Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 14

J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741

DOI 10.1007/s10826-017-0774-9

ORIGINAL PAPER

Creating Supportive Environments for Children Who have had


Exposure to Traumatic Events
1
Katrina P. Cummings ●
Samantha Addante1 Jami Swindell1 Hedda Meadan1
● ●

Published online: 13 May 2017


© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2017

Abstract The prevalence of trauma among young children that trauma-informed care might be viable in early child-
and its impact on educational outcomes is gaining attention. hood classroom settings. Implications for research are
It is probable that the needs of children who have experi- discussed.
enced or been exposed to trauma have long gone unmet due
to identification challenges and a lack of knowledge con- Keywords Early childhood education Early childhood

cerning best practices. For this study, qualitative interviews special education Trauma Socio-emotional development
● ● ●

were conducted to gather perspectives of 14 community- Parent-teacher partnerships


based service providers who worked with children and
families regarding trauma-related concerns. Each shared his
or her perspectives on knowledge and skills early childhood
education teachers need to support children who have Introduction
experienced traumatic events and partner with their famil-
ies. Research questions were: What should early childhood About 1 in 4 children experience potentially traumatic
teachers know about (1) trauma experiences among young events before their third birthday (Briggs‐Gowan et al.
children; (2) the emotional and behavioral patterns of chil- 2010; Mongillo et al. 2009). By age nine, 13% of children
dren who have experienced traumatic events; and (3) sup- will have experienced 4 or more traumatic events (Finkelhor
porting the social and emotional well-being of children in et al. 2007). The American Psychological Association
the classroom setting, including partnering with families, (2013) defines trauma as “an emotional response to a terrible
who have experienced or been exposed to traumatic events? event like an accident, rape or natural disaster (para. 1).”
Participants indicated that teachers might not readily con- The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Admin-
nect children’s behaviors and emotions to trauma. However, istration (SAMHSA 2014) further conceptualizes trauma by
teachers can use approaches and strategies (e.g., being indicating, “Individual trauma results from an event, series
attuned and supporting positive social and emotional and of events, or set of circumstances that is experienced by an
communicative responses) that promote social and emo- individual as physically or emotionally harmful or life
tional well-being for children who experience trauma. Par- threatening and that has lasting adverse effects on the
ticipants also noted that teachers can resist re-traumatization individual’s functioning and mental, physical, social, emo-
by making adaptations to social, physical, and temporal tional, or spiritual well-being (p. 11).”
aspects of the classroom environment. Findings indicate Children who experience potentially traumatic events are
more likely to display clinical symptoms than children who
do not (Briggs‐Gowan et al. 2010). Posttraumatic stress
disorder (PTSD) is the common diagnosis for persons who
* Katrina P. Cummings have display a range of clinical symptoms following
ksangute@illinois.edu
exposure to traumatic events. The American Psychiatric
1
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1310 S. Sixth Street, Association sought to better capture trauma in young chil-
288 Education Building, Champaign, IL 61822, USA dren in the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical
J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741 2729

Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) by including a pre- mediators between trauma exposure and challenging beha-
school subtype of PTSD (APA 2013). The preschool sub- viors. In a longitudinal study, Briggs-Gowan et al. (2012)
type is characterized by (a) exposure to a traumatic event, found that among a random sample of 437 preschool and
(b) re-experiencing, (c) avoidance or negative alteration in kindergarten-aged children, PTSD symptoms mediated
mood or cognition, (d) hyperarousal, (e) 1 month duration, longitudinal pathways between violence exposure and
and (f) impairment in functioning. internalizing and externalizing behaviors. Milot et al. (2010)
Substantial evidence suggests that the symptomology reported similar results from a cross-sectional study with
among individuals that experience trauma in early child- children who were either maltreated or nonmaltreated
hood differs from symptomology in individuals who first between ages 46 to 72-months-old. They found that trau-
experience trauma later in life (Jones and Cureton 2014). matic stress symptoms mediated the relation between early
Generally, young children exhibit symptoms related to re- maltreatment and later internalizing and externalizing
experiencing, avoidance, and hyperarousal just as older behaviors.
persons do, but with different intensity and in varied The support needs of children who experience trauma
amounts (De Young et al. 2011). Re-experiencing includes requires a range of knowledge (Chafouleas et al. 2016). Yet,
reenacting themes from the traumatic event, having dis- early childhood teachers receive limited training on the
turbing nightmares (Lieberman and Knorr 2007; Scheeringa promotion of social and emotional competence (Han 2014).
et al. 2003), and exhibiting distress upon exposure to Thus, they likely lack the competencies for supporting
reminders of the traumatic event (Scheeringa et al. 2003). social and emotional well-being among children who have
Avoidance symptoms involve efforts to avoid people, pla- been exposed to traumatic events. Limited awareness of
ces, and activities that bring about memories of the trauma potential environmental triggers and the multiple ways in
and also loss of developmental skills, such as toileting and which child trauma manifests could lead to inadvertently
speech (Scheeringa et al. 2003). Avoidance might be subtle triggering stress reactions in children, thereby provoking the
(e.g., avoiding eye contact) or obvious (e.g., refusal to make presence or exacerbation of symptomology (Lieberman
contact with objects) and manifest as social withdrawal or et al. 2011).
diminished participation in activities as children get older Holmes et al. (2015) described the only known trauma-
(De Young et al. 2011). Rather than avoidance, young related professional development material designed speci-
children might display negative alterations in mood and fically for early childhood teachers. Holmes et al. adapted
cognition that is characterized by numbing positive emo- the Attachment, Self-Regulation, and Competency Model,
tions (Jones and Cureton 2014). Finally, hyperarousal which was developed to address trauma (Blaustein and
manifests as difficulty concentrating, hypervigilance, Kinniburgh 2010), to include nonclinical language, age-
exaggerated response, anxiety, and aggression (Scheeringa appropriate resources for children ages three to five, and a
et al. 2003). The American Academy of Pediatrics (2014) training format appropriate for program participants. Other
has also identified several eating-related symptoms (e.g., researchers draw foundational trauma-informed profes-
rapid eating, hoarding food, loss of appetite) that might be sional development content (e.g., prevalence and impact)
categorized as hyperarousal or avoidance symptoms. from organizations and governmental initiatives (Chafou-
Many children who experience trauma also display leas et al. 2016). At this time, neither the transferability nor
internalizing and externalizing behaviors. Understanding effectiveness of trauma-informed professional development
the links between trauma and internalizing and externalizing materials for classroom use have been adequately studied.
behaviors during early childhood years is complex, yet Given the prevalence of trauma and the emergence of a
essential for a supporting children who have experienced or literature base depicting clinical needs among young chil-
been exposed to traumatic events (Jones and Cureton 2014). dren who experience potentially traumatic events, it is
In a random sample of 917 18 to 36-month-olds, about 20% important to explore knowledge and skills that teachers can
of children who had been exposed to traumatic events use to support young children who are impacted by trauma.
exhibited challenging behaviors (Mongillo et al. 2009). Thus, this study explored information that might be helpful
These children scored higher on the Child Behavior to teachers as they shape educational experiences for young
Checklist and the Brief Infant Toddler Social Emotional children who have experienced trauma (e.g., child physical,
Assessment internalizing and externalizing scales compared sexual abuse, domestic violence). Four guiding assumptions
to children with no trauma exposure. Finally, the children were that trauma-informed environments include service
who had been exposed to traumatic events and also providers who (a) realize the impact of trauma, (b) recog-
exhibited challenging behaviors demonstrated more re- nize the signs of trauma, (c) respond by integrating
experiencing and hyperarousal than children who had been knowledge about trauma within the environment, and (d)
exposed to traumatic events, but did not display challenging actively resist re-traumatization of individuals who have a
behaviors. Other studies go a step further by identifying trauma history (SAMHSA 2014). These assumptions are the
2730 J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741

