Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Creative Non-Fiction: Evaluating and Revising A Short Fiction
Creative Non-Fiction: Evaluating and Revising A Short Fiction
Creative Non-Fiction
Quarter 1 - Modules 5 & 6:
Evaluating and Revising a Short Fiction
Specialized Subject – Creative Non-Fiction
Supplementary Learning Material
Quarter 1 – Evaluating and Revising a Short Fiction
First Edition, 2020
Republic Act 8293, section 176 states that: No copyright shall subsist in any
work of the Government of the Philippines. However, prior approval of the
government agency or office wherein the work is created shall be necessary for
exploitation of such work for profit. Such agency or office may, among other
things, impose as a condition the payment of royalties.
Management Team:
Gregorio C. Quinto, Jr., EdD
Chief, Curriculum Implementation Division
Glenda S. Constantino
Project Development Officer II
Joannarie C. Garcia
Librarian II
This module was collaboratively designed, developed and reviewed by educators from public
institutions to assist you, the teacher or facilitator, in helping the learners meet the standards set by
the K to 12 Curriculum while overcoming their personal, social, and economic constraints in
schooling.
This learning resource hopes to engage the learners into guided and independent learning activities
at their own pace and time. Furthermore, this also aims to help learners acquire the needed 21st
century skills while taking into consideration their needs and circumstances.
In addition to the material in the main text, you will also see this box in the body of the module:
As a facilitator, you are expected to orient the learners on how to use this module. You also need
to keep track of the learners’ progress while allowing them to manage their own learning.
Furthermore, you are expected to encourage and assist the learners as they do the tasks included
in the module.
This module was designed to provide you with fun and meaningful opportunities for guided and
independent learning at your own pace and time. You will be enabled to process the contents of
the learning resource while being an active learner.
1
This is a brief drill or review to help you link the
What’s In
current lesson with the previous one.
2
What I Need to Know
What I Know
Modified True or False. Write True if the statement is correct. If not, underline the word or
phrase which makes it incorrect, then write the correct word or phrase.
3
What’s In
Before we proceed with our lesson, let us find out if you can recall the topics we had
in our previous discussion. In your last module, we dug deep on Short Fiction Writing. You
were asked to write your own Short Fiction by following the pointers discussed.
Direction: Matching Type. Now, prove your understanding of Short Fiction by matching its
elements in Column A to their corresponding samples in Column B. Write the letter of your
answer on the given space before each number.
COLUMN A COLUMN B
1. Character a. An enchanting afternoon by the purest of all
streams where most of the town’s children
play
2. Setting b. A mother’s love
3. Plot c. Her son was missing, and with that in mind her
entire world collapsed. For a second, her heart
forgot its own beating.
4. Theme d. Mother and world
5. Conflict e. A mother of three
What’s New
Spot the difference! Identify five differences which make Image B incorrect by writing the
faulty numbers on the blanks.
A B
1. is smaller in Image B.
2. is slanted in Image B.
3. in Image A became in Image B.
4. is repeated in Image B.
5. is underlined in Image B.
4
What is It
What you did in the What’s New, wherein you identified the numbers which made
Image B incorrect, is a direct analogy of our target in this module. At this point, as you have
already written your Short Fiction in the previous module, your new task is to evaluate
someone else’s Short Fiction. The goal is for you to learn how to spot points for improvement
by means of clarity of idea and choice and use of literary elements.
Clarity of Ideas
A fiction, or any other literary genre, may be considered clear if it can easily be
understood by the target readers. Hence, we shall carefully look at the choice of words,
redundancy, and flow. Let us study each factor one by one.
1. Diction – This pertains to the writer’s choice of words. To achieve clarity, it is of utmost
importance to choose the words which are appropriate to the level of reading abilities
of the target readers. That is, if a story is intended for Kindergarten pupils, make sure
that the words are simple and common. On the other hand, if a story is to be read by
Senior High School Students, then opt for words which are suited to their abilities.
3. Organization – This refers to how the story was sequenced and how well are they
connected, from the exposition down to the denouement. If a story does not follow a
logical sequence or format, the readers may find themselves confused and worst,
uninterested in the story. Hence, it is important to identify how united the parts are, so
that they all tell the same concepts.
