Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Seminar Report Astha
Seminar Report Astha
On
Other Side of Globalization: Threat to Health Promotion
Submitted by:
Astha Lamichhane
Reg. No: 2019-4-17-0005
Submitted to:
Master of Public Health Program
Department of Public Health
Nobel College, Sinamangal
(Affiliated to Pokhara University)
2022
Student Declaration
I declare that this seminar report entitled “Other side of Globalization: Threat to Health
Promotion, is my own work and no part of this work was used for any other purpose prior to this
date.
Astha Lamichhane
.................................... (Signature)
Submitted by
Astha Lamichhane
for
of
.................................... ...........................
........................... ..................................
Reviewer Reviewer
.................................... ...........................
.................................. ...........................
Objectives
To explore the other aspects of globalization that may cause threat to health promotion.
To disseminate the findings through seminar.
Methodology:
Desk review
Expected Outcome:
This study will help to provide detail knowledge about the Globalization, and the study is
focused towards exploring the other side of globalization that may threat the health promotion
Table of Contents
Student Declaration................................................................................................................2
Executive Summary.................................................................................................................4
Abbreviations..........................................................................................................................6
Chapter I Introduction.............................................................................................................1
1.1 Background............................................................................................................................1
1.2 Statement of the Problem.....................................................................................................3
1.3 Rationale of the study...........................................................................................................4
1.4 Research Question.................................................................................................................5
1.5 Objectives..............................................................................................................................5
Chapter II Literature Review....................................................................................................6
2.1 Literature Review Methods Strategies.........................................................................................6
2.2 Source of Information..................................................................................................................6
2.3 Search strategy.............................................................................................................................6
2.4 Articles/Report identification process..........................................................................................6
2.5 Review of relevant literature........................................................................................................7
Chapter III:Analysis.................................................................................................................9
Positive Impact of Globalization.........................................................................................................9
Negative Impact of Globalization.....................................................................................................10
Key Public Health Concern Arising from Globalization.....................................................................10
Chapter IV: Discussion...........................................................................................................12
Ways to minimize threats of Globalization on public health as per 5 action areas of Ottawa
Charter..................................................................................................................................14
Chapter V: Conclusion...........................................................................................................17
Chapter VI: Way Forward......................................................................................................17
References............................................................................................................................18
Activity Chart........................................................................................................................19
Abbreviations
1.1 Background
Globalization is the word used to describe the growing interdependence of the world’s
economies, cultures, and populations, brought about by cross-border trade in goods and services,
technology, and flows of investment, people, and information (PIIE, 2021).
It is the process of interaction and integration among people, companies, and governments
worldwide. Globalization has accelerated since the 18th century due to advances in
transportation and communication technology. This increase in global interactions has caused a
growth in international trade and the exchange of ideas, beliefs, and culture (Wikipedia,2022).
The modern world is seen as the world without geographical boundaries and any kinds of
barriers. Globalization has been the major force behind this. Globalization is the integration of
the worlds economy and exchanging the ideas, products, technologies etc. Globalization means
rapid increase in the share of ecnomic activities taking place across national borders.
Broadly defined, globalization describes how nations, businesses, and people worldwide are
becoming more connected and interdependent through increased economic integration and
communication exchange, cultural diffusion, and travel ( lee, 2002).
Globalization is characterized by intensification of human contact. In everyday life, people are
moving around more often via tourism, business and migration.
Globalisation affects how we perceive and experience physical or territorial space. Movement of
people, other life forms, information, capital, goods and services has not only intensified across
the borders of countries but, in some cases, has rendered national borders irrelevant. Trafficking
of illicit drugs, cigarette smuggling, undocumented migration, money laundering and global
climate change are transborder phenomena that are challenging the capacity of governments to
effectively regulate them (lee, 2004).
Globalization has contributed to health improvements through diffusion of new health
knowledge, low-cost health technologies, and human rights.
In recent decades, public health policy and practice have been increasingly challenged by
globalization, even as global financing for health has increased dramatically.
1
As the world around us is becoming progressively interconnected and complex, human health is
increasingly perceived as the integrated outcome of its ecological, social-cultural, economic, and
institutional determinants (Labonté et al., 2011).
