Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Quest For Legitimacy in Modern Druidic Divination Practices
The Quest For Legitimacy in Modern Druidic Divination Practices
The Quest For Legitimacy in Modern Druidic Divination Practices
Noah Depner
This is the case with Neo-Shamanism, Wicca and especially Druidry; roots to ancient Celtic
religions are a fundamental selling point for the efficacy of their practices. One would logically
turn towards primary source material to establish these roots, but when surviving primary texts
about the Druids only add up to “ten pages or so,” is it even possible to build an entire religious
movement on them?1 Gaps in knowledge, beliefs and traditions need to be filled somehow, and
in the case of the modern Druid Revival, eclectic belief systems and writers with claims to
ancient Celtic ancestry have attempted to fill in the missing pieces. The modern practice of
Ogham divination is key example of this phenomenon, and Druidic discourse around its use
highlights the way practitioners respond to the unsettling discrepancy between modern
legitimacy and ancient roots. Responses include both ignorance and the implementation of
strict boundaries, but of even greater interest are the groups that embrace their eclectic
practices and establish an internal validity that does not rely on ancient Celtic authenticity.
Historical knowledge about the Ogham is sparse, and the information available is
interpretations of the alphabet. The Ogham is a collection of twenty symbols and is the earliest
known system of writing used by the Irish.2 It first appeared in the 5th century, and while early
work assigned its origin to Germanic runes or Greek alphabets, the modern consensus has
1
John Michael Greer, “What is the Druid Revival?” accessed April 8, 2021, http://aoda.org/publications/articles-on-
druidry/druidrevival/
2
An additional five characters, the Forfeda, were added at a much later date, likely to accommodate more letters
from the Latin alphabet. See Damien McManus, “Ogham,” in The World’s Writing Systems, ed. Peter T. Daniels and
William Bright (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996): 340
settled on a Latin origin.3 The oldest appearance of the symbols is in funerary inscriptions, but
information about their meanings was later written down by poets in various manuscripts. Each
symbol is connected to an acrostic letter-name and each name to a two-word kenning. Most
letters have three distinct kennings stemming from three independent lists, commonly referred
to as “Briatharogaim.”4 These kennings give particular meanings to each letter, with eight of
them explicitly relating to trees.5 Medieval Irish glossators later developed a tradition of
assigning all of the letters to different trees; a tradition that remains dominant today even with
little evidence to support it.6 Gaelic poets created other lists, linking the Ogham to bird species
or colours.7 The most authentic meanings are contained in the aforementioned kennings, while
these variants can be attributed to later medieval scholarship or use as poetic devices.
According to McManus, “no other aspect…has contributed more to the derailment of a serious
study of the history of [Ogham]” than viewing “all the Irish letter-names as names of trees.” 8
However, the connection of all Ogham symbols to distinct trees is a fundamental aspect of the
modern practice of Ogham divination, placing the practice in conflict with historical evidence.
The use of Ogham as a divinatory tool does have some historical basis, appearing in an
old Irish tale, “The Wooing of Etain.” The tale is set in approximately 100 BCE, describing the
“courtship” of the maiden Etain by the fairy Midir. Her husband, Eochaid, the king of Ireland,
3
The timeframe lines up with the arrival of Latin peoples in the British Isles, and the occurrence of 5 vowels in each
script matches the Latin script. Some scholars assert it was developed as a form of cryptography. See McManus,
“Ogham,” 340, 342.
4
Damien McManus, “Irish Letter-Names and Their Kennings,” Eriu 29 (1988): 130.
5
McManus, “Letter-Names,” 137, 150-166. An example is the letter B, Beithe, connected to “withered foot with
fine hair,” “greyest of skin,” and “beauty of the eyebrow,” with the first two describing unique features of the birch
tree. F, S, D, C, O, E and I are all originally in reference to trees as well. The other letters, such as T or G, are
connected to other nouns, specifically “Iron Bar” and “Field” in this case.
