Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 19

B1_Section 8_9_Higher.

qxp 1/4/10 8:17 AM Page 182

j Appendix C: Suggested Criteria for the Use


of Optional Assessments
The following are reasonable criteria for use in observing riculum standards and the type of instruction offered stu-
change over time in literacy competencies. They show learn- dents. You may adjust these criteria to fit your district deci-
ing progressing across areas, but development of concepts sions. Revisions or updates to this document can be found at
and understandings will depend on the school or district cur- www.fountasandpinnell.com.

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Kindergarten

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

LETTER LEARNING

Letter Children say the names of upper and 1 = 6+ 1 = 21+ 1 = 31+ 1 = 52


Recognition lower case letters.
2=5 2 = 20 2 = 30 2 = 52
Individual Notice: score, speed, comparison upper
3=3 3 = 12 3 = 18–29 3 = 26–51
Score = 52 and lower scores, letter confusions,
sounds known (instead of letter name), 4=0 4 = <12 4 = <18 4 = <26
knowledge of first letter of name.

EARLY LITERACY CONCEPTS

Early Literacy Children demonstrate that they can 1 = 3+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 10


Behaviors use conventions related to print.
2=2 2=5 2=8 2 = 10
Individual Notice: speed, automaticity, evidence
3=1 3=4 3 = 6–7 3=9
Score = 10 of left to right directionality, ability to
distinguish letter and word features. 4=0 4 = <4 4 = <6 4 = <9

HIGH-FREQUENCY WORDS

Reading High- Children read 25 high-frequency 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 16+ 1 = 20+


Frequency words.
2=0 2=5 2 = 15 2 = 20
Words: 25 Notice: speed, word substitutions
words 3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 10–14 3 = 15–24
(similar visual features), good
Individual attempts, letter/sound relationships 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <10 4 = <15
Score = 25 the reader controls.

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

182 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:17 AM Page 183

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Kindergarten, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

PHONOLOGICAL/PHONEMIC AWARENESS

One- and Children say a word and clap or tap a 1 = 1+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 10 1 = 10


Two-Syllable finger for each syllable, then identify
2=0 2=8 2 = 10 2 = 10
Words: Clap the number of syllables in the word.
Syllables 3=0 3 = 4–7 3 = 6–9 3=9
Notice: accuracy and quickness of
Score = 10 response; ease of the task; number of 4=0 4 = <4 4 = <6 4 = <9
syllables they can easily identify.

Phonological Children identify pictures with the 1 = 1+ 1 = 4+ 1 = 7+ 1=8


Awareness: same initial sound as a spoken word.
2=0 2=4 2=6 2=8
Initial Sounds Notice: score (sounds matched cor-
3=0 3 = 2–3 3 = 4–5 3=7
Individual rectly); ability to orally produce initial
Score = 8 sound. 4=0 4 = <2 4 = <4 4 = <7

Phonological Children hear and say the individual 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 10


Awareness: sounds in a word and then blend the
2=0 2=5 2=8 2 = 10
Blending sounds to say the word.
Words 3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 5–7 3 = 8–9
Notice: ability to listen and understand
Individual task; ability to orally blend sounds. 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <5 4 = <8
Score = 10

Phonological Children say a word and then say the 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 10


Awareness: individual sounds separately but in
2=0 2=5 2=8 2 = 10
Segmenting sequence.
Words 3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 6–7 3 = 7–9
Notice: ability to listen and understand
Individual task; ability to orally separate and say 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <6 4 = <7
Score = 10 sounds in sequence.

section 9
Phonological Children match words that sound alike 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 10
Awareness: in the ending part (rime).
2=0 2=5 2=8 2 = 10
Rhyming Notice: ability to identify and say
3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 6–7 3 = 8–9
Individual labels of objects; ability to listen for Appendix, Glossary, Index
Score = 10 and match sound patterns, speed. 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <6 4 = <8

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1 183


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:17 AM Page 184

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Kindergarten, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

PHONICS

Writing Children say words slowly and write 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 16+ 1 = 20+


Picture the sounds they hear.
2=0 2=5 2 = 15 2 = 20
Names Notice: score, speed, specific
3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 9–14 3 = 9–19
Group phonemes accurately represented,
Score = 25 substitutions. 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <9 4 = <9

Phonograms– Children read words with simple 1 = 1+ 1 = 4+ 1 = 7+ 1 = 9+


List 1 phonogram patterns.
2=0 2=3 2=6 2=8
Individual Notice: score, speed, and evidence of
3=0 3 = 1–2 3 = 2–5 3 = 5–7
Score = 20 knowing patterns even in incorrect
attempts. 4=0 4 = <1 4 = <2 4 = <5

WRITING (SPELLING)

Word Writing Children write all of the words they can 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 16+
Individual within a designated time limit (maxi-
2=1 2=5 2 = 10 2 = 15
mum 10 minutes; stop when the child
Score = # of 3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 7–9 3 = 13–14
can write no more).
accurately
spelled words Notice: evidence of knowledge of 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <7 4 = <13
word connections, phonograms,
spelling patterns, word endings; ability
to hear sounds and represent them
with letters; known high-frequency
words; speech of letter formation.

