Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Música Isis
Música Isis
Música Isis
To cite this article: Nelly Lahoud & Jonathan Pieslak (2018) Music of the Islamic State, Survival,
60:1, 153-168, DOI: 10.1080/00396338.2018.1427372
When the animals in George Orwell’s Animal Farm concluded that their
misery could be ‘summed up in a single word’, namely ‘Man’, and became
resolved to ‘Remove Man from the scene’, it was a song that propelled them
to revolution.1 Old Major the boar, the most highly regarded among the
animals, addressed his comrades with a philosophical speech about the
‘tyranny of human beings’, going on to tell them of a dream he had had
about life after the disappearance of Man. In particular, he recalled a song
from the dream, ‘Beasts of England’, the lyrics of which contained ‘joyful
tidings’ of a ‘golden future time’ when ‘tyrant man shall be o’erthrown’ and
the fields ‘shall be trod by beasts alone’.2 The song ‘threw the animals into
the wildest excitement’, much more so than Old Major’s speech had done,
and before long ‘the whole farm burst out into Beasts of England in tremen-
dous unison’.3 In short, the song forged a common bond among the animals,
transcending their differences and imbuing Old Major’s plan to eradicate
Man with a potency and resonance that his rhetoric had clearly lacked.
In December 2013, the Islamic State (also known as ISIS or ISIL) was expe-
riencing its own Orwellian moment and, like Old Major, saw fit to mark the
occasion with a song – specifically an Islamic a cappella song or nashid (plural
anashid). That month, ISIS killed Abu Sa‘d al-Hadrami, the leader of rival
jihadi group Jabhat al-Nusra in Raqqa, and was set to take over the province.
Convinced that divine providence was guiding its leaders and fighters, the
Nelly Lahoud is Senior Fellow for Political Islamism, IISS–Middle East. Jonathan Pieslak is Professor at The City
College of New York and Graduate Center, CUNY.
group decided to share its own joyful tidings (bushra) by releasing a nashid
so that the faithful might join in the celebration, and of course in the fighting:
Because the use of musical instruments is not lawful under Islamic law,
anashid melodies are delivered through the rhythmic chanting of lyrics. To
ensure that these rhythms move the listeners’ emotions to the greatest possi-
ble extent, modern Islamic anashid make ample use of sound effects; it seems
that, despite jihadis’ disposition to apply Islamic law according to the nar-
rowest interpretation, they do not quibble with the use of such effects. Thus,
the casual listener would not necessarily discern that the audio recording
of the nashid just cited – ‘Ummati qad Laha Fajrun’ (‘My Umma, [a new]
Dawn Is Breaking’) – did not make use of musical instruments. The lyrics
and the upbeat rhythm produced by the nashid’s sophisticated sound effects
succeed in conveying the glad tidings ISIS wished to share.
tancy and incite violence. Its use by actors with such differing aims as racist
skinheads and animal-rights militants demonstrates that the use of music
as a political tool is unrestrained by ideological orientation, culture, reli-
gion or geography.5 Indeed, it would not be an exaggeration to observe that
the strength of a radical organisation is typically reflected by the degree to
which its musical culture thrives.6
The value of music has not escaped the attention of jihadis. Anwar al-
‘Awlaqi, the American Yemeni imam who joined al-Qaeda in the Arabian
Peninsula (AQAP) and was killed by a US drone in Yemen in 2011, made
a special case for anashid in his 2009 missive, ‘44 Ways to Support Jihad’.
He contended that a ‘good nasheed can spread so widely it can reach to an
audience that you could not reach through a lecture or a book. Nasheeds
are especially inspiring to the youth, who are the foundation of Jihad in
every age and time. Nasheed are an important element in creating a “Jihad
culture”.’7 ‘Awlaqi was merely articulating what jihadi groups had been
doing for decades in their media propaganda.
To be clear, we are not suggesting a direct causal relationship between
the consumption of anashid and the resort to militancy. However, real-
world examples demonstrate the impact that anashid and video messaging
can have, and there is ample evidence to suggest that such cultural forms
are much more than mere jingles intended to liven up the cause in moments
of leisure.
