Alkaline Depolymerization of Polyethylene Terephthalate Plastic Waste

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/274837426

Alkaline Depolymerization of Polyethylene Terephthalate Plastic Waste

Article  in  Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences · June 2014


DOI: 10.25130/tjes.v22i1.334

CITATIONS READS

0 1,421

1 author:

Ammar S. Abbas
University of Baghdad
51 PUBLICATIONS   303 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Taguchi Experimental Design, Optimization and Kinetic Study of Biodiesel Production View project

Electrochemical Degradation of Phenol in Aqueous Solution View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Ammar S. Abbas on 13 April 2015.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Ammar S. Abbas/Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences 21(2) (2014)1-8 1

ISSN: 1813-162X
Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences
available online at: http://www.tj-es.com

Alkaline Depolymerization of Polyethylene Terephthalate Plastic Waste

Ammar S. Abbas
Chemical Engineering Department, College of Engineering, University of Baghdad

(Received 09 July 2013, Accepted 12 January 2014, Available online 5 June 2014)

ABSTRACT
Depolymerization reaction is considered one of the most significant ways of converting waste
polyethylene terephthalate in to terephthalic acid. The water polyethylene terephthalate bottle waste was
collected from different places in Baghdad. The collection step shows that there is plenty amount of
polyethylene terephthalate suitable to be an important source of terephthalic acid production.
PET plastic waste conversion to terephthalic acid by depolymerization process was examined.
The effect of ethylene glycol amount, reaction time (up to 90 minutes) and reaction
temperature (from 70 to 170° C) on the polyethylene terephthalate conversion was obtained.
The kinetic study shows that the ordination of the depolymerization reaction of PET is first
order irreversible reaction with 31103.5 J/mole activation energy.
A 97.9 % terephthalic acid purity has been obtained by purification with N, N-
dimethylformamide.
Keywords: Depolymerization, Polyethylene terephthalate plastic, Terephthalic acid, Kinetic study,
Domestic municipality waste.

‫التحلل القلوي لمخلفات البولي أثلين البالستيكية‬

‫الخالصة‬
‫ت ات عيررر اعتدلررر اا ررر فا وعررر ا‬. ‫يعتبرررفاتل ارررلا وتحدرررلال حرررلاعرررةا وحرررفما وععتبرررفااوتحليرررلاعتدلررر اابرررلوفا لدررريةاتفيل ويررراا وررر احررر ع ا وتفيل ويررر‬
‫ا رر فاا رر ا وتحررلاا ورر اتررليفاوعيرر اال يررفااعررةابك ررتي ابررلوفا‬.‫وعصرر لاماعررةابك ررتي ابررلوفا لدرريةاتفيل ويررااعررةاع رر حماعتلف ررماعررةاب ررل ل‬
‫ تعررراالف رررماتل ارررلا وتحديررررلاوبك رررتي ابرررلوفا لدررريةاتفيل ويررراا ورررر ا‬.‫لدررريةاتفيل ويررراالا وررر صايعتبرررفاعصرررلفاعلرررر اي تررر احررر ع ا وتفيل ويرررا‬
‫ال يقرررم الالف رررماحررررف فاا‬09‫الاتررر ا وحصرررللاادرررر اتررردليفاورررلاعرررةاوعيررررمال رررللا يلدررريةاوكيورررللالا عرررةا وتل اررررلا حتررر ا‬.‫حررر ع ا وتفيل ويرررا‬
‫ لف رررماحفويرررما وتل ارررلا ررر فاا وررر ا ةا وتل ارررلا‬.‫الف رررماعةليرررم اادررر اتحرررللابك رررتي ابرررلوفا لدررريةاتفيل ويرررا‬009‫الاحتررر ا‬09‫وتل ارررلا عرررةا‬
‫ ترر ا وحصرررللاادرر احرر ع ا وتفيل ويرررااب قرر لااعقرررل ف ا‬.‫ا رررللاووررلاعررلل‬31103.5‫غيررفااو ررفالاعرررةا ولف ررما يلورر ابح رررمات رريحاعقررل ف ا‬
.‫ابعلات قيتهاب ول صاعيل يلايلفع ع يل‬%‫ا‬00.0
.‫ النفايات البلدية المحلية‬،‫ دراسة الحركية‬،‫ حامض الترفثالك‬،‫ ب الستك البولي اثلين ترفثاليت‬،‫ تفاعل التحلل‬:‫الكلمات الدالة‬

