Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mineralogy and Surface Properties of The Clay Fra-Wageningen University and Research 317389
Mineralogy and Surface Properties of The Clay Fra-Wageningen University and Research 317389
AFFECTING SOILBEHAVIOURANDMANAGEMENT
RobertBrinkman
Department ofSoilScienceandGeology
P.O.Box37,6700AAWageningen,TheNetherlands
Abstract
Themineralcompositionoftheclayfractionisdiscussed intermsof
crystalstructureandofchemicalandphysicalpropertiesrelatedto
mineralogy.Themaintransformationprocessesaffectingtheclayfractionand
theconditionsinwhichtheyoccurarebrieflydescribed.Examplesaregiven
ofrelationsbetweenlandscapeposition,dominanttransformationprocessand
claymineralogy.Differencesbetweensurfacesofclaysandtheirbulk
compositionmayarisenaturally,asexternalconditionschange,andbythe
actionofman.Althoughitisgenerally impracticaltoattemptchangesin
compositionoftheclayfraction,somechangesinsurfacepropertiesare
feasible.Thesemaymaskoralleviateundesirablecharacteristics oftheclay
fractionasawhole.
MINERALOGY AND SURFACEPROPERTIES OFTHE CLAY FRACTION
structureconsiderationsorcontentsofbases,andconsidered theclay
fractiontoconsistofaninorganic,colloidal,hypotheticalsoilacid
(termed,e.g.,pyrophyllicacidbecauseofitssimilarityincompositionto
pyrophyllite).
Weshallneedtoconsiderthecrystallinenatureofthebulkoftheclay
fractioninmanysoils,thepresenceofamorphousorx-rayamorphousmaterial
whichmaydeterminethesurfacepropertiesoftheclayfractions,andthe
importantandrapidchangesthatmayoccurinthesurfaceoftheclay
fraction,evenwhilethebulkofthematerialmayremainsubstantially
unchanged incompositionorstructure.
ThereferencesinthispaperincludeseveralchaptersofabookwhichI
stillconsidertobethebestsinglesourceofinformationonthe/clay
fractionofsoils,alsofornon-claymineralogists:DixonandWeed (eds),
1977.
MINERALCOMPOSITIONOFTHECLAYFRACTION
Thepropertiesofasoilaredetermined toalargeextentbythe
proportionandthenatureoftheclayfraction.Inmostsoils,thisconsists
of
- layersilicates(claymineralsinthestrictsense);
- othercrystallinemineralssuchasquartz,anatase,orpalygorskite(a
magnesium-aluminium silicatewithafibrousstructure),whichwillnotbe
discussedhere;
- ironand,insomecases,aluminiumoxidesandhydroxides,whichmaybe
crystallineoramorphous;
- amorphousorparacrystallinealuminosilicates(allophane,imogolite);
- organiccompoundsassociatedwiththemineralpartoftheclayfractions.
SomepropertiesofthemineralmaterialsaresummarizedinTable 1and
furtherdiscussedbelow.
Mostsoilsinplainscontainanassemblageofclayminerals,whileupland
soilstendtohaveasimplerclaymineralogy.Inbothcases,oneorafewclay
mineralsmaydominatethesoilproperties.
Forpracticalpurposes,twobroadgroupsofclaymineralsmaybe
distinguished:agroupwithpermanentcharge,whichhaveamoderateorhigh
cationexchangecapacity (cec)atallpHvaluesofinterest,andagroupwith
pH-dependentcharge.
Claymineralswithpermanentcharge
Theclaymineralswithpermanentchargehave layersconsistingoftwo
tetrahedralsheetsenclosing anoctahedralsheet:mainlysilicaandmainly
aluminiumormagnesiumoxide,respectively.SubstitutionofAlorFe(HI)for
Siinthetetrahedralsheets,orofMg,KorFe(II)forAlintheoctahedral
sheetcausesthepermanentchargeofthemineral.Theswellingclayminerals
orsmectitessuchasmontmorillonite,beidellite,nontroniteareexamplesof
thisgroup.
Theexchangeablecationsthatcompensatethepermanentchargeare
electrostatically bound totheclaysurfaces;partofthem,aluminiumin
particular,closelyattached tothesurface,theremainderinadiffuselayer,
ratherliketheatmosphereovertheearth'ssurface.Inthenearbypartsof
thislayerthereareveryfewanions,becauseofelectrostatic repulsion,and
thewatermoleculesneartotheclay surfacearefirmlyoriented bythe
electricfield:notfree,likeinwater.Thediffuselayeristhinwherethe
exchangeablecationsarelargelytrivalent(AI)anddivalent (Ca,Mg), and
wherethesoilsolutionisconcentrated. Withincreasingdilution,oran
increasingproportionofmonovalentcations(Na),thediffuselayerbecomes
thicker.
Suchclayscancontainmuchwaterintheirdiffuselayersthatis
unavailabletoplants.InthesmectiteclaysoilsoftheSudanGezira,for
example,moisturedepletionbyplantsstopsatabout25masspercent,while
soilsaturationisatabout36masspercent(Farbrother,1970).Whilewater
canbetransported throughthediffuselayers,albeitslowly,saltscannot
becauseoftheexclusionofanionsfromthem (Smilesand Bond,1984).This
causesalowefficiency ofsaltremovalfromsalineheavyclaysoils:salt
concentrations inthedrainagewaterarelowerthaninthesoilsolution.
