Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Design of Locally Produced Activated Carbon Filter From Agricultural Waste For Water Purification IJERTV3IS060610
Design of Locally Produced Activated Carbon Filter From Agricultural Waste For Water Purification IJERTV3IS060610
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 3 Issue 6, June - 2014
J. D. Obayemi
Department of Materials Science and Engineering,
Kwara State University, Malete, Ilorin-Nigeria.
Abstract-This paper presents basic design and fabrication of all parts in the world. However, Ghana is still the second
activated carbon filters from agricultural wastes (coconut and highest rated country with cases of guinea worm in the world,
palm kernel shells) for water purification in the Northern next to Sudan with 501 new cases reported in 2008 [3,4].
Region of Ghana. The content of the activated carbon (AC) Drinking water from contaminated sources including
produced were between 80 and 90 vol. %, depending on the type
RT
inadequate sanitation and hygiene practices are some of the
of the agricultural waste used in water purification. Adsorption
contributing factors to waterborne diseases [5]. In water
and turbidity tests were carried out. The test results indicated
that, AC with favorable physicochemical properties can be related diseases, guinea worm and diarrhea are the
produced locally from agricultural waste. The volume predominant, with diarrhea constituting one third of the
IJE
percentage of impurity removed was also evaluated to be ̴ 97 ± 2 reported cases in health centers across the country [5]. A total
vol. %. The superficial water flow velocity through the porous number of 113,786 cases of diarrhea among children under
AC was found to be 1.62 m/s. Also, the volumetric flow rate was five years with 354 deaths cases were reported in 2011 [6].
determined to be 0.056 m3/s. The filter is capable of producing This problem is intensified due to lack of safe sanitation and
0.02 m3 of water in 2 hours. Also, the work show that, the poor water quality in poor countries [7-9].
contact time between water and the AC increases the amount of
impurities removed. A paired sample T-test was used to analyse
Sawla-Tuna-Kalba District is located in the western part of
the flow rate results for both AC produced. The results obtained
are then discussed for the production of locally AC filters for the Northern Region, between latitudes 8° 401 and 9° 401
water purification. North and longitudes 1°501 and 2° 451 West. The population
of Sawla-Tuna-Kalba according to the Ministry of Health
Keywords— activated carbon; water filter; adsorption; population and housing census in 2000 was estimated to be
turbidity; impurities; statistical analysis. 84,664 with a population density increasing from 8 persons
per square Km in 1984 to 14 persons per square km in 2000
I. INTRODUCTION [6]. Eighty five percent (85%) of the total population in the
district lived in rural areas, whiles fifteen percent (15%) lived
Water is essential for human wellbeing and the in the urban areas [10]. Recent survey conducted indicates
environment. Beyond meeting basic human needs, water that, a community such as Dakompilayiri owned just a single
supply and sanitation services, as well as water as a resource, borehole to provide portable drinking water for the entire
are critical to sustainable development. In Ghana, 58% of the community. Unfortunately, this borehole breaks down
populations live in rural areas. Out of these communities, 66% consistently for almost every season due to excessive human
of the population lack access to clean and safe drinking water pressure. In such situations, people were left with no choice
[1]. In the Northern Region of Ghana, people lack access to than to depend on stream/dugout (Fig.1a) and dam (Fig.1b)
portable water. About 40% of the populace in the region water for their daily use.
obtains their source of drinking water from boreholes, dams
and streams [2]. These sources of drinking water are untreated
and exposed to many contaminations. As a result, they have
incidence of water-borne diseases (diarrhea, hepatitis A,
typhoid, cholera and guinea worm) which are high in the
Northern Region. Guinea worm has been eradicated in almost
cost. In Ghana, the major production areas of these waste C. Design Principles
materials are located in large coconut/palm plantation farm
lands at Akame (in the Volta Region), Asuansi, Benso, The designed filter contains granular AC loaded in an inner
Ayiem, Axim, Salma and Akosuno (in the Western Region), plastic container (carbon cartridge) at the point of entering
Kade (in the Eastern Region) and Juziben (in the Ashanti (Fig. 3). The cross-sectional area of the filter cartridge
Region) [29]. Ghana produces about 397,502 metric ton of oil decreases from top to bottom causing the pressure to increase
palm with a projected cropped area of 2,000,000 metric ton at the bottom of the filter. A reservoir is mounted on the
[29], and their by-products could serve as raw materials for collector for an easy access to water.
the production of AC.