VOCABULARY

Concept Prompted by a picture card, children 1 = 3+ 1 = 7+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 11


Words say the related concept words. Tasks:
2=2 2=6 2=8 2 = 10
Number (1) tell number of dots; (2) Match dots
and numerals; (3) Match dots and num- 3=1 3 = 3–4 3 = 6–7 3 = 8–9
Score = 12 for
ber words; or (4) Match all. 4=1 4 = <3 4 = <7 4 = <8
each task
Notice: extent to which child has devel-
oped concept of number, ability to rec-
ognize and use number words, score.

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

184 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 185

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Kindergarten, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

VOCABULARY, continued

Concept Prompted by a picture card, children 1 = 1+ 1 = 5+ 1 = 7+ 1=8


Words say the related concept word. Tasks:
2=0 2=4 2=6 2=7
Color: (1) say the color word for each card;
(2) Match color cards and words with 3=0 3 = 2–3 3 = 4–5 3 = 5–6
Identifying
Colors by appropriate color crayon. [Remember 4=0 4 = <2 4 = <4 4 = <5
Name that many children have some form of
color blindness.
Notice: ease with which children can
identify and/or match colors.

Concept Prompted by a picture card, children 1 = 1+ 1 = 2+ 1 = 3+ 1 = 5+


Words say the related concept word. Task:
2=0 2=2 2=2 2=4
Color: Read the word cards and match with
colors. [Remember that many children 3=0 3=1 3=1 3 = 2–3
Reading Color
Words have some form of color blindness.] 4=0 4 = <1 4 = <1 4 = <2
Individual or Notice: color words children can
Group match to the right color.
Score = 8

Vocabulary Children use context to correctly iden- Level A Level B Level C


in Context; tify the meaning of 3 words selected
1 = NA 1 = 7–9 1 = 7–9 1 = 7–9
Levels A – C from a Benchmark Assessment Book at
their instructional or independent level. 2 = NA 2 = 5–6 2 = 5–6 2 = 5–6
Score: 9 on
rubric Notice: number of words known or 3 = NA 3 = 2–4 3 = 2–4 3 = 2–4
almost known; ability to use context; 4 = NA 4 = <2 4 = <2 4 = <2
ability to articulate meaning.

section 9
Rubric:
0) Did not respond or said “I don’t know.
1) Made a response that is in some
way related to the meaning of the Appendix, Glossary, Index
word (any definition).
1) Responded with a definition that is
approximately the meaning of the
word (same definition as used in the
text). Key
2) Responded with a full definition of Exceeds Expectations
the word (precise definition used in
the text). Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1 185


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 186

j
Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Grade 1

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

LETTER LEARNING

Letter Children say the names of upper and 1 = 52 1 = 52 1 = 52 1 = 52


Recognition lower case letters.
2 = 52 2 = 52 2 = 52 2 = 52
Individual Notice: score, speed, comparison
3 = 26–51 3 = 44–51 3 = 44–51 3 = <52
Score = 52 upper and lower scores, letter confu-
sions, sounds known (instead of letter 4 = <26 4 = <44 4 = <44 4 = <52
name), knowledge of first letter of
name.

EARLY LITERACY CONCEPTS

Early Literacy Children demonstrate that they can 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10


Behaviors use conventions related to print.
2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10
Individual Notice: speed, automaticity, evidence
3 = 7–0 3 = <10 3 = <10 3 = <10
Score = 10 of left to right directionality, ability to
distinguish letter and word features. 4 = <7 4 = <10 4 = <10 4 = <10

HIGH-FREQUENCY WORDS

Reading High Children read 100 high-frequency 1 = 26+ 1 = 51+ 1 = 76+ 1 = 100
Frequency words.
2 = 25 2 = 50 2 = 75 2 = 100
Words: 100 Notice: speed, word substitutions
Words 3 = 15–24 3 = 25–49 3 = 50–74 3 = 75–99
(similar visual features), good
Individual attempts, letter/sound relationships 4 = <15 4 = <25 4 = <50 4 = <75
Score = 100 the reader controls.

