Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Christina Lopez Estate's Lawsuit Against Metra
Christina Lopez Estate's Lawsuit Against Metra
ZOOM. Jury
Civil
For more Actionand
information Cover
ZoomSheet - Case
Meeting IDs goInitiation (12/01/20) CCL 0520
to https://www.cookcountycourt.org/HOME/Zoom-Links/Agg4906_SelectTab/12
Remote Court date: 8/24/2022 9:30 AM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY, ILLINOIS FILED
COUNTY DEPARTMENT, LAW DIVISION 6/21/2022 12:38 PM
IRIS Y. MARTINEZ
Josephine Klonowski, as Special Administrator of Estate of Christina Lopez, Dec. CIRCUIT CLERK
___________________________________________________________
COOK COUNTY, IL
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
2022L005561
Calendar, R
v. 18364746
2022L005561
Northeast Illinois Regional Commuter Railroad Corp d/b/a METRA et al.
___________________________________________________________ No. ______________________________
Pro Se Only: I have read and agree to the terms of the Clerk’s O ice Electronic Notice Policy and choose to opt in to electronic notice
form the Clerk’s Office for this case at this email address: ______________________________________________________________
JOSEPHINE KLONOWSKI, as )
Special Administrator of the Estate of )
CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, )
)
Plaintiff, ) 2022L005561
) No.
v. )
) JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NORTHEAST ILLINOIS REGIONAL )
COMMUTER RAILROAD CORPORATION )
d/b/a METRA, BNSF RAILWAY COMPANY, )
DEL’S MOVING, INC. d/b/a DEL’S MOVING )
& STORAGE, and SABRIJA CUBIC, )
)
Defendants. )
COMPLAINT AT LAW
Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, by and through her attorneys, Kralovec, Jambois &
DEL’S MOVING, INC. d/b/a DEL’S MOVING & STORAGE, and SABRIJA CUBIC, Plaintiff
states as follows:
1. On May 11, 2022, Defendant DEL’S MOVING, INC. d/b/a DEL’S MOVING &
STORAGE (hereinafter “DEL’S MOVING”) was a corporation duly registered and licensed to do
2. On May 11, 2022, Defendant DEL’S MOVING was a motor carrier which
provided moving, storage, and 3rd party logistics services to residential and commercial customers
throughout the City of Chicago, throughout Cook County, and in some Chicagoland suburbs.
1
3. On and prior to May 11, 2022, Defendant DEL’S MOVING conducted extensive
business throughout Cook County and maintained at least four (4) offices in Cook County,
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
including its principal place of business located at 5430 Dansher Road in Countryside, in addition
to its offices at 4918 N. Monitor Avenue in Chicago, 9500 W. Ogden Avenue in Brookfield, and
4. On May 11, 2022, Defendant SABRIJA CUBIC was a resident of Cook County,
Illinois.
5. On May 11, 2022, Defendant CUBIC was an employee, servant, and/or agent,
whether actual or apparent, of DEL’S MOVING, driving at all times under DEL’S MOVING’s
6. On May 11, 2022, and at all times referenced herein, Defendant Northeast Illinois
corporation duly registered and licensed to do business under the laws of the State of Illinois with
its principal place of business located at 547 W. Jackson Boulevard, Chicago, Illinois 60661.
7. On May 11, 2022, and at all times referenced herein, Defendant METRA was a
common carrier in the business of transporting passengers by rail between Chicago and various
municipalities throughout northeastern Illinois, including a line designated as the METRA BNSF
8. On May 11, 2022, and at all times referenced herein, Defendant BNSF RAILWAY
CO. was a Delaware corporation with its principal place of business in Fort Worth, Texas which
was a common carrier that owned and operated trains, railways, rights of way, and grade crossings
2
9. On May 11, 2022, and at all times referenced herein, Defendant BNSF RAILWAY
CO. maintained various facilities and railyards within Cook County, including but not limited to,
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
5601 W. 26th Street, Cicero, IL 60804; 5275 W. 26th Street, Cicero, IL 60804; and 5010 Ogden
10. On May 11, 2022, and at all times referenced herein, BNSF RAILWAY CO.
owned, operated, managed, controlled, and maintained a certain railway consisting of three (3)
parallel sets of railroad tracks which ran in a generally east and west direction between Chicago,
Illinois and Aurora, Illinois, over which METRA’s BNSF Line trains travelled.