There are at least three general notions of globalization. First, globalization refers to the
multiplication and intensification of economic, political, social, and cultural linkages among
people, organizations, and countries at the world level. This notion encompasses economic and
non-economic components, including larger trade and financial flows; 3 expanding cross-border
communications, international contacts among political groups, non-governmental organizations
(NGOs), and other members of the civil society; and increased levels of tourism, among other
examples. A second dimension is the tendency toward universal application of economic,
institutional, legal, political, and cultural practices. The codification of trade rules under the
WTO and its predecessor, the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), is one of many
possible economic examples. Non-economic aspects include the spread of democracy, the
increase in the number and coverage of environmental treaties, and even the controversial
possibility of cultural homogenization in entertainment, food, and health habits. A third meaning
of globalization is the emergence of significant spillovers to the rest of the world coming from
the behaviour of individuals and societies. Examples include environmental issues such as cross-
border pollution and global warming, financial crises and contagion, the global spread of
HIV/AIDS and other diseases, and international crime (Huyne et al., 2005)
A study was conducted to study the growing impact of globalization for health and public health
practice, findings revealed that Several globalization-related pathways to health exist, two key
ones of which are: globalized diseases and economic vulnerabilities. The article concludes with a
call for national governments, especially those of wealthier nations, to take greater account of
global health and its social determinants in all their foreign policies (Labonté et al., 2011).
2
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Globalization is the flow of information, goods, capital and people across political and
geographical boundaries (Labonte, 2015).
Globalization has a dramatic impact on healthcare systems and health outcomes. In 2004, when
Nepal got its WTO membership, since then globalization accelerated in Nepal. Globalization can
bring both opportunity and threats to developing country, business and livelihood (Abbott et al.,
2008).
At first glance, many people would say that globalization has had an overall positive impact on
people’s health. Global transportation and the communication revolution enable rapid response
to epidemic and catastrophes, saving the thousands of lives.
But there is also a downside to the health and well-being of people as a direct or indirect result of
globalization. Due to the rapid movement of the people across borders, the spread of infectious
disease is a threat to everyone, particularly to poor. “Today no microbes in the world is more
than 24 hours away from the gateway of every industrialized country” (Kelley,2005).
Due to the easy access to the internet and other means of communication technology one can get
information about health instantaneously but for this people need to have access to the
fundamentals such as electricity and computers and along with this risk of cybercrime is also
increasing day by day, people from one corner can control the world (Labonte, 2015).
Globalization in positive sense has resulted in trade expansion, with an increase in living
standards and improved social and economic status, particularly for women. Conversely,
advances in globalization are also increasing the risk for health problem including an increased
adoption of unhealthy western habits and lifestyles, resulting in increased obesity and prevalence
of disease (abbott et al., 2008).
3
Globalizing Forces
Economic change
Communicable disease
Trade liberalization and
regulation
Rise of the global
Marketplace
Non communicable disease
Political change
Redistribution of power
with in and across
countries Food and nutrition
Growth of global civil Determinants of Health
society Genes and biology
Health care
Sociocultural change Health related
Global shift in Lifestyles Environmental health
behavioral risk factors
Globalization of western Social and natural
culture environments
Globalization can be defined as a process that is changing the nature of human interaction across
a wide range of spheres (e.g., economic, political, social, cultural, technological environment).
Regarding the impact of globalization on health it has dual effects, both positive and negative
(lee, 2004).
Globalization has shown potential positive impacts by minimizing the gaps in health inequalities
between rich and poor people, by the introduction of new technologies and by improving
healthcare for all (Kelley,2005).
4
There are also downsides to global health, such as the spread of infectious diseases due to rapid
mobility, which is emerging as the greatest threat to all. Under the umbrella of globalization and
its impact, other systems beyond human health should not be neglected, such as the impact on
animal health and/or ecosystem health and their impact on human health (abbott et al., 2008).
More recently, the global spread of the influenza pandemic accounted for far more casualties
than the 1st world war.
This study is focused to explore the other aspects of globalization which is threat for health
promotion.
what are the other aspects of globalization that may cause threat to health promotion?
1.5 Objectives
To explore the other aspects of globalization that may cause threat to health promotion.
To find out the ways to minimize the threats of globalization on public health .
To disseminate the findings through seminar.
