Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sophie Young Case Study 1
Sophie Young Case Study 1
Sophie Young Case Study 1
Client History
Bob struggles with frequent anxiety attacks and depression. He has a positive relationship
with his mother but does not visit or communicate with his father or two brothers. He was shy in
high school and became a “follower” in college by partying with large groups of people. He has
difficulty keeping a job, is currently unemployed, and lives with his girlfriend despite their
frequent communication issues. Bob stated that he has come to therapy as a last resort.
Presenting concerns
Bob’s presenting concerns are recurrent anxiety attacks that he claims are due to a single
use of LSD in college. He reports often feeling sad or angry, though he does not recognize a
current issue that would have instigated these emotions. He states that he hates his father, was
bullied by his brothers as a child, and in college was pressured by them to do well academically.
Bob is currently unemployed and claims to be too weary to find work. Additionally, he disclosed
his unhealthy communication cycle between him and his cohabitating girlfriend.
It appears that Bob lacks congruence between his self-concept and ideal self (Murdock,
2017). His unemployment and relationship complications likely contribute to the negative
feelings he possesses about himself. These issues are hindering Bob from his self-actualizing
tendency, an innate desire that all humans have (Murdock, 2017). Bob is having trouble
1
distinguishing between events that help or hinder this growth. By experiencing more accurately,
Bob could begin to lean towards self-actualization (Murdock, 2017). Genetically, Bob has the
potential for success, as seen by his successful brothers and father. Bob’s self-concept can be
inherent potential. One study by Farber and Doolin (2011) found that positive regard has a
moderate association with therapy outcomes and can have many benefits for the client, such as
strengthening their ego, involving them in an effective relationship, and empowering the client
towards their innate tendency to grow. A non-conditional, accepting self-concept will help give
In the first two sessions, the counselor-client relationship was established through
empathetic listening, unconditional positive regard, and treating Bob as an equal. The therapeutic
relationship was established immediately because it is one of the most necessary and sufficient
aspects of counseling (Murdock, 2017). After gaining Bob’s trust, the following sessions focused
on determining how his self-concept is similar to or different from his ideal self. When Bob
discussed his frustration with anxiety and depression, he was empathetically told “it sounds like
you are dealing with a lot of painful emotions. It takes a lot of strength to come and work on
those”. A 2011 study by Elliot, Bohart, Watson, and Greenberg indicated that therapy outcomes
have a moderately strong association with counselor empathy. They also note that it is
imperative for therapists to accurately understand and respond to what the client is saying for
empathy to be perceived well. When Bob discussed his relationships with his brothers and father,
he was told “I’m hearing you say that you don’t think you will ever be as successful as them.”
2
This nondirective statement allowed Bob to disclose his belief that a stable job and a high
Bob currently has an external locus of evaluation about his present circumstances,
making him feel unsure of how to help himself (Murdock, 2017). He mentioned that he values a
career and that “working gives people purpose”. We discussed his undergraduate grades and how
he could be seen as a desirable employee in the chemistry field. After helping Bob realize this,
his self-talk became less defensive and more accepting. He said, “I want to apply for a chemical
analyst job, and I think I might have a good shot at it.” This sense of hope was unlike his usual
self-deprecating responses. We are currently on our fifth weekly session out of the ten that are
anticipated. In the following sessions, it is expected that Bob will continue to see his potential
towards living the life he wants. He will continue reporting one accomplishment that he is proud
Counseling goals
Bob’s short term goals are to shift his self-talk to a more positive tone. It is probable that
this will alleviate many of his anxious and depressive symptoms. Bob has been encouraged to
apply for the chemical analyst position and to updated me on his progress. If he were to obtain
this job, he would likely be more willing to speak with his father and brothers due to his
perceived success. Bob’s long term goals are to see himself as a person who is capable of
reaching his full potential (i.e. fulfilling career, relationship, and mental health goals). As Bob’s
time in therapy concludes, he will be empowered to use his gained insight to make intuitive
3
Anticipated outcomes of counseling
By holding a positive self-concept that aligns with his ideal self, Bob will experience less
incongruence (namely, anxiety and depression) and will feel motivated to continue the work he
has done in counseling. Bob’s gained independence and intuition will help him to distinguish
what life events are helpful and harmful regarding his self-growth (Murdock, 2017). Obtaining
the chemical analyst job will boost Bob’s confidence and inspire him to seek growth in other
areas of life, such as in his romantic and familial relationships. Because of his dedication to our
sessions, Bob has the ability to continue transitioning from a dysfunctional, incongruent state to
one of healthy congruence, which is the ultimate goal of our time together (Murdock, 2017).
4
References
Elliot, R., Bohart, A. C., Watson, J. C., & Greenberg, L. S. (2011). Empathy. Psychotherapy,
Farber, B. A., & Doolin, E. M. (2011). Positive regard. Psychotherapy, 48(1), 58-64.
https://doi:10.1037/a0022141
Murdock, N. L. (2017). Theories of counseling and psychotherapy: A case approach (4). Boston:
Pearson.