liquids,
Powders and Granules. It specializes in various formulations in the form of:
Liquids - EC/SL/SC/PGR
Powders - CG/SG/PRILLS/WDG
Granules - WP/SP
The main process in the manufacture of various types of Pesticide Formulations are Mixing of technical grade
pesticide with inert materials such as suitable solvents, emulsifiers, stabilizers and colouring agents if any,
according to pre determined formula to produce stable products to the consumers.
The Manufacturing process of liquid Pesticide formulations, Wettable Powder Formulations, and Granulated
Formulations does not involve any exo or endo thermic reactions or the process does not leave either by-products
or waste products and is essentially a dilution process.
In other words, the formulated pesticides are active pesticides technical reduced / diluted to approve
concentrations confirming to central Insecticides Board regulations.
The Liquid pesticide formulations are categorized as Emulsifiable concentrates (EC formulations) and
Suspension Concentrates (SC formulations). The Granulated Formulations are categorized as Coated Granules
(CG formulations) and Wettable Granules (Extruded Granules) (WG granules).
The organization initiated a process for carrying out a Hazard Analysis and Risk Assessment Study for the
existing products to identify possible Hazards wrt. the existing products & to evaluate risks for taking appropriate
safety measures or alternative design solutions by the Management to mitigate or control the risks or to reduce
associated risks to an acceptable level and improve reliability wrt safety of the plant operations.
Dr. Sudhir Kumar Mittal, an independent EHS & Fire Safety consultant has been appointed as the consultant for
carrying out HARA Studies of the existing products. The consultant visited the plant, discussed with concerned
Head of Departments and prepared this study report based on the information provided by the Company,
regarding the manufacturing process, reaction conditions, existing safety measures etc. The study reflects the
logical analysis based on the information provided by the organization only.
Dr. Sudhir Kumar Mittal discussed with the Site EHS In-Charge and prepared this study report based on
the information provided regarding the manufacturing process, reaction conditions, the existing safety
measures etc. The HARA study reflects the logical analysis based on the information provided by the
organization only. Site EHS In-Charge participated in the discussion for identification of the Process
Hazards. Production, Safety & Process/Production support was also taken in reviewing the design
safety issues.
Hazard Analysis and Risk Assessment (HARA) is carried out to identify hazardous chemicals,
Hazardous Operations in the process & storage and quantifying the hazards and consequences by
qualitative methods only.
As per the rules 10 to 13 under Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemicals
(MSIHC) Rules, 1989 as amended in year 2000, made under Environment (Protection) Act,
1986, the Occupier of the industry using hazardous chemicals in its manufacturing activity is
obliged to submit report on Hazard Analysis and Risk Assessment to the authorities.
Gas Cylinders
S.No. Name of Gas Cylinders Nos. of Gas Cylinders Usage Area
1 Hydrogen 2 QC Lab
2 Oxygen 6 QC Lab
3 Nitrogen 6 QC Lab
4 Acetylene 1 Work shop
5 Oxygen (commercial) 1 Work shop
The industry shall manufacture only 8 products from the particular stream not exceeding their total
capacity and shall not manufacture the products banned by Government of India.
01 LIQUID FORMULATION
1. Quinalpas
2. Monocrotopos 36%SL
3. Dichlorvos 76%EC
4. Chlorpyriphos 20 % EC
5. Alphamethrin 10% EC
6. Lambda Cyhalothrin 2.5 % EC
7. Profenofos 50% EC
8. Pretilachlor 50 % EC
9. Propiconazole 25 % EC
02 POWDER FORMULATION
1. Acephate 75 % SP
2. Carbendazim 50%WP
3. Cartap Hydrochloride 50%SP
4. Atrizine 50 % WP
5. Thiophanate methyl 70%WP
6. Tricyclazole 75 % WP
7. Validamycin 3% L
8. Myclobutanil 10 % WP
9. Acetamiprid 20% SP
03 GRANULES FORMULATION
1. Carbofuran 3%CG
2. Cartaphydrochloride 4%GR
3. Acephate 90% Prills
4. Emamectin Benzoate 5% SG
5. Glyphosate 71% SG
6. Imidacloprid 70% WG
7. Metsulfuron Methyl 20% WG
8. Thiamethoxam 25% WG
9. Fipronil 0.3 % Gr
At present, 38 products are being manufactured on regular basis. 18 Products are procured
in bulk and then filling of bulk technical is done in small sizes packs as per the market
requirements.
37 products are not being formulated due to poor market demands.
The above data about the products covers all 92 products.
8.0 PROCESS DESCRIPTION & PROCESS FLOW CHART FOR EACH PRODUCT
Note: The above mentioned process shall be applicable for all Powder formulations, only technical,
Raw Materials, will change
Note: The above mentioned process shall be applicable for all Granule formulations, only technical,
Raw Materials, will change
9.21 Carbofuran 3% CG
S. No. Hazardous Raw Materials/ Chemicals/Solvent
1 Methyl Violet
2 Sand
3 Calcium Carbonate
4 Sugar
5 PVA Gum
6 Carbofuran Technical
7 IGSurf 2754
9.24 Validamycin 3% L
S. No. Hazardous Raw Materials/ Chemicals/Solvent
1 Sulphuric Acid SQ
2 Acid Brill Green
3 D.M.Water
4 Methanol
5 Potassium Sorbate
6 IGSurf 2008 E
7 Validamycin Technical
8 Atlox 3772
4 Solvent C-IX
3 P5G
4 Spray Dried Silica
5 FORMALDEHYDE
6 Atlox 3772
7 Rodopol 23
9 D.M.Water
Bulk quantity Techical Products are subjected to filling operation in small pack sizes as per the
market requiremnts.
Hazards related to all Technical materials involved in 92 products manufacturing have been
considered in section No.10.0
Risk is defined as the product of the frequency (probability, likelihood) of an event occurring and its
consequence (severity, impact, injury/fatality rate). Risk assessment is often an iterative process that
involves the major steps:
1. Define a worst case scenario (WCS) in terms of its likelihood and consequence
2. Develop line of defense appropriate to the risk
3. Evaluate the risk reduction/elimination afforded by the line(s) of defense
4. Decide if risk reduction is sufficient and complete the project if sufficient
5. Decide if additional risk reduction can be achieved
6. Decide to not perform the process if further risk reduction is not feasible
This process of hazard identification and risk assessment is designed to reduce risk to an acceptable
level. Achieving the required level of risk reduction completes the review process. Alternatively, if
the risk cannot be reduced using the available resources the process should be terminated.
fact the characteristic of system/plant/storage that presents potential for an accident. Hence,
all the components of system/plant / process need to be thoroughly examined to assess
their potential for initiating or propagating an unplanned event/sequence of events which can
be termed as an accident.
