Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Prevalensi Dan Risiko Faktor Untuk Stunting Antara Anak Sekolah Dan Remaja Di Abeokuta, Southwest Nigeria
Prevalensi Dan Risiko Faktor Untuk Stunting Antara Anak Sekolah Dan Remaja Di Abeokuta, Southwest Nigeria
1 Departemen Pediatri dan Kesehatan Anak dan 2Departemen Kesehatan Masyarakat dan Perawatan Primer,
College of Medicine, Lagos State University, PMB 21.266, Ikeja, Lagos, Nigeria
ABSTRAK
Stunting adversely affects the physical and mental outcome of children. The objectives of the study were to
determine the prevalence of and risk factors associated with stunting among urban school children and adolescents
in Abeokuta, Nigeria. Five hundred and seventy children aged 5-19 years were selected using the multi-stage
random-sampling technique. Stunting was defined as height-for-age z-score (HAZ) of <-2 standard deviation (SD)
of the National Center for Health Statistics reference. Severe stunting was defined as HAZ of <-3 SD. The mean
age of the children was 12.2+3.41 years, and 296 (51.5%) were males. Ninety-nine (17.4%) children were stunted.
Of the stunted children, 20 (22.2%) were severely stunted. Identified risk factors associated with stunting were
attendance of public schools (p<0.001), polygamous family set-ting (p=0.001), low maternal education (p=0.001),
and low social class (p=0.034). Following multivariate analysis with logistic regression, low maternal education
(odds ratio=2.4; 95% confidence interval 1.20-4.9; p=0.015) was the major contributory factor to stunting.
Encouraging female education may improve healthcare-seeking behaviour and the use of health services and
ultimately reduce stunting and its conse-quences.
Key words: Adolescent; Child; Child nutrition disorders; Community-based studies; Cross-sectional stud-ies;
Nutrition disorders; Risk factor; Stunting; Nigeria
stunting impairs host immunity, thereby increas-ing the were selected by balloting. This selection process was
incidence, severity, and duration of many infectious adopted because the population of students in public
diseases (9). In countries where malaria infection is primary schools was higher than that of private
endemic, stunting increases the degree to which primary schools while that of secondary schools was
malaria is associated with severe anaemia causing about equal. From each selected school, all grades
considerably higher likelihood of mortality due to were studied (primary–Grade 1-6 and jun-ior and
malaria (9). senior secondary school–Grade 1-6).
The long-term consequences of stunting include short Using the estimated prevalence of stunting of 19.8%
stature, reduced capacity of work, and in-creased risk by Oninla et al (12), the minimum sample-size (n) for
of poor reproductive performance (1,3). There is a the study was calculated as follows:
positive association among stunt-ing, central obesity,
n=z2 p (1-p)÷d2x2.
and cardio-metabolic disorders (10). The burden of
these chronic diseases is daunt-ing as they remain where ‘z’ is the critical value, and in a two-tailed test,
significant causes of morbidity and mortality even in it is equal to 1.96, p is the estimated prevalence of
the tropics and subtropics. This could stretch health stunting, and d is the absolute sampling error that can
facilities which are either non-existent or ill-equipped be tolerated. In this study, it was fixed at 5%.
to cope with the yet-to-be resolved problems of Multiplication by 2 was done for correct-ing design
undernutrition and in-fections. effect. Therefore, the minimum sample-size was:
n=1.962x0.198x(1-0.198)÷0.052=488.
In developing countries, most deaths in children are On the day of the study, one arm from each class was
among the under-five children. As a result, there is selected by balloting. Ballot papers were served to all
extensive literature on under-five children compared to the children in the selected arm. The ballot papers were
dearth of information on the health of school children. blank, except those that were marked with number 1 to
Moreover, children who are stunted are likely to 15. After all the students had picked a paper, they were
remain stunted into adulthood (11). The objectives of asked to open, and those with number 1 to 15 were
this study were, therefore, to determine the prevalence selected. Ninety pupils were selected from each of the
of and risk factors as-sociated with stunting among seven schools.
