Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nalin Nagar - Student - EnloeHS - Soils Reading
Nalin Nagar - Student - EnloeHS - Soils Reading
Nalin Nagar - Student - EnloeHS - Soils Reading
THE GREAT TERRAIN ROBBERY Under this 1872 law, a person or corporation
can assume legal ownership of any public land not
Want to get rich at the taxpayers' expense? You can classified as wilderness or park simply by patenting
if you know how to make use of a little-known min- it. This involves declaring their belief that the land
ing law passed in 1872 to encourage mining of gold, contains valuable hard-rock minerals, spending $500
silver, lead, copper, uranium, and other hard-rock to improve the land for mineral development, filing
minerals on U.S. public lands. a claim, and then paying the federal government
$6—12 per hectare ($2.50—5.00 an acre) for the land. So
far, lands containing at least $385 billion of the public's
Figure 14-1 Bear Trap Creek in Montana is one example of how gold
mining can contaminate water with highly toxic cyanide or mercury
used to extract gold from its ore. Air and water also convert the sulfur
in gold ore to sulfuric acid, which releases toxic metals such as
mium and copper into streams and groundwater. (Bryan Peterson)
don it, file fet- bankruptcy, and leave the public with
the cleanup bill (see Case Study, p. 353). It is esti-
mated that the ta.xpayers' cleanup costs for all land 14-1 GEOLOGIC PROCESSES
damaged by hard-rock mining on existing or sold
public lands will be $33—72 billion, depending on What Is the Earth's Structure? As the prim-
whether groundwater and toxic waste cleanup are itive earth cooled over eons, its interior separated into
included. Environmentalists have been trying, with- three major concentric zones, which geologists identify
out success, to have this law revised to protect tax- as the core, the mantle, and the crust (Figure 4-5). Vari-
payers and the environment. ous indirect measurements indicate that the earth's
We live on a dynamic planet. Energy from the innermost zone, the core, is made mostly of iron (with
sun and from the earth's interior, and the action of perhaps some nickel). The core has a solid inner part,
surrounded by a liquid core of molten material.
water, have created continents, mountains, valleys,
The earth's core is surrounded by a thick, solid
plains, and ocean basins—an ongoing process that
zone called the mantle. This largest zone of the earth's
continues to change the landscape. Nonrenewable
interior is rich in iron (its major constituent), silicon,
resources in the earth's crust (Figure 1-11) are among
oxygen, and magnesium. Most of the mantle is solid
the foundations of modern civilization; no less
rock, but under its rigid outermost part there is a
Important is potentially renewable soil (Figures 5-13
zone of very hot, partly melted rock that flows like
and 5-16). In addition to food, soil indirectly provides
soft plastic. This plastic region of the mantle is called
us with wood, paper, fiber, and medicines, and it
the asthenosphere.
helps to purify the water we drink and to decompose The outermost and thinnest zone of the earth is
and recycle biodegradable wastes. There is no sub- called the crust. It consists of the continental crust,
stitute for fertile soil. Unfortunately, human activities which underlies the continents (including the conti-
that lead to rapid soil erosion can convert this poten- nental shelves extending into the oceans), and the
hall}' renewable resource into a nonrenewable resource. oceanic crust, which underlies the ocean basins and
enting such loss of vital earth capital should be covers 71% of the earth's surface (Figure 14-2). It is
339
Abyssal plain
'Séontinental cru
Mantle (asthenosphere)
Figure 14-2 Major features of the earths crust and upper mantle. The lithosphere, composed of the crust
and outermost mantle, is rigid and brittle. The asthenosphere, a zone in the mantle, can be deformed by heat and
pressure (that it is plastic).
from the earth's crust that mineral resources and soil and the rigid, outermost part of the mantle (above the
come, as do the elements that make up living organ- asthenosphere)—-a combination called the lithosphere.
isms. The three types of rocks—igneous, sedimentary, These plates move constantly, supported by the slowly
and in the earth's mantle and flowing asthenosphere like large pieces of ice floating
core from one type to another in the rock on the surface of a lake during the spring breakup.
cycle (Figure 5-10). Some plates move faster than others, but a typical
The earth's crust, which is still forming in various speed is about the rate at which fingernails grow.
places, is composed of minerals and rocks. It is the The theory explaining the movements of the plates
source of virtually all the nonrenewable resources we and the processes that occur at their boundaries is called
use: fossil fuels, metallic minerals, and nonmetallic plate tectonics. The concept, which became widely ae
minerals (Figure 1-11). It is also the source of soil cepted by geologists in the 1960s, was developed from
(Figures 5-13and 5-16) and the elements (Figure 3-4) an earlier idea called continental drift. Throughout the
that make up our bodies and those of other living or- earth's history, continents have split and joined as plates
ganisms. Most of the over 2,000 identified minerals have drifted thousands of kilometers back and forth
occur as inorganic compounds formed by various across the planet's surface (Figure 6-12).