4. Grammar and Punctuations – This covers how knowledgeable the writer is when it
comes to the usage of the English language in writing. For clarity, all sentences should
follow the standards of English grammar, as well as the rules in punctuation marks.
5
Choice and Use of Literary Elements
In the previous module, we discussed about the elements of a Short Fiction. Today,
let us identify the pointers to consider to ascertain that the elements we have chosen and used
are appropriate or not.
1. The characters are carefully selected. Their personalities and attributes are of great
influence as they add color to the storyline. None of them are irrelevant to the flow
of the story as they perform their purposes rightfully.
2. The setting is fitting to the story, the characters, the theme, and the target readers.
It is also explained in such a way that the readers’ senses are stimulated.
3. The parts of the plot are relevant. None of them may be removed from the storyline
as they greatly affect other the other parts. They are also not too obvious nor too
out of context. They stick to the theme and bear with them necessary scenes to
complete the story.
4. The theme is age appropriate to the readers. The overall idea of the story is
interesting, gender-sensitive, and socially-relevant in such a way that the readers
can relate based on their probable experiences in accordance with their ages.
Revising a Draft
Parallel to evaluation, another skill that you have to develop is revising a draft. Simply, a
draft is a preliminary writing inputs of your original paper. This is called a draft since it naturally
requires a second look to check if your writing is noteworthy. Seemingly, revising is simply
reading while scrutinizing a certain literary piece or draft. Here are some pointers that may
help you in revising a draft.
1. Read the literary thoroughly. While reading, jot down terms that you cannot grasp.
Later, use a Dictionary or try to contextualize to obtain the meaning of the terms.
2. Organize your thoughts. Think as if you are talking.
3. Work by chunks. You may start working with the vocabularies, the agreement of
subject and verb, the tenses, the transitional devices, relationships of ideas, etcetera.
4. Rewrite the whole literary draft. Now, in writing - consider all the necessary
corrections that you have noted down.
5. Let someone more knowledgeable read the revised draft. If there are still some
corrections, revise again.
Remember, practice makes perfect. One may not be able to evaluate and revise a
literary piece if he/she lacks exposure to different literary nonfiction. One may start to
simple revision and later find himself/herself revising some academic manuscripts.
6
What’s More
Independent Activity 1
True or False. Write True if the statement is correct and False if it is incorrect. Use the space
provided before each number.
Independent Assessment 1
Multiple Choice. Identify the factors to attain the clarity of the given statements or scenarios.
Use the space provided before each number.
2. Nica had a problem with the company policies and it was solved, but she gave
up before it was solved.
a. Diction b. Organization
4. Let us merge together our ideas in order to come up with the best solution.
a. Organization b. Conciseness
Independent Activity 2
Organization is one of the major factors that we must consider for clarity of idea. In
a Short Fiction, this pertains to the clear flow of the parts of a story’s plot.
7
As mentioned in the previous module, a plot has five parts namely the exposition, rising
action, climax, falling action, and denouement. To check for organization, let us see your
understanding of these basic concepts.
Identification. Identify which part of a plot is being explained in each of the given statement.
Use the space provided before each number.
Independent Assessment 2
Sequencing of events. Arrange the parts of the given plot. Write 1 for exposition, 2 for rising
action, 3 for climax, 4 for falling action, and 5 for denouement on the given spaces.
Yu Hua, who was born in April 03, 1960 in Hangzhou, Zhejiang province, is a Chinese
author. Right after his debut in 1988, he was considered a post-New Wave writer in the field
of fictional writing as many critics credited him a champion for Chinese meta- fictional or post-
modernized writing. However, when he shifted to a more psychological way of narrating in
1990s, he received strong criticisms from both critics and readers.
Yu Hua has and three collections of essays, six collections of stories, five novels. His
novels have been translated into English, Spanish, Portuguese, French, German, Russian,
Italian, Dutch, Czech, Polish, Romanian, Swedish, Hungarian, Serbian, Turkish, Persian,
Hebrew, Korean, Mongolian and Malayalam.