Typical schemes of predictive hazard evaluation and quantitative risk analysis suggest that hazard
identification step plays a key role. Estimation of probability of an unexpected event and its
consequences form the basis of quantification of risk in terms of damage to property, environment
or personnel. Therefore, the type, quantity, location and conditions of release of a toxic or
flammable substance have to be identified in order to estimate its damaging effects, the area
involved, and the possible precautionary measures required to be taken.
Some of the hazard identification procedures are as follows:
a. Fire Explosion and Toxicity Index (FETI) Approach
b. HAZOP studies
c. Maximum Credible Accident and Consequence Analysis (MCACA)
d. Classification of Major Hazard Substances
e. Manufacture Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989(GOI Rules, 1989)
f. Identification of Major Hazardous Units.
The Hazard identification process adopted is to interpret the chemical storage Manufacture
Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989 (GOI Rules, 1989) for the storage of
chemicals in this unit.
Preliminary Hazard Identification is used to identify typical and often relatively apparent hazards
and damage events in a system.
Hazard of significant nature whose consequence potential is of worth consideration and wherein a
specified area or where more number of personnel likely to be present etc., are considered in
identifying the hazards.
10.3.2 Health Hazards, Fire & Explosion Hazards. Reactivity & stability hazards and
Toxicity Hazards of Materials
A consolidated list of hazardous/toxic chemicals & Technical materials is prepared based on the
raw materials list for each product as mentioned in Section No.9 of this report.
28 Epichlorohydrin
29 Fipronil Technical
30 Formaldehyde
31 Gibberellic Acid Technical
32 Glyphosate Technical and 36 % SL& 41% SL
33 Hexaconazole Technical
34 Hydrochloric Acid 36% DM Grade
35 Indoxacarb Technical
36 Imidacloprid Technical & Imidacloprid 70 % WDG
37 Lambda-Cyhalothrin Technical
38 Lufenuron
39 Malathion Technical
40 Mancozeb Technical
41 Metalaxyl Technical
42 Metsulfuron Methyl Technical
43 Methanol
44 N-Methyl-2-Pyrrolidone
45 Mono Chloro Benzene
46 Monocrotophos Technical (E)
47 Myclobutanil (CCQ- ROOT)
48 Oxyflourfen 23.5% EC
49 Paraquat Dichloride 24%SL
50 Pendimethalin Technical
51 Phosphoric Acid
52 Pretilachlor Technical
53 Profenofos Technical
54 Propargite 57 % EC
55 Propiconazole Technical
56 Propylene Glycol
57 Quinalphos
58 Sodium Hypo Chlorite
59 Sodium Para-Nitrophenolate 1.8% SL
60 Sulphur 80 % WDG
61 Sulphuric Acid SQ
62 Tebuconazole 25.9% EC
63 Thiodicarb 75% WP
64 Triadimefon 25% WP
66 Thiomethoxam Technical
66 Tricyclazole Technical
67 Triazophos 40 % EC
68 Validamycin Technical
Special hazards arising from the substance or mixture carbon monoxide, Hydrogen chloride,
Hydrogen cyanide, Carbon dioxide, organochloric compounds The substances/groups of
substances mentioned can be released in case of fire.
Flash point: approx. 44 °C
Stability & Reactvity hazards:
Reactivity:No hazardous reactions if stored and handled as prescribed/indicated.
Chemical stability:The product is stable if stored and handled as prescribed/indicated.
Possibility of hazardous reactions: No hazardous reactions if stored and handled as
prescribed/indicated.
Incompatible materials Substances to avoid: strong bases, strong acids, strong oxidizing agents
Toxicity Hazards:
Acute toxicity Assessment of acute toxicity: Of high toxicity after single ingestion. Of moderate toxicity
after short-term inhalation. Virtually nontoxic after a single skin contact.
Experimental/calculated data: LD50 rat (oral): > 210 - < 1,050 mg/kg (OECD Guideline 425)
LC50 rat (by inhalation): 1.96 mg/l 4 h (OECD Guideline 403) The product has not been tested. The
statement has been derived from substances/products of a similar structure or composition.
LD50 rat (dermal): > 5,000 mg/kg (OECD Guideline 402) No mortality was observed. Irritation
Assessment of irritating effects: May cause severe damage to the eyes. Skin contact causes irritation
Toxicity Hazards:
Acute Toxicity/Irritation Studies (Finished Product)
Reproductive/Developmental Effects
Ingestion: Oral (LD50 Female Rat): 3129 mg/kg body weight
Dermal: Dermal (LD50 Rabbit) :> 5050 mg/kg body weight
Inhalation: Inhalation (LC50 Rat) : > 2.5 mg/l air - 4 hours
Eye Contact: Minimally Irritating (Rabbit)
Skin Contact: Non-Irritating (Rabbit)
Skin Sensitization: Not a Sensitizer (Guinea Pig)
Sensitization: This product produces skin sensitization (allergic reaction) in laboratory animals, and
may produce similar effects in humans.
Reactivity hazards: The substance is an alcohol. Alcohols exhibit both weak acid and weak base
behavior. They may initiate the polymerization of isocyanates and epoxides. esters through
condensation reactions. The substance may be oxidized to aldehydes and ketones.
Possibility of hazardous reactions Reacts with: Oxidizing substances, Strong acids. Reacts with
ethylene carbonate to form butyl cellosolve (highly toxic). Reacts with nitrous acid to form butyl
nitrite (toxic). Reacts with ammonia to produce toxic Butyl amine. 10.4. Conditions to avoid Keep
away from heat, sparks, flame and other sources of ignition (i.e., pilot lights, electric motors and
static electricity). 10.5. Incompatible materials Strong oxidizing agents. Attacks plastic and rubber
Fire Hazards: Purple granules with a slightly phenolic odor. Slightly combustible. May support
combustion at elevated temperatures. Degrades at temperatures above 130℃. Thermal decomposition
and burning may form toxic by-products.
Reactivity Hazards: Conditions/Materials to Avoid (Incompatibility): Excessive heat and fire.
Toxicity Hazards: Rat Acute Oral: LD50 = 167 mg/kg Rabbit Acute Dermal: LD50 > 2000 mg/kg
Rat Acute Inhalation: LC50 = 1.18 mg/L/4 hr Reproductive effects: Consuming high doses over long
periods of time caused damage to testes in dogs, but carbofuran did not have any reproductive effects
on rats or mice. Available studies indicate carbofuran is unlikely to cause reproductive effects in
humans at expected exposure levels.
Chronic toxicity: Repeated or prolonged exposure to organophosphates may result in the same
effects as acute exposure including the delayed symptoms.
Fire Hazards: If involves in fire, oxides of copper, hydrogen chloride may be produced.
Reactivity Hazards: Strong Acids.