basis for trauma-informed care set forth by SAMHSA Table 1 Participant demographics
(2014). They provided a useful means to frame this study, Category Variable n (%)
which explored the perceptions of community-based service
Gender Male 1 (7.14)
providers, e.g., social workers and family counselors, on
training and preparation considerations for teachers of Female 13 (92.86)
children in early childhood education settings who have Discipline Education 3 (21.43)
experienced or been exposed to traumatizing circumstances. Social Work 8 (57.14)
The three questions that guided this research were: (1) What Human development 2 (14.29)
or family studies
should early childhood teachers know about trauma
Psychology 1 (7.14)
experiences among young children; (2) What should early
childhood teachers know about the emotional and beha- Years of experience 1–10 years 3 (21.43)
vioral patterns of children who have experienced traumatic 11–20 years 4 (28.57)
events; and (3) What should early childhood teachers know 21 or more years 7 (50.00)
about supporting the social and emotional well-being of Highest degree earned Master’s 11 (78.57)
children in the classroom setting, including partnering with Bachelor’s 3 (21.43)
families, who have experienced or been exposed to trau- Populations served Child protective 11 (78.57)
matic events? service involved
Low Income 10 (71.43)
Homeless 7 (50.00)
Method Top SOURCES of trauma for Abuse/Neglect 10 (71.43)
children served
Domestic violence 7 (50.00)
Participants
Area of life affected by trauma School 11 (78.57)
This study included individual interviews with 14 Home 10 (71.43)
community-based service providers across a state in the Relationships 5 (35.71)
Midwest. Participants had worked with or on behalf of
young children (ages 0–5) who had experienced or been
exposed to traumatic events for a range of four to 43 years. individuals expressed interest during the initial contact and
The participants’ primary job responsibilities involved pre- additional recruitment continued via follow up contacts.
vention of child maltreatment and/or enhanced parent-child Prior to data collection, the questionnaire and interview
relationships. A few of the positions held by participants protocol were piloted with a doctoral student who had field
were: Mental Health Consultant, Child Life Specialist, and experiences with the target population and amended for
School Social Worker. The diverse group of participants clarity. Both measures were administered by the first author
presented a wide range of work experience; however, 12 to each participant in person or by phone at a time and place
(86%) of the 14 participants delivered family-oriented ser- convenient for the participant. Data collection continued
vices rather than or in addition to child-oriented services. until data were saturated, or no new themes emerged during
Additional details about participants’ work experiences are data analysis (Guest et al. 2006). All interviews were audio
in Table 1. recorded. Interviews ranged from about 30–80 min in
duration and were 48 min on average. Participants received
Procedures a $20 gift card after completion of the interview.

The key informant sampling technique was used to select


participants whose work exposed them to firsthand knowl- Measures
edge of the population of interest and relevant information
regarding the identified research questions (Marshall 1996). Participants completed a questionnaire and a semi-
The lead author contacted individuals as well as local and structured interview. The questionnaire included 12 items
state agencies that primarily focus on prevention of child related to the community based service providers’ work
maltreatment and/or enhanced parent-child attachment experiences and characteristics of persons with whom they
relationships for children ages 0–5 and their families. The work. The questionnaire included items regarding partici-
lead author spoke with 48 individuals by phone or email pants’ job title, degree, and years of experience working
and, consequently, distributed recruitment flyers via email with young children who have experienced or been exposed
to allow individuals and agency staff to share information to traumatic events and/or families as well as subpopula-
about the research project with colleagues. Some tions typically served, sources of traumatic experiences and
J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741 2731

exposure for young children served, and areas of life to Trauma, (c) Responding to Trauma: Promotive Approa-
affected (home, school, community, work). The interview ches and Strategies, and (d) Resisting Re-Traumatization:
protocol was developed by the lead author following an in Environmental Consideration. The alignment of each theme
depth review of literature on trauma during early childhood and related categories with guiding research questions and
years. The interview protocol included 13 questions, as well SAMHSA’s trauma-informed assumptions that were pre-
as prompts, that were used to understand service providers’ sented in the introduction is provided in Table 3. Frequency
definition of trauma, further delve into their work experi- counts and percentages are provided alongside each
ences, and gain detailed insights about each of the research category.
questions.
Realizing the Existence and Impact of Trauma among
Data Analyses Young Children

