Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cost Planning and Management: Typical Construction Project Organization
Cost Planning and Management: Typical Construction Project Organization
1
3/24/2022
Sequence of Activities
Construction Estimates
2
3/24/2022
Estimation
Estimate
• Estimation is the scientific way of working out the approximate cost of an engineering
project before execution of the work.
• It is totally different from calculation of the exact cost after completion of the project.
• Estimation requires a thorough Knowledge of the construction procedures and cost of
materials & labour in addition to the skill , experience, foresight and good judgment.
• An estimate of the cost of a construction job is the probable cost of that job as computed
from plans and specifications.
• For a good estimate the, actual cost of the proposed work after completion should not
differ by more then 5 to 10 % from its approximate cost estimate, provided there are no
unusual, unforeseen circumstances
3
3/24/2022
• While preparing a detailed estimate, one had to be very careful to see that all items of
the work are incorporated.
• It is likely that a few Items, though unimportant in nature, might have been overlooked
and which may result in raising the estimate of the project.
• There may be also certain unforeseen circumstances affecting the project.
• Hence, a certain allowance usually
5 to 10% of the total cost, is made
in the estimation which will take
care of all these items that are
unforeseen or are overlooked and
are known as "Contingencies".
4
3/24/2022
Types of Estimates
Types of Estimates
• Cost estimates are divided into three major types based on fully developed construction drawings
and specifications
1. Conceptual cost estimates are developed using incomplete project documentation;
2. Semi-detailed cost estimates are prepared when parts of the project have been completely
designed; and
3. Detailed cost estimates are prepared.
• The accuracy of the estimate depends on the completeness of the contract documents and the
experience of an estimator.
10
5
3/24/2022
Conceptual Detailed
Feasibility Pre-bid Construction
design design
11
Types of Estimate
12
6
3/24/2022
Conceptual Estimates
• At the outset of the project, when the scope and definition are in the early stages of
development, little information is available, yet there is often a need for some assessment
of the potential cost. The owner needs to have a rough or approximate value for the
project’s cost for purposes of determining the economic desirability of proceeding with
design and construction. Special quick techniques are usually employed, utilizing minimal
available information at this point to prepare a conceptual estimate.
• Little effort is expended to prepare this type of estimate, which often utilizes only a
single project parameter, such as square feet of floor area, span length of a bridge, or
barrels per day of output. Using available, historical cost information and applying like
parameters, a quick and simple estimate can be prepared
• These types of estimates are valuable in determining the order of magnitude of the cost
for very rough comparisons and analysis but are not appropriate for critical decision
making and commitment.
• Conceptual estimates have value, but they have many limitations as well. Care must be
exercised to choose the appropriate method for conceptual estimating based on the
available information
13
Conceptual Estimates
• Conceptual estimating relies heavily on past cost data, which is adjusted to reflect current
trends and actual project economic conditions
• The accuracy of an estimate is a function of time spent in its preparation, the quantity of
design data utilized in the evaluation, and the accuracy of the information used. In
general, more effort and more money produce a better estimate, one in which the
estimator has more confidence regarding the accuracy of his or her prediction.
14
7
3/24/2022
Conceptual Estimates
• Conceptual estimates are often called ballpark estimates. Typically there are no
drawings available at all. You can use conceptual estimates when you are in the idea or
concept stage of a project. Often an owner doesn’t really know whether their idea is
economically feasible, and they don’t want to start spending money on design until they
know that the project is at least possible. An experienced estimator can help out in a
situation like this by offering a rough order of magnitude (ROM) estimate. These
estimates are based upon a cost per primary unit for the facility. For example, for
hospitals, the primary unit of measure would be beds, and you would multiply the
proposed number of beds by the appropriate unit cost. For a school, the calculation
would be cost per pupil; for a highway the estimate would be based on a cost per mile.
Once the owner suggests how many primary units they would like to build, an estimator
can whip out a rough order of magnitude estimate within minutes; however, the accuracy
is limited.
15
Conceptual estimate
16
8
3/24/2022
• The first recognized characteristic of conceptual estimating, like all other estimating, is the
inexactness in the process. With the absence of data and with shortage of time, there
may be no other way to evaluate designs but to use opinion. Conceptual estimating is a
mixture of art and science; the science of estimating tells the cost of past work. The art is
in visualizing a project and the construction of each detail, selecting comparative costs
from past projects and adjusting them to new conditions.
• The second characteristic of conceptual estimating is that its accuracy and validity are
highly related to the level of information provided by the project scope. The
availability of a good, complete scope definition is considered the most crucial factor for
conceptual estimating.
• The third characteristic of conceptual estimating is that it is a resource restricted activity.
The main resources for conceptual estimating are information, time, and cost. Due to the
fact that conceptual estimating is performed in the early stages of the project, the scope
information available is usually restricted in detail as well as in precision. In addition, the
time and cost available for making the estimate is restricted.
17
• These estimate assists the overall cost-control program by serving as the first check
against the budget. It will indicate the cost overruns early enough for the project team to
review the design for possible alternates.
• Since these estimate is made prior to the completion of detailed design, the margin of
error will be relatively large. Then, the larger contingency should be applied. The
contingency varies with the amount of design information available and the extent of cost
information obtainable from similar projects.
18
9
3/24/2022
• Prior the design of a project, cost estimate could be prepared based on the cost
information based on previously completed projects similar to the proposed project. The
number of units or size of the project is the only available information. Although the
range of costs varies among projects, the estimator can develop unit costs to forecast the
cost of future projects.
• The unit cost should be developed from weighting the data that emphasizes the average
value, yet it should account for the extreme maximum and minimum values. In that regard
Eq. can be used for weighting cost data from previous projects.
• UC = (A + 4B + C) / 6
Where: UC = forecast unit cost
A = minimum unit cost of previous projects
B = average unit cost of previous project
C = maximum unit cost of previous projects
19
Problem
• Determine the conceptual cost estimate for a proposed parking that is to contain 135
parked cars. Previous projects data are given in Table.
(Rs)
20
10
3/24/2022
Solution
21
Problem
22
11
3/24/2022
Semi-detailed estimate
• Semi-detailed cost estimates are developed while basic design decisions are being made
to verify that the project can be constructed at its intended scope within the owner's
budget. Some aspects of the project may be completely designed. Detailed estimating
methods can be used to estimate the cost of project components that have been
designed, and conceptual estimating methods are used to estimate the cost of those
components that remain to be designed. This means that databases are used to estimate
the cost of components for which the design is not complete, and project data are used to
estimate the cost of components for which the design is complete. Therefore, these
estimates are known as semi-detailed cost estimates.
