Professional Documents
Culture Documents
S96 CKS Acne Vulgaris
S96 CKS Acne Vulgaris
[Brown and Shalita, 1998; Thiboutot, 2000; Simpson and Cunliffe, 2004; ICSI, 2006]
Clinical variants
If acne presents with atypical features, consider the possibility of a rarer form of
acne.
o Acne conglobata is very severe acne where inflammatory lesions
predominate and run together, often accompanied by exudate or
bleeding. This form of acne may cause extensive scarring.
o Acne fulminans is a sudden severe inflammatory reaction that
precipitates deep ulcerations and erosions, sometimes with systemic
effects (such as fever and arthralgia).
o Acne excoriée mainly affects young women and is characterized by self-
inflicted wounds. It is primarily a psychological or emotional problem.
o Acne mechanica is caused secondarily to pressure, friction, or rubbing
from clothing (such as a mask or hat).
o Acne cosmetica is caused by contact of the skin with comedogenic
products.
o Chloracne is caused by occupational exposure to halogenated
hydrocarbons. It is characterized by the presence of numerous, large
comedones.
Recommendations for the diagnosis of acne vulgaris and its clinical variants are based
on an international guideline [ICSI, 2006] and expert opinion from narrative reviews
[Brown and Shalita, 1998; Thiboutot, 2000; Wolf, 2002; Simpson and Cunliffe, 2004].
o Ab
Acne vulgaris - Management
View full scenario
What information should I give about acne?
Reassure the person about the natural course of the condition, but do not
trivialize it. Advise that:
o Acne is one of the most common disorders, affecting nearly everyone at
some point in their life.
o Acne will improve. It is primarily a skin disorder of the young, and will
usually clear up in later life without leaving significant scarring.
o Treatments are effective but take time to work (typically up to 8 weeks)
and may irritate the skin, especially at the start of treatment.
Dispel popular myths about acne. In particular inform the person that:
o Acne is not caused by poor hygiene, and there is no evidence it is
improved by cleaning. In fact, excessive washing can aggravate acne.
o Diet has little or no effect on acne. For example, there is no evidence that
chocolate or fatty foods cause or aggravate acne. However if the person
notices that a particular food triggers flares of acne then it is reasonable
to avoid it.
o Picking at acne does not improve it, and may cause scarring.
Occasionally it may be beneficial to drain large purulent lesions, but this
should be done under medical supervision.
o Stress probably does not cause acne, although there is a correlation
between stress and acne, and unsightly lesions may cause increased
levels of stress.
o Acne is not infectious and cannot be passed on to other people. The main
bacterium involved in the inflammation, Propionibacteria acnes, is
naturally present on skin but, in acne, it colonizes follicles.
o Sunlight probably has little benefit in acne, and there is no evidence to
support active sunbathing or exposure to other sources of ultraviolet
light. Excessive sun exposure should be avoided by all people, especially
when taking drugs such as topical or oral retinoids, or oral tetracyclines.
Providing reassurance
The prognosis of acne is good for most people, with less than 12% of women
and 3% men being affected after 25 years of age. However, the condition should
not be trivialized, as it may last for several years and have a negative
psychological impact in some people. A balanced understanding of the disease
course and its impact on everyday life is required [Acne Working Group, 2008].
There is little evidence to support the use of CAM in the treatment of acne.
o A review of CAM treatments for acne found an overall lack of good
quality evidence of beneficial effect; studies were limited in number and
most were methodologically poor or underpowered [Magin et al, 2006].
o One systematic review (search date: October 2002) found two trials that
investigated the efficacy of herbal remedies in acne [Martin and Ernst,
2003]. Both studies were small and of poor methodological quality.
One trial compared tea tree oil with benzoyl peroxide. There was
no placebo group and the study lacked the statistical power to
show equivalence or superiority of the regimens.
In the other trial, the herb Ocimum gratissimum (dissolved in
alcohol and added to oil) was compared with benzoyl peroxide
and placebo. However, as various concentrations were
investigated, the groups were too small to allow any firm
conclusions.