6
McManus, “Letter-Names”, 129
7
Damien McManus, A Guide to Ogam, (An Sagart, 1991), 139
8
McManus, “Letter-Names”, 129
searches desperately for her, although the method of searching varies depending on the source
used. The older 12th century “Leabhar na h-Uidre” manuscript concludes the tale with the
rampant destruction of all fairy mounds in the search for Etain, while the 16 th century “Egerton
1782” manuscript concludes with the king’s consultation of the Druid Dalan. 9 Tasked to find the
location of Etain, Dalan “made three wands of yew; and upon the wands he wrote an ogham;
and by the keys of wisdom that he had, and by the ogham, it was revealed to him the Etain was
in the fairy mound of Bri Leith.”10 No other details of the practice are given. Other, less
complete versions of the tale exist as well, but only the most recent “Egerton 1782” manuscript
contains a reference to this practice. There is an obvious discrepancy with the 100 BCE setting
as well given that Ogham originated in the 5th century CE. While this is the only historical
additional link to the practice. In Germania (98 CE), Roman historian Tacitus describes a
divination ritual practiced by the Germanic people: “They cut off a branch from a nut-bearing
tree and slice it into strips, these they mark with different signs and throw them at random
onto a white cloth. Then, the state’s priest…offers a prayer to the gods and looking up towards
heaven, picks up three strips, one at a time, and, according to which sign they have been
previously marked with, makes his interpretation.” 11 The identity of the signs is unknown, be it
runes or something else entirely, but the practice described here bears a strong resemblance to
modern Ogham divination rituals. The Celts of the British Isles shared strong connections with
9
Of note, the text states “king Eochaid sent for his Druid,” implying that Druids were integrated in the political
system of the King at the time. See Arthur Herbert Leahy, Heroic Romances of Ireland, Translated into English
Prose and Verse – Volume 1 (Illinois: Project Gutenberg, 2004), The Courtship of Etain,
http://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/5678/pg5678.html.
10
Leahy, Heroic Romances, The Courtship of Etain
11
Tacitus, Agricola and Germany, trans. Anthony Birley (Oxford University Press, 1999), 42
the Germanic peoples of mainland Europe, so there is a distinct possibility the practice
described by Dalan is connected to the one described here; the use of three sticks is a strong
link supporting this. However, one cannot discount the possibility that the modern Druidic ties
cultural pluralism.
The modern practice of Ogham divination has been expanded beyond its historical
roots, often incorporating other neopagan elements. Similar to the historical accounts of Dalan
and Tacitus, these symbols are often carved on small tree branches. As modern practitioners
use systems that assign each symbol to a distinct tree, it is recommended that one obtains
wood from the tree itself to maximise connection. Emphasis is placed on “interacting with the
spirits of the trees,” which includes meditation in their presence, asking for their blessing and
leaving offerings.12 Some also encourage learning about the folklore and science behind a
relationship with each tree is a fundamental part of the practice, an element which sets it apart
from similar divinatory practices. The actual ritual is often framed in seeking help from the
Ogham sprits or ancestral wisdom from the ancient Druids.14 Practitioners can pull a single
stave, three staves, five staves to create a Celtic Cross or scatter the staves on a surface. The
three-stave approach is the most common, but meanings of the three positions vary
considerably. Past, present and future is a simple approach that is built on three-rayed Celtic
“Awen,” but more nature-based meanings are common as well, such as land, sea and sky, or
12
Danu Forest, Celtic Tree Magic: Ogham Lore and Druid Mysteries (Llewellyn Worldwide, 2014), Ogham Stave and
Wands, Ogham Divination
13
