Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Business Research Methods TUT
Business Research Methods TUT
Business Research Methods TUT
Research Methods
Amare Abawa, PhD
E‐mail: amare.abawa@aau.edu.et
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUTION TO BUSINESS RESEARCH
Meaning of Research
Definition of Business Research
Business research is defined as the
systematic and objective process of
generating information for aid in
making business decisions(Zikmund, 2011)
Introduction………………
• Walliman (2011) argues that everyday uses of the
term ‘research’ are not research in the true
meaning of the word.
The term is used wrongly:
• Just collecting facts or information with no clear
purpose;
• Reassembling and reordering facts or information
without interpretation;
• As an activity with no or little relevance to everyday
life;
• As a term to get your product or idea noticed and
respected.
Introduction………………
Characteristics of Research
• The purpose, to find out things, is stated clearly.
• The data are collected systematically.
• The data are interpreted systematically.
• Therefore, we can define research as a
process that is undertaken in a systematic
way with a clear purpose, to find things out.
Factors in Conducting research
• Why? to equip yourself with the information you
need to make informed business decisions about
• Start-up,
• Innovation,
• Growth etc.
• Time constraints
• Availability of data
• Nature of the decision
• Benefits versus costs
Determining Factors
Availability of Data Benefits
Time Constraints Nature of the Decision vs. Costs
Is the infor- Does the value
Is sufficient time Is the decision Conducting
Yes mation already Yes Yes of the research Yes
available before of considerable
a managerial
on hand
strategic
information Business
inadequate exceed the cost
decision
for making
or tactical
of conducting Research
must be made? importance?
the decision? research?
No No No No
Possible Areas
• General Business Conditions and Corporate Research
• Financial and Accounting Research
• Management and Organizational Behavior Research
• Sales and Marketing Research
• Information Systems Research
• Corporate Responsibility Research
• Etc.
CHAPTER TWO
Theory and the Business
Research Process
Theories
• A theory is a proposed relationship between two or more
concepts.
• Theories are formulated to explain, predict, and
understand phenomena and, in many cases, to challenge
and extend existing knowledge within the limits of critical
bounding assumptions.
• independent variable is what • dependent variable is what is
is manipulated affected by the independent
variable
• a treatment or program or
cause • effects or outcomes
• ‘Factor’ • ‘Measure’
Research Design and Methodology
•Exploratory
•Descriptive
•explanatory
Cross‐Sectional Design
Basic research
Applied research
Basic Research
• Attempts to expand the limits of knowledge.
• Not directly involved in the solution to a pragmatic
problem.
• Needs strong theoretical gap identification
Basic Research Example
• Is executive success correlated with high need for
achievement?
• Are members of highly cohesive work groups more
satisfied than members of less cohesive work groups?
• Do consumers experience cognitive dissonance in low‐
involvement situations?
Applied Research
• Conducted when a decision must be made about a
specific real‐life problem
Applied Research Examples
• Should a company advertise intensively while it the
only company in the industry?
Ethical Issues
• Societal norms
• Codes of behavior
Rights and Obligations of the Respondent
• The obligation to be truthful
• The right to maintain Privacy
• The obligation not to deceive
• The right to be informed
Rights and Obligations of the Researcher
• The purpose of research is research
• Objectivity
• Not misrepresenting research
• Protect the right to confidentiality of both subjects
and clients
• No dissemination of faulty conclusions
Major Parts of a Proposal
Revision
CHAPTER THREE
Use quantitative if your
Use qualitative if your research
research problem requires
problem requires you to
you to
Learn about the views of the
• Measure Variables people you plan to study
• Assess the impact of these
Assess a process over time
variables on an outcome
Generate theories based on
• Test theories or broad
participant perspectives
explanations
Obtain detailed information about
• Apply results to a large
a few people or research sites.
number of people
Five Elements of a “Problem
Statement”
FLOW OF IDEAS
What
Remedying
Evidence for Deficiencies
Educational the Deficiencies
Topic the in the
Issue will do for
Issue Evidence
Select
Subject •A Concern •Evidence from •In this body of Audiences
Area •A Problem the literature evidence, what is
•Something •Evidence from missing? How will
that needs a practical •What do we addressing
solution experiences need to know what we need to
more about? know help:
– researchers
– educators
– policy makers
– individuals like
those in the study
How Do We Write the “Statement of the
Problem” Section?