school children and adolescents in Abeokuta,
Each student was interviewed to obtain informa-tion
southwestern part of Ni-geria.
on demographic and socioeconomic charac-teristics of
the child’s family. The families were as-signed to a
MATERIALS AND METHODS socioeconomic class using the method (modified)
recommended by Oyedeji (13). The par-ents’
Location occupation and highest education attained were scored
from 1 (highest) to 5 (lowest). The mean score for both
This questionnaire-based, cross-sectional study was
parents gives social class fall-ing within the 1-5 range.
carried out in randomly-selected primary and
Those with the mean score of <2 were further
secondary (both public and private) schools in
reclassified into upper class while those with the mean
Abeokuta. Abeokuta, located on longitude 7’10’N and
score of >2 were reclassified into lower social class.
latitude 3’26’E and is about 100 km north of Lagos, For the occupa-tion score, those in upper social class
the capital of Ogun State in southwestern part of included parents, such as senior public officers, large-
Nigeria. It has an estimated population of four million. scale traders, large-scale farmers, and professionals
Abeokuta is predominantly made up of people of the while lower class included artisans and primary school
Yoruba tribe but urbanization and industrialization teachers, peasant farmers, labourers, and the
have brought in many other eth-nic groups. unemployed. For the education score, those with PhD,
masters degree, bachelors and higher national diploma
(HND) were categorized as upper class while those
Method of sampling
with ordinary national diploma (OND), national
At the time of the survey, there were 322 schools in certificate of educa-tion (NCE), technical education
Abeokuta (the ratio of public to private primary grade II teaching certificate, junior and senior
schools was 1:1 while the ratio of public to private secondary school certificates, primary school
secondary schools was 3:1). Using the multistage certificate, and those with no formal education were
random-sampling technique, seven schools—two classified as lower social class.
private primary schools, one public primary school,
one private, and three public secondary schools—
Volume 29 | Nomor 4 | Agustus 2011 365
Prevalensi dan faktor risiko stunting Senbanjo IO et al.
366 JHPN
Prevalensi dan faktor risiko stunting Senbanjo IO et al.
Dren berusia 15-19 tahun, tinggi rata-rata adalah di antara anak-anak sekolah perkotaan di Ile-Ife,
signifi-cantly (p = 0,000) lebih tinggi pada laki-laki Nigeria (12), 16,64% di kalangan anak-anak sekolah
daripada perempuan. menengah Kenya (7), dan 17,9% di antara Santal anak
Puruliya dis-trict di India (14). Ini lebih rendah dari
Sembilan puluh sembilan (17%) anak-anak terhambat kisaran 48-56% diperoleh untuk anak-anak dari
dengan tidak ada perbedaan yang signifikan antara negara-negara di bawah Kemitraan untuk
jenis kelamin (χ2= 0,33, p = 0,567). anak-sembilan Pembangunan Anak (Ghana, Tan-
(3,0%) laki-laki tersebut dan
Ara. Distribusi tinggi-untuk-usia z-skor rata menurut umur dan jenis kelamin
6.00
Wanita Pria
unt -Umur z-skor
4.00
2.00
-
0.00
ketinggian
rata-rata
-2.00
-4,00
5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Umur (tahun)
Kesalahan bar: 95% CI
CI = Interval Keyakinan
11 (4.0%) betina-sangat terhambat. Hal ini zania, Indonesia, India, and Viet Nam) (15) while it is
memberikan tingkat prevalensi keseluruhan stunting high when compared with Turkish children where only
berat menjadi 3,5%. Prevalensi stunting meningkat 5.7% are stunted (16). This difference is likely to stem
dengan usia dan secara signifikan lebih dengan laki- from differential nutritional in-take, socioeconomic
laki (χ2= 7.67, p = 0,022). and cultural differences rather than differences in their
genetic potential to achieve maximum height.