Data were analyzed by the first through third authors who Participants were not provided with a definition of trauma,
had 10 years of field experience in clinical mental health but rather encouraged to share their own perspectives of
services and early childhood mental health consultation. defining aspects of trauma. Participants noted that young
The first and third authors coded open-ended questionnaire children as well as their families experience trauma and its
responses (e.g., populations served, area of life affected by impact.
trauma) and then calculated percentages where appropriate
to provide descriptive data. Interviews were transcribed The existence of trauma: Defining characteristics
verbatim and checked for accuracy by a research team
member. The first and second authors then analyzed tran- Across participant responses, two key characteristics of
scripts via a constant comparison process (Creswell 2013). trauma were identified: external influences and an impact as
Specifically, the authors coded transcripts line by line, one a result of these influences. External influences were men-
at a time, independently. Afterwards, they met to come to a tioned by 11 participants (79%). External influences were
consensus on codes. Concurrently, the authors developed a described as events that occur within the home, community,
coding index that included definitions for each code. This or other systems (e.g., divorce, abuse, natural disasters).
process continued until one half of the transcripts had been Additionally, four participants (29%) mentioned internal
coded. Next, the authors refined the coding index to reflect a influences, which were described as a person’s ability or
final set of themes and categories that emerged across inability to integrate a potentially traumatic experience.
transcripts. Then, the first and second authors used the Thirteen participants (93%) mentioned the existence of an
coding index to code across the 14 interview transcripts. impact, maybe over time, that results in biological, emo-
Finally, for transparency, the authors calculated frequencies tional, or behavioral changes. In general, participants agreed
and percentages to denote how many participants referenced that trauma resulted from an influence, mostly a negative
each category. event that interrupted typical functioning. Lisa summed up
During analyses, authors used three indicators to foster these sentiments in her definition by noting, “Trauma to me
credibility and trustworthiness: thick descriptives, colla- would be any type of experience that leaves a lasting scar, I
borative work, and member checks (Brantlinger et al. 2005; would say for a child, or has any type of latent or immediate
Tracy 2010). Thirteen participants (92.86%) engaged in effects.”
member checks, which included reviewing one to two page
summaries of their interviews to provide feedback on their The impact of trauma: Adaptive behaviors
accuracy and comprehensiveness (Tracy 2010). Feedback
included minor changes (e.g., clarification of work All participants provided examples of ways trauma might
responsibilities, clarification of word usage—resiliency as manifest for children and their families. Participants shared
amazing vs. surprising, etc.). The authors refer to each an array of adaptive behaviors that children use as a result
participant by a pseudonym in the findings that follow (see of experiencing traumatic events. Patricia noted,
Table 2).
I think a lot of our kids, if they have been hurt,
particularly by a caregiver, when they start to feel that
level of intimacy, they react by maybe portraying a
Results
really negative behavior to try to create some distance
between them and that person because they’ve kind of
Findings are organized by themes and related categories.
learned that maybe the caregiver isn’t necessarily a
Themes were: (a) Realizing the Existence and Impact of
safe concept.
Trauma among Young Children, (b) Recognizing Reactions
2732 J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741

Table 2 Participant pseudonyms and work characteristics


Participant Years of experience Discipline (degree) Current services provided
pseudonyms with trauma

Tim 43 Psychology (master’s) • Family therapy


• Assessment
Marla 11 Social work (master’s) • School services
Joan 9 English and education • Home visits
(bachelor’s) • Social emotional screenings
• Support groups
• Crisis counseling
• Referrals
Terry 27 Social work (master’s) • Residential services
Lisa 4 Family studies (bachelor’s) • Parent support groups
• Home visits
• Play groups
• Crisis counseling
Joyce 35 Social work (master’s) • Counseling
• Supervised parent-child visits
Patty 20 Social work (master’s) • Foster care
• Residential services
• Case management
Linda 26 Early childhood education • Parent and professional
(master’s) consultation for challenging
behaviors
• Home visits
Jo Anne 20 Social work (master’s) • Foster care
• Family counseling
Patricia 28 Social work (master’s) • Foster care
• Transitional and independent
living
• Vocational rehabilitation
• Counseling
Suzanne 5 Human development and • Family support and advocacy
family studies (master’s)
Shayna 23 Social work (master’s) • Mental health consultation to
service providers
Amanda 20 Social work(master’s) • Counseling
Annette 30 Education (bachelor’s) • Family support and advocacy
Linda 26 Early childhood education • Parent and professional
(master’s) consultation for challenging
behaviors
• Home visits
Jo Anne 20 Social work (master’s) • Foster care
• Family counseling
Patricia 28 Social work (master’s) • Foster care
• Transitional and independent
living
• Vocational rehabilitation
• Counseling
Suzanne 5 Human development and • Family support and advocacy
family studies (master’s)
J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741 2733

Table 2 continued
Participant Years of experience Discipline (degree) Current services provided
pseudonyms with trauma

Shayna 23 Social work (master’s) • Mental health consultation to


service providers
Amanda 20 Social work(master’s) • Counseling
Annette 30 Education (bachelor’s) • Family support and advocacy