Abbreviations : The depolymerization reaction activation


EG: Ethylene glycol. energy (J/mole).
PET: Polyethylene terephthalate.
: The depolymerization reaction coefficient
pTPA: Producing terephthalic acid.
sTPA: Standard terephthalic acid. (min).
TPA: Terephthalic acid. : The frequency factor of the Arrhenius
Nomenclatures equation (min).
: The concentration of PET. : The Universal gas constant (8.314
: The initial concentration of PET. J/mole.K).
: The PET depolymerization reaction rate
(mole/min).
Ammar S. Abbas/Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences 21(2) (2014)1-8 2

: The depolymerization reaction time (min). triggered by the addition of alcohol under basic
conditions. Transesterification is the process
: The depolymerization reaction temperature
of substituting the alkoxyl group of an ester
(K). compound with that of an alcohol [6].
: The PET conversion (calculated from Oku et al. [7] was produced
Eq. 1). terephthalic acid from PET by reacting it with
NaOH solution at boiling point of the reaction
Introduction mixture (about 200°C). The result show that
Through the resent years, plastics terephthalic acid can be produced at this
portion in the municipal solid waste increases temperature within 20 minutes the produced
dramatically. Plastics are occupied between 5 mixture after that washed by water firstly
to 15 wt.% (20 to 30 vol. %) of municipal solid followed by H2SO4 solution and then water
waste [1]. again.
Most plastics are non-degradable and Ben-Zn Wan et al. [8] made hydrolytic
possibly take hundred years to decompose depolymerization of PET flakes in a potassium
naturally. hydroxide solution. The reaction was carried
The published statistics for Western out in a stirred batch reactor at 120, 140 and
Europe estimate the yearly consumption of 160° C for 30 minutes and under pressure of
plastic products about 100 kg per person for a about 1.7, 2.9 and 4.9 atm. Zinc acetate was
total of over 39.1 million tones [2]. Over 78 used as catalyst in the reaction with sulfuric
wt.% of this total corresponds to acid into the filtrate to neutralize the potassium
thermoplastics such as high density hydroxide and TPA produced was by water.
polyethylene (HDPE), low density polyethylene Abbas et al. [9], reported that the maximum
(LDPE), polypropylene (PP), poly-vinyl yield of terephthalic acid from PET by the
chloride (PVC) and polyethylene terephthalate depolymerization reaction in the presence of
(PET). The remaining 22 wt.% to thermosets ethylene glycol can be obtained at 40 minutes
(mainly epoxy resins and polyurethane) [3]. and 170°C.
In Arab countries (Saudi Arabia as an Yusuke Asakuma et al. [6], studied the
example), the amount of plastic waste is about depolymerization reaction of virgin PET bottles
15 wt. % in the domestic municipality waste on the basis of both experimental data and
[4].According to the report of Jackson and numerical data obtained from quantum
Bertényi [5], each three tons of plastic waste chemistry calculations. Various alcohols were
contain about one ton of PET which equal to used as solvents in the search for the reaction
20000 PET bottles. mechanism. The maximum PET conversion
The depolymerization of PET was through the depolymerization reaction in
conducted by various alcohols with sodium presence of ethylene glycol was about 30% at
hydroxide under atmospheric pressure. PET 78°C after 3 hours.
was depolymerized to EG and disodium The present work, was intended
terephthalate (Na2-TPA). The to study the depolymerization reaction of
depolymerization reaction is illustrated in collecting waste PET bottles with NaOH in
Figure 1. order to produce terephthalic acid. The
effects of the initial amount of ethylene
glycol, reaction temperature and time
were considered.