Anashid figure prominently in the propaganda-consumption habits
of the 17 jihadists who have caused casualties within the US since 2013.
Boston Marathon bombers Tamerlan and Dzhokhar (‘Jahar’) Tsarnaev, for
example, specifically demanded that Dun Meng, who became their captive
after they carjacked him, instruct them on how to connect their iPhone to his
car’s stereo so they could listen to militant anashid during their flight from
law enforcement.8 When they could not connect the device, they actually
drove back to the green Honda they had abandoned in Watertown, MA, to
retrieve a CD.9 If the Tsarnaev brothers’ purpose in listening to the anashid
was to celebrate the bloodbath they had created, their prosecutors later used
the music to establish the brothers’ guilt in court, playing a slideshow for
jurors as part of their closing arguments in which scenes of carnage (pools
156 | Nelly Lahoud and Jonathan Pieslak
of blood, severed limbs, people screaming) were set to the Islamic chanting
of the Tsarnaevs’ CD.10
In another example, Elton Simpson and Nadir Soofi opened fire on the
Curtis Culwell Center, which was hosting the ‘First Annual Muhammad
Art Exhibit and Contest’, in Garland, TX, on 3 May 2015. Both Simpson
and Soofi were killed by law enforcement in an exchange of gunfire. In the
hours leading up to the attack, Simpson not only tweeted his bay‘a (pledge
of allegiance) to the self-styled ‘caliph’ of the Islamic State, Abu Bakr
al-Baghdadi, but also tweeted and hashtagged lyrics from the ISIS nashid
‘Qariban, Qariban’ (‘Soon, Soon’), a well-known track that gained currency
in the world of jihadi propaganda when it was used as the soundtrack to the
immolation video of Jordanian pilot Muaz al-Kasasbeh. Further evidence
drawn from the investigations into attacks by Abdul Arkan, Omar Mateen,
Faisal Mohammad, Alton Nolan, Ahmad Rahami and Zale Thompson
supports the assertion that anashid constitute a significant proportion of the
media consumed by attackers who have embraced the cause of jihadism,
and especially that of the Islamic State.11 Among these predominantly home-
grown perpetrators, the overwhelming majority were radicalised through
online mechanisms such as social media and propaganda dissemination,
and operated without direct training from ISIS cadres or in-person contact
from the organisation that most of them died for. This route to terrorist
violence is becoming increasingly familiar in Western countries.
music necessarily sympathise with jihadis. What is distinct about the use
of Islamic anashid by jihadists is that they disproportionately rely on those
with militant themes in their propaganda.12 Jihadi groups have freely bor-
rowed anashid deemed to be sonically emblematic of their cause, especially
as video soundtracks or as anthems chanted by fighters on the battlefield.
The Islamic State’s parent group, the Islamic State of Iraq (ISI), was no
exception. When the ISI founded its own media outlet – al-Furqan, which
broadcast its first video on 21 November 2006 – the group relied on borrowed
anashid. It continued to do so for more than six years. Recurring selections
were titles such as ‘Qum’ (‘Rise Up’), ‘al-Qawl, Qawl’ (‘The Word Is the
Word’), ‘Madin ka-al-Sayf’ (‘Sharp Like the Sword’), ‘bi-Jihadina’ (‘Through
our Jihad’) and ‘Jaljalat’ (‘Thunderclouds’). Among the group’s preferred
munshidun were the Saudi performers Abu ‘Ali and Abu ‘Abd al-Malik, and
the Yemeni Abu Hajar al-Hadrami.13 Among these three, only al-Hadrami is
associated with a jihadi group; he appears as the subject of an interview in a
pamphlet released in 2014 by AQAP’s al-Malahim media.
