VOLUSIA GOUNTY MEDICAL EXAMINER'S OFFICE
nanng,_CAR A AT, ep caseno,_2/rofot ¥
. ase pace ox pare ony_Z14 [ol
grant rime_0B 30
E-0036-0509OPFICE OF THE MEDICAL EXAMINER
FLORIDA, DISTRICTS 7 & 2+
VOLUSIA & ORKINOLE COMNTZES -
A960 THDTAM LAME ROAD, DATSONA BEACH, Fi 33224-2061
(904) 280-4060
wot eanoy, nape pag A aay
MOE 49 Dow __ BRAT 20. 3952 RACK SEX _M_ comty __yauusra __
DATE DEATH (FOUND) _ERRROARY 10, 700% GATE OF SOUH_RRDAVARY 22, 300, TIME_oDi EBS,
GROSS AEATOMEC DIAGKOSES
FRpnNs: 2. Blunw foree injuries.
A. Read and neck.
2. Ring feactuce of base of kell.
Ring includes eccipical bone, diastatic: fracture ox Daleceral
Scclpitonsstoid sutures, fractures af the clivua behind the
dorsum sella and through the body of che ophaneid Bone
Shougn the lesser wing Gritm preservation Of che bypoprysial
os:
b. Aasoctaced subarachgoid and epidural heporchage
€! Hild cdeae Of the postecior etelpitad Lobos and poacericz
temporal lobes bilsrerally.
2. Abrapion, right side of chin.
3. Contusies sf left occipital scalp.
B. Tezao.
1. Rib fractures.
a. Left ribs % through 4 fractured anterierly.
bl. Daft fib 9 fractured laterally.
2. Practure of 3" atornebra.
3. Supereceial abrasions.
<. Extremities.
2. Fracture of eft ankle (with fracture
2) superticial abrasions
T1. enolerithinets.
‘ioual fibula).
FINAL DIAQROSIS
CAUSE OF DEATH: Blunt Force injuries of the Mead.
motor Whole Aectdent, &
Rotident.
SPECIAL STUDIRG: (See act page off report
RE: State Attorasy’a Office
Daytana Bauch Police Department
DATE
KESOCIATE NEDTEAL EXAMINER/Thomae A. Parsons, o.D-
THIS DOCUMENT HAG MOT BEEN ROVIRWDD Ok COARECTED bY TH FHYOICEAM, AND KAY CONTAIN ERRORS
AND/OR ONTSSIONS WHICH MAY Of MAY hor ANFECT THR FIVAL REPORT.OFFICE OF TIE MEDICKL XAKINER
DISTRICTS 7 & 24
PAGE 2 OF ¢
wom mamernet, pate pare 0 _aoogy
REPORT OF AUTOPSY
EATREMAL EXAMTHATION
Recoived is the wnombaleed, symmetrically developed. adequately nourished and
hydrated, of an adele-waite male appearing approximately his reported age
ot 42 years, Tne lengch 40 63 inches. whe weight 10 108 ~The body ie
gool ta the touch and has béen previously refrigurated. Rigor martin is fully
developed in the Msolee of the jav and oxtremities. Uersal livor mortia is
gperod in orcan expoacd to Presdure, and blanchey ube Cin vrecgure. the
cranium is symmetrically developed, with browm scalp hair moscuring up to 10 ce
Sa'lengtn. “There io no palpable eropitus over the bridge of che nase. The
eyebress ore intact. These is ag conguocion or petechial henozrhages within the
palpabya! oz bulbar conjunctivac. The irides are blue. ‘the pupfle aré round.
tqual, coneral and ceasure } mm. The pagal septum is intact and in the
ayprowteste eidiine. Over cho upper lip io a well groazed, broyn haty sustacke.
The remaining cheeks, chin, and nock ate clean-ohavan, Tae external sare are
vnmrenarsable, with no foreign saterial in the external auditory canals, ‘There
ie sbundet blood ia the external auditory canaig bilaterally. Dentition i¢
natural and tn 4 good state of ic. There age no oxal puceal mcceal
njusies, ‘The neck ss symatrically developed, wichove unusual jeasse= palpable.