Experimental Work
Materials
1. PET bottle waste, collected from different
Fig.1,Depolymerization reaction of PET [6] places in Baghdad, was used. Water
bottles with thickness 0.4 mm and density
The depolymerization reaction of PET is 1.18 g/cm3.
is a kind of trans-esterification reaction
Ammar S. Abbas/Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences 21(2) (2014)1-8 3

2. Sodium hydroxide (NaOH): NaOH


molecular weight 40 and purity of 99.8%.
(RIEDELDEHAEN AG
SEELZEHANNOVER Chem. rian, …1
plozchen, DAB7, B.P.1968 M.Wt. 40)
3. Ethylene glycol (C2H6O2), BDH Chemicals In order to purification of TPA, the
Ltd. precipitated amount of TPA was filtered and
4. Sulfuric acid: H2SO4 of molecular weight of then dried in oven at 85 °C overnight to get rid
98.07 and specific gravity of 1.84 was of the moisture. The produced dry TPA was
used. dissolved in DMF, the un-dissolved materials
5. N, N-dimethylformamide (DMF):‫ ا‬DMF were removed by filtration and TPA is
(C3H7NO) of molecular weight 73.10 was recovered by evaporation of DMF. The
used as purification agent because of its characterization tests of producing TPA were
highly selective dissolver of terephthalic compared with those for standard TPA.
acid rather than by product of
depolymerization reaction. Testing methods
6. Standard terephthalic acid: Terephthalic Final produce terephthalic acid sample
acid of 98.3 % purity was used as was tested for:
standard. The standard terephthalic acid is 1. Melting point: according to ASTM D-127-
from Aldrich Chemical Co. Ltd. 05, the test was done in the Ministry of
Industry and Minerals, General
Apparatus Commission for Research and Industrial
The apparatus used in this study for Development, Chemical and
depolymerization (saponification) reaction in a Petrochemical Research Center.
batch scale system consists of the followings: 2. Acid number: according to ASTM D664-
1. 3 Necks flask (500 ml). 06, the test was done in the Ministry of
2. Heat flat magnetic stirrer (Stuart Industry and Minerals, General
CB302 / USA). Commission for Research and Industrial
3. Reflux Condenser (Germany), 37 cm. Development, Chemical and
4. Mercury thermometer from zero to Petrochemical Research Center.
250 °C. 3. Ash residue: according to ASTM D1951-
86, the test was performed at the
Depolymerization of PET procedure University of Baghdad, College of
50 g of waste PET flakes of the Engineering, Chemical Engineering
dimension of about 5*5*0.4 mm, with 25 g of Department.
NaOH (about 20% excess of the stoichiometric 4. Infra-red (IR) analysis: IR-scan, with
amount) and different amounts of ethylene wavelength between 4000 and 400, for
glycol (200, 300 and 400 ml) were entered in a producing TPA was accomplished by IR-
flask under atmospheric pressure. The mixture spectrophotometer made by Shimadzu of
was heated to 70 to 170°C with stirring. A model FTIR-8400S. This test was done in
sample of the reaction mixture was used up the Central Organization of
(every 15 minutes) and pour directly in a 20 ml Standardization and Quality Control.
of distilled water of room temperature to stop
the reaction, and the unreacted PET was Results and Discussion
filtered. Furthermore, a small amount of H2SO4 Collection of PET bottles waste
was added until neutralized to the filtrate, and PET bottles were collected from
the terephthalic acid (TPA) was precipitated. different places in Baghdad (Iraq), these
Conversion of PET through reaction places were 17 houses from different
was calculated as: neighborhoods of the capital Baghdad, 1
kindergarten, and 1 coffee-shop. These places
serve about 397 persons per day. The
collection was done in different days in March
and April, 2013.
Ammar S. Abbas/Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences 21(2) (2014)1-8 4

Table 1 shows the classification and is very close to the reported estimation values
weight of the collected PET bottles, while of Western Europe and Saudi Arabia [2, 3].
Table 2 summarized the places, numbers of
persons and the average collected waste Effect of EG on the PET conversion
bottles per days. The effect of EG on the PET
depolymerization was intended at 90 minutes
Table 1, Classification and weight of PET of reaction time and at different reaction
waste bottles collected in Baghdad per day temperatures: 70, 130 and 170 °C.
Kinder Coffee- The results (Figure 2) show, that there
Bottle size Houses
garden shop is no significant effect of the EG on the
conversion of PET through the
0.3 L 23 70 -
depolymerization reaction.
0.5 L 55 46 -

