!"   "  #
$%#&  '  #

   

  
  
  
  
 

 
       
   
    ! 

"  #
  $% 
  
&
  
 '(

)&(*
 
+

  
 '

 

 
  


   
!


 
  ,
 
  
 



    
"


 

   
 

!

 
 
 

-!







   
!
 
 




 
  
 
)

 *

  !& 
 


   

-





!

 
 
 



    
"

  



 

 
 



-!
( . 
   
"


  
          
!  (  
    /%0 
    
 


!(  

1%0 $%/%!(
   


 
 
  
      !  & 
   
           


    2 
      
             

" 


 
3
 




 
 


 
  !
 &
  
 '(

)&(*  415 







 
  
 


  

 
  
  
 !

"
&(
  
      
  
         

 
   
  ! 


"#
67$%
 

 

 
 
 


  
 
 !  


"#
 &(
67 8 
 '


+
8
 
)( !$% $*!





 
 

 !

 
  
 
 
 

  

! 
3 


Advances in Underground Space Development – Zhou, Cai & Sterling (eds)

Copyright c 2013 by The Society for Rock Mechanics & Engineering Geology (Singapore).
Published by Research Publishing
ISBN: 978-981-07-3757-3 :: doi:10.3850/978-981-07-3757-3 RP-087-P012 1528
 Advances in Underground Space Development 1529

   .  &  

       
    

 
  

!  &                    2 


.

 


 




 
  

' 

 


,
 


  
 


6




(


9!
( 
   



 
 
 
      
                  
  
 
!(   
 




 


  


 




  !:
 



 
 
 
 


  


 

!
 &
 
 
 

 
 
 
   !
 



 
  

!
 
 
 

 
 
  
  
 
  
  

 !
 
"

    
 
 

!


 !
&  
 
 

 

 


!3

!

  
    
     
  
  
    
  
!
  3

  
 


 

   
 
   

 
 


 



!


 
      
 
          2  

 
 
 
);
 44<=$%%%*!
& 9 

    2
 
 
    



! 

      
    

    
           

  
 




     2 

  
       
  "  
    




 
 2 

2 
 

 


)6 4> *!
 &
 



 
 



 
3 ! .

=
  "
)

" 
*




1530 Advances in Underground Space Development

(  







 

 



(2 


2 

'   

 

?



'
  

'  

!

"





 
 



+
 

3 
 


 !
                
   
        
    !
:  


"   




=@
 
2

$
#@+)#
 $%%<*!


 

  
2
 
!' 
"A%
4%

  
 

.
"

!' 
 

"A
 $
!
   
  
  
  
      
  
        




  

!

"



 
 


: 
 


3 
!
&
 
 

   

-
!&
 
    





 
!(

 
  


 !




  

 



  


   
   
 

 !

"#



  

 
 
 

  

 
  

           
    
 

 

  

!#

 




 

 
 
9   
 !?
3
 

  






 

 !
  
 

! 
 
 

9

 
!( 
 3  
 



2"  
 
 

 
-
2")
$% %*!

A
 Advances in Underground Space Development 1531

#
$!
 
 
  
 
 !
 
 
 

   
 
  
 
 !

 
 )( $%%1*.


 )
*.+
 


 
  
 

+

.

 
 


'.'
 
  
 


" 
"

'
.'
  
 3
 
  


(. 
 
B

 
 

9  !

#"



 
 
   

    4 


  9 
" 
  
 

   

 
!
  
 


 

 
 9  




  

 

!
   
 
 


3 
!
  
 )
*  
 
  


9
  
  ;

 <>%!6 
  
 
!(
  
 


 
  
  
 
 

  
!
 =
 
 



  

 
     !  (      
  ,  ),*  

  
  
 

 
 
 
B

 B 

!
    
 
  

 

 
 
 
 
"
    !( 



    !'

C
 D
 

 

!

 
   
 
   


 
    .  +  ,  ,    + ,
  '  
"
 
F 
!
&
'


' '?

  
 

  
 
    
  
4/%    >%! '        


      
     
   
   
      
  
      
   -  
  
 !
 