PHONOLOGICAL/PHONEMIC AWARENESS

One- and Children say the names of pictures and 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10


Two- Syllable sort them in two columns.
2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10
Words: Clap Notice: speed, accuracy, need to clap
Syllables 3 = 8–9 3 = <10 3 = <10 3 = <10
more than once before responding.
Individual 4 = <8 4 = <10 4 = <10 4 = <10
Score = 10

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

186 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 187

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Grade 1, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

PHONOLOGICAL/PHONEMIC AWARENESS, continued

Phonological Children identify pictures with the 1=8 1=8 1=8 1=8
Awareness: same initial sound as a spoken word.
2=8 2=8 2=8 2=8
Initial Sounds Notice: score (sounds matched cor-
3 = 6–7 3 = <8 3 = <8 3 = <8
Individual rectly); ability to orally produce initial
Score = 8 sound. 4 = <6 4 = <8 4 = <8 4 = <8

Phonological Children hear and say the individual 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10


Awareness: sounds in a word and then blend the
2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10
Blending sounds to say the word.
Words 3=9 3 = <10 3 = <10 3 = <10
Notice: ability to listen and understand
4 = <9 4 = <10 4 = <10 4 = <10
Individual task; ability to orally blend sounds.
Score = 10

Phonological Children say a word and then say the 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10


Awareness: individual sounds separately but in
2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10
Segmenting sequence.
Words 3 = 8–9 3 = <10 3 = <10 3 = <10
Notice: ability to listen and understand
Individual task; ability to orally separate and say 4 = <8 4 = <10 4 = <10 4 = <10
Score = 10 sounds in sequence.

Phonological Children match words that sound alike 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10 1 = 10


Awareness: in the ending part (rime).
2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 10
Rhyming Notice: ability to identify and say
3 = 8–9 3 = <10 3 = <10 3 = <10
Individual labels of objects; ability to listen for
Score = 10 and match sound patterns, speed. 4 = <8 4 = <10 4 = <10 4 = <10

PHONICS

section 9
Writing Children say words slowly and write 1 = 21+ 1 = 25 1 = 25 1 = 25
Picture the sounds they hear.
2 = 20 2 = 25 2 = 25 2 = 25
Names Notice: score, speed. [Words do not
3 = 11–19 3 = 20–24 3 = <25 3 = <25
Group have to be correctly spelled to score Appendix, Glossary, Index
Score = 25 phoneme representation.] 4 = <11 4 = <19 4 = <25 4 = <25

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1 187


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 188

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Grade 1, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

PHONICS, continued

Phonograms– Children read words with simple 1 = 9+ 1 = 16+ 1 = 20 1 = 20


List 1 phonogram patterns (CVC words with
2=8 2 = 15 2 = 20 2 = 20
Individual short vowels).
3 = 5–7 3 = 10–14 3 = 15–19 3 = <20
Score = 20 Notice: score, substitutions, and
speed. 4 = <5 4 = <10 4 = <14 4 = <20

Phonograms– Children read words with digraphs and 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 20


List 2 short vowels in phonogram patterns.
2=0 2=5 2 = 12 2 = 20
Individual Notice: score, speed, and evidence of
3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 10–11 3 = 20
Score = 20 knowing patterns even in incorrect
attempt. 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <10 4 = <20

Phonograms– Children read words with long vowels 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 20


List 3 and silent e in phonogram pattern.
2=0 2=5 2 = 12 2 = 18
Individual Notice: score, speed, and evidence of
3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 10–11 3 = 15–17
Score = 20 knowing patterns even in incorrect
attempt. 4=0 4=3 4 = <10 4 = <15

Phonograms– Children read words with a variety of 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 20


List 4 phonogram patterns.
2=0 2=5 2 = 12 2 = 18
Individual Notice: score, speed, and evidence of
3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 10–11 3 = 15–17
Score = 20 knowing patterns even in incorrect
attempt. 4=0 4=3 4 = <10 4 = <15

Consonant Children read words, marking the con- 1=0 1 = 6+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 11+


Blends sonant blends, or words with two or
2=0 2=5 2=8 2 = 10
Individual three consonant sounds together.
3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 5–7 3 = 7–9
Score = 14 Notice: ability to use consonant blends
to attempt word; number of words 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <5 4 = <7
with consonant blends child can read;
awareness of consonant blends as
shown in incorrect attempts.