0.6 L 68 15 208 1.0

1.0 L 5 - - 0.8

PET conversion, -
1.5 L 24 1 34
0.6

Total No. 175 132 242


0.4
Weight, kg 2.104 1.050 3.165
0.2 o
T = 70 C
o
T = 130 C
Table 2, Numbers of PET waste bottles o
T = 170 C
Reaction time = 90 minutes
collected in Baghdad per day 0.0
150 200 250 300 350 400 450
Avg.
Ethylen glycol volume (ml) per 50 g of PET feed
No. No. Weight,
Place
person PET kg
bottles Fig.2, Effect of the ethylene glycol on PET
conversion of different temperature and at 90
Houses 93 175 2.104 minutes reaction time
Kindergarten 104 132 1.050
The addition more amount of
Coffee-shop 200* 242 3.165 produced material (EG) did not cause
significant change in PET conversion or did
Total weight, kg 6.319 not change the backward reaction or
decreased the forward reaction of the
Average PET waste per person, g 15.92
depolymerization of PET. Thus,
*Approximate average number of customers depolymerization reaction shown in Figure 1
can be considered as irreversible reaction.
The average weight of PET waste per
This result is in good agreement of Yusuke
person (15.92 g) means 509.44 tons per day
Asakuma et al. [6], and it’s reinforced the next
for Iraq (Iraq population is approximately 32
assumption of being the depolymerization
million persons). This huge amount of only one
reaction of PET irreversible reaction.
single type of plastics (PET) causes an
environmental nightmare for any country. But
Effect of reaction temperature on the PET
when the filled half of the cup seen, this
conversion
massive amount of PET plastic waste is
Figure 3 shows the effect of the
considered a plenty sources for different
depolymerization reaction time and reaction
chemicals production such as terephthalic
temperature on the conversion of PET.
acid.
As shown in Figure 3, the PET
The estimation results of PET waste
conversion increase with reaction temperature
amount in Iraq, about 5.8 kg per person yearly,
and reach the highest value (0.99) at 170 °C.
Ammar S. Abbas/Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences 21(2) (2014)1-8 5

While, the conversions at 70 °C were 0.04 aqueous phase and form the di-sodium
during the first 15 minutes of reaction time and terephthalate salt with NA+ [12].
0.35 after 90 minutes of reaction.
Kinetic model of PET depolymerization
o
reaction
T= 70 C
T=
o
90 C
o
The kinetic of PET depolymerization
1.0 T= 110 C
T= 130 C
o

o
was studied by assuming that the reaction is
T= 150 C
0.8 T= 170 C
o
irreversible homogeneous first order according
PET conversion, -

to PET.
0.6
The first order homogenous reaction
0.4
kinetic model is [13]:

0.2
...2
200 ml of ethylene glycol per 50 g of PET feed
0.0
0 20 40 60 80 100

Depolymerization reaction time (t), min.


But:

Fig.3, Effect of the depolymerization reaction ...3


time on the PET conversion of different
temperatures and 200 ml of ethylene glycol
per 50 g of PET feed ...4

These results are in good agreement The integration of Equation 4 gives the regular
with those that extracted from Abbas et al. [9] first order reaction model:
which reported that the maximum yield of
terephthalic acid (maximum conversion of
...5
PET) can be obtained at 170 °C. Yusuke
Asakuma et al. [6], that pointed the conversion
of PET through the depolymerization reaction ...6
about 10 % during the 90 minutes reaction
time and at 70 °C temperature. While,
And:
Spaseska and Civkaroska [10] found that the
above 90 TPA wt.% produced during 5 hours
in temperature range 80 to 120 °C but with ...7
presence of trioctyl methyl ammonium bromide
as a catalyst.
A marked increase in PET conversion A plot of versus , as
appeared when the temperature increases to shown in Figure 4, gives straight lines with
110 °C and above. According to the collusion zero intercepts and slopes equal to the
theory [11], when temperature increases, it
reaction coefficients ( ).
may cause an increase of molecular activity,
and in the same time, the increasing of The numerical values of
solubility of PET in EG and decreasing in depolymerization reaction coefficients versus
viscosity of solution mixture. So the molecules temperature are summarized in Table 3.
have more energy to react and more The activation energy of the reaction
probability to collisions together to accomplish and frequency factor for the first order
the reaction. homogeneous depolymerization reaction are
As the solubility of PET increasing this calculated according to the Arrhenius’
means increasing of PET macromolecules equation (Eq. 7).
which that can be easily attacked by the OH -
and then be depolymerized. After that, the
produced terephthalate anion returns to the
Ammar S. Abbas/Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences 21(2) (2014)1-8 6

