Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Govardhan Project
Govardhan Project
Govardhan Project
PROJECT REPORT
ON
SUCCESSION PLANNING FOR SENIOR STAFF POSITIONS
1. INTRODUCTION
1-6
Introduction
Need for the study
Scope of the study
Limitations of the study
Research Methodology
Interpretation
6. Bibliography 47-48
7. Annexure 49-53
2
INTRODUCTION
3
Introduction
Essentially, succession planning is a conscious decision by an organization to foster and
promote the continual development of employees, and ensure that key positions maintain
some measure of stability, thus enabling an organization to achieve business objectives.
Traditionally, succession planning has sometimes taken a replacement approach, often
focusing on executive-level positions. One or two successors might be identified and
selected, probably based on the exclusive input of their immediate supervisor, and then
placed on the fast-track into a senior position. However, succession planning has evolved
into a process that can be used to:
2. Identify, assess and develop employee knowledge, skills and abilities to meet the
Knowing what jobs at various levels, if removed, would cause a significant loss to the
organization, and which of these jobs represent the greatest retention risk.
Knowing which employees are both interested in, and demonstrate short- and/or
long-term potential for, succession into key positions.
Significant investment to ensure that employees have appropriate and structured
learning, development and training opportunities to fulfill their potential.
Aligning succession planning with current and anticipated business goals and
objectives.
Succession management is principally about knowing the needs of the organization and its
employees and developing the capacity to address emerging issues that can or will affect
business continuity.
4
NEED AND SCOPE OF STUDY
Human resources are dynamic; no person is going to stay in a job forever. There are
retirements, resignations, deaths, or such other contingencies that render a position vacant.
Finding the right person to fill it is of utmost importance to make sure that things continue
on a smooth keel. Succession planning is even more important in senior management
positions because of the experience, wisdom, and abilities that come with them.
5
Additionally, while succession management practices are believed to contribute toemployee
retention. Management who indicated the need to find out what was causing the exits. One of
the assumptions then was that the perceived low remuneration was the main factor
occasioning this exits and responded by reviewing the terms of service for all Management
employees However, the scenario did not change prompting the management to see the need
for investigation into the factors that affect employee retention in the organization. Among
these was the need to come up with policy guidelines on succession management in the
company. It is therefore important to establish whether this connection exists and further
investigate its nature in order to inform human resource management strategies for effective
achievement of o
organizations objectives.
This research study aims to investigate the existence and extent to which succession
management practices have been implemented in public sector organizations.
Objectives
Identify succession management practices in public sector organization
Determine the extent of succession management practices in public
sectororganizations
Analyse the implications of such practices on employee retention in publicsector
organizations.
6
COMPANY PROFILE
7
8
9
10
THEORITICAL FRAMEWORK
11
Succession Planning
Succession planning is the process of replacing your organisation’s leaders and managers
with high-potential, internal (sometimes external) replacements. Essentially, it is about
identifying, developing and replacing employees to make a potential shift in
responsibilities/hierarchy as smooth as possible.
12
Data points to consider in your workforce snapshot include:
Employee onboard count & Provides visual representation of the employees onboard,
retirement eligibility their distribution across the organization and how much of
the workforce is retirement eligible.
Separations and Accession Shows hiring and separation trends for forecasting future
(hiring) counts over years staffing needs across different scenarios
Time stayed past retirement Provides insight into how long employees typically stay past
their retirement eligibility date.
Separation and accession Identifies areas of high turnover to prioritize for succession
trends by series planning activities
Time to hire Helps determine which positions take longest to fill and are
therefore more vulnerable when turnover occurs.
13
As part of the broader workforce planning process, there are several considerations that
should preface any succession planning initiative. Some preliminary questions to consider
include the following:
14
If we think of succession planning not only as replacing but of adequately preparing
employees to take on new roles, HR has a role to play here in terms of career development,
learning and overall L&D strategies.
15
Keep in mind, though, that succession planning is not only relevant for large or medium-
sized companies. Even small, family-run businesses should have a plan in place when it
comes to successful succession.
