Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Application of New HEC RAS Version 5 For 1D Hydrodynamic Food
Application of New HEC RAS Version 5 For 1D Hydrodynamic Food
Application of New HEC RAS Version 5 For 1D Hydrodynamic Food
https://doi.org/10.1007/s40808-020-00961-0
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Abstract
Floods are among the extreme natural events which result in catastrophic damage to properties and adversely effects com-
munities. To curb and manage the effects of such events, the decision-makers and disaster management authorities require
dependable data in terms of flood depth, discharge, magnitude, and special datasets. The low lying areas of Navsari city was
inundated in the floods of 2002 and 2003. This study aims to use the latest version of HEC-RAS for 1D hydrodynamic flood
modelling of Purna river in Navasari city, Gujarat, India, with special reference to geospatial techniques. This study is aimed
to demonstrate the geospatial analyzing capabilities of HEC-RAS v5. For the purpose of flood modeling, the river data such
as bank lines, flow path lines, cross-section cut lines are extracted from Cartosat-1 DEM (Digital Elevation Model). Steady
flow analysis is carried out for the simulation of a 1D hydrodynamic model. The outcome obtained from the model is in
the form of water depth, which can be observed in the geospatial HEC-RAS mapper window. The flood depth maps for the
2002 and 2004 flood events are generated, which indicate that the low lying areas of Navsari city near Jalalpore and Viraval
are susceptible to flooding when the discharge in the river exceeds 8836 m3/s. The accuracy of the model is calculated by
comparing the simulated data with the observed data for the above-mentioned flood events. The results obtained from the
1D models are promising and accurate.
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
forecasting (Bulti and Abebe 2020). The hydraulic model Global flood monitoring system (GFMS) to recognize flood
HEC-RAS and Global Flood Monitoring System (GFMS) potential of Yamuna River Allahabad, India. Flood event
are very effective tools to delineate the extent of flooding of devastative magnitude had taken place in the year 2006
and recognize the flood hazards zones, that can be helpful in Surat, India, resulting in almost 95% of the city being
to the disaster management authorities to warn the con- inundated due to flood water. Using geospatial techniques,
cerned communities about the flooding event (Kumar et al. digitization of river geometry along with GPS and Ground
2020). The integrated hydraulic and hydrologic models like Contour Point (GCP) with a 0.5 m interval, contour map
HEC-RAS, SWAT model are very useful to develop the flood inundation map were developed for low lying areas
flood risk map and flood forecasting models with different of Surat city (Patel and Srivastava 2014). Pathan and Agni-
return periods (Prabnakorn et al. 2019). In the present time, hotri ( 2020a) simulated a 1-Dimensional flood modelling
flood events are rapidly increasing in urban areas due to approach using HEC-RAS and ArcGIS to identify the flood
climate change and urbanization. For such cases, 2D flood extent of the lower region of the Navsari city.
modeling using HEC-RAS will help to identify the flood This study is aimed to demonstrate the application of
extent and vulnerability to flood in an urban area (Rangari the latest version of HEC-RAS (Hydrologic engineering
et al. 2019). centre-River Analysis System) in 1D hydrodynamic flood
Remote sensing is a promising approach to identify the modeling. The main focus of the study is the extraction
extent of the flood and risk assessment by using the remotely of river geometry data from Cartosat-1 DEM (Digital
sensed satellite imagery (Haq et al. 2012). High-intensity Elevation Model) using the RAS-mapper geospatial tools
rainfall even for short time intervals can cause damage to available in HEC-RAS, which show the application of
properties and lives to a great extent. In such a situation geospatial techniques in flood modeling. The simulated
(Patel and Dholakia 2010) have used Remote Sensing (RS) results present the water depth at each cross-section dur-
and Geographical Information System (GIS) techniques to ing flooding events. This approach can be a useful tool for
identify flood-prone areas in Surat city, India. The main fac- disaster management authorities for the purposes of flood
tor responsible for flooding is industrialization, cyclone, and forecasting and flood warning during possible flood events
urbanization, which results in the destruction of valuable in the future.