Topical retinoids
Topical antibiotics
Azelaic acid
Azelaic acid is a second-line option that should be considered for mild acne if
other treatments are unsuitable [Acne Working Group, 2008]. There is a lack of
trial evidence to support the use of azelaic acid in comparison with data
available for other topical treatments, and the clinical effect of azelaic acid has
been reported to be disappointing by some experts [Brown and Shalita, 1998;
James, 2005].
Recommendations for following up people with acne are based on international [ICSI,
2006] and national [Acne Working Group, 2008] guidelines.
These are pragmatic recommendations that are in line with expert opinion from
international [ICSI, 2006] and national [Acne Working Group, 2008] guidelines.
Referral criteria for acne vulgaris are based on Referral advice: A guide to appropriate
referral from general to specialist services, published by the National Institute for
Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE). For people requiring referral 'immediately' or
'soon', NICE specify that 'Health authorities, trusts, and primary care organizations
should work to local definitions of maximum waiting times in each of these categories.
The multidisciplinary advisory groups considered a maximum waiting time of 2 weeks
to be appropriate for the urgent category' [NICE, 2001].
Prescriptions
Benzoyl peroxide (gel)
Topical retinoids
Topical antibiotics
Azelaic acid
Oral antibiotics
Providing reassurance
The prognosis of acne is good for most people, with less than 12% of women
and 3% men being affected after 25 years of age. However, the condition should
not be trivialized, as it may last for several years and have a negative
psychological impact in some people. A balanced understanding of the disease
course and its impact on everyday life is required [Acne Working Group, 2008].
Most OTC products are not recommended because there is a lack of evidence
from clinical trials to support their efficacy [Sharpe, 1995; Brown and Shalita,
1998; Ravenscroft, 2005; Strauss et al, 2007].
o Salicylic acid is a common ingredient in OTC acne treatments. It is a
keratolytic drug that has some anti-comedone activity, but there is a lack
of evidence from controlled trials to confirm this, and it is considered
less effective than the topical retinoids.
o Abrasives (such as aluminium oxide) and sulphur (available combined
with resorcinol, as Eskamel®) have been used historically, but lack
evidence from controlled trials. Some products containing aluminium
oxide are abrasive and can irritate inflamed skin.
o Nicotinamide (available as Nicam®) has been reported as being as
effective as topical clindamycin in open-label cohort studies [Dos et al,
2003; Sardesai and Kambli, 2003], but CKS identified no randomized
controlled trials to confirm this.
o However, there is substantial placebo-controlled trial evidence to support
the use of benzoyl peroxide in the treatment of acne.
There is little evidence to support the use of CAM in the treatment of acne.
o A review of CAM treatments for acne found an overall lack of good
quality evidence of beneficial effect; studies were limited in number and
most were methodologically poor or underpowered [Magin et al, 2006].
o One systematic review (search date: October 2002) found two trials that
investigated the efficacy of herbal remedies in acne [Martin and Ernst,
2003]. Both studies were small and of poor methodological quality.
One trial compared tea tree oil with benzoyl peroxide. There was
no placebo group and the study lacked the statistical power to
show equivalence or superiority of the regimens.
In the other trial, the herb Ocimum gratissimum (dissolved in
alcohol and added to oil) was compared with benzoyl peroxide
and placebo. However, as various concentrations were
investigated, the groups were too small to allow any firm
conclusions.
Recommendations for following up people with acne are based on international [ICSI,
2006] and national [Acne Working Group, 2008] guidelines.
If the person has not responded adequately, bear in mind that it can take up to
3 months for a full response to occur.
o Check adherence to treatment.
o If there has been some response, continue treatment and consider adding
topical benzoyl peroxide or a topical retinoid (if the person is not already
using these), or prescribe both of these.
o If there has been no response, consider seeking specialist advice or
referral.
These are pragmatic recommendations that are in line with expert opinion from
international [ICSI, 2006] and national [Acne Working Group, 2008] guidelines.
Referral criteria for acne vulgaris are based on Referral advice: A guide to appropriate
referral from general to specialist services, published by the National Institute for
Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE). For people requiring referral 'immediately' or
'soon', NICE specify that 'Health authorities, trusts, and primary care organizations
should work to local definitions of maximum waiting times in each of these categories.
