Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gears - General: Shigley's Mechanical Engineering Design
Gears - General: Shigley's Mechanical Engineering Design
Gears - General: Shigley's Mechanical Engineering Design
Machine Design II
Chapter 13
Shigley’s Mechanical Engineering Design
Gears: Introduction Pinion (2)
Spur gears have teeth parallel to the Helical gears have teeth inclined to
axis of rotation. They are used to the axis of rotation. Sometimes
transmit motion from one shaft to helical gears are used to transmit
another, parallel, shaft. motion between nonparallel shafts
Types of Gears
Module, m (mm/tooth)
Preferred 1, 1.25, 1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12, 16, 20, 25, 32, 40, 50
Next Choice 1.125, 1.375, 1.75, 2.25, 2.75, 3.5, 4.5, 5.5, 7, 9, 11, 14, 18, 22, 28,
36, 45
Standardized Tooth Systems (Spur Gears)
Tooth System Pressure Angle ϕ, deg Addendum a Dedendum b
Full depth 20 1/P or m 1.25/P or 1.25m
1.35/P or 1.35m
Fig. 13–9
(a) Answer p
Example 13–1 (2)
The pitch diameters of the pinion and gear are, respectively,
d p m x N p 12(16) 192mm dG m x N G 12(40) 480mm
Therefore the center distance is
d P dG 192+480
Answer 336mm
2 2
From Equation (13–6), with a 20° pressure angle, the base radii are
192
Answer (rb ) pinion cos 20 85.24mm
2
480
Answer (rb ) gear cos 20 225.53mm
2
Example 13–1 (3)
(b) Designating d′P and d′G as the new pitch-circle diameters, the 6.35 mm
increase in the center distance requires that
d P dG
342.35 (1)
2
Since rb = r cos ϕ, using either the pinion or gear, the new pressure angle is
(rb ) pinion 85.24
f cos
1
cos 1 22.59
Answer
dP 2 95.63 2
Contact Ratio
Arc of action qt is the sum of the arc of approach qa and the arc of recess qr.,
that is
qt qa qr
The contact ratio, mc, is the ratio of the arc of action and the circular pitch.
qt
mc (13 - 8)
p
The contact ratio is the average number of pairs of teeth in contact.
Fig. 13–11
Contact Ratio
Contact ratio can also be found from the length of the line of
action.
Lab
mc (13 - 9)
p cos f
Fig. 13–11
Interference
• Contact of portions of
tooth profiles that are not
conjugate is called
interference.
• Occurs when contact
occurs below the base
circle.
• If teeth were produced by
generating process
(rather than stamping),
then the generating
process removes the
interfering portion;
known as undercutting.
NP
2k
3sin f
2
1 1 3sin 2
f (13 - 10)
NP
2k
1 2m sin f
2
m
m 2
(1 2 m )sin 2
f (13 - 11)
Interference of Spur Gears
Largest gear with a specified pinion that is interference-free is
N P2 sin 2 f 4k 2
NG (13 -12)
4k 2 N P sin 2 f
2(k )
NP (13 - 13)
sin 2 f
Force analysis of Spur Gears
Notations for Force Analysis
Numbering: Beginning from the frame of the machine as 1
In put gear is 2, and the successive gears are 2, 3, 4 - - -
Shafts: Shafts are numbered as a, b, c - - -
Force exerted by a gear on the other:
F23 – Force exerted by 2 on 3
F2a – Force exerted by 2 on shaft a
Directions of the force as superscripts:
Force Analysis – Spur Gearing
FREE BODY DIAGRAMS
Fig. 13–28
• Access the text alternative for slide images.
Force Analysis – Spur Gearing
Transmitted load Wt is the
tangential load.
Wt F32t
d
T Wt
2
V dn 12 (13 - 34)
where V = pitch-line velocity, ft/min.
d = gear diameter, in.
n = gear speed, rev/min.
Power in Spur Gearing
Useful power relation in customary units,
H
Wt 33000 (13 - 35)
V
where Wt = transmitted load, lbf.
H = power, hp. V = pitch-line velocity, ft/min.
In SI units,
60000 H
Wt (13 - 36)
dn
where Wt = transmitted load, kN.
H = power, kW.
d = gear diameter, mm.
n = speed, rev/min.
Example 13–7
Pinion 2 in Figure 13–30a runs at 1750 rev/min and transmits 2.5
kW to idler gear 3. The teeth are cut on the 20° full-depth system
and have a module of m = 2.5 mm. Draw a free-body diagram of
gear 3 and show all the forces that act upon it.
Fig. 13–30
• Access the text alternative for slide images.
Example 13–7 (2)
Solution
The pitch diameters of gears 2 and 3 are
d 2 N 2 m 20(2.5) 50 mm
d3 N 3m 50(2.5) 125mm
From Equation (13–36) we find the transmitted load to be
60000 H 60000(2.5)
Wt 0.546 kN
d2n (50)(1750)
Thus, the tangential force of gear 2 on gear 3 is Ft23 = 0.546 kN, as shown in Figure 13–
30b. Therefore
F23r F23t tan 20 (0.546) tan 20 0.199 kN
and so F23t 0.546
F23 0.581 kN
cos 20 cos 20
Since gear 3 is an idler, it transmits no power (torque) to its shaft, and so the tangential
reaction of gear 4 on gear 3 is also equal to Wt. Therefore
F43t 0.546 kN F43r 0.199 kN F43 0.581kN
and the directions are shown in Figure 13–30b.