Thisisnottheonlyreasonforrelatively lowefficienciesofsalt
removalfromclayswithahighcationexchangecapacity.Mostswellingclay
soilsarestructured,havingpedssurroundedbycracksowingtoshrinkage;
manyalsohavetubularporesthatareduetobioticactivity.AsBoumaandco-
workershaveshowninseveralstudies(referencesinBouma,1984),partofthe
irrigationwaterapplied onastructured clayey soilflowsthroughthelarge
voidsandisdrainedwithoutremovingmorethanasmallfractionofthesalt
withinthepeds:aprocesscalled short-circuiting.Ifsolubleplantnutrients
areappliedtothesoilsurfaceinsuchasystem,partofthesewouldalsobe
-5-
removedbelowtherootingzonebyrainorirrigationwatershort-circuited
throughlargevoids,becauseofinsufficientcontactwiththecationexchange
siteswithinthestructuralelements.
Thesalt-sievingeffectcanbeminimized,butnotentirelyavoided,by
keepingthesaltconcentrationhighforaslongaspossibleandincreasingthe
proportionofdi-andtrivalentcations.Short-circuitingcanbeminimizedor
eliminated byloweringtheratesofwatermovementthroughthesoiltoavoid
saturation,e.g.bylowratesofirrigationwaterapplicationorbypuddling
thesurfacehorizon.
Swellingclaysoilsmaybecomevirtually imperviousbywatersaturation,
forexampleunderwetland rice,orbyexcessiveorfrequentirrigation.
Shrinkagebydryinggenerally restoresthestructureofthesurfacehorizon
andthehydraulicconductivityofthesubsoilhorizonsthroughtheformation
ofanintersectingsystemofcracks.Thisisusefulfordrylandcropsafter
wetland rice,forexample.
Insoilswithhighshrink-swellratios,bulkdensityisprobablynot
limitingforrootpenetration(Jones,1983),incontrasttoothersoils.
Onslopesinwater-saturatedconditions,soilscontainingmainlysmectite
aresubjecttoslowcreepofthesurfacematerialorsuddendeepslumping
alongarotationalplane(IstokandHarward, 1982).
Theswellingclaymineralshaveamoderateproportionofsubstituted
atoms,hencearelatively lowchargedensity.Forthatreason,the
exchangeablecationsareboundonlymoderatelystrongly,spreadoutina
diffuselayer.Eachlayeroftheclaystructurecontributestothecation
exchangecapacityandtotheswellingcharacteristics.
Otherclaymineralswithasimilarstructurehavemuchhigherproportions
ofsubstitution,henceahighchargedensity:illiteandvermiculite.
Thesebindcertaincationswithenoughenergytofixthembetweenadjacent
layersinnon-exchangeable form.ParticularlyionssuchasK,whichfitneatly
inholesintheclaystruture,servetoprodigearigidstackofclaylayers.
Onlytheoutersurfacesand,toavaryingextent,inperfectlyfittinglayers
withinthestackedstructure,thencontributetocationexchange,andthese
claymineralsswellandshrinkmuchlessthanthesmectites.Ontheonehand,
theseclaymineralscontainmuchKwithintheirstructure,andthisbecomes
availabletoplants,butslowly,duringweathering.Ontheotherhand,parts
-6-
oftheclaystructurethataredepletedofKcanveryreadily fixfertilizerK
(Douglas,1977,p.285-287;Borchardt,1977,p.314)whenthisispresentin
temporarilyhighconcentration.Sincetheammonium ionisphysicallyvery
similartopotassium,NH, canalsobefixed byvermiculiteorK-depleted
illite(IRRI, 1983),butsomewhatlessstrongly.
Oneoftheswellingclayminerals,beidellite,hasastructure inwhich
NH^ fitsparticularlywell.Soilscontainingbeidellitefixammoniumvery
strongly,aswellasK(Bajwa,1981a).
ClaymineralswithpH-dependentcharge
Theclaymineralswithvariablechargehavelayersconsistingof
alternating tetrahedralsilicaandoctahedralaluminiumhydroxidesheets,with
verylittlesubstitutioncharge.Themainexamplesarekaoliniteand
halloysite.Kaolinitenormallyoccursashexagon-shaped orrounded flakes,of
theorderof 1urnindiameter,muchcoarserthantheswellingclayminerals.
Halloysiteoccursintwovariants:ahydrated formcontainingwaterlayers
betweentheclaylayersandadehydrated form,similarto,butlesswell
ordered thenkaolinite.Halloysiteoftenoccursascurvedorrolledplates
(tubular)orasglobularaggregates,muchfinerthanmostkaolinites.
Thealuminiumattheedgeofthesheetsispositivelycharged,particu-
arlyatlowpH,whichproducesasmallanionexchangecapacity.Whereasions
suchaschlorideornitrateareinfactexchangeableonsuchsites,phosphate
andsilicaareboundtightly,andremainfixed (Muljadietal, 1966;summary
inDixon1977,p.388).Kaolinitesgenerallyhavearelativelycoarseparticle
size,andinthatcasetheamountoffixationissmall.Fine-grained
kaolinitesaswellashalloysites,whichareextremelyfine-grainedwithlarge
edgeareas,canfixlargeamountsofappliedphosphate(Bajwa,1981b).
Theseclaymineralshaveaverylowcec,increasingwithpHby
dissociationofOHgroups.Theyshowvirtuallynoswellingorshrinkagewith
changesinwatercontent.Soilsdominated bykaoliniteorhalloysitegenerally
havenooronlyweakpedstructure.Forsuchsoils,Jones(1983)estimates
thatrootpenetrationisimpededaboveacriticalbulkdensity,
(1.2+0.005xsand 'A)
Soilsonsteepslopeshavingaclayfractionwithsmallwaterholding
capacity,forexamplemainlykaoliniteordehydratedhalloysite,arenot
subjecttocreeporslumping,butmayformdebrisavalanchesinverywet
conditionswherebeddingplanesoftherockrunparalleltotheslope(Istok
-7-
andHarvard,1982).