combinations of the eight elements that make up Plate motion produces mountains (including vol-
98.5% by weight of the earth's crust (Figure 3-11). canoes), the oceanic ridge system, trenches, and other
EURASIAN PLATE
Ridg EURASIAN
PLATE
JUAN DE Atlanti
FUCA PLATE NORTH Ocean ANATOLIAN PLATE
CHINA AMERICAN Ridge
SUBPLA PHILIPPINE Transform PLATE
fault CARIBBEAN
PLATE
PACIFIC PLATE
Mid- PLATE
Indian AFRICAN
Transform PLATE
idge fault 4 SOUTH
rtsberg
East Pacifi AMERICAN Ridge
INDIAN-AUSTRALIAN PLATE Rise
NAZCA PLATE
PLATE SOMALIAN
SUBPLATE
Southeast Indian
Ocean Ridge
Transform Southwest Indian
fault
Ocean Ridge
ANTARCTIC PLATE
Figure 14•3 (a) Earthquake and volcano sites are distributed mostly in bands along the planets surface.
(b) These bands correspond to the patterns for the types of lithospheric plate boundaries shown in figure 14-4.
CHAPTER 14
Lithosphere
What Geologic Processes Occur on the Earth's
Asthenosphere
Surface? Geological changes based directly or indi-
rectly on energy from the sun and on gravity (rather
Oceanic ridge at a divergent plate boundary
than on heat in the earth's interior) are called external
Trench Volcanic island arc processes. IVhereas internal processes generally build
up the earth's surface, external processes tend to wear
itdown.
A major external process is erosion. It is the
process by which loosened material (as well as mate-
rial not yet separated) is dissolved, loosened, or worn
away from one part of the earth's surface and de-
posited in other places. Loosened material that can
Lithosphere be eroded is usually produced by weathering, which
Ristng can occur as a result of mechanical processes, chemi-
magma
cal processes (Figure 5-11), or both. Weathering is re-
Subduction
Asthenosphere sponsible for the development of soil, as discussed in
zone Section 5-8.
Streams, the most important agent of erosion,
Trench and volcanic island arc at a convergent operate everywhere on the earth except in the polar re-
plate boundary
gions.They produce ordinary valleys and canyons, and
Fracture zone they may form deltas where streams flow into lakes and
oceans (Figure 14-5). Some erosion is also caused when
Transform
wind blows particles of soil from one area to anothet
fault
Human activities, particularly those that destroy vege-
tation, accelerate emsion, as discussed in Section 14-6.
342
Lagoon Barrier
islands
Shallow marine
environment
Shallow marine
environment
Volcanic island
Coral reef
Continental shelf
Continental slope
Abyssal plain
Continental rise
Deep-sea fan
Figure 14-5 The variety of landforms and sedimentary environments depicted here is mainly the result of
externa! processes, powered primarily by solar energy (as it drives the hydrologic cycle and wind) and gravity,
with some assistance from organisms such as reef-building corals.
resources (coal, oil, natural gas, uranium, geothermal Reserves are identified resources that can be ex-
energy), metallic mineral resources (iron, copper, tracted economically at current prices using current
aluminum), and nonmetallic mineral resources (salt, mining technology. Other resources are identified and
gypsum, clay, sand, phosphates, water, and soil). undiscovered resources not classified as reserves.
An ore is a metal-yielding material that can be Most published estimates of particular mineral re-
economically extracted at a given time. To be prof- sources refer only to reserves. Reserves can increase
itable, copper in copper ore must be concentrated when exploration finds previously undiscovered
to 86 times its crustal average, gold 1,000 times, and economic-grade mineral resources, or when identified
mercury an astonishing 100,000 times. subeconomic-grade mineral resources become eco-
We know how to find and extract more than 100 nomically viable because of new technology or higher
nonrenewable minerals from the earth's crust. We con- prices. Figure 14-6 shows a region labeled potential
vert these minerals into many everyday items that we reserves, indicating how resources can be expanded.
either use and discard (Figure 3-21) or learn to reuse, Theoretically, all of the other resources could eventually
be converted to reserves, but this is highly unlikely.
recycle, oruse less wastefully (Figure 3-22).
The U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) divides min-
eral resources into two broad categories, identified and
How Do We Find and Remove Mineral
Deposits? Mining companies use several methods
undiscovered (Figure 14-6). Identified resources are
to find promising mineral deposits. Geological in-
deposits of a particular mineral resource that have a
formation about plate tectonics and mineral formation
known location, quantity, and quality, or deposits for
suggests areas worthy of closer study. Aerial photos
which these parameters are estimated from direct geo-
and satellite images sometimes reveal rock forma-
logical evidence and measurements. Undiscovered
tions associated with certain minerals. Other instru-
resources are potential supplies of a particular min-
ments on aircraft and satellites can detect mineral
eral resource that are assumed to exist on the basis of
deposits by their effects on the earth's magnetic or
geologic knowledge and theory (although specific
gravitational fields.
locations, quality, and amounts are unknown).