16
Role of advisor in Financial Planing
Theoretical Framework
A theoretical framework has been developed to assist in the analysis of the findings on
succession management practices and their possible implications on employee retention in
public sector organizations in Kenya. The independent variables, 20 dependent variable and
the anticipated outcomes is provided in the framework.
Succession Management
Supervisor Career
Support
opportunities
Working Environment
Employee Retention
Rewards
Work-life Policies
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
18
Development Assignments
This involves the development of a number of employee development programs that ensure
that high performing early talents within the organization are equipped and prepared to take
up higher positions in an organization. This include such programs as flexible job
descriptions as advanced by the study by Pennel (2010), and job rotation that enables
employees to perform tasks across functional areas. Development assignments also enable
employees gain real life exposure to the organization’s overall operations and culture.
Use of information systems such as the Human Resource Management Information Systems
(HRMIS) enables the organizations manage its management systems appropriately.
Computerized systems also assist in planning and maintaining progress of employee’s
development.
19
Outcomes:
Management assignments Employee satisfaction
Senior management support Improved productivity
Mentoring and coaching Employees Retention Business efficiency
Computerized systems to plan Customer service and
progress satisfaction
Low employee turnover
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
The first step in succession planning is identifying key positions. After all, succession
planning is based on departure, so you need to consider which roles are at risk.
Key positions come in all shapes and sizes. It helps to have a strong handle on where the
highest amounts of ‘institutional knowledge’ exist within your organisation. Once you know
that, you can prepare for departures accordingly
20
Imagine a wheel with five spokes, or a calendar item that alerts you every fifth month, or
assigning each of these steps to different people. These are the five steps in an ongoing
succession planning process:
Identify key roles (such as managers and above) that may require replacement in the next 3
years. List each role and each person.
List the job competencies and personalities for each role that are a) required, and b)
recommended. Keep it simple. Lean on your human resources colleagues. Solicit updates
from those in the role. We know that the best workers’ compensation people, for example,
have a high attention to detail. If uncertain, or if you desire confidential expertise, hire an
external vendor.
Assess your current staff members based on their a) status now (e.g., ready now, development
needs defined, development needs to be defined), and b) potential (e.g., skills, ability,
longevity, health). Then list concerns for each person such as job performance, health risks,
medical needs, family concerns, job potential or ability to travel. Create a database or flow
chart.
Identify a pool of potential talent. Great people are everywhere. Talent scarcity is a myth
perpetuated by managers who choose not to invest in their people. Your primary talent pool is
internal; your secondary talent pool is external. Hire internally. Internal promotions lead to
higher levels of retention and engagement at lower cost. External hires typically cost more
and drive conflict (which can be a necessary motivator at any company).
Actively develop key people using progressions of experiences so that they can be ready now
for advancement. Succession planning is not a checklist or software package. It is a series of
meaningful experiences. For example, action-learning teams of cross-functional managers
may be selected to develop a breakthrough product. High potential managers may be tasked
with a business development opportunity or leadership training experience. Senior leaders
can be partnered with three or four “HI-POs” (individuals with high potential) for quarterly
mentoring sessions. Note that none of these experiences is expensive. For expertise contact
any external vendor with experience in succession planning and leadership development
experiences. Avoid wasting money on events.
21
The Succession Planning Process
These are the seven key steps in the succession planning process:
Identify needs
22
The Succession Planning Process in 7 Steps
Here are seven well-coordinated steps to ensure key positions are filled successfully…
This is going to require some internal reflection. Begin the succession planning process
by identifying qualifications that are essential to your company’s success. This could include
years of experience, qualifications or licenses, or other ‘soft skills’ that have an impact on
company success (like customer relations abilities, for example).
Then, you need to write them down. So, take these qualifications essential to your company’s
success and document them in what we might call ‘initial job profiles.’ Now you have an idea
of what you need, relatively speaking, but we need to dig a bit deeper to get to the core of the
issue.
2) Identify Needs
If we start by knowing the key qualifications that influence success, now we need to plan for
where we might lose those skills. So, you need to establish which key positions might
become vacant in the near future. Ask yourself:
Which employees are about to retire?