resources in the region of northern Australia. Linking flood
risk management with GIS was a better approach to mitigate Study area
the floods (Zerger and Wealands 2004). Due to typhoons,
the major part of Korea is extremely vulnerable to heavy Navsari City is in Southern Gujarat, India. Navsari city is
rainfall and flooding, resulting in loss of human life. Wang situated between north longitude 72°42′ and 73°30′ and
et al. (2002) had developed a flood mitigation plan using east latitude 20°32′ and 21°05. The city has approximately
Landsat TM and DEM. The rise in sea level may pose a seri- 2211.97 km2 of geographical area. Study area map of the
ous risk to the coastal area. A geospatial modeling approach Navsari City, Gujarat, India is shown in (Fig. 1). Flooding
to identify the impact of sea-level rise and climate change is a very frequent phenomenon in this area as it lies along
finds probable consequences on a coastal area (Malik and the coastal line of the Arabian Sea. Currently, there are no
Abdalla 2016). Wetland seems to be a key factor in flood- preventive measures deployed to minimize the impact of
ing. Remote Sensing (RS) and Geographical Information flood in the study area.
System (GIS) techniques for natural drainage in the wet-
land were found to be an effective solution to mitigate the Frequency of floods in the Study area
flood (Deb and Talukdar 2010). Pathan (2019) introduced
integrated use of Geographical Information System (GIS) Navsari region regularly experiences floods due to heavy
and Hydrologic Engineering Center River Analysis System rainfall, annually. Here in (Fig. 2), the flood frequency of
(HEC-RAS) for a one-dimensional modelling approach to the past 30 years is shown. As per observed data, a major
determine flooding at different cross-sections on the Purna flood occurred in the year 2002 with a peak discharge of
River basin. Kumar Samanta et al. (2018) demonstrated the 8836 m3/s, which resulted in a huge loss of property and
flood susceptibility mapping approach using Geographical life. Similarly, in the year of 2003, the flood discharge was
Information System (GIS) and Remote sensing (RS) tech- 5437 m3/s. This study is aimed to provide a reliable model to
niques on Subarnarekha River Basin, India. Kumar et al. predict flooding probability and the extent of flooding in the
(2017) presented the application of Geographical Infor- Navasari region, to make decisions and to take preventive
mation System (GIS) and Remote sensing (RS) tools like measures to mitigate the effects of the flood.
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Research methodology of the area of the case study and later, creating a Shapefile
of the research study area in Arc GIS software. Cartosat-1
1D hydrodynamic model using geospatial techniques is a DEM (Digital Elevation Model) is freely downloaded with
very efficient and precise approach to recognize flood depths 30 m resolution (https://bhuvan.nrsc.gov.in/bhuvan_links
at different cross-sections. In this approach, the floodplain .php). Digital Elevation Model (DEM) is used to classify
mapping is done in two stages. Stage 1ѿRAS-mapper data the magnitude of the flood and the extent of the flood. Flood
processing, Stage 2—HEC-RAS model execution. The flow- maps can be prepared by extracting river geometry data from
chart of research methodology is shown in (Fig. 3). DEM. (Wang et al. 2002). Satellite imagery from Synthetic
aperture radar (SAR) is used to identify the vulnerability of
Data required for research flood and assessment of flood risk. Flood plain mapping is
done based on past flood data (Brivio et al. 2002).
Discharge data from 1971 to 2012 is obtained from the
Irrigation circle, Navsari city. The data collected is for the Data processing in geospatial tools (RAS‑mapper)
lower region of Navsari city at 1.12 km south of Kurul vil-
lage (Latitude 20°98′79 and Longitude 73°05′24″). In RAS RAS-Mapper is a geospatial tool that is capable of extracting
mapper, setting the coordinate system to load the projection GIS information of bank lines, centerline, flow path lines,
file is important. The first step is to perform Georeferencing and cross-section lines through river digitization. Flood
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
modelling input parameters in HEC-RAS mapper are illus- should cross the centerline of the channel, bank lines, and
trated below. flow path lines are shown in (Fig. 4).
