Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Use of Virtual Media Laboratory in Increasing
The Use of Virtual Media Laboratory in Increasing
EMHADELIMA
E-mail : emhadelima@gmail.com
Received: 12th June 2015; Revised: 20th July 2015; Accepted: 24th July 2015
Abstract:The purpose of the study is to determine whether there is a significance effect on the use of Practicum
methods by using Crocodile Program combined with lectures, question and answer activities give significant
effect on students’ activities in learning electricity simple lesson and to identify whether the use of the
simulation lab provides better results than the traditional lab on learning outcomes. 36 natural science students
was involved in the study. The data was analyzed by using t-test. The finding showed that the use of Practicum
methods by using Crocodile Program combined with lectures; question and answer activities give significant
effect on students’ activities in learning electricity simple lesson. The finding also showed that the use of the
simulation lab can provide better results than the traditional lab on learning outcomes. It occurred when there is
an adequate software capability and students can operate the software properly. Without taking into account
about the cost of procurement of computers and software programs Crocodile, lab simulations are very low cost
because it does not need to purchase laboratory equipment, supplies and other consumables. It is expected that
Crocodile Program not only as a practical method to implement but also as a medium to explain the concepts of
electronic circuits.
How to Cite: Emhadelima. (2015). The Use of Virtual Media Laboratory in Increasing Students’ Motivation in
Learning Physics on Direct Current Circuits Materials in Class X MAN I Pekanbaru. Al-Ta Lim, 22(3).
doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.15548/jt.v22i3.147
the opportunity to actualize themselves, and improve the quality of student learning.
their ideas and the concepts they have. Considered to the practical activities in
Madrasah, it was found that the practicum
2. Commonly, physics is presented only as a
tools were inadequate and damaged, it caused
mere collection of formulas to be
frequent trouble in practicum activities in
memorized by students, finally when the
Madrasah, the Damage of the practical tool is
teacher evaluated the lesson, the formula
not comparable with the procurement of labor
becomes tangled in the minds of students.
each year.
3. In conveying the material, there is less
attention to the proportion of the material
and systematic delivery, and also it put
LITERATURE REVIEW
little emphasis on the basic concepts so
that, it made students difficult to The Nature of Physics and the Results of
understand. Studying Physics
4. The lack of variety in teaching as well as Physics at Madrasah aims to use
infrequent use of tool that can clarify the physics as a vehicle for understanding the
description of the students on the material physics concepts and their interrelationships,
being studied. and also be able to apply the concepts of
5. The tendency to complicate, rather than physics in scientific methods that involve the
simplify. This is often done in order the process skills to solve the problems in
students do not underestimate the lessons everyday life and develop attitudes and values
of Physics and Physics teacher of science. Thus, learning physics in
himself/herself. Madrasah includes the process of giving
6. learning methods used were less able to understanding of physics concepts,
motivate students to ask developing the ability to solve problems by
7. the material given to the students is an understanding concepts, developing skills and
advanced knowledge of material that has the ability to execute experiments, developing
been prepared and is not a material attitudes and values of science, developing
concerning to daily life interest and motivation, introducing the use of
8. Lack of an integrated concept among physics in daily life and technology. Teaching
other science and learning processes in Physics at least
9. Lack of specific devices and lab tools on include transferring information and
learning physics at Madrasah. understanding of the concept, doing practice
10. The lack of ability of the teachers in the questions and performing experiments in the
mastery of technology laboratory. However, the teaching learning
Related to the problem above, physics is process of physics often found in the field did
seen as a process and product at the same time not attempt an understanding of physics
so that the learning should consider strategies concepts, but rather providing information
or methods that effectively and efficiently. about the symptoms of physics and equations
One of the strategy or method is through and practice how to use these formulas.
practical activities. Through practical Therefore, the students just get used to
activities, students perform well by using memorize formulas without understanding its
mind and hand. Yet, to make the physics class meaning.
become more interesting and fun not only Learning outcomes is a process for
from the learning method but also tools in the determining the value of student learning
laboratory tools supporting the practical through assessment or measurement of
lesson. learning outcomes (Dimyati and Mudjiono,
Practicum in teaching physics has a role 1999). Measurement of learning outcomes
as a motivation in learning, giving students can be determined by using a test gauge.
the opportunity to develop a number of skills, Arikunto (1993) stated learning outcomes is a
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)
Emhadelima, The Use of Virtual Media Laboratory,... | 256
result obtained by the students following the control the anger and use time effectively.
learning process. The results are usually Motoric skills are the abilities related to
expressed in the form of numbers, letters or physical activities like driving a car, cycling
words very good, good, fair, less, and failed. and so on. It is added by Gagne (cited in
Dimyati and Mujiono (1999: 18) states that Ratna (1988)), motoric skills includes not
learning is an internal complex process. This only physical activity, but it is combined with
internal process involved the whole mental the intellectual skills, such as reading, writing,
that includes cognitive, affective and using a microscope and others. The last is
psychomotor. attitude. Attitude can affect a person's
behavior towards objects and other events.
