Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pornography Effects On Academic Performances
Pornography Effects On Academic Performances
Pornography Effects On Academic Performances
Promise Tewogbola
An Abstract of
a Thesis
W
Health Sciences and Social Work
IE
Western Illinois University
EV
In Partial Fulfilment
PR
Master of Science
By
Promise Tewogbola
December 2018
ProQuest Number: 13421287
All rights reserved
INFORMATION TO ALL USERS
The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted.
In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript
and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed,
a note will indicate the deletion.
W
IE
EV
ProQuest 13421287
Published by ProQuest LLC (2019 ). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author.
All rights reserved.
PR
This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code
Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC.
ProQuest LLC.
789 East Eisenhower Parkway
P.O. Box 1346
Ann Arbor, MI 48106 - 1346
ABSTRACT
Pornography is a public health issue that is prevalent among youths of college
age, with empirical research revealing many negative effects on the human brain.
Currently, there are few studies examining the association between pornography
consumption and academic performance. This study aimed to investigate the relationship
between the pornography consumption habits of college students and their academic
students (210 male, 156 female) and their academic performances was analyzed by using
W
with the Problematic Pornography Use Scale (Kor, A., Zilcha-Mano, Fogel, Mikulincer,
IE
Reid, & Potenza, 2014), while their academic performances were measured with the
Academic Success Inventory (Prevatt, Li, Welles, Festa-Dreher, Yelland, & Lee, 2011)
EV
and grade point averages. The results showed that the more frequently college students
consumed pornography, the less likely they were to expend their efforts on their school
work (r = -0.30762, p < 0.001). The results also suggested that the more frequently
PR
college students consumed pornography, the lower their grade point averages are likely to
be (r = -0.19050, p < 0.001). Additionally, the results showed that the more frequently
college students consumed pornography, the more likely they were to experience
pornography consumption (r = 0.34945, p < 0.001). From a mental health perspective, the
findings of this study reveal the need for public health stakeholders and policy makers to
consider the effect that pornography consumption has on the academic performance of
college students.
PR
EV
IE
W
The Effect of Pornography Use on the Academic Performance of College Students
Promise Tewogbola
A Thesis
W
Western Illinois University
IE
EV
In Partial Fulfilment
Master of Science
By
Promise Tewogbola
December 2018
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Firstly, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my advisor Dr. Jamie Johnson for
the continuous support of my research, for his patience, motivation, and immense
practical knowledge. His guidance helped me in literally every step of this thesis. I could
not have imagined having a better advisor and mentor for this stage of my academic
career.
Besides my advisor, I would like to thank the rest of my thesis committee: Dr. Lorette
Oden and Dr. Maureen Bezold, for their insightful comments, corrections and
W
encouragement.
IE
I also want to thank my fellow classmates, Mr. Ibrahim Ijale and Mrs. Uyiosa Chukwuka,
who went through this rigorous research process with me. I appreciate you guys for the
EV
stimulating discussions, for the sleepless nights we were working together before
deadlines, and for all the fun we have had these past two years.
PR
love, inspiration, guidance and encouragement. I would like to thank my parents, Pastor
& Mrs. M. O. Tewogbola for their constant spiritual support, love and prayers. I also
want to thank Miss Myya Robinson for her undiluted love, constant care, and relentless
emotional support.
Last, but not the least, I want to appreciate God, the source of all wisdom, knowledge,
understanding, power, might and love. He has brought me this far, and I am excited about
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................. ii
Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1
W
Purpose of the Study ..................................................................................................... 3
Limitations ..................................................................................................................... 9
PR
Assumptions ................................................................................................................... 9
Definitions .................................................................................................................... 10
Performance ................................................................................................................. 23
Summary ...................................................................................................................... 24
CHAPTER 3. METHODS...............................................................................................25
Purpose ......................................................................................................................... 25
Research Design........................................................................................................... 25
W
Research Questions ..................................................................................................... 26
Purpose ......................................................................................................................... 32
Statement of Problem.................................................................................................. 60
Purpose ......................................................................................................................... 60
W
Pornography Consumption, Functional and Behavioral Problems .................... 67
APPENDIX A ...................................................................................................................90
PR
APPENDIX B ...................................................................................................................96
v
LIST OF TABLES
W
SUCCESS INVENTORY .......................................................................................... 42
INVENTORY ............................................................................................................ 56
vi
1
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
Introduction
pornography is a public health hazard because of the different studies that have revealed
individuals, families and even communities (Dines, 2016). To put this into perspective,
W
more than 1 in every 5 searches on Google’s mobile search engine is associated with
pornography (Kamvar & Baluja, 2006). The figures about use of pornography, especially
IE
among college students, are astonishing. In a study of 813 college students from schools
in the United States, 21.3% of the young men studied said that they viewed pornographic
EV
material every day (Carroll et al., 2008). In another survey of 29,000 students at North
American universities, a whopping 64% of the college men said they spent time watching
PR
online pornography every week (Leahy, 2009). Even more alarming, a study conducted
among 800 students from the University of Sidney revealed that 47% of the students
spent between 30 minutes and 3 hours every day on pornography (Szittner, 2012).