F. Adsorption Isotherm
Fig.3 Schematic of the Activated Carbon filtration System. Langmuir isotherm is a simple application of the mass
action law leading to the thermodynamic equilibrium
constant [33]. This links the concentration of free sites on the
adsorbent with the adsorbate concentration in the solution and
the concentration of complex sites at the adsorbent surface
[33]. On the other hand, the simple and empirical Freundlich
equation is the most important and commonly used isotherm
equation for describing multilayer adsorption [34]. It has no
saturated adsorption value and it is widely applied in physical
and chemical adsorptions, as well as in solution adsorption.
RT
The liquid phase isotherms are generally interpreted using the
Freundlich equation. The empirical Freundlich adsorption
isotherm was used to relate the amount of impurity in the
IJE
E. Adsorption Measurement
(a) (b)
The constants, k and 1/n were obtained from the graph where
n was related to the gradient of the graph given as
summarized in table I. The k was related to the intercept on
the x/m-axis which yielded 2.77 and 2.09 for carbon A and B,
respectively. The value of k is related to the adsorbent
RT
capacity, while the value of n is related to the strength of
adsorption [35]. The mass of adsorbate per dry unit weight of
carbon (x/m) (mg/g) depends directly on k and exponentially
on n. The values of n and k reported (Table I) have shown
IJE
2.8
2.6 Carbon B
Carbon A
2.4
2.2
2
yA = 0.6388x + 1.0197
1.8 R2 = 0.999
yB = 0.717x + 0.7392
1.6
R2 = 0.979
1.4
0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8
Turbidity (JTU)
0.35
A 1.57 2.77
0.30
B 1.39 2.09 0.25
0.20
0.15
In other words a nearly vertical isotherm line shows poor 0.10
adsorptive properties at lower impurity concentrations. After 0.05
performing several tests on the treated water using the ACs 0.00
loaded in the filters, the impurity levels were reduced Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4
appreciably with AC produced from coconut shells than the Test Samples
Fig. 9a: Turbidity Test on Dam Water Using AC from Coconut Shells.
one produced from palm kernel. This could be as a result of
high adsorption capacity of AC produced from coconut shells
than palm kernel. The porous structure of the char was 0.40 Before Treatment
enhanced by using steam as the activating agent for thermal
0.35 After Treatment
with the carbon. Also from Darcy’s law, it was realized that
Carbon Dosage
the superficial water flow velocity through the porous 500
Concentration of impurity remaining
medium of AC relate inversely to the thickness of the porous Impurity Removed
Impurity Removed/Unit wt of Carbon
medium. This means that, the velocity of the water passing 400
capacity). If this happened, contaminants may not be obtained from Carbon A and Carbon B water filters. This was
adsorbed any longer by the carbon, but instead contaminants achieved by using origin pro 8 software package (OriginLab
may move from the carbon back into the water. Corporation, Northampton, MA, USA) in analyzing the test
results as illustrated in table II. The probability value of 0.066
In this case, it may be that the concentration of the is greater than the significance level α of 0.05. At this α-
contaminant in the untreated water is less than the treated value, the test result was statistically significant, since the
water. To avoid this effect, it is recommended that, the difference between their means is not significantly different
carbon cartridge in the filter should be replaced. with the test difference. We therefore fail to reject Ho in
favor of Ha and conclude that, the difference in the
600
Carbon Dosage percentage removal of impurities obtained from Carbon A
Concentration of impurity remaining and Carbon B filters was small. This implies that, the removal
500
Impurity Removed of contaminants in water was effective for both coconut and
Impurity Removed/Unit wt of Carbon palm kernel shells.