Bloom (1956) cited by Ratna (1988) has
Attitude refers to an action that is
explained that the learning outcomes are
characterized by positive and negative
demonstrated objectives or expected behavior
reactions.
to be achieved in teaching a subject matter
that has been formulated in specific Romiszowski (1981) reported the
instructional objectives. learning achievement was obtained from
knowledge and skills. The Knowledge is
The learning process actualizing these
grouped into four sections, namely, facts,
values is focused on specific learning
concepts, procedures and principles.
materials. Learning is to acquire knowledge,
Knowledge is all the information that is
skills and planting mental attitude and values.
captured by someone’s senses and then stored
The achievement of learning objectives will
in the brain. Skills are an act or behavior of a
produce better learning outcomes. The Ability
person who is able to show a sign of the
as a result of learning can be grouped into five
skilled person. The fact is a real object, the
categories: 1) intellectual skills, 2) Cognitive
association of the fact that acquired through
Strategy, 3) verbal information, (4) motoric
observation. This is processed and presented
skill and (5) an attitude. (Gagne, 1989).
by scientists being the data. The concept is an
Intellectual skills are an ability that allows a
idea or a notion that generalized from certain
person to interact with the environment
relevant experiences. Principle is a
through the use of symbols or ideas, so that
generalization that includes concepts which
with the intellectual skills, one may know
are related and quality, correlation or
how to do something by using his thoughts.
axiomatic. The procedure is the knowledge of
Ratna revealed that learning intellectual skills
doing the actions step by step that are linear
has been started since the first levels of
or vary in achieving a goal. The essence of
primary school and continued by appropriate
learning is the students' actions and behavior
attention and intellectual abilities of a person.
which are complex. Students are the
Cognitive strategies are specific intellectual
determinant in the learning process effectively
skills that have a particular interest for
and efficiently. Students learning are driven
learning and thinking. Cognitive strategy is a
by curiosity or necessity.
process that controls the internal processes
used by students to choose and change the Learning outcomes should be effective,
ways of paying attention, learning, efficient and attractive. Effectiveness is
remembering and thinking. Verbal measured from the level of student
information is often also called verbal achievement both in quality and quantity;
knowledge is related to the ability to efficiency is measured by time needed by the
remember the information received, the words students to learn, while the attractiveness is
which were spoken by person, the reader, measured whether or not there is the tendency
listener and watcher. Verbal information is of students’ motivation to learn more
the result of learning at school and in the (Reigeluth, 1983). As the characteristics of
family, and this is a technique used by effective learning include (1) the achievement
students to focus and sustain attention, to of the learning program, (2) changes in
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)
257 | Volume 22, Number 3, November, 2015, Page 254-265
behavior, (3) a conducive learning conditions, so-called achievement test. The test results are
(4) the role of the teacher as facilitator, (5) the then expressed in the form of numbers, letters
use of appropriate time and (6) the student as or words very good, good, fair, less, and
the subject of study. Effectiveness was failed.
measured by the achievement of student Physics is a subject that is difficult for
learning outcomes. Dimyati and Mujiono most students and many studies show that
(1999) that studying physical knowledge, student learning outcomes in these subjects is
knowledge of mathematical logic and social very low. Thus the teacher must firstly
sciences includes three phases: (1) exploration understand the characteristics of the physic
(2) experience of the concept and, (3) subjects. This is as proposed by Beiser and
application of the concept. In the exploration Addison (1972) who states that physics is the
phase students learn the symptoms with the science of matter and this is a kind of
guidance, then, the experience concept. In this understanding of the nature and behavior of
phase, the students recognize the concept that the fundamental structure. As a science, it has
there is a relationship with the symptoms. In also shown that physical linkages with other
the application phase of concepts, students sciences. Furthermore, Morris Kline in
use the concepts to conduct further Suriasumantri (2001) stated that the physical
investigation on the other symptoms. characteristics include laws, the principle that
Information about the objectives study, can be done by induction or experiments.