The treches {2 palpated in the midline. rhe checc is synotricelly developed.
ae abdonen i soft and without palpable mncucc or orgsneregaly. The externa)
genitaliz ure thove of a circumiged adult mile with bilarera!ly desconded testec
Palpable within the écrocue, The snug and perineal region are grossly
Snremixkable. ‘The lower extvanitics axe symmetrically developed and are without
an absence of digits. Attachad to the left great toe ia a cardboard
dentification tug witch 1s dneerined with whe secedent’s identifying
information. {neluding the name “Ralph Karnharde", Snedroling ‘tha right ankle
‘& hospital identification bracelet vnich is inscribed with the name “Joho
Pacific boo. Attached co the right great toa by a piece of otring ia a hospital
identification dick which hac the camo mana on it. Tho laft ankle haa @
dioplaced fracture with contusion, deacribed further subsequently {g¢¢ EVIDENCE
Or INURY). A white plastic identification bracelet encizclea the left wrist
with the nama ‘Dale Parsharde' on ie. Tha upper axtrenitien ara oymmetrionily
developed and are Without an absence of digits. The gingernails are of mediuna
leageh. vithoue Underlying aire, Gebris, hair, or Cigoue. There ave no absent
fingerpaaia. ‘There ic no tearing of tha fingornaile on the loft hand. There io
no acute tearing of the fingernaile on the right a D
money op smear a mune rane ae gram ORAET 1
endotracheal tube essnates from the vight corner of the mouth. "An rencus
eachater ig secured an che right side ef the neck by black ‘sycure material.
Ghent cuben axe ceaured in tho chect Dilacorally by black suture material. These
are inserted cucansoualy at approximately the Level of the nipploa, just anterior
to the aidaxiilary line. An intwavendug Catheter i¢ decired in the left
aateouhstal foana. Muncrous colf-adhaeiva Bic pads are pyeoent over the anterior
shost bilaterally, over the left lateral abdonen, and left posterior shoulder.
Three needle puncture arks are present over the flexor aspect of the right
fowearm and antecubital feows, ‘Tiere are nunevous needle punctude marks iu the
vight subclavian area and on the left ride of the neck, No other evidence of
therapeutic ancervention is seen on the surface of the body.
SCARS AND IDENTIFYING MARKS: A nearly vertically oriented, 11 cn goar is present
over the left knee, Jateral to the patella. A nearly vortleally ordeuted, well
hoaied, curvilinoar soar is preaont over the wight hice and moapures 22 cx in
fengen’ 2 2 om, vareically orionted. veil healed, curvilinear cear in precast
Svor tho ital nead of Che biceps on the Utero) bapcet of the left ubper axa.
Thexe are ne other convincing ecsre, tattoos, ox identifyaty malin olaerved on
the surface of the Body,
THIS DOCUMENT HAS HOT BREN REVISHED OX CORRECTED py TAS PHYSICIAN. AND MAY CONTAIN RoDrvEOPPICE OF THE MEDICOM FEMCEEER
prsomrems 7 6 24
EAGE 3 OF 6
woot ___KARNARDT. BAER DALE ae eo -ongay
REPORT OF AUTOPSY
SVLDBNCE OF INJURY: Over the right side of the chin jo a 2.5 x 1.0 am,
euperfisial abrasion, ‘Ovex the deft clavicular head io a jh) x 0.6 oD,
superficial abraoien. Over the left hip vegion 1a a nearly trancvorssly
oriented, 10 x 2 om arca of superficial abradion. Over the right hip region 1
A 22 x 5 em arca of fuint superficial abrasions. Over tha mid abdomen is an area
of diffuse purple-red contusion which maacuren 2.0% 4.5 em, Quat infexier to
the umbilicus in the midline ig a 9.3 x 0.4 om lacexation.