5
Chapter II Literature Review
2.1 Literature Review Methods Strategies
The literature review method includes internal search, desk review and reports review. The major
objectives of this literature review is to explore the other aspects of globalization that may cause
threat to health promotion.
The source of information for this study are Google and Google scholar mostly. Literature search
has been done by reviewing of printed materials, including journals, books, reports etc.
Additional studies were searched through the electronic databases (PUBMED) using Endnote X3
software. The electronic search was applied to PUBMED. All the articles related to the topic
were included in the review.
While searching articles from Google Scholar, key words used were “Globalization”, “ impact”,
“ public health”, “health promotion”, putting custom range 2000-2022. Around 100 articles were
screened by title and abstract then selected 10 articles for this study.
Desk review of these selected printed materials including peer reviewed journal published
articles, reports of UN agencies, country reports
6
Articles/Reports identification process
15 full article
10 articles excluded
5articles selected
A conceptual framework was developed to study the health impact of globalization, study
revealed that globalisation affects the institutional, economic, social-cultural and ecological
determinants of population health, and that the globalisation process mainly operates at the
7
contextual level, while influencing health through its more distal and proximal determinants. The
developed framework provides valuable insights in how to organise the complexity involved in
studying the health effects resulting from globalisation. It could, therefore, give a meaningful
contribution to further empirical research by serving as a 'think-model' and provides a basis for
the development of future scenarios on health (Huynen et al., 2005).
A study was conducted to investigate the effects of globalization on public health results show
that globalization leads to improvements in health indicators (infant mortality rate, the mortality
rate for children under 5 years and the average life expectancy at birth). Also, the results reveal
that the social dimension of globalization will have a greater effect on public health
(Hozarmoghadam et al., 2015).
A study was conducted to study the growing impact of globalization for health and public health
practice, findings revealed that Several globalization-related pathways to health exist, two key
ones of which are: globalized diseases and economic vulnerabilities. The article concludes with a
call for national governments, especially those of wealthier nations, to take greater account of
global health and its social determinants in all their foreign policies (Labonté, et al., 2011).
An overview of the linkages between globalization and health was conducted, which examines
many of the global health issues associated with the globalization of economic, political, social,
and cultural forces in the world today. The conceptualization and analysis of these linkages
between globalization and health and the effects of globalization on population health are
discussed from the vantage point of various perspectives. Particular attention is given to the
global spread of disease, the diseases of globalization, the health inequities associated with
globalization, the effects of globalization on environmental health, and the globalization of
health-related technologies (Harris et al., 2004).
8
Chapter III:Analysis
9
employment opportunities in export-oriented industries allowing women to earn income
outside patriarchal social structures.
■ Increasing communication, in the face of growing complexity of health system, has made
international comparison more valuable than ever. WHO to assess the performance of all
191 health system of the world.
Negative Impact of Globalization
■ Whether it is the risk of drug-resistant tuberculosis or pandemic influenza, the movement
of people means the transport of pathogens.
■ Global promotion of brands such as: Coca-Cola and Mc. Donald’s, driven by opportunity
to expand profits and markets are increasing Obesity and its health consequences in much
of the developing world.
■ The accelerated flow of traded goods and services enabled by economic integration has
created new sources of wealth and health for some. But patterns of production and
exchange, along with labor market changes, have left many vulnerable to employment
insecurity, insufficient health and safety protections, and environmental degradation.
■ Now the longest intercontinental flights are briefer than the incubation period of any
human infectious diseases, thus the infections can travel from detection centres to other
countries in just few hours.
■ The energy requirements of global production chains, and the fossil fuels used in
transportation, are now among the fastest-growing sectoral contributors to climate change
Key Public Health Concern Arising from Globalization
■ Globalized Disease: The increase in human mobility has accelerated the speed and
distance at which microbes are able to travel, while urbanization, which in some contexts
is accelerated by globalization's effects on rural livelihoods, has facilitated the spread of
infectious diseases. Infectious diseases such as the Covid 19, plague, smallpox, and
cholera have spread owing to human migrations associated with trade, military
campaigns, and religious pilgrimages.
■ Climate change is playing a role in the spread of infectious diseases: Rising
temperatures will increase transmission rates of vector- and rodent-borne diseases,
including malaria, dengue fever, and schistosomiasis.