Toxicity Hazards: Oral LD50 (Rat): 700 – 800 mg/kg.Dermal LD50 (Rat): > 2000 mg/kg,
Inhalation LC50 (Rat): > 30 (4h) mg/L
10.3.2.17 Cypermethrin
MajorHealthHazards:The onset of symptoms varies depending upon such factors as the route of
absorption and quantity involved. Inpatients with occupational poisoning, skin symptoms. Usually
develop within 4-6 hours after exposure, with systemic symptoms occurring as late as 48 Hours after
exposure. Paraesthesia of the facial skin can develop approximately 30minutes after Exposure and
does not usually last beyond 24hours when exposure is terminated. Following ingestion, the initial
symptoms involve the gastrointestinal tract, developing 10-60 minutes after exposure. Patients
suffering from acute oral poisoning usually develop prominent digestive symptoms such as epigastric
pain, nausea and vomiting.
Fire Hazards: The substance decomposes on heating above 220℃, producing toxic fumes including
hydrogen cyanide, hydrogen chloride.
Reactivity Hazards: Conditions to avoid: avoid high temperature and flame; Products to avoid:
alkaline pesticides; Thermal decomposition: 150~300℃; Hazardous decomposition products:
hydrogen cyanide, hydrogen chloride.
Toxicity Hazards: Acute oral LD50: rat 250-4150mg/kg Acute dermal LD50: rat >4920mg/kg
Contact with the skin: slight irritation to skin of rabbit; Contact with the eyes: slight irritation to eyes
of rabbit;
Carcinogenic effects: EPA has classified cypermethrin as a possible human carcinogen because
available information is inconclusive. It caused benign lung tumors in female mice at the highest dose
tested (229 mg/kg/day); however, no tumors occurred in rats given high doses of up to 75 mg/kg/day.
10.3.2.19 Cyfluthrin 5% EW
Health hazards: Fatal if swallowed.Toxic if inhaled.Very toxic to aquatic life.Very toxic to aquatic
life with long lasting effects.
ACGIH TLV: CEIL: 5 mg/m3 (salts)
Fire Hazards: No data available
Hazardous Decomposition or Byproducts: carbon dioxide carbon monoxide hydrogen cyanide
hyddrogen fluoride nitrogen oxides phosgene
Toxicity Hazards: No data available
10.3.2.20 Cyclohexanone
Health Hazards: Inhalation: OEL: 1000 ppm, may cause Narcosis and dealth. Exposure above 80
ppm is already irritating for eyes, throat and respiratory tract.
Ingestion: Gastrointestinal tract irritation. Can be fatal if ingested from 10ml or more.
Skin contact: Moderate irritation and discomfort possible. Defatting of skin, redness and chemical
dermatitis possible. Toxic systemic effects from absorption are possible.
Eye Contact: Severe irritation and discomfort. Reversible and/or irreversible corneal damage may
occur.
Fire Hazards: Auto-Ignition Temperature: 420°C (788°F) Flash Points: CLOSED CUP: 43.889°C
(111°F). OPEN CUP: 46°C (114.8°F). Flammable Limits: LOWER: 1.1% UPPER: 9.4% Products of
Combustion: These products are carbon oxides (CO, CO2).
Fire Hazards in Presence of Various Substances: Flammable in presence of open flames and sparks,
of heat
Reactivity Hazards: Conditions of Instability: Heat, ignition sources, incompatible materials
Incompatibility with various substances: Reactive with oxidizing agents, acids, alkalis.
Special Remarks on Reactivity: Incompatible with amines, nitric acid and other strong acids,
strongt alkalies (bases) such as sodium hydroxide or potassium hydroxide, strong oxidizing agents
Fire Hazards: Hazards from combustion products: Heating/combustion will generate oxides of
carbon and nitrogen, and other irritant and toxic fumes.
Reactivity Hazards: Incompatibility: Incompatible with acids, alkalies, strong oxidising agents.
Conditions to avoid: Extreme heat
Toxicological Information:
Acute:Oral toxicity: LD50 rat: 1965 mg/kg, Dermal toxicity: LD50 rat: > 2000 mg/kg
Inhalation toxicity: N/A, Skin irritation: Not irritating – rabbit
Eye irritation: Irritating – rabbit, Sensitisation: Not sensitising - guinea pig
Reproductive Effects: A reproductive 3-generation study in rats reported a reproductive NOEL to be
greater than 2.5 mg/kg/day. Levels tested were 0, 0.1, 1.0 and 2.5 mg/kg/day.
Oral administration of deltamethrin to mice on days 7 to 16 of gestation produced a dosage-related
reduction of weight gain but no effect on the number of implants, fetal mortality, fetal weight or
malformations.
10.3.2.23 Dichlorvos
Warning Statements: This product is an organophosphate (cholinesterase- inhibiting) insecticide.
Reactivity Hazards: Incompatibility: Strong oxidizers, acids, bases.
Conditions to Avoid: Extreme heat, sparks and open flame.
Hazardous Decomposition Products: CO2, CO, NOx, phosphorus containing compounds and other
unknown hazardous material may be formed in a fire situation. Incomplete combustion may lead to
formation of carbon monoxide and/or other asphyxiants.
Toxicity Hazards:
Acute Oral LD50 (rat): (Dichlorvos (DDVP) technical) 56 mg/kg
Eye Irritation (rabbit): May cause eye irritation.
Inhalation LC50 (rat): 140mg/m3 (whole body, mist).
Acute Dermal LD 50 (rabbit): (Dichlorvos Technical): 205 mg/kg
Skin Irritation (rabbit): Caused mild irritation.
Ingestion: May cause stomach distress, nausea or vomiting.
Mutagenic effects: Dichlorvos can bind to molecules such as DNA. For this reason, there has been
extensive testing of dichlorvos for mutagenicity. Several studies have shown dichlorvos to be a
mutagen; for example, dichlorvos is reported positive in the Ames mutagenicity assay and in other
tests involving bacterial or animal cell cultures. However, no evidence of mutagenicity has been
found in tests performed on live animals. Its lack of mutagenicity in live animals may be due to rapid
metabolism and excretion. Organ toxicity: Dichlorvos primarily affects the nervous system through
cholinesterase inhibition, the blockage of an enzyme required for proper nerve functioning.
10.3.2.24 Difenoconozole
Symptoms of Acute Exposure: May cause eye irritation.
Hazardous Decomposition Products: Can decompose at high temperatures forming toxic gases.
Unusual Fire, Explosion and Reactivity Hazards: During a fire, irritating and possibly toxic gases
may be generated by thermal decomposition or combustion.
incompatible materials, ignition sources, excess heat, temperatures above 55 Deg C Acids, oxidizers,
halogenated materials, nitrates, chloroformates, reducing agents, chlorine, bromine, potassium
permanganate
Stability: Stable under ordinary conditions of use and storage.
Hazardous Decomposition Products: May form ammonia, carbon oxides, amines, and nitrogen
oxides when heated to decomposition. Above 350 Deg C, DMF begins to degrade with formation of
Dimethyl amine and carbon monoxide.