Example 13–7 (3)
The shaft reactions in the x and y directions are
Fbx3 ( F23t F43r ) ( 0.546 0.199) 0.347 kN
Chapter 13
Shigley’s Mechanical Engineering Design
Lecture outline
• Straight Bevel Gears
• Force Analysis of Bevel Gears
• Parallel Helical Gears
• Force Analysis of Helical Gears
• Worm Gears
• Force Analysis of Worm gears
• Gear Manufacturing
• Forming
• Milling
• Shaping
• Hobbing
• Finishing
Straight Bevel Gears
• A Bevel gear is a gear
having teeth cut into a
conical surface, usually
meshing with a similar
gear set at right angles
• Bevel Gears transfer
motion between
nonparallel shafts
Nomenclature of Bevel Gears
Nomenclature of Bevel Gears
Pitch Cone: Pitch surface of the bevel gear represented by
OP.
Back cone.- The complementary cone generated by a line at
right angles to the pitch cone generator at the pitch
diameter and intersecting the axis.
Cone Centre: The apex of the pitch cone where the axes
mating gears intersect
Pitch Diameter d: The pitch of bevel gears is measured at
the large end of the tooth, and both the circular pitch and
the pitch diameter are calculated in the same manner as for
spur gears.
Pitch cone Angle, , : The pitch angles are defined by the
pitch cones meeting at the apex.
Nomenclature of Bevel Gears
Face Width F: Length of one tooth
Cone Distance Ao: Distance from pitch circle to intersection of
shaft axes.
NP NG
tan tan (13 -14)
NG NP
Back-Cone Radius rb
The shape of teeth, projected on back cone, is same as in a
spur gear with radius rb.
Virtual number of teeth in this virtual spur gear is
2 rb
N (13 - 15)
p
Table 13–3
Force analysis of Bevel Gears
T
Wt (13 - 37)
rav
Wr Wt tan cos
(13 - 38)
Wa Wt tan sin
Force analysis of Bevel Gears
Force analysis of Bevel Gears
Example
The bevel pinion in the Figure rotates at 600 rev/min in the direction shown and
transmits 5 hp to the gear. The mounting distances, the location of all bearings, and
the average pitch radii of the pinion and gear are shown in the figure. The pinion
has 15 teeth and P = 5 teeth/in. For simplicity, the teeth have been replaced by
pitch cones. Bearings A and C should take the thrust loads. Find the bearing forces
on the gear shaft.
Force analysis of Bevel Gears
Solution
The pitch angles are
In preparing to take a sum of the moments about bearing D, define the position vector
from D to G as
After the two cross products are taken, the equation becomes
(2)
from which
(3)
Force analysis of Bevel Gears
Solution
Now sum the forces to zero. Thus
FD FC W 0 (4)
When the details are inserted, Equation (4) becomes
(5)
Answer
These are all shown in Figure 13–32b in the proper directions. The analysis for
the pinion shaft is quite similar.
Helical Gears
• Similar to spur gears, but with
teeth making a helix angle with
respect to the gear centerline.
• Adds axial force component to
shaft and bearings.
• Smoother transition of force
between mating teeth due to
gradual engagement and
disengagement.
Parallel Helical Gears
Tooth shape is involute helicoid
• If a piece of paper cut in the
shape of a parallelogram is
wrapped around a cylinder,
the angular edge of the
paper becomes a helix.
• If we unwind this paper, each
point on the angular edge
generates an involute
curve.
• The surface obtained when
every point on the edge
generates an involute is
called an involute helicoid
Right hand and Left hand Helical Gears
• The teeth of a LEFT HAND Helical Gear lean to the left when
the gear is placed flat on a horizontal surface.
• The teeth of a RIGHT HAND Helical Gear lean to the right
when the gear is placed flat on a horizontal surface.
Helical gears basic Geometry
plane of rotation
the plane
perpendicular to
the teeth.
Parallel Helical Gears
Transverse circular pitch pt is in the plane of
rotation.
Normal circular pitch pn is in the plane
perpendicular to the teeth.
pn pt cos (13 - 16)
Axial pitch px is along the direction of the
shaft axis.
pt
px (13 - 17)
tan
Normal diametral pitch.
Pt
Pn
cos (13 -18)
pn Pn
Relationship between angles.
tan n
cos (13 - 19)
tan t Fig. 13–18
Parallel Helical Gears
Normal diametral pitch. (for USC units)
Pt
Pn
cos (13 -18)
pn Pn
tan n
cos (13 - 19)
tan t
Parallel Helical Gears
The parameters on the normal plane are the
standard values.
To use the formulae for spur gear Transverse
plane parameters should be used.
• Viewing along the teeth, the apparent pitch
radius is greater than when viewed along the
shaft.
• The greater virtual R has a greater virtual
number of teeth N‘.
N
N (13 - 20)
cos3
Fig. 13–19
Properties of helical gears
Transmit motion between Parallel shafts
The helix angle is the same for each gear but the direction is different; One is
right hand and the other is left.
The shape of the tooth is an involute helicoid
.Unlike the spur gears the line of contact is diagonal across the face of the
teeth.
This gradual engagement of teeth makes it possible for smooth transfer of
high speeds and torques.