Similarly, Joan shared: or preschool settings, behaviors and emotions appear dif-
ferently across individuals based upon individual char-
Infants sometimes will sleep and sleep for a long
acteristics, context, and the traumatic event experienced.
period of time because it’s a way of avoiding what’s
Lisa highlighted the complexity of trauma in early child-
going on. Some children become extra-clingy and are,
hood by explaining, “It’s difficult when it comes to trauma
you know, very people-pleasing and then others kind
because you can’t ever place a child or situation into a box. I
of ward everybody off. They do everything they can
mean there’s just so many situations, so many reactions, and
to keep somebody from liking them.
every family is unique.” Regardless, participants indicated
Yet Linda shared, that emotional and behavioral signs exist for children and
their families. A section on emotional and behavioral signs,
They will strike out first. So they are aggressive as
including biological and developmental considerations
well, like, “I’m going to hurt you before you hurt me,”
(e.g., sleep patterns and age, respectively) is presented fol-
kind of “I’m going to be on guard all the time.” And
lowed by sections on identification challenges and adaptive
so, it’s kind of their first reaction to things might be
behaviors and resilience.
kind of aggressive and push away …to protect
themselves from hurt. We’ve certainly seen that.
Emotional and behavioral signs
Linda also noted that a teacher might think that a child is
“not listening” or “ignoring” when instead they “check out” All participants discussed emotional and behavioral indi-
because they are overwhelmed. cators of trauma. Commonly discussed behavioral patterns
All participants noted that trauma-related challenges included aggression, clinginess, demandingness, violent,
often exist within family systems. When asked specifically attention-seeking, low self-control, pestering and hypervi-
about the functioning of families of children who have gilance. Tim noted, “… aggressiveness with other children,
experienced trauma, Patty stated, “Well what I’ve seen its withdrawal from the caregiver, high levels of demanding-
chaos. Because they’ve gone through trauma themselves ness of the caregiver, clinginess and signs of depression.”
and they’ve never been treated or had treatment for their He further noted that most caregivers do not recognize signs
trauma so they just perpetuate that generational thing so it’s of depression, but identify behavioral displays of depres-
chaotic. They don’t function well at all.” Terry emotionally sion. For example, caregivers might say, “he’s just real
expressed the challenges some families face, saying, poopy” or “he doesn’t play with the other kids” or “when I
fix snack he doesn’t come.” Terry shared,
I think there is a lot of resilience and I think people
who are getting by and people who are moving on and I think you can see the gamut of emotions, you can
continuing to kind of move through their day-to-day see kids that are very flat-affect, that just kind of are
functions. I think it’s, it’s hard to see people that, that expressionless. I think you kind of see kids that are
they- they’ve decided that’s as far as they can go, that very high-energy, super-hyper, you know, just kind of
they can’t- that this is as good as it’s going to get, I everything.
mean that’s kind of sad.
Eleven participants (79%) agreed that children who have
experienced or been exposed to traumatic events might
Recognizing Reactions to Trauma display signs that are influenced by biological and/or
developmental trajectories. Patricia referred to being “age-
A recurring theme that was found across all participants appropriately-delayed” whereby a child might need more
included the mutual understanding that although children support than his or her same-aged peers in order to
who have experienced or been exposed to traumatic events demonstrate various social and emotional competencies.
may display behavioral and emotional patterns in childcare Lisa shared examples that highlight potential intersections
Table 3 Aligned trauma assumptions, research questions, themes, and categories
2734

Research questions Trauma-informed assumptions Themes Categories

What should early childhood teachers know about trauma Service providers realize the impact of Realizing the existence and impact of • The existence of trauma: Defining
experiences among young children? trauma and recovery paths trauma among young children characteristics
• The impact of trauma: Adaptive
behaviors
What should early childhood teachers know about the Service providers recognize the signs of Recognizing reactions to trauma • Emotional and behavioral signs,
emotional and behavioral patterns of children who have trauma in children, families, and others including biological and developmental
experienced traumatic events? involved signs
• Identification challenges
• Resilience
What should early childhood teachers know about Service providers respond by incorporating Responding to trauma: Promotive • Be attuned
supporting the social and emotional well-being of knowledge about trauma into practices approaches and strategies • Convey positive regard
children in the classroom setting, including partnering • Collaborate with parents and other
with families, who have experienced or been exposed professionals
to traumatic events? • Support positive social and emotional and
communicative responses
• Engage in proper reactions
Service providers resist re-traumatization Resisting re-traumatization: • The social environment
environmental considerations • The temporal environment
• The physical-sensory environment
J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741
J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741 2735

between behaviors, emotions, developmental age, and bio- an issue of it’s a certain color of a shirt that someone
logical characteristics. Regarding trauma in young children, has worn because maybe their perpetrator wore that
she noted, shirt when they were attacked. So, some people…they
think it might be a typical behavior but when you get
I think it differs depending on age and child, but some
down to the nitty gritty and start digging into that kind
of the typical ones are, definitely for younger children,
of stuff, the trauma, it’s not typical behavior. It’s not
just overly emotional and some…they can be
something a pill’s going to cure.
fearful…night terrors are something I’ve seen or
trouble sleeping. The fear of being alone, maybe just Several participants also noted that children’s inability to
constant crying is something that I’ve seen as well. identify or articulate what they are experiencing can be a
Inability to be consoled. I’ve also seen, I guess challenge. Terry noted, “We think things are obvious…we
reclusion would be the word, where a child just wants don’t get that whole picture because they’re not verbal
to be isolated just kind of has a fear of adults or maybe enough to tell us.”
attaches to one adult, but is afraid of interacting with
others. For different types of physical or sexual abuse Resilience
I would definitely say changing and bathing and
things like that. There is a definite fear surrounding Despite challenges that experiencing trauma might pose to
that. You can just kind of see the fear in crying, in children and their families, participants unanimously agree
body language, stiff bodies when they are picked up. that children who have experienced or been exposed to
trauma, as well as their families, are capable of displaying
Eleven participants (79%) also indicated several indica-
signs of resilience. All participants acknowledged the resi-
tors of trauma that parents might display while interacting
lience of children and twelve participants (86%) talked
with teachers. Despite the many other responsibilities tea-
about the strengths of families. Participants described the
chers have, one participant noted, “… you’re kind of there
resilience of children as “remarkable,” “amazing,” and
for the whole family… you don’t just get children … you
“impressive.” Most participants described resilience as a
get the whole package deal whether you want them or not,”
trait. For example, Shayna stated, “Children are resilient,
Terry shared. Participants noted that parents might be
and even though children go through really traumatizing
defensive, afraid, or even envious of teachers. However,
things, they can grow up and be strong successful adults.”
most comments were related to parental distrust. Joan
On the other hand, some participants described resilience
acknowledged that, “Sometimes it might be kind of hard to
that existed on a spectrum, as did Amanda who noted,
talk with the parents about what’s going on with the child.”
Marla concluded, “Parents and schools, sometimes there’s a I have a child right now who recently went through a
lot of distrust and maybe I can never fully build that rela- horrible situation, but this child immediately went to
tionship but whatever we can do for that child is what brings stay with his grandparents who are providing so much
us to the table.” continuity for him … I think that really makes a
difference for children in helping them to be resilient.
Then there are some children who’ll develop resilience
Identification challenges
and you just kind of wonder how. But I truly think
that they are, most children will need and benefit from
While describing the range of behaviors and emotions that
an adult who’s really consistent and loving, and that
children who have experienced or been exposed to trauma
could even be the preschool teacher, the one
may display, 10 participants (71%) referenced the chal-
consistency in their lives, especially if they get moved
lenges that exist with identifying these patterns of behavior
out of, out of their home, that, keeping children in the
and emotion. “I think it’s hard to say this is what a child
same day-care setting, preschool setting can really
looks like that’s been abused or neglected,” Terry shared.
make a big difference in helping them be more
Participants explained the importance of investigating the
resilient.
purpose of and reasons behind these behaviors and emo-
tions, rather than making assumptions. For example, Patty
Regarding families’ strengths, Lisa stated, “They
noted,
always find a way.” Joan explained,
We have kids that wet their pants. We have kids that
hoard food. We have kids that want to be by Just the fact that they have stayed together and con-
themselves. We have kids that act out and throw tinue to go on so long, I think that deserves some
temper traumas from the least little kind of thing, [for respect, the fact that they’re still present and they do
example] trying to give them direction. It can even be still get their child to school in the morning, that they
2736 J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741

