Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wang 2011
Wang 2011
Wang 2011
.a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: In this study, a simple but effective method to realize excellent comprehensive performances in
Received 9 October 2010 polypropylene (PP)/multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWNTs) was developed. Before melt extrusion,
Received in revised form 16 May 2011 solid-state iPP powders and MWNTs were pre-mixed upon high-speed rotating. By this way, the disper-
Accepted 20 May 2011
sion extent of nanotubes was significantly improved as comparing to the common one-step melt extru-
Available online 31 May 2011
sion strategy. As validated by scanning electron microscopy, most of MWNTs exist as a form of filament
bundles with size of hundreds nanometers; no obvious agglomerate was found even at high MWNTs con-
Keywords:
tent, 5%. The improvements of the major mechanical properties and electric conductivity were much effi-
A. Carbon nanotubes
A. Polymer–matrix composites (PMCs)
cient for the composites obtained via the two-step process of rotating solid-state mixing (RSSM)-plus-
B. Mechanical properties melt extrusion. The tensile strength, Young’s modulus and impact strength at 5% MWNTs content were
B. Electrical properties enhanced for 35%, 42% and 45%, respectively, indicating an excellent strength–rigidity–toughness bal-
B. Fracture toughness ance, which was hardly achieved in polyolefin/carbon nanotubes composite. It is believed that the
method developed in this study is so far the most effective and convenient for efficiently dispersing nano-
tubes into the nonpolar, intractable thermoplastics and resulting in good properties, among a variety of
fabrication method suggested in the previous researches. Importantly, the used RSSM equipment is a kind
of frequently used dispersion machine, thus it has tremendous potential to be applied in industrial pro-
ducing immediately.
Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction groups, the high polarity similarity between basal resin and nano-
tubes [5] and/or the additional physical bonding arisen from a
Since carbon nanotubes (CNTs) were discovered in 1991, the ex- combination of shear stress and thermal activation [6] could in-
tremely high modulus, strength, excellent electrical and thermal duce relatively good dispersion of CNTs. Nevertheless, for non-
conductivity enable them for a wide range of applications [1,2]. polar ones, such as polyolefin, there present more of a challenge
In particular, CNTs can act as an ideal modifier to enhance the to achieve ideal CNTs-dispersion merely by melt compounding.
properties of polymer materials, frequently focused on mechanical To optimize dispersion of CNTs and interfacial adhesion, tre-
strength and electric conductivity [3]. However, the level of perfor- mendous amount of methods have been developed. They can be
mance enhancement is often limited, i.e., the addition of CNTs usu- classified roughly into chemical (covalent) treatment [7–10] and
ally results in a mild increase of elastic modulus compared to physical (noncovalent) treatment [11,12]. The first strategy in-
pristine polymer [4]. This is due to (1) CNTs tend to agglomerate cludes the sidewall functionalization [13], the sidewall grafting
together because of van der Waals attraction and physical entan- with polymer chains [14,15] and the in situ polymerization on
glement between adjacent nanotubes and (2) efficient stress trans- sidewall of CNTs [16]. By these covalent modifications, the chemi-
fer from basal resin to nanotubes is absent. Therefore the good cal nature of CNTs was altered evidently, and the obvious incre-
dispersion of CNTs and strong interfacial adhesion are two domi- ments in dispersion and interaction were desired [17,18]. The
nant issues for realizing superior performance enhancement in cost of covalent treatment, however, does not justify the repay-
polymer/CNTs nanocomposite. ment of property improvement. Their applications in industrial
Melt compounding is a facile approach to fabricate polymer/ fields are by far limited, especially for large-scale fabrication.
