Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Awhitmore Inquiry Apa Writing
Awhitmore Inquiry Apa Writing
Abigail Whitmore
Prior to starting my internship through USF, I never imagined the time and effort teachers
spend developing classroom management strategies that support the smooth operation of day to
day learning. Without a classroom management plan in place, instructional time can be wasted.
students were off task. This overwhelming feeling led to internal frustration, multiple
redirections to student behavior, and a loss of instructional time. I knew these factors
contributed to students' lack of controlling their own behavior, as well as a negative learning
personal and academic lives, I wondered how I might implement new classroom management
located in central Florida. The school is set in a rural area on the outskirts of the city. There are
a total of 656 students at Lakeside Elementary with the majority being of Hispanic descent.
Altogether, the school’s population consists of 64.33% Hispanic students, 28.81% White
students, 5.49% Black students, 1.22% multiracial students, and .15% Asian students. Last year
and the year prior, Lakeside Elementary proudly received a B grade. Because this school has a
high rate of students from multicultural and ESE backgrounds, many hands-on activities and
cultural backgrounds. This particular class has 54% of students who are White, 31.81% of
students who are Hispanic, and 4.54% students who are black. In terms of gender, 59% are
3
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
female students and 41% are male students. LOL Dolls, Legos, and Pokemon are just a few of
the common interests amongst these students. Interestingly, a number of the boys and girls from
Mr. G’s homeroom are children of school faculty (teachers, paraprofessionals, etc.).
classroom management and the strategies I was using to achieve this goal. While I have
observed successful classroom management, I have struggled to enact it myself. It has been
shown that, “pupils in classes where the teacher has good control of the class and also shows
care for the pupils have higher cognitive achievements and more positive attitudes to the
subjects than pupils who do not have such teachers” (Postholm, 2013, p. 390). It is critical that
teachers develop strategies to successfully manage the class, while building relationships with
students. These actions support students in developing positive dispositions towards academics,
thus supporting their learning. For the teacher, it is a professional responsibility to have the
utmost concern for the development of students’ potential. With these factors in mind, it is
Artifact I: Wondering
In what ways can I implement engaging classroom management strategies to assist students in
staying on task?
behavior and promote high rates of engagement in learning” (Cook, Fiat, Larson, Daikos,
Slemrod, Holland, Thayer, and Renshaw, 2018, p. 131). These evidence-based practices will
support my inquiry to explore the following question: In what ways can I implement engaging
Oftentimes, the use of reactive measures have been used as a means of managing the classroom
(Nagro, Fraser, & Hooks, 2019); for example, calling out student names when negative
unaware of and are not adequately trained to manage student behavior” (Cook et al., 2018, p.
131). While the strategies recommended to support classroom management vary, student
engagement is at the center of increasing on-task behavior. Student choice (Lane, Royer,
Messenger, Common, Ennis, & Swogger, 2015), the integration of movement (Nagro, et al.,
2019), and specific praise (Diedrich, 2010) are all ways to engage students, therefore increasing
becoming actively engaged before instruction even begins (Cook et. al, 2018; Strout, 2015).
For example, Positive Greetings at the Door (PGD), recommended by Cook et al. (2018),“is a
preventive approach that seeks to boost academic engagement and thereby curtail inappropriate
behaviors that inhibit learning” ( p. 150). Movement is also shown to support students who are
typically inattentive; the purpose behind movements connected to content can support students’
ability to focus throughout a lesson (Nagro et al., 2019). Another proactive strategy includes
giving students choice (Lane et al., 2015). When children have the opportunity to make low-
risk decisions within a classroom setting, it “can ultimately offer them a sense of control that
may improve the quality of their life” (Lane et al., 2015, p. 475). These strategies demonstrate
how students actively learn through engagement, rather than through reactive comments
Diedrich states, “Creating a positive and engaging classroom atmosphere is one of the most
powerful tools teachers can use to encourage children's learning and prevent problem behaviors
from occurring” (2010, p. 13). For example, positively stating classroom rules, teaching
positive behaviors, and maintaining consistency are small actions with a great impact on
students’ behavior when they enter the class (Strout, 2005). Rewards, such as marbles in a jar
for positive behaviors, demonstrate to students that positive behaviors are desired (Diedrich,
2010). While some degree of misbehavior is always expected (Strout, 2005), “research
indicates that using PCM (positive classroom management) strategies to promote desired
behavior can prevent many of the externalizing behaviors that negatively affect the learning
environment” (Cook et al., 2018, p. 150). When teachers implement positive interventions, the
increase in instructional time and teacher-student bond benefits the student emotionally and
academically (Nagro et al., 2019). Diedrich (2010) also claims that productivity in the
classroom “is directly linked to student involvement and academic achievement” (p. 36). With
these factors considered, it is critical for educators to consider the impact that low-cost
In the following section, I describe the strategies used to support my inquiry work.