Raven nic Rhóisín and Kathryn Price NicDhàna, “Tree Huggers: A Methodology for Crann Ogham Work,”
accessed April 6, 2021, http://www.paganachd.com/articles/treehuggers.html
14
Forest, Tree Magic, Ogham Divination
the lower, middle and upper worlds.15 The Celtic Cross includes another two positions
representing masculine and feminine traits, while the scatter method involves the proximity of
staves to oneself as an indicator of past, present and future, as well as connections between
overlapping staves.16 Each letter has meanings beyond the tree it is assigned to, but a
practitioner’s understanding of these meanings in a divinatory context vary widely based on the
literature they use and personal experiences in their tree explorations. Tarot influences are
clear in the spreads, mainly the use of “past, present and future” as well as the modified Celtic
Cross. In the YouTube community, eclectic practices are extremely common, with practitioners
using Ogham in conjunction with tarot, I-Ching and pendulums. Even with its high variability in
practice, the underlying appeal of Ogham lies in its supposed roots to ancient knowledge. The
practitioners, foundational elements behind the meanings of many symbols are not as ancient
the modern Druid revival movement. In his 1937 book, Ogham scholar R.A.S Macalister makes
the claim that Ogham comes from “an early form of the Greek alphabet…borrowed by the
Druids in Southern Gaul for the purpose of writing sometime in the 5th century BC.”17 Distinct
ties to antiquity are established here, but connections with divination are established by the
poet Robert Graves in The White Goddess. By analyzing ancient poetry from a myriad of
different cultures, Graves asserts that much of it implies the existence of a central White
15
Forest, Tree Magic, Ogham Divination; Carrowcrory Journal, “Ogham, The Divination Story,” YouTube, streamed
Nov 19, 2020, 35:00 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AM7HaLQclXU
16
Forest, Tree Magic, Ogham Divination; Purple Bloom Apothecary Presents, “Ogham rune sticks for beginning
divination,” YouTube, posted October 10, 2013, 3:45, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VSVAYrWMro
17
R.A. Stewart Macalister, The Secret Languages of Ireland (Cambridge University Press, 2014), 28.
Goddess worshiped by all of them. This same logic is applied to the Ogham. Graves, using an
containing 13 consonants and 5 vowels, creates the Celtic Tree Calendar. 18 In this, he claims
that each consonant is linked to a tree, zodiac and specific lunar month, while the vowels
represent seasons as well as the “trees particularly sacred to the White Goddess.” 19 The
merging of letters and trees is not a new concept, but in his description of each letter Graves
weaves in ideas from Assyrian sculptures, Greek mystery cults, Shakespearean poetry and a
variety of other cultures.20 The supposed authenticity of Graves’ calendar does not solely rest
on its links to ancient Druidic astrology, but instead to syncretic links between a myriad of
world religions. Graves does not lay out specific divination practices, but his ideas are the
foundation for many interpretations of the meaning behind the symbols. A popular Ogham
deck, the Celtic Tree Oracle, claims to be “based on ancient Celtic wisdom” but is largely rooted
in Graves’ Celtic Tree Calendar.21 In reality, Graves’ theories are based off of a flawed alphabet
and run counter to solid evidence for Vedic forms of Celtic astrology, yet they continue to
garner a high amount of respect. Graves is not the only example of a preference for poets over
The complex history and fragmentation of the Druid revival has resulted in a wide range
of responses to this conflict between Celtic authenticity and modern practice. The Druid revival
has its roots in 18th century Romanticism, largely as a response to rapid industrialization. Early
18
Peter B. Ellis, “The Fabrication of ‘Celtic’ Astrology,” accessed April 4, 2021, http://cura.free.fr/xv/13ellis2.html
19
Robert Graves, The White Goddess: a Historical Grammar of Poetic Myth (London: Faber & Faber, 1961), 166,
189.
20
Graves, The White Goddess, 194-195.