 
 
 
 


!
&
 

 

 
"
  9 
 
9 "
!
1532 Advances in Underground Space Development

#"



 

 
 

 
  

(

 
!'

 
 

 " 
 !'
 
   
 



!

" 

  
 2
 



 "!
  


 

     2 

"
 
!
 
 

$%%% !
 

 







!' 
 
 
 





 " 
 
!

#"#



 
 

 
 

 

: 








 
  
          
  
  
      !   



 




  - 




 


    

 

!








 .






  





 
)
 

 *
 
  
  
 





3 
 
 !
 


-

 ',( 
  
-  )'
 ,    
  *!  
- 
    
 G;, 






 
- 
!4!1"
',(


, $%%1



!@

 
A"


 

 " 


 
 








!&
 

 
-

 

 

 A!$ 

 
! 


 

 


 ! 


 
G;
  
 
 
 !

#"%



 

 

 
  

 
 
 

  

 
  
         2    
  
"
 
! 

 
!
 
 

  
  


 
 
!
 Advances in Underground Space Development 1533

@ 

 )
*
B 

 
"
 
   
 !  
3 

 
  
 !

 





 

!#
 
 

  !
 #
 

 
 

 

 

!& 
 
 

 

!#
 
 
 
  
 
    
      
 !  (  
      
 
 


!
  
 
 

 

!:
 

  
    
 
    
      
      !       


 

 



! 
 
 
 

2


 
 



!, -


""


 

 3
 
  

 

!
 
 





! 
  .      
  2 
        
! ?
   

   
 
    
   

  
 
 


!' 

  
 
  


  " 
  !     
   
              

 
  
 
!
(
:"? 
 




 
 
!
 

 
  
  


 
 

 

 !
 
 

   
 
 
 
  
  4 !+

 



 

3 2  

    
  
  
             
  
  
!  
  

    

                    


   

 
 



 

 
!'  



 
 2      

 
 

 
 !

#"&



 
 


 
 

 


 
  
 
!

  
 
" 
C2 
D!


   
  !@
 


   

 
 !
 " +
=

# 


H

 9
#
= !#3

 
' (

 
 
1534 Advances in Underground Space Development



)I@
J*!  
 



>1%%A!
 H 
"
 #-K"
6
 !#-K" :


;
  
# 445 

>%%%
!
  

  
!;
+? 

-"(  
6 

 
 
!
  

    
     -
  
  
     

   
  L     
   

   !           

  
I 
 = J
 ,
= !;"'
- 
,





"
'
 

 
!

#"'



 
 


( 
 " 

    



" 

 !&  
 


 




"!& 
  

  
 
 
" 
 
"!
 ? 
 
   3  
9
  
"!
 
 
"
   2 
 
 
 

  !

#"(



 
 


 


:      

     
"       
       ! 
6 

 
  

 

 

2 
 


!&
"
 


"
 

  
 B  
  
 

!
     
          
   

 
   
!'
  
 


  
" 
     

  

 
         
    
   
 

 

 
!

%!)$!!
  
  "  
  
            


  -
 


  
 


 .

?  

@ 

 

  - 




,"
)


*

;  


(
  
  

6 

 "
 
 Advances in Underground Space Development 1535

.

!
:
    
    
            
         

"  
 .





  


-
 



+      . 
   
        
  


&
.      
  
-     
 " 



&
 =

. 
  


"


  


!
@
9"
 


" 
  
 

 




-
" 



-

-  
!
+
- 

-

 
  
 


  

"!
&



-
2    

  
    



  
- 
 2 
-
   

   !  @
  
     
  
-  

  
 
"
   

     
    
-    "  
   
!  &  
 
  

  "
       
     2        
  



!
 &




-


 
 

  
"      
  "
   
     



" 

 

 
"!
 :
 


 

  
 
 
 

!& 


 
   
  

 
 
 
   "
 ! 
N



 

 


 



"
 
2 




     

 !
 


 




 
 
 

 
!&  

 

 "

 .

'
9

 

'   

( B 






B




;B 
  3




 

 


B 



2 "
 !

  
"
 

  
 


  



 



"
 !6
  
 
1536 Advances in Underground Space Development


  

 
 

!(
" 
 
 







  

"  
   

  
 


 !