11. On May 11, 2022, and at all times referenced herein, Prospect Avenue was a public
roadway in Clarendon Hills, Illinois which ran in a generally north and south direction which
intersected and crossed the aforesaid railway owned by Defendant BNSF RAILWAY CO.
12. On May 11, 2022, and at all times referenced herein, BNSF RAILWAY CO.
owned, operated, managed, controlled, and maintained a railway crossing, bearing DOT Crossing
No. 079529S, at Prospect Avenue in Clarendon Hills, Illinois (the “Prospect Avenue Crossing”).
13. On May 11, 2022, BNSF RAILWAY CO. operated and controlled a certain
commuter rail train, METRA Train #1242, travelling on the METRA BNSF Line.
14. On May 11, 2022, METRA Train #1242 was an inbound train along the METRA
BNSF Line, operating in push-pull configuration and consisting of two (2) cab cars at the front of
the train, followed by four (4) passenger cars, followed by a locomotive at the rear of the train.
15. On May 11, 2022, METRA owned, managed, and maintained METRA Train
16. On May 11, 2022, upon information and belief, METRA and BNSF were party to
a Purchase of Service Agreement (“PSA”) for the METRA BNSF Line. Upon information and
3
belief, METRA owned, managed, and maintained the rolling stock – namely the locomotives and
train cars – while BNSF owned the railways, the rights-of-way, and operated the trains with BNSF
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
employees. Upon information and belief, METRA was responsible for all commuter passenger
ticket sales at Chicago Union Station, including for the METRA BNSF Line.
17. On May 11, 2022, the Decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, was a fare-paying
18 On May 11, 2022, METRA Train #1242 was scheduled to depart Aurora, Illinois
at 7:29 a.m., make all local stops along METRA’s BNSF Line, and arrive to Chicago Union Station
at 08:52 a.m.
19. On May 11, 2022, METRA Train #1242 was the subject of a last-minute schedule
change which required Train #1242 to originate at Downers Grove Main Street Station rather than
the Aurora METRA Station, and required train #1242 to travel express from Downers Grove
20. On May 11, 2022, METRA Train #1242 became an express train from Downers
Grove Fairview Avenue, which required it bypass stations in Westmont, Clarendon Hills, West
Hinsdale, Hinsdale, Highlands, Western Springs, and LaGrange Stone Avenue, without stopping.
21. On May 11, 2022, Defendant CUBIC was driving a 2004 International commercial
box truck owned by DEL’S MOVING, in a northerly direction on Prospect Avenue in Clarendon
22. On May 11, 2022, the DEL’S MOVING truck was on the southernmost tracks of
the Prospect Avenue crossing while the warning lights and gates were activated.
23. On May 11, 2022, as METRA Train #1242 approached the Prospect Avenue
crossing, Defendant CUBIC exited the DEL’S MOVING truck while it remained on the tracks.
4
24. On May 11, 2022, the Decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, was seated on METRA
25. On May 11, 2022, METRA Train #1242 struck the front left aspect of the DEL’S
MOVING truck.
26. The force of the collision was such that the DEL’S MOVING truck was rapidly
rotated clockwise, resulting in the rear of the truck striking the rear aspect of the lead cab car where
27. As a result of the collision, the Decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, was ejected
28. On May 11, 2022, CHRISTINA LOPEZ was pronounced deceased at the scene of
the collision.
29. On May 11, 2022, the Plaintiff’s Decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, was in the
the Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, has been entered by the Circuit Court of Cook
County in accordance with 740 ILCS 180/2.1. A copy of the aforesaid Order is attached hereto as
Exhibit A. Plaintiff brings this action pursuant to the provisions of 740 ILCS 180/1, et. seq.
