Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Substance Abuse and Dependence
Substance Abuse and Dependence
Adolescents who abuse or are dependent on alcohol often have coexisting mental disorders.
These disorders may both precipitate alcohol use disorders and result from them. In addition,
both types of disorders may arise independently in adolescents at high risk. Mental disorders
that commonly co-occur with alcohol use disorders in adolescents include antisocial
disorders, mood disorders, and anxiety disorders. Treatment programs for adolescents with
alcohol use disorders should seek not only to eliminate alcohol and other drug use but also to
improve the symptoms of other mental disorders. KEY WORDS: antisocial personality disorder;
emotional and psychiatric depression; AODD (alcohol and other drug use disorder); affective
psychosis; comorbidity; dual diagnosis; adolescent; psychiatric care; addiction care; patient
assessment; treatment method; literature review
A
dolescents with alcohol use disorder characterized by aggression, Theories that attempt to explain
disorders (AUDs) (e.g., alcohol destruction of property, deceitfulness the development of AUDs in adoles-
abuse or dependence1) have or theft, and the violation of rules), cents have typically proposed that the
high rates of coexisting (i.e., comor- major depressive disorder (i.e., a nega- presence of psychopathology increases
bid) psychopathology (i.e., mental tive-affect disorder characterized by the adolescent’s risk of developing an
disorders other than alcohol and other severe bouts of depression), or both AUD by either precipitating the onset
drug use disorders). Common comorbid (Clark et al. 1997). Understanding of an AUD in vulnerable people or
psychopathologies include those that the effects of comorbid psychopathol- exacerbating mild alcohol problems
interfere with social functioning (e.g., ogy on the development and course (Zucker 1987). Conversely, AUDs
antisocial disorders) and disorders of AUDs may enhance preventive and may influence the development of
that cause severe depression or increase treatment interventions for adolescents psychopathology through similar
anxiety (i.e., negative-affect disorders) with AUDs.
(Bukstein et al. 1989; Clark and The development of an AUD in DUNCAN B. CLARK, M.D., PH.D., is
Neighbors 1996). One study found adolescence may be an important an associate professor of psychiatry at
that more than 80 percent of adoles- indicator of other problems. Clark the University of Pittsburgh School of
cents who were dependent on or and colleagues (1998c) found that Medicine and scientific director of the
abused alcohol also had some other compared with men who developed Pittsburgh Adolescent Alcohol Research
form of psychopathology (Rohde et substance use disorders (SUDs) (i.e., Center (PAARC), and Oscar G.
al. 1996). Among a group of alcohol- alcohol and other drug use disorders) Bukstein, M.D., M.P.H., is an
dependent adolescents participating as adults, adolescent males with SUDs associate professor of psychiatry at the
in treatment, 89 percent also had and male adults who developed SUDs University of Pittsburgh School of
conduct disorder (i.e., an antisocial as adolescents had higher rates of dis- Medicine and clinical director of
1
ruptive behavior disorders and major PAARC, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Alcohol abuse and alcohol dependence are condi- depression as well as more rapid pro-
tions defined by specific criteria in the American
Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical gression from first use to substance Support for this work was provided by
Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition. dependence. NIAAA grant P50–AA–08746.
managing problems such as ADHD BROWN, S.A.; GLEGHORN, A.; SCHUCKIT, M.A.; model. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
MYERS, M.G.; AND MOTT, M.A. Conduct disorder 65(1):130–140, 1997.
and major depression. In adolescents among adolescent alcohol and drug abusers. Journal
with AUDs complicated by other disor- of Studies on Alcohol 57(3):314–324, 1996. DEYKIN, E.Y., AND BUKA, S.L. Prevalence and risk
ders, interventions of greater intensity factors for posttraumatic stress disorder among
BUKSTEIN, O.G. Adolescent Substance Abuse: chemically dependent adolescents. American
and duration are probably needed. Assessment, Prevention, and Treatment. New York: Journal of Psychiatry 154(6):752–757, 1997.
Whether coexisting problems are John Wiley and Sons, 1995.
DEYKIN, E.Y.; BUKA, S.L.; AND ZEENA, T.H.
addressed concurrently or consecutively, Depressive illness among chemically dependent
BUKSTEIN, O.G.; BRENT, D.A.; AND KAMINER, Y.
treatment for adolescents with both Comorbidity of substance abuse and other psychi- adolescents. American Journal of Psychiatry 149(10):
AUDs and comorbid mental disorders atric disorders in adolescents. American Journal of 1341–1347, 1992.
requires more time and resources than Psychiatry 146(9):1131–1141, 1989.
DONOVAN, J.E., AND JESSOR, R. Structure of
treatment for adolescents with a single BUKSTEIN, O.G.; GLANCY, L.J.; AND KAMINER, Y. problem behavior in adolescence and young adult-
disorder. Comprehensive approaches, Patterns of affective comorbidity in a clinical pop- hood. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
such as MST (Henggeler et al. 1998), ulation of dually diagnosed adolescent substance 53(6):890–904, 1985.
may hold the most promise for ado- abusers. Journal of the American Academy of Child EMSLIE, G.J.; RUSH, A.J.; WEINBERG, W.A.;
and Adolescent Psychiatry 31:1041–1045, 1992.
lescents with comorbidity. KOWATCH, R.A.; HUGHES, C.W.; CARMODY, T.;
CLARK, D.B., AND MILLER, T.W. Stress adapta- AND RINTELMANN, J. A double-blind, randomized,
tion in children: Theoretical models. In: Miller, placebo-controlled trial of fluoxetine in children
T.W., ed., Stressful Life Events: Children and and adolescents with depression. Archives of
Conclusion Trauma. Madison, CT: International Universities General Psychiatry 54(11):1031–1037, 1997.
