Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Why Evidence-Based Case Report?
Why Evidence-Based Case Report?
case report?
Evidence Based
During the course of a day in the office, many questions will arise
that will require decisions
Electronic searching
Database
The Search
Keywords & combination of search term(s):
AND, OR, brackets
Appraisals
Hand searching
Make it transparent!
Appraisals !"#$%&'()%*+',-'.-/,-0'%1,/%-2%'345%1%$+67'89:'/,;%:%-)')<*%+'98'=>%+?9-
!"#"$%&"'()*+(,-./(01-$2"34(56-2"4(7./'(7.)3-3*89(:-;$(<$-4=.%;(5>0?@A89(B3.41(<3""/1-$C1(5D0789(0-3$(E"/"C1-/(5>0?@A89(6"3"2*(E%F.GH(5>0?@A89(I$"44-/'3%(7.)"3-J9(,#-/(
A%4G1"K9(@%)(:1.$$.&49(-/'(E-="$(B1%3/L%/
Several standard tools are available $)"C@#$ M@)I+B&'$@$)#')0E+?**0@#C+ $)"C@#$+F@)I&")+B&'$@$)#')0E+ $)"CE+F@)I+'&'=@'C#*#'C#')+ "'C&B"D#')#C+#J*#<@#'B#:+&<+
<#G#<#'B#+$)?'C?<C+?'C+ ?**0@#C+<#G#<#'B#+$)?'C?<C$8 <#G#<#'B#+$)?'C?<C >?$#C+&'+D#BI?'@$D$
>0@'C@'9
NC")'B,$$'C"**%-',8' (E$)#D?%B+<#/@#F+ N'B#*%&'+B&I&<)+$)"C@#$ O&I&<)+&<+B&')<&0+?<D+&G+ (E$)#D?%B+<#/@#F+&G+B?$#=$#<@#$H*@'@&'+F@)I&")+#J*0@B@)+B<@%B?0+
B%'/9'-9)C,-0M &G+@'B#*%&'+B&I&<)+ <?'C&D@P#C+)<@?0 ?**<?@$?0:+>?$#C+&'+0@D@)#CK+
level of evidence -
&G+B?$#=B&')<&0+$)"C@#$:+ &<+-#JB#*%&'?00E2+
-Q<#?)D#')+W?<D$2 &<+$)"C@#$+<#/#?0@'9+
C<?D?%B+#U#B)$
&>$#</?%&'?0+$)"CE+F@)I+
C<?D?%B+#U#B)
F+'%":$<'/%)%2?9-' (E$)#D?%B+<#/@#F+&G+ T?'C&D@P#C+)<@?0 V&'=<?'C&D@P#C+B&')<&00#C+ O?$#=B&')<&0+$)"C@#$:+I@$)&<@B?00E+H*@'@&'+F@)I&")+#J*0@B@)+B<@%B?0+
Oxford CEBM
B9:)CBC,$%M <?'C&D@P#C+)<@?0$ B&I&<)KG&00&F="*+$)"CE B&')<&00#C+$)"C@#$ ?**<?@$?0:+>?$#C+&'+0@D@)#CK+
@'5%1%$'A"<'#%'0:"/%/'/9B-'9-')C%'#"+,+'98'+)>/<'=>"$,)<D',A*:%2,+,9-D',-/,:%2)-%++'3+)>/<'EFGH'/9%+'-9)'A")2C'=>%+?9-+'EFGH7D'#%2">+%'98',-29-+,+)%-2<'#%)B%%-'+)>/,%+D'9:'
#%2">+%')C%'"#+9$>)%'%;%2)'+,I%',+'1%:<'+A"$$J'5%1%$'A"<'#%'0:"/%/'>*',8')C%:%',+'"'$":0%'9:'1%:<'$":0%'%;%2)'+,I%K www.cebm.net
Can I trust the accuracy of
data from a diagnostic study? Results
Recruitment: Was an appropriate spectrum of patients
included?
Search Results
Selected
Database Search strategy Hits
articles
doi:10.1510/icvts.2008.180083
Clinical review
www.icvts.org
Best evidence papers Department of Cardiothoracic Surgery, Southampton General Hospital, Southampton, UK
Received 18 March 2008; received in revised form 10 April 2008; accepted 23 April 2008
Author Patient group Outcome Key results Comments
Ooi et al., (2006), 52 operations on children under Duration of post- Patients under 3 months Authors concluded that early
Evidence based case report Summary
Eur J Cardiothorac 12 months of age undergoing operative ventilation old required greater duration definitive repair of TOF can
Surg, UK w2x evidence topiccorrection
A best in cardiacofsurgery
isolated was
TOF written according to a structured(3.8"1.2 vs. 1.4"0.2
protocol. days; addressed
The question be performed
was whethersafelyearly
in those
Advantages Disadvantages
Learn to apply Detailed / minute-to-
evidence-based minute management
practice might be lacking