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

188 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 189

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Grade 1, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

WORD STRUCTURE

Grade 1 Word Children read 30 words, which include 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 16+ 1 = 21+


Features Test a variety of features.
2=0 2=5 2 = 15 2 = 20
Individual Notice: words read correctly, evidence
3=0 3 = 2–4 3 = 10–14 3 = 15–19
Score = 30 of understanding word features in
incorrect attempts. 4=0 4 = <2 4 = 10 4 = <15

Compound Children read simple compound words 1=0 1 = 4+ 1 = 10+ 1 = 13+


Words and identify the two words put
2=0 2=3 2=9 2 = 12
Individual together.
3=0 3 = 1–2 3 = 5–8 3 = 8–11
Score = 38 Notice: score, evidence in attempts
that the child notices parts of words. 4=0 4 = <1 4 = <8 4 = <8

WRITING

Word Writing Children write all of the words they can 1 = 21+ 1 = 31+ 1 = 41+ 1 = 51+
Individual write within a designated time limit
2 = 20 2 = 30 2 = 40 2 = 50
(maximum 10 minutes; stop when the
Score = # of 3 = 10–19 3 = 20–30 3 = 30–39 3 = 40–49
child can write no more).
accurately
spelled words Notice: evidence of knowledge of word 4 = <10 4 = <20 4 = <30 4 = <40
connections, phonograms, spelling pat-
terns, word endings; ability to hear
sounds and represent with letters;
known high-frequency words; speed.

VOCABULARY

Concept Prompted by a picture card, children 1 = 10+ 1 = 12 1 = 12 1 = 12


Words: say the related concept words. Tasks:
2 = 10 2 = 12 2 = 12 2 = 12

section 9
Number (1) tell number of dots; (2) match dots
and numerals; (3) match dots and 3 = 4–9 3 = 8–11 3 = <12 3 = <12
Score = 12
for each task number words; or (4) match all. 4 = <4 4 = <8 4 = <12 4 = <12
Notice: extent to which child has devel-
oped concept of number, ability to rec- Appendix, Glossary, Index
ognize and use number words, score.

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1 189


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 190

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Grade 1, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

VOCABULARY, continued

Concept Prompted by a picture card, children say 1 = 11+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 12+ 1 = 13+
Words: Color the related concept word. Tasks: (1) say
2 = 10 2 = 10 2 = 11 2 = 12
Individual or the color word for each card; (2) match
color cards and words with appropriate 3 = 5–9 3 = 7–9 3 = 8–10 3 = 9–11
Group
color crayon; or (3) read the word cards. 4 = <5 4 = <7 4 = <8 4 = <9
Score = 25
[Remember that many children have
some form of color blindness.]
Notice: speed.

Concept Children read concept words and sort 1 = 1+ 1 = 4+ 1 = 5+ 1 = 6+


Words: Time them into appropriate categories.
2=0 2=3 2=4 2=5
Score = 24 [Alternatively, they select words from a
larger group of words.] They tell how 3=0 3 = 1–2 3 = 1–3 3 = 2–4
they are alike. 4=0 4 = <1 4 = <1 4 = <2
Notice: score evidence of connections.

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 1+ 1 = 4+ 1 = 5+ 1 = 6+


Words: Color [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=0 2=3 2=4 2=5
Score = 25 larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3=0 3 = 1–2 3 = 2–3 3 = 3–4
Notice: score, evidence of connections. 4=0 4 = <1 4 = <2 4 = <3

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 9+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 16


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=8 2 = 10 2 = 12 2 = 16
Calendar larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 5–7 3 = 6–9 3 = 9–11 3 = 12–15
Score = 16
Notice: score, evidence of connections. 4 = <5 4 = <6 4=<9 4 = <12

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 5+ 1 = 7+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 11+


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=4 2=6 2=8 2 = 10
Motion larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 2–3 3 = 4–5 3 = 7–8 3 = 8–9
Score = 20
Notice: score, evidence of connections. 4 = <2 4 = <4 4 = <7 4 = <8

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

190 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 191

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Grade 1, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

VOCABULARY, continued

Concept Children read concept word. 1 = 5+ 1 = 7+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 11+


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=4 2=6 2=8 2 = 10
Weather larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 2–3 3 = 4–5 3 = 7–8 3 = 8–9
Score = 21
Notice: score, evidence of connections. 4 = <2 4 = <4 4 = <7 4 = <8

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 3+ 1 = 5+ 1 = 7+ 1 = 9+


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=2 2=4 2=6 2=8
Transportation larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3=1 3 = 2–3 3 = 4–5 3 = 6–7
Score = 24
Notice: score, evidence of connections. 4 = <1 4 = <2 4 = <4 4 = <6

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 5+ 1 = 7+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 10+


Words: Action [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=4 2=6 2=8 2 = 10
Words (Verbs) larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 2–3 3 = 4–5 3 = 5–7 3 = 7–9
Score = 12
Notice: score, evidence of connections. 4 = <2 4 = <4 4 = <5 4 = <7

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 3+ 1 = 7+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 13+


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=2 2=6 2 = 10 2 = 12
Describing larger group of words.] They tell how
Words they are alike. 3=1 3 = 3–5 3 = 6–9 3 = 8–11
(Adjectives) Notice: score, evidence of 4 = <1 4 = <3 4 = <6 4 = <8
Score = 15 understanding.

