Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bauer Et - Al The Destruction of The Yurac Rumi Shrine
Bauer Et - Al The Destruction of The Yurac Rumi Shrine
Brian S. Bauer
University of Illinois at Chicago
George S. Burr
University of Arizona
The Vilcabamba region, however, gains its House of the Sun),5 various attendants, and a
unique importance from the role that it held in head priest (Figure 2).
the final days of the Incas. In 1537, after the
Incas failed to regain control of Cusco, their In 1568, while the Inca were still in control
capital city, from the Spaniards, many native of the Vilcabamba region, the ruling Inca (Titu
loyalists withdrew into this mountainous region. Cusi Yupanqui) invited the Augustinian priest,
Marcos Garcia, to enter the area and establish a
The leader of the resistance, Manco Inca, mission. About a year later a second Augustin-
established himself at the town of Vitcos,3 as he ian, Diego Ortiz, was also given permission to
attempted to restore control over what had been live in the area.6 As Titu Cusi contemplated a
the largest indigenous state to develop in the full conversion to Christianity7 the relationship
Americas.4 For nearly eight years Manco Inca between the Incas and the Christians were
both negotiated with the Spaniards and orga- stable, and the missions run by Ortiz and Garcia
nized raids against them. After his death, strong lived in an uneasy state of truce with the Yurac
indigenous resistance continued under the Rumi shrine and its attendants. However, in
successive leadership of three of Manco Inca’s 1570, angered by their recent poor treatment by
sons: Sayri Tupac, Titu Cusi, and Tupac Amaru. the Inca and emboldened by a growing number
During this same period, the Spanish leaders of of converts to Christianity, the two priests and
Cusco sent diplomats, priests, miners, and, at a small group of local people burned the Yurac
times, military expeditions into the Vilcabamba Rumi shrine complex (Calancha 1981[1638]:
region, attempting to bring an end to the con- 1826, Book 4, Chapter 4]; Murúa 1987[1611-
flict (Gose 2008; Hemming 1970).
1616]: 270, Book 1, Chapter 75). In the wake of there. Unlike most other known shrine centers
this provocative move, the Inca himself had to in the Andes, the Yurac Rumi site remains
race to the shrine to restore order and to save relatively well preserved (Lee 2000; Samanez
the priests from being killed by a large and angry and Zapata 1996).
mob. The next year, however, Titu Cusi sud-
denly died while visiting Vitcos,8 and soon
afterwards, in April 1572, Viceroy Toledo OVERVIEW OF THE 2008 EXCAVATIONS
ordered a massive raid on the Vilcabamba
region which resulted in the capture of the new The Yurac Rumi shrine is in a small, but
Inca (Tupac Amaru), and a general depopula- steep-sided, river valley at an altitude of approx-
tion of the area soon followed. The city of imately 3,080 m.a.s.l. Now, as in Inca times, the
Vitcos was abandoned, and the important valley slopes are covered with dense vegetation,
rituals that had been performed at the shrine of while the valley floor has been cleared and
Yurac Rumi slowly faded from local memory. terraced. The complex is relatively small, less
than 80 meters square, and is some twenty
BINGHAM AT YURAC RUMI minutes by foot from the royal palace structures
of Vitcos. The sculpted rock of Yurac Rumi is in
Over the centuries, the forests of Vilca- the center of the shrine complex, and the spring
bamba reclaimed the city of Vitcos as well as its mentioned by the chroniclers still emerges from
nearby shrine. On August 9, 1911, less than a beneath it, and flows north into a small court-
month after he discovered Machu Picchu, yard framed by a suite of buildings (Figure 3).