Incompatibilities: Bromine, carbon tetrachloride, chromic anhydride, 2,5-dimethylpyrrole,
Phosphorus Oxychloride, Hexa chloro benzene, magnesium nitrate, Methylene diisocyanate,
phosphorus trioxide, Triethyl aluminum, organic nitrates, acidic and alkaline materials, and other
halogenated compounds. Contact with iron or
strong oxidizers may cause fires and explosions; may react violently with alkyl aluminums.
Methylene diisocyanate can polymerize violently on contact with DMF.
Conditions to Avoid: Heat, flames, ignition sources and incompatibles.
10.3.2.28 Epichlorohydrin
Health Hazards:
Acute Health Hazards: Hazardous in case of skin contact (irritant), of eye contact (irritant), of
ingestion, of inhalation (lung irritant). Corrosive to skin and eyes on contact. Liquid or spray mist
may produce tissue damage particularly on mucous membranes of eyes, mouth and respiratory tract.
Skin contact may produce burns. Inhalation of the spray mist may produce severe irritation of
respiratory tract.
Potential Chronic Health Effects: CARCINOGENIC EFFECTS: Classified + (PROVEN) by OSHA+
(PROVEN) by NIOSH. Classified A3 (Proven for animal.) by ACGIH. Classified 2A (Probable for
human.) by IARC, 2 (Reasonably anticipated.) by NTP. MUTAGENIC EFFECTS: Classified
POSSIBLE for human.
The substance is toxic to kidneys, lungs, liver, skin.
Exposure Limits: United States: TWA: 0.5 (ppm) from ACGIH (TLV) SKIN United States: TWA:
0.5 (ppm) from OSHA (PEL)
10.3.2.30 Formaldehyde
Potential Health Effects:
The perception of formaldehyde by odor and eye irritation becomes less sensitive with time as one
adapts to formaldehyde. This can lead to overexposure if a worker is relying on formaldehyde's
warning properties to alert him or her to the potential for exposure.
Inhalation: May cause sore throat, coughing, and shortness of breath. Causes irritation and
sensitization of the respiratory tract. Concentrations of 25 to 30 ppm cause severe respiratory tract
injury leading to pulmonary edema and pneumonitis.
Ingestion: Can cause severe abdominal pain, violent vomiting, headache, and diarrhea. Larger doses
may produce decreased body temperature, pain in the digestive tract, shallow respiration, weak
irregular pulse, unconsciousness and death. Methanol component affects the optic nerve and may
cause blindness.
Skin Contact: Toxic. May cause irritation to skin with redness, pain, and possibly burns. Skin
absorption may occur with symptoms paralleling those from ingestion. Formaldehyde is a severe skin
irritant and sensitizer. Contact causes white discoloration, smarting, cracking and scaling.
Eye Contact: Vapors cause irritation to the eyes with redness, pain, and blurred vision. Higher
concentrations or splashes may cause irreversible eye damage.
Chronic Exposure: Frequent or prolonged exposure to formaldehyde may cause hypersensitivity
leading to contact dermatitis. Repeated or prolonged skin contact with formaldehyde may cause an
allergic reaction in some people. Vision impairment and enlargement of liver may occur from
methanol component. Formaldehyde is a suspected carcinogen (positive animal inhalation studies).
Fire Hazards: Flash point: 60 Deg C , Auto-ignition temperature: 300 Deg C
Flammable limits in air % by volume: LEL: 7.0; UEL: 73
Flammable liquid and vapor! Gas vaporizes readily from solution and is flammable in air.
Explosion: Above flash point, vapor-air mixtures are explosive within flammable limits noted above.
Containers may explode when involved in a fire.
ACGIH Threshold Limit Value (TLV):0.3 ppm Ceiling formaldehyde, Sensitizer, A2 Suspected
Human Carcinogen 200 ppm (TWA) 250 ppm (STEL) skin for methanol
Reactivity Hazards:
Stability: Stable under ordinary conditions of use and storage.
Hazardous Decomposition Products: May form carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, and
formaldehyde when heated to decomposition.
Hazardous Polymerization: Trioxymethylene precipitate can be formed on long standing at very
low temperatures. Nonhazardous
polymerization may occur at low temperatures, forming Paraformaldehyde, a white solid.
Incompatibilities: Incompatible with oxidizing agents and alkalis. Reacts explosively with nitrogen
dioxide at ca. 180 Deg C . Reacts violently with Perchloric acid, Perchloric acid-aniline mixtures, and
Nitromethane.
Reaction with hydrochloric acid may form bis-Chloromethyl ether, an OSHA regulated carcinogen.
Conditions to Avoid: Heat, flames, ignition sources and incompatibles
Potential Health Effects: Eye: Causes severe eye irritation and irreversible effects to eye tissue.
Severity depends on the amount and duration of exposure.
Skin: May be absorbed through the skin. Prolonged or repeated exposure may cause skin irritation.
Severity of the irritation depends on the amount and duration of exposure.
Ingestion: Low acute oral toxicity. May be harmful if ingested.
Inhalation: Low acute inhalation toxicity. Exposure to dust may cause irritation to the respiratory
tract.
Chronic: Long-term studies in laboratory animals indicated effects in the liver and kidneys. High
levels of exposure can cause irregular heartbeat (arrhythmia). There was no evidence of
carcinogenicity or mutagenicity in laboratory studies.
Fire Hazards: Flash Point: Not available. Flammability Limits: Not available.
Storage Hazards: Storage: Do not allow contact with metals. Keep away from sources of ignition.
This product may present a dust explosion hazard. Store in a cool, dry place. Store in a tightly closed
container.
Stability & Rectivity Hazards: Stability: Stable under normal temperatures and pressures.
Incompatibility (Material to Avoid): Strong oxidizing agents, acids, bases and metals (e. g. iron).
Hazardous decomposition or By-products: Carbon mono-oxide, carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides
and phosphor oxides.
Hazardous Polymerization: Will not occur.
Conditions to Avoid: stored at temperature 40 C or less and in a dry and ventilated place. At
elevated temperature or in wet conditions, this material may lead to cake or decomposition.
Toxicity Hazards:
Acute Oral, rat: LD50>5000mg/kg; Acute Dermal, rabbit: LD50 >2000 mg/kg;
Eye irritation: slightly irritation - corrosive to eye tissue; Skin irritation, rabbit: slight irritation;
Skin sensitization, guinea pig: not a sensitizer.
Unusual Fire and Explosion Hazards: Thermal decomposition (e.g. fire) may produce carbon
monoxide, carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides
Toxicity Hazards: Acute oral LD50 (rat): male 2189mg/kg, female 6071mg.kg
Dermal LD50 (rat): >2000mg/kg, Inhalation LC50 (4h): >5.9mg/l
Skin irritantion: no irritantion for rabbit. Eye irritantion: moderate irritantion for rabbit
Carcinogenic effects: Available evidence suggests that Hexaconazole is not carcinogenic
Toxicity Data:
Oral LD50 (male rat): 1867 mg/kg, Oral LD50 (female rat): 687 mg/kg
Dermal LD50 (rats): > 5000 mg/kg , 4 hr inhalation LC50 (rat): > 5.6 mg/L
3 3.