23
Detailed estimate
24
12
3/24/2022
Detailed estimate
25
Detailed Estimates
26
13
3/24/2022
1. Review the scope of project. Consider the effect of location, security, traffic, available
storage space, underground utilities, etc. on costs.
2. Determine quantities. Perform a material quantity takeoff for all work items.
3. Obtain suppliers’ bids.
4. Price material. Material cost = quantity x unit price.
5. Price labor based on their probable production rate.
6. Price equipment based on their probable production rates.
7. Obtain specialty contractors’ bids.
8. Calculate taxes, bonds, insurance and overhead.
9. Contingency and markup. Add costs for potential unforeseen work.
10. Profit. Add costs for compensation for performing the work.
27
28
14
3/24/2022
Preliminary Estimates
• If you have a preliminary set of drawings with overall dimensions, you can move to the
next level of estimating after conceptual estimates. Preliminary estimates provide a
somewhat higher level of accuracy and may be used to establish initial budgets and
preliminary financing scenarios. However, these estimates should never be used to commit
to a contract price because too many factors can influence the reliability of the numbers.
Although there are numerous preliminary estimate methodologies, the most common is
probably the square foot method. In its simplest form, the estimator calculates the area
of the floor plan and multiplies that number by a unit price.
• There are various levels of skill and detail that can be applied to the square foot
estimating method, and the degree of accuracy increases with each step up, as will the
time it takes to calculate the price.
29
TYPES OF ESTIMATES
2 Preliminary estimate Budgeting costs toward the end of planning and design phase
30
15
3/24/2022
1 Buildings Depending upon the type of the building, the basis could be number of occupants (e.g., per student
for schools and hostels, per bed for hospitals, or per seat for theatres).
2 Roads and The estimates are usually made on a per-kilometre basis, depending upon the nature and
highways classification of the road, its width and the cross-section of the road. Obviously, the estimates are
different for concrete and bitumen-topped roads.
3 Irrigation Estimates for these could be on the basis of length involved, the capacity of the channel, or also the
works area of land to be covered.
4 Bridges and This is done on the basis of the span of the structure, depending on the roadway, the nature and
culverts depth of foundation, the type of structure, etc. For small culverts, an approximate cost may also be
available in handbooks on a ‘per culvert’ basis for culverts of different spans. At times, approximate
costs of bridges are also worked out separately for the substructure and the superstructure.
5 Sewage and Estimates for these could be made on the basis of per head of population served or the area
water supply covered.
6 Overhead Estimates could be made on the basis of the capacity of the tank, depending on the type of
water tank structure, height of staging, etc.
31
32
16
3/24/2022
With the price per unit method of estimating, a certain unit that is common to all projects of this type
is selected and the number of these units is calculated for each project, for example, beds in a
hospital. Using this method, the construction cost of a newly constructed hospital is divided by the
number of beds provided in the new building. This calculation provides the unit price per bed, which
can then be used to price future hospital projects by multiplying the number of beds in the proposed
facility by this unit price per bed. For example, suppose a 500-bed hospital wing has been
constructed for $60 million. So the unit cost = $30 million/500 beds = $60,000 per bed. A similar
400- bed wing is proposed, so its estimated price is 400 × $60,000 = $24 million.
This method of preliminary estimating has some strengths:
• Produces an estimate quickly.
• Little data required for the calculation—just the number of units involved and the projected cost
per unit.
• Can serve as a rough check on estimates.
• One building can be compared with another on a functional basis.
• It can be an indication of design efficiency.
Weakness – low accuracy level; not useful for cost control
33
• Here the unit of analysis is the square foot or square meter of gross floor area of the
project. The gross floor area is defined as the area of all floors measured to the outside
of containing walls. As with the previous method, the analysis begins with the construction
cost of a completed project. The known project construction cost is divided by the gross
floor area of the project to obtain a cost per unit area, which can then be applied to
future projects to estimate their construction cost. This is the most common method of
preliminary estimating as it is easy to understand and a large amount of data on prices
per square foot are published that may supplement data derived from designers’
analysis of their own projects. Because one of the first details of design to be defined is
always the floor area of a proposed building, this method of estimating can be applied
very early in the development of a project.
• For example, suppose a 50,000-square-foot office building of a certain type was built in
a certain place for $9,850,000. Therefore, the unit cost is $9,850,000/50,000, or $197
per square foot. A similar 39,000-square-foot office is proposed, so the estimated price
is 39,000 × $197 = $7,683,000.
34
17
3/24/2022
The unit area method has several strengths: However, the unit area method does have
• Produces an estimate quickly. some weaknesses:
• Can be accurate only when very similar
• Little data required for the calculation—just
buildings are involved.
the gross floor area (GFA) and the projected
cost per square foot. • Improving accuracy is complicated: Rate
adjustments are required for differences in
• As a rough check on estimates.
building function, building size, building
• One design can be compared with another. shape, location, quality and type of
• A large amount of data is published on unit construction, and other factors.
area costs. • Because there is no breakdown of the single
• Widely used and understood. rate, it is not useful for controlling costs.
• Easy to communicate to laypeople.
35
• One variable that can be a significant influence on the cost of some projects is the story
height. The height of warehouses, for instance, can vary considerably, thus making the use
of price per unit floor area inappropriate. A better method employs the price per unit of
volume as the means of determining the preliminary estimate.
• The cost per unit volume is obtained by dividing the total construction cost by the volume
of the building. The volume of the building is calculated by multiplying the area of the
building by the height from the bottom of the gravel under the basement slab-on-grade
to the top of the roof surface. The area of the building is again measured to the outside
of containing walls.
• Example: A retail building with a volume of 274,500 cubic feet was constructed for
$2,470,500, so the cost = $2,470,500/274,500 = $9 per cu. ft. A similar 290,000 cu.
ft. retail building is proposed, so the estimated price is 290,000 × $9 = $2,610,000.
36
18
3/24/2022
37
• Plinth Area Rate (PAR) method is one of the popular methods for preparing preliminary
estimates. PAR is prepared by Central Public Works Department (CPWD) for preparation
of preliminary estimates based on plinth area of a building. In PAR-2007, buildings are
classified in residential and non residential categories such as houses of different types
(e.g. Type I, Type II, Type III, Type IV, Type V, Type VI, and Servant quarters), hostels,
offices, college, schools, and hospitals.
• In PAR-2007, typical specifications such as type of foundation (based on safe bearing
capacity), type of structure (such as load-bearing or RCC-framed structure), flooring
(such as mosaic, Kota stone, or marble), other finishing items and electrical fixtures are
specified for a standard (nominal) building specification.
• The rates specified in PAR-2012 are based on prevailing market rates as on 1.10.2012,
and the base index for year 2012 is assumed to be 100. At regular intervals, the indices
are revised based on the current market rates. Correction factors need to be applied if
PAR-2012 is to be used in places other than Delhi.