Oncesoilsdominatedbykaoliniteorhalloysitehavebecomedensebyland
clearingactivities,byrainimpact,orbywheelorbullocktrafficorplough
pressureduringcultivation,theydonotregaintheirstructureandhydraulic
conductivitybywettinganddryingliketheswellingclaysoils,butneedto
berestoredbybiologicalormechanicalmeans.Thiscanbedonebystimulation
ofwormactivitythroughmulching.Initialrippingorcultivatortreatmentmay
beuseful,butonly ifthesoilisdryormoist.Thesameproblemoccurswhere
suchsoilsarepuddledforawetlandcropandsubsequentlyusedforadryland
crop.Proceduresforsafemanagementofsuchsoilsaregiven,e.g.,by
Vierhout (1983).
Aluminium-interlayeredmaterials
Incertainsoilscontainingclaymineralswithpermanentcharge,the
interlayerspacesoftheseclaymineralsareblockedbysheetsofpartly
neutralizedaluminium ions.Thesesheets,incompleteandgenerallypoorly
3+
ordered,consistofringstructuressuchasAlg(OH),e .Theyarenot
exchangeable,neutraliseaconsiderablepartofthecec,andrestrictthe
swelling thatcantakeplace.Fairlycompletealuminiuminterlayersthus
convertclayswithpermanentchargeintomaterialssimilartokaolinite.
Evenmoderateproportionsofaluminiuminterlayeringhaveagreateffect
onstabilityofclaysagainstdispersion,asexperimentallyverifiedby
MuranyiandBruggenwert (1984).Atlowsaltconcentrations,anilliteclay
soilmaterialdispersedandcollapsedintoavirtually impermeablemassat
exchangeablesodiumpercentages(ESP)about30andabove,whereasthepartly
aluminium-interlayeredmaterialremainedpermeableatallESPvaluestested,
upto80percent."
Thismayberelevantforthereclamationofsodic,orsaline-sodicsoils.
Acidformedafterapplicationofsulfuroroffinelygroundpyriteasinparts
ofIndia,orwasteacidfromchemicalindustries,asusedlocallyinthe
U.S.S.R,presumablydissolvesomealuminiumfromclaymineralsbesidesCafrom
limethatmaybepresent.Thiswouldproducealuminiuminterlayersbesides
dissolvedcalciumsulfate,bothaidingreclamation.
Oxidesandhydroxidesofiron(III)andaluminium
Soilscontaininglow-activityclays(claysfractionswithalowcec)
oftencontaingibbsite(Al(OH)o)besideskaolinite,generallyasdiscrete
clay-sized particles.Thismaterialaggravatesthemanagementproblemsofsuch
soils,because itscecaswellasmoisture-holding capacityareessentially
zero,andbecauseappliedphosphateisfixedmoreseverely bygibbsite thanby
kaolinite.
Iron(III)oxides,too,mayoccurintheclayfractionasdiscrete,
crystallineparticlesofgoethiteorhematite.-Thesetwogenerallyhavea
relatively lowspecificsurfaceandhavesimilarpropertiesasgibbsite,at
leastinwelldrainedsoils.
Ironoxidesorhydroxidescanalsoformgenerallydiscontinuouscoatings
onkaoliniteanotherclayminerals.Theseareoftenamorphous,haveavery
highspecificsurface,anddrasticallymodify thechargecharacteristicsand
thephysicalpropertiesofsuchsoils.Thecationexchangecapacity isvery
low.Phosphatefixationissevereandremainssevereexceptafterverylarge
phosphateapplications.Thestructurestability ismuchhigherthanthatof
kaoliniticsoilswithlowproportionsofironoxides:infiltrationrates
remainhighevenafterrainfallimpactandtheporescollapselessreadilyby
traffic.
Insurfacesoilswithhighorganicmattercontents,theassociationof
organicmatterwiththeironoxidescounteractsalltheseeffectstosome
extent.Wetland conditions,too,modify theeffectsofthefinelydistributed
iron(III)hydroxides.Reductionofiron(III)phosphatesincreasesphosphate
availability;reductionofFe(III)oxidestoFe(II)increasescecdirectlyas
wellasbytheassociated riseinpH.
Amorphousaluminosilicates
Amorphousaluminosilicatesandrelatedmaterialswhichonlyhaveshort-
rangeorderincludeallophaneandimogolite.Theseoccurinmanyyoung
volcanicsoils.Suchsoilshaveveryhighmoistureretentionandphosphate
fixationandalowtoveryhighpH-dependentcec.Theymanycontainveryhigh
proportionsoforganicmatter,presumably protectedagainstrapidmicrobial
decompositionbytheassociationwithlargeamountsofaluminium.
Thesesoilsarequitestableagainstrainimpactandnoterodible,but
mayfailunderload.Failure,mayoccurintheformoflandslides,slumpsor
creep(WarkentinandMaeda,1980).Soilscontainingamorphousclay
constituentsandhydratedhalloysitemayturnliquid,andslow-moving
earthflowoverconsiderabledepthmayoccurfrequently,evenwhereoverall
-9-
slopesarenotverysteep(IstokandHarvard,1982).
Allthetypesoffailurementioned forsoilswithdifferentclay
mineralogiesoccurinwater-saturatedcondition.Preventioninalandscape
withwetlandterraceswouldhavetodependondrainageatthebottomofthe
terracewallsand,wherepossible,oncarefulconstructionoftheterraces
withthemostslowlypermeablematerialinthesurfacelayer.Thesetechniques
havebeenraisedtothelevelofafineartbytheIfugaosofcentralLuzon,
Philippines(MoormannandvanBreemen,1978,p.89-90;vanBreemenetal.