8
As the North Wind Howled
(Selected Parts)
By Yu Hua
1. Sunlight had sneaked in through the window and was creeping toward the chair
where my pants dangled. I was lying bare-chested in bed, rubbing some gunk from the corner
of my right eye. It must have collected while I was sleeping, and to just let it stay there seemed
inappropriate. Meanwhile, my left eye was idle, so I gave it the job of looking at my pants. I
had taken them off the night before, and now I regretted tossing them so casually over the
chair, where they lay wrinkled and crumpled beside my jacket. As my left eye inspected them,
I began to wonder whether while sleeping I had shed, snakelike, a layer of skin, for that’s what
my jacket and pants looked like. At this point, a drop of sunshine reached my pant leg; the
little splotch of leaping light made me think of a golden flea. And so I felt itchy all over and had
my idle left hand make itself useful by scratching.
2. I knew it was pointless to argue any further with this guy, because he was at least
five times as strong as me. “Seeing as a dying man wants to see me,” I told him, “of course
I’m happy to go.”
3. Once we were in the street, the north wind blew me and the big fellow to the
friend’s house just as quickly as it would blow leaves off a tree. The doorway was piled high
with wreaths. The big fellow turned to me and said dolefully, “Your friend is dead.”
4. So that was how, on this lousy morning, a muscleman kicked down my door and
lumbered me with a friend I had no interest in having—a friend who was about to die, no less.
What’s more, the north wind was howling like a banshee outside. I had no overcoat or scarf,
no gloves or hat—all I was wearing was a thin jacket as I went off to visit this friend I knew
absolutely nothing about.
5. Someone was knocking on the door. But who could it be? I was the only person
with a reason to come here, and I was already here. So I decided to ignore the knocking and
continue with my scratching. Now the door was making a colossal noise, as though it were
about to cave in. The person outside, I realized, was knocking not with his hand but with his
foot, and, before I had time to think of a response, the door fell to the floor with such a crash
that it sent shock waves through me. A brawny fellow with whiskers on his face charged over
to my bed. “Your friend’s dying, and you’re still not up?” he yelled. I’d never seen this man
before. “Have you come to the wrong address?” I asked.
9
Independent Activity 3
Alicia or Not?
by Maica Jill N. de Guzman
28 October 2010
Dear Alicia,
Be careful. Ten years from when I am writing this letter, you must be living by yourself
at 108 Eve Street in Uphills. You are unhappy with your job and that is okay. If you
survive, you will get that promotion. Someone will try to kill you there. Your hair, a fake
gun, and your black doormat. You have to fight back. Call Detective McAdams from the
South, he could help you.
P.S. Stop blaming yourself for Mom and Dad’s death. We both know it was not your
intention to make Dad mad while he was driving. Besides, nobody knows about that
heated conversation.
Alicia
10
Independent Assessment 3
Analyze the combination of ideas and the literary elements of the story. Write your
analyses on the spaces provided.
1. Characters:
2. Setting:
3. Plot:
4. Theme:
11
What I Have Learned
Write what you have learned about the given words related to clarity of idea and proper
choice and use of literary elements on the given spaces.
1. Diction
2. Conciseness
3. Organization
12
6. Choice and Use of Setting
What I Can Do
A. Evaluate the clarity of ideas and choice and use of literary elements of this short
fiction by answering the rubrics on the page 15.
R. Zamora Linmark is a Filipino American poet, novelist, and playwright. He was born in
Manila but he earned his bachelor's degree at the University of Hawaii in Honolulu. An
award-winning author, Linmark is a recipient of a Japan-United States Friendship
Commission, a National Endowment for the Arts creative writing fellowship in poetry in
2001, and was a Fulbright Foundation Senior Lecturer/Researcher in the Philippines in
2005 to 2006.
He also became a Creative Writing professor at the University of Hawaii and University of
Miami. He is known for his works Rolling the R’s published in 1995, Prime-Time Apparitions
published in 2005, The Evolution of a Sigh which was written in 2008, Drive- By Vigils in
2011, Leche in 2011, and The Importance of Being Wilde at Heart in 2019.
13
Turban Legend
By R Zamora Linmark
Everywhere Vince turns are boxes, boxes, and more boxes. Boxes secured by
electrical tape and ropes. Boxes with drawstring covers made from canvas or tarp. Boxes
lined up like a fortified wall behind check-in counters or convoying on squeaky conveyor
belts of x-ray machines. Boxes blocking the Mabuhay Express lane for first-and business-
class passengers. Boxes stacked up on carts right beside coach passengers standing in
queues that are straight only at their starting points before branching out to form more-or
converge with other-lines, bottlenecking as they near the ticket counter.