CHAPTER 14 343
Reserves
o
c o
o
1 0
1
o
z
Figure 14-6 General classification of mineral resources. Figure 14-7 This open-pit copper mine in Bingham, Utah,
(The area shown for each class does not represent its relative is the largest human-made hole in the world—4.O kilometers
abundance.) In theory, all mineral resources classified as other (2.5 miles) in diameter and 0.8 kilometer (0.5 mile) deep. The
resources cou!O become reserves because of rising mineral amount of material removed from this mine is seven times the
prices, improved n•..neral location and extraction technology, amount moved to build the Panama Canal. (Don Green/Ken-
or both. In pract:ce, geologists expect only a fraction of other necott Copper Corporation, now owned by British Petroleum)
resources to beco:ne reserves. The area labeled potential
reserves shows the way reserves normally increase.
After profitable deposits of minerals are located, trench is filled with overburden and a new cut is made
deep deposits are removed by subsurface mining parallel to the previous one. The process is repeated
and shallow deposits by surface mining. In surface over the entire site. If the land is not restored, area strip
mining, mechanized equipment strips away the over- mining leaves a wavy series of highly erodible hills of
burden of soil and rock and usually discards it; such rubble called spoil banks (Figure 14-8).
waste material is called spoil. Surface mining ex- Contour strip mining is used in hilly or mountain-
tracts about 90% of the mineral and rock resources
ous terrain (Figure 14-9). A power shovel cuts a series
and more than 60% of the coal by weight in the of terraces into the side of a hill. An earthmover re-
United States.
moves the overburden and a power shovel extracts the
The type of surface mining used depends on the coal; theoverburden from each new terrace is dumped
resource being sought and on local topography. In onto the one below. Unless the land is restored, a wall
open-pit mining (Figure 14-7), machines dig holes and of dirt is left in front of a highly erodible bank of soil
remove ores such as iron and copper. This method is and rock called a highwall.
also used for sand and gravel and for building stone Sometimes giant augers are used to drill horizon-
such as limestone, sandstone, slate, granite, and mar- tally into a hillside to extract underground coal. There
ble. Another form of surface mining is dredging, in is also growing use of extracting coal in parts of West
which chain buckets and draglines scrape up under- and Pennsyl-
Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee, Virginia,
water mineral deposits. vania by a form of surface mining called mountaintop
Stripmining is surface mining in which bulldoz- removal. A powerful $100-million machine called a
ers, power shovels, or stripping wheels remove the dragline that can be as high as 20 stories is used to
overburden in strips. It is used mostly for extract- completely remove the top of a mountain to get at the
ing coal and some phosphate rock. Most surface- coal below. The debris is dumped into the valleys. Aer-
mined coal is removed by area strip mining or contour ial surveys reveal that 15—25% of the mountaintoPS in
strip mining, depending on the terrain.
the south-central part of West Virginia are being re-
Area strip mining is used where the terrain is fairly moved by this technique. Indeed, if this type of min-
flat. An earthmover strips away the overburden, and
ing continues unabated, environmentalists project that
then a power shovel digs a cut to remove the mineral
in two decades half the mountain peaks of southern
deposit, such as coal. After the mineral is removed, the
West Virginia's blue-green skyline will be gone•
344
Q: How much of the world's food and fiber are U.S. farmers?
Strip-mined for coal in the Appalachian region has not particular nonrenewable mineral will last at current
been restored. In addition, about three-fourths of the annual production rates.
coal that can be surface mined in the United States is in Estimates of reserves are continually changing
arid and semiarid regions in the West, where the soil
because new deposits are often discovered, and new
mining and processing can allow some of the minerals
and climate usually prevent full restoration.
classified as other resources (Figure 14-6) to be con-
Subsurface used to remove coal and
mining is
verted to reserves. Under these circumstances, the
various metal ores that are too deep to be extracted by
CHAPTER 14 345
mining technology, higher prices, and new discoveries range from about 20 years for zinc, lead, and
will increase reserves (curve B, Figure 14-10). An even
to well over 100 years for iron and aluminum.
longer depletion time assumes that new discoveries will No industrialized country is self-sufficient in min-
expand reserves and that recycling, reuse, and
further eral resources, although the former Soviet Union came
reduced consumption will extend supplies (curve C, close and was a major exporter of important minerals.