38
19
3/24/2022
39
40
20
3/24/2022
41
42
21
3/24/2022
43
• The schematic diagram provides only the entry and exit schemes of the proposed car park,
besides providing the overall area involved in the project. The designer at this stage is familiar
with broad specifications of the project and he would also know the preliminary scheme of car
parking. For example, at this stage he is expected to know the number of levels in which cars will
be stacked and, thus, the construction height involved in the project. Based on the broad
specifications and the preliminary sketch, the quantities are worked out and schedules are
referred to in order to arrive at the project cost. The preliminary plan and sectional drawing
shown form the basis of plinth area calculation, which is the basis of estimate preparation at this
stage. The plinth area calculation for this example.
• Now, based on the plinth area calculated above, the broad specification for the project can be
laid out, and on basis of CPWD plinth area rate as on 01.10.2007, the estimate can be
prepared. The estimate is made in two parts—for schedule items and for non-schedule items.
While the rates for schedule items are readily available in the schedule of rates, the non-schedule
items are estimated based on the market rates prevailing at the time of preparation of estimate.
44
22
3/24/2022
The estimate for schedule items is given in Table. The estimate contains the following major
parts:
• RCC Frame Structure
• The total area for RCC frame structure is 16,000 m2, and the corresponding rate given
in schedule of rates is Rs. 18,035/m2. On this base rate, the provision for mastic asphalt
in the basement, earthquake resistant design and stronger structural members to carry
heavy loads are to be added. Further, the schedule specifies additional cost provisions
for modules over 35 m2 (which in our case is applicable), and for additional heights
above 3.35 m (this is again applicable in our case), and accordingly, these provisions
have been kept as given in Table.
45
46
23
3/24/2022
47
Problem
• Derive the rate per cubic metre for providing and laying in position cement concrete
1:2:4 (1 cement: 2 coarse aggregate: 4 graded stone aggregate 20 mm nominal size)
for all work up to plinth level excluding the cost of centering and shuttering.
Solution:
• The approach adopted here for the analysis of rate is mostly adopted by government
departments for small jobs or projects. The labour and material coefficients per m3 or
per 10 m3 are specified along with the rates of material and labour as on the base
year of the schedule of rates. The coefficient for material carriage is also specified in
them. The working for this example is based on per m3basis according to the Delhi
Schedule of Rates for the base year 2007.
48
24
3/24/2022
49
Problem 1
• Calculate the rough cost estimate for a 1st class building having plinth area 500 sq. m.
Make necessary addition for public health and electric services.
• Solution:
• Plinth Area = 500 sq. m.
• Rate per sq.m. = ` 6000/- (assumed)
• Total cost = 500 × 6000 = ` 30,00,000/-
• Add for Public health & Electric services
• @ 20% of the estimate = ` 6,00,000/-
• Cost × percentage/100
• Total = ` 30,00,000 + 6,00,000 = ` 36,00,000.00/-
• (Brief report and brief specifications are also attached as documents with this estimate.)
50
25
3/24/2022
Problem 2
51
Problem 2
52
26
3/24/2022
Problem 3
• Prepare a preliminary estimate for civil works required for establishing a polytechnic
building requiring a total carpet area of 6000 sq.m. This includes actual total area
required for classrooms, labs, office, store etc. Suitable extra provision as 12% of the
carpet area be made for walls, verandah corridors, toilets, staircase etc. The plinth area
rate is ` 900/- sq.m. Suitable extra provision as 8% of building cost for water supply,
10% for electric fittings, 6% for other services, 1.5% for special architectural treatment,
of the building cost is also to be calculated.
53
Solution 3
54
27
3/24/2022
Problem 4
55
Solution 4
56
28
3/24/2022
Problem 5
57
Solution 5
58
29
3/24/2022
Problem 6
• Prepare a rough cost estimate to secure Administrative approval, for a dispensary and
residence with the following data:
• Covered Area of main building = 410 sq.m. @ 4,500/- per sq.m.
• Covered Area of residence = 165 sq.m. @ 4,600/- per sq.m.
• Cost of Land @ 4% of cost of building
• Levelling and dressing of land = 0.5 % of building cost.
• Cost of approach road −3.5 % of building cost
• Services @ 24% of the building cost.
• External Electric fittings and connections = 1% of the building cost
• Contingencies @ 4% of the building cost
Ans. ` 35,67,480.00
59
• With buildings such as warehouses, we can divide the floor area into bays using the
column gridlines to define the size of the bays. A price per typical bay can be compiled
by estimating the cost of all the components that go into its construction. Either the
detailed or assembly method of estimating can be used to arrive at the bay price.
Adjustments may have to be made for any non-typical bays that have to be included,
and the cost of the exterior wall construction is usually accounted for separately. Once
the price of the typical bay is determined, it is multiplied by the number of bays in the
building to obtain the basic building price. Prices for the exterior walls, plumbing and
HVAC, electrical, and site improvements are added to obtain the total estimated price
for the project.
• It is not always possible to use this method since some buildings are not divided into
regular bays. Even with buildings that are laid out in bays, it can be difficult to find a
“typical” bay when each bay can differ in size or have a different combination of
components. Because of this, typical bay estimates are not very common. However, if
typical bays can be identified, this method provides a speedy way to obtain a fairly
accurate estimate price
60
30
3/24/2022
strengths: weaknesses:
• Far more accurate than single-rate • Not all types of buildings can be divided
methods. into regular bays.
• Produces an estimate fairly quickly, but • It is not widely used except for large
more calculations are required than those retail and warehouse-type structures.
needed for single-rate methods. • Accuracy depends on the availability of
• Although little data are published on prices of similar buildings
typical bay costs, prices can be put
together from publications.
• Useful as a means of comparing designs.
• Can be useful as a cost control tool.
61
62
31
3/24/2022
63
• Assembly estimating can be a powerful cost control tool since the nature of the assembly,
materials, and construction methods can all be defined and these data reflected in the
estimated price.
• If a change is made in any aspect of the scope, its impact on price can be determined;
this will allow the owner to make an informed decision about the scope change. Keeping
track of these changes can provide a document trail that helps explain why final costs
differ from initial estimates.
• However, assembly estimating requires at least some design information (specifications),
and accuracy can suffer if assumptions are made that turn out to be wrong. Also, if
composite unit prices are not readily available and have to be calculated, assembly
estimating can be a very time-consuming process.
64
32
3/24/2022
strengths: weaknesses:
• Far more accurate than single-rate • Poor accuracy may result from erroneous
methods. design assumptions.
• Can be used with any building design. • Can involve a lot of calculating if
• Produces an estimate fairly quickly but composite rates have to be developed.
more calculations are required than those
needed for single-rate methods.