reinforcement, evaluation and learning
success will lead students to be aware of their In addition, Kane (1978) states that the
abilities. According to Sardiman (2000) the concept of physics presents rules and laws /
results study includes, (a) matters of science proposition. Therefore one of the approach to
and knowledge, concepts or facts (cognitive), define the concept of physics is the physicists
(b) personal affairs, personality or attitude have to really try to understand the rules and
(affective), and (c) matters of behavior, skills laws / proposition. Also, Anderson and
(psychomotor ). Kautnik (1972) describe one of the
characteristics of good teaching and relevant
The Teacher planned in learning to science is that teachers should first think
activities outlined in the learning program is about the subject matter to be taught or to be
lead to the success of the students. This given to students.
reinforces the desire to become more
independent in learning to achieve the The other characteristics of physics is
learning goals and to achieve a level of through the subjects of physics, students are
independence. Teachers arrange learning expected to gain experience in the form of
events and try to reach the goal of learning, to reasoning ability and mathematical
improve the cognitive abilities, effective and quantitative deductive based on a qualitative
psychomotor, in achieving the goal of the analysis by using various concepts of physics.
education or the learning. According to (Depdiknas, 2001). For this reason, Kember
Bloom (1961), quoted by Dimyati and (2001) explains that efforts to improve
Mujiono (1999) there are facts, concepts, learning outcomes require a wide variety of
theories in a particular subject, or have student learning approaches. This means that
priority on using method of solving the the ability of the teachers and the students’
problems such as the use of formulas, performance. The performance of the teacher
learning tools, and the discovery process should be innovative in their performance.
skills approach. Budikase and Kertiasa (1995) states that
The learning outcomes covered three physics is a science that requires a lot more
domains include the cognitive, affective and understanding than memorizing, so that, the
psychomotor. To measure the learning students can be said successful in learning
outcomes, it is required measurement or the physics when he was able to master the three
main points in physics, namely the concepts,
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)
Emhadelima, The Use of Virtual Media Laboratory,... | 258
principles and theories. A student can be said derived from Latin and is the plural form of
understand the physic lesson if the student can the word "medium" which literally means
demonstrate its ability to implement the "intermediary" is an intermediary source of
principal of physics. Moreover, as stated by the message (a source) to the message
the Ministry of Education (2001) that after the receiver (a receiver). Heinich exemplifies this
students follow courses in physics, the media such as movies, television, charts,
students are expected to have the ability and printed material, computers, and instructors.
attitude such as: (1) positive attitude toward The examples of media can be considered as a
science of physics as a quantitative basis, (2) medium of learning if carrying messages in
the ability to apply the concepts and order to achieve learning objectives. Heinich
principles of physics in explaining various also links between media messages and
natural phenomena as well as the workings of methods.
technology, and how to solve problems, (3) At the beginning of the learning history,
the emergence of a scientific attitude, which a media is simply a tool that is used by a
is an open and critical attitude towards the teacher to help the teacher in explaining
other opinions, and not easily believe of the lesson. The first tools used in teaching
statement which is not supported by the physics is visual aids, which can provide a
empirical proof, and (5) the ability to study visual experience to students, to encourage
science at universities or attend various them to learn, to clarify and simplify abstract
trainings that require basic skill of physics. concepts, and to enhance absorption or
From the various opinions above, it can retention of learning. Then, by the
be concluded that a student is successful in development of technology, particularly audio
learning physics if the student changes their technology, in the middle of the 20th century
point of view on physics, such as students it was born the tool of audio-visual aids which
can master the concepts, principles and are primarily using concrete experience to
principles of physics. Also, this knowledge avoid verbalism. In using the media as a tool,
can be applied to explain various phenomena Edgar Dale held a classification according to
the level of the most concrete to the most
Media
abstract.
According to Heinich (1993) media is a
tool of communication channels. Media is
The above classification is known as the In the late 1950s the theory of
"cone of experience" from Edgar Dale and at communication began to affect the use of
the time, it was widely adopted in media, so that, the function of the media as
determining the most appropriate tools for the handy tool also can be functioned as a
learning experience. sending message. Then, by the influence of
the behavior theory by BF Skinner, since
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)
259 | Volume 22, Number 3, November, 2015, Page 254-265
1960 learning objectives shifted toward the the meaning. This sort of thing will lead to
change of students' behavior, because misperceptions of the students. Therefore,
according to this theory, people learning are students should have more concrete
by changing their behavior. A programmed experience so the message can actually
learning is a product of Skinner's flow. achieve the goals and objectives. In general,
the media have utility:
The development of instructional media
is following the development of educational 1. Clarify the message that is not too
technology. If we analyzed further, the verbalistics.
development paradigm in education 2. Overcome the limitations of space, time,
technology affect the development of energy and resources senses.
instructional media. They are as follows: 3. Emerge the excitement in learning, direct
interaction between pupils with learning
1. In the first paradigm, learning media is the
resources.
same as audio-visual aids used by
4. Allow children to learn independently
instructors to carry out their duties.
according to their talents and abilities of
2. In the second paradigm, the media is seen
visual, auditory and kinesthetic.
as something that developed
5. Provide the same stimulus, likening the
systematically and adhering to the rules of
experience and creating the same
communication.
perceptions.