1970, p.39-73).
ORIGINSOFTHECLAYFRACTION;TRANSFORMATIONPROCESSES
Theclayfractioninsoilsmaybetransportedanddeposited,together
withotherfractionsofthesediment;itmaybeinheritedfromasedimentary
rockthathasphysicallyweathered;oritmayhavebeenformedbyweathering
ofmineralsincoarserfractions,ortransformedfromotherclayminerals.
Onyounglandsurfaces,suchasrecentalluvialplainsorslopeswitha
moderateorhighrateoferosion,thenatureoftheclayfractionislargely
determinedbytheoriginalmaterial.Sincemanysedimentshavearatherwide
sourcearea,theirclayfractionsoftenareamixtureof,e.g.,illite,
montmorilloniteorvermiculitewithorwithout somealuminiuminterlayering,
kaoliniteandsomeclay-sizedquartz.Suchmixturestendtoberatherconstant
withinanalluvialplainbutmayvaryfromoneriverplainorestuaryto
another.
Onolderlandsurfaces,forexampleonriverorcoastalterracesorin
uplandareaswithlittleerosion,weatheringandclaytransformationbecome
moreimportant.Afewmajorclaytransformationprocesses,actingonavariety
oforiginalmaterials,canexplainthedifferentclaymineralogiesthatmay
occur.Theseprocesses,discussedatsomelengthinBrinkman(1982),are
summarizedbelow.Theyarethefollowingfive,inorderofdecreasingareal
importance.
-Hydrolysisbywatercontainingcarbondioxide,whichremovessilicaaswell
asbasiccations.
-Cheluviation,whichdissolvesandremovesespeciallyaluminiumandironby
chelatingorganicacids.
-10-
- Ferrolysis,acyclicprocessofclaytransformationanddissolutionunder
theinfluenceofalternating reductionandoxidationofiron,whichlowers
thececbyaluminium interlayering.
- Dissolutionbystrongmineralacids,whichattacksallclayminerals,
producingacidaluminium saltsandamorphoussilica.
- Claytransformationunderneutraltostronglyalkalineconditions (reverse
weathering),whichmaygiverisetomineralssuchasmontmorillonite,orin
extremecasespalygorskiteoranalcime.
Hydrolysisbywatercontainingcarbondioxide
Hydrolysisbywatercontaining CO?,alsocalleddesilication,sometimes
referred toas"weathering"without furtherspecification,isadominant
processofclayformationandtransformationparticularly inthehumid
tropics,butalsoinpartofthetemperatezone.
WaterinequilibriumwithatmosphericCC>2hasapHofabout5.6,thesane
asuncontaminated rainwater.Whenexcessrainwaterpassesthroughasoil,
claymineralsbegintodissolvecongruently (proportionately)untilthe
solubilityproductofgibbsite,Al(0H)o,isreached.Thishappensalreadyat
_Q
Thestabilityrelationshipsreferred tointhissectionarebasedon
thermodynamics,butcanbevisualizedmostsimplyintermsofsolubility
productsthatdeterminewhetheragivencompounddissolvesorisprecipitated.
Hydrolysisofclaymineralsoroffeldsparsorotherweatherableminerals
incoarserfractionsisaslowprocess,inwhichsilicaisremovedatratesof
about1to10mg/1,andbasiccationsatsimilarorlowerrates.
Wherepotassiumconcentrationsinsolutionarekeptverylowbyplant
uptake,dissolutionofKfromillitemayproceedfasterthandesilicationof
thematerial.Then,illitemaybetransformed intoK-depleted (swelling)
illite,andwithfurtherminorchangesintovermiculiteoraswellingclay
mineralsimilartobeidellite.These,inturn,wouldbesubjecttotheslower
tranformationsdiscussedabove.
Decomposition bystrongacids
Whenpyriteclays,occurringinmanymangroveareas,areoxidizedby
drainage,sulfuricacidisformedbyoxidationofthepyrite.Thisrapidly
dissolvesclayminerals,atpHvaluesbetween2.5and3.5,untilthesilica
concentrationisabout2x10 mol/1(about 120mg/1).Then,amorphoussilica
isprecipitated.
IfMgandKconcentrationsarehighenough,forexampleinsaline
conditions,montmorilloniteandillitemaybestablewithrespectto
kaolinite.Then,thedirectionofclaytransformationisawayfromkaolinite,
incontrasttohydrolysis.
Dissolutionbystrongacidsgivesrisetoaluminiumconcentrations
rangingfrom 1tosomehundredsofmg/1,severalordersofmagnitudehigher
thaninhydrolysisbywaterwithC0 2 ,andtosilicaconcentrationsofabout
100mg/1, about10timeshigher (vanBreemen,1976).Theprocesscantherefore
proceedmuchfasterthanhydrolysisifthereactionproductsareremoved,
e.g.,indrainagewater.
Reactionproductsthatarenotremovedmayformamorphoussilicaand
aluminiuminterlayersinswellingclaymineralsoncethepHhasrisenagainto
about5orhigher.
Cheluviation
Duringcheluviation,organicacidsspecificallydissolvealuminiumandiron,
andremovetheminchelatedform.Thedirectionofclaytransformationis
-12-
similartothatduringdissolutionbystrongacids.
Cheluviationoccursextensively inhumidclimateswithacoldseason,but
onlylocallyinverypoor,sandymaterialswithpoordrainage inthehumid
tropics.Itisnotdiscussedherebecauseitisofnegligibleimportancein
wetlandordryland riceareas.