10
■ Chronic noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) such as cancer, cardiovascular disease, and
diabetes have been steadily growing in prevalence and now account for the largest
proportion of the global burden of disease.
■ Rising incidence of injuries, not only RTA but also work-related injuries and illness,
crime and health damage and social and economic dislocation are occurring in zones of
wars and conflict.
■ Increasing burden of HIV is challenge for both Health System and social policy.
■ The rise in NCDs in low- and middle-income countries is attributable to global trade and
investment policies and practices that are globalizing Western lifestyles, including
increased consumption of unhealthy products. For example, the nutrition transition in
low- and middle-income countries—the shift toward a high-energy diet (containing
animal protein, saturated fats, sugars, and highly processed food) and higher levels of
inactivity—is occurring much faster and at earlier stages of development.
■ Increased trade in tobacco and alcohol products is associated with higher levels of
consumption and health-related problems .
■ Misuse of antibiotics in many countries, especially those that lack well-regulated public
health systems, is heightening concern over the spread of multiple or extremely drug-
resistant infections.
■ Research and policy attention is being paid to the globalization of infectious diseases,
chronic noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) such as cancer, cardiovascular disease, and
diabetes have been steadily growing in prevalence and now account for the largest
proportion of the global burden of disease.
■ Open boarders are causing difficulties in careful restriction on access to prescription
drugs in one country may be subverted when its neighbors allows without restriction.
■ Globalization has led to pollution and ecological damage, resource depletion, climate
change, and increased fossil fuel emission.
■ Global environment: The environmental threats to human health are numerous. Some of
them are more localized, such as lack of access to safe drinking water; inadequate basic
sanitation in the household and the community; and indoor air pollution from cooking
and heating using inadequate fuels and inadequate solid waste disposal. Water pollution
from populated areas, air pollution from motorcars, coal power stations and industries,
11
these can contribute to climate change, ozone depletion, acid rain, loss of biodiversity.
Poor environmental quality has been calculated to be directly responsible for around 25
per cent of all preventable ill-health in the world today, mostly in the form of diarrhoea
diseases, acute respiratory infections, malaria, other vector-borne diseases, chronic
respiratory diseases, and childhood infections.
bank, WTO are working globally to uplift the health status of the people. The framework
convention on Tobacco is a contrasting example of first international public health law, which
aims to reduce harms associated with a toxic products whose production and marketing are
global in scale and scope. Child health revolution of 1980s, with its emphasis on low-cost health
interventions: GOBI, later followed by triple FFF are some of the low-cost health intervention
(Joachim, 2021).
With all these positive aspects globalization has also some of the negative aspects which needs to
be focused, whether it is the risk of drug-resistant tuberculosis or pandemic influenza, COVID
the movement of people means the transport of pathogens.
Global promotion of brands such as: Coca-Cola and Mc. Donald’s, driven by opportunity to
expand profits and markets are increasing Obesity and its health consequences in much of the
12
developing world. The energy requirements of global production chains, and the fossil fuels used
in transportation, are now among the fastest-growing sectoral contributors to climate change
Increased trade in tobacco and alcohol products is associated with higher levels of consumption
and health-related problems and are the major causes of NCDs. Increasing burden of HIV is
challenge for both Health System and social policy (Hozarmoghadam et al., 2015).
13
Nepal has also faced the major problem of brain drain as skilled manpower like doctors,
engineers are moving from home countries to abroad for better opportunities, which resulted in
lack of skilled manpower in the country.
Globalization has also brought some major challenges around the globe, i.e. cyber attack,
communal riots, racial discrimination, environmental degradation, climate change and so on
(Ghimire, 2021).
14
Ways to minimize threats of Globalization on public health as per 5 action
areas of Ottawa Charter
The Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion is the name of an international agreement signed at the
First International Conference on Health Promotion, organized by the World Health
Organization (WHO) and held in Ottawa, Canada, in November 1986.
Health promotion, as defined by the World Health Organization, is the process of enabling
people to increase control over and to improve their health.