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 1+ 1 = 3+ 1 = 5+ 1 = 7+

section 9
Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=0 2=2 2=4 2=6
Describing larger group of words.] They tell how
Words they are alike. 3=0 3=1 3=3 3 = 4–5
(Adverbs) Notice: score, evidence of 4=0 4 = <1 4 = <2 4 = <4
Score = 12 understanding. Appendix, Glossary, Index

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1 191


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 192

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Grade 1, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

VOCABULARY, continued

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 11+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 15+ 1 = 17+


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a 2 = 16
2 = 10 2 = 12 2 = 14
Number larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 6–9 3 = 8–11 3 = 10–13 3 = 12–15
Score = 25
Notice: score, evidence of 4 = >6 4 = <8 4 = <10 4 = <12
understanding.

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 1+ 1 = 3+ 1 = 5+ 1 = 7+


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=0 2=2 2=4 2=6
Ordinal larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3=0 3=1 3 = 2–3 3 = 4–5
Score = 20
Notice: score, evidence of 4=0 4 = <1 4 = <2 4 = <4
understanding.

Synonyms I Children locate words that mean the 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 13+


Score = 15 same or about the same as words read
2=0 2=5 2 = 10 2 = 12
by the teacher.
3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 6–9 3 = 8–11
Notice: number of pairs children can
identify; understanding of the concept 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <6 4 = <8
of synonym; known synonym pairs.

Antonyms 1 Children read and identify words that 1 = 1+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 15


Score = 15 mean the opposite or almost the
2=0 2=5 2 = 10 2 = 15
opposite as words read by the
teacher. 3=0 3 = 3–4 3 = 7–9 3 = 9–11
Notice: score, evidence of the 4=0 4 = <3 4 = <7 4 = <9
concept.

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

192 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 193

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria—Grade 1, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

VOCABULARY, continued

Vocabulary in Children use context to correctly iden- Level C Level F Level H Level J
Context: tify the meaning of 3 words selected
1 = 7–9 1 = 9–12 1 = 13–15 1 = 13–15
Levels C, F, from a Benchmark Assessment Book at
H, J their instructional or independent level. 2 = 5–6 2 = 7–8 2 = 9–11 2 = 9–11
Score = 12 Notice: number of words known or 3 = 2–4 3 = 2–6 3 = 4–8 3 = 4–8
on rubric almost known; ability to use context; 4 = <2 4 = <2 4 = <4 4 = <4
ability to articulate meaning.
Rubric:
2) Did not respond or said “I don’t
know.
3) Made a response that is in
some way related to the mean-
ing of the word (any definition).
3) Responded with a definition that
is approximately the meaning of
the word (same definition as
used in the text).
4) Responded with a full definition
of the word (precise definition
used in the text).

section 9
Appendix, Glossary, Index

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1 193


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 194

j
Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria —Grade 2

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

HIGH FREQUENCY WORDS

Reading High- Children read 100 high-frequency 1 = 100 1 = 100 1 = 100 1 = 100
Frequency words.
2 = 100 2 = 100 2 = 100 2 = 100
Words: 100 Notice: speed, word substitutions (simi-
Words 3 = <100 3 = <100 3 = <100 3 = <100
lar visual features), good attempts, letter/
Individual sound relationships the reader controls. 4 = <100 4 = <100 4 = <100 4 = <100
Score = 100

Reading High- Children read 200 high-frequency 1 = 101+ 1 = 150+ 1 = 175+ 1 = 200
Frequency words.
2 = 100 2 = 125 2 = 150 2 = 175+
Words: 200 Notice: speed, word substitutions
Words 3 = 75 3 = 100–124 3 = 149 3 = 150–174
(similar visual features), good
Individual attempts, letter/sound relationships 4 = 50 4 = <124 4 = <125 4 = <174
Score = 200 the reader controls.