Ferrolysis
Claydecompositionandtransformationbyferrolysisrequirestwo
alternating setsofcircumstances.Duringwater-saturated conditionswithsome
leaching,thesoilisreducedandthepHrisesslowlybytheconversionof
2+ becomesexchangeableaswellassoluble.Partofthe
Fe(OH)^intoFe ,which
exchangeablebasiccationsareremovedbyleaching.Watersaturation
alternateswithdryingandoxygenentry.Then,exchangeableFe 2+
isoxidized,
producingFe(OH)^andexchangeablehydrogen.Thisattackstheclaymineralsas
dootherstrongacids,butthealuminiumandothercationsreleased fromthe
claystructurebecomeexchangeable,notsoluble.Thesilicafromtheclaymay
remainasunsupported edgesoftheformerclaystructure.
Duringthenextperiodofwatersaturation,iron(III)hydroxidesare
2+ ofwhichdisplacesexchangeablealuminiumand
againreduced toFe ,part
othercationsintothesoilsolution.Partofthesilicaintheunsupported
edgesisdissolvedaswell.Leachingwatermayremovesomesilica,aswellas
partoftheAlandothercations,togetherwithbicarbonate.
BecausethepHrisesduringreduction,thealuminiumstillpresentis
partlyneutralized,andpolymerizes intoringstructuressuchasAl^(OH)^. 3+
Theseformincompleteoctahedralsheetsintheinterlayerspacesofswelling
clayminerals.Suchaluminium interlayersarenotexchangeable;they
neutralizepartofthececandblockother,originallyexchangeablecationsin
inaccessiblecavitiesoftheincompletelayerstructure.
Ferrolysisthusgivesrisetoaluminium-interlayeredmaterialswithlow
cec, formed fromswellingclaymineralswithoriginallyhighcec,andalsoto
amorphoussilica-thelatterincontrast tohydrolysisbywatercontaining
carbondioxide.Therateofclaytransformationbyferrolyisisprobablyan
orderofmagnitudehigherthanthatofhydrolysisbywaterwithCO-,
Claytransformationunderalkalineconditions
Whereconcentrationsofsilicaandstructuralcationsarerelatively
-13-
high,mineralsynthesisratherthandissolutioncantakeplace,aprocessalso
referredtoas"reverseweathering".
InalkalineorneutralconditionswithmoderateMgconcentrationsin
solution,montmorillonite isstableoverotherclaymineralssuchaskaolinite
orvermiculite.Montmorillonite isinfactformedinplainsorvalleysin
humidtosemiarid tropicalclimates,insofarastheinflowofmagnesiumand
silicafromadjoininguplandsissufficient.
WhereMgconcentrationsarehigh,asinsomesemiaridandarid
environments,afibrousmineral:palygorskiteisformed.Thiscontainsa
higherproportionofMgthanmontmorillonite.
InstronglyalkalineconditionswithhighNaconcentrationsinsolution,
analcimeisformed,generallyinaclay fractiondominated bymontmorillonite.
BecausetheNainstructureofthismineralistosomeextentexchangeable,
anomalouslyhighexchangeablesodiumpercentagescanbemeasured insuch
soils.
CLAYMINERALOGYANDLANDSCAPEPOSITION
Indifferentclimatezones,differentclaytransformationprocessestend
todominate:desilicationinperhumidclimates,reverseweathering inarid
conditions,orferrolysisonlevelsitesinclimateswithastrongseasonal
alternationbetweenthesetwo.Inmanyclimates,however,soilsoncrestsor
slopesmayhaveaverydifferentclaymineralogy fromthevalleysorplains-
notbecauseofdifferentparentmaterialsbutbecausethesoilhydrologygives
rise'todifferentclaytransformationprocessesoveroftenshortdistances.
Therelationshipsbetweenlandform,hydrology,soilformingprocessesand
claymineralogyofwetlandricesoilsaresummarizedbyMoormannandvan
Breemen(19/8).Someexamples,partextendingintodryland,arediscussed
below.
Kaoliniteandsmectite
Redorbrownkaoliniticsoilsonuplandslopesalternatewithblack
smectiteclaysoilsinvalleysorplainsoverextensiveareasinhumidto
semiaridAfricaandAsia.Theuplandsoils,formedbyhydrolysisbywater
containingcarbondioxide,arestronglytoweaklyacid,withlowormoderate
basesaturation,andhaveaclayfractionwithmainlykaolinite,oftensome
illite,andiron(III)oxides,quartzandfeldspar.Thececoftheclay
-14-
Aluminium-interlayered andinterstratifiedminerals
Whereslopesaremoregentlesothatsoilsonthelowerpartsofthe
slopesbecomeperiodicallywater-saturated,Planosols(Albaqualfs),orless
extremesurface-watergleysoils,maybefoundbetweentheuplandandvalley
soils.
Suchsoilsmayhavealuminium-interlayered materialintheclayfraction,
orinterstratifiedminerals:thesehavethesamegeneralstructureassmectite
butshowincompleteswellingbecauseofaluminium interlayeringofpartofthe
material.Theseperiodicallywetsoils,whicharesubjecttoleachingrather
thanaccumulationasinthevalleys,havelowclaycontentsandalowcecof
theclayfractionintheupperhorizons;theyaregenerallymoreacid thanthe
welldrainedsoilsonsteeperorhigherpartsofthelandscape.Ferrolysis
presumablyisthemainprocessthathasformedtheseasonallywetsoilsonthe
gentleslopesandlowrises,betweenhydrolysisontheuplandsandclay
formationunderneutraloralkalineconditionsinthevalleysofdepressions.