Five action areas for health promotion were identified in the charter:
15
Fig: 5 action areas of Ottwa Charter
16
o International and national comparative analysis of health system should be done
so, that we can build a solid knowledge base of what works and what doesn’t.
o Bilateral and multi-lateral agreements among the richer and poorer nations should
be signed to promote human rights, protect environment and to promote global
health.
o Mobilization of domestic resources on health should be done by ensuring the
efficacy of resources use and equity in coverage of financial protection.
5. Re-orient health services:
o Package on essential NCDs and Communicable disease needs to be launched
globally, to decrease the global burden of disease.
o Regular health screening must be done for early diagnosis and treatment.
o Promotion of universal access to health services.
o Restriction on boarder areas must be done to prevent the global transmission of
infection like: COVID 19 pandemic
o Improper use of drugs should be strictly prohibited to minimize the rate of
antibiotics resistance.
o Promotion of PPE use should be done to prevent the transmission of Bacteria and
Viruses.
17
Chapter V: Conclusion
Globalization has a dramatic impact on healthcare systems and health outcomes. The effect of
globalization on health systems and individuals is complex. The globalization processes may
have positive and negative health consequences on the population. These includes increasing
health care and education access, legislation designed to protect human and labor rights,
restriction on exposure to hazardous drugs and products, such as tobacco, environmental waste,
and environmental protection. On the other side there has been evidence that globalization has
resulted in higher tobacco consumption, notably in poorer countries, higher alcohol consumption
particularly among the young. Liberalization may, indeed result in price increase or price
reduction, lower wages or risk to the farmers, because of low price they have to work more to
become self-sustaining. Economic sustainability is not maintained without further assistance
through grants and loans by wealthier and technologically more advanced institutions and
nations. Liberalization policies may sometime led to unemployment and poverty.
Under the umbrella of globalization and its impact, other systems beyond human health should
not be neglected, such as the impact on animal health and/or ecosystem health and their impact
on human health.
With the increasing globalization the risk of Communicable disease, Non-communicable disease,
are increasing day by day and has become a global issues, it has also affected the environmental
health and affecting the public health (Ghimire,2021).
18
References
• Labonte, R. (2015). Globalization and health. International Encyclopedia of the Social &
Behavioral Sciences, 198.
• Farhat, S., & Mahmood, M. A. (1996). Globalisation, Information Technology, and
Economic Development [with Comments]. The Pakistan Development Review, 1019-
1033.
• Abbott, P. A., & Coenen, A. (2008). Globalization and advances in information and
communication technologies: The impact on nursing and health. Nursing outlook, 56(5),
238-246.
• Frenk, J., & Gómez-Dantés, O. (2002). Globalisation and the challenges to health
systems. BMJ, 325(7355), 95-97.
• Azevedo, M. J., & Johnson, B. H. (2011). The impact of globalization determinants and
the health of the world’s population. New knowledge in a new era of globalization.
London: InTech, 165-82.
• Lee, K. (2004). Globalisation: what is it and how does it affect health?. Medical journal
of Australia, 180(4), 156-158.
• Labonté, R., Mohindra, K., & Schrecker, T. (2011). The growing impact of globalization
for health and public health practice. Annual review of public health, 32, 263-283.
• HOZARMOGHADAM, N., SAHABI, B., AHMADI, A. M., & MAHMOUDI, V.
(2015). Impacts of globalization on health indicators.
• Huynen, M. M., Martens, P., & Hilderink, H. (2005). The health impacts of globalisation:
a conceptual framework. Globalization and health, 1(1), 1-12.
• Harris, R. L., & Seid, M. J. (2004). Globalization and health in the new millennium.
In Globalization and health (pp. 1-46). Brill.
• Dodgson, R., Lee, K., & Drager, N. (2002). Global health governance. A Conceptual Review,
London/Geneva.
• Ghimire,S. (2021). What are the impact of globalization?. in.html#:~:text=As%20a%20result
%20of%20globalization%2C%20Nepal%20has%20faced%20the%20major,skilled
%20manpower%20for%20the%20country.
• https://www.piie.com/microsites/globalization/what-is-
globalization#:~:text=Globalization%20is%20the%20word%20used,investment%2C
%20people%2C%20and%20information.
• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Globalization
• https://www.mdpi.com/topics/healthcare
19
Activity Chart
9 Report preparation
Report
10
Submission
20