PHONICS

Word Writing Children write all of the words they can 1 = 51+ 1 = 61+ 1 = 71+ 1 = 81+
Individual write within a designated time limit
2 = 50 2 = 60 2 = 70 2 = 80
(maximum 10 minutes; stop when the
Score = 3 = 40–49 3 = 50–59 3 = 60–69 3 = 70–79
child can write no more).
number of
accurately Notice: evidence of knowledge of word 4 = <40 4 = <50 4 = <60 4 = <70
spelled words connections, phonograms, spelling pat-
(Time will create terns, word endings; ability to hear
an upper limit sounds and represent with letters;
known high-frequency words; speed.

Phonograms– Children read words with simple 1 = 20 1 = 20 1 = 20 1 = 20


List 1 phonogram patterns (CVC words with
2 = 20 2 = 20 2 = 20 2 = 20
Individual short vowels).
3 = <20 3 = <20 3 = <20 3 = <20
Score = 20 Notice: score, substitutions, and speed.
4 = <20 4 = <20 4 = <20 4 = <20
Phonograms– Children read words with digraphs and 1 = 20 1 = 20 1 = 20 1 = 20
List 2 short vowels in phonogram patterns.
2 = 20 2 = 20 2 = 20 2 = 20
Individual Notice: score, speed, and evidence of
3 = <20 3 = <20 3 = <20 3 = <20
Score = 20 knowing patterns even in incorrect
attempt. 4 = <20 4 = <20 4 = <20 4 = <20

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

194 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 195

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria —Grade 2, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

PHONICS, continued

Phonograms– Children read words with long vowels 1 = 19+ 1 = 20 1 = 20 1 = 20


List 3 and silent e in phonogram pattern.
2 = 18 2 = 20 2 = 20 2 = 20
Individual Notice: score, speed, and evidence of
3 = 15–17 3 = <20 3 = <20 3 = <20
Score = 20 knowing patterns even in incorrect
attempt. 4 = <15 4 = <20 4 = <20 4 = <20

Phonograms– Children read words with a variety of 1 = 19+ 1 = 20 1 = 20 1 = 20


List 4 phonogram patterns.
2 = 18 2 = 20 2 = 20 2 = 20
Individual Notice: score, speed, and evidence of
3 = 15–17 3 = <20 3 = <20 3 = <20
Score = 20 knowing patterns even in incorrect
attempt. 4 = <15 4 = <20 4 = <20 4 = <20

Consonant Children read words, marking the con- 1 = 11+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 14 1 = 14


Blends sonant blends, or words with two or
2 = 10 2 = 12 2 = 14 2 = 14
Individual three consonant sounds together.
3 = 7–9 3 = 9–11 3 = <14 3 = <14
Score = 14 Notice: ability to use consonant blends
to attempt word; number of words 4 = <7 4 = <9 4 = <14 4 = <14
with consonant blends child can read;
awareness of consonant blends as
shown in incorrect attempts.

Vowel Children read words with vowels that 1 = 8+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 19+ 1 = 23


Clusters: appear together and represent one
2=8 2 = 12 2 = 18 2 = 22
List 1 sound (simple vowel clusters (ee, ea,
ai, oo). 3 = 5–7 3 = 9–11 3 = 15–17 3 = 18–21
Individual
Score = 23 Notice: score, knowledge of vowel 4 = <5 4 = <9 4 = <15 4 = <18
clusters shown in attempts, vowel
clusters the reader controls.

section 9
Vowel Children read words with vowels that 1 = 7+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 16+ 1 = 20
Clusters: appear together and represent one
2=6 2 = 10 2 = 15 2 = 18
List 2 sound (a greater variety of vowel clus-
ters including combinations with w). 3 = 3–5 3 = 7–9 3 = 12–14 3 = 15–17
Individual Appendix, Glossary, Index
Score = 20 Notice: score, knowledge of vowel 4 = <3 4 = <7 4 = <12 4 = <15
clusters shown in attempts, vowel
clusters the reader controls.

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1 195


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 196

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria —Grade 2, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

PHONICS, continued

Vowel Children read words with vowels that 1 = 3+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 13


Clusters: appear together and represent one
2=2 2=5 2 = 10 2 = 12
List 3 sound (vowel clusters with r ).
3=1 3 = 3–4 3 = 7–9 3 = 9–11
Individual Notice: score, knowledge of vowel
Score = 14 clusters shown in attempts, vowel 4 = <1 4 = <3 4 = <7 4 = <9
clusters the reader controls.