CNTs composites, and has been most frequently adopted in the Therefore, the second strategy, noncovalent modification, has
previous literature. For polar thermoplastics with functional attracted intensive attention [19,20]. Lu et al. [21] developed a
so-called latex technology that isotactic polypropylene (iPP) latex
⇑ Corresponding authors. Tel.: +86 28 85461795; fax: +86 28 85405402 (Q. Fu). was mixed into aqueous CNTs suspended solution containing
E-mail addresses: wkestar@scu.edu.cn (K. Wang), qiangfu@scu.edu.cn (Q. Fu). commercial surfactant likes sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), after
0266-3538/$ - see front matter Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.compscitech.2011.05.012
1398 Z. Wang et al. / Composites Science and Technology 71 (2011) 1397–1403
evaporation of liquid components a dispersion state of individual 3 and 5 wt%). After being pelletized and placed in a vacuum oven at
CNT filament could be achieved. In a relatively simple procedures, 80 °C for 24 h, injection molding was conducted on a PS40E5ASE
aqueous CNTs suspended solution was sprayed onto the surface of injection machine (Japan) at 200 °C to obtain standard specimen
PE granule [22], or the PE granules were immersed into such solu- for mechanical property measurements. In addition, some extruded
tion [23], after evaporation of solvent the CNT filaments adsorbed pellets were compression-molded under 190 °C and 5 MPa to make
on the surface of PE granule. The pre-dispersion state that PE gran- films with a thickness about 2.5 mm, and then cut into regular shape
ule was coated with CNTs, improved the dispersion of CNTs prom- for conductivity measurement. For comparison purpose, a series of
inently during the subsequential process of melt compounding. iPP/PP-g-MA/MWNTs (90/10/x wt%, x = 0.5, 1, 3, 5) composites de-
Although the physical methods mentioned above can promote noted as PP-p-MWNTx were also prepared upon the same process-
the dispersion level of CNTs effectively, they still require a great ing conditions, but without experiencing the RSSM process.
of liquid chemical solvent. To avoid this problem, some pre-disper
sion treatments have been implemented as solid-state upon the 2.3. Characterizations
shear fields. Masuda et al. [24] pre-dispersed MWNTs into PP resin
through a so-called solid-state shear pulverization (SSSP) technol- 2.3.1. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM)
ogy. The ultra-uniform dispersion of CNTs and the excellent com- The SEM experiments were performed using a Hitachi
prehension properties were realized in the sequential melt S3400tEDX SEM instrument to inspect the dispersion of MWNTs
compounding. It may be due to the rigorous technological require- in nanocomposites. The samples were obtained by compression-
ments that the SSSP cannot become a conventional processing molding extruded pellets under 190 °C and 5 MPa to make batten,
method at present. In an other similar research, Xia et al. [25] then cryofractured, gold-coated and observed under an accelera-
pre-mixed iPP granules and CNTs together through a solid-state tion voltage of 10 kV.
mechanochemical pulverization process conducted on a pan mill-
ing. However, due to the severe decomposition of macromolecular 2.3.2. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC)
chains and scission of CNT filaments, the enhancements in The calorimetric analysis was implemented on a Perkin–Elmer
mechanical properties were retarded. So these solid-state premix- Pyris I differential scanning calorimeter with nitrogen as the purge
ing methods mentioned are not suitable for fabrication of polymer/ gas. The slice of testing sample, about 5 mg, was fast heated to
CNTs composites in practical industrial fields though they result in 210 °C at a rate of 10 °C/min, hold for 5 min to erase any thermal
better dispersion of CNTs than simple melt compounding. history and then cooled down to 50 °C at a rate of 1.5 °C/min.
The major aim of this study is to explore the possibility that uti-
lizing a available and often used solid-state shear equipment, 2.3.3. Gel permeation chromatography analysis (GPC)
rotating four-leaf oar mixer, to tailor the dispersion of CNTs in GPC was carried out on an HP1100 using two PL gel columns
PP. Our goal is to develop a simple but effective method for the (10 m 104 Å, 10 m 500 Å). Molecular weights are relative to mono-
large-scale fabrication of polyolefin/CNTs composites with excel- disperse polystyrene standards. The mobile phase was trichloro-
lent comprehension performances by only using some easily avail- benzene. Sample concentration was 1 g/l. The detector was RID
able processing equipments. and the flow rate was 1 ml/min.