3. In the third paradigm, the media is seen as
an integral part in the learning system and In addition, the contribution of
therefore calls for changes in the other learning media according to Kemp and
components in the learning process. Dayton, 1985:
4. Learning media, in the fourth paradigm, is 1. Delivering the learning message can be
seen as one of the sources who standardized
intentionally and aims to develop and or 2. Learning can be more attractive
used for learning purposes. 3. Learning becomes more interactive by
Even a prominent American architect, applying learning theory
Buckminster Fuller, in Haney & Ulmer, stated 4. The timing of the learning can be
that the media is the third parents (teachers shortened
are the second parents). Indonesia had already 5. Quality of learning can be improved
begun to use the trend by broadcasting 6. The process of learning can take place
education by private TV "Televisi Pendidikan whenever and wherever it is needed
"( Education Television) to the entire country 7. A positive attitude of students towards
since 1991. learning materials and the learning
process can be improved
With the conception of the more stable,
8. The role of the teacher change in a
the function of media in learning activities not
positive one
only as aids for the teacher, but also as a
carrier of information or messages that fit to Instructional media functions can be
the learning needs. Thus a teacher can focus emphasized from the following points:
its work on the other aspects such as 1. The use of instructional media is not an
individual guidance and counseling activities additional function, but it has its own
in the learning activities. function as aids to create a more effective
The acquisition of students’ knowledge learning situations.
as depicted by Edgar Dale in Cone experience 2. Learning media is an integral part of the
that the knowledge will be more abstract if overall learning process. This implies that
the message conveyed through verbal word. the learning media as one of the
This means that students only know about and components that does not stand alone but
understand the words without understanding interconnected with other components in
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)
Emhadelima, The Use of Virtual Media Laboratory,... | 260
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)
261 | Volume 22, Number 3, November, 2015, Page 254-265
making a hypothesis. In this case the produced theory cannot be given just by
simulation taken from the word "stimulatory" providing information, but it should provide a
is defined as media for testing an experiment real experience through experimentation. As
or trial as if as the original one stated by Nurhadi (2002), knowledge is not a
set of facts, concepts, or rules that are ready to
be taken and remembered.
The Relationship of Virtual Media with
Humans must construct knowledge and
Learning Motivation
give meaning through real experience. Yet,
The laboratory that is in the form of experiments in electronics require much cost
software is run by a computer. All the because it takes a lot of components and
equipment needed by a laboratory contained instruments which are relatively expensive.
in the software. By having a computer lab and Therefore, the electric practicum in physics in
a variety of software simulation lab, it means MAN 1 Pekanbaru was conducted using a
that the school is that the school has a variety panel system. On the panel system, a series
of other laboratories such as laboratories of that will be studied or characteristic has made
physics, chemistry, biology, mathematics, permanently on the circuit board. Student task
language, art and others depending on the is to perform the measurement of various
kinds of software owned. parameters on the circuit. The weakness of
One example of virtual laboratory this system is students cannot change the
software is Crocodile Program. By using value of the resistor and capacitor
Crocodile program we can make a variety of components into the variable shape; the panel
electronic circuits virtually on the computer made is very limited, the value of the
screen, perform measurements, and perform component can be changed so it changes the
various analyses on the circuit. Crocodile output characteristics, and the students cannot
program is equipped with various input design its own system and cannot modify the
sources such as batteries, an AC voltage circuit. As a result, the student's ability in
source, Vcc source, FM source; various basic analyzing the characteristics and designing
components such as resistors, capacitors, electronic circuits is low. To overcome the
relays, switches and transformers; various above problems, it can be used by simulating
diodes including DIAC, triac, LED and Zener a software program called the Crocodile. By
diodes; various indicators such as: voltmeter, using CROCODILE PROGRAM we can
ammeter, and a variety of other instruments. make a variety of electronic circuits virtually
on the computer screen, perform
measurements, and perform various analyses
The Practical Simulation by using on the circuit.