The contact ratio therefore becomes less important and the contact area
which is the face area that becomes important.
Properties of helical gears
Helical gears produce both axial and radial loads on the shaft.
When the thrust loads become objectionably high double helical or
herringbone gears are used.
A double helical or herringbone is equivalent to two helical gears of
opposite hands mounted side by side on the same shaft.
They develop opposite thrusts and cancels each other.
When two or more helical gears are mounted on the same shaft the hands
of the gears should be chosen to minimize the thrust load.
Parallel Helical Gears
Example
A stock helical gear has a normal pressure angle of 20°, a helix
angle of 25°, and a transverse diametral pitch of 6 teeth/in, and has
18 teeth. Find:
(a) The pitch diameter.
(b) The transverse, the normal, and the axial pitches.
(c) The normal diametral pitch.
(d) The transverse pressure angle.
Parallel Helical Gears
Solution
Interference with Helical Gears
On helical gear with one-to-one gear ratio, smallest
number of teeth which will not have interference is
NP
2k cos
3sin t
2
1
1 3sin 2
t (13 - 21)
Dedendum 1.25
Standard center Dd
Pn 2
distance
NP
Pinion pitch diameter Pn cos Gear outside diameter D + 2a
NG
Gear pitch diameter Pn cos Pinion outside diameter d + 2a
Bn
Normal arc tooth thickness† 2 Pn 2 Gear root diameter D − 2b
Wr W sin n
Wt W cos n cos (13 - 39)
Wa W cos n sin
Wr Wt tan t
Wa Wt tan (13 - 40)
Wt
W
cos n cos
Fig. 13–33
• Access the text alternative for slide images.
Force Analysis of Helical Gears
Example
A 0.75 kw electric motor runs at
1800 rev/min in the clockwise
direction, as viewed from the
positive x axis. Keyed to the motor
shaft is an 18-tooth helical pinion
having a normal pressure angle of
20◦, a helix angle of 30◦, and a
normal module of 2 mm. The hand
of the helix is shown in the figure.
Make a three-dimensional sketch of
the motor shaft and pinion, and
76.2mm
show the forces acting on the pinion 254mm
and the bearing reactions at A and B.
The thrust should be taken out at A
Force Analysis of Helical Gears
The pinion transmits the forces it experiences to
bearings A and B.
Bearing B cannot take axial loads and hence bearing A
takes up the Axial loads.
Hence the forces in the bearings A and B are as follows:
Chapter 13
Shigley’s Mechanical Engineering Design
(Part 3)
Lecture outline
• Worm Gears
• General features and properties
• Force Analysis of Worm gears
• Gear Manufacturing
• Forming
• Milling
• Shaping
• Hobbing
• Finishing
Worm and Worm Gears
A worm gear is a device consisting of a
threaded shaft (a worm) that meshes
with a gearwheel (the worm wheel), so
that rotary motion can be transferred
between two shafts at right angles to
each other, and their axes do not meet.
Worm gears are used to transmit
motion or power between right-angled
shafts when a high-ratio reduction is
necessary. https://youtu.be/ozy7gdiCTY8
When the worm rotates against the
wheel, the screw face pushes on the https://www.youtube.com/
watch?v=S3XAeMCeZr0
teeth of the wheel.
The wheel is connected to the load and
thus is pushed against the load.
Worm and Worm Gears
Why the gear reduction is large?
When the worm makes a full rotation, the gear advances by a
distance of a single lead.
For a single start thread, the distance travelled by the worm is
the pitch (Distance between two corresponding points in a
screw)
This means if the wheel has 20 teeth, the worm has to make 20
rotations for the wheel to make one full rotation.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aKwWvlhqes0
Worm and Worm Gears
Common to specify lead
angle λ for worm and helix
angle G for gear.
Common to specify axial
pitch px for worm and
transverse circular pitch pt
for gear.
Pitch diameter of gear is
measured on plane
containing worm axis.
N G pt
dG (13 - 25)
Fig. 13–20
Worm and Worm Gears
Warm Gear Pairs
Velocity ratio =
=
Worm and Worm gears
Recommended Pressure Angles and Tooth Depths
for Worm Gearing
Lead Angle λ, deg Pressure Angle ϕn, deg Addendum a Dedendum bG
0–15 0.3683px 0.3683px
15–30 20 0.3683px 0.3683px
30–35 25 0.2865px 0.3314px
35–40 25 0.2546px 0.2947px
40–45 30 0.2228px 0.2578px
Table 13–5
Answer:
Answer:
© McGraw Hill 13
Worm Gearing Efficiency
Efficiency is defined as
cos n f tan
(13 - 46)
cos n f cot
© McGraw Hill 14
Worm Gearing Efficiency
With typical value of f = 0.05, and ϕn = 20º, efficiency as a function
of lead angle is given in the table.
Lead Angle λ, deg Efficiency η, %
1.0 25.2
2.5 45.7
5.0 62.6
7.5 71.3
10.0 76.6
15.0 82.7
20.0 85.6
30.0 88.7
Table 13–6
© McGraw Hill 15
Worm Gearing Efficiency
Coefficient of friction is
dependent on relative or sliding
velocity VS.
VG is pitch line velocity of gear.
VW is pitch line velocity of worm.