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
solves Energy equation which is based on the Saint Venant’s is shown in Table 1. Only one gauging site is available for
equation expressed as, measuring the discharge data at Mahuva, Navsari. Due to the
scarcity of data in the study area, only two flood events are
𝛼2 V22 𝛼1 V12 simulated to check the accuracy of the model. The outcomes
Z 2 + Y2 + = Z1 + Y1 + + he ,
2g 2g obtained from the HEC-RAS model for the study area are as
summarized below:
where, Y1, Y2 = depth of water at cross-sections, Z1, Z2 = ele-
vation of the main river channel, α1, α2 = velocity weighting • The outcomes from the HEC-RAS model in terms of
coefficients, V1, V2 = average velocities, g = acceleration due
water depths for peak discharges for flood events of 2002
to gravity, he = energy head loss.
and 2003 at Mahuva Gauge station near Navsari city.
The HEC-RAS model is globally used for hydraulic anal- • Difference between simulated and observed water depths
ysis of river reaches. The model contains a hydraulic analy-
(Validation).
sis component, graphical user interface, data management,
and data storage capabilities. HEC-RAS has been globally
available for more than a decade and newer versions are
also available on the website (https://www.hec.usace.army.
Simulation results in the HEC‑RAS model
mil/software/hec-ras/). It is globally used by various con-
sultancy, government authorities, and private agencies. For
At Mahuva gauge station, the peak discharge is measured
these reasons, HEC-RAS was chosen for flood modeling in
for an eleven-year time-period, between 2001 and 2012.
the present study.
Steady flow analysis is performed for the model simulation.
In the present study, the outcomes obtained are in terms
Model execution
of water depths for the years 2002 and 2003 with the cor-
responding discharges of 8836 m3/s and 5437 m3/s respec-
Initially, Cartosat-1 DEM with 30 m resolution which is
tively. The simulation results demonstrate that at peak dis-
freely available, are downloaded from ISRO BHUVAN
charge conditions, cross-section no. 1 is less affected by
(https://bhuvan.nrsc.gov.in/bhuvan_links.php). Later, the
the flood, and cross-section no. 20, which is situated near
DEM data is added in the RAS Mapper (GIS) tool in HEC-
Jalalpore and Viraval area in Navsari is prone to flooding
RAS (Hydrological engineering centre-River Analysis
as shown in (Fig. 8a, b). Simulated flood map of Navsari
System), to convert the DEM data into DTM (Digital Ter-
city for the flood events of 2002 and 2004 are shown in
rain Model). Moreover, the Georeference projection file is
(Fig. 9a, b), with corresponding discharges of 8836 m 3/s
assigned in the same window where the coordinates of the 3
and 5437 m /s respectively. Simulated flood maps show the
study area are set up. River center-line, bank lines, flow path
variation water depths along the channel in terms of colors,
lines, and cross-sections lines are digitized in HEC-RAS
where the dark blue color indicates higher depths and light
mapper as shown in (Figs. 4 and 5). The extracted river reach
blue color indicates lower depths. (Fig. 9a, b) shows the
of the study area in HEC-RAS data editor window is shown
impact of flooding is very high in the downstream of Purna
in (Fig. 6) and the station-elevation data of extracted CS-1
river, Navsari city (Jalalpore, Viraval) during the 2002 year
and CS-20 are shown in (Fig. 7a, b). River Centerline is
flood event with corresponding discharge of 8836 m 3/sec
shown in blue color and the cross-sections lines are shown
as compared to the 2003 year flood event with the corre-
in green color with Google maps-satellite image as a base
sponding discharge of 5437 m3/s. A major flood occurred
map overlayed on the terrain image. Steady flow analysis is
in Navsari city in the years 2002 and 2003, most of the
performed in which peak discharge of 8836 m 3/s and 5437
3 people living in the low lying area of Navsari suffer from a
m /s for the years 2002 and 2003 are taken as the upstream
disastrous flood. Pathan and Agnihotri (2020b) had imple-
boundary condition and a normal slope of 0.00195 is taken
mented computational techniques with GIS tools on the
as the downstream boundary condition for the Purna River
lower region of Purna River, Navsari city, to mitigate the
(Patel et al. 2020). Manning’s ‘n’ value is taken as 0.0035,
flood and produce reliable results which can be used for
referred from Chow’s table (Chow 1959; Chow et al. 1988).
flood forecasting and management. GIS soft computation
techniques had presented promising and accurate results
in identifying flood depths at different cross-sections on
Results the downstream of Purna River, Navsari City (Pathan and
Agnihotri 2020a).
