Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys - Seeking Alpha
Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys - Seeking Alpha
REITs
Brad Thomas
Marketplace
Summary
A few days ago, I wrote an article titled "Think Like A Landlord."
Now, I'm moving over to mREITs in which I challenge you to "Think Like A
Banker."
But remember, I'm writing on commercial mREITs, a sector that I'm rather bullish
about, in light of rising rates.
I do much more than just articles at iREIT on Alpha: Members get access to
model portfolios, regular updates, a chat room, and more. Learn More »
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=rt… 1/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
A few days ago I wrote an article titled “Think Like A Landlord” in which I said that “I
think it’s extremely important for readers to think like the business owner because this
is core to being a true value investor, and, of course, in the REIT sector this means
that you must always "Think Like a Landlord.""
Today, I’m moving over to the mREIT sector. These are REITs that provide financing
for income-producing real estate by purchasing or initiating mortgages and mortgage-
backed securities, and earning income from the interest. They help provide essential
liquidity for the real estate market. A few weeks ago, I wrote an article in which I
explained,
if you had purchased NLY in 2003 and held onto shares until now, you would have
generated annual returns of 3.6%.
I followed up that article with another one on Annaly Capital Management (NLY), in
which I explained,
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=rt… 2/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Many of my regular readers know I'm not a big fan of residential mortgage REITs.
I've frequently warned investors to stay away from them, in fact.
Like most any investment, the more debt you use, the greater the potential for gain
or loss. And when we buy stocks on margin, we're leveraging investment returns
with debt.
It's well known that mortgage REITs (mREITs) own debt, not property. So the risks
of investing in them are considerably elevated compared with other dividend-
paying stocks.
They benefit when interest rates come down, which increases the value of the
mortgages they hold. Essentially, it's the beneficial use of borrowing money that
magnifies returns (leverage).
That's the reason spreads for mREITs are wider and dividends are much higher
than equity REITs. To put in bluntly, as I've often argued, they don't belong in a
retirement portfolio.
Personally, I’ve avoided residential mREITs because they’re highly leveraged – which
can make earning streams and dividend payments much more volatile. They tend to
be more sensitive to interest rates.
Given our experience in credit analysis, we’re keen on identifying the key
characteristics used to ascertain mREITs’ relative value and safety.
Part of that analysis focuses on the quality and durability of those earnings. As I
explained in yet another article,
“The vast majority are structured as floating rate loans offering good protection
against rising interest rates. There is no inherent inflation protection, however, in
the sense that inflation without rising rates won't increase their income.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=rt… 3/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Equity REITs have undoubtedly seen appreciation of their assets on average, and
in many cases much higher rents, while mREITs wait patiently for higher interest
rates to move LIBOR and boost their income.”
iREIT on Alpha
Historical default rates for commercial mortgage loans are highly cyclical and
comparable to high yield bonds over a full economic cycle, but inferior to preferred
stocks and BDCs.
Overall, we consider quality mREITs attractive to high yield bonds and preferred
stocks, marginally inferior to quality BDCs, and slightly undervalued against the
sector's historical averages.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=rt… 4/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
The commercial mortgage REIT sector can be further broken down into two
categories: pure balance sheet lender and balance sheet/conduit lender.
A pure balance sheet lender originates or purchases loans for their own balance
sheet and holds these loans on their balance sheet (although they may sell
participation units in the loans to diversify some of the risks). Examples include
Blackstone Mortgage Trust (BXMT) and Apollo Commercial Real Estate Finance
(ARI).
A balance sheet/conduit lender originates and/or purchases loans for its own account
(balance sheet) or to be sold into a securitized vehicle such as CMBS (conduit). Ares
Commercial Real Estate (ACRE), Ladder Capital (LADR), and Starwood Property
Trust (STWD) are all conduit lenders.
There are differences between these two types as well, and risk can be further
diversified. Balance sheet lenders originate loans with the intent of holding them on
their books. Balance sheet/conduit lenders originate loans for both their own books
and to sell into securitized markets such as CMBS.
The risk with balance sheet lenders is relatively straightforward - the risk that the
loans don't perform as expected. Balance sheet / conduit lenders have the risk of
non-performance as well as the risk that the conduit market experiences a disruption
and cannot take as many loans as expected.
As you can see below, these commercial mortgage REITs generate dividend yields
from 2.1% for iSTAR (STAR) to 13.2% for Cherry Hill Mortgage (CHMI). The average
dividend yield for the sector is 8.6%.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=rt… 5/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
iREIT on Alpha
Today I will provide you with a list of three commercial mREIT buys and our reasons
for liking them. Recognizing that credit analysis is extremely important when
analyzing mREITs, I must remind you to always think like a banker!