VW VG VS
VW
VS (13 - 47)
cos
Fig. 13–37
Access the text alternative for slide images.
© McGraw Hill 16
Coefficient of Friction for Worm Gearing
Graph shows representative values.
Curve A is for when more friction is expected, such as when gears are cast iron.
Curve B is for high-quality materials.
Fig. 13–38
Access the text alternative for slide images.
© McGraw Hill 17
Force Analysis of Worm Gears
Example
A worm drive transmits 15 kW at 2000 rpm to a machine carriage at 75 rpm. The
worm is triple threaded and has 65 mm pitch diameter. The worm gear has 90
teeth and 6 mm module. The tooth form is to be 200 involute. Calculate
a. The tangential force on the worm
b. Axial thrust on the worm
c. Separating force on the worm
Solution: × ×
Torque on the worm, T
×
× × . ×
Answer: Tangential force on the worm
Answer:
Fig. 13–39
© McGraw Hill 19
Force Analysis of Worm Gears
Solution:
(a) The axial pitch is the same as the transverse circular pitch of the gear, which is
Answer
The pitch diameter of the gear is dG = NG/P = 30∕6 = 5 in. Therefore, the center
distance is
Answer
Answer
Answer
© McGraw Hill 20
Force Analysis of Worm Gears
Solution:
(b) Using the right-hand rule for the rotation of the worm, you
will see that your thumb points in the positive z direction. Now
use the bolt-and-nut analogy (the worm is right-handed, as is the
Wwa
screw thread of a bolt), and turn the bolt clockwise with the
right hand while preventing nut rotation with the left. The nut Wwr Wwt
will move axially along the bolt toward your right hand.
Therefore the surface of the gear (Figure 13–39) in contact with WGa WGr
the worm will move in the negative z direction as shown in the
figure. WGt
The pitch-line velocity of the worm is:
The speed and velocity of the gear can be determined. Direction of rotation
The speed of the gear can be determined: nG = Fig. 13–39b
t
© McGraw Hill 21
Force Analysis of Worm Gears
Solution:
Then, from Equation (13–47), the sliding velocity VS is found to be
This force acts in the negative x direction, as shown in the Fig. 13-39b. Using Figure 13–38,
we find f = 0.03. Then, the first equation of Equation (13–43) gives
© McGraw Hill 22
Force Analysis of Worm Gears
Solution:
‘ now identify the components
We
acting on the gear as
© McGraw Hill 23
Force
Solution:
Analysis of Worm Gears
Taking moments about the z axis, we have:
Answer
It is because of the frictional loss that this output torque is less than
the product of the gear ratio and the input torque.
© McGraw Hill 24
Gear Manufacturing
Forming of Gear Teeth
Common ways of forming gear teeth.
• Sand casting.
• Shell molding.
• Investment casting.
• Permanent-mold casting.
• Die casting.
• Centrifugal casting.
• Powder-metallurgy.
• Extrusion.
• Injection molding (for thermoplastics).
• Cold forming.
Gear Manufacturing
Cutting of Gear Teeth
• Shaping.
Cutter reciprocates, usually on vertical spindle
• Hobbing.
Workpiece (gear blank) and cutter (hob) rotate in coordinated fashion.
• Finishing
Gear Manufacturing
Gear Cutting Tools
Hob for small pitch gears Hob for high pitch gears
having large teeth having small teeth
Gear Manufacturing
Finishing
Different methods of gear finishing:
• Shaving
• a minute amount of metal is cut bringing the accuracy of the tooth
profile within the limits of 250 μin.
• Burnishing,
• hardened gears with slightly oversize teeth are run in mesh with the
gear until the surfaces become smooth.
• Grinding
• used for hardened gear teeth after heat treatment.
• Employs the generating principle and produces very accurate teeth.
• Lapping
• Also used for hardened gear teeth after heat treatment.
• The teeth of the gear and lap slide axially so that the whole surface
of the teeth is abraded equally.
Gear Manufacturing
Generating a Spur Gear with a Pinion Cutter
Fig. 13–13
Fig. 13–14
• Access the text alternative for slide images.
Gear Manufacturing
Hobbing a Spur Gear
Fig. 13–15
Gear Manufacturing
Videos for Gear Manufacturing
https://youtu.be/B0XSsa79Y1w
https://youtu.be/XZgsV0AZJJ0
Gears - General
Machine Design II
Chapter 13
Shigley’s Mechanical Engineering Design
(Part 4)
Lecture outline
• Gear Trains
• Definition
• Types of Gear Trains
• Simple gear Train
• Compound gear Train
• Compound Reverted Gear Train
• Epicyclic or Planetary gear Train
• Planetary Gear Analysis
Gear Trains
A gear train consists of a combination of two or more gears
mounted on rotating shafts to transmit power from one to the
other and act as speed reducer or speed increaser.
For spur and parallel helical gears, the directions in the viewing plane
ordinarily correspond to the right-hand rule—positive for counterclockwise
rotation and negative for clockwise rotation.
Gear Trains
Rotational directions are somewhat difficult to deduce for worm
and crossed helical gearsets. Figure below will be of help in these
situations
Fig. 13–22
Gear Trains
Fig. 13–23
Gear Trains
Velocity Ratio: Ratio of rotational speed of input gear to
output gear for single pair of gears
where nL is the speed of the last gear in the train and nF is the speed of the first.