Figure 14-10). Finding a substitute for a resource leads Since breakup, some of its republics have ample
its
to a new set of depletion curves for the new resource. minerals, but others do not. By contrast, Japan, in ad-
While world population doubled between 1950 dition to lacking coal, oil, and timber resources, has
and 1993, global production of six key metals (alu- virtually no metals. Japan depends on resource im-
minum, copper, lead, nickel, tin, and zinc) increased ports, which it upgrades to finished products and thm
more than eightfold. During this same period, world sells abroad to buy the resources it needs to sustain its
reserves of copper increased almost fivefold, lead al- economy. Most western European countries depend
most and aluminum almost
threefold, zinc fourfold, heavily on minerals from Africa.
ninefold. Furthermore, the prices of most metals today
have chanoed little in constant dollars over the last 150 Case Study: Mineral Resources in the United
years, mostly because of government subsidies and States The U.S. Bureau of Mines estimates that the
failure to include the harmful environmental effects of totalconsumption of virgin materials in the United
metal mining and processing in their market prices. States increased 14-fold between 1900 and 1991; dur-
Figure 14-10 Depletion curves for a nonrenewable "Without manganese, chromium, platinum, and cobalb
resource (such as aluminum or copper) using three sets there can be no automobiles, no airplanes, no jet
of assumptions. Dashed vertical lines represent times
engines, no satellites, and no sophisticated weapo
when 80% depletion occurs.
not even home appliances."
Manganese 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100%
Cobalt
Tantalum South Africa, Gabon, Brazil
Figure 14-11 Evaluation of the supply of selected nonfuel minerals in the United States, 1982-2000, and
major foreign sources of these minerals. Foreign sources subject to potential interruption of supply by political,
economic, or military disruption are shown in boldface. Virtually all U.S. supplies of four important minerals—
manganese, cobalt, platinum, and chromium—are imported from potentially unstable countries. (Data from
U.S. Geological Survey and U.S. Bureau of Mines)
CHAVrER 14 347
348
Q: How many units of energy are required to put one unit of food energy on the tablednthennited states?
Availability of freshwater also may limit the supply lated with either natural or genetically engineered
of some mineral resources. To extract and process most bacteria to extract the desired metal. Next the ore
minerals isflooded with water, which is then pumped to
conventional means requires large
the surface, where the desired metal is removed.
amounts cG water and many mineral-rich areas lack
This technique permits economical extraction
fresh water. Finally, exploitation of lower-grade ores
from low-grade ores, which are increasingly being
may be lint by the environmental impact of waste used as high-grade ores are depleted. Since 1958,
material prnduced during mining and processing. At the copper industry has been using natural strains
gyme point, the costs of land restoration and pollution of the bacterium Thiobacillusfrrmxidans to remove
control exceed the current value of the minerals, un- copper from low-grade copper ore. Currently, at
less we continue to pass these harmful costs on to scy least 25"0 of all copper produced worldwide,
ciety and to future generations. worth more than Sl billion a year, comes from
such biomining.
Microbiological of ores is slow.
Can We
Get Enough Minerals by Mining the
however: It can take decades to remove the same
Oceans? Ocean mineral resources are found in three
amount of material that conventional methods
areas: seawater, sediments and deposits on the
can remove within months or years, So far, biologi-
and sediments
shallow continental shelf (Figure 14-5), cal methods are €XNnomically feasible only with
and nodules on the deep-ocean Most of the
floor. low-grade ore (such as gold and copper) for which
chemical elements found in seawater occur in such conventional are too expensive.
low concentrations that recovering them takes more
energy and money than they are worth. Only magne- Critical Thinking
sium, bromine, and sodium chloride are abundant If you had a large sum of money to invest. would
enough to be extracted profitably at current prices you invest it in the microbiological processing of
with existing technology. aluminum ON? Explain.
Deposits of minerals (mostly sediments) along the
continental shelf and near shorelines are already
significant sources of sand, gravel, phosphates, sulfur.
tin, copper, iron, tungsten, silver, titanium, platinum,
and even diamonds. Mutule beds in international waters are not being
The deep-ocean floor at various sites may be a developed because of squabbles over who owns
future source of manganese and other metals. Man• them, how any profits should be distributed among the
ganese•rich nodules may cover 2(YYo of the world's ocean world's nations, and because land supplies of these
floors and have been found in large quantities at a few minerals are more plentiful and An interna-
sites, These cherry- to potato•sized tocks are 30-40% tional Law of the Sea Treaty (signed by the United
manganese by weight; they also contain small amounts States in 1994) may resolve some of these issues.