ror we inferior left paralla is 2 0.6 x 0-5 on, cupersieiad abravion,
durrounding the palpable dislocation of the left ankle ia a porple-blue area of
contusion which extends from the medial malleolus inferiorly to the ole of the
foct, and from the heel antorievly to the head of the motatarcalc. ‘thia
sontinacs to the agproxizate midline. There if palpable fracture of the distal
jefe fibula included in this dislocatios and txractuxe of the left ankle. -Qvor
the medial head of tha left gustrocnenius ia a faint purpla coneusion MeRPUTIng
4.5 x 3.5 en, Over tho posterior proximal left. forearm ic a 2.0 x 9.8 cm,
pRAF
Through the usual Y-chaped incision, 4.0 cm of yollow eubeutanseus adipsos tisaue
and ooft, ced-hrown musculature are revealed. there Lo generalized congestion
of the subcutaneous tissues and tisculature. The peritoncal cavisy is free of
seers fluid, The onde of tha cheet tuhen aro prevent bilaterally within whe
pleural cavities bilaterally through the 5" intereostal spacca. the onentum and
vasceza are noraaliy disposed. appendix veraifurnit ig intact and grossly
Unremarkable. Tho xight and lefe pleura? cavities have the aasoolated incietons-
without other dafeccs of che pleurae. The reraining pieurae are smooth.
glistening, and purple-gray to red-brown with aroar of dependant congestion, The
Bericardial uae is intact and containa a coant amount of pols yellow, clear
fluid. the pericardial sac iz othevwice unremarkable. Tha mediastinum is
grossly unremarkable.” The sternum ia tranoversely fractured at the 3°
sireatian, « Mage Tube 2 shvough 9 are fractured anteriorly, with sgany hewserhage
surrounding the feactured and. Left rib $ io fractured laterally.
approximately the mid axillary line, There are io fractures of the right ribs.
there arg ao unucual oere.
¥o ether evidence of acute injury is seen externally
aeeayy
CARDIOVASCULLE SYSTEM: The sorta is of normal courge and caliber, hore is Eocal
Sthozonatous ctveaking with miniwal caleifiention distelly. There are fo
ameuryana idewtified. The great vessela have their vsukl anatomical
xelatierehips. The pulmonary arteyiea appoar patent and free of chrorboenboli.
The pulmonary yeino are grogsly unremarkable. the vena caya is groggay
vorenarkable. ‘thu heart wedgha 429 gyama. The epicordial surface ic aseceh,
glistening, and red-bram with medorate asount of yellow subepicaxdial fac.
Tha sorenaty eatia aro patent and give riag toa nertatiy aLstrimuced soroneey
arce system which is xighe dominant. The eoxonazy arteries are thin-
elastic, and ave focal atheromatous streaking, without eignaficant stenosis
Serial ceoticns through the myocardium are firm end red-brown, with RO aEcaa of
softening or fibrosig. The cardiac valves and chanbere ‘have cheiy usual
anatomical relationships. The valvo leaflets are thin end delicate, without
wegetationa. Sections through the acca vf lhe conduction wyeten axe grossly
varenazkable. “
THIS DOCOKENT HAS NOT BERN REVIEWED OR CORRECTED BY THE PMYSECIAN, ANU MAY CONTAIN means
(AND/OR OMISSTONS WHTCH NAY ox MAY Kor arecroe woe oruse ueaeeeOFFICE OF THE YEDICAL EXRHTUBK
Dbisteicré 7 4
oe 7 ad Page 4 oF €
WAMz _.___ RARE BDY_ ALP DALE ___.. ue # _ ft etary
REPORT OF AUTOPST
RESPIRATORY TRACT: The tracho& conteins an appropriately placed endotracheal
tube. A meall amount of Bleod is prasent over the mucosal ourfacee. Tha mucoasl
surfaces of the trachea and main stem bronchi are otherwise groaily unzemarkeble.
The right luag weigno 590 grame. The Jefe lung weighs 660 Srans.! The lungs are
mederately collayocd, with @ pattem of henoaspiretion benesih the pisaral
surfaces. The pleural surfaces are otherwise amooch, glistening, and pimk-tan
to red-browm, Serial sectaene arg pink-tan to red-brown, th areas of dependant
Congestion ana tila Renoaspiration. masa lesiong are noc identificd. Purulent
exidates are not appacent. Emphysamacous changes are inconspicsous.
CASTROINTEETINAL TRACT: The esophagus Su of posal courec and caliber. The
gurfgce of the esophaqus is grosmly unremaxkable. The eoophazus in free of
foreign material. nasogastric tube ic curled atove the level of the epiglortis
End did nov onter inte the stomach, "he mucuoal surface of che evophagus io
grossly unremarkable. Tle seresal surface of the stonach ie grossly
Mnremarkable. the stomach eontaino So cc of bloody fluid, a portion of which {9
reveined. Ho food ox wadications arc identified. The mucoval ourface of the
stomach i grossly unremarkable. The seragai surface of the (Amall bowel ig
groubly unrémarkable. The small bovel contains a moderate amgunt of liquid.
fellow-geeen anterial, Medicatiens are nol appreeiaced. ine mucosa) ourzaco of
the small bowel ig greogly unremarkable. The serosal surface of the colom is
rosely unremarkable. The colon contains a modorate amouht of pasty. greenish
rown decal maceric?. The mucosal surface of Une colon 15 grougly untemarkebie.