WORD STRUCTURE

Suffixes Children read words with suffixes that 1 = 3+ 1 = 6+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 13+


Individual change the part of speech.
2=2 2=5 2 = 10 2 = 12
Score = 10 Notice: score, particular suffixes rec-
3=1 3 = 3–4 3 = 7–9 3 = 9–10
ognized (even in incorrect attempts),
speed. 4 = <1 4 = <3 4 = <7 4 = <9

VOCABULARY

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 6+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 16+ 1 = 21+


Words: Time [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=5 2 = 10 2 = 15 2 = 20
Score = 24 larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 2–4 3 = 7–9 3 = 9–14 3 = 17–19
Notice: speed, evidence of connections. 4 = <2 4 = <7 4 = <9 4 = <17

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 6+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 19+ 1 = 23+


Words: Color [Alternatively, they select words from a
2=5 2 = 12 2 = 18 2 = 22
Score = 24 larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 3–4 3 = 8–11 3 = 12–17 3 = 16–21
Notice: speed, evidence of connections. 4 = <3 4 = <8 4 = <12 4 = <16

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 16 1 = 16 1 = 16 1 = 16


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2 = 16 2 = 16 2 = 16 2 = 16
Calendar larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 10–15 3 = <16 3 = <16 3 = <16
Score = 16
Notice: speed, evidence of connections. 4 = <10 4 = <16 4 = <16 4 = <16

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

196 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 197

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria —Grade 2, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

VOCABULARY, continued

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 11+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 19+ 1 = 20


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2 = 10 2 = 12 2 = 18 2 = 20
Motion larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 8–9 3 = 9–11 3 = 12–17 3 = 17–19
Score = 20
Notice: speed, evidence of connections. 4 = <8 4 = <9 4 = <12 4 = <17

Concept Children read concept words. 1 = 11+ 1 = 15+ 1 = 19+ 1 = 21


Words: [Alternatively, they select words from a
2 = 10 2 = 14 2 = 21 2 = 21
Weather larger group of words.] They tell how
they are alike. 3 = 6–9 3 = 9–13 3 = 13–17 3 = 18–20
Score = 21
Notice: speed, evidence of connections. 4 = <6 4 = <9 4 = <13 4 = <18

Concept Children read concept words and sort 1 = 9+ 1 = 18+ 1 = 21 1 = 24


Words: them into appropriate categories.
2=8 2 = 17 2 = 20 2 = 24
Transportation [Alternatively, they select words from a
larger group of words.] They tell how 3 = 1–7 3 = 10–16 3 = 12–19 3 = 18–23
Score = 24
they are alike. 4 = <1 4 = <10 4 = <12 4 = <18
Notice: score, evidence of connections.

Concept Children read concept words and sort 1 = 11+ 1 = 12 1 = 12 1 = 12


Words: Action them into appropriate categories.
2 = 10 2 = 11 2 = 12 2 = 12
Words (Verbs) [Alternatively, they select words from a
larger group of words.] They tell how 3 = 7–9 3 = 9–10 3 = <12 3 = 12
Score = 12
they are alike. 4 = <7 4 = <10 4 = <12 4 = <12
Notice: score, evidence of connections.

Concept Children read concept words and sort 1 = 13+ 1 = 15 1 = 15 1 = 15


Words: them into appropriate categories.
2 = 12 2 = 14 2 = 15 2 = 15

section 9
Describing [Alternatively, they select words from a
Words larger group of words.] They tell how 3 = 8–11 3 = 10–13 3 = <15 3 = <15
(Adjectives) they are alike. 4 = <8 4 = <10 4 = <15 4 = <15
Score = 15 Notice: score, evidence of connections.
Appendix, Glossary, Index

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1 197


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 198

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria —Grade 2, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

VOCABULARY, continued

Concept Children read concept words and sort 1 = 7+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 12


Words: them into appropriate categories.
2=6 2=8 2 = 10 2 = 12
Describing [Alternatively, they select words from a
Words larger group of words.] They tell how 3 = 4–5 3 = 5–7 3 = 7–9 3 = 9–11
(Adverbs) they are alike. 4 = <4 4 = <5 4 = <7 4 = <9
Score = 12 Notice: score, evidence of connections.

Concept Children read concept words and sort 1 = 17+ 1 = 19+ 1 = 23+ 1 = 25
Words: them into appropriate categories.
2 = 16 2 = 18 2 = 22 2 = 25
Number [Alternatively, they select words from a
larger group of words.] They tell how 3 = 14–15 3 = 12–17 3 = 16–21 3 = 23–25
Score = 25
they are alike. 4 = <14 4 = <12 4 = <15 4 = <23
Notice: score, evidence of connections.