Of other important metals such as nickel, copper, and Rich deposits of gold, Silver, zinc, and copper are
cobalt. Tlicy might be sucked up fmm the ocean floor by alsoproduced as sulfide around very hot vol-
giant vacuum pipes or scooped up by buckets on a cone canic springs and vents found various areas in the
tinuous cable operated by a mining ship. deep ocean. Some Of these crystallized deposits, called
can cover the high costs of removing such metal de- tional metals. They are harder, stronger, lighte%
so dæp in the However. the Australian longer-lasting than many metals. These withstand
mining company says that making a profit is likely tense heat and do not corrode. iVithin a few deades
through use of advanced technologies such as sonar. we may have high-temperature ceramic
tors in which flows without resistance.
and giant claws lowered from ships. Accord-
ing to the company's CEO, A. Geoff Loudon, such a development may lead to faster computers,
dæp-sæ mining is and Will eventually turn efficient power transmission. and affordahle elee-:s
ocean food webs. Surface waters ing, and can be molded into any shape. New
also be polluted by the discharge of sediments and gels are also being developed to provide
frem ships and rigs. insulation without taking up much space.
*ene biologrsts warn that deep-sea mining could plastic can withstand extremely high temperatzre
a effect on mostly unknown marine and isnot even affected by exposure to eve
scientists now believe there may be 10 intense laser beams.
mi!iior---and perhaps as many as 100 million—previ- Substitutes can undoubtedlv be found fat man
custv unknown species of microbes and small animals scarce mineral resources. but the search is
residing in the watersand sediments of the ln- phasing a substitute into a complex
stead of sunlight, these microbes rely on heat and tak•cs time. a vanishing
disy)lved chemicals vented from the earth's turbulent replaced, people and businesses it ray
interior as t}wir energy These them- suffer economic hardships. Moreovet. findtng suk•stt•
selves the base of food webs involving tutes for some key materials may diRiNlt
crabs, fish. mussels, tube worms, sible.Examples are helium. phosphorus
and other animals not yet recognized that colonize manganese for making strx•l. and
fertilizers,
butntx•rs. D. 199A
Use Noise;
water polLRyon;
transportation or transmission pottution of air. water, and soil;
to individual user, s05d and radioactive wages;
eventual use, and discarding safety and heatth hazards; heat
Figure 14-13 Some harmful environmental effects of resource extraction, processing, and use. The energy used
to carry each step causes additional pollution and environmental degradation. Harm could be rninmzed by
requiring a-rntng, processing, and manufacturing companies to include the full costs of the pollution and environ-
mental degradation in the prices of their products. Many of these external costs are now passed on to society in
the form of poorer health, increased health and insurance costs, and increased taxes to deal with pollution and
environmental degradation.
fires in coal mines cannot always be put out. Land uranium compounds and compounds of toxic metals
above underground mines collapses or subsides, caus- such as lead, mercury, arsaüc, and cadmium. To date,
ing houses to tilt, sewer lines to crack, gas mains to effluents from mines in the United States have conta-
break, and groundwater systems to be disrupted. In minated 19,300 kilometers (12,000 miles) of streams
addition, spoil heaps and tailings can be eroded by and rivers, 73,000 hectares (180,000 acres) of reservoirs
wind and water. The air can be contaminated with and lakes, and untold amounts of groundwater.
dust and toxic substances, and water pollution is a se- After extraction from the ground, many resources
rious concern.
must be separated from other matter, a process that
Past and present mining operations for metallic can pollute the air and water. Ore, for example, typi-
and nonmetallic minerals occupy only a small percent- cally contains two parts: the ore mineral, which con-
age of the total land area in any country (0.25% of the tains the desired metal, and the gangue, which is the
United States). However, the scars from mining are waste mineral material. Beneficiation, or separation
long lasting (Figure 14-7), and the resulting air and in a mill of the ore mineral from the gangue, produces
water pollution can extend beyond the limits of waste called tailings. Piles of tailings are ugly, and
ground disturbance. toxic metals blown or leached from them by rainfall
Rainwater seeping through a mine or mine wastes can contaminate surface and groundwater.
can carry sulfuric acid (H2S04, produced when aero- Most ore minerals do not consist of pure metal, so
bic bacteria act on iron sulfide minerals in spoil) to smelting is done to separate the metal from the other
nearby streams and groundwater (Figure 14-14). Such elements in the ore mineral. Without effective pol-
acid mine drainage can destroy aquatic life and contam- lution control equipment, smelters emit enormous
inate water supplies. Other harmful materials that ei- quantities of air pollutants, which damage vegetation
ther run off or are dissolved from underground mines and soils in the surrounding area. Pollutants include
or aboveground mining wastes include radioactive sulfur dioxide, soot, and tiny particles of arsenic,
Hint: Enter the search term mines and mineral resources; then select the subtopic laws, regulations, etc. 14 351
iment
Acid drainage from
oil
reaction of mineral
or ore With water
Figure 14-14 Poi:ovon anc ±gradation of a stream and groundwater by runoff of acids—called acid mine
drainage—and b; from surface and subsurface mining. These substances can kill fish and other
aquatic life. Acid carnaged over 26 000 kilometers (16,000 miles) of streams in the United
States, most:y in in the West.