Carbon Dosage (g/L) (M)
400
Percentage of Impurities Removed (%)
100
300
80
200
60
Carbon A
100 40 Carbon B
0 20
%IR
Percentage of Impurities Removed, SD Standard
100 Deviation, DF Degree of Freedom, N number of Test Data, SEM
Percentae of Impurity Removed (%)
suspended particles (turbidity) and some other inorganic kernel. AC from the coconut shells were found to be mainly
substances after a laboratory tests were carried on the treated mesopores with irregular, different shapes and sizes for char,
water. The designed calculation for the AC filter shows the and the macropores seemed to be connected to mesopores,
filtration rate of treated water is about 2.5 liters/hr. Since especially for a case of palm kernel. This result is in
treated water can be obtained from the AC filter within the agreement with other studies conducted [40,41].
shortest possible time, the design approach presented will be
feasible. The data obtained from the adsorption and turbidity However, although the AC produced from coconut shells
tests indicated that AM with favorable physicochemical had a better adsorption capacity than the palm kernel shells,
properties may be produced locally from agricultural waste. the statistical results show no significant difference between
them. The test result is statistically significant and the
The unit cost of the activated carbon filter produced difference in their mean of the percentage removal of
compared to a clay filter was $18.0. The AC filter produced impurities is very small and as such, can be omitted.
was more cost effective than the clay filter by a factor of 2.6.
There was simply no fuel consumption during the process The methylene blue adsorptions indicate that the AC
and that reduced the cost of labor for the filter production. from coconut shells was shown to be much better. The
granular ACs from coconut and palm kernel shells had very
similar capacities to adsorb iodine, methylene blue, and
TABLE II. DESCRIPTIVE AND TEST STATISTICS residual chlorine, but that from coconut shells was the most
effective. The AC from coconut shells was successful to
completely eliminate turbidity in water. Home water
N Mean SD SEM t DF Prob>|t| purification using AC filter is one option that is often used by
statistic people who have problems with quality drinking water. AC is
considered the best home method, for treating certain organic
% IR 6 60.125 36.744 15.001 2.346 5 0.066 compounds. However, AC filters have a limited lifetime.
Eventually, the surface of the AC will be saturated with
6 56.875 35.441 14.469 adsorbed pollutants, and no further purification will occur.
D 3.250
AC filters is not recommended for metals and other ions [7] T. Sittoni and S. Maina (Editors), “Economic Impacts of Poor
Sanitation in Africa”, WSP (Water and Sanitation Program), 2012,
that can also be common in drinking water contaminants.
pp.1-5.
These are clearly some of the challenges that should be [8] M. Kosek, C. Bern and R. L. Guerant “The Global Burden of
further investigated. The choice of an AC filter should be Diarrheal Disease, As Estimated from Studies Published between
based upon, water analysis and a thorough assessment of the 1992 and 2000”, Bulletin of the World Health Organization, Vol. 81,
No. 3, 2003, pp.197-204.
individual homeowner's situation. The appropriate filter depth
[9] WHO (World Health Organization) “Global Water Supply and
depends on the flow rate of water through the filter. The Sanitation Assessment. Geneva”, WHO, 2000.
slower the flow rate, the better the removal. The poor [10] STKDCA (Sawla-Tuna-Kalba District Assembly)
performance of the filter may be due to blockage of the pores (sawlaghanadistricts.gov.gh.), 2006, unpublished.
[11] M. Kamrin, H. Nancy, C. Barry, B. Dan and D. W. Q. Frank “Home
with the AC and probably due to improper filter depth. This
Water Treatment Using Activated Carbon, Cooperative Extension
filter produced can only make used of 1.5 kg of AC to Service”, Michigan State University, Vol. 23, 1990.
produce 5 liters of treated water within 2 hrs. The incredible [12] Z. Hu, M. P. Srinivasan, “Mesoporous high surface area activated
properties of AC in addition to the complex metrix/structural carbons”. Microporous Mesoporous Mater. Vol. 34, 2001, pp.267-
275.
network allow it to trap poisons, creosotes, heavy metals,
[13] G. Strand, “Activated Carbon for Purification of Alcohol: and Some
insecticides, bad smells and tastes, chemical substances, and Useful Distillation Tips”, www.homedistllation.com/freebook.htm,
impurities, or undesirable substances in both liquid and gases. unpublished, 2001.