Hiram Bingham entered the Vilcabamba region The area immediately to the south of the sacred
looking for the final capital of the Incas. After rock contains a large open plaza (approximately
visiting the ruins of Vitcos he was told of, and 25 by 20 meters), and a series of small carved
subsequently found, a large, nearby, carved rock rocks. The area to the southwest of the Yurac
which stood above a spring. Bingham cleared Rumi contains a second set of buildings with an
the forest around the rock the following day and interior courtyard and a large looters’ pit.
found various Inca buildings grouped in patio-
units beside it. He also found a host of smaller During June and July of 2008, Bauer and
carved rocks and an impressive terrace and Aráoz Silva conducted field-work at Yurac
canal system beside the rock. Bingham (1912a, Rumi. The project included fourteen (one meter
1912 b, 1912c, 1913, 1922) immediately recog- by one meter) test units, as well as six larger
nized that this was the shrine complex of Yurac excavations.9 The goal of the smaller units was
Rumi. He returned to the shrine site the next to gain information on the stratigraphy of the
year (1912), drained the swamp at its base, and site, while the larger units were dug to more
conducted limited excavations. Finding little, fully investigate specific areas and buildings. At
and being drawn to working at the larger site of
Machu Picchu, Bingham left the rest of the site
untouched. Remarkably, no other archaeologi- 9
Major funding for this project was provided by the
cal projects have been conducted at Yurac National Geographic Society, the University of Illinois at
Rumi, and only limited looting has taken place Chicago, the Curtiss T. Brennan and Mary G. Brennan
Foundation, the Institute for New World Archaeology,
and the Accelerator Mass Spectrometry Laboratory at the
University of Arizona. We thank Vincent Lee for
8
The exact date of Titu Cusi Yupanqui’s death is not providing the building drawing used in this work, as well
known. However it most likely occurred in 1571, or early as Andean Past reviewers Steven A. Wernke and Steven
in 1572. Kosiba for their comments on improving the manuscript.
ANDEAN PAST 10 (2012) - 198
the conclusion of the field-work, a series of dark earth, followed by another floor of crushed
carbon samples were submitted for dating under white granite. Under the second granite floor
the direction of Burr at the Accelerator Mass was a thin layer of earthen fill used to level this
Spectrometry Laboratory at the University of area of the site, and a then thick stratum, more
Arizona. While a report on the full excavation than thirty centimeters deep, of very dark
is currently in preparation, here we discuss the brown, clayish loam which is thought to be the
contributions of the radiocarbon dates to our natural sediment of the valley before the Inca
understanding of the shrine complex. Our occupation (Figure 4).
research suggests that the shrine was established
during the early expansion of the Inca empire. Evidence of a similar level of crushed white
Furthermore, we find overwhelming evidence granite was found in P11. This unit, measuring
that the shrine was destroyed by fire, and that 1.0 by 1.2 meters was placed in the northeast
the ritual complex was then briefly reoccupied, sector of the site, against the back wall of the
before being completely abandoned. These building facing the sacred rock. The excavations
archaeological data strongly support the narra- soon revealed an irregular, hard-packed earthen
tive accounts given by Murúa (1987 [1611- floor with large fragments of classic Inca pottery,
1616], Calancha (1981 [1638]), and Cobo carbon, and some minute burnt bone fragments.
(1979 [1653]). Beneath the earthen floor was a level fill, ap-
proximately twenty centimeters thick, which
DATING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE SHRINE rested above a two centimeter thick floor of
crushed white granite. This floor had been well
Excavations in the plaza and courtyards of prepared and rested directly above a thin,
the shrine documented that the open areas of greater than one centimeter, level of red clay,
the complex were covered with hard-packed which may have been used as a sealant to pro-
gravel floors during its final years of use. Fur- tect the granite floor in this waterlogged area of
thermore, excavations in the buildings revealed the site.10 Beneath the red clay, was a thick
that most of the structures contained well- stratum, fifty to sixty centimeters, of multiple fill
prepared, green clay floors. Importantly, in two levels which was used to raise the interior area
different units we also found evidence of earlier of the structure (Figure 5).
floors, made with crushed white granite.