Are any employees currently pregnant?
What is your overall attrition rate?
You can also take a top-down approach in this step, and plan for your entire company’s
succession plan starting from your CEO to executive leadership and further down the
organisational chart. That said, if you are in a pinch and want to get started immediately, you
should start filling gaps that may reveal themselves sooner than later.
In this step, it is also important to include the financial resources you may need for the
recruiting process. It is important to note how the recruiting process transfers into time (and
23
money) spent. It’s also at this point that proper recruitment software can help maintain
efficiency without draining resources.
24
If you are taking a proactive approach, maybe you have all the time in the world for
succession planning. But, if you’re low on time, you may want to set deadlines for finding a
suitable candidate or completing the handover period.
5) Appoint A ‘Successor’
Whether internally or externally, this is the part of succession planning that signals the end.
While a lot of the heavy lifting may have been done during the job profile stage, now you
have someone in mind that could be able to take on this role.
Apart from interviews, though, finding the right candidate during the succession planning
process should rely on more nuanced measures. You should work with assessment centres,
case studies or work trials, to determine the best fit.
That said, a technical fit is not always a cultural fit. For succession planning to be successful,
it often comes down to how someone fits within a company’s distinct culture.
How do you begin to evaluate this? First, you likely need to have a hold on your own culture
and what it means to work with your company, but you may want to consider the following to
evaluate a candidate’s fit:
When done right, succession planning also loops in the person leaving the role. This is most
felt during the handover process, where a new employee gradually learns their new tasks,
both from their future co-workers and team leads, as well as from their predecessor (who will
share existing knowledge or institution knowledge they only have.
25
Keep in mind, though, that the handover period shouldn’t be too short. Especially if a key
position is being filled, it is important to bake in more time (think in terms of months and not
weeks) for an employee to manage complex tasks that used to go smoothly. They will get
there, but they require patience.
However, if a handover period is too long, there is a risk that the successor won’t be able to
come into the role in their own right. They will be too influenced by how the role used to
perform, and you may lose out on the future-oriented skills that you feel this role needs to
thrive.
The best answer is somewhere in the middle. While team leads should have a long-term
perspective, there should be an active, fast-paced, and collaborative approach to handing over
knowledge. Ideally, this would also be done through confluence pages or a company wiki,
where institutional knowledge is public and not private.
Now that the handover of the job has been completed, what comes
next? Documenting the transition is a crucial step, in order to note how the position was
filled and to inform future processes. Keep in mind the following:
26
depicts internal successors for successors for each critical
each critical position in the position, describes how ready
organization. they are to replace the key job
incumbent, and predicts how
long it will likely take to
prepare each successor for
advancement.
Critical-position Similar to a job description, a Lists key responsibilities,
profile critical-position profile is a list duties, and activities for each
typically written on a single critical position in the
page. organization.
High-potential Similar to a resume, a high- Lists an individual’s education,
profile potential profile is usually work experience, performance
written on a single page and lists rating, career goals (when
important biographical possible), and other important
information about the key job work-related information that
incumbent and any individuals has a bearing on advancement
identified on replacement charts potential and/or present
as a possible successor performance.
Employee Rates the individual’s Assesses an individual’s
performance performance on their present present work performance.
appraisal job. (Advancement usually
depends on an employee’s
performing at least competently
on their present job.)
Individual potential Rates the individual’s potential Assesses an individual’s
assessment for advancement, either to one potential for advancement or
critically important position or for exercising increased
to higher levels of responsibility technical proficiency in their
or technical proficiency. current position.
Individual A plan to narrow the Although individuals are
development plans developmental gap between sometimes promoted on the
(IDPs) what the individual currently strength of their performance
27
knows or does on their current on a previous job, an IDP
job and what they need to know assumes that higher-level
or do to advance to a future, positions demand special
critically important position or preparation.An IDP, though
to a higher level of usually updated annually, is
responsibility. typically long-term (covering
several years) and may include
various training and work
assignment requirements to
help an individual quality for a
succession, achieve a higher
level of responsibility, or
exercise increased technical
proficiency.