Exposure Standard: PEL (OSHA): 15 mg/m TWA, Total dust: 5 mg/ m TWA respirable dust
10.3.2.36 Imidacloprid Technical & Imidacloprid 70 % WDG
Fire Hazards: None
Stability and Reactivity Hazards:
Conditions to avoid: Flame, fire and high temperature.
Products to avoid: Incompatible with alkaline pesticides
Thermal decomposition: Not applicable
Hazardous decomposition products: Nitride, chloride, carbon dioxide and so on.
Toxicity Hazards: Contact with the skin: Not irritant to skin
Contact with the eyes: Not irritant to eye.
Signs and Symptoms of Poisoning: Although no account of human poisoning was found in the
literature, signs and symptoms of poisoning would be expected to be similar to 4nicotinic signs and
symptoms, including fatigue, twitching, cramps, and muscle weakness including the muscles
necessary for breathing.
Inhalation LC50 (4 h) 0.06 mg/l air (total particulate), Moderate eye irritant (rabbits).
Not skin irritant (rabbits)., Non-sensitizer (guinea pigs)
Conditions to avoid: Extreme heat and sparks. Avoid contact with iron, strong alkali and storage above 120°F.
Incompatibility with other materials: Incompatible with alkaline materials and strong oxidizers.
Toxicity Hazards: Oral: LD50 for Rats (M): 1375-5500 mg/kg.
LD50 for mice: 775-3320 mg/kg. Dermal: LD50 for Rats: > 2000 mg/kg
LD50 for Rabbits: 4100-8800 mg/kg. Inhalation: LC50 (4h) for Rats > 5.2 mg/l air.
10.3.2.43 Methanol
Health Hazards: A slight irritant to the mucous membranes. Toxic effects exerted upon nervous
system, particularly the optic nerve. Once absorbed into the body, it is very slowly eliminated.
Symptoms of overexposure may include headache, drowsiness, nausea, vomiting, blurred vision,
blindness, coma, and death. A person may get better but then worse again up to 30 hours later.
Toxic Symptoms parallel inhalation. Can intoxicate and cause blindness. Usual fatal dose: 100-125
milliliters.
Methyl alcohol is a defatting agent and may cause skin to become dry and cracked. Skin absorption
can occur; symptoms may parallel inhalation exposure. Irritant. Continued exposure may cause eye
lesions.
Marked impairment of vision has been reported. Repeated or prolonged exposure may cause skin
irritation. Aggravation of Pre-existing Conditions:
Fire & Explosion Hazards:
Hazardous Decomposition Products: May form carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, and formaldehyde
when heated to decomposition.
Chemical Hazards: Strong oxidizing agents such as nitrates, perchlorates or sulfuric acid. Will attack
some forms of plastics, rubber, and coatings. May react with metallic aluminum and generate
hydrogen gas. Heat, flames, ignition sources and incompatibles.
10.3.2.44 N-Methyl-2-Pyrrolidone
Health Hazards: Causes skin irritation Causes serious eye irritation May cause respiratory irritation
May damage the unborn child May cause damage to organs through prolonged or repeated exposure
Fire Hazards: Combustible liquids, Flash Point 91 °C, Autoignition Temperature 346 °C
Reactivity & Stability Hazards:
Reactive Hazard None known, based on information available Stability Hygroscopic. Air sensitive.
Light sensitive.
Conditions to Avoid:Incompatible products. Heat, flames and sparks. Exposure to air. Exposure to
moist air or water. Exposure to light. Keep away from open flames, hot surfaces and sources of
ignition. Incompatible Materials Strong oxidizing agents, Strong acids, Strong bases
Hazardous Decomposition Products: Carbon monoxide (CO), Carbon dioxide (CO2), Nitrogen oxides
(NOx), peroxides
Hazardous Polymerization: Hazardous polymerization does not occur.
Toxicity Hazards: Acute Toxicity: Monocrotophos is a direct acting cholinesterase inhibitor capable
of
Penetration through the skin. The dose which kills half of the test animals, the LD50, is 17-18 mg/kg
for male rats and 20 mg/kg for female rats. The LD50 for dermal exposure is 126 mg/kg for male rats,
112 mg/kg for female rats, and 354 mg/kg for rabbits. The concentration in air at which half of the
test animals die, the LC50 is 0.8 mg/l air.Monocrotophos is not irritating to skin and eyes.
10.3.2.47 Myclobutanil
Potential Health Hazards: Harmful if swallowed.Causes serious eye irritation. Suspected of
damaging fertility or the unborn child.Toxic to aquatic life with long lasting effects.
ACGIH TLV: CEIL: 5 mg/m3 (salts)
Fire Hazards: No data available
Reactivity & Stability Hazards:
Incompatibility Materials: strong oxidizing agents
Hazardous Decomposition or Byproducts: carbon dioxide carbon monoxide hydrogen chloride
nitrogen oxides
Toxicity Hazards:
Information on Toxicological Effects: The toxicological effects of this product have not been
thoroughly studied. Myclobutanil - Toxicity Data: Oral LD50 (rat): 1600 mg/kg; Oral LD50 (mouse):
1300 mg/kg;
Chronic Toxicological Effects: Myclobutanil - Investigated as an agricultural chemical, drug, and
reproductive effector
10.3.2.48 Oxyflourfen
Potential Health Hazards: May be harmful if swallowed, inhaled or absorbed through the skin. May
cause skin or eye irritation. May cause reproductive/development damage from repeated oral
exposure. May cause organ damage from repeated oral exposure at high doses. Avoid skin and eye
contact and inhalation.
Fire Hazards:Combustible liquid. Do not store or use near heat or naked flame. Will burn if ignited
Reactivity & Stability Hazards:
Eye Contact: Moderately Irritation (Rabbit), Skin Contact: Slightly Irritation (Rabit)
Skin Sensitization: Not a skin sensitizer in animal tests.
10.3.2.54 Propargite 57 % EC
Potential Health Hazards: This substance is an eye irritant, and is corrosive to eyes. Corrosive and
irritating liquid. Treat symptomatically and supportively.
Fire Hazards: Combustible liquid.
Flash point >71.4o C .Thermal decomposition products :Combustible liquid that will on burning emit
noxious vapours and oxides of carbon and sulphur.
Reactivity & Stability Hazards: Stability Stable at normal temperature and pressure. Conditionsto
avoid: Reacts with strong acids and alkalis. Stable under normal storage conditions.
Materials to avoid: High temperatures, direct sunlight, acids and alkalis.
Hazardous reactions: No dangerous reaction known under conditions of normal use.