Concept Children read concept words and sort 1 = 7+ 1 = 9+ 1 = 11+ 1 = 13+


Words: them into appropriate categories.
2=6 2=8 2 = 10 2 = 12
Ordinal [Alternatively, they select words from a
larger group of words.] They tell how 3 = 3–5 3 = 4–7 3 = 7–9 3 = 9–11
Score = 20
they are alike. 4=3 4 = <4 4 = <7 4 = <9
Notice: score, evidence of connections.

Compound Children read simple compound words 1 = 21+ 1 = 27+ 1 = 33+ 1 = 38


Words and identify the two words that have
2 = 20 2 = 26 2 = 32 2 = 38
Individual been put together.
3 = 14–19 3 = 20–25 3 = 22–31 3 = 32–37
Score = 38 Notice: score, evidence in attempts
that the reader notices parts of words. 4 = <14 4 = <20 4 = <22 4 = <32

Grade 2 Children read 30 words, which include 1 = 16+ 1 = 21+ 1 = 25+ 1 = 31+
Word a variety of features.
2 = 15 2 = 20 2 = 24 2 = 30
Features Test Notice: words read correctly, evidence
3 = 12–14 3 = 15–19 3 = 20–23 3 = 25–29
Individual of understanding word features in
incorrect attempts. 4 = <12 4 = <15 4 = <20 4 = <25
Score = 30

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

198 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 199

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria —Grade 2, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

VOCABULARY, continued

Synonyms 1 Children locate words that mean the 1 = 13+ 1 = 15 1 = 15 1 = 15


Score = 15 same or abut the same as words read
2 = 12 2 = 15 2 = 15 2 = 15
by the teacher.
3 = 8–11 3 = 10–14 3 = <15 3 = <15
Notice: number of pairs children can
identify; understanding of the concept 4 = <8 4 = <10 4 = <15 4 = <15
of synonym; known synonym pairs.

Synonyms 2 Children locate words that mean the 1 = 11+ 1 = 12+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 15
Score = 15 same or abut the same as words read
2 = 10 2 = 11 2 = 12 2 = 14
by the teacher.
3 = 7–9 3 = 9–10 3 = 10–11 3 = 13
Notice: number of pairs children can
identify; understanding of the concept 4 = <7 4 = <9 4 = <10 4 = <13
of synonym; known synonym pairs.

Antonyms 1 Children read and identify words that 1 = 13+ 1 = 15 1 = 15 1 = 15


Score = 15 mean the opposite or almost the
2 = 12 2 = 15 2 = 15 2 = 15
opposite.
3 = 8–11 3 = 10–14 3 = <15 3 = <15
Notice: score number of pairs children
can identify as opposites. 4 = <8 4 = <10 4 = <15 4 = <15

Antonyms 2 Children read and identify words that 1 = 11+ 1 = 12+ 1 = 13+ 1 = 15
Score = 15 mean the opposite or almost the
2 = 10 2 = 11 2 = 12 2 = 14
opposite.
3 = 7–9 3 = 8–10 3 = 9–11 3 = 11–13
Notice: score number of pairs children
can identify as opposites. 4 = <7 4 = <8 4 = <9 4 = <11

section 9
Appendix, Glossary, Index

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1 199


B1_Section 8_9_Higher.qxp 1/4/10 8:18 AM Page 200

Optional Literacy Assessment Criteria —Grade 2, continued

Optional Description Beginning 1st Interval 2nd Interval End of Year


Assessment of Year Assessment Assessment (May–June)
(Aug.–Sept.) (Nov.–Dec.) (Feb.–Mar.)

VOCABULARY, continued

Vocabulary Children use context to correctly iden- Level I Level K Level L Level M
in Context: tify the meaning of 3 words selected
1 = 12–15 1 = 12–15 1 = 12–15 1 = 12–15
Levels I, K, from a benchmark book at their
L, M instructional level or independent level. 2 = 9–11 2 = 9–11 2 = 9–11 2 = 9–11
Score: 12 on Notice: number of words known or 3 = 4–8 3 = 4–8 3 = 4–8 3 = 4–8
rubric almost known; ability to use context; 4 = <4 4 = <4 4 = <4 4 = <4
ability to articulate meaning.
Rubric:
4) Did not respond or said “I don’t
know.
5) Made a response that is in
some way related to the mean-
ing of the word (any definition).
6) Responded with a definition that
is approximately the meaning of
the word (same definition as
used in the text).
6) Responded with a full definition
of the word (precise definition
used in the text).

Key
Exceeds Expectations
Meets Expectations
Approaches Expectations: Needs Short-Term Intervention
Does Not Meet Expectations: Needs Intensive Intervention

200 Fountas & Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System 1

You might also like