Boxes that ought to be the Philippines’ exhibit at the next World’s Fair, Vince tells
himself as he navigates his cartload of Louis Vuitton bags in and out of the maze. An exhibit
that should take place none other than here, at the Honolulu International Airport, he
laughs, as he imagines an entire terminal buried in the Filipinos’ most popular-and
preferred-pieces of luggage.
With a balikbayan box, Filipinos can pack cans of Hormel corned beef, Libby’s
Vienna sausage, Folgers, and SPAM; perfume samples; new or hand-me-down designer
jeans; travel-sized bottles of shampoo, conditioner, and body lotion gleaned from Las
Vegas hotels; and appliances marked with first-world labels that, as anyone who’s been to
the Philippines knows, can easily be purchased at Duty Free right outside the airport or
from any of the crypt-like malls that are so gargantuan they’re a metropolis unto
themselves.
Filipinos will even throw themselves into these boxes, as was the case of the
overseas contract worker in Dubai. The man, an engineer was so homesick that, unable
to afford the ticket-most of his earnings went to cover his living expenses and the rest to
his wife and children-he talked his roommate, who was homebound for the holidays, into
checking him in. He paid for the excess baggage fee, which still came out cheaper than a
round-trip airfare. En route to Manila, he died from hypothermia.
Vince, who had heard the story from his older sister Jing, didn’t buy it. There were
too many loopholes, too many unanswered questions, like wouldn’t an x-ray machine in
the Middle East detect a Filipino man curled up inside a box? He simply dismissed it as a
“turban legend.”
“You’re missing the point brother,” Jing said. “It’s not the mechanics that matter. It’s
about drama. The extremes a Filipino will go to just to be back home for Christmas with
his family.”
14
RUBRICS FOR EVALUATING THE COMBINATION OF CLARITY OF IDEAS
AND CHOICE AND USE OF LITERARY ELEMENTS IN A SHORT FICTION
4 points 3 points 2 points 1 point Score
Diction All of the Most of the Some of the Majority of the
words used by words used by words used by words used by
the writer are the writer are the writer are the writer are
appropriate to appropriate to appropriate to inappropriate to
the level of the level of the level of the level of
reading reading abilities reading abilities reading abilities
abilities of the of the target of the target of the target
target readers readers readers readers
Conciseness The short The short The short The short fiction
fiction bears fiction bears 1- fiction bears 4- bears 7 or more
no 3 redundant or 6 redundant or redundant or
redundancy wordy wordy wordy
nor wordiness statements statements statements
Organization The plot is The plot is The plot is The plot is
sequenced sequenced somewhat somewhat
properly and properly, but sequenced sequenced
are logically some parts are properly and properly and
connected not logically some parts are some parts are
with one connected with not logically not logically
another one another connected with connected with
one another one another
Grammar The short The short The short The short fiction
and fiction is free fiction has 1-3 fiction has 4-6 has more than 7
Punctuations from any mistakes in mistakes in mistakes in
mistakes in grammar and grammar and grammar and
grammar and punctuations punctuations punctuations
punctuations
Use and All elements Most of the Some of the Majority of the
Choice of of the short elements of the elements of the elements of the
Literary fiction are short fiction are short fiction are short fiction are
Elements carefully carefully carefully not carefully
selected, have selected, have selected, have selected, have
great great great no great
influences to influences to influences to influences to the
the storyline, the storyline, the storyline, storyline, and
and are and are and are are
appropriate to appropriate to appropriate to inappropriate to
the target the target the target the target
readers readers. readers. readers.
TOTAL SCORE:
15
B. Revise the short fiction based on your evaluation. Write your revision on the given
space.
(Title)
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
16
Assessment
Modified True or False. Write True if the statement is correct. If wrong, underline the word or
phrase which make it incorrect, then write the correct word or phrase.
11. While reading, jot down terms that you cannot grasp.
draft.
17
Interview your parents or any member of your family and ask them how they cope with the
COVID-19 pandemic. Draft their stories and evaluate your own work using the same rubric
that you used on page 15. Then, revise your own work based on the result of the rubric. Be
sure to consider the clarity of idea, appropriate choice and use of the element, and effective
combination of the idea and the chosen literary element.
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
18
References
19
20
For inquiries or feedback, please write or call:
Email Address:lrmdsbulacan@deped.gov.ph
20