Toxicity Hazards:
Birds:Acute oral LC50 for mallard ducks >4640 mg/kg Dietary LC50 (8 d) mallard ducks >4640
mg/kg diet bobwhite quail 3401 mg/kg diet
Fish: LC50 (96 h) for bluegill sunfish 0.081 mg/l, Rainbow trout 0.043 mg/l
Bees: LD50 (48 h) (oral): >100 µg/bee LD50 (48 h) (contact): >47.92 µg/bee
Health Hazards: Harmful or fatal if swallowed - can enter lungs and cause damage
Contact can cause eye or skin irritation.
Fire Hazards: Flash Point: 26 Deg C.
Hazardous Decomposition Products: Sulfur dioxide and trioxide
Reactivity Hazards: Conditions to avoid: Keep dry and avoid excessive heat and ignition sources.
Incomatibility: Oxidisng Agents
Toxicity Hazards:Acute Oral Toxicity:LD 50 (Oral-rat):71 mg/kg
Health Hazards: It has TLV of 1 mg/M3. Local exposure causes irritation of nose, throat and
laryngeal edema, bronchitis, pneumatis and pulmonary edema.
Toxicological Information:
Acute oral LD50, for rats 82 mg/kg. for dogs 320 mg/kg; Acute percutaneous LD50 for rats
1100mg/kg. In 2-year feeding trials rats receiving 1 ppm diet and dogs 0.3 ppm diet only direct effect
was inhibition of blood serum cholinesterase. Fish toxicity LC50 (48-h), for crucian 8.4 mg/l. ADI for
man 0.002 mg/kg body weight.
c. Failure of main storage tanks or mixing tanks or failure of level gauges, pipes etc leading to
containment failure of solvents and flammable materials
d. Gasket failures on pipe lines flanges/ pump glands leaks etc
e. Containment failure of Toxic Pesticides/Insecticides Technical caused by damaged drums or
bags etc
f. Containment failure from mixing tanks caused by failure of bottom discharge valves etc
g. Leakage of of LPG during feeding to proposed LPG Lot system & then to proposed LPG fired
Boiler which may result into a major fire.
Risk analysis (RA) provides a numerical to quantify the risk that a particular facility poses to the
public. It begins with the identification of probable potential hazardous events at an industry and
categorization as per the predetermined criteria.
Dow Chemical Company issued a guideline for hazard determination and protection. By this method
a chemical process unit is rated numerically for hazards. The numerical value used is the Fire
and Explosion Index (F&EI) which is most widely used for hazard evaluation in chemical process
industries.
The guide applies to process unit only and not to auxiliary units such as power generating
stations, plant water systems, control rooms, fired heaters, structural requirements, corrosive nature
of material handled and personal safety equipment. These are regarded as basic features that do not
vary according to the magnitude of the fire and explosion hazard involved. The guide also does not
cover the processing and handling of explosives such as dynamite, TNT etc.
General process hazard are factors that play a primary role in determining the magnitude of
loss of incident. It takes into account the nature of the reaction, ventilation of the unit, accessibility
of the unit, drainage facilities etc., special process hazards are factors that contribute primarily to the
probability of a loss incident. They consist of specific process conditions that have shown themselves
to be major causes of fire and explosion incidents. It takes into account toxicity of the material,
operating pressure, operation near flammable range, quantity of material, joints and packing, use of
hot oil exchange system etc.,
The F&EI is calculated as a product of Material Factor, General Process Hazard factor, and special
process hazard factor.
Fire & Explosion Indexing is a rapid ranking method for identifying the degree of hazard. The FEI
calculation is a tool to help determine the areas of greater loss potential in a particular process. In
preliminary hazard analysis, chemicals have Toxic & Fire hazards.
The application of FEI would help to make a quick assessment of the nature and quantification of
the hazard in these areas.
Based on FEI value, the plant elements are categorized, category I plant element is the least
hazardous and caetory III is the highest hazardous in terms & Fire & Explosion.
The fire and explosion index evaluation can be very useful in developing plant layouts or adding
equipment and buildings to existing plants. Evaluation of the F&EI calculations and layout
considerations will result a safe, operable, maintainable and cost-effective arrangement of equipment
and buildings.
13.4.5 FIRE & EXPLOSION INDEX CALCULATION FOR CIX SOLVENT &
CYCLOHEXANONE IN TANKS
13.4.6 FIRE & EXPLOSION INDEX CALCULATION FOR PROPOSED LPG LOT SYSTEM
(IF ALL SAFETY MEASURES AS PROPOSED ARE IMPLEMENTED)
General Process Hazards Penalty used
Material Factor (MF) 21
Base factor (1.0) 1.00
Exothermic chemical reactions (factor 0.30 to 1.25) 0.00
Endothermic processes (factor 0.20 to 0.40) 0.00
Material handling & transfer (factor 0.25 to 1.05) 0.60
Enclosed or indoor process units (factor 0.25 to 90) 0.00
Access (0.20 to 0.35) 0.15
Drainage and spill control ( 0.25 to 0.50) 0.10
General Process Hazards factor (F1) 1.85
Special Process Hazards
Base factor (1.00) 1.00
Toxic material(s) (factor 0.20 to 0.80) 0.00
Sub-atmospheric pressure (Less than 500 mm Hg) (0.50) 0.00
Operation in or near flammable range 0.00
1. Tank farms storage flammable liquids (0.50) 0.00
2. Process upset or purge failure (0.30) 0.00
3. Always in flammable range (0.80) 0.20
Dust explosion (factor 0.25 to 2.00) 0.00
Pressure 0.00
Low temperature (factor 0.20 to 0.30) 0.00
Quantity of flammable/unstable material 0.00
Quantity :
1. Liquids, gases and reactive materials in process 0.00
2. Liquids or gases in storage 0.40
3. Combustible solids in storage. 0.00
Dust in process (0.00 to 2.00) 0.00
Corrosion and erosion ( 0.10 to 0.75) 0.30
Leakage - joints and packing (0.10 to 1.50) 0.30
A rationale approach of converting these to one year depending upon the operations, no. of shifts,
etc has been done. It cannot be claimed as accurate procedure. However, in the absence of any
other reliable data as well as procedure, this method can be considered as useful.
Supply pipe 0.25 x 10^-3/Hour
Spillage of road tanker/loading 5 x 10^-3/Hour
Motors for blowers 10.5 x 10^-6/Hour
Rotating Equipment 24.7 x 10^-6/Hour
Pressure Vessel Failure In 100 x 300 vessel
Catastrophic Failures 0.7 x 10^-4 Failures/Year
Valves 12.3 x 10^-6/Hour
Human errors 1800 to 5000 errors in One Million operations.
While computing pipe failures, 6 hours per day of pipe working is assumed as the pipes are called
into operation while transferring the solvents to reactors. In estimating spillage of tankers, on an
average 4 tanks per week at two hours each time are assumed in estimating number of hours the
tanker is located in the plant.