21
“Celtic Tree Oracle,” Tarot Totes, accessed April 3, 2021, https://www.tarottotes.com/item.asp?iid=2797;
Gefensdottir, “Deck Review: Celtic Tree Oracle by Sharlyn Hidalgo and Jimmy Manton,” Adventures in Vanaheim,
WordPress, published June 11, 2017, https://adventuresinvanaheim.wordpress.com/2017/06/11/deck-review-
celtic-tree-oracle-by-sharlyn-hidalgo-and-jimmy-manton/
organizations, such as the Ancient Order of Druids (1781), were based in freemason beliefs,
acting primarily as a social club for those holding Romantic ideals.22 Iolo Morganwg (1747-
1826), a Welsh poet with fictitious claims to ancestral Druidic knowledge, took the movement
in a more religious, ordered direction.23 The latter half of the 20th century was characterized by
reverence for nature and ancestry is a broad link between organizations, but the emphasis on
the individual’s journey and practice allows for members to tie in a myriad of other belief
systems.24 Emic definitions of a Druid vary too; some organizations consider every member a
Druid while other groups require “years of study and practice” before the application of this
label.25 Given this wide diversity in beliefs and structures, every practitioner will have their own
response to internal contradictions. These responses, however, can be broadly divided into
three categories. A lack of knowledge is one ‘approach’ that is common among individual
practitioners. Some neo-Druidic literature asserts the Celtic authenticity of a particular practice
with flawed or non-existent evidence. One author, Danu Forest, discusses the uses of the
Ogham tree alphabet in divination, ironically citing a book from Ogham scholar Damien
McManus that explicitly discounts the historical authenticity of this idea. 26 The second approach
is one taken by the Celtic Reconstructionist movement; the removal of neopagan practices and
Reconstructionism].”27 In relation to Ogham, the movement states the Robert Graves’ Celtic
Tree Calendar has “nothing to do with any of the early Celtic peoples,” instead encouraging an
approach to Ogham grounded in historical documents, folklore and scientific knowledge. 28 The
legitimacy of their practice is rooted in its authenticity, forcing them to establish strict
boundaries. The third approach is based on the idea that historical authenticity is not a
requirement for the validity of modern Druidic beliefs and practices; ancient and modern
practices are fundamentally different. This is the approach taken by many modern Druid groups
and is best explored in the large body of academic work written by members of the Ancient
The AODA was originally founded in 1912 as a primarily Masonic organization; the
Ancient Order of Masonic Druids in America (AMODA). 29 The organization was largely dormant
until 2003, when scholar John Michael Greer resurrected it.30 He served as the Grand Archdruid
until 2015, contributing enormous amounts of literature to the field of modern Druidry in that
time. Greer is a particularly interesting figure in his blunt honesty and unique perspective in
dealing with contradictions between ancient and modern practice. In an interview, he admits
27
“Does CR include syncretisms?” The CR FAQ, accessed March 29, 2021,
http://paganachd.com/faq/intermediate.html#syncretisms
28
“Do you use the Celtic Tree Calendar and Celtic Astrology?” The CR FAQ, accessed March 29, 2021,
http://paganachd.com/faq/misconceptions.html#treecalendar; Rhóisín and NicDhàna, “Tree Huggers”; The
divination outlined on this page still falls into the trap of assigning each letter to a tree, but does acknowledge the
wide range of associations each letter has, encouraging readers to conduct rigorous research and find one they
connect to.
29
Betty J.M. Reeves, “History and Heritage of the AODA,” Ancient Order of Druids in America, accessed April 2,
2021, https://aoda.org/history-heritage-of-the-aoda/
30
Dana O’Driscoll, “Letter from the New Grand Archdruid: Into the Future of AODA,” Trilithon 6 (2019): 4,
http://aoda.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/TrilithonVolIV2019_Web.pdf
“quiet deletions” and “a lot of mosaic work” was done in his resurrection of the organization. 31
The Masonic history of the AODA is acknowledged as well, but Greer believes “the AODO isn’t a
neopagan order.”32 Conversely, Greer states that AODO members “don’t pretend to be ancient
Druids”; he even explicitly denounces Druids claiming to hail from a continuous tradition. 33
Instead, Greer assert that the AODA is rooted in the Druid Revival, and more importantly, that
the Revival is both valid and distinct from ancient practice. A distinction between the “content
of a spiritual tradition” and “its pedigree” is drawn; the former does not rely on the latter to be
recognized as a valid tradition.34 The modern movement of nature spiritualty already has “three
centuries of…teaching and practices,” and if these practices have relevance and effectiveness
today, links to ancient Druids are not necessary.35 Greer still maintains some connection to the
ancient Celts, stating “the themes of modern tradition have roots in the past,” but places clear
boundaries between modern and ancient practices.36 Ogham divination is explicitly addressed
by Greer in The Druidry Handbook. He recognizes that Graves’ Celtic Tree Calendar lacks ancient
roots, but emphasizes that because it is useful to many modern Druids, it retains validity as a
practice. Thus, in his descriptions of each symbol, Greer openly states where each piece of
symbolism comes from, ranging from old Ogham texts to very modern developments.