The present study is carried out for the lower region of
Navsari city. Historical discharge data of the flood events
of 2002 and 2003 are used for simulation purposes, and it
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Validation the years 2002 and 2003 are used to test for the consistency
of the model simulation. The comparison between simulated
Validation is done using the observed data at Mahuva gauge data and the observed data at Mahuva gauge station is shown
station near Navsari city. Due to Data scarcity, data for only in Table 1. Figure 10 shows the regression relationship
one gauging station is available, to validate the simulated between simulated and observed depths at Mahuva gauge
results obtained using HEC-RAS. The water depth data for station, which shows that the model is accurate and efficient.
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Fig. 7 Station-elevation data of extracted cross-sections a CS-1 & b CS-20 in HEC-RAS geometric data editor window
Table 1 The Difference between Satellite Years Discharge (m3/s) Observed Simulated Difference
the observed and simulated Water depth (m) Water depth (m) (m)
water depth
Cartosat-1 2001 2946 19.3 19.29 0.01
2002 8836 19.5 19.23 0.27
2003 5434 19.88 20.1 − 0.22
2004 3273 23.9 22.3 1.6
2005 3058 21.28 20.36 0.92
2006 1853 20.3 19.93 0.37
2007 667.2 20.5 21.6 − 1.1
2008 744.5 18.8 18.78 0.02
2009 607.5 14.74 14.61 0.13
2010 692.6 14.4 14.46 − 0.06
2011 706.5 14.14 14.12 0.02
2012 689.3 13.8 13.79 0.01
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Purna in Navsari to find the extent of flooding in the low shows the difference between the simulated and observed
lying area of the city. Hence, it is necessary to simulate water depth, which is minor. So the applicability of mod-
the HEC-RAS 2D model for the entire reach of Purna eling through HEC-RAS along with geospatial techniques
River, Navsari city. is precious and efficient.
Discussion
Conclusion
The main purpose of this study is to show the applica-
tion of the latest version HEC-RAS, which has geospa- The current study was carried out to demonstrate the appli-
tial capabilities for extracting the river geometry data by cation of the newly released version of HEC-RAS with spe-
digitizing the bank lines, river centerline, cross-section cial reference to geospatial techniques on the River Purna
cit lines and flow path lines directly from RAS-mapper in Navsari, Gujarat, India. The city experiences flooding
tools, available in HEC-RAS. This digitization process was during monsoons, annually. This study validates the GIS
earlier performed in ARC-GIS with HEC-GeoRAS exten- capabilities of the latest version of HEC-RAS v5. River
sion. By introducing geospatial techniques, the hydraulic geometry is extracted from Cartosat-1 Digital Elevation
modeling approach will be more realistic and it saves the Model (DEM). 1D hydrodynamic simulation is performed
time needed for preprocessing work. In the present study, with steady flow analysis. Model Execution is done in the
Cartosat-1 satellite imagery with 30 m resolution is used HEC-RAS and simulated results of 2002 and 2003 years
and river geometry is extracted from DEMs. Two major of flood events are displayed in the RAS Mapper window
flood events are simulated and a steady flow analysis is in the form of water depths. The simulated results when
performed. The output of the simulated results indicate compared with observed data show a minor difference,
that the low lying areas of Jalalpore and Viraval in Navsari demonstrating a close relation between simulated results
is affected for its entirety, for the 2002 flood event and and observed data. With this approach, it is observed that
some part of the low lying areas are affected by the flood the geospatial techniques along with HEC-RAS can be an
for the 2003 flood event. The flood map with the google accurate and reliable approach for 1D hydrodynamic flood
base map presented in (Fig. 9) shows the variation of depth modelling on the Purna River, Navsari City. Future work
at each cross-section and (Fig. 10) shows the regression planned related to this topic and study area is to analyze
analysis of simulated and observed water depths, which the flood extent with a 2D modelling approach using HEC-
indicates that the model is accurate. Figure 8 illustrates the RAS for the entire stretch of Purna River in Navsari city, to
water levels at each cross-section which can be measured get a better and more precise understanding of the several
by extracting geometry data from the DEMs. It is observed parameters that can be employed in measures to mitigate
that cross-section no. 20 is more affected by floods and the effects floods in the region.