Studies have shown that college students spend a lot of time watching
pornography (Carroll et al., 2008; Leahy, 2009; Szittner, 2012). They have also revealed
that there are associations between pornography consumption and stress, anxiety,
depression, and social malfunctioning (Levin, Lillis & Hayes, 2012); impaired sexual
tastes and reduced satisfaction from relationships (Morgan, 2011); poor health and
1
reduced quality of life (Weaver et al., 2011), as well as, intimacy issues (Philaretou,
changes in the brain’s grey matter and reward areas. This is the primary reason this study
presence and degrees of correlations between pornography use and the variables that
W
Pornography is a public health issue that is prevalent among youths of college
age. This is a trend that will continue because pornography is a form of supernormal
IE
stimulation (Barrett, 2010) that thrives on factors such as accessibility and novelty, which
EV
have been proven to cause changes in the brain (Krebs, Heipertz & Duzel, 2011; Spicer et
al., 2007).
PR
empirical research. For instance, Kühn and Gallinat (2014) observed that there was an
association between the amount of time spent watching pornography and reductions in
the amount of grey matter in the rewards centers responsible for motivation and decision-
making. They also discovered that an increase in the amount of time spent watching
pornography would lead to weakening of the nerve connections between the prefrontal
cortex and reward areas. Kühn and Gallinat (2014) reported that the weakening of the
2
However, since there have been few studies showing direct associations between
pornography consumption and academic performance, this study was designed to provide
a better understanding of how the use of pornography among college age students is
The purpose of this study was to discover the impact of pornography use on the
and the Quad Cities campuses. The findings from this study provided a clearer picture of
W
the associations between the use of pornography among college students and their
academic performance while also providing a basis for key stakeholders in the public
IE
health sector to take proactive measures towards containing the looming pornography
epidemic. Having said that, the findings of this study could potentially provide college
EV
students the opportunity to make educated choices with respect to their physical,
psychological, emotional and mental wellbeing, such that they are able to lead fruitful
PR
The findings of this study filled a crucial gap in the literature pertaining to the
associations between the use of pornography and poor academic performance among the
youths of college age. This is because the world is in the internet age where access to
pornography has considerably increased with more people rendered incapable of reducing
or stopping its consumption (Stark & Klucken, 2017). For instance, a study that tried to
compare pornography users with those who did not watch pornography was thwarted
3
because the experimenters did not find a single college student who had not viewed
The role of the youth in any society cannot be overemphasized. They are a
fundamental part of any society’s posterity and their academic performance is a factor
that can make them eligible to fill key positions of economic significance in the nearest
future (Kell, Lubinski, & Benbow, 2013). A longitudinal study conducted by Kell,
Lubinski, and Benbow (2013) tracked 320 academically excellent students from the ages
of 13 to 38. The results from the study revealed that many of them went on to hold
W
important positions of leadership and were assigned responsibilities crucial for individual
and organizational growth and development (Kell, Lubinski, & Benbow, 2013). Studies
IE
have also revealed that college graduates with academic success are more likely to be
gainfully employed, have stable jobs, and earn more money, while being less likely to
EV
engage in illegal activities (Rentner & Kober, 2001; National Alliance of Business Inc.,
1998). Unfortunately, many youths do not stand a chance since studies have shown that
PR
poor academic performances can destabilize the life course of an individual, ultimately
because of its ease of accessibility (McAllister, 2017) and this should raise genuine
concerns in the public health sector. Kühn and Gallinat (2014) discovered that there is a
relationship between pornography consumption and low motivation levels, poor decision-
making skills, as well as, an inability to delay gratification. These are factors that may
ultimately affect the academic performance of college students. On the other hand,
abstinence from pornography has been associated with an increase in the ability to delay
4
gratification (Sproten, 2016). There are very few studies that seek to explore the
relationship between pornography use and academic performance. This could be because
pornography is a stigmatized topic which very few researchers are willing or capable of
high levels of depressive moods among pornography consumers (Skinner, 2011; Walton,
Cantor, & Lykins, 2017). These depressive moods may lead college students to remain in
isolation while not being in the right frame of mind to show up in class. Hysenbegasi,
W
Hass, and Rowland (2005) observed that depression was associated with decreases in
performance of one’s working memory (Laier, Schulte, & Brand, 2013). To show the
students with a low working memory capacity were more likely to lose focus when they
faced challenging tasks. On the other hand, individuals with higher working memory
capacity chose to keep their minds on the task at hand, rather than daydreaming (Kane et
(ADHD) and normal control students revealed that working memory is associated with
academic performance and can severely impact the ability of college students to perform
5
Pornography consumption has been also associated with an unwillingness to
interact and integrate with others socially (Boies, Cooper, & Osborne, 2004). Researchers
have observed that individuals who manifested social anxiety and selective mutism were
less likely to do well on mathematics tests (Edison et al., 2011). Further studies have
especially when it involved lecturers and other students (Russell, 2008; Topham, 2009).