For succession planning to be successful, you need to think about whether your company
currently has the talent to replace a key position. This means that, even if it is cheaper to fill a
position internally, it does not guarantee that a current employee is up to the task.
28
In fact, an employee may not be qualified for the role, but they also may not be interested.
Here is what you should consider for either internal or external fillings:
Advantages Disadvantages
None or a short recruiting process, as the Newcomers bring in fresh ideas, drive innovation,
employee's skills and qualifications are already and help counteract blindness to the company's
known. failings.
The employee can be provided with specific External candidates provide access to new
training to develop key skills before they take on networks.
the new role.
Short induction phase: The employee is already Newcomers are objective and disinterested in
familiar with the company and its processes. previous conflicts within the company.
Investing in staff development fosters employee External candidates may enjoy greater
loyalty. acceptance, above all in leadership positions.
Developing internal staff has a positive effect on New employees contribute additional skills and
the motivation and loyalty of other team members. knowledge.
Start the succession planning process early. Ideally, you would do so five years ahead of
time. This would then entail developing steps and processes to find the ideal succession
candidate to manage the transition effectively.
After all, this is about far more than simply finding the right fit. You need to find the right
candidate, develop them, and prepare them for the role, and this can take a great deal of
time and effort
In these cases, HR consultants will usually provide an experienced manager for a temporary
deployment at short notice until a permanent successor has been found.
CHAPTER 4
30
seven steps to follow when you are succession planning
First, consider all the key roles on your team and answer these two questions:
31
2. Pinpoint succession candidates
Once you have a handle on the ripple effect that the departure of certain employees might
cause, choose team members who could potentially step into those positions.
Ask yourself:
While the obvious successor to a role may be the person who is immediately
next in line in the organizational chart, don’t discount other promising
employees. Look for people who display the skills necessary to thrive in higher
positions, regardless of their current title.
But don’t just assume you know how people on your team view their career
goals. You may have certain team members in mind for senior management
roles, but who’s to say they’ll even be interested in the idea once it’s
presented to them? If you haven’t already, talk to these employees about how
they view their professional future before making your succession choices.
32
4. Step up professional development
efforts
Ideally, you have already been investing in the professional development of those you select
as your succession choices. Now that preparation needs to be ramped up. Job rotation is a
good way to help your candidates gain additional knowledge and experience. And
connecting them with mentors can boost their abilities in the critical area of soft skills: The
best leaders have strong communication skills, as well as polished interpersonal abilities,
such as empathy and diplomacy.
33
which employee could step into your shoes one day? And what can you do, starting now, to
help that person prepare for the transition?
The members of your workforce aren’t fixed assets — and changes in your team’s lineup are
inevitable. You may not always be able to predict a valued employee’s departure from the
firm. But through effective succession planning, you can pave the way for the continuity so
critical to your business’s future.
34
35
36
37
CHAPTER 5
FINDINGS, SUGGESTIONS AND CONCLUSION
38
Finding :
The firm also must develop one or more effective future leaders. This involves
identifying individuals with leadership skills or potential and determining how to
train or develop those skills so that they can become successful firm leaders. That
can be significantly more burdensome when mid-level lawyers leave the firm.
Opinions vary on the characteristics that distinguish a leader, but some of the
qualities that are often cited include a focus on high potential, not just
performance; a high level of engagement; accountability; multitasking abilities;
communication skills; evidence of empathy and emotional intelligence;
decisiveness; and the ability to admit failure and accept responsibility. The firm’s
culture will dictate which qualities are most important for its future firm leaders,
but a vision for the future and the ability to effect change are characteristics that
are particularly important in today’s challenging legal environment.