These strategies supported the following wondering: In what ways can I implement engaging
improve their desire to engage in content, thus increasing their on-task behavior. Student choice
can be implemented in a variety of ways in the classroom. When I was deciding upon how to
implement this strategy in my class, I initially wanted students to choose instructional materials
morning meetings with my students and noticed frequent off-task behavior during this time. In
order to support my students in staying on task, I integrated the ‘student choice’ strategy into
our morning meetings every day. Each morning, the monthly calendar was displayed on the
board with two students’ names on each day. The students whose names were displayed chose
which question they wanted to be shared during the morning meeting. The two students would
come to my desk and tell me the question, then I updated the PowerPoint to reflect the updates.
This opportunity allowed students to choose a special question the entire class had the option of
answering. Before students met me on the carpet, I read the two questions aloud, noting which
students chose each question for our time together. Then students were asked to choose one
question they would like to answer during our time of sharing. By allowing students to choose
the question of the day and answer one of two question options, I was giving students a sense
In order to determine the effectiveness of the strategy, I collected data for two weeks. I
utilized a student survey when starting the strategy to see if students cared about having a
choice and why that mattered to them. The second student survey, conducted at the end of two
weeks, provided me with insight into whether students were still enjoying the ‘choice strategy’
and whether they believed it was helping them to stay on-task. Reflective blogs were completed
at the end of both weeks in order to record my observations of students’ behaviors, comments,
7
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
etc. These reflective blogs would allow me to determine the effectiveness by seeing whether
Marbles for Manners is a positive behavioral intervention that rewards students for
exhibiting desirable observable behaviors. Diedrich (2010) argued, “The use of positive
reinforcement as an effective, high-impact strategy for improving students' behaviors has been
supported by documented research for a variety of school circumstances for both individual
students and groups of students” (p. 12). In order to implement this strategy, I divided the class
into five table groups, each group consisting of four to five students. Clear cups with each
group’s table number were placed at the front of the classroom in clear view for students. I
introduced the strategy to students during a morning meeting where I explained the purpose and
process. The class was told that when a student in their group displays a positive behavior, such
as staying on task, sitting quietly, participating, or helping a friend, I would place a marble in
the group’s cup. I gave students the opportunity to ask questions they had about the marbles,
Each day, I set a goal for the number of marbles students needed to obtain in order to
receive a reward. Based on my understanding of this group of students, I decided to set a daily
goal, rather than weekly, in order to keep them motivated. If students acquired the number of
marbles required to receive the reward, they were able to choose a prize at the end of the day.
When I placed a marble in a group’s cup, I would announce, “Wow, I love how my friends in
this group are following directions quickly. Thank you so much. I will place a marble in their
group cup.” I verbally praised groups who met the goal and encouraged those who did not to
keep up their awesome work. If I noticed a group did not reach the goal for multiple days in a
row, I would seek out opportunities to place more marbles in their cup.
8
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
This strategy was implemented for two consecutive weeks. Data was collected through
the use of student surveys and reflective blogs. A student survey was taken at the beginning of
the strategy implementation in order to determine if students understood the purpose and
whether they felt it motivated them or not. Another student survey was taken at the end of the
two weeks to see if it was still motivating students to display positive behaviors. I also
completed reflective blogs at the end of each week, making note of students’ comments and
behaviors throughout the course of the two weeks. The final form of data collected was field
notes. These were notes taken throughout the day of comments students make and actions I
observed. Field notes will be analyzed by seeing if students responded positively or negatively
Promoting positive behaviors when students are transitioning from a less structured
environment to the classroom can be a challenge. Cook et al. (2018) recommends positively
greeting students at the door and setting the expectation for behavior in order to engage
students before instruction even begins. This proactive strategy sets the climate for the
classroom and decreases the likelihood of the teacher having to correct problem behaviors.