TwosuchtoptsequenceshavebeenstudiedbyBocquier (1973).One,
illustrated inFig.1,extendsfromgraniticuplandthroughagentleslope
intoanearly levelplain.Theothertoposequenceappearstobevirtually
flat,butinfacthaselevationdifferencesupto1mandslopesupto1per
cent.Eventhesehavebeenenoughtocausemajorsoilandclaymineral
differencesasdescribedabove.
Instillflatterlandscapes,forexampleintheolderriverplainsand
lowterracelandformsofBangladesh(Brinkman,1977),seasonallywetsoils
withlowclaycontentsinsurfacehorizonsandwithaluminium-interlayered
-15-
clayfractionscovermostofthelandscape,whileperenniallywet,heavyclay
soilswithoutevidenceofclaydestruction,occurinthedepressions.
Amorphousclayminerals
Inareaswithrecentvolcanicactivity,particularly ontuff,soil
formationisrapidbecauseofthelargeproportionofeasilyweatherable
materialinthesoils.Initially,thesesupporthighsilicaandbasiccation
concentrationsevenduringratherintensiveleaching,andifthepHishighas
well,smectiteisformed.Highrunoffonsteepslopesmaydecreasethe
leachingrate,sothatthisstageisextended.Allophaneisformedrapidly
fromdissolved silicaandpolymericoctahedralAlcompounds,presumablyata
somewhat lowerpHandlowerbasiccationconcentrations thanmontmorillonite.
Afterremovalofmostofthebasiccationsandreadilydissolved silicaby
continued leaching,theirconcentrations inthesoilsolutionbecome solow
thatkaoliniteorhalloysiteisstableovermontmorillonite.Amorphous
aluminosilicatestendtocrystallizeand form imogolite,thenhalloysite,
eventuallykaolinite,withtimeaidedbyperiodicdryingout.
Inawelldrained toposequenceonbasicvolcanicrocksinaperhumid
climate,fromnearthedratero£QuoinHill,Sabah,tothebottomofthe
slope,Eswaranand Sys(1976aand b)showedatrendfrommajorproportionsof
allophaneorrelatedamorphousmaterialintheclayfractiononthesteep
upperslope,graduallydecreasing tozerointheoldest soilsonamoregentle
slopedownhill.Smectitedecreasedfrommajorontheupperslopetonearzero
onthemid-slope;kaoliniteandhalloysiteincreaseddownhillfromminor
proportionstodominant intheoldestsoils.
SURFACEVERSUSBULKCOMPOSITIONOFCLAYFRACTIONS
Themineralogicalcompositionofclayfractiongenerally istheresultof
long-terraprocessesanddoesnotchangequicklywithachangein
circumstances.However,thesurfacepropertiesofaparticle in-theclay
fractionarenotnecessarily inequilibriumwithitsbulkcomposition.Surface
propertiesaremodifiedrelativelyquicklywhenexternalcircumstanceschange,
andsurfaceratherthanbulkpropertiesaregenerallyofprimary importance
forphysicalchemistry:forthefertility,toxicity,andothermanagement
aspectsofsoils.Herbillon(1981),e.g.,hassummarized thenatureand
propertiesofclayandoxidesurfaces.
Ironoxides
Soilswithkaoliniticclayfractionscontaininglessthanabout12
percentFe^O^generallyhavethepropertiesassociatedwithkaolinite:low,
pH-dependent cec,lowstructurestability,consequenterodibilityandtendency
tobecomedensewhenmechanicallydisturbed bytrafficorrainimpact,
moderatephosphatebufferingcapacityandfixation.
Inkaolinitic soilswithcontentsoffreeironoxidesexceeding12
percentoftheclayfraction,theclay tendstohaveanoxidesurface.Such
soilsthenhaveverylowcec,highstructurestabilityandgenerallysevere
phosphatefixation.Thepercentagequoted isvariable,however,dependingon
thenatureanddistribution oftheoxides.
Insmectitesoils,too,thereisamajordistinctioninstructure
stabilityandinthedegreetowhichagranularorfineblockysurface
structurecanberestoredbydrying.TheChromicVertisols,withrelatively
highcontentsoffreeironoxides,havefavourablepropertiesinthisregard,
whilethePellicVertisolsdonot.Theremaybeothercausativefactorsas
wellbesidesthecontentanddistributionofironoxides.
Othersubstancesorbondingagents
Structuralstabilityinsomesoilsmaybeduetoothersurfacefeatures
oftheclayfractionbesidesorganicmatter,oxidicsurfacesorpolyvalent
exchangeablecations.Besidesfinelydispersed ironoxides,features
identified byButleretal(1976)inAustralia includethepresenceofafine
clayfractionstrongly bondedorcemented intosilt-sizedaggregates,probably
-17-
mainlyatedgesofclaypacketsratherthanonplanarfaces.Silica
cementationispossiblebuthasnotbeenprovedinthesesoils.Intergrowthof
claymineralcrystalsmayalsobeafactor,aswellasthelargeelectrostatic
interactionbetweenclaylayerswithahighchargedensity.
Kaolinitecorrosionandsubsequentcementationhasalsobeensuggestedas
acauseforanomalouslyhighstructuralstabilityincertainOxisols Coughla.i
etal,1973andHerbillonetal, 1966).
TnclayfractionsofKenyansoilswithamorphousmaterialWielemaker
(1984)foundindicationsthatthececatagivenpHishigherwithevenminor
increasesintheratioofextractableamorphousSitoAlandSitoFe.Healso
modified thechargecharacteristicsexperimentallywithapplicationsof
amorphoussilica.Similaramorphoussilica-ironcompoundswithsomealuminium
coverthesurfacesofcrystallineclaymineralsinclaysoilsoverlargeareas
inQuebecandOntario,Canada.Thesesoilareverystiffinplace,butmay
becomevirtuallyliquidwhenextensivelysheared (McKyesetal, 1974),even
thoughthecontentofamorphousmaterialisonly 10-12percent.