There is little doubt that the crushed white
The crushed white granite floors were first granite in the floors identified in units P9 and
identified in Unit P9; a one by one meter exca- P11 was the direct by-product of the Incas’
vation in the Southwest Courtyard. The excava- carving the many granite boulders that lie
tion revealed a humus level followed by a thick within the shrine complex. A carbon sample,
stratum of disturbed soil, representing the back- (AA83415) collected from within the upper
dirt of a nearby looters’ pit. The third stratum floor of crushed granite in P9, yielded an AMS
was composed of colluvially redeposited materi- radiocarbon date of 601±34 BP. A carbon
als (i.e. slope wash) laid down after the site was sample, (AA83416) collected from the crushed
abandoned. Next came a series of closely granite floor in Unit P11, provided an AMS
spaced, relatively thin levels, each two to three date radiocarbon age 496±51 BP. The cali-
centimeters thick. The first was the pebble floor
which extends across much of the courtyard
area. This was followed by a floor of finely 10
Similar thin levels of red clay were also noted within the
crushed, white granite. Next came a lens of profiles of two excavation units (P7, P8) on the terrace
above the shrine complex.
199 - Bauer et al.: Destruction of the Yurac Rumi Shrine
brated dates from these samples suggest that the after the two priests returned from seeing the
shrine was established in the late 1300s to mid- Inca in Vilcabamba.13 No matter which chroni-
1400s (Table 1). cler is more accurate, the burning of the shrine
appears to have taken place sometime between
DATING THE DESTRUCTION OF THE SHRINE mid-February and mid-March 1570.14
The destruction of Yurac Rumi can be Our 2008 excavations at Yurac Rumi con-
narrowed down to a relatively short time period. firm that the shrine was destroyed in a massive
The two priests, Ortiz and Garcia, witnessed fire. Each of the buildings that we sampled
and signed a document dictated by Titu Cusi contained thick levels of burnt building materi-
Yupanqui (2005[1570]:139) in the Inca town of als, including large amounts of burnt plaster, as
Vilcabamba on February 6, 1570, after which well as carbonized roof remains. These excava-
they returned to the town of Puquiura near tions also revealed that each of the buildings
Vitcos.11 According to Calancha (1981[1638]: had well maintained floors at the time of the
1825-1827, Book 4, Chapter 4),12 when Ortiz destruction. A few complete ceramic vessels
and Garcia arrived in Puquiura there were many (both for storage and cooking) were found on
people from different towns waiting for them. the floors, and one structure yielded a bronze
Some were bemoaning deaths which had been halberd (yauri) head which appears to have
caused by the “demon” of Yurac Rumi, while been left in the rafters of one of the buildings
others were trembling in fear from the havoc when it burned (Figure 6). Furthermore, some
and destruction that the demon was causing to organic artifacts in use at the time of the burn-
their families, herds, and fields because they had ing were preserved in carbonized form. For
been baptized. Angry, and perhaps humiliated example, we recovered a carved wood staff that
by the events that had taken place in the city of had been resting on one of the floors. It should
Vilcabamba, Ortiz and Garcia announced be noted, however, that overall our excavations
through the town crier that all the converts found very few artifacts within the structures,
should gather the next day at the church on the suggesting that the priests and attendants had
plaza, and that each person was to bring fire- had time to remove the most valued items
wood, because they were going to burn the before the complex was burned.
shrine. The following day the priests and their
followers marched to Yurac Rumi, encircled it
with firewood, and, after conducting an exor-
cism, they burned the temple and the rock. 13
The Mercedarian friar Martín de Murúa lived in Cusco
Murúa (1987[1611-1616]:270), provides many at least from 1585 to 1588, more likely even longer, and
of the same details. However, Murúa suggests he was stationed as the parish priest of Curahuasi on the
that Yurac Rumi was burned about a month southern edge of the Vilcabamba region in 1595 (Ossio
2008a). It was during these decades that he collected
information on the history of the Incas and the early
conquest of the Andes by the Spaniards. He personally
11
17 February 1570 in the Gregorian calendar. interviewed many of the Spaniards who had lead raids into
the Vilcabamba region, as well as some of the natives who
12
Antonio de la Calancha wrote a history of the had lived there (Adorno and Boserup 2008; Ossio 2008b).