Studies carried out by Laier and Brand (2017) reported that the use of
pornography could negatively affect one’s general feeling of wellbeing, while making the
W
pornography users more likely to be stressed out. In addition, pornography use has also
been found to be related with poor quality of life, as well as low self-esteem (Leppink,
IE
Chamberlain, Redden, & Grant, 2016). In a Pakistani study, the researchers observed that
there were positive correlations between self-esteem and the academic achievement of 80
EV
college students (Arshad, Zaidi, & Mahmood, 2015). The results obtained from a study
by Rosli et al. (2012) also revealed that college students with high self-esteem perform
PR
better in their academics than those with low self-esteem. This present study shed more
inadequacy, poor social interactions, poor quality of life, and low self-esteem, the number
performance is astonishingly low. Thus, the findings from this study uncovered a clearer
performance. This knowledge could potentially help health policy makers, health
6
educators and, health and educational administrators develop more proactive measures,
interventions and programs that will safeguard the loss of the future’s workforce to the
menace of pornography.
Moreover, the results of this study will equip college students with the knowledge
needed to make educated decisions that will contribute to their all-round health and
wellbeing. This is in line with the explanations given by Glanz, Rimer, and Viswanath
W
condition would have potentially serious consequences, believe that a course of
Research Questions
For this study, the following questions were addressed to shed more light on the
college students?
7
4. Is pornography consumption associated with functional and behavioral problems
in college students?
Delimitations
Macomb and the Quad Cities, Illinois. First of all, the researcher is currently
W
representative sample population from the college students enrolled in the same
school. Diverse studies have consistently reported that there are physical,
IE
behavioral, and, neurological differences between males and females (DuBois,
EV
2017). Therefore, this present study explores the degree of impact gender has on
2. College students with mobile phones or laptops, and access to the Internet.
Pornography is accessed through the Internet (Maas, 2010) and members of the
population group of interest typically stay connected to the Internet through their
mobile phones and laptops. In addition, primary data for this study was obtained
through an online survey which can only be accessed through Internet connection
3. College students who have completed at least one semester of the 2017-2018
academic year and are currently enrolled for the current semester. This is because
8
Gibson, & Rankin, 2015), which college students start to accumulate only after
4. Though this study is not intended to be a full-blown intervention, there was a brief
health education session at the end of the questionnaire which is based upon the
Limitations
1. The study sample did not include college students from other universities and
W
colleges in Illinois.
IE
2. The study did not consider other sources of pornography besides the Internet.
EV
3. Members of the target population might have been uncomfortable with answering
habits.
PR
4. The study relied on self-reported data from the sample which may introduce bias.
Assumptions
1. The inclusion criteria are appropriate, and the participants of the study are aware
2. The participants of the study will cooperate to answer the interview questions
9
Definitions
a person has accomplished specific goals that were the focus of activities in instructional
Grey Matter. Tissue of the central nervous system composed of neuronal cell
W
It often involves the depiction of erotic behavior (as in pictures or writing) intended to
for the temporarily holding information to process it (Miyake & Shah, 1999).
10
CHAPTER TWO
General Introduction
Less than a year after the Utah House of Representatives passed their resolution
affirming the public harm that pornography constitutes, the legislative arm of three other
US states (South Dakota, Virginia and Tennessee) had also passed resolutions to curb the
pornography epidemic (Bado, 2017; Dines, 2016; Richmond, 2017; Waltman, 2017). The
W
atmosphere of anonymity, accessibility and affordability in which its users enjoy
IE
(Cooper, 2000). One of the biggest pornographic sites, reported that in 2016 alone, over
92 billion pornography videos were downloaded from its site, with 99 GB of data
EV
streamed every second (Pornhub, 2017). This is enough data to fill 194 million 16 GB
USB sticks (Pornhub, 2017). To put this into sharper focus, it has been reported that
$3,075.64 is spent viewing pornography every single second, with no less than 28,258
PR
people viewing pornography in the same period, a single second (Ropelato, 2007; Tarver,
2010). Popular pornography site, Pornhub, bragged that among the vast amounts of
people who viewed pornography from its site, over 60% of them were within the ages of
18 and 24, which interestingly coincides with the typical age of most college students
(Pornhub, 2017).