Rapidchangesinsurfaceproperties
Themostrapidchangesinsurfacepropertiesandphysicalchemistryof
soilsarebroughtaboutbyalternatingreductionandoxidation.Theprocesses
occurringduringsoilreductionhavebeenextensivelydealtwithby
Ponnamperuma (1972).
Duringreduction,iron(III)oxidesareconvertedintosolubleand
2+
exchangeableFe ,withaconcurrent riseinpH.Inneutralsoilswith
smectiteorverraiculiteintheclayfraction,thismaygiverisetosynthesis
ofmaterialswithastructuresimilartosmectiteandcontainingFe(II)inthe
octahedralsheet.Wheresuchsoilsremainperenniallywet,zinctendstobe
fixedinaformunavailable towetlandrice:Isuspectbecauseitcanbebuilt
intotheoctahedralpositionsofthesynthesizedmaterial.Uponreoxidation,
thezincbecomesavailableagain,whichsuggeststhatthematerialisonly
stableinreducedconditions-presumablybecauseofitshighFe(II)content.
Inacidsoils,particularly thosewithakaoliniticclaymineralogy,
solubleFe 2+
concentrationstendtorisetohighlevelsbecauseofthelowcec
andbecauseconditionsareunfavourableforprecipitationofiron(II)oxides
orcarbonatesorsynthesisofsilicates.Then,theirontoxicitysyndromemay
2+
beobserved inwetlandrice,dependingontheFe concentrationinrelation
-18-
totheconcentrationsofnutrientcationsandphosphateavailability.
2+ into
Whenareduced soilisoxidizedagain,theFe isconverted
Fe(OH)3.Theoriginalironoxidesarethusdistributed inadifferentway,and
withagenerallyhigherspecificsurfaceandactivity.Inhigh-activityclay
soils,thismayincreasethestabilityofastructureestablishedbefore
inundation,asinfloodfallowingofsugarcanelandintheGuyanacoastal
plain,orofastructureestablished justbeforeoxidation,asinland
preparationforwheatafterriceintheJangtzedelta,China.Inlow-activity
claysoils,theeffectsofalternate reductionandoxidationarelessclearly
beneficial,inpartbecausetheremovalbyleachingofnutrientcationstends
tobeaccelerated inperiodically reducedconditions.
Insoilswithhighamountsofactiveironoraluminium,forexamplewith
amorphous,halloysiticoroxidicclay fractions,phosphatefixationissevere
andcecmaybeloworvery low.Phosphateorsilicaonthesurfaceofsuch
materialsdrasticallychangestheirproperties.Althoughveryhighphosphate
applicationstodecreaseoreliminatephosphatefixationmaynotbeexonomic
inmostcases,theyareeffectiveand rapid.Theuseofsilicaorfinely
groundsilicatesmaybemoreeconomic.This,too,tendstolowertheamount
andseverityofphosphatefixationandraisesthececatagivenpH.
Substancesthatcouldbetriedincludewollastonite(Casilicate),usedasa
silicafertilizerinsomewetland riceareas,orground feldspar,orbasic
slag,containingphosphateandsilicate.
Inpractice,CasilicateapplicationsonaGibbsihumoxinHawaiigave
disappointing results,butthehighPfixingcapacity inOxisolswasreduced
bylong-term irrigationwithwatercontaining 30mgSiperliter(Fox,19S0).
Thisresulted inatriplingofwater-solubleSifrom 1.6to5.3mg/1,increase
inpoorlycrystallinesoilSifrom730to1360mg/kg,andadropinPsorption
(at0.2mg/1solutionconcentration)from235to100mg/kg,allcomparedwith
thesoilthatreceived low-Siirrigationwater.
ExperimentsbyJepsonetal(1976)indicatethatsilicareactswitha
gibbsite(AKOH)^)surfaceinquantities fromlessthanamonolayeratpH4to
morethanthatatpH9,withanincreaseincationexchangecapacityand
decreasesinanionexchangecapacityandAlsolubilityatagivenpH.
Thesedifferentfindingscanprobably besummarized intheestimatethat
silicationofoxidicsurfacesisfeasible,butthattheprocessworksmuch
moreslowly insoilsthaninlaboratory situationsbecauseofimperfectmixing
-19-
andslowdiffusionofsilicatotheoxidicsurfaces-probablyoverseveral
cropseasons.
-20-
1
References
AgronomyDept,IRRI1983.ReleaseandfixationofNH^-Ninwetlandsoils.
InternationalRiceResearchInstituteannualreportfor1981:281-
283.
Bajwa,M.I.1981a.Soilbeidelliteanditsrelationtoproblemsof
potassiumfertilityandpoorresponsetopotassiumfertilizers.Plant
andSoil62:299-303.
Bajwa,M.I.1981b.Soilclaymineralogies inrelationtofertility
management:effectofsoilclaymineralcompositionsonphosphorus
fixationunderconditionsofwetland riceculture.Commun,inSoil
Sei.PlantAnal.12(5): 475-482.
Black,A.S.andS.A.Waring 1979.Adsorptionofnitrate,chlorideand
sulphatebysomehighlyweathered soilsfromsouth-eastQueensland.
Aust.J.SoilRes.17:271-282.
Bocquier,G.1973.Geneseetévolutiondedeuxtoposéquencesdesols
tropicauxduTchad.Interprétationbiogéodynamique.Mémoires0RST0M
No.62.0RST0M,Paris.350p,4colourplates.