WBEATODIGIARY TRACT:.The liver weigho 1640 grams. Tha smooth, glistening,
zed-brown eapsulex surface ie intact. sergai sections are firmi and red-brown,
ith preservation of the nermal hopatic lobular architecture. Steatosie io not
apparent, Fibrosis is imeonspicuous. Hage lesions are not identificd. The
Seilbiedder i, intact and contains 20 cc of davk gYeun, liguid bile, a portion
of which ic retained. ‘there are focal. leas than 2.0 cm. ET ga2lueonas.
The Biliary tract appears tree of ebueruction.
HOMATOPOIBTIC SYSTEM: The spleen weighs 219 grams. BE gray connective
tiggue capsule is intact and slightly wrinkled, jerial sections are soft to
gelatinous and red-brown, ‘There ave ne Mass lesions. she lywpn nodes and beue
marrow ure grossly unremarkable.
RMDOCRINE S¥S7EM: The xight and simflar left adranal glands are of normal size.
shape and position. On cut section. the cortices ara yellow and the nadullas ava
aoft and gray. Thore aré Hd hendtrhagec or waae lesions. The pancreas is of
normal. efze, shape and position. ‘The etrfaca of the pancrdas is grossly
Uncemakable, Soziol sections demansczace preservation of the naxwal paneroatic
lolailar architecture. There are no calcifications ox henorrhages. The thyroid
gleba is of normal size, ahape and position. The ceresal suxface and cut
Sections are grescly unremarkable, The pituitary is ef sornai Gina, ohape and
position.
GENTTOURINARY TRACT: The right and Lefe kidneys weigh 260 grane each. The capaulcs:
scrip with e6¢ te reveal ohooth, dark red-browa carkical surfaces punctuated by
escaosenal fete) lebulationa, There are no cortical eyete, On cut section, the
earticar and medullue are wali denarcatad in thelr recpective acnee. There aro
no bass lesionc. ‘The renal pyzinids are groocly wnresarkable. Tha calicoal
gyytuns ace grossly wurumarkeblo, Stouno A nok identified. Pie uretere are
of uniform eourse and caliber, ‘The rarorai curfaco of the urinary bladdex io
grossly unremarkable. The bladder contains 386 c= of palé yellow, clear urine,
S pergien uf which du rotained, ghe miacosal surrace of the urinary bladder is
getely unremarkable. The prevtave qiand 2 of serael gia, ohapc, and poescson
fo palpation.
NES DOCOMENT MAS HOT SEEN REVIEWED OR CORRECTED BY THE PHYSICIAN, AND MAY COWTAZN ERRORS
(ANB/OR GMISKZONS KEICH MAY OR HAY NOT APFFOr THE Friar, REPORT.OFFICE OF ‘THs MSDTCAL EXAMINER
Dierarers 7 & 26
PAGE 5 OF 6
yor RAT, BALE DAE enon
RRoORT OF AUTOPSY
BAD: Reflecting the scalp demonstrates an 4.0 x 5.5 cm area of contusion on Ehe
Jefe side of the cecipical aceip. This Ls tocluded in tho area of ring fraccure,
which extonde dt the temporal hones and occipital bane, There ie honerzhage
beneath the temporalis quacles bilaterally in the area of she fracture. A feu
other areas of scactersd contusion are present over tbe right sjde of the scalp
and over the vortex, Reflecting the bony calvariue demonstrates epidural ond
Zebasachnoid hemorrhage. ‘There 10 mo eUbdural henorrhage. Subarachnoid
fenormiage is accentuated in the areal surrounding che Cracture and the bags of
the brain. pidural Kenorrhige ia surrounding tho fraccure sitoe
Discolorations of the bony calvarivm arg not appareat. The superior sagittal
sinus end a2 venouy dural sinusas sppoar p2tent and freq of thromboemboli. ‘The
brain in the fresh g¢ate weighs 1450 grams. From the vrertek, the aeebral
Hemigphoren are symmetrical, withoot afgnificunt atvophy. | There ie flatcening
of che gysal curfaces and narrowing or the aici in the pooterigr eecipital
tenporal loban. Antevicrly, there is no evidwise of edema, Tha leptoneringes
ver the urface af the brain and around tho base of the brain are thin and
delicacc, with the previously described subarachnoid hesocchage. Puruleat
exudates are mot appreciated. Thara is ac evidence ef hernaacien of the
hippocampal viel or cerebellar tonsils. The circle of Willis mas Sts usual
anstonica) relationsnipa. Tiece are ne athercnas or anqurysxr progent, gerial
Sexonal ecttions af the cerebral heniepheres denonsteate no grace abnormality of
che gray of white eattor. Macs lesions are not identifiet. -Serfal sagittal
feecions of the cerenellam demonstrate preservation of the normal cavebellar
architecture, There 36 ne gxogs alwounaiity of the dvay oF vhstd matter. Sersa2
transverse aections of the brainsten and midbrain demoatrate evecervation of the
normal architecture. Tnere is no gross abnormality of tho gray or white matter.