Table 2 shows the association between stunting and
Although the NCHS standard used in this study
various demographic and socioeconomic factors. The
prevalence of stunting was significantly higher among represents the growth pattern of children from the
children aged above 10 years (p=0.031), children from USA, it is accepted in-ternationally to adequately
polygamous homes (p=0.001), chil-dren attending reflect variation in growth that is related to nutrition
public schools (p=0.000), children of mothers and and health of children from different ethnic
fathers with low level of education (p=0.0000, p=0.026 backgrounds (17). The new multi-centre growth
respectively), and low social class (p=0.019). These reference chart of the World Health Organization
were entered into a multiple regression model as (WHO) was not used because there are very few
independent variables with stunting as the dependent studies that used it on school children and adolescents,
variable. Following this multivariate analysis (Table and this will make it difficult for us to compare our
3), only low level of education of mothers (odds findings with those of many other studies that used the
ratio=2.4; 95% confi-dence interval 1.20-4.9; p=0.015) NCHS. Moreover, Stephenson et al. showed that the
significantly con-tributed to the occurrence of stunting height of well-off, urban school children in Kenya was
in the popu-lation studied. not different from the NCHS refer-ence values (15)
while Jane et al. found that the growth of the ‘elite’
Nigerian children is very similar to the figures of the
DISCUSSION
NCHS (18). Thus, our finding is a true mirror-image of
The overall prevalence of stunting in this study was overall standard
17.4%. This is similar to the finding of 19.8%
Tidak. % Tidak. %
Umur (tahun)
> 10 82 19,4 341 80,6
*
<10 17 11.6 130 88,4 1,84 1,02-3,35
Seks
Pria 54 18.2 242 81.8
Wanita 45 16,4 229 83,6 1.14 0,72-1,79
†
Jenis keluarga
Poligami 47 25,0 141 75.0
**
Monogami 51 13,6 323 86,4 2.11 1,32-3,37
Jenis sekolah
Publik 84 21.1 315 78.9
***
Pribadi 15 8.8 156 91,2 2,77 1,50-5,19
Pendidikan ibu
≤Secondary 75 22,3 262 77,7
***
Pasca-sekolah menengah 24 10.3 209 89,7 2,49 1,52-4,09
Pendidikan ayah
≤Secondary 62 20,7 237 73,9
*
Pasca-sekolah menengah 37 13,7 234 86.3 1,65 1,06-2,58
Kelas sosial
Menurunkan 80 19,8 325 80.2
*
Atas 11,519 146 88,5 1,89 1,07-3,36
† * ** ***
Total jumlah tanggapan adalah 562; p <0,05; p <0,01; p <0,0001; CI = Interval Keyakinan
hidup di Abeokuta dan kemampuan popula-tion untuk di seluruh penduduk usia sekolah.
memenuhi kebutuhan dasar, seperti akses ke makanan,
perumahan, dan kesehatan, yang sendiri merupakan Hubungan antara stunting dan jenis kelamin bervariasi.
Sementara beberapa studi menunjukkan prevalensi
faktor terkait erat dengan pengembangan kurang gizi.
lebih tinggi di antara laki-laki (7,12,16), lain-lain
Namun, ada kemungkinan underes-timation dari beban
menunjukkan prevalensi lebih tinggi di antara
stunting dalam penelitian ini sebagai survei kami
perempuan (14,21). Dalam penelitian ini, prevalensi
hanya di sekolah-penonton. Hasil penelitian di Ghana stunting lebih tinggi di antara anak-anak perempuan
dan Tanzania menunjukkan bahwa anak-anak non- muda berusia 5-9 tahun sedangkan sebaliknya adalah
yang terdaftar lebih kekurangan gizi dibandingkan kasus antara anak-anak berusia 15-19 tahun. Hal ini
anak-anak terdaftar di sekolah (19,20). Tingkat en- bisa disebabkan oleh peningkatan ac-cess untuk
rollment anak di sekolah sangat rendah di Ni-Geria. makanan di usia yang lebih tua ketika perempuan
Antara tahun 2000 dan 2006, rasio partisipasi murni terlibat budaya dalam memasak keluarga-makanan,
sekolah dasar dan menengah Nigeria berkisar 25-72 dan karenanya, status gizi mereka lebih baik
(4). Oleh karena itu, prevalensi 17% mungkin hanya dibandingkan dengan rekan-rekan pria. Penjelasan lain
menjadi ujung beban stunting untuk fakta bahwa lebih anak laki-laki berusia 15-19
yang terhambat dibandingkan anak perempuan bisa
karena miskin, perempuan kerdil memiliki
kesimpulan
REFERENSI
gizi kronis tetap menjadi fitur yang menonjol dari anak-
1. Organisasi Kesehatan Dunia. status fisik: penggunaan
anak sekolah Nigeria perkotaan dan remaja. PBB telah
dan interpretasi antropometri. Jenewa: Organisasi
menetapkan Millennium Mengembangkan-ment Goals
Kesehatan Dunia, 1995. 36 p. (Laporan tidak ada Teknis.