do continue to try to work. I have some families that child’s parent died or divorced, the teacher might have
are really special to me, and it isn’t because they have Family Day rather than Mother’s Day or Father’s Day.
become super successful or I’ve seen them go from,
Participants shared similar ideas regarding partnering
you know, homelessness to extremely stable housing
with parents. Linda stated,
and a much better job. It’s because they always get
back up. It’s because they, maybe mom lost her job
Parents are often times doing their darndest to
and lost her car, but she took the bus for 3 months to
problem-solve it, but it looks to the outsider, out of
get another job and piece together child care all that
context, it looks like pathological … We don’t really
time, and just kept going. And just because, and I see
know what their story is in the home that they’re
it all the time, people fall all the way back to the
trying to respond to.
starting line, and you would think that they would go
back even further than that, and they would be done… Lisa commented, “Most people who have experienced
But they don’t. They put everything back together as trauma don’t feel that others have the best intentions for
best they can and go on. I’ve seen people have entire them, so I think just unconditional support, showing those
households of stuff that’s just gone and they built up a good and pure intentions is really important.” Yet Marla
new household and it’s, it’s not any better than it was noted the importance of being attuned by saying, “I think
before, but it’s continuous and I think there’s some- parents if we are having behavioral concerns, it’s like oh my
thing really big to be said for that, just being still god it’s one more thing that they have to deal with right.”
standing. She then reflected on being attuned and showing sensitivity
toward parents:

Responding to Trauma: Promotive Approaches and “Here’s what we want you to do. We want you to go
Strategies home and try this positive behavior strategy….” It’s
4–6 weeks of an intervention before we can say it’s a
Participants were asked to identify classroom strategies to success or not. How do I tell a parent who is so
build social and emotional competence among children who stressed out “give it 4–6 weeks?”
have experienced or been exposed to traumatic events and
also to provide recommendations for partnering with
families. Participants identified several promotive approa- Convey positive regard
ches that teachers might use while interacting with children
and their families, including being attuned, showing posi- Eight participants (57%) recommended that teachers show
tive regard, and collaborating with parents and other pro- positive regard to children and four (29%) recommended
fessionals. Additionally, regarding interacting with children applying this principle when partnering with parents. Terry
in classroom settings, participants suggested that teachers referenced a child who “was always suspended from her
support positive social and emotional and communicative classroom” and wondered “…is there a way to incorporate
responses and engage in proper reactions to children. her in the classroom. Is there a way to build her as a leader”
as opposed to isolating her as the “bad kid.” She further
Be attuned noted,
We’re always worried that we don’t want to reward
Being attuned to children and families’ needs was men-
negative behaviors, but, but maybe rewarding and
tioned by all participants. Moreover, participants referenced
pulling that child in as the assistant to the teacher, it
being attuned twice as often as any other category when
might appear as a reward but if it fixes- it fixes the
referring to both children and families. Participants descri-
other problem then what’s wrong with that, you
bed being attuned as understanding and anticipating the
know?
needs of children who have experienced trauma and their
families and then responding accordingly. Terry explained Marla reasoned, that children will have challenging days.
that when a child has gone through something potentially When they do, teachers should respond by saying, “We’ll
traumatic “looking at the bigger picture” is important. Linda see you tomorrow and we’re going to start again tomorrow.”
recommended “staying open and curious.” In tandem with Similarly, regarding families, Marla recommended, “If we
understanding and anticipating a child’s needs, participants do have to have hard conversations, truly finding the
noted that teachers should respond with sensitivity to strengths of that child and that family and bringing those to
identified needs. For example, Annette proposed that tea- the table.” Amanda suggested, “include the parent in any
chers modify classroom observances. She noted that if a kind of positive that you see in the classroom” and “greet
J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741 2737

each child as if he’s the most important wonderful child in I think art is a really huge tool that a teacher could use
the world.” to kind of foster, um- it doesn’t have to be just specific
to that child’s loss or traumatic event … Give, you
know, the children as a whole in their classroom that
Collaborate with parents and other professionals avenue to express themselves through their art.

Several participants suggested using a collaborative


Engage in proper reactions
approach when supporting children (n = 8, 57%) and part-
nering with families (n = 4, 29%). Suzzane said, “I think
Six participants (43%) shared the importance of teachers
keeping a respectful relationship with the parents is going to
having proper reactions to children who have experienced
make sure that you’re more knowledgeable of what your
trauma. The participants shared a range of strategies focused
kids are going through and what kind of mindset they’re
on non-punitive responses and allowing the child to practice
bringing into the classroom.” Jo Anne noted,
adaptive behaviors. Joan suggested that teachers be
Probably the single most and importantly thing “informed and well-aware of why the child might behave
[teachers] can do is build that positive relationship- the way they do instead of being quick to anger or judge or
the teacher-child relationship and anything they can punish, think about where that behavior might come from
do to kind of bridge that with maybe a positive and adjust their ways of handling that child accordingly.”
caregiver. From one school year teacher to the next Similarly, Lisa shared,
school year teacher, I mean, you know, if there’s
I think being able to have a safe and proper reaction to
mentoring opportunities once a kid leaves your
the language that a child displays … remaining calm.
classroom and you’re able to still check in with them
Just being informed as … how to respond so that the
or, kind of follow their progress, see them in the
child never feels bad or like it’s their fault, like it’s
hallway, you know, that kind of stuff, I think is
inappropriate to discuss that.
important.
Regarding proper reactions to adaptive behaviors, Linda
When asked about partnering with families, participants
depicted a child who may not have developed language
shared similar ideas. Marla acknowledged, “I want [parents]
skills but is able to efficiently move around the environ-
to come and feel like I’m here as an equal and as a person as
ment. She explained,
we’re all collaborating to help my child.” She also
acknowledged the importance of helping parents navigate It’s not important whether they can talk a lot, what’s
the school system and other services, by noting, important is that they can move quickly to get out of
the way, and so how do you use those motor skills to,
I don’t think it can all be on [school staff]. I think we
instead of [saying] “Sit down, sit down, sit down, sit
have to somehow work with other agencies … but
down,” how do we use those motor skills to, to kind of
then you run into time and coordination … I think
offset the language barriers that children might have.
until a student, what’s sad, is in such far need you get
It’s becoming creative, um, instead of making children
like wrap around plans, involving more people.
feel ashamed for some of their resiliency skills.