excess of the stoichiometric amount of NaOH


5 and in the presence of ethylene glycol is:
T= 70 oC
T= 90 oC
T= 110 oC
4 T= 130 oC
T= 150 oC
T= 170 oC

3 ...8
-ln (1-xPET)

2 -2.5

-3.0

1
-3.5

-4.0
0

ln (k)
0 20 40 60 80 100
-4.5
Depolymerization reaction time (t), min.
-5.0

Fig.4, First order kinetic model of the PET -5.5


depolymerization
-6.0
0.0022 0.0023 0.0024 0.0025 0.0026 0.0027 0.0028 0.0029 0.0030

1/T, K-1

Table 3, Values of the depolymerization


reaction coefficients versus temperature Fig.5, Arrhenius’ plot of depolymerization
Temperature, °C Temperature, K k, min. reaction of PET

70 343 0.0041 The found values of reaction


coefficients are in the same magnitude of
90 363 0.0088
those obtained by Yusuke Asakuma et al. [6],
110 383 0.0198 but the calculated activation energy of the
depolymerization reaction (31103.5 J/mole)
130 403 0.0256 differs from the reported value for the
activation energy of depolymerization reaction
150 423 0.0330
in the presence of EG that about 115 kJ/mole.
170 443 0.0530 This difference due to the wide range of the
temperature studied by the present work (70 to
170 °C) on the contrary of the study of Yusuke
The plot of versus gives Asakuma et al. [6], whose studied the
polymerization reaction of PET in presence of
straight line with slope of and intercept different alcohols, but in the narrow range of
temperature (65 to 78 °C) for depolymerization
of the value if this plot is called
reaction in presence of EG.
Arrhenius’ plot. Predicted values calculated from
Arrhenius’ plot of depolymerization the first order model of PET
reaction are shown in Figure 5. depolymerization (Eq. 5), which uses the
The value of the straight line slope of found reaction rate coefficients (Table 3),
the Arrhenius’ plot equal to -3741.1 then and experimental data are shown in
Figure 6.
the value of the activation energy of the Statistical analysis of the
depolymerization reaction of PET is 31103.5 experimental data shows that the solution
J/mole, and the intercept value is of the model (Eq. 6) is proportional to the
5.5646 then the value of the frequency factor experimental results. The statistical
of the depolymerization reaction of PET is analyses are summarized in Table 4.
The statistical analyses promote that
261.02 minutes.
the depolymerization reaction of PET with EG
The final reaction rate equation of the
behaves as homogeneous first order reaction
depolymerization reaction of PET with a 20%
Ammar S. Abbas/Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences 21(2) (2014)1-8 7

with a high correlation coefficient (0.9872) and Table 5, Comparison of testing properties
low standard deviation (0.0710) and standard between producing and standard TPA
error (0.0467) for 36 observations (no. of Test pTPA sTPA
experiments).
Melting point, °C 306 304
1.0
Ash residue, ppm 13 10
Predicted PET conversion (xPET), -

0.8
Acid number, mg KOH/g 674 675
0.6

Conclusion
0.4
1. The enormous quantity of PET plastic bottle
waste (approximately 509.44 tons) throws
0.2
away in Iraq daily.
2. Ethylene glycol did not effect on the
0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
conversion of PET through the
Real PET conversion (xPET),- depolymerization reaction with NaOH
significantly.
Fig.6, Experimental and predicted values of 3. Conversion of PET of about 99% can be
apparent rate constant by using suggested reached by depolymerization of PET waste for
model of depolymerization of PET 90 minutes at 170 °C.
4. The reaction of the PET depolymerization
Table 4, Statistical analysis of the reaction was first order according to the PET.
depolymerization of PET model 5. The activation energy of the depolymerization
Statistical analysis Value reaction was 31103.5 J/mole with 261.02
minutes as the value of frequency factor.
No. of observation 36 6. The statistical analyses strengthened that the
depolymerization reaction of PET with EG
Correlation coefficient 0.9872 behaves as homogeneous first order reaction.
Standard error 0.0467 7. The purity of the produced TPA was 97.9 %.