• A large amount of data are published.
• Can be used as a means of comparing
designs.
• Very useful as a cost control tool.
65
Example
66
33
3/24/2022
• One final multi-rate option for preparing preliminary estimates is the elemental method.
This is the most sophisticated preliminary estimating technique and provides the greatest
ability to manage the cost of projects from conception to construction.
67
68
34
3/24/2022
Answer
Description Unit Qty Rate Amount
Concrete piles: $950.00 each Nos 1 950 950
Concrete pile caps: $ 725.00 each Nos 1 725 725
Slab-on-grade: $12.50 per sq. ft. sqft 1500 12.5 18750
Structural steel frame: $4.90 per sq. ft. sqft 1500 4.9 7350
Roof structure: $10.75 per sq. ft. sqft 1500 10.8 16125
Roofing: $8.20 per sq. ft. sqft 1500 8.2 12300
Plumbing & HVAC: $9.80 per sq. ft. sqft 1500 9.8 14700
Electrical: $6.10 per sq. ft. sqft 1500 6.1 9150
Cost per Bay 80050
No of bays 50
Total Cost 4002500
Exterior foundations: $100.00 per linear ft. Lft 1100 100 110000
Exterior walls: 728.00 per linear ft. Lft 1100 728 800800
Total Cost of the Building 4913300
69
70
35
3/24/2022
Estimation of
Quantities
Module 2
71
80 cm
Section on A-A
G.L
60cm
– Center Line length = 2x[(4-0.4x2)+(6-0.4x2)] = 16.8m
– Volume = 16.8x0.6x0.8 = 8.064 cu.m 80 cm
72
36
3/24/2022
Earth works
73
Earthworks
Consider another case (Figure). Plain concrete dimensions (1.2 × 2.0 × 0.2 m), reinforced
concrete footings dimensions (0.8 × 1.6 × 0.4 m); depth of excavation 1.2 m and ground
beams cross section is (0.25 × 0.4 m). Find the volume of the excavated material (see
Figure 2.4). Distance between centerlines is 5 m.
74
37
3/24/2022
dm Am L/2
B
L
d1 A1 L/2
75
Earthwork
• Case I. When natural surface level is above full supply level i.e. fully in cutting.
• Case II. When natural surface level is between F.S.L. and Bed level i.e. partly in cutting
and partly in filling.
• Case III. When natural surface level is below bed level i.e. fully in embankment
76
38
3/24/2022
Problem
• Prepare and estimate for the portion of a road between chainage 14 to 22 from the
data given below. The rate of earthwork in cutting is Rs.8.50 per cu.m and embankment
is Rs 7.50 per cu.m. The formation width of the proposed road is 12m, side slope is 1.5:1
in cutting and 2:1 in banking. The road formation is proposed at a uniform falling
gradient 1 in 200 passing through G.L. at chainage 14. Length of one chain is 30m
Chainage (30m) 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
R.L. of Ground 108.6 109.25 109.40 108.85 108.50 107.25 106.8 107.15 107.2
77
Solution
Chainage (30m) 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
R.L. of Ground 108.6 109.25 109.40 108.85 108.50 107.25 106.8 107.15 107.2
R.L of Formation 108.6 108.45 108.3 108.15 108 107.85 107.7 107.55 107.4
78
39
3/24/2022
Profile
14 15 16 17 18 20
19 21 22
79
0.5
30-X
X
0.6
18
19
80
40
3/24/2022
Calculations
81
Calculations
14 0
15 -0.8
16 -1.1
17 -0.7
18 -0.5
19A 0
19 0.6
20 0.9
21 0.4
22 0.2
Total
82
41
3/24/2022
Calculations
14 0 0
15 -0.8 -0.4
16 -1.1 -0.95
17 -0.7 -0.9
18 -0.5 -0.6
19A 0 -0.25
19 0.6 0.3
20 0.9 0.75
21 0.4 0.65
22 0.2 0.3
Total
83
Calculations
14 0 0 0
15 -0.8 -0.4 5.04
16 -1.1 -0.95 12.75
17 -0.7 -0.9 12.02
18 -0.5 -0.6 7.74
19A 0 -0.25 3.09
19 0.6 0.3 3.78
20 0.9 0.75 10.12
21 0.4 0.65 8.64
22 0.2 0.3 3.78
Total
84
42
3/24/2022
Calculations
14 0 0 0 0
15 -0.8 -0.4 5.04 30
16 -1.1 -0.95 12.75 30
17 -0.7 -0.9 12.02 30
18 -0.5 -0.6 7.74 30
19A 0 -0.25 3.09 14
19 0.6 0.3 3.78 16
20 0.9 0.75 10.12 30
21 0.4 0.65 8.64 30
22 0.2 0.3 3.78 30
Total
85
Calculations
14 0 0 0 0 0 0
15 -0.8 -0.4 5.04 30 151.2
16 -1.1 -0.95 12.75 30 382.61
17 -0.7 -0.9 12.02 30 360.45
18 -0.5 -0.6 7.74 30 232.20
19A 0 -0.25 3.09 14 43.31
19 0.6 0.3 3.78 16 60.48
20 0.9 0.75 10.12 30 303.7
21 0.4 0.65 8.64 30 259.3
22 0.2 0.3 3.78 30 113.4
86
43
3/24/2022
Final Estimate
Unit Amount
No. Item Quantity Unit
Rate (Rs.)
Total 15470.44
87
Problem
• Estimate the quantity and cost of earthwork for a road between two stations A to B with
the following data-
• Width for road is 10m at formation surface. Side slope is 2:1 rate for earthwork in
banking and cutting. Rate of earthwork may be taken as Rs 10.00per cubic meter
included a lead up to a 150 m with a condition that portion of earthwork available from
cutting is to be utilized for banking within the same lead of 150 m. the data of field
book for the portion of road are as below [one chain =30 m]
88
44
3/24/2022
Solution
785 1954.5
89
Solution
• Since qty of earthwork in cutting from 0 to 2.14 chainage may be utilized in banking
within a range of 150m lead, balance quantity of earthwork required for banking =
1954.5 – 785.8 = 1168.7 cum
• Total qty of earthwork to be aid = 785.8 + 1168.7 = 1954.5 cum
• Cost of earthwork @ Rs 10.00per cubic meter = 1954.5 * 10 = Rs. 19545.00
90
45
3/24/2022
Problem
• Prepare and estimate for the portion of a road between chainage 10 to 18 from the
data given below. The rate of earthwork in cutting is Rs. 20.50 per cu.m and
embankment is Rs 24.50 per cu.m. The formation width of the proposed road is 14m,
side slope is 1.8:1 in cutting and 2.4:1 in banking. The road formation is proposed at a
uniform falling gradient 1 in 180 passing through G.L. at chainage 10.