All loans secured by first lien mortgages with conservative maximum 70% loan-to-
value ratio; all loans require personal guarantee by the principals of the borrowers.
As viewed below, shares have fallen by ~15% YTD.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=rt… 6/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Yahoo Finance
The broader market backdrop continues to support growth for residential construction
projects as demand continues to outpace available supply. A decade of under-
development has led to aging housing stock in which the median house is ~40 years
old.
One key differentiator for SACH is its nimble approach to origination. The company
can close a loan in as quickly as 5 days, whereas the competitors can take 3-6+
months. Due diligence is more centered around the value of the collateral rather than
the property cash flows or borrower’s credit.
Despite the rise in interest rates, SACH believes that there exists significant market
opportunity for a well-capitalized “hard money” lender to originate attractively priced
loans to small and mid-scale real estate developers with good collateral.
I asked the company’s CIO, Bill Haydon, last week about the increased expenses in
2021 (of $7.5 million), which represented 78%. He told me that the expenses should
normalize in 2022.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=rt… 7/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Net income for 2021 was approximately $11.5 million (compared to approximately
$9.0 million for 2020) an increase of approximately $2.5 million, or 27.5%. The net
income per weighted average common share outstanding for 2021 was $0.44,
compared to $0.41 for 2020.
FAST Graphs
As viewed above, SACH’s payout ratio was 109% in 2021, which means the dividend
was not covered; however, the analyst forecast for 2022 looks solid, with 34% growth
(keep in mind, there are just 2 analysts reporting to Fast Graphs).
Nonetheless, given the pipeline and modest default rate (of around 1.6%) we believe
SACH could easily cover the dividend and provide shareholders with a meaningful
boost in 2022.
We maintain a Strong Buy, although we must also acknowledge this small cap REIT
($176 mm market cap) can be extremely volatile. Shares are now trading at $4.94
with a P/E of 10.3 and dividend yield of 9.7%.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=rt… 8/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
FAST Graphs
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=rt… 9/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Yahoo Finance
KREF is externally-managed by KKR (KKR), and we view this as positive given the
strong alignment (KKR owns 23% of KREF) and deep experience of the private
equity sponsor ($471 BB in AUM and 135 real estate professionals).
KREF seeks to lend to the highest quality sponsors with properties located in the
highest quality markets. As noted above, the average loan size is $131 million, and
the portfolio has a modest 5% in construction loans. 89% of the portfolio is located
within the Top 20 MSAs.
Over the last 12 months, KREF screened $145.9 billion of financing opportunities and
originated $4.8 billion (3%) of senior loans. In the latest quarter the company
collected 97.3% of interest payments due on loan portfolio and 100% on loans rated
4 or better.
The portfolio is well-positioned for rising rates, as 100% of the loan portfolio is
indexed to one-month USD LIBOR. Around 54% of the portfolio is subject to a LIBOR
floor of at least 0.25%, and 9% of total outstanding financing, including the Secured
Term Loan, is subject to a LIBOR floor greater than 0.0%. Ongoing portfolio rotation
out of higher rate-floor loans is positioning KREF to benefit from a rising rate
environment.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=… 10/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
KREF’ Q4-21 GAAP net income was $35.2 million, or $0.59 per share, and
distributable earnings was negative $2.9 million (or negative $0.05 per share) due to
$0.55 per share in realized losses on loan write-offs. In mid-January, the company
paid a cash dividend of $0.43 per share.
In December, the company took title to its Portland retail property and has capitalized
the property through a JV with a partner at Urban Renaissance Group, a full-service
institutional real estate company with a local Portland presence. On the latest
earnings call Patrick Mattson, President and COO said,
we’re seeing positive underlying trends with our remaining watch list loans, for
example, on our New York luxury condo loan which had an initial loan balance of
$240 million has now been paid down to $40 million through unit sales. Only six
units remain to be sold, three of which are under contract.
Fast Graphs
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=r… 11/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
As seen above, KREF did not cover its dividend in 2021. However, analysts estimate
growth of 4% in 2022 and 9% in 2023, which supports a continued dividend of $1.72
per share.
Shares are trading now at $20.18, or around 8% below our buy target price. The
dividend yield is now 8.5%, and we’re forecasting shares to return around 15% over
the next 12 months.