According to Greer, the Ogham texts themselves ask students to “rework symbols to suit their
own experiences and needs,” and since these symbols are fundamentally “tools for…inner
31
Paul Angelini, “Interview with Grand Archdruid Emeritus John Michael Greer,” Trilithon 3 (2016): 12-13,
http://aoda.org/trilithon/Trilithon_Vol3_Web.pdf
32
Angelini, “Interview,” 18
33
“Frequently Asked Questions,” Ancient Order of Druids in America, accessed April 2, 2021,
https://aoda.org/aoda-membership/frequently-asked-questions/; Greer, “Druid Revival.”
34
Greer, “Druid Revival.”
35
“Frequently Asked Questions,” Ancient Order of Druids in America
36
John Michael Greer, The Druidry Handbook: Spiritual Practice Rooted in the Living Earth (Newburyport: Weiser
Books, 2006), 4.
transformation,” any combination of meanings, ancient or modern, are completely valid. 37
Greer’s boundary-keeping between ancient Druids and the Druid Revival has the paradoxical
effect of increasing the legitimacy of modern practices as well as creating a larger space for
Dana O’Driscoll is another prominent figure in the AODA, one that highlights the
individual-focused philosophy that underlies the distinction between ancient and modern
practice. O’Driscoll is the current Grand Archdruid of the AODA, previously serving as the chief
editor for the academic AODA journal, the Trilithon. 38 In her first public correspondence as the
“compatible with many other belief systems” and emphasizing the importance of member’s
development of their own personal practices.39 This is echoed in her personal work as well,
specifically in her creation of a tree-themed tarot deck.40 O’Driscoll argues that connection to
nature and to self are the core tenants of modern Druidry. An individual’s path is developed by
“exploring your own meanings and what resonates with you.”41 For the early members of the
their practices. The modern world elicits a different response in each individual; hence each
individual practice is just as valid as any other. Furthermore, O’Driscoll believes the
individualisation of practice is essential in the global world, especially in relation to Ogham. She
has developed her own Ogham meanings specific to the Appalachian Mountains, encouraging
37
Greer, Druidry Handbook, 84, 107
38
“Grand Grove Bios,” Ancient Order of Druids in America, accessed April 4, 2021, https://aoda.org/aoda-
structure/the-aoda-grand-grove/grand-grove-bios/
39
O’Driscoll, “Letter,” 3
40
“The Tarot of Trees,” accessed April 4. 2021, https://www.tarotoftrees.com
41
Dana O’Driscoll, “Connection as the Core Spiritual Philosophy in the Druid Tradition,” Trilithon 5 (2018): 47,
http://aoda.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/TrilithonVol5_2018.pdf
other to do the same in their own ecosystems.42 Another AODA writer encourages practitioners
to only study the traditional Irish Ogham after they “personally [know] the Ogham trees”
specific to their area.43 Prioritization of the individual’s needs further de-emphasizes the
The creation of historical lineages, real or invented, is a legitimation strategy that occurs
in nearly all major religious traditions.44 Even occultism, a movement that engages with wide
variety of sources, still asserts that truth can only be found in the ancients. The Druid Revival
was born into a similar philosophy but has matured into a religious tradition that can stand on
its own two legs. The lack of a concrete pantheon, wide accessibility of a personal connection to
nature and emphasis on individual practice have created a movement that is appealing to a
growing group that prioritizes spirituality over religion. The current climate crisis provides an
interesting catalyst for further adaptations to modern Druidry, one that will likely cement its
42
Dana O’Driscoll, “The Allegheny Mountain Ogham: An Ogham for the Northern Appalachian Mountains in the
Eastern USA,” The Druid’s Garden, WordPress, accessed April 4, 2021,
https://druidgarden.wordpress.com/2020/06/21/the-allegheny-ogham-an-ogham-for-the-northern-appalachian-
mountains-in-the-eastern-usa/
43
Dana Wyninger, “A Local Ogham, Finding Your Area’s Sacred Plants,” Trilithon 1 (2014): 31,
http://aoda.org/trilithon/TrilithonVol1_Web.pdf
44
Lewis, “Celts,” 491
Works Cited:
Ancient Order of Druids in America. “Frequently Asked Questions.” Accessed April 2, 2021.
https://aoda.org/aoda-membership/frequently-asked-questions/.