Chainage (30m) 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
R.L. of Ground 109.9 110.55 110.7 110.15 109.8 108.55 108.1 108.45 108.5
91
Cross Section
Superstructure Wall
3.5 m 20 cm
2.5 cm. DPC
Plinth Level
60 cm 30 cm
G.L
30 cm Plinth Wall
20 cm 40 cm Second Footing
20 cm 50 cm First Footing
20 cm Lime Concrete
70 cm PLAN
92
46
3/24/2022
Estimate
Item
Description No Length Breadth Height Qty Unit
No
1 Earthwork in Excavation
Lime Concrete in
2
Foundation
Brickwork in
3
Foundation and Plinth
First Footing
Second Footing
Plinth Wall
Total
Brickwork in
4
Superstructure Wall
5 2.5 cm thick DPC
93
PLAN
Cross Section
Superstructure Wall
3.5 m 20 cm
2.5 cm. DPC
Plinth Level
60 cm 30 cm
G.L
30 cm Plinth Wall
20 cm 40 cm Second Footing
20 cm 50 cm First Footing
20 cm Lime Concrete
70 cm
94
47
3/24/2022
Estimate
Item
Description No Length Breadth Height Qty Unit
No
1 Earthwork in Excavation
2 Lime Concrete in Foundation
Brickwork in Foundation and
3
Plinth
First Footing
Second Footing
Plinth Wall
Total
Brickwork in Superstructure
4
Wall
5 2.5 cm thick DPC
95
PLAN
Cross Section
Superstructure Wall
3.5 m 20 cm
2.5 cm. DPC
Plinth Level
60 cm 30 cm
G.L
30 cm Plinth Wall
20 cm 40 cm Second Footing
20 cm 50 cm First Footing
20 cm Lime Concrete
70 cm
96
48
3/24/2022
Estimate
Item
Description No Length Breadth Height Qty Unit
No
1 Earthwork in Excavation 1 5 0.7 0.9 3.15 cu.m
2 Lime Concrete in Foundation 1 5 0.7 0.2 0.7 cu.m
Brickwork in Foundation and
3
Plinth
First Footing 1 5 0.5 0.2 0.5 cu.m
Second Footing 1 5 0.4 0.2 0.4 cu.m
Plinth Wall 1 5 0.3 0.9 1.35 cu.m
Total 2.25 cu.m
Brickwork in Superstructure
4 1 5 0.2 3.5 3.5 cu.m
Wall
5 2.5 cm thick DPC 1 5 0.2 1 sq.m
97
Buffers
GL
Side Slope
Working Space
98
49
3/24/2022
Excavation Support
• Supports need to be used when the area is congested and side slopes cannot be formed
• Example
• Sheet Piling,
• Soldier Piles and Horizontal Sheeting
• Diaphragm Wall
99
Excavation Support
100
50
3/24/2022
Piling BOQ
SL. NO. PARTICULARS UNIT RATE QUANTITY
1.2 Providing and concreting Of bored cast in situ end bearing piles conforming to IS 2911, Part l, with M30
Concrete (minimum cement content as per IS 456 as specified in the structural drawings which ever is more)
through tremie pipe; including use Of plasticisers and other additives as approved, to correct level, withdrawing
the steel casing pipe as directed etc.; including finishing Of pile heads as per specifications, and completing as
per drawings and specifications, all complete to the satisfaction of the PMC. (Concreting of piles to be carried
out 600mm above the cut Off level which not be paid.) Note: After lowering the reinforcement cage and tremie
pipe, the borehole shall be thoroughly cleaned by continuous circulation of fresh bentonite slurry to remove all
the debris from shaft bottom. The concreting shall be immediately carried out after the cleaning.
a. 600mm dia, capacity 180 Tonne Rmt 2936
b. 1000mm dia, capacity 500 Tonne Rmt 8203
1.3 Empty Boring measured from the existing ground level to the cut-off levels the piles. Further it shall be filled with
approved dry sand.
a. 600mm dia Rmt 294
b. 1000mm dia Rmt 1231
1.4 Providing and fixing steel RCC. including transporting, de- coiling, straightening, cutting, bending, and placing in
position at all levels and binding with approved quality G.l. annealed binding wire of 18 gauge for end
bearing cast-in-situ piles conforming to IS 2911,Part I with correct size PVC cover blocks or approved concrete
cover blocks of same grade as of concrete. The rate shall include cost of binding wire, chairs, spacers, pins,
which will not be measured separately for payment. Quantity Of steel as per bar bending schedule as
approved by the PMC and with authorized overlaps only shall be measured and paid for. Further include where
required carryout dewatering, provide required labour and machines/ equipments/ tools/ tackles
a. High yield strength deformed TMT bars conforming to IS 1786 - Fe 500 MT 846
101
Piling BOQ
BILLS OF QUANTITIES
SL. NO. PARTICULARS UNIT RATE QUANTITY AMOUNT
1.5 Providing, conducting Of routine Dynamic high strain testing pile Driving analyser by a
1.5 percent of capacity of pile with a fall varying from 1m to 3m including preparing
head, providing ply and steel plates, fixing strain gauges etc. all conforming to
ASTMD4945. Further include evaluating and submitting report covering:
i) True static capacity of the pile at the time of testing
ii) Simulated static load test curve
iii) Total skin friction and end bearing of pile
iv) Skin friction variation along the length of the pile
v) Compressive and tensile stresses developed in pile during testing
vi) Net and total displacement of the pile
vii) Pile integrity
all complete to satisfaction of the PMC for followings
a. 600mm dia, capacity 180 Tonne Nos. 5
b. 1000 dia, capacity 500 Tonne Nos. 13
1.6 Providing, conducting and submission documented report on RCC bored pile integrity
test using pile integrity tester on completion of required setting of piles, preparation of
heads, mobilising and demobilising of equipments all complete. Report should include
graphical wave form, interpretation of results, cross sectional or material changes if any
in, length of pile, concrete quantity etc. all complete conforming to ASTMD5882 and to
satisfaction of the PMC. (Routine test - Samples shall be chosen by PMC at random )
a. 600mm dia, capacity 180 Tonne Nos. 5
b. 1000 dia, capacity 500 Tonne Nos. 5
102
51
3/24/2022
Other Consideration
• Dewatering
• If ground water level is too high. Pump the water out
• Piling
• Number of Piles
• Bored vs Driven etc
• Paving
• Flexible or Rigid
• Landscaping
• Number and Type of Trees
103
Estimating
Concrete and Masonry
Module 2
104
52
3/24/2022
105
1. Form Preparation
2. Embedded Unit Placement
3. Concrete Placement
4. Curing
5. Form Removal
106
53
3/24/2022
Name Role
1. Carpenter Formwork
107
Equipment
108
54
3/24/2022
Alternative Checklist
Item Consideration
1. Material Cement, Sand etc
109
Formwork
• Types
• Wall forms
• Slab/Beam/Column Forms
• High-Rise Forms
• Materials
• Plywood, Aluminium
110
55
3/24/2022
Formwork Types
Table Forms Ply Forms
111
Supporting
112
56
3/24/2022
8m
0.3 m
6m
113
Solution
L B
SNo Item No D Units Qty
(m) (m)
1 Wall Forms
114
57
3/24/2022
Footing formwork
7.7 m
5.7 m
7.7+0.9/2+0.9/2=8.6 m
7.7-
0.9=6.8 m
5.7- 5.7+0.9/2+0
0.9=4.8 m .9/2=6.6 m
5.7+0.9/2+0.9/2=6.6 m
7.7+0.9/2+0.9/2=8.6 m
115
Solution
L B
SNo Item No D Units Qty
(m) (m)
1 Footing Forms
116
58
3/24/2022
117
• Approximately the quantity of steel for a R.C.C. member can be calculated as below;
when detailed drawings and designs are not available.