Gear Trains
External and Internal Meshing
External meshing produces rotation in opposite directions.
Internal meshing produces rotation in the same direction
Types of the Gear Trains
Simple gear Train – One gear mounted in one shaft
Compound gear – Two gears are placed in the same shaft
Compound Reverted Gears – Input and output shafts are
collinear
Epicyclic or planetary gears – At least one of the gears is
rotating with the axis of another gear. (Epi means axis cyclic
means rotating)
Simple Gear Train
Simple gear Train – One gear mounted in one shaft
Driver Driven
gear gear
Intermediate
(idler) gears
Simple Gear Trains
• Note that when the number of intermediate gears is odd,
driver and driven gears rotate on the same direction; but
if the number of intermediate gears is even, driver and
driven gears rotate on opposite directions.
• Train value is independent of the size and the number of
intermediate gears.
• Intermediate gears are called idle gears, as they do not
effect the speed ratio of the system.
• The idle gears are used for the following two purposes :
1. To connect gears where a large distance is required, and
2. To obtain the desired direction of motion of the driven
gear(i.e. clockwise or anticlockwise).
Compound Gear Train
• Definition: When there are more than one gear a shaft as shown
in the figure, it is known as compound gear train.
• Compound gear trains are useful in bridging over the space
between the driver and the driven.
• The advantage of compound train over a simple train is that a
much longer speed reduction from one shaft to the last shaft can
be obtained with small gears
Compound Reverted Gear Trains
It is sometimes desirable for the input shaft and the output shaft
of a two-stage compound gear train to be in-line, as shown in
Figure 13–25. This configuration is called a compound reverted
gear train.
Requires the distances between the shafts to be the same for both
stages of the train.
The distance constraint is: d 2 2 d3 2 d 4 2 d5 2
Diametral pitch is P N d
Therefore, N 2 (2 P) N 3 (2 P) N 4 (2 P) N 5 (2 P) N 2 N3 N 4 N5
Fig. 13–25
Gear Trains
Guidance for Gear Train design:
• Rough guideline: a train value of up to 10 to 1 can be obtained
with one pair of gears.
• Greater ratios can be obtained in less space and with fewer
dynamic problems by compounding additional pairs of gears.
• A two-stage compound gear train can obtain a train value of up to
100 to 1.
• Since numbers of teeth on gears must be integers, it is better to
determine them first, and then obtain pitch diameters second.
• Determine the number of stages necessary to obtain the overall
ratio, then divide the overall ratio into portions to be
accomplished in each stage
• To minimize package size, keep the portions as evenly divided
between the stages as possible. For example, if the overall train
value need only be approximated, each stage can be identical.
Gear Trains
Example 13-3:
A gearbox is needed to provide a 30:1 (±1 percent) increase in speed,
while minimizing the overall gearbox size. Specify appropriate tooth
numbers.
Solution
Assign
Assign then
Planetary Gear Trains
Definition: If one or more shafts rotate around another shaft
as well as spinning about their own axes, the gear train is called
a planetary or epicyclic gear train.
/Arm
https://youtu.be/ARd-Om2VyiE
https://youtu.be/kmJADKX5yaw
Planetary Gear Trains
Planetary gear trains are used extensively for compact gear
reducers. Also, because they are basically devices with multiple
degrees of freedom, they are used in automatic transmissions for
automobiles and trucks
A planetary gear train has the following advantages over ordinary
gear trains:
1. It has compact space requirements, particularly when the
input and output axes are collinear
2. Both static and dynamic forces are balanced when multiple
planets are equally spaced about the central axes of the gear
train
3. High torque capacity is possible, by using multiple planets.
4. It can provide a wide range of speed ratios.
Planetary Gear Trains
• Planetary (Epicyclic) Gear Box
Planetary Gear Trains
A simple planetary gear trains are typically made up of the
following:
1. Sun gear (which may or may not be fixed) - has fixed center
axis.
2. Planet carrier or Arm - carries planet axis relative to sun axis.
3. Planet gears (one or more) - has moving center axis).
4. Internal ring gear (not used in all planetary gear trains).
Planetary
2/9/2022 gear train Side view Skeleton representation
Planetary Gear Analysis
• The motion of a planetary gear train is not always as
intuitive as fixed-center trains.
• As gears and carriers rotate, the motion can appear
rather complex.
• To analyze the motion of a planetary gear train, Two
methods are usually employed:
1. Formula method
2. Superposition method (Tabular method)
Formula Method
To develop the formula method, the motion of the mating gears
is examined relative to the arm or carrier. Thus, kinematic
inversion is used to view the train as if the carrier were fixed.
One gear on the end of the train is designated the first gear. The
gear on the opposite end of the train is designated the last gear
The first gear is designated as a driver gear and the last gear is
a driven gear. The intermediate gears are appropriately
identified depending on whether they drive or are driven.
The first gear has a velocity designated nF and the last gear has
a velocity designated nL. The arm (carrier) has a velocity nA.
Formula Method
The angular velocity of the first gear relative to the arm in rev/min
is: nF/A = nF – nA (a)
Also, the angular velocity of the last gear relative to the arm in
rev/min is: nL/A = nL – nA (c)
Dividing Equation (c) by Equation (b) gives:
/
(13-32)
/
The above equation can be solved for any of the angular velocity
terms, knowing the other two. Often, either the first gear, last gear,
or the carrier is fixed and a zero is substituted for that term.