surface area of the electrodes exceeded the cross-sectional area of numerous MWNT filaments, while the crack region is filled with
the discs. mass MWNT coils. Obviously, the physical absorption of MWNTs
on the surface of iPP granule has been enhanced prominently via
3. Results and discussion the RSSM, which should be arisen from the following three items:
(1) static electric attraction yielded by frication between iPP gran-
3.1. Rotating solid-state premixing (RSSM) process ule and MWNTs; (2) the generation of new surface area because
the pristine iPP granule is broken up; (3) the appearance of crack,
Scheme 1 describes the transition of dispersion state between which penetrates into the inner of iPP granule, attributed to the
iPP granules and MWNTs throughout a convective process of crash effect. The occurrence that cracks filled with mass MWNTs
high-speed rotating. Before the RSSM procedure, the MWNTs are enables the dispersed level of MWNTs in iPP granule improved
trended to aggregate together, and less area of iPP powder surface remarkably.
was coated with nanotube filaments. The rotating four-leaf oar
mixer yielded tremendous disturbance effect and the collision 3.2. Dispersion of MWNTs in composites
and friction occur intensively between iPP granules, MWNTs and
the stiff metal wall of mixer, resulting in a size decrease of pristine After experiencing the melt compounding step, the dispersion
iPP granule and compact adsorption of MWNTs on the surface of status of MWNTs in composites has been ascertained by SEM, and
iPP granule, as illustrated in Scheme 1. The topographic morphol- some typical micrographs are presented in Fig. 1. Since the remark-
ogy of iPP granule obtained after experiencing the RSSM has been able difference in electro-conductivity between CNTs and PP resin,
examined by SEM and also presented in Scheme 1. For every the CNT substance exhibits as light white, while the basal polymer
individual iPP granule, the relative flat area is covered with is commonly dark or gray, which offers high reliability for using
Scheme 1. Mechanism of dispersing MWNTs in PP powder during superhigh-speed shear blending and SEM images of (a) the surface morphology of the mixed powder, (b)
MWNTs absorbed on the surface of PP and (c) moderate and small MWNTs agglomerates inserted in the crack of PP granule.
1400 Z. Wang et al. / Composites Science and Technology 71 (2011) 1397–1403
Fig. 1. SEM micrographs for PP–MWNTx: x = 1 (a), 5 (b); the corresponding SEM micrographs for PP-p-MWNTx: x = 1 (c) and 5 (d).
SEM to identify the dispersion and/or distribution of CNTs in contin- zation temperature of iPP should be increased. The cooling crystal-
uous polymer matrix [24]. For the composites obtained via the two- lization curves of PP–MWNTs and PP-p-MWNTs composites are
step procedure of RSSM-plus-melt compounding, numerous white plotted in Fig. 2a. For PP–MWNTs systems, a sharp increment of
spots are found, which are the ends of MWNT filaments. It can be 9 °C in Tc is found in PP–MWNT0.5 (122 °C), as compared with PP
concluded that most of MWNTs exist as a form of filament bundle (113 °C). With increasing the MWNTs content, Tc is further in-
with size scale of hundreds nanometers, particularly for the high creased and reached 127 °C in PP–MWNT5. This indicates strong
MWCNT content, 5%. After carefully analyzing many SEM images, heterogeneous nucleation effect of MWNTs to facilitate the crystal-
we find the size scale of filament bundle of MWCNTs in PP–MWNT5 lization of basal iPP. Comparing with the PP–MWNTs system, the
is in the range of 200–800 nm, and some typical examples are indi- improvement magnitude of Tc is less in the composites of PP-p-
cated by arrows in Fig. 1b; nevertheless, the large aggregates of MWNTs. A maximum increment of Tc is only 7 °C from basal iPP
MWNTs are seen in the composites prepared by direct melt com- to PP-p-MWNT5. Obviously, the higher heterogeneous nucleating
pounding. According to SEM images, the size of aggregation block efficiency in the composites of PP–MWNTs is due to the better dis-
in PP-p-MWNT5 is ranged from several micrometers to ten microm- persion of MWNTs induced by the RSSM treatment. At the same
eters, and this is indicated by arrows in Fig. 1d. By comparing the dis- content of CNTs, the extent of crystallization temperature increase
persion status between two-step procedure and single-step can be used as an indicator of CNTs dispersion. The higher the crys-
procedure, it is concluded that the RSSM treatment can enhance tallization temperature, the better the CNTs dispersion could be.