• For lintel and slab: Quantity of steel = 0.7 to 1% of quantity of concrete (m3)
• For beams: Quantity of steel = 1 to 2 %
• For columns: Quantity of steel = 1 to 5%
• For foundation and footing: Quantity of steel = 0.5 to 0.8%
118
59
3/24/2022
BBS
• For guidance of supervisors and laborers it is provided. It is list of the reinforcement bars
give in tabular form as below:
• It is the list of reinforcement bars in tabular form giving the particulars of bars, shape of
bending with sketches, length of each bar, total length and total weight for each R.C.C.
work, a schedule of bar or bar bending schedule is prepared. From this requirement of
different size and length of bars may be known and bent up during the time of
construction.
Bar Bending Schedule, commonly referred to as “BBS” is a comprehensive list that describes the
location, mark, type, size, length and number, and bending details of each bar or fabric in
a Reinforcement Drawing of a Structure.
119
120
60
3/24/2022
121
122
61
3/24/2022
Rebar
123
Cover blocks
• cover blocks were provided to bottom reinforcement. Concrete cover for steel bar is
much necessary to protect the steel against corrosion (rusting) and to provide resistance
against fire.
124
62
3/24/2022
Stools
• Stools are commonly used to maintain a cover between top and bottom reinforcements
bars. It is used in arrangement of reinforcement bars of slabs. As we are walking on the
top reinforcement mesh stools should strength enough to bear the load without changing
the gap of two layers.
125
126
63
3/24/2022
Steel
• Reinforced concrete is a composite material, hence a proper bond between the two
materials – concrete and reinforcement – is the first requirement. A minimum length of
reinforcing bar is needed to develop the full bond strength between concrete and steel.
This length is expressed in terms of development length.
127
128
64
3/24/2022
Steel
• Reinforcing bars have limited lengths for ease of handling and transporting; hence in
case of a continuous member or a member of large span it is necessary for continuity to
join two bars by overlapping the ends at the joint. The overlapping portion are joined
together either by concrete itself by providing proper development length or by welding
in case of limitation of length for overlapping. Such jointing of two bars for continuity of
reinforcing bar at any section is called splicing.
129
130
65
3/24/2022
131
BBS
132
66
3/24/2022
Reinforcement
133
Reinforcement
L bend length is 5d
134
67
3/24/2022
No of stirrups
Number of bars:
• Suppose the spacing of stirrups is 150 c/c and the length along which they are placed is
6800 mm, we can find the number of bars by the formula below:
#$ℎ 6800
+ 1 = ()* +, * → + 1 = 46.33
& $ 150
• In this case, we always round up. Hence, we require 47 stirrups.
For stirrups:
• 90 degree hook: Length of stirrup = (2A + 2B) + 20 x dia
• 135 degree hook: Length of stirrup = (2A + 2B) + 24 x dia
135
Lap length
• Normally, steel bars have a 6m length. If length of a bar is not enough to keep
the reinforcement, we have to lap two steel bars.
• Normally, lapping position is at where near the minimum shear force is acting.
• Normally lap length is 50D meaning 50 times the bar diameter if both bars are of same
diameter.
• When lapping two bars of different diameters, the lap length is considered as 50 times
the smaller diameter.
136
68
3/24/2022
Cutting Length
• We must remember that steel is ductile in nature and is subject to elongation. Hence, the
length of a bar is increased when bends or hooks are introduced. Hence, certain
deductions are needed to offset this increase in length.
Cutting Length = True Length of a bar – Deductions
• For 45 degree
Cutting length = Total length – 1 x Dia of bar x No. of bends
• For 90 degree
Cutting length = Total length – 2 x Dia of bar x No. of bends
137
Example Problem
Consider a beam of clear length of 4m, 300mm wide by 450mm depth. It consists of 2-12
diameter bars at top, and 2-16 diameter and 1 – 12 diameter bars at the bottom.
Diameter of stirrup is 8mm spaced at 180mm center to center and provided between walls
or support for a beam. Clear cover to reinforcement provided is 40mm.
138
69
3/24/2022
Example
139
BBS
#$ℎ 4000
+1= + 1 = 24
& $ 180
140
70
3/24/2022
BBS
1 B1 16 2 4540 14.5
2 B2 12 1 4681 4.02
3 T1 12 2 4380 7.80
4 S1 8 24 1372 13
141
Hook Length
142
71
3/24/2022
Precasting
• Types
• Precast Panels, Slabs
• Precast Joists
• Tilt-Up Walls
• Precast Beams, Columns
• Prices are set based on the
economics of the yard and
transportation
• Pre-stressing also adds to the
cost
143
Masonry Components
• Masonry Units
• Bricks, blocks etc
• Mortar
• Cement, Lime and Sand
• Grout
• Can fill cells in hollow units,
or between units
• Accessory Materials
• Reinforcement, Sealants,
vapour barriers
144
72
3/24/2022
Masonry
145
Estimating Finishes
146
73
3/24/2022
Waterproofing
• Membrane
• Fluid
• Sheet
• Bituminous
• Bentonite Clay
• Cementitious Waterproofing
147
Insulation
• Rigid Insulation
• Sheets or Boards made out of Polystyrene, Glass fiber etc
• Foamed Insulation
• Foam boards made of Urethane etc
148
74
3/24/2022
149
150
75
3/24/2022
151
Acoustical Treatment
152
76
3/24/2022
153
Tutorial
Estimation
154
77
3/24/2022
Problem 1
Typical plan and sections views of a building footing and foundation wall are given in figures.
a. Determine the amount of earth that will be removed from the site.
b. Determine amount of formwork required to pour footings, walls and slab.