[14] Mendez M O A, Lisboa A C L, Coutinhoand A R, and Otani C,
“Activated Petroleum Coke for Natural Gas Storage”, J. Braz. Chem.
The AC works when ordinary physical filtering (using a
Soc., Vol. 17, No. 6, 2006, pp.1144-1150.
sieve, filter paper and filter pads, and sand) cannot separate a [15] Inagaki M, Kang F, Toyada M and Konno H, (), Advanced Materials
particular substance. AC works by adsorbing impurities into Science and Engineering of Carbon, 1st Edition, 2013, p.440, ISBN:
its pores. Absorption happens through cooperation of the 978-0-12-407789-8.
[16] O. A. Shenderova, V. V. Shirnov and D. W. Brenner, “Carbon
carbon’s enormous adsorptive surface, including its weak
Nanostructures”, Critical Reviews in Solid State and Materials
electrostatic charges (known as Van der Waals forces) Sciences, Vol. 27 No.3, 2002, pp.227-356.
together with the distribution of pores sizes and the [17] N. Sevage. Materials Science: Super Carbon. Nature 483. 2012,
construction of the pores surfaces. The carbon pores become pp.30-31. Doi: 10.1038/483s30a.
[18] D. D. L. Chung, Composite Materials: Science and Applications.
saturated with impurities, attaching even to the outside of the
Second Edition. Springer, 2010, p.370, ISBN: 978-1-84882-830-8.
carbon. [19] A. C. Lua and J. Guo, “Mircroporuos Oil-Palm-Shell Activated
Carbon Prepared by Physical Activation for Gas-Phase Adsorption”,
RT
It should be noted here that no one piece of treatment Langmuir, Vol. 17, No. 12, 2001, pp.7112-7117.
[20] M. I. Yusufu, C. C. Ariahu and B. D. Igbabul, “Production and
equipment can manage all contaminants in water. All
characterization of activated carbon from selected local raw
treatment methods have their own limitations. A combination materials”, African Journal of Pure and Applied Chemistry, Vol. 6,
IJE
of treatment processes are required to effectively treat water No. 9, 2012, pp.123-131.
for human use. It might be stated that different types of [21] I. K. Adewumi, “Activated Carbon for Water Treatment in Nigeria:
Problems and Prospects”, E. K. Yanful (Ed), Appropriate Technology
carbon and carbon filters remove different contaminants. For
for Environmental Protection in the Developing World. Springer
instance, AC filters are incapable of removing microbial Science and Business Media B.V., 2009, pp.115-122.
contaminants (bacteria and viruses), calcium and magnesium [22] C. Dileck, A. Y. Oznuh “Production and characterization of activated
(hard water minerals), fluoride nitrate including other carbon from bituminous coal through chemical activation”, Afr. J.
Biotechnol., Vol. 7, No. 2, 2008, pp.3703-3710.
compounds. Sedimentation method is therefore recommended
[23] I. D. Bruce and O. S. Sharon, “Drinking Water Treatment: Activated
in the first place to reduce turbidity before introducing water Carbon Filtration”, Revise Version, University of Nebraska Lincoln,
into a filter. This is because surface water needs pre-treatment NebGuid 1489, 2013.
to reduce turbidity and this is an added advantage in that, it [24] G. Leopold, “Hand-Book of Chemistry”. Harrison and Sons, London,
4th Edition, Vol. 7, 1848, pp.4-501
will prolong the filter-saturation/life time.
[25] EPA (Environmental Protection Agency)-USA, “Water Health Series:
Filtration Facts”, www.epa.gov/safewater, 2005.
