How Will India Accept Passive Euthanasia

1/13/2021 How will India accept passive euthanasia?
HOME LATEST TRENDING MY READS
Budget 2021 Coronavirus Vaccine Tracker Long Reads 2021: The Great Reset Plain Facts Primer Market Dash
Home >Science >Health >How will India accept passive euthanasia?
OPEN APP
The issue of euthanasia rose to prominence in India after several noteworthy cases including that of Aruna Shanbaug,
a nurse who spent 42 years in a vegetative state as a result of a violent sexual assault.
How will India accept passive euthanasia?

3 min read . Updated: 12 Mar 2018, 04:06 PM IST
Neetu Chandra Sharma
Even though the Supreme Court has recognised the right to die with dignity as a fundamental right,
major hurdles might be posed by religious communities
New Delhi: With religious beliefs against premature death held strong in India, right to
life may weigh over the right to die with dignity that has just been granted legal
sanction by the apex court.
https://www.livemint.com/Science/Whfhef9I34eZ8iAXWaHVqK/How-will-India-accept-passive-euthanasia.html 1/13
Requests from patients suffering from terminal medical conditions across India, have
led to government and courts professing for palliative care policies. Yet the debate has
been around issues that are legal, ethical, human rights-related, health-related,
religious,
Budget 2021
economic, spiritual, social
Coronavirus Vaccine Tracker
and cultural.
Long Reads 2021: The Great Reset Plain Facts Primer Market Dash
Even though the Supreme Court has recognised the right to die with dignity as a
fundamental right, major hurdles might be posed by religious communities, who mostly
oppose euthanasia in India.
“In Hinduism Atma-gatha meaning suicide—the intention to voluntary kill—was

prohibited in Hindu culture. Indian Muslims also don’t favour euthanasia however they
haven’t made any public statements on the subject. Muslims believe that no one has a
right to die before the time decided by the God," said Scaria Kanniyakonil, Professor of
Moral Theology at Paurastya Vidyāpītham, Pontifical Oriental Institute of Religious
Studies in Kerala.
“According to both Sunnis and Shias, killing a terminally ill person, whether through
active euthanasia (physician assisted suicide) or passive euthanasia (stopping life
support or medicine), is considered as an act of disobedience against God. Similarly,
Indian Christians, especially the Catholic Bishops Conference of India, are againstOPEN APP
euthanasia. The Catholic Church forever promotes the sanctity of life, thus euthanasia is
contrary to its teachings," Kanniyakonil said.
Medical professionals hold that passive euthanasia is already a common event in

majority of the hospitals all across the country as many poor terminally ill patients or
their family members choose to withdraw treatment because of the huge costs involved
in treatment to keep them alive. However, for the few who can afford such treatment,
maintaining life with advanced medical technologies and palliative care has become
more routine. “Earlier diseases outcome was discussed in terms of cure but in the
contemporary world of diseases such as cancer, AIDS, diabetes, hypertension and
mental illness are debated in terms of care, since cure is distant," said Suresh Bada
Math, Department of Psychiatry, National Institute of Mental Health & Neuro Sciences
(NIMHANS).
The government has already been promoting palliative care policies for elderly, poor and
terminally ill patients who are most likely to opt for euthanasia. “There are several
programs for health and welfare of elderly, people inflicted with AIDS, cancer, terminal
Closelatest National Health Protection

kidney disease and neurological disorders. The
Scheme is an answer to quality healthcare for poor managing serious terminal diseases.
PatientsHOME
want good care and ifLATEST
we provide it to them, why would they opt for
TRENDING MY READS
euthanasia?" said a senior health ministry official requesting anonymity.

Public health experts said it is essential to assess the mental health status of the
individual seeking euthanasia. “The main reasons for opting euthanasia are depression,
hopelessness, pain and lack of care. Patients can overcome their decision on euthanasia
or to receive natural death when they are well taken care of. Studies show that when
patients receive adequate palliative care, requests for euthanasia decrease. Many of
them are not aware of modern pain management techniques," said Kanniyakonil.
According to Roopkumar Gursahani, Consultant Neurologist and Epileptologist, P.D.

Hinduja Hospital, Mumbai, taking charge of one’s last days is a basic human right but
there is a lot left to do. “India does not have a comprehensive law on End of Life
decision-making. The Supreme Court judgement is one step forward in handing control
over to the individual. As a society we need to normalise death and to remove the taboo
around discussing it. All doctors need to be aware of the basic principles of palliative
care so that we can offer care when cure is no longer possible," said Gursahani.
OPEN APP
The issue of euthanasia rose to prominence in India after several noteworthy cases
including that of Aruna Shanbaug, a nurse who spent 42 years in a vegetative state as a
result of a violent sexual assault. ‘Passive Euthanasia’ was legalized by the Supreme
Court on 7 March 2011. Also, based on the recommendations of the Law Commission,
ministry of health and family welfare had prepared a draft of The Medical Treatment of
Terminally Ill patients (protection of patients and medical practitioners) in May 2016.
Upholding the right to die with dignity, the Supreme Court on Friday gave legal sanction
to passive euthanasia and execution of a living will of persons suffering from chronic
terminal diseases and likely to go into a permanent vegetative state.
Subscribe to Mint Newsletters

Enter email address Subscribe
Click here to read the Mint ePaper
Mint is now
HOMEon Telegram. Join LATEST
Mint channel in yourTRENDING
Telegram and stay updated with the
MY READS
latest business news.