155
Problem 1
156
78
3/24/2022
157
Solution
158
79
3/24/2022
Solution
b. Formwork calculations:
• Footing outer strip: 2 (25.6 + 10.6) x 0.3 = 21.7 m2.
• Footing inner strip: 2 (24 + 9) x 0.3 = 19.8 m2.
• Walls outer strip: 2 (25 + 10) x (18.2 – 16.7) = 105 m2.
• Walls inner strip: 2 (24.6 + 9.6) x (18.2 – 16.7) = 102.6 m2.
• No formwork is needed for the slab.
• Total formwork needed: 21.7 + 19.8 + 105 + 102.6 = 249.1 m2.
• Note: Calculations are made assuming that first walls are poured than slab is poured.
159
Problem 2
The following width of road embankment is 10m. The side slopes are 2:1. The depth along
the centre line road at 50m intervals are 1.25, 1.10, 1.50, 1.20, 1.0,1.10, 1.15m calculate
the Quantity of earth work by
a. Mid sectional rule
b. Trapezoidal rule
c. Prismoidal rule
160
80
3/24/2022
Solution 2
161
Solution 2
• Trapezoidal rule
162
81
3/24/2022
Solution 2
• By Prismoidal rule
163
Problem 3
• Estimate the Quantity of earth work for a portion of road from the following data
• The formation level at Chainage 0 is 8.0 and having falling gradient of 1 in 100. The
top width is 12m and side slopes 1½ horizontal to 1 vertical assuming the transverse
direction is in level calculate the quantity of earth work Take 1 chain = 20m by using
trapezoidal & Prismoidol formula.
164
82
3/24/2022
Calculations
Total
165
Solution 3
166
83
3/24/2022
Solution 3
• b = 12m
• n = 1.5
167
Solution 3
168
84
3/24/2022
Solution 3
169
Problem 4
Calculate the quantities of items of the stair case of the figure shown in below:
• Landing, Waist slab & toe wall – RCC
• Steps in Brickwork, 20mm thick plaster finish
• 2.5cm nosing
170
85
3/24/2022
Problem 4
Calculate the quantities of items of the
stair case of the figure shown in below:
• Landing, Waist slab & toe wall –
RCC
• Steps in Brickwork, 20mm thick
plaster finish
• 2.5cm nosing
171
0.5* 0.25*
0.15
172
86
3/24/2022
173
Problem 5
174
87
3/24/2022
Solution
Bricks Mortar
• Total Wall Length = 35m • Volume of Mortar required =
• Total Wall Area = 35x3.4 = 119 sqm (7500/1000) x 0.29 x 1.15 (wastage) =
2.5cu.m
• Total Area of Windows = 6x2 sqm =
12sqm • Quantity of Cement = 2.5 x 250 =
625kg
• Total Area of Doors = 2x1.8x2.4 =
8.64sqm • Quantity of Lime = 2.5 x 67 kg =
167.5kg
• Hence Total wall area to be filled by
bricks = 119-(12+8.64) = 98.36sqm
• No. of bricks required = • Quantity of sand = 2.5 x 1.3 = 3.25cu.m
98.36x74x1.03(wastage)= 7497 bricks.
You are therefore likely to order 7500
bricks.
175
Problem 6
• Prepare the bar bending schedule of the given figure for R.C.C. Lintel
Cover is 25mm
12mm Bars
176
88
3/24/2022
Solution
177
Solution
2x12x6
178
89
3/24/2022
Problem
• Prepare the bar bending schedule of the given figure for R.C.C. beam.
2-12dia
• Clear Cover
• Bottom = 25mm 500
• Top=25mm 4-16dia
• Ends=32mm 6mm dia stirrups Anchor Bars 2
@210c/c Nos – 12 dia 2-12dia 230
2-12dia +
2-16dia
500
2-16dia+
2-12 dis
600 4-16dia 500
6 dia@400c/c
2-16dia
230
179
Solution
2x12x6
180
90
3/24/2022
Problem
230
6 dia@180 c/c
Straight without hooks
8 dia@170 c/c
Bars with hooks
230 230
230
181
Solution
182
91
3/24/2022
Problem
• Excavation • 12mm Interior and Exterior Plaster
• Cement Concrete in Foundation • 10 cm thick lime terracing on the roof
• Brickwork in Foundations and Plinth Wall • Doors and Windows
• Brickwork in superstructure • 6mm thick plaster on the ceiling
• RCC work on the roof • 2.5 cm artificial stone flooring
183
Rates
184
92
3/24/2022
Rate Unit of
Item Description Quantity Unit Amount
(Rs.) Rate
1 Excavation 10.422 cu. M 7 cu.m 72.954
2 Cement Concrete 3.552 cu. M 700 cu.m 2486.4
3 Brickwork in Foundations and Steps 9.616 cu. M 650 cu.m 6250.4
4 Brickwork in Superstructure 15.45 cu.M 665 cu.m 10274.25
5 RCC for roof and lintel 3.0492 cu.M 980 cu.m 2988.216
6 12mm Plaster 124.5 sq. m 12.5 sq.m 1556.25
7 10 cm lime terracing on roof 15.96 sq. m 85 sq.m 1356.6
8 Steel Door 2.52 sq. m 680 sq.m 1713.6
9 6 mm plaster on ceiling 28.08 sq. m 10.5 sq.m 294.84
10 2.5 cm Artifical stone flooring 14.4 sq. m 38 sq.m 547.2
Total Rs. 27540.71
185
Problem
186
93
3/24/2022
Problem
187
Problem
188
94
3/24/2022
Solution
189
190
95
3/24/2022
191
192
96
3/24/2022
193
194
97
3/24/2022
195
PROJECT COST
MANAGEMENT
PMBOK Chapter 7.1,7.2
196
98
3/24/2022
197
198
99
3/24/2022
• Learning curve theory states that when many items are produced repetitively, the unit cost of
those items decreases in a regular pattern as more units are produced
• Reserves are monies included in a cost estimate to mitigate cost risk by allowing for future
situations that are difficult to predict
• Contingency reserves allow for future situations that may be partially planned for
(sometimes called known unknowns) and are included in the project cost baseline
• Management reserves allow for future situations that are unpredictable (sometimes called
unknown unknowns)
199
199
Important Terms
200
100
3/24/2022
Important Terms
• Circulation Area: Area used for movement i.e. verandah, staircase, corridor, balconies
etc. is termed as circulation area. Circulation area is approximately equal to plinth area
minus carpet area.
• Premium and Rebate: The tendered percentage rate above the notified rates is called
Premium while the tendered rate below the notified rates is called Rebate. The premium
depends upon the current price index and is decided by a team of Chief Engineers and
Superintending Engineers from time to time, and the notified rates are rates approved in
“Schedule of rates’’.