• One paragraph for each of the five elements
• Heavily reference this section to the literature
• Provide statistics to support trends
• Use quotes from participants
Writing a
Literature Review
• A literature review
surveys scholarly articles, books and other
sources
(e.g. dissertations, conference proceedings)
• You can use software, such as minitab and excel to generate random
numbers or to draw directly from the columns
Systematic Sampling
• Systematic sampling is often used instead of random sampling.
• It is also called an Nth name selection technique.
• After the required sample size has been calculated, every Nth
record is selected from a list of population members.
• As long as the list does not contain any hidden order, this
sampling method is as good as the random sampling method.
• Effective under the following conditions:
• A good sampling frame is not available or costly, while a frame listing
clusters is easily obtained
• The cost of obtaining observations increases as the distance separating
the elements increases
• Examples of clusters:
• City blocks – political or geographical
• Housing units – college students
• Hospitals – illnesses
• Automobile – set of four tires
Convenience Sampling
• Convenience sampling is used in exploratory research where
the researcher is interested in getting an inexpensive
approximation.
• It is a nonprobability method.
• Often used during preliminary research efforts to get an estimate
without incurring the cost or time required to select a random sample
Judgment Sampling
• Judgment sampling is a common nonprobability method.
• Depends on topic – frequently it occurs?
• For probability sampling, the larger the sample size, the
better.
• With nonprobability samples, not generalizable regardless –
still consider stability of results
Sample Size Formula
2
zs Where: n =
n
sample size, Z =
Confidence level,
E s= standard
deviation E= error
• Follow up techniques could bring it up to about 50%
• Still, response rates under 60 – 70% challenge the integrity of
the random sample
• How the survey is distributed can affect the quality of
sampling
Errors (Sampling and Non sampling)
• Sampling error is one which occurs due to
unrepresentativeness of the sample selected for
observation.
• Occurs when the sample selected does not contain the
true characteristics, qualities or figures of the whole
population
• Non‐sampling error is an error arise from human error,
such as error in problem identification, method or
procedure used, etc.
• It arise due to a number of reasons, i.e. error in problem
definition, questionnaire design, approach, coverage,
information provided by respondents, data preparation,
collection, tabulation, and analysis
Errors could be Committed by:
Interviewers
• Interviewers have a direct and dramatic effect on the way
a person responds to a question.
• Most people tend to side with the view apparently favored by
the interviewer, especially if they are neutral.
• Friendly interviewers are more successful.
• In general, interviewers of the same gender, racial, and ethnic
groups as those being interviewed are slightly more successful.
Respondents
• Respondents differ greatly in motivation to answer correctly
and in ability to do so.
• Obtaining an honest response to sensitive questions is
difficult.
• Basic errors
• Recall bias: simply does not remember
• Prestige bias: exaggerates to ‘look’ better
• Intentional deception: lying
• Incorrect measurement: does not understand the units or definition
DATA COLLECTION METHODS
Data
• Data is a collection of facts, figures, objects, symbols, and
events gathered from different sources.
• Organizations collect data to make better decisions.
• Without data, it would be difficult for organizations to
make appropriate decisions
• In case data (related to pdt) is not collected beforehand,
the organization’s newly launched product may lead to
failure for many reasons, such as less demand and
inability to meet customer needs.
Primary Data Collection Methods
• Primary data is collected from the first‐hand
experience and is not used in the past.
• The data gathered by primary data collection methods
are specific to the research’s motive and highly
accurate.
• Primary data can be divided into two categories:
quantitative and qualitative
Quantitative Methods:
Statistical methods are highly reliable as the element
of subjectivity is minimum in these methods
Time Series Analysis ‐ The term time series refers to a
sequential order of values of a variable, known as a
trend, at equal time intervals.
• Using patterns, an organization can predict the demand
for its products and services for the projected time
Qualitative Methods
• Useful in situations when historical data is not available.
• Or there is no need of numbers or mathematical
calculations.
• Qualitative research is closely associated with words,
sounds, feeling, emotions, colors, and other elements
that are non‐quantifiable.
• Quantitative methods do not provide the motive behind
participants’ responses, often don’t reach
underrepresented populations, and span long periods to
collect the data.
• Hence, it is best to combine quantitative methods with
qualitative methods.
Surveys
• Surveys are used to collect data from the target audience
and gather insights into their preferences, opinions,
choices, and feedback related to their products and
services.
• You can also use a ready‐made survey template to save
on time and effort.
• Survey can be distributed through several distribution
channels such as email, website, social media, etc.