Before implementing the strategy, I noticed when students came into the class each morning,
they were talkative, walking to each others’ desks, and ignoring reminders. During a morning
meeting, I introduced students to the new expectations for entering the classroom. Students
were told to enter the classroom quietly after they had been greeted, eat their breakfast, then
complete their morning work. Students were given the opportunity to ask questions to clarify
the dos and don'ts. Before students entered the classroom each morning, I propped the door
open and waited for their arrival. When students entered the classroom, we exchanged a high-
five, fist bump, wave, or side hug. I greeted each student, then reminded them to quietly walk
9
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
to their desk and read the announcement on the board. Using the student’s name, having a
smile, and providing a gentle reminder allowed me to set the tone for the day as students
arrived.
This strategy was implemented for two consecutive weeks. Data was collected through
the use of student surveys and reflective blogs. The student survey completed at the beginning
of the strategy implementation ensured students understood what was expected when they
entered the classroom and which greeting they were most excited about. The student survey
collected at the end of the two weeks allowed me to understand how students felt about the new
routine. The reflective blogs completed at the end of each week recorded my observations of
students’ behaviors and comments over the course of the two weeks.
In order to determine the effectiveness of the three chosen strategies, I collected data
over the course of five weeks. I used reflective blogs to make note of students’ behaviors,
conversations, and engagement levels on the days when I implemented the strategies.
Reflective blogs allowed me to see how students' behavior changed over the course of each
week. Student surveys were another form of important data that provided insight into the
students’ feelings of the various strategies. The trends noticed in students’ answers allowed me
Patterns started to emerge when I looked across all of the data, showing me how each
strategy impacted students. When I first looked at the data, I sorted it by each strategy
implemented. A digital folder was created for Marbles for Manners, Student Choice, and PDG
(Positive Greetings at the Door). To keep track of these patterns, I coded and memoed each
piece of data. The data was coded by either my own observations about students’ behaviors in
10
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
response to the strategies or how students felt about the strategies. From there, I memoed each
piece of data, using a star to highlight positive responses and a circle to show a negative
response. For example, I looked at what students were saying or doing that demonstrated a
Collecting and analyzing the data from my inquiry supported three learning statements
that informed the following wondering: “In what ways can I implement engaging classroom
Throughout this inquiry process, Marbles for Manners became a routine part of the
everyday classroom management plan. Each time an entire group of students displayed positive
behavior, I placed a marble in their cup. If a group received the goal number of marbles for that
day, they would receive a small reward (candy, erasers, fidget toy, etc.). The strategy is
supported by Diedrich’s (2010) use of positive reinforcement which, “is the presentation of a
reward immediately following a desired behavior intended to make that behavior more likely to
occur in the future” (p. 16). My students' excitement in receiving marbles (the reward) would
increase their motivation (the desired behavior) towards displaying positive behaviors.
When I first started implementing the strategy, I surveyed students to evaluate how they
felt about Marbles for Manners. I asked my students, “How do you feel about using the marbles
for manners?” On a scale from 1-10, five of the six students chose 10/10 (see Appendix B).
Students’ felt positively towards the strategy from the beginning and this was evident in their
behaviors as well. One student, in particular, B.S., was observed gently reminding his peers to
be quiet by placing his finger in front of his mouth. B.S. typically calls out during lessons and
has to be reminded to raise his hand to share. However, on multiple occasions, I observed him
11
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
working towards the goal number of marbles to win a reward at the end of the day. I asked B.S.,
“Do you enjoy using the marbles during class,” to which he responded, “Yes, because maybe
my group can get more marbles again” (see Appendix C). Even though his group had not
obtained the goal number of marbles yet, he was motivated to keep staying on task in hopes of
The second survey provided insight into how students felt after two weeks of using the
strategy. As shown in Appendix B, only one students’ rating of the strategy went down. Five of
the six students had a rating that remained the same or increased. One particular student, B.L.,
initially rated the strategy a 5/10 and that increased to an 8/10 on the second survey. I noticed
over the course of the two weeks, B.L. became more interested in the marbles which increased
his on-task behavior. Each morning, he came to me asking, “Ms. Whitmore, are we doing the
marbles today?” His motivation was evident in his gentle reminders to peers and his
promptness in following directions. On two different occasions, I saw B.L. help his tablemates
by puting away their notebooks after he finished cleaning up his own area. This clearly
When I implemented the marbles for manners during lessons, it greatly supported
students’ motivation in staying on task in order to receive the goal. During a whole group
lesson, I collected video data to analyze the strategy’s effectiveness. As shown in Appendix D, I
called students to the carpet and reminded them I would be rewarding one marble to the group
that was quietest. Once all the students were seated, I observed which group was showing they
were silent by putting a quiet finger in front of their mouth. Each group came to the carpet and
sat criss-cross without talking. The marble was rewarded to group two who had been following
my instructions perfectly. After the marble was placed in the groups’ cup, a student in the front
12
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
row smiled and silently cheered. The evidence in the video demonstrates the on-task behavior
from every student throughout the transition, due to students’ motivation in receiving a marble.