201
Wastes in Estimation
202
101
3/24/2022
COST MANAGEMENT
203
Executing
Processes
Process
Knowledge
Area Monitoring &
Initiating Planning Executing Closing
Control
Cost Estimating
Cost Cost Budgeting
Cost Control
204
102
3/24/2022
Resource Planning
• The objective here is to prepare different resources schedule such as labour and staff
schedule, material schedule, plant and equipment schedule, and subcontractor or
specialist’s schedule. As mentioned earlier, these schedules show the quantity requirement
of each of these resources either on a weekly basis or on a monthly basis. The basis for
preparing these schedules is the project time schedule
205
1- Resource Planning
INPUTS
• Involves determining what physical resources (people, equipment, materials etc) and what
quantities of each should be used to perform project activities.
1. Work Breakdown Structure:
A deliverable-oriented grouping of project elements that organizes and defines
the total scope of the project. It Identifies the project elements that will need resources.
2. Historical Information
3. Scope Statement:
Contains the project justification and the project objectives.
4. Resource Pool Description:
Knowledge of what resources are potentially available.
5. Organizational Policies:
The policies of the performing organization regarding staffing and the rental or
purchase of supplies and equipment.
206
103
3/24/2022
• Expert Judgment
• Alternative identifications:
To adopt different approaches for the same problem.
207
208
104
3/24/2022
209
3
ENTERPRISE 1
PROJECT
ENVIRONMENT Other Information
FACTORS (EEF) MANAGEMENT
PLAN
1. Org. Culture & Structure that influences cost 4
2. Market Conditions ORGANIZATIONAL
3. Currency exchange for international projects PROCESS 2 Summary Budget,
4. Published & Commercially Available Info ASSETS PROJECT Approval requirements
5. Project Management Information System (OPA) CHARTER
TOOLS &
TECHNIQUES
1. EXPERT JUDGMENT
• Financial controls procedures 2. ANALYTICAL TECHNIQUES –
• Historical information & lessons learned funding with equity, debt,
OUTPUT
• Financial databases; and OUTPU buy, rent, purchase, IRR, NPV,
• Existing formal & informal cost estimating T Payback
& budgeting policies COST 3. MEETINGS
MANAGEMENT
PLAN
210
105
3/24/2022
• Describes how the project costs will be planned, structured & controlled.
• Cost management plan can establish:
• Units of Measure : kms, sqm etc
• Level of Precision : degree to which cost to be rounded off
• Level of Accuracy : Acceptable range
• Organizational Procedures Links : WBS framework, control account
• Control Thresholds: Agreed amount of variation
• Rules of Performance Measurement: define points in WBS
• Reporting Formats : Cost reports, cash flow
• Process Descriptions : each of the processes are documented
• Additional details such as description of strategic funding choices, procedure to account for
fluctuation in currency exchange & cost reporting
211
2. ESTIMATE COSTS
Plan Cost Management: Inputs, Tools & Techniques, & Outputs
Cost Estimating involves developing an assessment of the likely quantitative result-how much will it cost the
performing organization to provide the product or service involved.
Pricing is a business decision-how much will the performing organization charge for the product or service
212
106
3/24/2022
2. ESTIMATE COSTS
1. Market Conditions 6 3
1
2. Published Commercially Info ENTERPRISE SCOPE
COST 4
ENVIRONMENT BASELINE WBS Dictionary
MANAGEMENT PROJECT
FACTORS (EEF)
PLAN SCHEDULE
7
5 ORGANIZATIONAL 2
RISK PROCESS H.R.
REGISTER ASSETS (OPA) MANAGEMENT
PLAN
213
214
107
3/24/2022
6. Reserve Analysis
Contingency Reserves are the budget within cost baseline that is allocated for
identified risks. It is often viewed as part of the budget to address the “known-
unknowns” that can affect a project. It may be a percentage of the estimated cost, a
fixed number, or may be developed by using quantitative analysis methods.
7. Cost of Quality (COQ) – it cost less to prevent quality issue than to fix it
8. Project Management Software – Computerized spreadsheets, simulation, and
statistical tools are used to assist with cost estimating.
9. Vendor Bid Analysis – Cost estimates can be based on the responsive bids from
qualified vendors
10. Group Decision-Making Techniques
Team based approaches, such as brainstorming, the Delphi or Nominal Group
Techniques are useful for engaging team members to improve estimate accuracy &
commitment to the estimates.
215
BASIS OF The amount and type of additional details supporting the cost estimates vary
ESTIMATES by application area.
Supporting detail may include:
• Documentation of the basis of the estimate (how it was developed),
• Documentation of all assumptions made,
• Documentation of any known constraints,
• Indication of the range of possible estimates (like +/- 10%) to indicate
that the item is expected to cost between a range of values, and
• Indication of the confidence level of the final estimate.
216
108
3/24/2022
• Analogous Estimating / Top-down Estimating: Using the actual cost of a previous, similar project
as the basis for estimating the cost of the current project. It is less costly but less accurate. (Rough-
cost Estimate). Managers use expert judgment or similar project costs [quick, less accurate]
• Parametric Modeling: Using project characteristics (parameters) in a mathematical model to
predict project costs. Use mathematical model (i.e. cost per sq ft). [accuracy varies] Two types:
• Regression analysis – based on analysis of multiple data points
• Learning Curve – The first unit costs more than the 100th, forecasts efficiency gains
• Bottom-up Estimating: Estimating the cost of individual work items, then summarizing or rolling up
the individual estimates to get a project cost. (Detailed Estimate). People doing work estimate
based on WBS, rolled up into project estimate [slow, most accurate]
• Computerized Tools: Use of computerized tools such as project management software and
spreadsheets to assist with cost estimating.
• Vendor Bid Analysis – Estimating using bids + allowances for gaps in bid scope [slow, accuracy
depends on gaps]
• Reserve Analysis – Adding contingency to each activity cost estimates as zero duration item [slow,
overstates cost]
217
Types of Cost
• Variable Costs
• Change with the amount of production/work
• e.g. material, supplies, wages
• Fixed Costs
• Do not change as production change
• e.g. set-up, rental
• Direct Costs
• Directly attributable to the work of project
• e.g. team travel, recognition, team wages
• Indirect Costs
• overhead or cost incurred for benefit of more than one project
• e.g. taxes, fringe benefit, janitorial services
218
109
3/24/2022
Estimate Accuracy
Rough Order of
Magnitude • Most difficult to estimate as very little project info is
+/- 50%
available, made during initiating process
(ROM)
Definitive -5%
• During the project and refined
Estimate 10%
219
110