Topics
mint-india-wire
Recommended
Recommended by
BSE SENSEX NIFTY 50

) 49,517.11 +247.79 (+0.50%) 14,563.45 +78.70 (+0.54%)
OPEN APP
The budget’s stimulus measures must be aimed well for a revival

4 min read 12 Jan 2021
The budget should be as much about measures to ease supply-side obstacles to growth as about a
Keynesian stimulus per se
Read Full Story
FROM THE WALL STREET JOURNAL View All
Making an Apple EV is a Conspiracy theorists, CEOs Fed’s Bostic says strong

poisoned chalice for car and grandmothers: inside recovery could open door to
companies the capitol mob bond taper this year
2 min read 12 Jan 2021 9 min read 12 Jan 2021 3 min read 12 Jan 2021
Brexit shock washes up on Britain’s shores

New tariffs, bureaucracy and quotas are disrupting life in the UK. The pain has only just begun.
The shrinking of Britain may even become physical and political. A Scottish referendum is now
OPEN APP
increasingly likely. There is a sense of exhaustion and fatigue among Britons.
Read Full Story
Recommended
Recommended by
Elon Musk's Tesla opens India entity in Bengaluru, names three directors
Tesla has named Vaibhav Taneja, Venkatrangam Sreeram and David Jon Feinstein as the three
directors in the newly formed entity in the country
The state government had earlierLATEST
HOME said that Tesla would open an R&D centre in Bengaluru
TRENDING MY READS
Read Full Story

View All
Winter carrots for a pop of Here's how astronomers Kaun Banega LGBTQ+ ally?
joy on your plate witnessed a galaxy die
12 Jan 2021 12 Jan 2021 12 Jan 2021
OPEN APP
How fiscal deficit has a bearing on inflationary woes

Fiscal deficit is difference between total government receipts (taxes and non-debt capital) and total
expenditure. Its size affects growth, price stability, and cost of production and overall inflation. A
large fiscal deficit can also impact a country’s rating. Mint explores.
Read Full Story
Byju’s to acquire Blackstone-backed Aakash Educational Services for ₹7,300

cr
The deal for what will be one of the largest edtech acquisitions in the world should close in the
next two or three months
Aakash Educational Services runs Aakash Institute, which has over 200 brick and mortar centers
and tutors students to gain entry into the country’s elite engineering and medical schools
Read Full Story
OPEN APP
Trump says rally before Capitol riot was ‘totally appropriate’

Before Capitol riot, Trump had told a large crowd in Washington that the presidential election was
stolen and that they should march on Congress and show 'strength'
Democrats and several Republicans have decried Trump’s role in inciting a mob that went on to
force its way into the Capitol in a chaotic scene that left five people dead
Read Full Story
Budget may unveil roadmap on scrapping old, polluting vehicles

The much-awaited vehicle scrappage policy, which aims to boost automobile demand by phasing
out old, polluting vehicles, could find mention in the Union Budget 2021-22, a top government
official said on Tuesday
Read Full Story
OPEN APP
CPI inflation eases to 4.59% in December; IIP contracts 1.9% in November

Retail inflation was 6.93% in Nov 2020; food inflation declined to 3.41% in Dec in 2020, compared
to 9.5% in the previous month
Manufacturing sector output shrank by 1.7% in Nov 2020, while mining output shrank 7.3%
Read Full Story
CAFE ECONOMICS
The comeback path for DFIs is strewn with strategic challenges

The idea of development finance institutions is being revisited but they’ll have new realities to face
Read Full Story
OPEN APP
Vodafone Idea's market share erosion will continue, says Goldman Sachs
Vodafone Idea could potentially save ₹58 billion in cash flows annually if the AGR liability were
lowered to its self-assessed value, the company said in a report
According to Trai data, Vi has lost 26.3 million subscribers in the first seven months of the current
financial year
Read Full Story
Wistron plant's re-opening delayed due to its internal audit: Karnataka govt
The company is carrying out some internal audit, awaiting clearances and are then expected to
update us on the status, a government official said
The delay in reopening the plant had given an unexpected lift to rival suppliers Foxconn and
Pegatron
Read Full Story
OPEN APP
Europe’s China gambit will fall short of its stated goals

Judge the deal not by how it impacts China but whether it lets Europe stay true to its own values
Read Full Story
EX MACHINA
The shift that could make India a data-first economy

Regulation should focus on the utility of data and not treat it as if it’s a scarce resource akin to oil
Read Full Story
OPEN APP
All members of SC-formed panel pro-govt, agitation will continue: Farmer

leaders
Supreme Court can repeal the farm laws suo motu, say farmer leaders
However, the farmer leaders said they would attend the 15 Jan meeting with the govt
Read Full Story
People won't be given a choice on which Covid vaccine to take: Govt

'In many countries, more than one vaccine is being used. There is no such option available to any of
the beneficiaries in these countries,' says Union Health Secretary
Read Full Story
OPEN APP
Haven't received govt's nod on selling Covid vaccine in pvt market: Serum CEO
'In the private market, for those who want to purchase the vaccine, the price would be ₹1,000. But
we have not received permission for this...,' Adar Poonawalla informed
Poonwalla termed the vaccine dispatch a historic moment and said the main challenge is to make
the vaccine available to everyone in the country
Read Full Story
Sensex closes in on 50,000 as RIL, HDFC Bank rally. What analysts say
The bullish reversal formation of Reliance Industries (RIL) would help the Sensex to reach the
milestone of 50,000 in the near term: Analyst
Read Full Story
OPEN APP

How Will India Accept Passive Euthanasia

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

How Will India Accept Passive Euthanasia

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

1/13/2021 How will India accept passive euthanasia?

HOME LATEST TRENDING MY READS

Home >Science >Health >How will India accept passive euthanasia?