Augustinian order in Peru which was published in 1638. Like Calancha, he had access to the Augustinian records
There is no evidence that he lived in the Cusco region. concerning the death of Ortiz (Aparicio 1989).
However, as an Augustinian himself, Calancha had access
14
to the records of the order, including the inquiries which The testimony of Juana Guerra states that the burning
were conducted on the death of Ortiz (Hemming 1970; took place “a cabo de un mes, poco más o menos” [At the
MacCormack 2008). end of a month, more or less] (Aparicio 1989:164).
ANDEAN PAST 10 (2012) - 200
The most intriguing information on the roof support (AA83419 [1], AA83419 [2]), the
massive burning of the shrine comes from grass thatch (AA83422), and carbon associated
Excavation Unit U6, where the ceiling and roof with the reoccupation of the structure (AA
of the structure appear to have fallen relatively 83420, AA83421).16 The results of the radiocar-
quickly (Figures 7, 8). During the course of bon assays are presented in Table 1 and Figure
excavation we exposed samples of burned and 11.
unburned mountain grass (Stipa ichu) used as
thatch, carbonized mountain bamboo (Chusqu- SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION
quea scandens) used as battens, carbonized
rafters made from alder (Alnus acuminata), and The Inca empire is well known for its elabo-
carbonized rope made from local grass (Calama- rately carved rocks, many of which were wor-
grostis heterophylla) used in lashing the battens shiped as shrines. One of the most celebrated
and rafters. These charred ceiling and roofing examples of such a rock shrine is Yurac Rumi in
materials rested directly on the green clay floor the Vilcabamba region. A series of radiocarbon
of the building, and were covered with a 30 tests were run on carbon collected at the shrine
centimeter thick stratum of burnt plaster and during excavations in 2008 to help determine:
other materials (Figure 9). 1) when the shrine was first established, 2)
when it was destroyed, and 3) when it was
A hard-packed earthen floor, enhanced by reoccupied. Not surprisingly, the two carbon
a few slate paving stones, above the burnt wall samples from the reoccupation level provided
plaster stratum, but below a large scale collapse the latest dates. However they were only slightly
of the structure walls, provided evidence of a later than the majority of the ceiling and roofing
brief reoccupation of the shrine after it had been materials which burned when the shrine was
burnt by the Augustinians.15 It appears that this initially destroyed. Although we may never
reoccupation also ended in fire, because the know with certainty, it is possible that parts of
hard-packed earth floor was also covered with a the shrine were immediately re-consecrated by
lens of ash and burnt wood (Figure 10). local inhabitants following the actions of Ortiz
and Garcia, and that those more limited struc-
The recovery of various identifiable organic tures were burnt again approximately two years
ceiling and roofing materials within a building later in 1572 as Spanish forces swept through
with a known destruction date provided a the region in their successful campaign to cap-
unique investigative opportunity. We wanted to ture Tupac Amaru and to end the independent
examine how the dates of various plant species Inca state established in the Vilcabamba region.
incorporated into the different parts of the roof
correlated with each other, as well as with the The burnt ceiling and roofing materials of
known destruction date of the shrine. As a the shrine also provided intriguing results. The
result, AMS measurements were run on a rope sampled batten, roof support, and thatch all
(AA83417 [1], AA83417 [2]), a batten (AA
83418 [1], AA83418 [2]), the outer layers of a
16
All samples were processed in The National Science
Foundation-University of Arizona Accelerator Mass
15
The reoccupation of Yurac Rumi may have been limited Spectrometry facility. Calibrated dates were generated by
to only certain areas of the shrine complex. Sometime Calib 5.1 beta, courtesy of the University of Washington
after this brief reoccupation, many of the buildings of the (Stuiver and Reimer 1993). Dates were calibrated using
shrine complex appear to have been systematically software employing southern hemisphere data (SHCal04
destroyed, with major architectural features, such as the calibration curve) (McCormac et al. 2004).
stone roof pegs, pulled from the walls.