Leadership is distinct from management, and leadership skills are more difficult to
acquire, so it is important that firms identify and begin developing the leadership
skills of individuals with leadership potential as early as possible. Some lawyers
have natural leadership skills, but training and experience can develop even those
39
individuals into better and more effective leaders. If the development process is
started early, as it should be, a young lawyer can be mentored and coached by
the then-current firm leaders. There is no substitute for actual experience, so
giving young lawyers increasingly more significant leadership tasks will allow them
to hone their skills and allow the firm to assess their progress. In fact, some
recommend that firms “look[] for opportunities to involve all lawyers in some
aspect of management, in order to evaluate whether they have the skills to be
future leaders of the firm.” (Greene, supra, at 32.) When firms are on a restrictive
time schedule, leadership seminars and leadership coaching may be the
best option
SUGGESTIONS :
Sensible open conversations are key
This social and cultural shift can be really beneficial to both the individuals and their
organisations, who stand to benefit from their talents and expertise for longer. But
because retirement is no longer a clear-cut, black-and-white issue, the flip side is
that many organisations aren’t properly planning for retirement and succession.
Companies are either, brushing it under the carpet until it’s too late or making
assumptions that can cause stress, frustration or worse for both parties.
40
thinking about it as early as possible. Typically, 10 years ahead of an expected retirement
point within your sector or the job role.
2. Be honest
Sometimes the hardest thing is starting the conversation about what people really want to
do. Are they looking to leave as soon as possible, whether it’s to sail around the world or
spend more time with their family? Or would they like to carry on working as long as
possible? If it’s the latter, what are the possibilities and options? What would they be willing
to do? And what’s manageable from the business perspective?
Whatever you do, don’t make assumptions. The lack of a clear plan can lead to unease on
both sides, with senior workers feeling a sense that there’s no future for them, or younger
workers waiting for them to move on so they can get stuck in. Those in more physical roles
may be looking forward to retiring at 65 – but equally, if they’ve worked somewhere for a
long time, it can feel like a family they don’t want to be cut off from, so keeping a limited
involvement might be more attractive. It’s not about bullying people to stay on if they don’t
want to – but neither is it about kicking them out before they’re ready. Sensible, open
conversations are key.
41
their leader, and haven’t had enough opportunity to be challenged in the leadership role
before actually stepping up to the position permanently. So invest in their learning,
development and leadership training before that leader retires, and give them the
opportunity to make key decisions, coached by their leader if necessary.
One school I worked with encountered serious problems when the deputy head took over
after the headteacher retired – so much so that the former head actually came back from
retirement and took back responsibility to initiate a tough recovery programme. This must
only ever be a last resort, and in many cases would not be possible anyway – but it
underlines the importance of investing time and money upfront to ensure a smooth
succession and avoid unnecessary stress all round.
Senior workers need the humility to accept that younger, less experienced colleagues may
be able to see a faster, better way of doing something. It’s not just about technology – from
ideas generation to new approaches for customer service, older workers should embrace
the fact that you’re never too old to learn. Be prepared to experiment; try new approaches
and then evaluate how they worked, so both sides can learn from the experience. It’ll
promote positive communication and collaboration.
CONCLUSION
This blog series has been excerpted from an article that originally appeared
in the November issue of the Defense Research Institute’s (DRI) “For The
Defense” magazine, which can be found here.
43
CHAPTER 6
BIBILOGRAPHY
Bibilography
Please provide an APA formatted bibliography for at least five of the sources in my list
below:
Adler, N.J., & Bartholomew, S. (1992). Academic and professional communities of discourse:
Generating knowledge on transnational human resource management. Journal of
International Business Studies, 23: 551-569.
Bonczek, M.E., Woodward, E.K. (2006). Who'll replace you when you're gone? Nursing
Management, 31-34 August 2006,.
44
Dinnen, S. (2014). Succession planning. Northwestern Financial Review, 199(2), 20-23.
Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/1498448684?accountid=14872
Harrison, M., McKinnon, T. & Terry, P.(2006). Effective succession planning-How to design
and implement a succession plan. Training and Development, October 2006, 22-23.
Charan, R., Drotter, S., & Noel, J. (2001). The Leadership Pipeline: How to Build the
Leadership Powered Company. San Francisco, GA: Jossey-Bass (owned by John Wiley &
Sons, Inc.)
Website:
1. URL-https//hr.scribe.com.www.scribd.com
2. URL – https//www.wikipedia .org-
www.wikipedia.com
45
CHAPTER -7
ANNEXURE
4).
47