Formula Method
Example 13–6
In Figure 13–26 the sun gear is the input, and it is driven clockwise at 100
rev/min. The ring gear is held stationary by being fastened to the frame. Find the
rev/min and direction of rotation of the arm and gear 4.
Solution
1. Specify the first and last gear: The sun (gear
2) will be designated the first gear and the
ring gear (gear 5) will be designated as the
last gear
2. Substitute Gear Ratios into the Planetary
Train Formula: Gear 2 (first) mates with gear
4, which in turn mates with gear 5 (last).
Substituting into the equation gives:
Solving;
nA = 0 rpm = 20 rpm CW
Solving;
nL = n4 1560 = 1560 rpm CW
Similarly;
/
Gear 4 rotates w.r.t gear 1: 4 N1 N 3 1 30 35
1 rev.
N3 N4 35 100
0.3 rev.
Step 2: Rotates all links –1 revolution. This returns the sun gear to its
original position, yielding a net movement of zero.
Superposition Method
Solution (continued):
Step 3: Combine the two motions, resulting in the actual planetary gear
train motion. Thus the rotations from both steps are algebraically
added together
Superposition Method
Solution (continued):
Step 4: Determine Velocities of All Links: The velocities can be
determined by using the ratios of angular displacements of any pair.
The reference can be made with the item with known speed. In this
case, it is the arm (no. 2)
Superposition Method
Example 13–6 (using superposition method)
In Figure 13–26 the sun gear is the input, and it is driven clockwise at 100
rev/min. The ring gear is held stationary by being fastened to the frame. Find the
rev/min and direction of rotation of the arm and gear 4.
Solution
Step 1: Temporarily fix the carrier then compute
the motions of all gears as the previously fixed
gear (ring gear) rotates one revolution. Thus, the
following can be determined:
Gear 5 rotates one revolution: θ5 = + 1 rev.
Gear 4 rotates w.r.t. gear 5:
Fig. 13–26
Superposition Method
Solution (continue..):
Step 2: Rotates all links –1 revolution. This returns the ring gear to its
original position, yielding a net movement of zero.
Step 3: Combine the two motions above resulting in the actual planetary
gear train motion. Thus the rotations from both steps are algebraically
added together
Link Ring (5) Planet (4) Arm (3) Sun (2)
Step 1: +1 +2.667 0 4
Rotate with fixed arm
Step 2: 1 1 1 1
Rotate all links 1 rev opposite direction
Step 3: 0 1.667 1 5
Total rotations
Superposition Method
Solution (continued):
Step 4. Determine Velocities of All Links: The velocities can be
determined by using the ratios of angular displacements of any pair.
The reference can be made with the item with known speed. In this
case, it is the sun gear (no. 2)
Planetary Gear Trains
Some Useful Links
Planetary Gear Simulator (thecatalystis.com)
Chapter 14
Shigley’s Mechanical Engineering Design
Lecture outline
• Introduction
• Cantilever Beam Model of Bending Stress in Gear
Tooth
• Lewis Equation
• Dynamic factor
• Fatigue Stress-Concentration Factor
• Surface Durability
• AGMA Method
• Various factors used in gear design
Introduction
Stress Distribution On Gear Tooth:
Stress distribution on the gear
tooth in operation can be
observed by considering the
Photoelastic Model of the tooth:
Here, concentrated lines show
high concentration of stresses
at two areas:
at the point of contact, and
at the root of the tooth
A cantilever of cross-sectional
dimensions F and t, having a length l
and a load Wt uniformly distributed
across the face width F.
Cantilever Beam Model of Bending Stress in
Gear Tooth
Considering the cantilever
M 6W t l
s (a)
I c Ft 2
600 V
Kv (cast iron, cast profile) (14 - 4a )
600
1200 V
Kv (cut or milled profile) (14 - 4b )
1200
50 V
Kv (hobbed or shaped profile) (14 - 5a )
50
78 V
Kv (shaved or ground profile) (14 - 5b )
78
Dynamic Effects
With pitch-line velocity V in meters per second,
3.05 V
Kv (cast iron, cast profile) (14 - 6a )
3.05
6.1 V
Kv (cut or milled profile) (14 - 6b )
6.1
3.56 V
Kv (hobbed or shaped profile) (14 - 6c )
3.56
5.56 V
Kv (shaved or ground profile) (14 - 6d )
5.56
Lewis Equation
The Lewis equation including velocity factor.
U.S. Customary version.
K vW t P
s (14 - 7)
FY
Metric version.
K vW t
s (14 - 8)
FmY
Acceptable for general estimation of stresses in gear
teeth.
Forms basis for AGMA method, which is preferred
approach.
Lewis Equation
Example 14–1
A design factor of 3 means that the allowable bending stress is 206/3 MPa
The pitch diameter is 3 x 16 = 48 mm, so the pitch-line velocity:
V
Lewis Equation
Example 14–1 (continues…)
12
K vW 1 1
t
s C C p (14 -14)
F cos f r1 r2
Again, this is useful for estimating, and as the basis for the
preferred AGMA approach.
AGMA Stress Equations
AGMA stands for the American Gear Manufacturers
Association.
• AGMA provides a recommended method for gear
design.
• Includes bending stress and contact stress as two failure
modes.