201 - Bauer et al.: Destruction of the Yurac Rumi Shrine
yielded very similar calibrated dates which Two separate test excavations found evi-
clustered in the late-1400s to the mid-1500s. dence of crushed granite floors in the Yurac
These age estimations make sense if the shrine Rumi shrine. The incorporation of the crushed
was established, as suggested by the dates from granite into the floors of the complex must have
the granite floors, during the late 1300s to mid- made them architecturally stunning, and rein-
1400s. However, the rope which was used to tie forced the ritual nature of the area surrounding
the thatch together provided surprisingly early the sacred central stone. Use of the “wastage”
dates. Our sample yielded calibrated probability from the carving of the Yurac Rumi stone as a
dates in the late-1200s, suggesting that the rope; paving material for the plaza space is consistent
was more than 200 years older than the rest of with Inca aesthetics. The pulverized debitage
the roof. Indeed, the results suggest that the from a huaca like this would not have been
rope may have even predated the Inca occupa- categorized as mere spoilage, but something
tion of the Vilcabamba region. Contamination more akin to a religious relic. Its use as a floor-
agents could have been introduced as a result of ing material would have bound the site together
fiber preparation before the weaving of the rope, as a single, sacred complex.
however, the Inca are not known to have used
such agents.17 While it is possible that the Incas Carbon samples were collected from two of
used older materials in the construction of the the granite floors.22 Although the radiocarbon
shrine, the dates of the rope seem excessively ages of these two samples are separated by some
early, and we currently cannot fully explain the one hundred years (601±34 BP, 496±51 BP),
results. their calibrated 1-sigmas do have considerable
overlap in the earliest decades of the cal AD
The precision of radiocarbon assays can be 1400s. We currently believe that these samples
increased by using pooled means of different but date the establishment of Yurac Rumi as a
related samples. In this study, the two samples shrine, and document when the Inca first ex-
from the reoccupation18 can be pooled together, panded into the Vilcabamba region. The fact
as can the samples from the batten,19 the roof that these levels were later buried, and that
support,20 and the rope.21 The results of the additional floors were established above them,
pooling, presented in Figure 12, helps to illus- indicates that a series of modifications occurred
trate how close the reoccupation dates are to at the shrine after its initial dedication. The
the roof dates, and how much earlier the rope dates are consistent with suggestions that the
dates are. region was incorporated relatively early into the
Inca empire, during its initial expansion period,
most likely during the reign of Pachacuti Inca
Yupanqui.
17
In other cases, conservation agents might also make a
rope test older than it really is, but in this case the sample
was taken in the field and sent directly to the laboratory
for analysis.
18
Samples AA83420, AA83421.
19
Samples AA83418 (1), AA83418 (2).
20
Samples AA83419 (2), AA83419 (1).
21 22
Samples AA83417 (1), AA83417 (2). Samples AA83415, AA83416.