352
Q: What percentage of the world's cropland is used to grow livestock
form of the 1872 mining law (p. 33S), including the fob
higher-grade ores are generally exploited first. As they
are depleted, it takes more money, energy, water, and lowing changes:
other materials to exploit lower-grade ores, and envi-
• Prohibiting buying ofpublic tnining but
ronmental effects increase accordingly. ing such land to bc leased for mining for up to 20 years.
Should the U.S. 1872 Mining Law ne Rc- • Requiring afull environmental impact assessment Ofthe
propsc•d mining activities before a mining lease is approoed,
formed to Reduce Environmental Harm and
Save Taxpayers Money? Environmentalists point • Setting strict environmental standardsfotprctvnting
Out that mining is the only natural resource industry and controlling pollution and environmental degradation
suitinsfivnt mining activities during the Ft•iod ofthe lease.
in the United States that by law can buy public lands;
it is also the only resource industry that pays no rents Requiring companies leasing public land to post an
or royalties for resource extraction. Environmentalists cnvironntental perforntmtcc bond to estimated
and a growing number of citizens support a drastic re-
sss
Sittefvr environmental cleanup and restoration ofeach site. Most soil erosion is caused by moving water. Soil
scientists distinguish among three types of water
Mining companies claim that charging royalties sion. Sheet erosion occurs when surface water moves
for minerals taken from public lands and requiring down a slope or across a field in a wide flow and
them to pay for cleanup will force them to do their peels off fairly uniform sheets or layers of soil. Be-
mining in other countries, which would cost Ameri- cause the topsoil disappears evenly, sheet erosion
can jobs and reduce tax revenues. They also argue that may not be noticeable until much damage has been
their average cost for patenting public land under the done. In rill erosion the surface water forms fast-flow.
1S72 law is about S42,000 per hectare ($17,000 per acre) ing little rivulets that cut small channels in the soil
when mi.-ting development costs are included. (Figure 14-16). In gully erosion, rivulets of fast-flow-
. a "')'.'.menta'i.sts counter that mining companies ing water join together and with each succeeding rain
would r till a ceasonable profit on the high-value cut the channels wider and deeper until they become
minenis such as gold and platinum they get from pub- ditches or gullies (Figure 14-16). Gully erosion usu-
lic lards and that threats to move operations elsewhere allyhappens on steep slopes where all or most vege-
are a rarely implemented scare tactic (greenmail). For tation has been removed.
example, gold costs miners about $30 per ounce to ex- Losing topsoil makes a soil less fertile and less able
tract, but in recent years it has been sold for $320—395 to hold water. The resulting sediment—the largest
per ounce. Even with a 12.5% royalty and responsibility source of water pollution—clogs irrigation ditches,
for cleanup costs---as required for oil, gas, and coal com- boat channels, reservoirs, and lakes. The sediment-
panies—hard-rock mining companies can turn a hefty laden water is cloudy and tastes bad, fish die, and tlod
profit on high-price minerals such as gold and platinum.
Environmentalists also point out that Canada,
Australia, South Africa,and other countries that are
major extractors of hard-rock minerals don't sell pub-
lic lands to mining companies, and they require the
companies to pay rent on any public land they lease
and royalties on the minerals they extract.
Mostly because of the political influence of min-
ing companies and their congressional allies, this law
stands little chance of serious reform in the near future
without intense pressure from citizens.
.4
ing to studies by several soil scientists, if global soil Today, soil on cultivated land in the United States
erosion is not severely reduced, it could cause a is eroding about 16 times faster than it can form.
19—29% drop in food production from rain-fed crop- Sion rates are even higher in heavily farmed regions
land during the 25 years between 1985 and 2010. including the Great Plains, which has lost one-third
In developing countries, poverty and erosion in- more of its topsoil in the 150 years since it was first
teract in a destructive positive feedback cycle. Many plowed. Some of the country's most productive agri.
cultural lands, such as those in Iowa, have lost about
poor farmers in developing countries plow up mar-
ginal (easily erodible) lands to survive, and the result- half their topsoil. California's soil is eroding about 80
times faster than it can be formed.
ing erosion and land degradation then increases
poverty—which reinforces the cycle of destruction. The estimated amount of topsoil that erodes away
According to a 1990 UN study, agricultural misman- each day in the United States would fill a line of dump
agement, overgrazing, deforestation, and overharvest- trucks 5,600 kilometers (3500 miles) long. In 1995, soil
ing of fuelwood mostly by the poor account of about expert David Pimentel (Guest Essay, p. 364) estimated
70% of the damage done to the world's soil. In 1995, that the direct and indirect costs of soil erosion and
David Pimentel estimated that soil erosion causes runoff in the United States exceed $44 billion per
nearly $400 billion per year worldwide in direct dam- year—an average loss of S5 million per hour.