REFERENCES [26] R. B. Lartey and A. Francis, “Developing National Capability for
Manufacture of Activated Carbon from Agricultural Wastes”, the
[1] Davey J, McNulty S, Semiao A, “Saving Rural Ghanaian Ghana Engineer, 1999.
Communities from Waterborne Diseases Using Ultrafiltration”, [27] GSSD (Ghana Statistical Service Department), 1997, unpublished.
Mondialogo (URL: http://www.org/295.html?L=en. Unpublished, [28] H. M. Mozammel, O. Masahiro and S. C. Bahattacharya “Activated
2009. Charcoal from Coconut Shell Using ZnCl2 Activation, Biomass
[2] C. W. S. (Community water solutions), Ghana Bioenergy Vol. 22, 2002, pp.397-400.
(Communitywatersolutions.org), Unpublished, 2009. [29] MOFA (Ministry of Food and Agriculture) “Agriculture in Ghana:
[3] C. D. C. (Center for Disease Control and Prevention) “Progress Facts and Figures”, 2011, pp.1-52.
Toward Global Eradication of Dracunculiasis”. Morbidity and [30] E. Myre and R. Shaw (2006), “The Turbidity Tube: Simple and
Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) Vol.57, 2008, pp1173-1176. Accurate Measurement of Turbidity in the Field”. Michigan
[4] WHO (World Health Organization) “Dracunculiasis Eradication: Technological University.
Global Surveillance Summary”: Wlkly Epidemiol Rec. Vol. 84, 2009, [31] WHO (World Health Organization) (2004), “Guidelines for Drinking-
pp.162- 167. water Quality”, 3rd Ed: Geneva, Vol. 1.
[5] GHS (Ghana Health Service), “Annual Report”. Government of [32] J. Davis and L. Robert Engineering in Emergencies: A Practical
Ghana through the Ministry of Health, 2011, pp.1-93. Guide for Relief Workers, 2nd Edition. Warwickshire, UK: RedR /
[6] GSSD (Ghana Statistical Service Department), Countries Fact Sheets, ITDG Publishing, 2002.
(http://www.afro.who.int/home/countries/fact_sheets/ghana.pdf). [33] D. Dang, W. Ding, A. Cheng, S. Liu and X. Zhang “Isotherm
WHO (World Health Organization), 2003. Equation Study of F Adsorbed from Water Solution by Fe2(SO4)3-
modified Granular Activated Alumina. Separation Science and
Engineering”, Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, Vol. 19, No. [38] UN (United Nation), “Water in a Changing World”, World
4, 2011, pp.581-585. Water Development Report, UNESCO Publishing,
[34] A. Violante, P. M. Huang, G. M. Gadd, “Biophysico-Chemical (http://www.unesco.org/water/wwap), 2003.
Processes of Heavy Metals and Metalloids in Soil Environments”,
[39] B. R. Munson, D. F. Younf, T. H. Okiishi and W. W. Huebsch,
Wiley-Interscience, America, Vol. 217, 2008.
Fundamentals of Fluid Mechanics. 6th Edition. John Wiley and
[35] W. J. Jr. Weber, Physicochemical Processes for Water Quality
Sons, Inc. USA, 2009, ISBN 978-0470-26284-9.
Control. Wiley Interscience, John Wiley and Sons Inc., New York,
[40] Norit Americas Inc. Norit Activated Carbon Data Sheet.
NY, 1972.
Hydrodarco 4000. http://www.norit-
[36] L. C. Russell., L. C. Gordon, “New Concepts in Water Purification”.
americas.com/pdf/HD4000_rev6.pdf, 2007a.
Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York, USA, 1974.
[41] Norit Americas Inc. Norit Activated Carbon GAC 1240 Plus.
[37] WHO (World Health Organization) “Burden of Disease and Cost-
Effectiveness Estimates”, 2010. http://www.norit-americas.com/pdf/GAC1240_rev6.pdf,2007b.
RT
IJE