Crocodile Program The aim of this study is to look at the
Next, it will describe the author's effect of the use of simulation software lab
experience in implementing virtual labs by using crocodile on students' ability to analyze
using CROCODILE software to improve the and design the circuit electronics. Computers
analysis and design of electronic circuits on a simulations have become a part of educational
student in a physics lab at MAN 1 Pekanbaru. reformation, redefining the role of teachers
One of the students' learning objectives and reshaping the learning experience in the
electronics in Physical courses is to develop classroom according to the National Science
the ability to analyze the characteristics and to Education Standard (NSES) and the National
design electronic circuits for various Science Teachers Association (NSTA)
applicable needed. Electronics has two main (2001). Science simulation can be used as an
aspectsin learning, namely the theoretical effective tool to help students understand and
aspects and practical aspects. Both of these apply the practical experience in scientific
aspects are interrelated, the ideas that thinking (Akpan, 2001); Akpan & Andre,
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)
Emhadelima, The Use of Virtual Media Laboratory,... | 262
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)
263 | Volume 22, Number 3, November, 2015, Page 254-265
involved in the study. The data was analyzed students encountered difficulties in
by using t-test. learning physics because of several
problems that become common problems
of learning physics in Indonesia as has
RESEARCH FINDINGS AND been shown in the background.
DISCUSSION 3. When the delivery of content by using the
The results of the implementation of Crocodile Program and combining with
learning by using CROCODILE PROGRAM the method of question and answer, to
is obtained from the observation during the explain what the circuit in series and
students carried out practice and analytical parallel.
skills test circuit and test of the ability of 4. What the advantages and disadvantages of
designing circuits in writing. The indicators each form of the circuit were.
of the ability in conducting an analysis of 5. Determine the amount of component
electronic circuits is determined by the ability values, strong currents and voltages
of using various parameters on the circuit as occurred.
the strong current, voltage and power at 6. When applying it in the form of test, it
certain points, in a circuit and others. was found the difficulties because of poor
Indicator of the ability to design circuits math skills.
includes the ability to plan a series of series 7. When giving exercises on simple electric
and parallel well. The good chain will be able circuit, the students found difficulties to
to produce the correct current and voltage. finish it but it could be overcome because
they were helped by some students who
From the observation and statistical have sufficient math skills, teachers and
analysis of data was obtained data asshown in other colleagues.
Table Simulation lab using Crocodile
Program with lab using both panel on boys Based on the observations at the first
and girls. Simulation lab using Crocodile activities, the general implementation of
Program gives a better effect than the lab learning can be carried out in accordance with
using a panel method for both the boys and the teaching plan that has been made. Based
girls. From the learning activities and on the observation of the students, it was
observations, the data were obtained as found that students are more active and
follows: motivated in learning activities and are very
interested with the displayed tools.
1. Lessons can be started in accordance with
the specified schedule Based on the initial questionnaire given
2. When a discussion is conducted with to students before teachers starting a lesson,
students about physics lessons, most the data were obtained as follows:
Note: The number of students who filled out the questionnaire was 36 students
From the table I, it can be seen that (point 2). Additional information obtained
80% of students stated they had got the lesson from the above data is that students like to ask
on the simple electronics though the level of questions and learn the teacher and friend
understanding of it was still low. Only 55% of rather than learning by themselves (point 6)
students stated that only understand the though some students still expressed more
material presented. It means there are 45% of enjoyable learning to the friend than that to
students who do not understand the lesson teachers.
presented. While the level of interest or Based on the final questionnaire given
concern and pleasure students to the lesson to the students after learning activities,
was high reaching 100% (point 7) and 100% obtained the following data :
From the table above, it can be seen that the output of the circuit is not in accordance
generally students of class XII IPA 1 in MAN with desired.
1 Pekanbaru have positive attitudes towards Based on the results of questionnaires
the use of learning by inquiry model with
known that students felt freely and creatively
emphasizing practice method by using to design a variety of electronic circuits
Crocodile Program and also combined with without having to take into account the cost of
lectures, discussions, and question and purchasing the components.
answer. With the model of the lesson,
students easily understood the material
presented. The level of understanding of CONCLUSION AND
students has increased from 55% to 80%. RECOMMENDATION
The time required to carry out the It can be concluded that the use of
experiment is much shorter compared to using Practicum methods by using Crocodile
actual components. In the same time, the Program combined with lectures, question
output of parameters of the design can be and answer brings significant effect on
immediately known and the circuit can be students’ activities in learning activities in
immediately repaired or value of the electricity simple lesson.
components can be replaced immediately if
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)
265 | Volume 22, Number 3, November, 2015, Page 254-265
© 2015 by Al-Ta'lim All right reserved. This work is licensed under (CC-BY-NC-ND)