Resisting Re-traumatization: Environmental


Support positive social and emotional and communicative
Considerations
responses
In addition to responding to a multitude of emotional and
Ten participants (71%) talked about facilitating positive
behavioral patterns that children who have experienced or
social and emotional and/or communicative responses
been exposed to trauma may present, participants indicated
within the classroom setting. Several participants indicated
that teachers should be knowledgeable about various
that teachers might promote self-regulation through parti-
aspects of the classroom environment (i.e., social, temporal,
cular means such as play, music, and books. For example,
and physical/sensory considerations) that might trigger
Amanda noted, “I think music, rhythm, dancing, kind of
trauma responses. Joan noted that the classroom might be
that, those kind of activities that kind of bring us into a kind
the only safe, secure setting the child experiences
of more relaxed state, I think [those] kind of activities are
throughout the day, so teachers should try to
really important.” Others focused more on the necessity of
providing means for children to express themselves. For …keep all your interactions as positive as you can,
example, Annette shared, being as respectful to the child as you can, and being
2738 J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741

as loving as you can… when a child might not have Fall was very much a trigger for [my son]. So, I think
access to that much love and respect at home, at least just the change in temperature and he would get very
we know we can give it to them [in the classroom]. emotional and it would- it would trigger him and [he
was] a normally well-behaved child, and then he
Participants noted that one way to promote a sense of
would just be more difficult and more challenging…
safety is by minimizing potential triggers of trauma in the
His response eventually would get to, you know, “I
classroom setting. For example, Jo Anne noted that teachers
miss my birth mom,” or “Why didn’t my birth mom
might arrange children in circles rather than in rows during
love me.” So that, because he came into foster care in
group meetings so that children can all see each other
the fall, his birthday is in the fall, his last contact with
because “people don’t trust people.” Considerations that
his birthmother was in the fall. So, you know,
teachers might make pertaining to aspects of the social,
something that nobody could control because Fall’s
temporal, and physical/sensory environments in order to
gonna come, but it was very much a trigger for him…
minimize negative or potentially harmful reactions from
It took me a couple years as a trained person, you
children who have experienced trauma are shared below.
know, not as a mom, but as a trained person to
connect- we just need to adjust things just a little
The social environment different in Fall.
Linda noted,
Participants shared numerous considerations for shaping a
sensitive social environment that mainly revolved around …especially after a weekend,…I’ve heard teachers
interactions. Participants highlighted considerations for say, “It’s the worst time, I hate that period of time,”
child–child interactions as well as teacher-child interactions. because they’re very, like, they’ve experienced- and
Eleven participants (79%) discussed social-related triggers they have to come back in to the classroom and
when asked what environmental considerations teachers reacclimate to a system or a schedule, um, at the end
should make when supporting children who have experi- of the day, um, or at the end of the week, that’s
enced or been exposed to trauma. Specific considerations difficult for some children. I think, um, around meal
included the gender of teachers, the demeanor of teachers, times, around, uh, certainly around nap times- nap
and physical contact. For example, Terry reflected, “I mean time really starts out- or if they have to use the
for kids that are in homes of violence, I think fighting, restroom, if they have to use the bathroom, so all of
yelling, could be a trigger, um, raised voices could be a those basic functions…they’ll throw up after they eat,
trigger for them. For kids that have been sexually abused, or they just fight going to sleep, they won’t even won’t
just a touch the wrong way [might be a trigger].” Lisa even lay down on the pad. Those are all, you know
pointed out, they could be indicators of trauma, I don’t want to say
that it always is.
I think children pick up on an adult’s demeanor and I
think if an adult is maybe not warm or friendly to an
extent and represents a coldness of maybe of someone The physical/sensory environment
whom they’ve experienced trauma with before that
could be a characteristic. Social interactions with Physical or sensory-related environmental considerations
children with other children as well. A lot of times in were mentioned by 10 participants (71%). A number of
homes we’ll see large families where abuse has participants specifically referred to darkness and loud noises
occurred with an older sibling or cousin and that will being sensory triggers. Linda explained, “Fire alarms,
trickle down to the younger children… That can cause slamming of a door, chaotic environments where they see a
anxiety as well from child to child. lot of movement in the room is very disorienting to the
child.” Linda, as did others, described links between a
chaotic physical/sensory environment and social con-
The temporal environment siderations described prior by further noting that such
environments could lead to inadvertently touching a child
Considerations related to the temporal environment, or and, thus, result in the child reacting aggressively or cow-
aspects of the environment that are relative to time, were ering. Several participants noted that considering physical
discussed by 11 participants (79%). Terry expressed that proximity might minimize unwanted social interactions
scheduled events (e.g., mealtime, naptime, bedtime) and (e.g., unwanted touches).
changes in climate or seasons could impact children who In general, participants noted that trauma-related envir-
have experienced trauma. For example, she shared, onmental considerations differ across individuals because
J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741 2739