Borchardt,G.A.1977.Montmorilloniteandothersmectiteminerals,p.293-
330in:DixonandWeed (eds)1977.
Bouma,J. 1984.Usingsoilmorphology todevelopmeasurementmethodsand
simulationtechniquesforwatermovement inheavyclaysoils.
Symposiumonwaterandsolutemovement inheavyclaysoils.
Wageningen (Inpress).
Breemen,N.van1976.Genesisandsolutionchemistryofacidsulfatesoilsin
Thailand.Agric.ResearchReports848.PUDOC,Wageningen.263p.,
map.
Breemen,N.van,L.R.Oldeman,W.J.PlantingaandW.G.Wielemaker 1970.The
Ifugaoriceterraces,p.39-73In:AspectsofricegrowinginAsia
andtheAmericas.Miscell.Papers7,Agric.UniversityWageningen.
Breeuwsma,A.1984.Soilpollutionandsoilsurvey:newwineinoldbags?
(Dutch),p.56-66in:Bodemenlandschapkwalitatiefenkwantitatief
bekeken.Pudoc,Wageningen.ISBN9022008258.
Brinkman,R.1977.Surface-watergleysoilsinBangladesh:genesis.Geoderma
17:111-144.
Brinkman,R.1982.Claytransformations:aspectsofequilibriumandkinetics.
Ch. 12,p.433-458 in-. Bolt,G.H.(ed).Soilchemistry.B.Physico—
-21-
instability inthecoaF«-rangeofOregon.SoilSei.Soc.Arier.J.46:
1326-1331.
Jcpson,W.B.,D.G.JeffsandA.P.Ferris 1976.Theadsorptionofsilicaon
gibbslteand itsrelevancetothekaolinitesurface.J.Colloid
InterfaceSei.55(2):454-461.
Jones,C.A. 1983.Effectofsoiltextureoncriticalbulkdensities forroot
growth.SoilSei.Soc.Amer.J.42:565-570
Krantz,B.A.,J.KampenandM.B.Rüssel1977.Soilmanagementdifferenceson
VertisolsandAlfisolsinthesemi-arid tropics.In:Stelly,>!. (ed).
Diversityofsoilsinthetropics.Spec.publ.34.Amer.Soc.Agron.,
Madison,Wis.119p.
McKyes,E.,A.SethiandR.N.Yong 1974.Amorphouscoatingsonparticlesof
sensitiveclaysoils.Claysandclayminerals22:427-433.
Mekaru,T.andG.Uehara 1972.Anionadsorption inferruginoustropicalsoils.
SoilSei.Soc.Amer.Proc.36:296-300.
Mohr,E.C.J. 1944.Thesoilsofequatorialregionswithspecialreference
totheNetherlandsEastIndies.J.V.7.Edwards,AnnArbor.766p.
TranslatedbyR.L.Pendletonfrom theDutchedition,1933-1938.Royal
TropicalInstitute,Amsterdam.816p.
Moormann,F.R.andN.vanBreemen 1978.Rice:soil,water,land.Internat.
RiceResearchInstitute,LosBanos,Philippines.185p.
Muljadi,D.,A.M.PosnerandJ.P.Quirk 1966.Themechanismofphosphate
adsorptionbykaolinite,gibbsiteandpseudoboehmite.J.SoilSei.
17:212-228.
Muranyi,A.andM.G.M.Bruggenwrrt 1984.EffectofAl-hydroxideonthe
stabilityand swellingofsoil(clay)aggregates.Proc.symposiumon
waterandsolutemovement inheavy claysoils.Wageningen (inpress).
Perrot,K.W.1978.Theinfluenceoforganicmatterextracted fromhumified
cloveronthepropertiesofamorphousaluminosilicates.1.Surface
charge.Aust.J.SoilRes.16:327-339.
Ponnamperuma,F.N. 1972.Thechemistry ofsubmerged soils.Advancesin
Agronomy24:29-88.
Schuylenborgh,J.vanandA.M.H.Sänger1954.Theelectrokineticbehaviourof
ironandaluminiumhydroxidesandoxides.RecueildesTravaux
ChimiquesdesPays-Bas68:1000-1010.
Schwertmann,U.andR.M.Taylor 1981.Thesignificanceofoxidesforthe
surfacepropertiesofsoilsand theusefulnessofsyntheticoxidesas
-23-
modelsfortheirstudy.Bull.Int.Soc.SoilSei.no60:62-66.
Smiles,D.E.andW.J.Bond 1984.Waterandsolutemovement inaheavyclay
soil.Symposiumonwaterandsolutemovementinheavyclaysoils.
Wageningen(inpress).
Theng,B.K.G.1979.Formationandpropertiesofclay-polymercomplexes.
Elsevier,Amsterdam.362p.
Vierhout,J. 1983.PhysicaldegradationofyellowkaoliniticOxisolsofthe
ZanderijformationinSuriname;afieldstudy.CELOSReportsno.139,
68p,10appendices.CentrumvoorLandbouwkundigOnderzoekin
Suriname,Paramaribo.
Warkentin,B.P.andT.Maeda1980.Physicalandmechanicalcharacteristicsof
andisols.Ch.14,p.281-301in:Theng,B.K.G.(ed).Soilswith
variablecharge.NewZealandSoc.ofSoilScience.LowerHutt.
Wielemaker,W.1984.Theimportanceofvariablechargeduetoamorphous
siliceousclayconstituentsinsomesoilsfromKenya.Geoderrr.a32:
9-20.
-24-
Table 1.Somechemicalandphysicalpropertiesofsoilswithclayfractions
dominated bydifferentmaterials.
Properties
* pH-dependent
-notsignificant
**highagainstrainfallorwatererosion;allophanesoilslowunderload