(MDGs) yang harus dicapai pada tahun 2015 (4). Delapan
854).
MDGs yang meliputi mengurangi separuh pro-porsi orang
yang menderita kelaparan dan mal-nutrisi, menyediakan 2. Organisasi Kesehatan Dunia. Katalog indikator
pendidikan dasar universal, dan promosi tingkat kesehatan: pilihan indikator kesehatan yang penting yang
pendidikan yang lebih tinggi lebih tinggi untuk pria dan direkomendasikan oleh program WHO. Jenewa: Organisasi
wanita membentuk cetak biru yang disepakati oleh semua Kesehatan Dunia, 1996. 117 p. (WHO / HST / SCI /96.8).
negara di dunia. upaya bersama dilakukan untuk 3. seri lanset pada undernutri-tion ringkasan eksekutif ibu
mempromosikan pendidikan tinggi pada wanita akan dan anak. 2008,11 p. (Http: //tc.iaea org / tcweb / abouttc /
membantu mempromosikan pemberdayaan perempuan tcseminar / Sem6-ExeSum.pdf, diakses pada tanggal 25
agar mereka dapat menerima penggunaan perkembangan Agustus 2009.).
initia-tives. 4. Dana Anak-anak PBB. kelangsungan hidup anak.
Keadaan anak-anak dunia. New York, NY: Disatukan
Dana Anak Bangsa, 2008. 154 p. 17. de Onis M, Habicht JP. data referensi antropometrik untuk
5. Organisasi Kesehatan Dunia. Malnutrisi: global penggunaan internasional: rekomendasi dari Organisasi
gambar. In: Nutrisi untuk kesehatan dan pengembangan: Kesehatan Komite Ahli Dunia. Am J Clin Nutr 1996; 64: 650-8.
agenda global untuk memerangi kekurangan gizi. 18. Janes MD, Macfarlene SB, Moody JB. Tinggi dan
Jenewa: Organisasi Kesehatan Dunia, 2000: 9-21. (WHO pertumbuhan berat badan standar untuk anak-anak Nigeria. Ann
/ NHD / 00.6). (Http: http://www.who.int/mip2001/ file / Trop Paediatr 1981; 1: 27-37.
2231 / NHDprogressreport2000.pdf, diakses pada 19. Fentiman A, Balai A. Faktor-faktor yang mempengaruhi
tanggal 25 Agustus 2009). sekolah en-rolment dan kesehatan anak-anak di Afram Plains.
6. Kemitraan untuk Pembangunan Anak. perawakan pendek Ghana: Dana Anak-anak PBB, 1997: 1-56.
dan usia pendaftaran di sekolah dasar: pejantan-ies di dua 20. Beasley NMR, Hall A, Tomkins AM, Donnelly C, Ntimbwa
negara Afrika. Soc Sci Med 1999; 48: 675-82. P, Kivuga J et al. Kesehatan anak-anak yang terdaftar dan non-
terdaftar usia sekolah di Tanga, Tanza-nia. Acta Trop 2000; 76:
7. Status Mukudi E. Nutrisi, partisipasi pendidikan, dan 223-9.
prestasi sekolah antara anak-anak sekolah menengah Kenya. 21. Ukoli FA, Adams-Campbell LL, Ononu J, Nwankwo MU,
Nutrisi 2003; 19: 612-6. status Chanetsa F. gizi anak-anak sekolah Nigeria perkotaan
8. de Onis M, Blossner M. Kesehatan Dunia Organization- relatif terhadap referensi NCHS popu-lation. Timur Afr Med J
tion global database pada pertumbuhan anak dan malnutri- 1993; 70: 409-13.