events or sensations that bring a child back to the time of than any other age group (Administration for Children and
trauma, causing them to present adverse behaviors and Families 2015). Also, children who experience poverty are
emotions reflective of that chaotic state, are highly indivi- at greater risk for exposure to traumatic events than children
dualized. “… I feel so sorry for a teacher who had to keep in living in higher socioeconomic conditions (Briggs‐Gowan
mind fifteen children’s responses to a variety of environ- et al. 2010). Thus, it is not surprising that a majority of
mental arrangements or stimuli in the room. That would be participants reported working with young children who
tough, but geez what a gift to the children,” noted Tim. were involved with child protective services (n = 11, 79%)
and families with low incomes (n = 10, 71%). One-half
reported working with families who are experiencing
Discussion homelessness.
Although trauma treatment is often person-focused,
This study presents key themes gathered from a group of participants reflected that supporting the needs of children
individuals from diverse disciplines about knowledge and who experience trauma is largely dependent upon teachers’
skills teachers might use to shape classrooms that accom- ability to understand, anticipate, and respond to the needs of
modate the growing number of children who have been children with curiosity, rather than based on assumptions.
exposed to or experienced traumatic events. Guiding Given the implicit bidirectional processes surrounding
research questions were: (1) What should early childhood trauma, teachers’ development of understandings and skills
teachers know about trauma experiences among young pertaining to trauma aimed at universal promotion and
children; (2) What should early childhood teachers know prevention in classroom settings appear to be noteworthy
about the emotional and behavioral patterns of children and goals. Participants shared various principles and strategies
families who have experienced traumatic events; and (3) related to children who have experienced or been exposed
What should early childhood teachers know about sup- to trauma that might be embedded at the classroom level
porting the social and emotional well-being of children in despite difficulties identifying trauma-related experiences of
the classroom setting, including partnering with families, individual children and making connections between
who have experienced or been exposed to traumatic events? environmental factors and traumatization. The aforemen-
Participants revealed that children and families might tioned difficulties come with the nature of trauma and
experience any of an array of traumatic events that result in should not deter from efforts to improve the classroom
adaptive behaviors to guard against the adverse effects of experiences of children who have experienced or been
those events. Second, the emotional and behavioral patterns exposed to trauma. For instance, there might be no way to
of children and families who have experienced trauma avoid potential triggers in a classroom (for example, a male
depend on individual experiences and characteristics and teacher or meal time); however, teachers can resist, or
these patterns might not be easily connected to trauma. prevent, re-traumatization by thinking creatively about
Third, while teachers can use individualized approaches and classroom level accommodations that minimize the poten-
strategies to promote social and emotional well-being for tial deleterious effects of such triggers.
children who have experienced trauma, many approaches The Pyramid Model, a positive behavior interventions
and strategies might be implemented at the classroom level. and supports model, might be an effective tool for guiding
Among a group of young children who had experienced the development of trauma-informed classroom settings
an array of traumatic events, use of the preschool subtype because its multi-tiered design (i.e., which includes uni-
criteria rather than DSM-IV criteria resulted in a spike in versal, preventive, and intervention components) espouses
PTSD identification from 13 to 69% (Scheeringa et al. the key elements needed (i.e., nurturing and supportive
2011). Widespread use of the preschool subtype of PTSD relationships, high quality environments, targeted social and
criteria will lead to increases in the number of children emotional strategies, and individualized strategies) to shape
identified with PTSD, and likely heightened realization of supportive environments for children who have experienced
the impact of trauma exposure during early childhood. trauma (Hemmeter et al. 2006). Recently, the Head Start
Eleven participants (79%) in this study reported that the Trauma Smart (HSTS) program was developed to address
children whom they serve have challenges in school settings trauma among young children (Holmes et al. 2015). Like
due to trauma. However, they suggested that teachers are the Pyramid model, HSTS involves a multi-tiered approach
often unaware of trauma among the children they serve and whereby universal practices are employed across the
its impact. A realization of the existence and impact of classroom and individualized interventions are implemented
trauma might be particularly valuable for early childhood with children who have clinical needs. Holmes et al.
education teachers who work with vulnerable populations implemented HSTS at three Head Start programs. Evalua-
because they are disproportionately affected by trauma. tion results showed that HSTS led to improvements in
Young children experience a higher rate of maltreatment teacher practices within several domains of the Classroom
2740 J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741

Assessment Scoring System (e.g., emotional support and to children’s social and emotional development. These
classroom organization) and also significant increases in studies should provide recommendations for practice,
attention and decreases in challenging behaviors based on including resources needed to implement trauma-informed
the Achenbach assessment. Although little evidence exists principles in classrooms. Additionally, research should be
on the effectiveness of HSTS, it includes the first known conducted regarding the effectiveness of existing interven-
intervention model that targets trauma among children in tion models (e.g., the Pyramid Model and HSTS) for
early childhood settings. addressing the social and emotional needs of children who
Finally, participants provided meaningful considerations experience trauma and their families. Additionally, school-
regarding realizing, recognizing, and responding to trauma level implementation of prevention and promotion strate-
in the family system. Twelve participants (86%) reported gies (e.g., the addition of ongoing professional development
providing family-oriented services. When asked what type for teachers, access to trained clinical staff, voluntary stu-
of trauma the children they serve most often experience, 10 dent support groups) rather than discipline should be
(71%) said abuse or neglect and seven (50%) said domestic examined given the punitive consequences that children
violence. Given that these sources of trauma are situated who experience trauma are prone to experience due their
within the family system, partnering with families should be propensity to engage in challenging behaviors. Finally,
a priority. Despite the emphasis participants placed on future research is needed to understand key skills for part-
families, majority consensus existed for only one approach nering with parents of children who have experienced
(i.e., being attuned) when they were asked for recommen- trauma. Research on positive behavior interventions and
dations for partnering with families. Such a disconnect was supports suggests that parents are open to partnering with
reflected in an article on the crisis in children’s mental teachers and actually want more information from their
health services by Huang et al. (2004) where they noted that children’s teachers regarding the promotion of positive
“partnering with families in treatment is not readily under- social and emotional skills (Cummings 2016). Considera-
stood or accepted by many professionals (p. 169).” Fur- tion should be given to ways that teachers might partner
thermore, they noted that these realities are reflected in with families experiencing unique circumstances (e.g.,
service delivery trends. So while consensus on the impor- foster care arrangements, homelessness) and referral to
tance of partnering with parents may now exist, service specialized services (e.g., special education, mental health).
delivery trends might not necessarily reflect these beliefs. Research in these areas can further the contributions of this
Overall, findings of this study reflect ways that teachers study aimed at fostering effective trauma-informed care
might demonstrate the trauma-informed assumptions set forth practices within early childhood settings.
by the SAMHSA (2014): realizing the impact of trauma,
recognizing the signs of trauma, responding by integrating Author Contributions K.P.C.: designed and executed the study, co-
knowledge about trauma, and actively resisting re- led data analyses, and wrote the paper. S.A.: co-led data analyses and
wrote part of the results. J.S.: assisted with data analysis and wrote part
traumatization. Thus, findings suggest that teachers can of the results. H.M.: collaborated in designing the study and editing the
develop the capacity to create supportive classroom environ- final manuscript.
ments for children who experienced trauma, despite children’s
individualized experiences with trauma. Moreover, interven- Compliance with Ethical Standards
tion models exist that might guide these efforts.
Conflict of Interest The authors declare that they have no compet-
ing interests.
Limitations