Standard deviation (S) 0.0710 References

Variance 0.0050
1. Williams, P.T., Waste treatment and disposal,
2nd edition, John Wiley and Sons, Weinheim,
Confidence level 0.95 Germany, (2006).
2. Association of Plastic Manufacturers in Europe
(APME), An analysis of plastics consumption
Characterization the produced TPA by PET
and recovery in Europe 2002-2003, Brussels,
depolymerization reaction
Belgium, (2004).
Depolymerization reaction of
50 g of PET with 20% stoichiometric excess of
3. Ashraf, G. S., Environmental waste
management and plastics recycling: An
NaOH in the presence of 200 ml EG at 170 °C
overview, Takveen – Khwarzimic Science
and 90 minutes was selected to produce TPA.
Society, (2005).
The comparison of the other tested properties
is shown in Table 5. 4. Siddiqi, M. N., Ali, M. F., Catalytic co–
IR-spectrometer analysis shows identically of liquefaction of model and waste plastics,
the produced terephthalic acid (pTPA) with the Proceedings of 15th Saudi–Japan joint
shows that the purity of the product sample is Symposium, Dhahran, Saudi Arabia, Nov .27-
97.9 % (after purification with DMF), while the 28, (2005).
standard terephthalic acid (sTPA) purity was 5. Jackson, S. and Bertényi, T., Recycling of
98.3 %. plastics, ImpEE Project, Department of
Engineering, University of Cambridge, (2006).
Ammar S. Abbas/Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences 21(2) (2014)1-8 8

6. Yusuke Asakuma, Yusuke Yamamura, Kyuya


Nakagawa, Kouji Maeda and Keisuke Fukui,
Mechanism of depolymerization reaction of
polyethylene terephthalate: Experimental and
theoretical studies, J Polym. Environ. 19:209–
216, (2011).
7. Oku, A., Hu, L.C., Yamada, E., Alkali
decomposition of poly (ethylene terephthalate)
with sodium hydroxide in nonaqueous
ethylene glycol: a study on recycling of
terephthalic acid and ethylene glycol, J Appl.
Polym. Sci. 63(5): 595–601, (1997).
8. Ben-Zu Wan, Chih-Yu Kao and Wu Hsum
Cheng., Kinetic of depolymerization of PET in
potassium hydroxide solution, Industrial &
Engineering Chemistry Research – Ind. Eng.
Chem. Res. 01; 40(2), (2001).
9. Abbas, A. S., Kamel, F. H., Ali, Z. H. and
Taaban, S. K., Converting of polyethylene
terephthalate to terephthalic acid, General
Authority for Industrial Research and
Development – Center of Chemical and
Petrochemical Researches, Iraqi Ministry of
Industry and Minerals, (2010).
10. Spaseska, D. and Civkaroska, M., Alkaline
hydrolysis of poly (rthylene terephthalate)
recycled from post-consumer soft-drink
bottles, Journal of the University of Chemical
Technology and Metallurgy, 45, 4, 379-384,
(2010).
11. Hill, C. G. Jr., An introduction to chemical
engineering kinetics and reactor design, John
Willy & Sons, (1977).
12. Das, J., Hageri, A.B., Sahu, V. and Parikh,
P.A., Alkaline hydrolysis of poly (ethylene
terephthalate) in presence of a phase transfer
catalyst, Indian Journal of Chemical
Technology, 14, 173-177, (2007).
13. Levenspiel, O., Chemical Reaction
Engineering, 4th edition, John Wiley and Sons
Inc., New York, (1999).

View publication stats

You might also like