tion: metodologi dan aplikasi. Int J Epidemiol 2003; 32: 518-
22. Choudhury KK, Hanifi MA, Rasheed S, Bhuya
26.
ketidaksetaraan A. Gender dan gizi buruk pada anak-anak di
9. Verhoef H, West CE, Veenemans J, Beguin Y, Kok FJ. daerah pedesaan terpencil Bangladesh. J Kesehatan popul Nutr
Stunting dapat menentukan keparahan anemia malaria terkait 2000; 18: 123-30.
pada anak-anak Afrika. Pediatrics 2002; 110: E48.
23. Madusolumuo MA, Akogun DB. Sosial budaya fac-tor gizi
10. Schroeder DG, Martorell R, bayi dan anak pertumbuhan kurang pada balita di negara bagian Adamawa, Nigeria. Nutr
Flores R. dan kegemukan dan distribusi lemak pada orang Kesehatan 1998; 12: 257 -62.
dewasa Guatema-lan. Am J Epidemiol 1999; 149: 177-85.
24. Stoltzfus RJ, Albonico M, Tielshch JM, Chwaya HM,
11. Adair LS, Guilkey DK. penentu usia-spesifik stunting Savioli L. Linear retardasi pertumbuhan pada anak-anak sekolah
pada anak-anak Filipina. J Nutr 1997; 127: 314-20. Zanzibari. J Nutr 1997; 127: 1099-105.
25. Ojofeitimi EO, Owolabi OO, Aderounmu A, Esimai AO,
12. Oninla SO, Owa JA, Onayade AA, Taiwo O. studi Olasanmi SO. Sebuah studi pada balita status gizi dan faktor
compara-tive status gizi anak-anak sekolah Ni-gerian penentu dalam semi - pedesaan ko-nity dari Ile-Ife, Osun State,
perkotaan dan pedesaan. J Trop Pediatr 2007; 53: 39-43. Nigeria. Nutr Kesehatan 2003; 17: 21-7.
13. Oyedeji GA. latar belakang sosial ekonomi dan budaya
anak-anak dirawat di rumah sakit di Ilesa. Nig J Paediatr 26. Rowland MGM. Pencegahan energi protein malnu-trition.
1985; 12: 111-7. Dalam: Standfield P, Brueton M, Chan M, Parkin M, Waterson
14. Chowdhury SD, Chakraborty T, Ghosh T. Prevalensi gizi T, editor. Penyakit anak-anak di daerah subtropis dan tropis. 4th
di Santal anak Puruliya dis-trict, Bengal Barat. Pediatr India ed. Kent: Edward Arnold, 1999: 358-66.
2008; 45: 43-6.
15. Kemitraan untuk Pembangunan Anak. Status anthropo- 27. Semba RD, de Pee S, Sun K, Sari M, Akhter N, Bloem MW.
metrik sekolah di lima negara dalam kemitraan untuk Pengaruh pendidikan formal orangtua pada risiko anak stunting
perkembangan anak. Procd Nutr Soc 1998; 57: 149-58. di Indonesia dan Bangladesh: studi cross-sectional. Lancet 2008;
16. Gur E, Can G, Akkus S, ErcanG, Arvas A, Güzelöz S et 371: 322-8.
al. Apakah gizi masalah di antara anak-anak sekolah Turki ?: 28. Dana Anak-anak PBB. pendidikan perempuan. Keadaan
faktor yang memiliki pengaruh di atasnya? J Trop Pediatr dunia anak-anak 2000. New York, NY: Dana Anak-anak PBB,
2006; 52: 421-6. 2000. 120 p.
370 JHPN