• Incorporates modifying factors to account for various
situations.
• Imbeds much of the detail in tables and figures.
AGMA Bending Stress
t Pd K m K B
W K K
o v s K (U.S. customary units)
F J
s (14 - 15)
1 KH KB
W t K o K v K s (SI units)
bmt YJ
where W t, Ko, Kv, Ks, Km, F, and b are the same terms as defined for
Equation (14–15). For U.S. customary units (SI units), the
additional terms are.
2 2
Cp (ZE) is an elastic coefficient, lbf in ( N mm )
Cf (ZR) is the surface condition factor.
dP (dw1) is the pitch diameter of the pinion, in (mm).
I (ZI) is the geometry factor for pitting resistance.
AGMA Strengths
AGMA uses allowable stress numbers rather than strengths.
These are referred to as strengths for consistency within the
textbook.
The gear strength values are only for use with the AGMA stress
values, and should not be compared with other true material
strengths.
Representative values of typically available bending strengths are
given in Table 14–3 for steel gears and Table 14–4 for iron and
bronze gears (See textbook)
Figures 14–2, 14–3, and 14–4 are used as indicated in the tables.
(See textbook)
Tables assume repeatedly applied loads at 107 cycles and 0.99
reliability.
Allowable Bending Stress
St YN
S K K (U.S. customary units)
s all F T R (14 - 17)
St YN (SI units)
S F Y YZ
cosft sinft mG
2m external gears
N mG 1
I (14 - 23)
cosft sinft mG internal gears
2mN mG 1
NG dG
mG (14 - 22)
NP dP
pN
mN (14 - 21)
0.95Z
Fig. 14–17
Summary for Surface Wear of Gear Teeth
s
Fig. 14–18
Gear Mesh Analysis
Example 14-4
A 17-tooth 20° pressure angle spur pinion rotates at 1800 rev/min and
transmits 4 hp to a 52-tooth disk gear. The diametral pitch is 10 teeth/in,
the face width 1.5 in, and the quality standard is No. 6. The gears are
straddle-mounted with bearings immediately adjacent. The pinion is a
grade 1 steel with a hardness of 240 Brinell tooth surface and through-
hardened core. The gear is steel, through-hardened also, grade 1 material,
with a Brinell hardness of 200, tooth surface and core. Poisson’s ratio is
0.30, JP = 0.30, JG = 0.40, and Young’s modulus is 30(106) psi. The loading is
smooth because of motor and load. Assume a pinion life of 108 cycles and a
reliability of 0.90, and use YN = 1.3558N−0.0178, ZN = 1.4488N−0.023. The tooth
profile is uncrowned. This is a commercial enclosed gear unit.
(a) Find the factor of safety of the gears in bending.
(b) Find the factor of safety of the gears in wear.
(c) By examining the factors of safety, identify the threat to each gear and
to the mesh.
Gear Mesh Analysis
Solution:
Gear Mesh Analysis
Solution (Continues..)
To determine the size factor, Ks, the Lewis form factor is needed. From Table 14–2,
with NP = 17 teeth, YP = 0.303. Interpolation for the gear with NG = 52 teeth yields
YG = 0.412. Thus from Eq. (a) of Sec. 14–10, with F = 1.5 in,
The load distribution factor Km is determined from Eq. (14–30), where five terms
are needed. They are, where F = 1.5 in when needed:
Gear Mesh Analysis
Solution (Continues..)
Gear Mesh Analysis
Solution (Continues..)
Gear Mesh Analysis
Solution (Continues..)
Gear Mesh Analysis
Solution (Continues..)
(c) For the pinion, we compare (SF)P with (SH)2P, or 5.73 with 1.692 = 2.86, so
the threat in the pinion is from wear. For the gear, we compare (SF)G with
(SH)2G, or 6.96 with 1.522 = 2.31, so the threat in the gear is also from wear.
Design of Gears for
Strength
(Bevel and Worm Gears)
Machine Design II
Chapter 15
Shigley’s Mechanical Engineering Design
Lecture outline
Bevel Gearing—General
Bevel-Gear Stresses and Strengths
AGMA Equation Factors
Straight-Bevel Gear Analysis
Design of a Straight Bevel Gear Mesh
Worm Gearing—AGMA Equation
Worm-Gear Analysis
Designing a Worm Gear Mesh
Buckingham Wear Load
Bevel Gearing - General
Bevel gear classifications.
• Straight bevel gears
• Spiral bevel gears
• Zerol bevel gears.
• Hypoid gears.
• Spiroid gears.
Consists of curved teeth but with a
zero spiral angle. Axial thrust loads
are less than spiral bevel gear.
Often used instead of straight bevel
gears.
Fig. 15–4
Bevel-Gear Stresses and Strengths
Due to complexity of other forms of bevel gears, only a portion of
the applicable standards that refer to straight-bevel gears is
presented here. Table 15–1 gives the symbols used in ANSI/AGMA
2003-B97.
Fundamental Contact Stress Equation
1/2
W t
sc σ c C p K o K υ K m Cs C xc (U.S. customary units)
Fd p I
(15 - 1)
1/ 2
1000W t
σH ZE K A K υ K Hβ Z x Z xc (SI units)
bd Z 1
Wt KK
st Pd K o K υ s m (U.S. customary units)
F Kx J
(15 - 3)
1000W K A K υ Yx K Hβ
t
σF (SI units)
b met Yβ YJ
sat K L
swt (U.S. customary units)
S F KT K R
(15 - 4)
σ F lim YNT
σF P (SI units)
S F K θYZ
AGMA Equation Factors
Many factors are defined as in the case of Spur gears. Students are
asked to refer to textbook for detail coverage of these factors.