ANDEAN PAST 10 (2012) - 202
AA83415 Granite floor Unidentified carbon -25.1 0.9280 ± 0.0039 601 ± 34 One-sigma ranges:
[cal AD 1326: cal AD 1341] 0.250409
[cal AD 1390: cal AD 1419] 0.749591
Two-sigma ranges:
[cal AD 1316: cal AD 1355] 0.326466
[cal AD 1382: cal AD 1435] 0.673534
Median probability: cal AD 1397
AA83416 Granite floor Unidentified carbon -27.5 0.9401 ± 0.0060 496 ± 51 One-sigma ranges:
[cal AD 1411: cal AD 1464] 0.955148
[cal AD 1470: cal AD 1476] 0.044852
Two-sigma ranges:
[cal AD 1394: cal AD 1509] 0.922702
[cal AD 1579: cal AD 1620] 0.077298
Median probability: cal AD 1446
AA83417 (1) Rope Calamagrostis -23.7 0.9075 ± 0.0059 780 ± 52 One-sigma range:
heterophylla [cal AD 1225: cal AD 1298] 1.0
Quechua: Hiro ichu Two-sigma ranges:
Reed grass [cal AD 1190: cal AD 1191] 0.001013
[cal AD 1202: cal AD 1322] 0.859046
[cal AD 1347: cal AD 1387] 0.139941
Median probability: cal AD 1271
AA83417 (2) Rope Calamagrostis -24.2 0.9089 ± 0.0056 767 ± 49 One-sigma ranges:
heterophylla [cal AD 1230: cal AD 1250] 0.205490
Quechua: Hiro ichu [cal AD 1261: cal AD 1304] 0.662807
Reed grass [cal AD 1363: cal AD 1377] 0.131703
Two-sigma ranges:
[cal AD 1215: cal AD 1323] 0.803562
[cal AD 1346: cal AD 1388] 0.196438
Median probability: cal AD 1283
AA83418 (1) Batten Chusququea scanden -25.9 09481 ± 0.0061 428 ± 52 One-sigma ranges:
Quechua: Kurkur [cal AD 1446: cal AD 1509] 0.666726
Mountain bamboo [cal AD 1580: cal AD 1620] 0.333274
Two-sigma range:
[cal AD 1438: cal AD 1628] 1.0
Median probability: cal AD 1508
AA83418 (2) Batten Chusququea scanden -23.7 0.9466 ± 0.0058 441 ± 49 One-sigma range:
Quechua: Kurkur [cal AD 1442: cal AD 1504] 0.763347
Mountain bamboo Two-sigma ranges:
[cal AD 1428: cal AD 1524] 0.636179
[cal AD 1529: cal AD 1531] 0.005259
[cal AD 1535: cal AD 1626] 0.358562
Median probability: cal AD 1493
AA83419 (1) Roof support Alnus acuminata -22.8 0.9484 ± 0.0058 426 ± 49 One-sigma ranges:
Spanish: Aliso [cal AD 1447: cal AD 1508] 0.670719
Alder [cal AD 1583: cal AD 1619] 0.329281
Two-sigma range:
[cal AD 1441: cal AD 1626] 1.0
Median probability: cal AD 1508
Continued:
AA83419 (2) Roof support Alnus acuminata -27.3 0.9524 ± 0.0061 392 ± 51 One-sigma ranges:
Spanish: Aliso [cal AD 1461: cal AD 1512] 0.428560
Alder [cal AD 1548: cal AD 1563] 0.113319
[cal AD 1569: cal AD 1622] 0.458120
Two-sigma range:
[cal AD 1453: cal AD 1635] 1.0
Median probability: cal AD 1547
AA83420 Reoccupation Unidentified carbon -25.6 0.9575 ± 0.0062 349 ± 52 One-sigma ranges:
[cal AD 1502: cal AD 1594] 0.792765
[cal AD 1613: cal AD 1638] 0.207235
Two-sigma range:
[cal AD 1457: cal AD 1658] 1.0
Median probability: cal AD 1562
AA83421 Reoccupation Unidentified carbon -25.6 0.9557 ± 0.0062 364 ± 52 One-sigma ranges:
[cal AD 1499: cal AD 1598] 0.835896
[cal AD 1610: cal AD 1630] 0.164104
Two-sigma range:
[cal AD 1458: cal AD 1646] 1.0
Median probability: cal AD 1557
AA83422 Grass thatch Stipa ichu -23.6 0.9470 ± 0.0061 437 ± 52 One-sigma ranges:
Quechua: Ichu [cal AD 1442: cal AD 1507] 0.716657
Mountain grass [cal AD 1586: cal AD 1618] 0.283343
Two-sigma range:
[cal AD 1432: cal AD 1626] 1.0
Median probability: cal AD 1498
Figure 12: Radiocarbon dates from Yurac Rumi using pooled means.