Fast Graphs
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=… 12/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Yahoo Finance
LADR has a unique model in which the company does not rely exclusively on
securitization for its revenue and has other diversified sources of revenue, including
earning a significant portion of its revenue from first mortgage balance sheet loans
and property rentals as well as expanding its market share in the commercial
mortgage loan origination market.
LADR is internally managed, and its senior management team averages 27 years of
industry experience and insiders (management and directors) own 11.4% of
outstanding shares. This includes 7,303,000 shares owned by the CEO, Brian Harris,
that puts his net worth in LADR at ~$85 million.
The company ended 2021 by having originated a total of $2.9 billion of loans,
including a record 92 balance sheet loans, totaling $2.7 billion resulting in the
highest annual production of Ladder's balance sheet loans in Ladder's history.
The growth in the portfolio led to strong earnings momentum over the course of the
year, and the company continues to conduct rigorous credit standards and return
expectations.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=… 13/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
As of December 31, over 65% of the $3.5 billion balance sheet loan portfolio was
comprised of post-COVID originated loans with fresh valuations and business plans.
The composition of the portfolio remains consistent and continues to be primarily
comprised of lightly transitional loans with a weighted average loan-to-value of 67%.
LADR’s $1.1 billion equity business is primarily made-up net lease assets, leased
primarily to investment-grade tenants with necessity-based businesses under long-
term leases. The portfolio contributed nicely to earnings during Q4-21 with $7.3
million of net gains, further illustrating the embedded value within the portfolio.
As of year-end 2021, the securities portfolio totaled $703 million, down from over $1
billion at the beginning of the year as the company reallocated capital into its balance
sheet loan business, which it believes is currently offering the best risk-adjusted
returns.
At the end of 2021, LADR’s total liquidity was over $800 million, and adjusted
leverage was 1.5x net of cash. Around 39% of LADR’s total debt was comprised of
unsecured bonds, and 83% of total debt was comprised of unsecured bonds and
nonrecourse financing.
LADR appears to be well positioned to benefit from a potential rising interest rate
environment, both by way of its large and growing portfolio of floating rate loans as
well as its significant base of fixed rate liabilities. On the recent earnings call, CEO
Brian Harris said,
…we have been waiting for this turn towards higher rates as inflation has taken on
a more structural than transitory field in the last few months. By balancing our
differentiated liability structure between a larger component of unsecured fixed
rate corporate borrowings and a combination of floating rate CLO and a minor
component of short-term repo debt, we have positioned Ladder to let the Fed do
some of the work for us in the coming year.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=… 14/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Fast Graphs
As viewed above, LADR did not cover its dividend in 2021. However, based on
analyst expectations, the company should easily distribute $.90 per share in 2022,
and we suspect dividend increases will also follow.
I credit the management team for creating ample liquidity in 2020 and taking the
necessary steps to navigate the pandemic and put the risk of a dividend cut in the
rear-view mirror.
LADR shares are now trading at $14.10 per share and a dividend yield of 6.9%. With
a large floating-rate balance sheet loan portfolio and predominantly fixed-rate
liabilities, earnings are positively correlated to rising interest rates. We maintain a Buy
rating.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=… 15/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Fast Graphs
In Closing…
Most investors own mREITs for yield only, but I’ve found that there are several other
reasons to own shares:
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=… 16/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Sharesight
Of course, yield enhancement is the primary reason we own mREITs, and we have
found that by selecting the best securities we can generate considerable alpha that
others don’t.
Sharesight
But remember, if you look to own shares in mREITs, you must always remember to
“think like a banker.”
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=… 17/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
Brad Thomas
100.91K Followers
Brad Thomas is the CEO of Wide Moat Research ("WMR") a subscription based publisher of financial
Show More
Follow
Disclosure: I/we have a beneficial long position in the shares of BXMT, KREF, LADR, SACH,
STAR, STWD either through stock ownership, options, or other derivatives. I wrote this article
myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than
from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is
mentioned in this article.
Additional disclosure: Author’s Note: Brad Thomas is a Wall Street writer, which means he's
not always right with his predictions or recommendations. Since that also applies to his
grammar, please excuse any typos you may find. Also, this article is free: written and distributed
only to assist in research while providing a forum for second-level thinking.
35 Likes 27 Comments
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=… 18/19
14/04/22, 07:40 Think Like A Banker - Three Commercial mREIT Buys _ Seeking Alpha
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4501069-think-like-a-banker?mailingid=27349943&messageid=2850&serial=27349943.4815&utm_campaign=… 19/19