%"




 

& 
"




  


 
 B


B   


 

 
 !




  .

=

 

 
 

 

'  
 O

@


O







6

 




!
 
 



 


!
    

  
 "  
 






 !3



 
  


 
! 

  

3 !

%"



 
 
 

(
 
     

  
 
 
 3 
!
  
 

 
 
 
"   

!&
  
" 



  !

3 2"
   
 



 
 

!



 

 

  


  



   !
 


 
     
  
        2"!  (        $% %     <!< 
 2"=
  
   
'

    !

%"#



  

           

   -
  2
  
  
     
 
 

 
 !=
 


 

"  
   
    
  
   
          
   

! 

 



   -

 !
      
   
  
   
 
     !    
 Advances in Underground Space Development 1537

2  
        
      
      
   

 
 



!

%"%





 
   
 

 
 3


 
  
 !  
                
  !     


   


  
  




 


 



!



 
 
 

 
!
 ,

   
  
  



!& 




 
                 
    
  

  

! 
  




 



 


 

!)"$%%/*

%"&







 


 

N
        
 "
  
  
  

! 
 
 








    

 !
  
" 





 !& 
 





3
 

  


!
(
3
 

 
  
          
   
 ! '          

  
   
  

       
   
      
 
"!(
  
 
  
 


 
 


 
 
  
!

 



  


 
  
 

   
 

 

    
 
!  &  P  
     

    

 
 
 
  


 





 
   


 

 

!




 @ 
 
3
($%%  

 5%
),;& 
$%% *!     - 
       
  
       
 



!

%"'



 



 
 
-
 
 
 

9
 


  


! 
:



 


   
   3

 
9!
1538 Advances in Underground Space Development

=
  
 


9"
 
 


  
 

9
 
- 
  

 !


 
 

 

  



 
 

 
 
 




 

  !&
 


9
9 

 




 
)+"  $%%<*!& 
 

   
 
 !
9 
   
 
  








 

  

! 
!

%"(



 
 

(

 
"




 

 
 


  !&
 
  

  
 


   

  
 
 




  !&   



  
   
  !           
     
 



 
 
 

 


 
 

!

&*!!

   
  
 

 
  
 

 
 

2 

 !& 
 
 
 
   
 

 
 2 !
 &
 
   

"





 
  




 
  
  
!  &   
  
  

   
         
 
   
 



! 
  




 



 


 

)"$%%/*!
 &
 
   
 

 
"
 


3

 
 

 
 

  !
 
 

 
 
 .

=
  "
)

" 
*





(  




(2 



'   

 
 Advances in Underground Space Development 1539

?





 

 



'
  

'  

!
 
 

 




 .


  

+"

@"
 



'


  

 


'
 




 


 
!
'

 !
&
 





 
 


 

   

    
  "  
!   
  
  
    
 
 

 
!

 


  
  

  
 
  
        
  
 
2 
  
  


 
 
  

!

)+$ !
 
&(
6
! 8 
 '


+
8 

 
 



"#
$%
&(     

  ( N(   
 
  

" #
     (
! 


 "
  !(
 


 
&( 
.QQ!9!


,!
( #! 

! 
(! #
 P!+! G

 +! 6P! +"
:! '! ,!) !*)$% $*! 
  
&+& !
&(
67 &(!
=@!!)$%%%*!'
'#
  * @$%%%!
"!)$%%/*! 
 '@ +!
#
 P!+!)$%%<*!'
 Q=
  
 ,' R ,--!
.*/!
;
  +!P!  ) 44<*! , +    0  &  1         && 
1 '6 

 
($1 44<!
, 
; &
 
),;&*)$%% *  
 
  
  2  +&1P!
6P! '"!)$%%/*!
  
 

 
-*


   .  %   ,

!
+":!
!  P!)$%%<*"  ;
= =

 
 +
-! 
"*  --!+ !
 6
)6*) 4> *! *         
   #@
!6
!!AQ$1%Q! 9!=6!/QA/A!66S
"

  '!  )$% %*!   )       34 ! "  ,  $% % 
.QQ"!
Q'
9,
9, %92"9!