age to agricultural lands and indirect damage to wa- Critics say that estimates of soil erosion and dam-
terways, infrastructure, and human health, an average ages from such erosion are overblown and that soil
of $46 million in damages per hour. erosion does not pose a serious threat to the capacity
According to recent studies by Lester Brown of the global agricultural system to increase yields
(Guest Essay, p. 34) and David Pimentel, without bet- (Section 12-3). They point to studies by several soil sci-
ter soil conservation practices between 1.4 million entistsconcluding that if current rates of cropland
(equal to th• land area of Alaska) and 2.0 million erosion in the United States continue for 100 years,
square kilomeæt•s (540,000—770,000 square miles) will crop yields will be only 3—10% less than they would
lose much of their good-quality topsoil by 2015. This be without such erosion.
will make the U.S. Dust Bowl (Case Study, right) look
like a sandbox in comparison. What Is and How Serious
Some critics, such as Pierre Crosson, say that there Is This Problem? Desertification is a process
is no accurate way to measure global soil erosion and whereby the productive potential of arid or semiarid
and the resulting environ-
that the estimates of erosion land falls by 1000 or more; this phenomenon results
mental and health costs are overblown. They also mostly from human activities. Moderate desertification
believe that projected losses of topsoil and soil nutri- is a 10—25% drop in productivity, severe desertification is
ents can be offset by shifting cropland to other areas, a 25—50% drop, and very severe desertification is a drop
applying larger amounts of fertilizer, and increasing of 50% or more, usually creating huge gullies and sand
various soil conservation measures (Section 14-7). dunes. Desertification is a serious and growing prob-
Soil erosion experts agree that all we can ever lem in many parts of the world (Figure 14-19).
have rough estimates but they contend that such
is Practices that leave topsoil vulnerable to deserdfica•
estimates from numerous sources show a growing and tion include (1) overgrazing on fragile arid and semiarid
alarming increase in soil erosion, regardless of the rangelands, (2) deforestation without reforestation,
exact numbers involved. Many economists and soil (3) surface mining without land reclamation, (4) irriga-
scientists say that, if anything, the estimates of short- tion techniques that lead to increased erosion, (5) salt
and long-term environmental and health costs of soil buildup and waterlogged soil, (6) farming on land with
erosion are too low. unsuitable terrain or soils, and (7) soil compaction by
Soil scientists also point out that fertilizers do not farm machinery and cattle hoofs. The consequences Of
fully replenish soil. And according to many agriculture worsening drought, famine, de
desertification include
experts and economists, the economic and environmen- and swelling numbers of en+
clining living standards,
tal costs involved in growing crops on most new land ronmental refugees whose land is too eroded to grow
available are too high, as discussed in Section 12-3. crops or feed livestock.
An estimated 8.1 million square kilometers (3.1 mile
How Serious Is Soil Erosion in the United lion square miles)—an area the size of Brazil and 12
States? According to the Soil Conservation Service times the size of Texas—have become desertified in the
(SCS), about one-third of the nation's original prime past 50 years. According to Harold Drengue, this threat*
topsoil has been washed or blown into streams, lakes, ens the livelihoods of at least 900 million people in 100
356 Q: What percentage of U.S. cropland is used to produce fruits and vegetablö?
urge of grass, denuding the the Soil Erosion Act, which estab-
pund The stage was set for severe lished the Soil Conservation Servke
wind erosrort and crop failures; all (SCS) as part of the USDA.
dut was need(d was a long drought. Bennett as its first head. the
Such a drought occurred be- promoting sound conserva- to
tween 1926 and 1934. In the 1930s, tion practices. first in the Great
dust clouds created by hot, dry Plains states and later elsewhere.
windstorms darkened the sky at Soil conservation districts were GScat
midday in some areas; rabbits and formed throughout the coun:ry. and Do you a
birds choked to death on the dust. farmers and ranchers were given as a
During May 1934, the entire eastern technical assistance in setting up result of in
was blanketed by a
United States soil conservation programs,
countries, with at least 135 million people suffering Solutions How Can We Des«tißcatin?
from the effects of very scvcre desertification. If current The most to deett:ficatian is to
trends continue, within a few years desertification drastically reduce and
could threaten the livelihoods of 1 €2 billion people destructive forms mintng
Every year, low to moderate new desertification that ate to Name, additicw t?teS
OCCurs on an estimated 60,000 square kilometers grasses wi.n anchor sod u-a±cr while
square miles, an arca the size of West Virginia) desertificaticm and of warms
another
Of agricultural land; square kilometers ing (E•ction
square miles, an area the size of Kansas) un- Such prevention and would cost
dergo severe desertification and lose so much soil and 510--22 bilbott attnuany iot 20
fertility that they are no longer economically valuable penditure is consideraNy less than ettmated SC
for farming or grazing, billion annual loss agricuttu•rai trom
Figtre 14-19 Desertfcatjon of arid and semiarid lands. (Data from UN Environmental Programme and Harold E.