This study drew from the experiences of non-teaching


professionals. Therefore, as mentioned above, the feasibility References
of implementing trauma-informed care in classroom settings
Administration for Children and Families (2015). Child Maltreatment
should be closely explored. Also, nine of the 14 participants 2013. Available from https://www.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/
(64%) worked in public agencies and the majority of them cb/cm2015.pdf.
reported receiving consumer referrals from public agencies. American Academy of Pediatrics (2014). The Medical Home
Approach to Identifying and Responding to Exposure to Trauma.
Therefore, participant perspectives might be most applic-
https://www.aap.org/en-us/Documents/ttb_medicalhomeapproa
able to children and families who receive public services. ch.Pdf.
To better understand the competencies that teachers need American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical
to support young children who have experienced or been manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: Author.
American Psychological Association (2013). Trauma. American Psy-
exposed to trauma, future research should examine what
chological Association. http://www.apa.org/topics/trauma/.
trauma-informed practices teachers are currently using as Blaustein, M., & Kinniburgh, K. (2010). Treating traumatic stress in
well as what teachers’ attitudes are toward trauma in relation children and adolescents: How to foster resilience through
J Child Fam Stud (2017) 26:2728–2741 2741

attachment, self-regulation, and competency. New York, NY: Holmes, C., Levy, M., Smith, A., Pinne, S., & Neese, P. (2015). A
The Guilford Press. model for creating a supportive trauma-informed culture for
Brantlinger, E., Jimenez, R., Klingner, J., Pugach, M., & Richardson, children in preschool settings. Journal of Child and Family Stu-
V. (2005). Qualitative studies in special education. Exceptional dies, 24, 1650–1659.
Children, 71, 195–207. Huang, L., Macbeth, G., Dodge, J., & Jacobstein, D. (2004). Trans-
Briggs-Gowan, M. J., Carter, A. S., & Ford, J. D. (2012). Parsing the forming the workforce in children’s mental health. Administration
effects violence exposure in early childhood: Modeling devel- and Policy in Mental Health and Mental. Health Services
opmental pathways. Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 37, 11–22. Research, 32, 167–187.
Briggs‐Gowan, M. J., Ford, J. D., Fraleigh, L., McCarthy, K., & Jones, L. K., & Cureton, J. L. (2014). Trauma redefined in the DSM-5:
Carter, A. S. (2010). Prevalence of exposure to potentially trau- Rationale and implications for counseling practice. The Profes-
matic events in a healthy birth cohort of very young children in sional Counselor, 4, 257–271.
the northeastern United States. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 23, Lieberman, A. F., Chu, A., Van Horn, P., & Harris, W. W. (2011).
725–733. Trauma in early childhood: Empirical evidence and clinical
Chafouleas, S. M., Johnson, A. H., Overstreet, S., & Santos, N. M. implications. Development and Psychopathology, 23, 397–410.
(2016). Toward a blueprint for trauma-informed service delivery Lieberman, A. F., & Knorr, K. (2007). The impact of trauma: A
in schools. School Mental Health, 8(1), 144–162. developmental framework for infancy and early childhood.
Creswell, J. W. (2013). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, Pediatric Annals, 36, 209.
and mixed methods approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Marshall, M. N. (1996). The key informant technique. Family Prac-
Cummings, K. P. (2016). Supporting parent engagement in tice, 13, 92–97.
programme-wide behavioural intervention implementation. Early Milot, T., Éthier, L. S., St-Laurent, D., & Provost, M. A. (2010). The
Child Development and Care. Advance online publication. role of trauma symptoms in the development of behavioral pro-
doi:10.1080/03004430.2016.1177042. blems in maltreated preschoolers. Child Abuse & Neglect, 34,
De Young, A. C., Kenardy, J. A., & Cobham, V. E. (2011). Trauma in 225–234.
early childhood: A neglected population. Clinical Child and Mongillo, E. A., Briggs-Gowan, M., Ford, J. D., & Carter, A. S.
Family Psychology Review, 14, 231–250. (2009). Impact of traumatic life events in a community sample of
Finkelhor, D., Ormrod, R. K., Turner, H. A., Avery-Leaf, S., Cascardi, toddlers. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 37, 455–468.
M., O’Leary, K. D., & Cuevas, C. (2007). Polyvictimization and Scheeringa, M. S., Zeanah, C. H., & Cohen, J. A. (2011). PTSD in
trauma in a national longitudinal cohort. Development and Psy- children and adolescents: toward an empirically based algorithm.
chopathology, 19, 149–166. Depression and Anxiety, 28, 770–782.
Guest, G., Bunce, A., & Johnson, L. (2006). How many interviews are Scheeringa, M. S., Zeanah, C. H., Myers, L., & Putnam, F. W. (2003).
enough? An experiment with data saturation and variability. Field New findings on alternative criteria for PTSD in preschool chil-
Methods, 18(1), 59–82. dren. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent
Han, H. S. (2014). Supporting early childhood teachers to promote Psychiatry, 42, 561–570.
children’s social competence: Components for best professional Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. (2014).
development practices. Early Childhood Education Journal, 42, SAMHSA’s concept of trauma and guidance for a trauma-
171–179. informed approach. Rockville, MD: SAMHSA.
Hemmeter, M. L., Ostrosky, M., & Fox, L. (2006). Social and emo- Tracy, S. J. (2010). Qualitative quality: Eight “big-tent” criteria for
tional foundations for early learning: A conceptual model for excellent qualitative research. Qualitative Inquiry, 16, 837–851.
intervention. School Psychology Review, 35, 583–601.

You might also like