Overall, I noticed increased motivation to stay on task from every table group in the
directions, redirect their behavior, and support their peers. In my reflective blog (see Appendix
A) I noted that multiple students used a quiet finger to the mouth or a gentle tap on the shoulder
to support their peers in staying on task. The disappointment with not reaching the goal number
of marbles was an issue I had to address with students on a couple occasions. When I noticed
frustration beginning to arise, I reminded groups to encourage their peers. We began clapping
and cheering for the winning group to support their efforts. Based upon my findings from
student interviews, reflective blogs, and videos, it is evident that Marbles for Manners
as well as decide between which of the two questions they wanted to answer. Lane et al. (2015)
suggests that, “In the short term, students who engage in choice making while meeting learning
meetings each day supported my inquiry by finding ways to help students stay on task. Before
implementing the strategy, off-task behavior was prevalent during morning meetings. However,
once I began implementing the strategy, I noticed students becoming much more engaged.
Engagement increased from the moment students came into the classroom. I observed
students’ eyes quickly drawn to the calendar to see whose turn it was to choose a question.
When a student observed their name on that day’s date, they would run to my desk to share
13
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
their question. I documented in my field notes (see Appendix F) that one of my focus students,
J.S., commented, “Tomorrow is my day to choose!” Furthermore, even though I announced this
was a daily routine, multiple students would quietly come to my desk asking, “Ms. Whitmore,
are we doing the morning meeting today?” Excitement associated with the student choice
strategy was my first clue into how it was impacting my students’ engagement.
Once students began choosing the morning meeting questions, I noticed a growing
number of them participating. Before implementing the strategy, I struggled to bring out the
voices of many students. However, after implementing the strategy, every student, besides two
to three, answered a question each day. Students would quietly come to the carpet, anxious to
share their answers. Furthermore, I could see the excitement on the two students’ faces as they
waited to see which of their peers would answer the question they created. In my reflective
blog shown in Appendix F, I noted that a student asked, “Can I answer both questions? It’s so
hard to choose!” Difficulty choosing between the questions is something I encountered multiple
times with students. Excitement related to the questions exhibited students’ increased
feelings about ‘student choice’. I asked students, “Do you like being given the choice to answer
two different morning meeting questions? Why?” Every student responded with a resounding
“Yes!” One student in particular stated, “Yes, because when I can’t think of something, I just
choose another one” (see Appendix G). This information shows students are more likely to
participate when they are given options because they are not limited in their choices. Prior to
implementing the strategy, students were exhibiting off-task behavior because they were only
able to choose one question. Increases in participation supported my students in staying on-task
While the majority of students found the strategies to be beneficial and the data pointed
to their effectiveness, I found that some students did not consistently respond positively. Nargo
et al. (2019) connects to this idea by stating, “Teachers are challenged daily with engaging
diverse populations of students with varied individual needs to sustain learning and promote
positive student outcomes” (p. 132). On-task behavior improved when I implemented the
strategies, but other undesirable behaviors arose with students who needed individualized
motivator in staying on-task throughout the day. However, some of these same students became
extremely frustrated with their group when they did not win the reward. For example, I noted in
a reflective blog (Appendix H) that B.L. and B.S. were very frustrated with their group
partners. While they did not make a scene of the situation, it was evident in their comments and
facial expressions that their groups’ lack of effort was problematic. B.L. and B.S. are the same
students who were observed gently reminding their peers to follow instructions. While they
were mostly motivated by the strategy, there were instances where their irritation was evident.
Another student was seen crying at his desk because his group had fewer marbles than other
groups (see Appendix J). I recorded these observations in my field notes when I saw unusual
behaviors occurring because of the strategies. Frustration was evident throughout the use of the
strategy.
Another piece of data that points to the need for individualized behavior management is
a students’ response on a survey (Appendix C). I asked students, “How do you feel when we
use the marbles?” The student, B.S., responded, “good” then added, “but my team hasn’t been
working together.” It was evident during my interaction with the student that he was greatly
15
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
disappointed. While he was trying to exhibit positive behaviors, there was another student in
his group who clearly did not care about receiving a marble. I noticed throughout the course of
the day when B.S.’s group member was off-task, his desire to stay on-task decreased.