the dispersion level of MWNTs in iPP matrix remarkably. Actually, compared with the increase of crystallization tempera-
ture reported in literature [29,30], our result is the highest at the
3.3. Crystallization property of composites same filler content. As to crystal type and crystallinity, the addition
of MWNTs has no impact on them, which is proved by WAXD
CNTs can act as nucleating agent for semicrystalline polymer experiment (Fig. 2b). For the composites obtained via RSSM-plus-
likes polypropylene [26–28]. In the presence of CNTs, the crystalli- melt compounding, only the diffraction characteristics for
Z. Wang et al. / Composites Science and Technology 71 (2011) 1397–1403 1401
(a) (b)
Fig. 2. (a) Dependence of crystallization temperature (Tc) on MWNTs loading and (b) WAXD of PP–MWNTx: x = 0, 0.5, 1, 3, 5.
monoclinic iPP a-form are found, and the crystallinity is approxi- In general, for polyolefin/CNTs composite, an excellent rein-
mately constant (45%) for all MWNTs contents. forced effect is easily obtained, but it is frequently accompanied
with a remarkable decrease in toughness. The impact strength of
the composites prepared by single-step melt compounding is re-
3.4. Enhancements of performance by the incorporation of MWNTs duced with increasing the MWNTs content, as shown in Fig. 3b.
However, the tendency of impact strength vs. MWNTs content
The effect of RSSM treatment on the decomposition of macro- for the composites prepared by RSSM-plus-melt compounding is
molecule has been assessed by GPC experiment. Seeing Table 1, totally different. Similar to the tensile properties, the impact
the weight mean molecular weights (Mw) of basal iPP for the com- strength is improved monotonically with the increase of MWNTs
posites obtained via RSSM-plus-melt compounding are comparable content, and an obvious increment for 45% is realized at the high-
to that of pure iPP prepared by single-step melt compounding. So est MWNTs content, 5%, indicating a simultaneously toughening
the decomposition of basal iPP does not occur during the RSSM and strengthening effect induced by the two-step procedure of
process. Meanwhile, the values of Mw in the composites are some- RSSM-plus-melt compounding. As to the elongation at break,
what higher than that of pure iPP, and the polydispersity varies which is also an indication for toughness, its dependence on
irregularly with increasing the MWNTs content. The reason may MWNT content differs to the impact strength. For both of PP–
be due to less mass of insoluble species, MWNTs, is residual in MWNTs and PP-p-MWNTs systems, the elongation at break contin-
the testing solution, which disturbs the accuracy of GPC mildly. uously decreases with the increasing of CNT content. However, the
Unlike to the solid-state pulverization process on a pan milling values for PP–MWNTs are significantly higher than that for PP-p-
[25], the RSSM process mainly offers a convective and disturbed ef- MWNTs, particularly at high MWNT contents, indicating the duct-
fect and the shear stress intensity imposed is mild, therefore the ibility of PP–MWNTs is better than that of PP-p-MWNTs. The exact
obvious scission of PP chains cannot occur. Since the RSSM treat- toughening mechanism in the PP–MWNTs composites is not clear
ment has improve the dispersion extent of MWNTs as well as the at present. Yuan et al. [31] suggested that strong interfacial adhe-
preserving of original physical property of basal iPP, superior per- sion are beneficial for higher toughening efficiency. In our present
formance enhancements by the incorporation of MWNTs are study, we would rather to expect that the interfacial adhesion
desirable. could be reinforced, due to a possible transcrystallization region
The enhancements in mechanical performance by adding formed around the sidewall of MWNTs, as visually validated by
MWNTs are illustrated in Fig. 3. The incorporation of MWNTs in- Miltner et al. [32].