Press, 1998. pp. 3–27. HENGGELER, S.W.; PICKREL, S.G.; BRONDINO,
Adolescent alcohol use may or may
CLARK, D.B., AND NEIGHBORS, B. Adolescent M.J.; AND CROUCH, J.L. Eliminating (almost)
not lead to alcohol abuse or depen- treatment dropout of substance abusing or
substance abuse and internalizing disorders. Child
dence, depending on the influence of and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics of North America dependent delinquents through home-based
multiple and complex factors (Tarter 5(1):45–57, 1996. multisystemic therapy. American Journal of
and Vanyukov 1994). Mental disor- Psychiatry 153(3):427–428, 1996.
CLARK, D.B.; BUKSTEIN, O.G.; SMITH, M.G.;
ders may both precipitate and result KACZYNSKI, N.A.; MEZZICH, A.C.; AND DONOVAN, HENGGELER, S.W.; SCHOENWALD, S.K.; BORDUIN,
from AUDs. In addition, both types J.E. Identifying anxiety disorders in adolescents
C.M.; ROWLAND, M.D.; AND CUNNINGHAM,
of disorders may arise independently P.E. Multisystemic Treatment of Antisocial Behavior
hospitalized for alcohol abuse or dependence.
in Children and Adolescents. New York, NY:
in adolescents at high risk. The multi- Psychiatric Services 46(6):618–620, 1995.
Guilford, 1998.
faceted relationships among comorbid CLARK, D.B.; POLLOCK, N.; BROMBERGER, J.T.;
KLEIN, R.G.; ABIKOFF, H.; KLASS, E.; GANELES,
mental disorders and AUDs in adoles- BUKSTEIN, O.G.; MEZZICH, A.C.; BROMBERGER,
D.; SEESE, L.M.; AND POLLACK, S. Clinical efficacy
cents are not yet fully understood. J.T.; AND DONOVAN, J.E. Gender and comorbid
of methylphenidate in conduct disorder with and
psychopathology in adolescents with alcohol depen-
Individual psychological characteristics dence. Journal of the American Academy of Child
without attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.
interact with and are influenced by Archives of General Psychiatry 54:1073–1080, 1997.
and Adolescent Psychiatry 36(9):1195–1203, 1997.
developmental stage, gender, family LEWIS, C.E., AND BUCHOLZ, K.K. Alcoholism,
CLARK, D.B.; BAILEY, S.L.; AND LYNCH, K.G.
characteristics, and preventive as well The effects of childhood abuse on adolescents with
antisocial behavior and family history. British
as treatment interventions. Treatment Journal of Addictions 86(2):177–194, 1991.
alcohol use disorders.(Abstract). Alcoholism: Clinical
programs designed for adolescents and Experimental Research 22:72A, 1998a. LOEBER, R.; KEENAN, K.; LAHEY, B.B.; GREEN,
with AUDs should seek not only to CLARK, D.B.; KIRISCI, L.; AND MOSS, H.B. Early
S.M.; AND THOMAS, C. Evidence for develop-
mentally based diagnoses of oppositional defiant
eliminate alcohol and other drug use adolescent gateway drug use in sons of fathers disorder and conduct disorder. Journal of
but also to improve the symptoms of with substance use disorders. Addictive Behaviors Abnormal Child Psychology 21:377–410, 1993.
other mental disorders by addressing 23(4):561–566, 1998b.
LYNSKEY, M.T., AND FERGUSSON, D.M. Childhood
family relationship difficulties and CLARK, D.B.; KIRISCI, L.; AND TARTER, R.E. conduct problems, attention deficit behaviors, and
reversing the adverse effects of alcohol Adolescent versus adult onset and the development adolescent alcohol, tobacco, and illicit drug use.
use on psychosocial functioning. ■ of substance use disorders in males. Drug and Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology 23(3): 281–302,
Alcohol Dependence 49(2):115–121, 1998c. 1995.
CLARK, D.B.; NEIGHBORS, B.D.; LESNICK, L.A.; MARTIN, C.S., AND BATES, M.E. Psychological
References AND DONOVAN, J.E. Family functioning and ado- and psychiatric consequences of alcohol. In: Tarter,
lescent alcohol use disorders. Journal of Family R.E.; Ott, P.J; and Ammerman, R.T., eds., Handbook
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Psychology 12(1):81–92, 1998d. of Substance Abuse: Neurobehavioral Pharmacology.
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth New York: Plenum Press, 1998. pp. 33–50.
Edition. Washington, DC: the Association, 1994. CORNELIUS, J.R.; SALLOUM, I.M.; EHLER, J.G.;
JARRETT, P.J.; CORNELIUS, M.D.; PEREL, J.M.; THASE, MYERS, M.G.; BROWN, S.A.; AND MOTT, M.A.
BROWN, S.A., AND SCHUCKIT, M.A. Changes in M.E.; AND BLACK, A.E. Fluoxetine in depressed Preadolescent conduct disorder behaviors predict
depression among abstinent male alcoholics. alcoholics: A double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. relapse and progression of addiction for adolescent
Journal of Studies on Alcohol 49(5):412–417, 1988. Archives of General Psychiatry 54:700–705, 1997. alcohol and drug abusers. Alcoholism: Clinical and
Experimental Research 19(6):1528–1536, 1995.
BROWN, S.A.; IRWIN, M.; AND SCHUCKIT, M.A. CURRAN, P.J.; STICE, E.; AND CHASSIN, L. The
Changes in anxiety among abstinent male alcoholics. relation between adolescent alcohol use and peer REIFMAN, A.; BARNES, G.M.; DINTCHEFF, B.A.;
Journal of Studies on Alcohol 52(1):55–61, 1991. alcohol use: A longitudinal random coefficients FARRELL, M.P.; AND UHTEG, L. Parental and peer