The multidisciplinary advisory groups considered a maximum waiting time of 2 weeks
to be appropriate for the urgent category' [NICE, 2001].
Prescriptions
Benzoyl peroxide (gel)
Referral
Referral of all people with severe acne vulgaris is consistent with Referral
advice: A guide to appropriate referral from general to specialist services,
published by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE)
[NICE, 2001]. This is recommended in order to alleviate pain and psychological
distress, and to prevent or limit scarring.
Oral antibiotics
These are pragmatic recommendations that are in line with expert opinion from
international [ICSI, 2006] and national [Acne Working Group, 2008] guidelines.
Referral criteria for acne vulgaris are based on Referral advice: A guide to appropriate
referral from general to specialist services, published by the National Institute for
Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE). For people requiring referral 'immediately' or
'soon', NICE specify that 'Health authorities, trusts, and primary care organizations
should work to local definitions of maximum waiting times in each of these categories.
The multidisciplinary advisory groups considered a maximum waiting time of 2 weeks
to be appropriate for the urgent category' [NICE, 2001].
Oral isotretinoin
Laser treatment
Surgical treatment
Various surgical and medical techniques may be used for the treatment of very
severe acne in secondary care [Brown and Shalita, 1998].
o Purulent nodules can be incised and drained of pus.
o Comedones can be cauterized. Alternatively, comedone extraction is a
technique in which entire comedones are removed. Usually this is done
following several weeks of topical treatment.
o Large, tender nodules can be treated with an intralesional injection of a
corticosteroid such as triamcinolone. This rapidly reduces inflammation
and reduces lesion size.
Surgical treatment of scarring is more problematic. If there is extensive
superficial scarring, dermabrasion may be performed by a plastic surgeon to
improve the appearance of the skin [Sharpe, 1995], although this procedure is
now less common.
Providing reassurance
The prognosis of acne is good for most people, with less than 12% of women
and 3% men being affected after 25 years of age. However, the condition should
not be trivialized, as it may last for several years and have a negative
psychological impact in some people. A balanced understanding of the disease
course and its impact on everyday life is required [Acne Working Group, 2008].
Most OTC products are not recommended because there is a lack of evidence
from clinical trials to support their efficacy [Sharpe, 1995; Brown and Shalita,
1998; Ravenscroft, 2005; Strauss et al, 2007].
o Salicylic acid is a common ingredient in OTC acne treatments. It is a
keratolytic drug that has some anti-comedone activity, but there is a lack
of evidence from controlled trials to confirm this, and it is considered
less effective than the topical retinoids.
o Abrasives (such as aluminium oxide) and sulphur (available combined
with resorcinol, as Eskamel®) have been used historically, but lack
evidence from controlled trials. Some products containing aluminium
oxide are abrasive and can irritate inflamed skin.
o Nicotinamide (available as Nicam®) has been reported as being as
effective as topical clindamycin in open-label cohort studies [Dos et al,
2003; Sardesai and Kambli, 2003], but CKS identified no randomized
controlled trials to confirm this.
o However, there is substantial placebo-controlled trial evidence to support
the use of benzoyl peroxide in the treatment of acne.
Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM)
There is little evidence to support the use of CAM in the treatment of acne.
o A review of CAM treatments for acne found an overall lack of good
quality evidence of beneficial effect; studies were limited in number and
most were methodologically poor or underpowered [Magin et al, 2006].
o One systematic review (search date: October 2002) found two trials that
investigated the efficacy of herbal remedies in acne [Martin and Ernst,
2003]. Both studies were small and of poor methodological quality.
One trial compared tea tree oil with benzoyl peroxide. There was
no placebo group and the study lacked the statistical power to
show equivalence or superiority of the regimens.
In the other trial, the herb Ocimum gratissimum (dissolved in
alcohol and added to oil) was compared with benzoyl peroxide
and placebo. However, as various concentrations were
investigated, the groups were too small to allow any firm
conclusions.
Prescriptions
Benzoyl peroxide (gel)