the cross-section no. 1 is less affected by floods. Table. 1
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Fig. 9 Simulated flood map of Navsari city for the 2002 and 2004 years flood events a 2002, Discharge at Mahuva − 8836 m3/s and b 2003,
Discharge at Mahuva − 5437 m3/s
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Fig. 10 Regression relationship
between simulated water depth
and observed depth for Mahuva
gauge station
Acknowledgements The authors would like to express their apprecia- Chow VT, Maidment DR, Mays LW (1988) Applied hydrology.
tion to Dr. P.G Agnihotri, Professor, My Research Supervisor, Water McGraw-Hill, New York
Resources engineering Section, Civil Engineering Department, SVNIT, Deb D, Talukdar B (2010) Remote sensing and geographic information
Surat, to encouraging me to take up this topic and providing me with system for assessment, monitoring, and management of flooded
all help and advice, I’m very much thankful to Director, Sardar Vallab- and waterlogged areas, North District of Tripura State, India.
hbhai National Institute of Technology for providing the department Watershed Manage, p 1013–1024
infrastructural Facilities. Hagen E, Lu XX, Hagen E, Lu XX (2011) Let us create flood hazard
maps for developing countries. Nat Hazards 58:841–843. https://
Funding On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author states that doi.org/10.1007/s11069-011-9750-7
there is no funding for the present research. Haq M, Akhtar M, Muhammad S et al (2012) Techniques of remote
sensing and GIS for flood monitoring and damage assessment:
A case study of Sindh province, Pakistan. Elsevier, Amsterdam
Availability of data and material The data that support the findings of
Khan A, Pathan I, Agnihotri PG (2020) 2-D unsteady flow modelling
this study are openly available in [ISRO BHUVAN] at [https://bhuva
and inundation mapping for Lower Region of Purna Basin using
n.nrsc.gov.in/bhuvan_links.php].
HEC-RAS
Kumar N, Lal D, Sherring A, Issac RK (2017) Applicability of HEC-RAS
Code availability The software, HEC-RAS (Hydrologic Engineering & GFMS tool for 1D water surface elevation/flood modeling of the
Center River Analysis System) that supports the findings of this study river: a Case Study of River Yamuna at Allahabad (Sangam), India.
is openly available at [www.hec.usace.army.mil › software › hec-ras]. Model Earth Syst Environ 3:1463–1475. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s40808-017-0390-0
Compliance with ethical standards Kumar Samanta R, Bhunia GS et al (2018) Flood susceptibility mapping
using geospatial frequency ratio technique: a case study of Sub-
arnarekha River Basin, India. Model Earth Syst Environ 4:395–408.
Conflict of Interest On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author
https://doi.org/10.1007/s40808-018-0427-z
states that there is no conflict of interest.
Kumar N, Kumar M, Sherring A et al (2020) Applicability of HEC-RAS
2D and GFMS for flood extent mapping: a case study of Sangam
area, Prayagraj, India. Model Earth Syst Environ 6:397–405. https
References ://doi.org/10.1007/s40808-019-00687-8
Malik A, Abdalla R (2016) Geospatial modeling of the impact of sea
level rise on coastal communities: application of Richmond, British
Brivio PA, Colombo R, Maggi M, Tomasoni R (2002) International Columbia, Canada. Model Earth Syst Environ 2:1–17. https://doi.