• Depending on the type and source of your audience, you
can select the channel.
Polls
• A poll is a way of knowing people’s choices and
understanding what works for them
• Polls comprise of one single or multiple choice
question.
• When it is required to have a quick pulse of the
audience’s sentiments, you can go for polls.
• Similar to surveys, polls, can be embedded into various
platforms.
Interviews
• In this method, the interviewer asks questions either
face‐to‐face or through telephone to the
respondents.
• In face‐to‐face interviews, the interviewer asks a
series of questions to the interviewee in person and
notes down responses.
• This form of data collection is suitable when there are
only a few respondents.
• It is too time‐consuming and tedious to repeat the
same process if there are many participants.
Delphi Technique
• In this method, experts are provided with the estimates
and assumptions of forecasts made by other experts in
the industry.
• Experts may reconsider and revise their estimates and
assumptions based on the information provided by
other experts.
• The consensus of all experts constitutes the final.
Focus Groups
• In a focus group, a small group of people, around 8‐10
members, discuss the common areas of the problem.
• Each individual provides his/her insights on the issue
concerned.
• A moderator regulates the discussion among the
group members.
• At the end of the discussion, the group reaches a
consensus.
Questionnaire
• A questionnaire is a printed set of questions, either
open‐ended or closed‐ended.
• The respondents are required to answer based on their
knowledge and experience with the issue concerned.
• The questionnaire is a part of the survey, whereas the
questionnaire’s end‐goal may or may not be a survey.
Secondary Data Collection Methods
• Secondary data is the data that has been used in the
past.
• The researcher can obtain data from the sources,
both internal and external, to the organization
• The secondary data collection methods, too, can
involve both quantitative and qualitative techniques.
• Secondary data is easily available and hence, less
time‐consuming and less expensive as compared to
the primary data.
• However, with the secondary data collection
methods, the authenticity of the data gathered
cannot be verified.
REVIEW
CHAPTER SIX
Measurement Concept
Measurement and Scaling Concepts
Consider two students who have percentage scores of 79.4 and 70.0, respectively. The most likely outcome when
these scores are translated into “letter grades” is that each receives a C (the common 10-point spread would yield a
70–80 percent range for a C). Consider a third student who finishes with a 69.0 percent average and a fourth
student who finishes with a 79.9 percent average.
Which students are happiest with this arrangement? The first two students receive the same grade, even though
their scores are 9.4 percent apart. The third student gets a grade lower (D) performance than the second student,
even though their scores are only 1 percent different. The fourth student, who has a score only 0.5 percent higher
than the first student, would receive a B. Thus, the measuring system (final grade) suggests that the fourth student
outperformed the first (assuming that 79.9 is rounded up to 80) student (B versus C), but the first student did not
outperform the second (each gets a C), even though the first and second students have the greatest difference in
percentage scores.
• Thus, a strong case can be made that error exists in
this measurement system.
• All measurement, particularly in the social sciences,
contains error.
• Researchers, if you are to represent concepts
truthfully, make sure that the measures used, if not
perfect, are accurate enough to yield correct
conclusions.
• Ultimately, research and measurement are tied closely
together
Concept
• A concept can be thought of as a generalized idea that
represents something of meaning.
• Concepts such as age, sex, education, and number of
children are relatively concrete properties.
• Other concepts are more abstract.
• Concepts such as loyalty, personality, channel power, trust,
corporate culture, customer satisfaction, value, and so on are
more difficult to both define and measure.
• E.g. Loyalty could be measured as a combination of customer
share (relative proportion of purchase) and commitment
(acceptable sacrifice to do business with you)
• A researcher has to know what to measure before
knowing how to measure something
Operational Definitions
• Researchers measure concepts through a process
known as operationalization
• Operationalization is the process of identifying scales
that correspond to variance in a concept that will be
involved in a research process
• This process involves identifying scales that correspond
to variance in the concept
• A scale is a device providing a range of values that
correspond to different values in a concept being
measured
• For example, you may use to check your weight, provide
a range of values that correspond to different values in
the concept being measured.
Variables
• A variable is an element, feature, or factor that is liable to
vary or change.
• For example, consider the following hypothesis;
• H1: Experience is positively related to job performance
• The hypothesis implies a relationship between two
variables, experience and job performance and they
capture variance in the experience and performance
concepts
• The scale used to measure experience is quite
straightforward in this case and would involve simply
providing the number of years an employee has been with
the company
• Job performance, on the other hand, can be quite complex
that could be measured by multiple variables
Constructs
• A construct is a term used for concepts that are
measured with multiple variables.