The ISI did not begin to produce its own original anashid until it started
to achieve some military momentum. Indeed, the recording of the group’s
first official nashid – al-Furqan’s ‘Ya Allah al-Jannah’ (‘O Allah [we seek]
Paradise’), released in July 2013 – followed its decision to rebrand itself as
the Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) on 8 April 2013, at a time when
it was making territorial advances. Although this was the first ‘official’
release, it is possible that the ISI had been producing original anashid even
earlier. The previous year, one of the anashid featuring in the first instalment
of the ISI’s momentous four-part series, ‘Salil al-Sawarim’ (‘Clanging of the
Swords’), released on 30 June 2012, included the nashid ‘Qama li-al-Islami
Sarhun’ (‘A State for Islam Has Arisen’),14 which specifically references the
‘Islamic State’, and has been attributed to the well-known Islamic State
munshid ‘Abu Yaser’. There may have been several group-specific recordings
in circulation before the ISI began making official releases.
When ISIS founded Ajnad, the group’s dedicated Arabic anashid- and
sura-recitation media branch, on 20 August 2013, the group began to produce
anashid in earnest, rarely allowing more than two weeks to elapse between
official releases. By the time ISIS delivered the fourth instalment of ‘Salil
158 | Nelly Lahoud and Jonathan Pieslak
a binary between Islam and jahiliyya – the pre-Islamic period that symbol-
ises a primordial ignorance of God – the Islamic State strives to distinguish
itself from anything outside it.
The new rupture promoted by ISIS does not just separate Muslims and
non-Muslims, or jihadis and mainstream Muslims; perhaps more importantly,
it demarcates the Islamic State from other jihadi groups that have refused to
pledge allegiance to al-Baghdadi. Accordingly, the group’s production of its
own anashid as an element of its state-building enterprise marks the start of a
new chapter for the role of such music in jihadi culture. In this new chapter,
anashid serve not just to extol militancy, but to heighten the divide between
the Islamic State and its enemies, particularly its jihadi rivals.
Key themes
In making a case for the political legitimacy of their self-proclaimed cali-
phate, the leaders of the Islamic State have asserted that its founding was
preordained by God. Indeed, when in June 2014 Abu Muhammad al-Adnani
proclaimed the establishment of a global state, the title of his public state-
ment was ‘This Is God’s Promise’ (‘Hadha Wa‘du Allah’).15 The title echoes a
Koranic verse (Q. 24:55) that speaks of God’s promise to believers who fight
in His path against unbelievers that they will be rewarded with tamkin (ter-
ritorial strength). In other words, the faithful will take political sovereignty
away from the infidel and will establish God’s religion:
God promised those of you who believe and do good works that He will
cause them to be successors in the earth, as He had caused the believers
who were before them to succeed the infidels of their time; and that He will
establish for them their religion, so that security will replace their fears.16
The themes of promise and tamkin in this verse are key to the Islamic State’s
core ideology, and to its claim to legitimate statehood.17 This verse is used
to identify the group’s followers and fighters as the true believers who are
worthy of God’s promise (wa‘du Allah). Given that ISIS is the first jihadi
group to achieve territorial governance, tamkin is understandably absent in
the anashid used by other jihadi groups.
160 | Nelly Lahoud and Jonathan Pieslak
The proof that the Islamic State represents the fulfilment of God’s promise,
ISIS has argued, can be found in its ability to establish tamkin, and in its
administration of God’s law within that territory. Thus, the theme of bushra
is intertwined both with the significance of God’s promise and with the ter-
ritorial proof that this promise is being fulfilled.
In view of ISIS’s territorial victories between 2014 and early 2015, its
sympathisers and followers likely believed that divine providence was
guiding the group. It then seemed invincible: it captured large cities in
Iraq and Syria, and in June 2014, to borrow from the title of the video it
produced that month, it ‘erased the borders’ – a reference to the borders
drawn almost a century earlier by the British and the French with the
signing of the Sykes–Picot Agreement in 1916. Islamic State publica-
tions featured articles framing the group’s victories in tamkin parlance to
assert that these were a sign from God that He was fulfilling His promise
to His faithful.