duces a reinforcing effect in both two composite systems that the It should be noted that the strengthening effect of this study is
tensile strength and Young’s modulus is improved continuously comparable to the best level reported in previous literature. In our
as the MWNTs content increases (Fig. 3a). However, the improved current study, the Young’s modulus is improved for 32% when 1%
magnitude of mechanical properties in the PP–MWNTs system is MWNTs is incorporated. For the iPP/MWNTs composite synthe-
obviously higher than that in the PP-p-MWNTs one. Compared to sized via in situ polymerization and molded by hot pressing, an
the basal iPP, the increments of 35% and 42% in tensile strength increment of 37% in Young’s modulus was achieved after adding
and modulus, respectively, are achieved when the MWNTs content 2.1% MWNTs [33]. For the PP/single-walled carbon nanotubes
is 5% for the composite obtained via RSSM-plus-melt compounding. (SWNTs) composite prepared in a melt internal mixer (Haake
Rhomix), the incorporation of 0.75% SWNTs resulted in a 39% in-
crease of Young’s modulus [30]. Masuda et al. [24] utilized a spe-
Table 1
cific SSSP extrusion equipment to fabricate PP/MWNTs
The molecular weight characterizations of composites prepared by a two-step
procedure of RSSM-plus-melt extrusion. composite, an obvious improvement of 57% in Young’s modulus
was achieved when the MWNTs content was 0.92%, which is by
Pure iPPa CNT 0.5% CNT 1% CNT 3% CNT 5%
far the best strengthen effect for PP/MWNTs composite. However,
Mw 53.5 104 57.4 104 54.1 104 57.6 104 54.8 104 the excellent strength–rigid–toughness balance is rarely seen in
Mw/Mn 5.6 5.4 7.4 6.5 4.8
the polyolefin/CNTs composites, especially for the toughening ef-
a
It is indeed a blend system of iPP/PP-g-MA (90/10 wt%), and without experi- fect [34]. It has been found only for the PE/PE-g-MWNTs compos-
encing the step of RSSM. ites prepared by chemical grafting of reactive extrusion with fine
1402 Z. Wang et al. / Composites Science and Technology 71 (2011) 1397–1403
(a) (b)
Fig. 3. Variation of (a) tension strength and Young’s modulus and (b) impact strength and elongation at break.
improved moderately. In our current research, the powerful evi- [3] McNally T, Potschke P, Halley P, Murphy M, Martin D. Polymer 2005;46:8222.
[4] Chazeau L, Gauthier C, Vigier G, Cavaillé JY. Relationships between
dence for the occurrence of MWNTs scission during RSSM is
microstructural aspects and mechanical properties of polymer-based
unavailable, which will be implemented in our future work by, nanocomposites. Handbook of organic–inorganic hybrid materials and
such as, electro-microscopy observation, composite viscosity mea- nanocomposites, vol. 2. American Scientific Publishers; 2003. p. 63–111.
surement and Raman spectroscopy characterization on the pristine [5] Zhang LY, Wan CY, Zhang Y. Compos Sci Technol 2009;69:2212.
[6] Zhang ZN, Zhang J, Chen P, Zhang BQ, He JS, Hu GH. Carbon 2006;44:692.
MWNTs and RSSM-treated MWNTs. [7] Georgakilas V, Kordatos K, Prato M, Guldi DM, Holzinger M, Hirsch A. J Am
Chem Soc 2002;124:760.
[8] Dyke CA, Tour JM. J Phys Chem A 2004;108:11151.
4. Conclusions [9] Blake R, Gun’ko YK, Coleman J, Cadek M, Fonseca A, Nagy JB, et al. J Am Chem
Soc 2004;126:10226.
A simple but effective methodology has been developed to fab- [10] Tasis D, Tagmatarchis N, Bianco A, Prato M. Chem Rev 2006;106:1105.
[11] Chen RJ, Zhang Y, Wang D, Dai H. J Am Chem Soc 2001;123:3838.
ricate the iPP/MWNTs composites by using the easily available
[12] Chen J, Liu H, Weimer WA, Halls MD, Waldeck DH, Walker GC. J Am Chem Soc
processing equipments. The RSSM treatment can improve the dis- 2002;124:9034.
persion extent of MWNTs and thus lead obvious enhancements in [13] Dyke CA, Tour JM. J Am Chem Soc 2003;125:1157.