• For instance, if you wishes to measure the customer
orientation of a salesperson, you could use several
variables like:
• I offer the product that is best suited to a customer’s problem
• A good employee has to have the customer’s best interests in
mind
• I try to find out what kind of products will be most helpful to
a customer
• Each of the variables are captured in a scale 1 to 5
• Thus, Constructs can be very helpful in operationalizing
a concept
Levels of Scale Measurement
• Though there are different scales, all scales may not
have the same richness in a measure and all concepts
may not require a rich measure as well
• The four levels or types of scale measurement are
nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio level scales.
• Each type offers the researcher progressively more
power in analyzing and testing the validity of a scale
Nominal Scale
• Represent the most elementary level of measurement.
• A nominal scale assigns a value to an object for
identification or classification purposes only
• A nominal scale is truly a qualitative scale.
• Nominal scales are extremely useful, and are sometimes
the only appropriate measure, even though they can be
considered elementary
• Nominal scaling is arbitrary. For example, you can assign
1 to designate male, and 0 to designate female. You can
also use any number to designate both gender
categories
Ordinal Scale
• Ordinal scales allow things to be arranged in order
based on how much of some concept they possess.
• In other words, an ordinal scale is a ranking scale
• we may use the term rank order to describe an ordinal
scale
• Ordinal scales are somewhat arbitrary, but not nearly
as arbitrary as a nominal scale because they tell us the
order/rank‐which come first etc.
Interval Scale
• Interval scales have both nominal and ordinal
properties, but they also capture information about
differences in quantities of a concept.
• For example, if a professor assigns grades to mid exam
using a numbering system ranging from 1.0–20.0, not
only does the scale represent the fact that a student
with a 16.0 outperformed a student with 12.0, but the
scale would show by how much (4.0).
Ratio Scale
• Ratio scales represent the highest form of
measurement in that they have all the properties of
interval scales with the additional attribute of
representing absolute quantities
• Interval scales possess only relative meaning,
whereas ratio scales represent absolute meaning.
In other words, ratio scales provide iconic
measurement
Mathematical and Statistical Analysis of Scales
A ratio scale has all the properties of nominal, ordinal, and interval scales. However, the same
cannot be said in reverse
• While it is true that mathematical operations can be
performed with numbers from nominal scales, the
result doesn’t have a great deal of meaning. For
example, a professor cant judge the quality of students
by the average ID number?
• Thus, although you can put numbers into formulas and
perform calculations with almost any numbers, the
researcher has to know the meaning behind the
numbers before meaningful conclusions can be drawn
Discrete Measures
• Discrete measures are those that take on only one of a finite
number of values.
• A discrete scale is most often used to represent a classification
variable.
• Therefore, discrete scales do not represent intensity of
measures, only membership.
• Common discrete scales include any yes‐or‐no response,
matching, color choices, or practically any scale that involves
selecting from among a small number of categories.
• Thus, when someone is asked to choose from the following
responses disagree, neutral, agree, the result is a discrete
value that can be coded 1, 2, or 3, respectively. This is also an
ordinal scale to the extent that it represents an ordered
arrangement of agreement.
• Nominal and ordinal scales are discrete measures
Continuous Measures
• Continuous measures are those assigning values anywhere along
some scale range in a place that corresponds to the intensity of
some concept.
• Strictly speaking, interval scales are not necessarily continuous.
Consider the following common type of survey question:
• Data that are not easily reduced to numbers
• Data that are related to concepts, opinions, values and
behaviors of people
• Data that can be broken down through the process of
classifying or coding; the pieces of data are then
categorized.
What is Qualitative Data Analysis?
•Qualitative Data Analysis (QDA) is the
range of processes and procedures
whereby we move from the qualitative
data that have been collected into some
form of explanation, understanding or
interpretation of the people and
situations we are investigating.
What is Qualitative Data Analysis
•Qualitative Data analysis is a process
of breaking down data into smaller
units, determining their importance,
and putting pertinent units together in
a more general form.
Qualitative Data Collection
• Observation (field notes, checklist….)
• Interviews
• Documents (reports, meeting minutes)
• Focus Groups
• Tape Recorder
• Audio/Video Recording
• Questionnaires (open‐ended)
Coding
•Coding is a process of reducing the data
into smaller groups so they are more
manageable.
•The process also helps you to begin to
see relationships between categories
and patterns of interaction.