Understandably, he did not think it was fair because he had worked diligently to follow my
instructions. Based on my understanding of this student and his responses on a survey, I found
When I began implementing the third strategy, PGD (Positive Greetings at the Door), I
surveyed students to understand their insights. Students were asked, “Is there anything in the
classroom that makes it difficult to do your morning work and talk quietly to your friends?”
Shown in Appendix I, R.C. responded, “Once I am finished with the questions I am bored and
want to play.” I often observed this student listening to what he was told when the expectations
were clearly outlined and he was occupied with a task. However, on multiple occasions, I saw
him being very disruptive after he finished his morning work. In order to accommodate his
needs, I let him draw once he was finished. This is simply another example of the
Artifact V: Conclusion
This inquiry of discovering engaging ways to support students’ in staying on-task has
taught me a great deal about myself as an educator. Implementing these strategies showed me
that misbehaviors are often a result of a child’s needs not being met by the teacher. For
example, engagement, choice, and positive reinforcement are things my students needed that
were easily incorporated into daily teaching. Prior to implementing the strategies, I became
frustrated with having to constantly redirect students’ behavior. However, once I started using
engaging strategies to proactively support my students’ needs, I found myself praising more
positive behavior, rather than redirecting misbehaviors. Nagro et al. (2019) points to the
16
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
positive outcomes of proactive strategies by stating, “In addition to sustaining student
engagement during instruction, embedding research-based proactive strategies can increase the
quality of instructional time by promoting active rather than passive learning” (p. 138). It was
often my lack of responsiveness to students’ needs that caused misbehavior. This inquiry taught
This inquiry taught me so much about my students as well. Each strategy focused on
proactively supporting students need in order to decrease the likelihood of off-task behavior. I
learned that students are more likely to be on-task when there are rewards, rather than being
reminded to be on-task when there are misbehaviors. For example, Appendix A shows how I
observed students gently reminding each other to stay on-task when I was putting marbles in
their cups. If I had pointed out one students’ negative behavior, I wouldn’t have been able to
support so many students in staying on-task. This piece of data points to the effectiveness of
well. When students had a voice, they were more likely to participate. Like one student who
was so anxious to share, they asked if they could answer both questions, which increased their
engagement and positive behavior (Appendix F). These proactive strategies elicited excitement
from students that I had not observed prior to their implementation. Reflecting upon my
students’ behavior throughout this process showed me how much it positively impacted their
engagement.
own actions before placing responsibility on the student. The classroom management strategies
behaviors to arise. Once I began reflecting upon what was causing off-task behavior and
17
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
adjusted classroom procedures, I saw a drastic change in my students’ motivation to remain on-
task. I plan to regularly reflect upon what my students’ behaviors are telling me about what
As a result of this inquiry, I have formed a new wondering: In what ways can I provide
implemented were intended to reach each and every student, I realized that some students
require more individualized attention. Strout (2005) points to this idea when discussing positive
behavioral supports by stating, “However, every classroom includes students who are diverse
and have different needs” (p. 3). Students like B.L. and B.S. typically responded well to the
strategies I implemented. However, unlike other students, they struggled to push past
momentary disappointment when things did not go as planned. For students like these, I would
be interested in seeing how individual rewards, rather than group rewards, might benefit their
motivation to display positive behavior. As I move into my own teaching practice, I am excited
to discover how different students respond to group and individual rewards to promote positive
behaviors.
References
Cook, C. R., Fiat, A., Larson, M., Daikos, C., Slemrod, T., Holland, E. A., Thayer, A. J., &
Lane, K.L., Royer, D.J., Messenger, M.L., Common, E.A., Ennis, R.P., & Swogger, E.D.
18
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
(2015). Empowering Teachers with Low-Intensity Strategies to Support Academic
Nagro, S. A., Fraser, D. W., & Hooks, S. D. (2019). Lesson Planning With Engagement in
Postholm, M. B. (2013). Classroom Management: What Does Research Tell Us? European
Strout, M. (2005). Positive Behavioral Support at the Classroom Level: Considerations and
Appendix B
Appendix C
20
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
Appendix E
21
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
Appendix F
Appendix G
22
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
Appendix H
Appendix I
23
EFFECTIVE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
Appendix J