Solvent storage containment failure : Per year
Vessel failure-no ignition 0.4
Immediate-ignition 0.1
Hose pipe failure-operator failure to immediately arrestors
No ignition 0.3
Immediate ignition 0.075
Reactor drain valve or pipe connection failure-operator failed
To control- no ignition 0.0015
Immediate ignition 0.0004
Condenser failure-operator failure to control or shut off
No ignition 0.3
Immediate ignition 0.075
Mild or slight
Severe irritation at Moderate irritation
Skin effects Corrosive irrigation at 72
72 hours at 72 hours
hours
Toxicity categories inform users of the potential hazards associated with the use of a particular
pesticide. Specific signal word(s) must appear on product labels depending on pesticide toxicity
category. For example, pesticides in Toxicity Category I must carry on their label the word
“Danger.” Some Category I pesticides must also display the word “Poison,” and the skull and
crossbones symbol. Child warning hazard statements must appear on practically all pesticide
labels.
15.3 Labelling
In addition, if the product is assigned a Toxicity Category I on the basis of its oral, inhalation, or
dermal toxicity, the word “Poison” shall appear in red on a contrasting background color, and the
skull and crossbones shall appear in immediate proximity to the word “Poison.”
Toxicity Category I – All pesticide products shall bear on the front panel the signal word
“Danger.” In addition, if the product is assigned a Toxicity Category I on the basis of its oral,
inhalation, or dermal toxicity, the word “Poison” shall appear in red on a contrasting
background color, and the skull and crossbones shall appear in immediate proximity to the
word “Poison.”
Toxicity Category II – All pesticide products shall bear on the front panel the signal word
“Warning.”
Toxicity Category III – All pesticide products shall bear on the front panel the signal word
“Caution.”
Toxicity Category IV – All pesticide products shall bear on the front panel the signal word
“Caution.”
Child Warning Hazard – Every pesticide product label shall bear on the front panel the
statement “Keep out of Reach of Children.” Limited exemptions exist only in cases where the
likelihood of contact with children during distribution, marketing, storage, or use is
demonstrated by the applicant to be extremely remote, or if the nature of the pesticide is such
that it is approved for use on infants or small children.
The EPA also provides guidance on how much of a pesticide constitutes a lethal dose depending on
the degree of toxicity. For example, Table 2 shows that the oral lethal dose for a 150-pound person of
a highly toxic pesticide (labeled “Danger”) is only a few drops to a teaspoon. A person’s size will
help determine the amount that is poisonous. The smaller the individual, the smaller the amount of a
substance required to be lethal; the larger the individual, the larger the amount required. It takes much
less of a toxicant to poison a small child than it does to poison an adult.
cholinesterase were not present, impulses from one nerve to the next would flow continuously.
Many pesticides function to work against, or inhibit, cholinesterase in insect pests. However, these
chemicals can also be poisonous, or toxic, to humans in some situations. Prolonged exposure to
cholinesterase-inhibiting chemicals, such as organophosphates and carbamates, can result from
inhalation, ingestion, or eye or skin contact during the manufacturing, mixing, or applications of
these pesticides. Unchecked nervous (or electrical) impulses can fire away continuously, causing
uncontrolled, rapid twitching of some muscles, paralyzed breathing, convulsions, and, in extreme
cases, death.
Organophosphate products can affect cholinesterase activity in both red blood cells and in blood
plasma, and can act directly, or in combination with other enzymes, on cholinesterase in the body.
Some of the most commonly used organophosphate products include Acephate, Diazinon, and
Carbophenothion.
Carbamates vary widely in toxicity and work by inhibiting plasma cholinesterase. Some examples
of Carbamates are Aldicarb, Carbaryl, and Carbofuran.
16.0 QUALITATIVE IMPACT ANALYSIS WITH DOMINO EFFECT & RISK MINIMISATION CONTROLS FOR
EXISTING & PROPOSED LPG LOTSYSTEM
QUALITATIVE IMPACT ANALYSIS WITH DOMINO EFFECT & RISK MINIMISATION CONTROLS
The following safety measures have emerged during Process Hazard Evaluation related discussion with Site
EHS-In-Charge of M/s NACL-Unit-II:
17.1 Fire Safety Measures
17.1.1 Earth pits have been provided at various places in factory premises.
17.1.2 Double static earthing is provided to Solvent Storage tanks & mixing units in liquid formaulation
block
171.3 Double static earthing is provided to all equipoment being used in 60 ACM , 30 SCM & 10
ACM machines in Production blocks
17.1.3 The monitoring of earth resistance is carried out for each Earth pit.
17.1.4 The monitoring of earthing/bonding systems at a regular interval is proposed.
17.1.5 All electrical fittings, On/Off push button, Motors etc in Production BlockS & Solvent
storage tanks yard area are flame proof conforming to Exd IIB only. Flame proof weighing balance
is also provided.
17.1.6 Water sprinkler system is provided for solvent storage tanks
17.1.7 Fire Hydrant system has been provided for the site as per the details mentioned in Table-I
POWDERS, GRANULES
11. Underground Static Water Storage AT FIRE HYDRANT SYSTEM 500 KL
Tank
12. Fire Pumps
12.1 Electrical Driven Pump-Main Pump Fire hydrant pump house 01
Flow: 10.6 m3/hour
HP:10
12.2 Diesel Engine Driven Pump Fire hydrant pump house 01
Flow: 137 m3/hour
HP:60
12.3 Electrical Driven -Jockey Pump Fire hydrant pump house 01
Flow: 61 m3/hour
HP:60
17.1.8 Portable Fire Extinguishers of varying capacities & types have been provided for extinguishing a small
onsdet of fire at site as mentioned in Table-II:
Table-II: SUMMARY OF PORTABLE FIRE EXTINGUISHERS
Fire Type Fire Extinguisher Capacity Total Grand total
A type fires Water co2 9ltrs 10 Nos. 10 Nos.
9ltrs 18 Nos.
A,B type fires Mechanical foam
50ltr 14 Nos. 34 Nos.
B,C type fires 25KG 04 Nos.
10KG 14 Nos. 47 Nos.
DCP 9KG 11 Nos.
6KG 07 Nos.
5KG 11 Nos.
9KG 14 Nos.
6.8KG 04 Nos.
B,C type fires CO2 4.5KG 38 Nos. 82 Nos.
3.2KG 10 Nos.
2KG 16 Nos.
All type of Fires ABC 2KG,1 KG 20 Nos. 20 Nos.
All type of Fires ABC 10 KG 8 Nos. 8 Nos.
TOTAL Fire Extinguishers 201 Nos.
17.1.9 Fixed fire suppression system has been provided as per Table-III
Table-III:SUMMARY OF FIXED FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM
Sr. Equipment Description Locations Existing
No. Qty./Nos.
1. Water cum Foam Monitor SOLVENT TANK YARD 08 Nos.
2. Foam compound AFFF 3 % 2 KL
3. Auto Modular ABC Type Fire NIL
Extinguishers
4. Water Sprinkler System SOLVENT TANK YARD 72 Nos.
5 Foam Inductors & Mobile Foam LIQUID BLOCK 02 Nos.
Unit of 100 Liters caapcity
17.2.3 One number Assembly point is provided near office & guest house building
17.2.4 One number ECC is provided for over all controlling of an emergency
17.2.5 Fire Alarm system is provided for the entire site for communication an emergency as per the
details furnished in Table-V.