Coding…
• all interviews,
• all field notes…….
Exploring Data
• The first step in data analysis is to explore
the data if it is complete & Legible
• Obtain a general sense of the data
• Read and write memos about all field notes,
observer comments to get an initial sense
of the data
Steps in Coding the Data
• Get a sense of the whole
• Pick one document (e.g. one interview, one
field note….).
• Go through it, asking the question “what is
this person talking about?”
• Identifying text segments, placing a bracket
around them and assigning a code word or
phrase that describes the meaning of the
text
Steps in Coding the Data…
• After coding an entire text, make a list of all
the code words. Group similar codes and
look for redundancy codes
• Take the list and go back to the data.
• Circle specific quotes from participants that
support the codes
• Reduce the list of codes to get five to seven
themes/categories
Identifying Themes
What are some of the challenges
that your students face in
Reading Challenges Time constraints
developing their critical thinking
skills?
How do you help to enhance the
Need authentic learning
critical thinking skills of your Greater immersion in reading
students? experience
What supplementary materials
do you encourage your students
Need to Read newspapers Reading of Journals
to read within the subject area?
Collating Data into a Table of Coded Responses
Interview Observation Questionnaire
(teachers) (students) (students)
13.5%
13.5%
2.5% 2.5%
-3 -2 -1 Mean +1 +2 +3
Standard Deviations
The Normal Curve of Mean Differences of All
Possible Outcomes If the Null Hypothesis Is True
(No difference b/n statistics & Parameter
• Double headed arrow ↔
• This is correlation
• Missing Paths
• Hypothesized absence of relationship
• Can also set path to zero
Path Diagram
D
E ZDRS Neglect E
Gender
SEM questions
• Does the model produce an estimated population
covariance matrix that “fits” the sample data?
• SEM calculates many indices of fit; close fit, absolute fit,
etc.
• Which model best fits the data?
• What is the percent of variance in the variables
explained by the factors?
• What is the reliability of the indicators?
• What are the parameter estimates from the
model?
SEM questions
• Are there any indirect or mediating effects in the
model?
• Are there group differences?
• Multigroup models
• Can change in the variance (or mean) be tracked
over time?
• Growth Curve or Latent Growth Curve Analysis
SEM questions
• Can a model be estimated with individual and
group level components?
• Multilevel Models
• Can latent categorical variables be estimated?
• Mixture models
• Can a latent group membership be estimated from
continuous and discrete variables?
• Latent Class Analysis
SEM questions
• Can we predict the rate at which people will drop
out of a study or end treatment?
• Discrete‐time survival mixture analysis
• Can these techniques be combined into a huge
mess?
• Multiple group multilevel growth curve latent class
analysis???????
SEM limitations
• SEM is a confirmatory approach
• You need to have established theory about the
relationships
• Cannot be used to explore possible relationships when
you have more than a handful of variables
• Exploratory methods (e.g. model modification) can be
used on top of the original theory
• SEM is not causal; experimental design = cause
SEM limitations
• SEM is often thought of as strictly correlational but
can be used (like regression) with experimental
data if you know how to use it.
• Mediation and manipulation can be tested
• SEM is by far a very fancy technique but this does
not make up for a bad experiment and the data can
only be generalized to the population at hand
SEM limitations
• Biggest limitation is sample size
• It needs to be large to get stable estimates of the
covariances/correlations
• 200 subjects for small to medium sized model
• A minimum of 10 subjects per estimated parameter
• Also affected by effect size and required power
SEM limitations
• Missing data
• Can be dealt with in the typical ways (e.g. regression,
EM algorithm, etc.) through SPSS and data screening
• Most SEM programs will estimate missing data and run
the model simultaneously
• Multivariate Normality and no outliers
• Screen for univariate and multivariate outliers
• SEM programs have tests for multi‐normality
• SEM programs have corrected estimators when there’s
a violation
SEM limitations
• Linearity
• No multicollinearity/singularity
• Residuals Covariances (R minus reproduced R)
• Should be small
• Centered around zero
• Symmetric distribution of errors
• If asymmetric than some covariances are being
estimated better than others
Practical Data Analysis, Report writing
and the Publication ProcessEntre
Competency Data GROUP.sav
• In this section, we will use the data to run
descriptive analysis and inferential analysis
like Correlation and SEM (Regression, EFA,
CFA, Path analysis, Mediating effect,
Moderating effect, etc along with the
model fit measures and all assumptions of
regression