399 lesiena are not identified. Stripping the dura Eroa tht bioo of the skull
denonetrates a ring fractere which extends through the occipital bene to the
venporal bode, with Qiastatic fractuve of the orcipitonasteid mutures bilaterally
and with Eracture behind the deveum aaija through the avaa ef the elivua
posteriorly and through the Leaser wing of the sphenoid anteriorly, to bave =
Dreervation of the hypophysis) fosaa, | This ring fracture indludes wide
reparation of whe ving antoriorly (through the ophonoid! bone and the
eeeipicozasteid sutures) and with minimal te co zeparation of the fracture
through tne posterior point ot che ocoipital bone. Although the fracture ie seen
on both thé interns? and outexnel tablea of the peoterdox point of che occipital
heng, thore ie ne separation of the Zractured calvarial plates ag thers ic on che
Zenaining portion of the ring fracture. Examination of the supersoY eozvica:
geinal canai, upon Llexion, extenaion and rokatiogeAf the head, demonat rates no
fractures ox gibluxations.
vice: g0 nyoid none and chyroid oa br). there are no abnormal
collections of extravasated blood overMthe purface of the hyoidlbone or thyroid.
cartilage. Laminar diccection of £N6 otrap nusclea of the Neck doconstrates no
abnormal collactione of oxtravacated blood. succpt in association with the
therapeutic devices and intravenous catheters of the right side of the neck. The
Ficoid cartilage a9 intact ond gxosely unremarkable. The lacynx and hypepharynx
axe freo of foroign natorial. Th: mecesal aurfaees of the Larynx are grocoly
gnremarkable. the epighoctie end vocal cords are grossly unyemarkable
Fosterior dissection of the neck devonstrates no injury to the vertebral arteries
or to the ligamante of the posterior cexvical spina.
MICeocorre AKRON
waiting olides.)
‘THIS DOCUNGNT HAS NOT BURN REVIEWED OR CORRECTED RY THE PHYSICIAN. AND 2Y CONTAIM Raoxs
“ANB/OR OniSéYOns wwrck MAY OR MAY MOT REPECT TUR FIMAL PororT.‘OveICE OF THY KSDIGAL EXAMINER
mrorRreza 7 2 24
PAGE 6 OF ¢
Wu ___RARNHARDN, RALPH DALE 0 ye __p-guy
TOXICOLOGE (Seat to Lab.) oeHALIFAX MEGICAL CENTER
PERSONAL EFFECTS INVENTORY
QUEL OL seep
- pare: SB PSO TIME: _ M
Patedes Name
‘The undersigned hereby cantfies inal ie ‘along personal stects were inventoried as the property of tha above patieat:
bs biaxh =—
wot ee ))
"2, Opie
| Blac faacy OF So
/ placint ond OM Page iy Eh
Inventory Witnodsed By: Inventory Taken By:
(Signature} . walure} .
(Signature)
Thereby acknewtedge receipt of wie abovs parconal steels (oxcoplthode rémbved to Safe).
pare: 22 /B-Of