Ancient Order of Druids in America. “Grand Grove Bios.” Accessed April 4, 2021.
https://aoda.org/aoda-structure/the-aoda-grand-grove/grand-grove-bios/
Angelini, Paul. “Interview with Grand Archdruid Emeritus John Michael Greer.” Trilithon 3
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AM7HaLQclXU.
http://cura.free.fr/xv/13ellis2.html.
Forest, Danu. Celtic Tree Magic: Ogham Lore and Druid Mysteries. Llewellyn Worldwide, 2014.
Gefensdottir. “Deck Review: Celtic Tree Oracle by Sharlyn Hidalgo and Jimmy Manton.”
https://adventuresinvanaheim.wordpress.com/2017/06/11/deck-review-celtic-tree-
oracle-by-sharlyn-hidalgo-and-jimmy-manton/.
Graves, Robert. The White Goddess: a Historical Grammar of Poetic Myth. London: Faber &
Faber, 1961.
Greer, John Michael. The Druidry Handbook: Spiritual Practice Rooted in the Living Earth.
Greer, John Michael. “What is the Druid Revival?” Accessed April 8, 2021.
http://aoda.org/publications/articles-on-druidry/druidrevival/
Leahy, Arthur H. Heroic Romances of Ireland, Translated into English Prose and Verse – Volume
http://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/5678/pg5678.html.
Lewis, James R. “Celts, Druids and the Invention of Tradition.” In Handbook of Contemporary
Paganism, edited by Murphy Pizza and James Lewis, 479-491. Leiden: Brill, 2009.
Macalister, R.A. Stewart. The Secret Languages of Ireland. Cambridge University Press, 2014.
McManus, Damien. “Ogham.” In The World’s Writing Systems, edited Peter T. Daniels and
O’Driscoll, Dana. “Connection as the Core Spiritual Philosophy in the Druid Tradition.” Trilithon
O’Driscoll, Dana. “Letter from the New Grand Archdruid: Into the Future of AODA.” Trilithon 6
O’Driscoll, Dana. “The Allegheny Mountain Ogham: An Ogham for the Northern Appalachian
Mountains in the Eastern USA.” The Druid’s Garden. WordPress. Accessed April 4, 2021.
https://druidgarden.wordpress.com/2020/06/21/the-allegheny-ogham-an-ogham-for-
the-northern-appalachian-mountains-in-the-eastern-usa/
Purple Bloom Apothecary Presents. “Ogham rune sticks for beginning divination.” Posted
Rhóisín, Raven nic and Kathryn Price NicDhàna. “Tree Huggers: A Methodology for Crann
http://www.paganachd.com/articles/treehuggers.html.
Reeves, Betty J.M. “History and Heritage of the AODA.” Ancient Order of Druids in America.
Tacitus. Agricola and Germany. Translated by Anthony Birley. Oxford University Press, 1999.
https://www.tarottotes.com/item.asp?iid=2797.
http://paganachd.com/faq/intermediate.html#syncretisms.
The CR FAQ. “Do you use the Celtic Tree Calendar and Celtic Astrology?” Accessed March 29,
2021. http://paganachd.com/faq/misconceptions.html#treecalendar.
The Druid Network. “Common Practices and Beliefs within Druidry.” Accessed April 1, 2021.
https://druidnetwork.org/what-is-druidry/beliefs-and-definitions/articles/common-
practice-and-beliefs-within-druidry/.
The Spiritual Life. “Druidry (modern).” Accessed March 30, 2021. https://slife.org/druidry/.
Wyninger, Dana. “A Local Ogham, Finding Your Area’s Sacred Plants.” Trilithon 1 (2014): 27-32.
http://aoda.org/trilithon/TrilithonVol1_Web.pdf.