17.3.4 Suitable type of Antidote (Table VII) in adequate quantity is provided at site for treating pesticide
poisoning or for any medical emergency treatment
Table VII:ANTIDOTES
S. No Name of the Antidote Stock in OHC
01 Decardran .inj.2ml 20
02 Avil . inj.2ml 10
03 Deriphyllin .inj.2ml 10
04 Ondem 10
05 Tet –oxadil 10
06 Lasix 5
07 Snake Anti Venam 2
08 PAM (20ml) 20
09 Atropine 50
10 Cyclo Pam 10
11 Rantac inj. 10
17.3.5 Two Numbers of Self contained Breathing Appratus (SCBA) sets have been deployed in Emeregncy
Control Centre for rescue purpose
17.3.6 Emergency PPEs such as respirators, hand gloves, full body air suits , Fire suits, air breathing masks ,
etc are also available in ECC as per Table VIII for providing supply of PPEs in acse of an emergency
situation
10 Face shields 20
11 Full Body air suit 10
12 Safety Full body Harness 10
13 Air Breathing Mask 05
14 Fire Suits 03
15 Fire Blankets 10
17.3.7 First aid boxes have been deployed as per the locations mentioned in Table-IX for rendering
first aid in case of an injury
1. OHC 01
2. SECURITY-1 01
3. QC 01
4 PRODUCTION LIQUIDS 01
5 ECC 01
6 SECURITY 01
7 ADMIN OFFICE 01
8 WAREHOUSE 01
14 Nos.
17.4.3 Eye wash fountain is provided outside the production blcoks for providing immediate first aid for any
spillage
17.4.4 Extraction Hoods with duct connected to a scrubber have been provided to blender, filling area &
machines, Nauta Mixer & filling area etc
17.4.5 A dedicated scrubber system with caustic tank & Pumps for circulation & blower is in place for
granulation block
17.4.6 Appropriate Hazard Warning Lables are affixed on barrels of Pesticides/Insecticides Formulation.
17.4.7 Spill control management system is in place as per the details furnished in Table-X.
17.4.8 Requisite spill control items have been provided for each spill control kit as mentioned in
Table XI.
17.4.9 Suitable extraction system over mixing tanks/ filling machines is provided and the duct is connected
to a scrubber for example: filling machine of dusting powder & granules area etc.
17.4.10 Dedicated dust collector has been provided for 30 ACM & 10 ACM, Powder &
Granulation Production Blocks
17.4.11 Production Blocks have been provided with adequate numbers of roof Turbo ventilators in addition
to adequate numbers of ventilation Windows for providing natural ventilation.
17.4.12 Production Blocks have been provided with adequate numbers of Shutters for providing good natural
ventilation
17.4.13 Operational instructions to check the level of scrubbing medium and pH measurement before start-up
of a batch is included in the Scrubber SOP
17.4.14 Sand buckets have been provided across the site as mentioned in Table-XII for containing
any spill
Table-XII :FIRE SAND BUCKET STANDS
S.NO. AREA NO.OF SAND BUCKETS
1. SUBSTATION-01 04 Nos.
2. DIESEL GENERATOR 04 Nos.
3. SUBSTATION-02 04 Nos.
4. SOLVENT STORAGE TANKS 04 Nos.
5. QUALITY CONTROL & LAB 04 Nos.
6. 30 ACM BLOCK 04 Nos.
7. 10 ACM BLOCK 04 Nos.
8. HERBICIDE BLOCK 04 Nos.
9. LIQUID BLOCK 04 Nos.
10. FINISHED BLOCK 04 Nos.
11 S.C FORMULATION BLOCK 04 Nos.
12 MONO LIQUID BLOCK 04 Nos.
13 PRILLS BLOCK 04 Nos.
14 PACKING MATERIAL GODOWN 04 Nos.
17.8.3 Various types of safety applinances have beem made available at site for handling any type of
emergency. The details of safety applinaces are furnished in Table-XIII.
18.1 Respiratpry PPE selection & PPE usage monitoring shall be done in view of
Pesticide/Insecticide Technical handling in large volume
18.2 As the over- exposure to hazardous chemicals and finished products can be injurious to
health, awareness of such conditions, avoidance of such conditions, use of suitable personal
protection, early detection of undesirable health conditions and medical management measures are
to be developed and included as procedures.
18.3 In view of handling of flammable solvents which generate static charge, measures to prevent
and minimize generation of static charge during transfer and handling operations as well as during
reaction should be ensured.
18.4 QRA is to be done by the Management for identification of impact of pool fire caused by CIX
Solvent & Cyclohexane storage in Tanks & for the proposed LPG LOT system. An estimation of
heat radiations at different distances from source are to be made (Recommendation R1 &R2 in
Section 13)
18.5 The Industry shoud carry out a study for Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) by using software
for MCA Analysis for CIX Solvent &Cyclohexane storage in Tanks (Recommendation R1 &2 in
Section No.13)
18.6 Comply with recommendation No.R3 as mentioned in Section No.16
18.7 Coompy with all recommendations as mentioned in Section No.16 for the proposed LPG LOT
system for Boiler before start-up of modified boiler with LPG as fuel.
19.0 CONCLUSIONS
A combination of the existing In Built Safety Measures and compliance of recommended safety
measures would go a long way in reducing identified associated risks to an acceptable level. The
measures are to be periodically reviewed with reference to best available technology and safety
practices and creating awareness among employees about changes taking place. This report shall
be read in conjunction with Safety Audit reports & HAZOP & Risk Assessment.
20.0 DISCLAIMER
The EHS & Fire Safety Consultant , based upon professional experience and training, will offer
recommendations to abate violations identified during the walk-through, but does not guarantee
that all (and every), safety issues will be identified. M/s NACL Industries Limited, Unit-II ,located
in survey No .460/1, 2, 3, 4& 5 at D.NO-4-208, Ethakota village, Near Ganti check post,
Ravulapalem Mandal in East Godavari district of Andhra Pradesh, will hold the Consultant,
harmless for violations identified but not cured; violations not identified; or any claim, dispute or
other form of controversy arising from or out of an actual or purported safety violation. M/s NACL
Industries Limited, Unit-II, located in survey No .460/1, 2, 3, 4& 5 at D.NO-4-208, Ethakota
village, Near Ganti check post, Ravulapalem Mandal in East Godavari district of Andhra Pradesh,
remains required to comply with Factories’ Acts & Rules, SMPV Rules and all applicable
Standards under State and CentralCodes. Consider other consultancy services that may be
available from Director of Factories, DGFASLI, your insurance carrier, and other safety
consultants.
21.0 ANNEXURE
Annexure-1: Site Lay Out Drawing