Drengue)
desertificd land; once this potential productivity is plants and ruins the land. According to a 1995 study,
restored, the cost of the program could be quickly severe salinization has reduced yields on of the
recouped. So far, less than Sl billion per year is spent world's irrigated cropland, and another has
globally to halt this form of land degradation. moderately salinized. The most severe salinization
curs in Asia, especially in China, India, and Pakistan.
now Do Excess Salts and Water Degrade Precipitation can desalinate soil, but this takes
Soils? The approximately 16% of the world's cropland thousands of years in arid and semiarid areas where
(almost equal to the area of India) that is now irrigated
irrigation is used. Salts can be flushed out of soil
by various methods (Figure 13-18) produces almost applying much more irrigation water than is
4(Y'/o of the world's food and may have to be expanded
for crop growth, but this practice increases pumptn*
to produce 50-75% of our food within the next 30 years.
and crop-production costs, wastes enormous amounts
Irrigated land can produce crop yields that are of water, and waterlogs plants if the water table rise
two to three times greater than those from rain water• close to the surface.
ing, but irrigation hag its downside. Moet irrigation
leavily salinized soil can also be renewexl by
water is a dilutc solution of various salts, picked up as ing the land out of production for 2 to 5 years, ilt•
358
controlling runoff.
How Can Conservation Tillage Reduce Soil In mountainous areas such as the Himalayas and
Erosion? Soil conservation involves reducing
the Andes, farmers traditionally built elaborate sys-
soil erosion and restoring soil fertility. For hundreds of
tems of terraces to grow crops. Today, however, some
Years, farmers have used various methods to reduce
of these slopes are being farmed without terraces, leav-
soil erosion, most of which involve keeping the soil
ing the land too nutrient poor to grow crops or gener-
covered with vegetation. ate new forest after only 10-40 years. Although most
In conventional-tillage farming the land is plowed
poor farmers know the risk of not terracing, many have
and then the soil is broken up and smoothed to make a
CHAITER 14 359
510 fre
Figure c•yz9e.
Ptessu;e,
Weat•r.g svess
EXTERNAL PROCERSES
IN TERNAL PROCESSES
Igneous Rock
Metamorphic Rock
pteotgo
quattt*e
(molten rxxÅ)
122
Z-lmet. Caff •The bctow.• t.
Disintegration of rock by mechanical weathering agents. Examples are anthracite (a form of coal), slate
accelerates chemical weathering by increasing the (Figure 5-12), and marble. Talc, asbestos, graphite,
surf•ce area that can be attacked by chemical weath- titanium, and some gems are also found in meta-
ering agents. This is similar to the way granulated morphic rocks.
sugar dissolves much faster than a large chunk
of sugar. Because chemical weathering is also aided
by higher temperatures and precipitation, it occurs
most rapidly in the tropics and next most rapidly in 1 5-8 SOIL: THE BASE OF LIFE
tempera te cli ma tes.
As deposited layers from weathering and erosion What Are the Major Layers Found in Mature
become buried and compacted, the resulting pressure Soils? The material we call soil is a complex mixture
causes their particles to bond together to form sedi- of eroded rock, mineral nutrients. decaying organic
mentary rocks such as sandQtone and shale. Some matter, water, air. and billions of living organisms,
sedimentary rocks, such as dolomite and limestone, most of them microscopic decomposers (Figure 5-13).
are formed from the compacted shells, skeletons, and Although soil is a potentially renewable resource. it is
other remains of dead organisms. Two types of coal— produced very slowly by the weathering oi rocks (Fig-
lignite and bituminous coal—are sedimentary rocks ure 5-11 deposit of sediments by erosion, and decom-
stone, for example, iG used ae cruched stone, as build- possible horizons (Figure 5•13).
ing stone, as flux in blast furnaces for smelting iron top layer, the surface-titter laver, or O horizon,
consist> mostly of freshly fallen anddecom-
partially
ore, and (with making l'ottland cement.
shale) for
Metamorphic rock is produced when a pre- posed leaves. twigs, animal waste, fungi, and other
organic materials. Normally, it is brown or black, The
existing tock is subjected to high temperatures
topsoil layer. or A horizon, is a porous mixture of par-
(which may cause it to melt partially), high pressures,
tially decomposed organic matter. called humus, and
chemically active fluids, or a combination Of those
123
it•ttif