Music of the Islamic State | 161
to defend Mosul. The nashid is thus Iraq-specific; any listener who is famil-
iar with the names of Iraqi cities can hear the musical note of victory in the
nashid, which sounds as though the cities captured by ISIS are dancing to the
beats of a broken Maliki and an impotent America:
The video series in which this nashid first appeared (the aforementioned
‘Salil al-Sawarim’ series) has actually received the credit for the Islamic
State’s victories in early 2014: it was reported that the series was widely
distributed in Iraq, which led to the Iraqi army fleeing Mosul.
Similarly, the nashid ‘Dawlatu al-Islami Suli wa-Idhari’ (‘Islam’s
[legitimate] State [with your] Attack[s proceed]’) is designed to highlight that
the legitimacy of the Islamic State goes hand in hand with the righteousness
of terrorising its enemies, a message it conveys in graphic detail:
…
This is the age of epic battles
With fighting it radiates
Do not relent, do not soften
Like the mountains [raise your head] high
Shatter the [infidels], destroy them
The heads of error crush
…
[Behold]
Upon the corpses of men
Islam’s [legitimate] state we shall raise
* * *
Music of the Islamic State | 165
The territory of the Islamic State peaked before the group celebrated its one-
year anniversary, though it continued to win some areas and lose others for
another year or so, especially in Syria. By September 2016, it became clear
that the group’s territorial losses were also having an impact on its online
presence. The group began to produce all its non-Arabic magazines under
the title Rumiyah, which consisted mainly of translations of articles that
had already appeared in its weekly Arabic magazine al-Naba’. The group’s
production of anashid also took a hit. Whereas in 2015, Ajnad produced 15
anashid, in 2016 it produced only five. One of them, ‘Mawkibu al-Nur’ (‘The
Process of [divine] Light’), is worth noting. Released in October, the first few
lines exhort the faithful to join the battle:
The nashid’s desperate tone appears to suggest that the composer knew
there was little to offer other than tarhib, promising that:
Does this nashid signal that the Islamic State saw that the end was near,
and wished to make a Sinatra-style, ‘we did it our way’ exit? While this
may be a plausible reading, those charged with prosecuting the group for
its crimes will find it impossible to prepare the kind of slideshow used in
the Tsarnaev trial. For notwithstanding the Islamic State’s prolific produc-
tion of anashid, its output of violence and blood has far exceeded its cultural
production.
Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful for the assistance they received from Muhammad al-‘Ubaydi
and Mohamed al-Shamlan in compiling and coding Arabic anashid lyrics. They are
also grateful for thoughtful conversations with colleagues, including linguistic sugges-
tions. Research for this article was supported by a Minerva Research Initiative, Grant
FA9550-15-1-0373.
Notes
1 George Orwell, Animal Farm CT: Wesleyan University Press, 2015).
(Harmondsworth: Penguin Books, 6 Ibid., p. 3.
1968), p. 9. 7 Anwar al-‘Awlaqi, ‘44 Ways to
Koran: Translated into English from the ised) and tahrid (inciting them to take
Original Arabic, with an Introduction up jihad) are usually found in combi-
by Sir Edward Denison Ross (London nation. Although the same might be
and New York: Frederick Warne, said of Islamic State anashid, the theme
n.d.), p. 351; and Edward William of tarhib is treated somewhat differ-
Lane, Arabic–English Lexicon (London: ently in these songs, and is therefore
Williams & Norgate, 1863), p. 793. worth considering separately. As the
17 Of 122 Islamic State anashid analysed anashid cited here show, tarhib does
for this study, eight have tamkin as not simply emerge as a method to
their key theme, while many others terrorise the enemy in Islamic State
also touch on it. propaganda, but is seen as inter-
18 Of 122 anashid analysed, 19 have twined with the group’s philosophy,
bushra and wa‘du Allah as key themes. as a means intrinsic to its ends. Tarhib
Such themes are largely absent from is the focus of 31 out of 122 Islamic
our dataset of 636 anashid used by State anashid, while tahrid in the
other jihadi groups. conventional sense is the focus of 30
19 In the anashid used by jihadi groups anashid.
other than ISIS, the themes of tarhib 20 The literal rendering of darat rahana is