Aside from the fact that college students waste valuable time watching
pornography (Carroll et al., 2008; Leahy, 2009; Szittner, 2012) rather than engaging in
academic activities, pornography may also be associated with neurological changes that
11
may impair mental health outcomes, including memory and cognition capabilities (Boies,
Cooper, & Osborne, 2004; Mesch, 2009; Philaretou, Mahfouz, & Allen, 2005; Svedin,
Åkerman, & Priebe, 2011; Tsitsika et al., 2009; Weaver et al., 2011; Yoder, Virden III, &
Amin, 2005).
This chapter is divided into five sections. The first section will place more focus
on the structure and function of the brain from cellular levels, all the way up to the brain
as an organ. The second section will deal with the changes that occur in the brain because
of pornography consumption. The third section will describe academic performance and
W
the various factors that affect academic performance. The fourth section will focus on the
effects of pornography consumption on males and females. Finally, the fifth section will
IE
present available research tying pornography consumption with academic performance.
college age. More youths are falling victim to pornography’s onslaught, given that its use
PR
thrives on anonymity, accessibility and affordability (Cooper, 2000). There have been
documented reports of the negative effects of pornography on the brain (Kühn &
Gallinat, 2014). However, there have not been many studies showing direct associations,
if any, between pornography use and academic performance. Therefore, the study was
concerned with understanding how pornography use among college age students is
imperative to first understand the way the brain functions at a cellular level (Gordon,
12
2002). This would clarify how brain cells form connections with each other, while also
adjusting to changes in their environment (Gordon, 2002). It is also important to note that
the brain is not a fixed structure but an actively changing system that reacts in diverse
manners to adjust to changes in its environment (Gordon, 2002). This fact makes it easier
to understand why the brain can rewire itself through the process of neuronal plasticity
(Gordon, 2002).
Neurons are cells in the brain which are responsible for all its activities (Gordon,
2002). There are more than 100 billion neurons which communicate and interact with
W
each other in the brain (Gordon, 2002). These neurons can be grouped into sensory
neurons that send input into the brain, interneurons that form connections with numerous
IE
other kinds of cells, motor neurons that facilitate movement, as well as neuroendocrine
Typically, the interaction between neurons starts when input in the form of
neurotransmitters from one neuron attaches itself to specific receptors located on the
PR
dendrites of the next neuron (Gordon, 2002). When the neurotransmitters reach the
dendrites, they facilitate the movement of information from the dendrites to the cell body
of the receiving neuron (Gordon, 2002). This results in the generation of electric signals
within the receiving neuron which travel through its axon to the terminals from where it
is released into the synapse that is present in between its axon terminal and the next
on or off to facilitate the creation of new proteins to improve its efficiency and cover for
13
imbalances to the original homeostatic state (Gordon, 2002). Therefore, neurons will
continue to fire at abnormal levels for a while even after the homeostatic disrupting
factors have been removed (Gordon, 2002). Examples of this phenomenon typically
Neuronal plasticity occurs to a large extent during the developmental stage of life.
This is because there are many connections present between the neurons in the brain
(Gordon, 2002). The implication of this is that there are stronger and more accurate
synaptic connections between neurons that lead to a more effective flow of information
W
and more efficiency in the workings of the various sensory and motor processes (Gordon,
2002). This, however, does not mean that neuronal plasticity is limited to the
IE
developmental stages of life, as the capacity of the brain to rewire itself is maintained
transmission (Gordon, 2002). There are at least 100 specific molecules that are
PR
designated to easing signaling between cells in the brain (Gordon, 2002). It is not easy to
identify these molecules due to the complex structure of the brain, the stupendous
amounts of synapses, as well as the sheer number of these signaling molecules (Gordon,
2002). While there is no neat classification of these chemical signaling molecules, they
can be classified into small molecule transmitters and large molecule transmitters
(Gordon, 2002). The small molecule transmitters are also called classical transmitters and
dopamine; and the amino acids such as gamma-aminobutyric acid and glycine (Gordon,
2002). The large group transmitters are generally polypeptides with chains that are 3 – 50
14