[14] Hill DE, Lin Y, Rao AM, Allard LF, Sun YP. Macromolecules 2002;35:9466.
variety of property. The tensile strength, Young’s modulus and im-
[15] Hong CY, You YZ, Pan CY. Polymer 2006;47:4300.
pact strength of composite prepared by the two-step procedure of [16] Ginic-Markovic M, Matisons JG, Cervini R, Simon GP, Fredericks PM. Chem
RSSM-plus-melt compounding is increased by 35%, 42% and 45%, Mater 2006;18:6258.
respectively, as the MWNTs is 5 wt%. Therefore, the simultaneously [17] Lee J, Yang SB, Jung HT. Macromolecules 2009;42:8328.
[18] Velasco-Santos C, Martinez-Hernandez M, Fisher FK, Ruoff R, Castario VM.
toughening and strengthening effect has been induced by the Chem Mater 2003;15:4470.
RSSM treatment, which is rarely seen in the polyolefin/CNTs com- [19] O’Connel MJ, Boul P, Ericson LM, Huffman C, Wang Y, Haroz E, et al. Chem Phys
posites. Meanwhile, the critical MWNTs content for the formation Lett 2001;342:265.
[20] Li X, Wong SY, Tjiu WC, Lyons BP, Oh SA, He CB. Carbon 2008;46:818.
of percolated conductive network is 1% for the composite system [21] Lu K, Grossiord N, Koning CE, Miltner HE, Mele B, Loos J. Macromolecules
obtained via RSSM-plus-melt compounding, which is less than that 2008;41:8081.
for the composites obtained via single-step procedure of melt com- [22] Zhang QH, Lippits DR, Rastogi S. Macromolecules 2006;39:658.
[23] Gao JF, Li ZM, Meng QJ, Yang Q. Mater Lett 2008;62:3530.
pounding. We believe that this methodology has tremendous po- [24] Masuda J, Torkelson JM. Macromolecules 2008;41:5974.
tential to be applied in practical industrial fields for fabricating [25] Xia H, Wang Q, Li K, Hu GH. J Appl Polym Sci 2004;93:378.
the polyolefin/CNTs composites with excellent comprehension [26] Grady BP, Pompeo F, Shambaugh RL, Resasco DE. J Phys Chem B
2002;106:5852.
properties.
[27] Valentini L, Biagiotti J, Kenny JM, Lopez Manchado MA. J Appl Polym Sci
2003;89:2657.
Acknowledgment [28] Leelapornpisist W, Ton-That MT, Perrin-Sarazin F, Cole KC, Denault J, Simard B.
J Polym Sci Part B 2005;43:2445.
[29] Bikiaris D, Vassiliou A, Chrissafis K, Paraskevopoulos KM. Polym Degrad Stab
We would like to express our sincere thanks to the National 2008;93:952.
Natural Science Foundation of China for Financial Support [30] Manchado MAL, Valentini L, Biagiotti J, Kenny JM. Carbon 2005;43:1499.
(50973065, 50873063, 20874064). [31] Yuan JM, Fan ZF, Chen XH, Chen XH, Wu ZJ, He LP. Polymer 2009;50:3285.
[32] Miltner HE, Grossiord N, Lu K, Loos J, Koning CE, Mele BV. Macromolecules
2008;41:5753.
References [33] Koval’chuk AA, Shevchenko VG, Shchegolikhin AN, Nedorezova PM, Klyamkina
AN, Aladyshev AM. Macromolecules 2008;41:7536.
[1] Baughman RH, Zakhidov AA, de Heer WA. Science 2002;297:787. [34] Mahfuz H, Adnan A, Rangari VK, Jeelani S. Int J Nanosci 2005;4:55.
[2] Cao J, Wang Q, Rolandi M, Dai H. Phys Rev Lett 2004;93:216. [35] Yang BX, Pramoda KP, Xu GQ, Goh SH. Adv Funct Mater 2007;17:2062.