This document discusses the advantages and disadvantages of employing different types of expatriates and local nationals to manage overseas subsidiaries. It analyzes factors such as cultural distance, communication ability, training costs, and enhancing the local company image. The document recommends employing Americans to manage the US subsidiary and Swedes to manage the Swedish one due to the cultural similarities which help overcome issues with cultural differences, communication challenges, and high training costs associated with expatriates from more culturally distant locations like Hong Kong.
This document discusses the advantages and disadvantages of employing different types of expatriates and local nationals to manage overseas subsidiaries. It analyzes factors such as cultural distance, communication ability, training costs, and enhancing the local company image. The document recommends employing Americans to manage the US subsidiary and Swedes to manage the Swedish one due to the cultural similarities which help overcome issues with cultural differences, communication challenges, and high training costs associated with expatriates from more culturally distant locations like Hong Kong.
This document discusses the advantages and disadvantages of employing different types of expatriates and local nationals to manage overseas subsidiaries. It analyzes factors such as cultural distance, communication ability, training costs, and enhancing the local company image. The document recommends employing Americans to manage the US subsidiary and Swedes to manage the Swedish one due to the cultural similarities which help overcome issues with cultural differences, communication challenges, and high training costs associated with expatriates from more culturally distant locations like Hong Kong.
Familiar home office operations ;Same language and culture (Home) Different local Compensation and recruiting costs positions ;Company foreign image emphasise Communication with host country ;language and culture Host country nationals Low recruiting/compensation costs ;Enhance company local image Same communications (Host) High training costs ;Limited understanding (Home) Different culture and language (Home) Third country nationals Best person from global search ;True international image High recruiting/training/compensation cost ;Limited understanding(Home) Company foreign image emphasise ;Communication with host country Different culture and language (Home) ;Different local language and culture
Local residents of USA and Sweden:
Direct/open;communication;Involve in decision making;Success-oriented; Accomplishment over personal relationship;Low recruitment cost Enhanced company's local image Ease of communication Problem:High training cost , Different culture/language
Expatriate employees from Hong Kong:
Required:Global leadership competencies ; Adaptability to new culture Language capabilityBenefits:Familiar with company's culture ; Ease of communication with headquarter ;Bring back new (good) changes to headquarterProblem:Expensive ;Different culture/working style
The greater the cultural distance, the greater the
difficulties experienced by expatriates (Hofstede, 2001). Interpersonal friction due to poor intercultural communication(Arman & Aycan,2013)
Collectivism, long-term oriented, loyal to pragmatism and compliance with norms, restraint of self-expression and are accustomed to social constraints,
Most Chinese companies follow paternalistic
management(Amel Zabihi,2013) n the choice of nationality, the nationality of the senior managers of new york subsidiary is American natives. Hofstede pointed out that the greater the cultural distance, the greater the influence on expatriates. Hong Kong is far away from North America, and cultural conflicts are far more difficult than work. We can see that the six dimensions in the figure clearly show the great differences between the two regions' cultures. Hong Kong is collectivist, long-term-oriented, loyal to pragmatism and abiding by norms. Higher authorities are not good at communicating with subordinates, self-expression is poor, and they are used to social constraints. On the contrary, Americans pursue equal rights and freedom, and extreme individualism makes Americans dare to take risks and make enterprises innovate and progress continuously. Armand Aycan also pointed out that poor cross-cultural communication will lead to interpersonal friction, which will reduce work efficiency and be detrimental to company management. Therefore, it is a good choice to let Americans manage Americans. At the same time, in the Swedish office, we still choose to let the local Swedish people manage the subsidiary. Through Hofstede's dimensional analysis, Sweden is a female society that advocates freedom, individualism, equal rights and can balance work and rest time. Don't blindly pursue money and success, what matters is spiritual enjoyment. Tixier also suggested that Swedes should encourage innovation and new ideas. However, most Chinese companies are paternalistic, and their employees' autonomy is low. Therefore, it is more appropriate to let the local Swedish people manage the subsidiaries. Although recruiting host nationals will have difficulties in communicating with the headquarters, as well as different cultures. However, it has many advantages, such as having the same culture as local employees, being able to communicate directly, reducing salary costs, and enhancing the company's local image and innovation ability.