Allowable Stresses
Refer to the relevant tables and graphs in the textbook for
allowable contact stresses and allowable bending stresses
Summary for Straight-Bevel Gear Wear
Fig. 15–14
Summary for Straight-Bevel Gear Bending
Continues
next side
Summary for Straight-Bevel Gear Bending
Fig. 15–15
Bevel-Gear Stresses and Strengths
Example 15–1
A pair of identical straight-tooth miter gears listed in a catalog has a
diametral pitch of 5 at the large end, 25 teeth, a 1.10-in face width,
and a 20° normal pressure angle; the gears are grade 1 steel through-
hardened with a core and case hardness of 180 Brinell. The gears are
uncrowned and intended for general industrial use. They have a
quality number of Qv = 7. It is likely that the application intended will
require outboard mounting of the gears. Use a safety factor of 1, a
107 cycle life, and a 0.99 reliability.
(a) For a speed of 600 rev/min find the power rating of this gearset
based on AGMA bending strength.
(b) For the same conditions as in part (a) find the power rating of this
gearset based on AGMA wear strength.
(c) For a reliability of 0.995, a gear life of 109 revolutions, and a safety
factor of SF = SH = 1.5, find the power rating for this gearset using
AGMA strengths.
Bevel-Gear Stresses and Strengths
Bevel-Gear Stresses and Strengths
Solution Continues…
Bevel-Gear Stresses and Strengths
Solution Continues…
Bevel-Gear Stresses and Strengths
Solution Continues…
Bevel-Gear Stresses and Strengths
Solution Continues…
Bevel-Gear Stresses and Strengths
Solution Continues…
Design of Straight-Bevel Gear Mesh
A useful decision set for straight-bevel gear design is
Function: power, speed, mG, R
Design factor: nd
Tooth system A priori decisions
Tooth count: NP, NG
Pitch and face width: Pd, F
Quality number: Qv Design decisions
Gear material, core and case hardness
Pinion material, core and case hardness
Recommended Face Width
Bending strength is not linear with face width.
Added material is placed at the small end of the teeth.
Recommended face width,
dP dG
A0 (15 - 24)
2 sin γ 2 sin
Worm Gearing - AGMA Equation
Worm gears are used to transmit rotary
motion between non-parallel and non-
intersecting shafts. Usually perpendicular
Relation between shaft angle and helix angles
is.
ψ P ψG (15 - 26)
Fig. 15–16
Worm Gear Dimensions
With center-to-center distance C, good proportions indicate the
pitch worm diameter d should be in the range.
C 0.875 C 0.875
d (15 - 27)
3 1.6
W t Dm
TG (15 - 31)
2
Worm Gearing - AGMA Equation
Worm Gearing Equations for Allowable Tangential Force
Wt
all
Cs Dm0.8 FeCmCv (15 - 28)
0.15 Vs 0
f 0.124 exp 0.074Vs0.645 0 Vs 10 ft/min (15 - 38)
0.103
exp 0.110Vs
0.450
0.012 Vs 10 ft/min
Worm-Gear Geometry
px
a 0.3183 px (15 - 39)
π
1.157 px
b 0.3683 px (15 - 40)
π
2.157 px
π 0.6866 px px 0.16 in
ht (15 - 41)
2.200 px 0.002 0.7003 p 0.002 p < 0.16 in
π x x
d o d 2a (15 - 42)
d r d 2b (15 - 43)
Dt D 2a (15 - 44)
Dr D 2b (15 - 45)
c ba (15 - 46)
Face Width
2 2
D D
( FW ) max 2 t a 2 2 Da (15 - 47)
2 2
2d m 3 p x 0.16 in
FG (15 - 48)
1.125 d o 2c 2
d o 4 a 2
px 0.16 in
Energy Issues
Heat loss rate from worm-gear case in ft·lbf/min,
H loss 33 000(1 e)H in (15 - 49)
WGt
σa (15 - 53)
pn Fe y
Friction power,
W f Vs
Hf hp (15 - 63)
33 000
Maximum Lead Angle for Worm Gearing
Table 15–9 Largest Lead Angle Associated with a
Normal Pressure Angle ϕ n for Worm Gearing
14.5° 16°
20° 25°
25° 35°
30° 45°
Design of Worm Gear Mesh
A useble decision set for worm gear mesh includes:
Function: power, speed, mG, Ka
Design factor: nd
Tooth system A priori decisions
Material and process
Number of threads on the worm: NW
Axial pitch of worm: px
Pitch diameter of the worm: dW
Design decisions
Face width of gear: FG .
Lateral area of case: A
Design of Worm Gear Mesh
The worm-gear materials in the experience base are principally
bronzes:
• Tin- and nickel-bronzes (chilled-casting produces hardest surfaces)
• Lead-bronze (high-speed applications)
• Aluminum- and silicon-bronze (heavy load, slow-speed application)
Axial pitches for the worm are usually integers, and quotients of
integers are common. Typical pitches are:
Then,
. .