Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Topic 1: Should Examinations Be Replaced With Other Forms of Assessment? Affirmative Negative
Topic 1: Should Examinations Be Replaced With Other Forms of Assessment? Affirmative Negative
AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE
1 PRESSURE OF TRADITIONAL EXAMINATION: ASSESSMENT STANDARD:
With examinations, student must under pressure from - They are more advanced than other assessments.
numerous sides such as family expectations, scores, teachers, - Exams at the end of the year are given so the
classmates or rank. teachers can understand if the students
+ Students always want to get high marks and be the top understood the materials throughout the school
students because they want to praised by another student as year. Depending on how the students do on the
well as their family. exam, tells the teachers what the students did or
+ Besides, there are many students learn day and night, extra- didn't learn.
curricular homework, learn after school or on Saturday in - What the teachers put on the exams, is the
order to keep up with their classmates. material that the students should know and that
+ This is very unhealthy to their mental health and cause may give them the advantage of getting a good
immense tension. score. Teachers usually use the exams do they can
+ (You can find in the newspaper that students commit suicide determine whether or not the student should be
because their pressure from examinations is unbearable. able to pass the grade or not.
Thus, I think that examinations can be created more
stress for students during growing up in the educational Evidence:
environments. Dr. Carol Utay says that "examinations are
Evidence: designed to help out students fill the gaps, help
- According to the poll carried out by the National them become their best and motivate students
Education Union in 2018, more than half (56%) of to study harder.”
school staffs said that youngsters had been self- Refute:
harming or thinking of self-harming because of mental - Your point is about Assessment standard.
health issues from testing and exams. - You said that the examination is better than the
Refute: other forms of assessments. If the teachers give
- student must under pressure from numerous sides such as the students a different assessment that doesn't
family expectations, scores, teachers, classmates or rank. include all the information they should know
- Stress also can create the motivation for the students during the program, that doesn't really give the
during learning with their classmate and their result can be teachers the progress of the student. And you give
improved. an example that examination can help student
- Student: will be familiar with stress because they will become best and motivate them to study harder.
face more stress in the future may be from family, friend, - But your evidence didn’t convince us because it
workplace. Stress usually exist everywhere, maybe not only in has no date and no specific data. So we disagree
study. Thus in the future they won’t be shock with pressure. with your point.