Journal of Remote Sensing Integration of remote sensing data and org/10.1007/s40808-016-0199-2
GIS for accurate mapping of flooded areas Integration of remote Patel DP, Dholakia MB (2010) Feasible Structural and Non-Structural
sensing data and GIS for accurate mapping of ooded areas. Int Measures to Minimize Effect of Flood in Lower Tapi Basin MOD-
J Remote Sens 23:429–441. https://doi.org/10.1080/0143116001 ELLING RUNOFF USING MODIFIED SCS-CN METHOD FOR
0014729 MIDDLE SOUTH SAURASHTRA REGION (GUJARAT-INDIA)
Bulti DT, Abebe BG (2020) A review of flood modeling methods View project Flood modeling on Sabarmati River View project Fea-
for urban pluvial flood application. Model Earth Syst Environ sible Structural and Non-Structural Measures to Minimize Effect of
6:1293–1302. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40808-020-00803-z Flood in Lower Tapi Basin
Chow V (1959) Open channel hydraulics. McGraw-Hill, New York Patel DP, Srivastava PK (2014) Application of geo-spatial technique for
flood inundation mapping of low lying areas. Remote Sens Appl
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Environ Res Soc Earth Sci Ser. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319- Quirogaa VM, Kurea S, Udoa K, Manoa A (2016) Application of 2D
05906-8_7 numerical simulation for the analysis of the February 2014 Boliv-
Patel DP, Srivastava PK, Singh SK et al (2020) One‐dimensional hydro- ian Amazonia flood: application of the new HEC-RAS version 5.
dynamic modeling of the River Tapi. In: Srivastava PK, Singh SK, Ribagua 3:25–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.riba.2015.12.001
Mohanty UC, Murty T (eds) Techniques for disaster risk manage- Rangari VA, Umamahesh NV, Bhatt CM (2019) Assessment of inunda-
ment and mitigation. Wiley, pp 209–235 tion risk in urban floods using HEC RAS 2D. Model Earth Syst
Pathan A (2019) A combined approach for 1-D hydrodynamic flood Environ 5:1839–1851. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40808-019-00641-8
modeling by using Arc-Gis, Hec-Georas, Hec-Ras Interface—a Ranzi R, Mazzoleni M, Milanesi L, Pilotti M (2011) Critical review of
case study on Purna River Of Navsari City, Gujarat. In: IJRTE PA-U non-structural measures for water-related risks. The Development
Pathan AI, Agnihotri PG (2020a) One dimensional floodplain modelling of a robust framework to represent and support the evaluation of
using soft computational techniques in HEC-RAS—a case study complex emergent properties within urban flood scenarios. View
on Purna Basin, Navsari District. In: Vasant P, Zelinka I, Weber project Copula application to hydraulic design View project
GW (eds) Advances in intelligent systems and computing. Springer, Ray T, Asce M, Stepinski E et al (2011) Dynamic modeling of storm
Cham, pp 541–548. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-33585-4_53 surge and inland flooding in a Texas Coastal Floodplain. J Hydraul
Pathan AI, Agnihotri PG (2020b) Use of computing techniques for flood Eng 137:1103–1110. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)HY.1943-
management in a coastal region of South Gujarat—a case study of 7900.0000398(ascelibrary.org)
Navsari District. In: Vasant P, Zelinka I, Weber GW (eds) Advances Samarasinghe SMJS, Nandalal HK, Weliwitiya DP et al (2010) Applica-
in intelligent systems and computing. Springer, Cham, pp 108–117. tion of remote sensing and gis for flood risk analysis: a case study at
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-33585-4_11 Kalu-Ganga River, Sri Lanka
Prabnakorn S, Suryadi FX, Chongwilaikasem J, de Fraiture C (2019) Wang Y, Colby JD, Mulcahy KA (2002) An efficient method for mapping
Development of an integrated flood hazard assessment model flood extent in a coastal floodplain using Landsat TM and DEM data.
for a complex river system: a case study of the Mun River Basin, Int J Remote Sens 23:3681–3696. https://doi.org/10.1080/01431
Thailand. Model Earth Syst Environ 5:1265–1281. https://doi. 160110114484
org/10.1007/s40808-019-00634-7 Zerger A, Wealands S (2004) Beyond modelling: linking models with
Prakash Mandal S, Chakrabarty A (2016) Flash flood risk assessment GIS for flood risk management. Nat Hazards 33:191–208. https://
for upper Teesta river basin: using the hydrological modeling sys- doi.org/10.1023/B:NHAZ.0000037040.72866.92
tem (HEC-HMS) software. Model Earth Syst Environ. https://doi.
org/10.1007/s40808-016-0110-1 Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
Quiroga VM, Popescu I, Solomatine DP, Bociort L (2013) Cloud and jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
cluster computing in uncertainty analysis of integrated flood models.
J HydroInform. https://doi.org/10.2166/hydro.2012.017(iwaponline.
com)
13