5
COUNT I – NORTHEAST ILLINOIS REGIONAL COMMUTER RAILROAD
CORPORATION d/b/a METRA
(Wrongful Death)
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, by and through her attorneys, Kralovec, Jambois &
states as follows:
31. On and prior to May 11, 2022, the Prospect Avenue crossing was under
construction.
32. On April 26, 2022, the Village of Clarendon Hills issued a public notice of lane
closures at the Prospect Avenue crossing which specifically warned that traffic delays at the
crossing will occur and urged residents to avoid the crossing to help ease traffic backups.
33. On and prior to May 11, 2022, METRA knew or should have known of ongoing
construction, lane closures, traffic delays, and traffic backups at the Prospect Avenue crossing.
34. On and prior to May 11, 2022, METRA knew or should have known that other
vehicles had been stuck or impeded on the tracks at the Prospect Avenue crossing.
35. On and prior to May 11, 2022, METRA knew or should have known of uneven
36. On and prior to May 11, 2022, METRA knew or should have known that near-miss
6
37. On and prior to May 11, 2022, given the unsafe condition of the Prospect Avenue
crossing, including but not limited to the ongoing construction, traffic delays and backups, lane
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
narrowing, other vehicles stuck or impeded on the tracks, uneven pavement and grade condition,
and near misses and/or near hits, METRA knew or should have known that the Prospect Avenue
crossing constituted a particular hazard to the public and to passing trains, including Train #1242
38. On and prior to May 11, 2022, METRA should have instructed, educated, trained,
communicated, and/or informed the operators of its trains to approach the Prospect Avenue
39. On and prior to May 11, 2022, METRA should have instructed, educated, trained,
communicated, and/or informed the operators of its trains to be on the lookout for stuck or impeded
40. On and prior to May 11, 2022, METRA should have instructed, educated, trained,
communicated, and/or informed the operators of its trains to immediately slow trains approaching
the Prospect Avenue crossing when vehicles were visible on the tracks.
41. On May 11, 2022, upon information and belief, METRA did not communicate to
the operators of its trains, including Train #1242, any of the conditions that existed at the Prospect
Avenue crossing.
42. On May 11, 2022, upon information and belief, METRA did not communicate the
true condition of the Prospect Avenue crossing to the operators of its trains, including Train #1242.
43. On and prior to May 11, 2022, Defendant METRA, by and through its employees,
servants, or agents, whether actual or apparent, had a duty to operate, inspect, manage, maintain,
7
and repair the railcars and locomotives that comprised METRA Train #1242 in a reasonable and
safe manner so as not to cause injury to its passengers, including CHRISTINA LOPEZ.
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
44. On and prior to May 11, 2022, Defendant METRA by and through its employees,
servants, or agents, whether actual or apparent, had a duty to comply with Federal regulations and
safety standards, as well as its own internal policies, procedures, rules, plans, and/or standards.
45. On and prior to May 11, 2022, Defendant METRA by and through its employees,
servants, or agents, whether actual or apparent, was a common carrier and owed its passenger,
46. Defendant, METRA, by and through its employees, servants, and/or agents,
whether actual or apparent, was negligent in one or more of the following ways:
g. Failed to monitor near misses or near hits at the Prospect Avenue crossing;
8
i. Failed to timely and/or properly inspect the Prospect Avenue crossing prior
to May 11, 2022;
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
k. Failed to properly maintain the rail cars and locomotives in a safe condition
for the operation of passenger trains;
l. Failed to properly train its agents and/or employees in the safe operation,
inspection, maintenance, and/or repair of the railcars and engines;
p. Failed to timely apply the emergency brakes after it was apparent that the
vehicle would not heed the warning signals;
s. Failed to comply with its own internal policies, procedures, rules, plans,
and/or standards;
47. As a direct and proximate result of one or more of the foregoing acts or omissions
of the Defendant METRA, the decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, suffered serious injuries which
48. At the time of her death, the Decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, was survived by her
three adult daughters: America Moyeno, Olivia Christopher, and Josephine Klonowski, each of
9
whom has suffered significant losses of a personal and pecuniary nature, grief, sorrow, emotional
anguish, and the loss of affection, companionship, and society of the Decedent, as a result of her
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
death.
Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, prays for judgment against the Defendant, METRA, in
such an amount in excess of this Court’s jurisdictional requisite to fully and fairly compensate the
Estate for all losses compensable under the terms of the Wrongful Death Act.
Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, by and through her attorneys, Kralovec, Jambois &
Schwartz, and complaining of the defendant, BNSF RAILWAY COMPANY, Plaintiff states as
follows:
paragraphs 1-30 of this Count II, as though fully set forth herein.
31. Upon information and belief, on May 11, 2022, METRA Train #1242 was operated
32. Defendant BNSF, owned, operated, maintained, supervised, and/or controlled the
railroad tracks over which METRA Train #1242 traveled on May 11, 2022.
33. On and prior to May 11, 2022, the Prospect Avenue crossing in Clarendon Hills,
34. On and prior to May 11, 2022, BNSF knew or should have known of ongoing
construction, lane closures, traffic delays, and traffic backups at the Prospect Avenue crossing.
10
35. On April 26, 2022, the Village of Clarendon Hills issued a public notice of lane
closures at the Prospect Avenue crossing which specifically warned that traffic delays at the
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
crossing will occur and urged residents to avoid the crossing to help ease traffic backups.
36. On and prior to May 11, 2022, BNSF knew or should have known that other
vehicles had been stuck or impeded on the tracks at the Prospect Avenue crossing.
37. On and prior to May 11, 2022, BNSF knew or should have known of uneven
38. On and prior to May 11, 2022, BNSF knew or should have known that near miss
and/or near hit events had occurred at the Prospect Avenue crossing.
39. On and prior to May 11, 2022, given the unsafe condition of the Prospect Avenue
crossing, including but not limited to the ongoing construction, traffic delays and backups, lane
narrowing, other vehicles stuck or impeded on the tracks, uneven pavement and grade condition,
and near misses and/or near hits, BNSF knew or should have known that the Prospect Avenue
crossing constituted a particular hazard to the public and to passing trains, including Train #1242
40. On and prior to May 11, 2022, BNSF should have instructed, educated, trained,
communicated, and/or informed its employees to approach the Prospect Avenue crossing with
caution.
41. On and prior to May 11, 2022, BNSF should have instructed, educated, trained,
communicated, and/or informed its employees to be on the lookout for stuck or impeded vehicles
11
42. On and prior to May 11, 2022, BNSF should have instructed, educated, trained,
communicated, and/or informed its employees to immediately slow trains approaching the
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
43. On May 11, 2022, upon information and belief, BNSF did not communicate to its
engineers any of the hazardous conditions that existed at the Prospect Avenue crossing.
44. On May 11, 2022, upon information and belief, BNSF did not communicate the
45. On and prior to May 11, 2022, Defendant BNSF, by and through its employees,
servants, and/or agents, whether actual or apparent, had a duty to conduct their railroad operations
in a reasonable and safe manner so as not to cause injury to its passengers, including CHRISTINA
LOPEZ.
46. On and prior to May 11, 2022, Defendant BNSF, by and through its employees,
servants, or agents, whether actual or apparent, had a duty to comply with Federal regulations and
safety standards, as well as its own internal policies, procedures, rules, plans, and/or standards.
47. On and prior to May 11, 2022, Defendant BNSF by and through its employees,
servants, or agents, whether actual or apparent, was a common carrier and owed its passenger,
48. Defendant, BNSF, by and through its employees, servants, and/or agents, whether
12
11, 2022, including but not limited to ongoing construction, traffic delays
and backups, lane narrowing, other vehicles stuck or impeded upon the
tracks, uneven pavement and grade condition, near misses and/or near hits;
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
g. Failed to monitor near misses or near hits at the Prospect Avenue crossing;
i. Failed to timely and/or properly inspect the Prospect Avenue crossing prior
to May 11, 2022;
k. Failed to properly maintain the railway crossing in a safe condition for the
passage of automobiles;
13
r. Failed to timely apply the emergency brakes after it was apparent that the
vehicle would not heed the warning signals;
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
t. Failed to comply with its own internal policies, procedures, rules, plans,
and/or standards;
49. As a direct and proximate result of one or more of the foregoing acts or omissions
of the Defendant BNSF, the decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, suffered serious injuries which
50. At the time of her death, the Decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, was survived by her
three adult daughters: America Moyeno, Olivia Christopher, and Josephine Klonowski, each of
whom has suffered significant losses of a personal and pecuniary nature, grief, sorrow, emotional
anguish, and the loss of affection, companionship, and society of the Decedent, as a result of her
death.
Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, prays for judgment against the Defendant, BNSF, in
such an amount in excess of this Court’s jurisdictional requisite to fully and fairly compensate the
Estate for all losses compensable under the terms of the Wrongful Death Act.
Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, by and through her attorneys, Kralovec, Jambois &
Schwartz, and complaining of the defendant, DEL’S MOVING, INC. d/b/a DEL’S MOVING &
14
1-30. Plaintiff hereby re-alleges paragraphs 1-30 of General Allegations, above, as
paragraphs 1-30 of this Count III, as though fully set forth herein.
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
31. On May 11, 2022, and at all times referenced herein, Defendant CUBIC was an
employee, servant, and/or agent, whether actual or apparent, of DEL’S MOVING and was acting
32. On May 11, 2022, it was the duty of the Defendant DEL’S MOVING, by and
through its employees, servants, and/or agents, whether actual or apparent, including SABRIJA
CUBIC, to exercise reasonable care in the operation of its vehicle so as not to cause injury or
33. On May 11, 2022, in disregarding said duties, the Defendant, DEL’S MOVING, by
and through its employees, servants, and/or agents, whether actual or apparent, including
SABRIJA CUBIC, was then and there guilty of one or more of the following negligent acts and/or
omissions:
a. Operated the DEL’S MOVING International box truck (“the subject truck”)
without keeping a proper and sufficient lookout;
d. Proceeded into the bounds of the subject crossing without sufficient space
for the subject truck to clear the tracks;
e. Failed to maintain proper control the subject truck in light of the vehicle’s
proximity to the subject crossing.
34. As a direct and proximate result of one or more of the foregoing acts or omissions
of the Defendant DEL’S MOVING, the decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, suffered serious injuries
15
35. At the time of her death, the Decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, was survived by her
three adult daughters: America Moyeno, Olivia Christopher, and Josephine Klonowski, each of
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
whom has suffered significant losses of a personal and pecuniary nature, grief, sorrow, emotional
anguish, and the loss of affection, companionship, and society of the Decedent, as a result of her
death.
Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, prays for judgment against the Defendant, DEL’S
MOVING, INC., in such an amount in excess of this Court’s jurisdictional requisite to fully and
fairly compensate the Estate for all losses compensable under the terms of the Wrongful Death
Act.
Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, by and through her attorneys, Kralovec, Jambois &
Schwartz, and complaining of the defendant, SABRIJA CUBIC (“CUBIC”), Plaintiff states as
follows:
paragraphs 1-30 of this Count IV, as though fully set forth herein.
31. On May 11, 2022, and at all times referenced herein, Defendant CUBIC was an
employee, servant, and/or agent, whether actual or apparent, of DEL’S MOVING and was acting
32. On May 11, 2022, it was the duty of the Defendant, CUBIC, to exercise reasonable
care in the operation of his vehicle so as not to cause injury or damage to the public, including
16
33. On May 11, 2022, in disregarding his duty, the Defendant, CUBIC, was then and
there guilty of one or more of the following negligent acts and/or omissions:
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
a. Operated the DEL’S MOVING International box truck (“the subject truck”)
without keeping a proper and sufficient lookout;
d. Proceeded into the bounds of the subject crossing without sufficient space
for the subject truck to clear the tracks;
e. Failed to maintain proper control the subject truck in light of the vehicle’s
proximity to the subject crossing.
34. As a direct and proximate result of one or more of the foregoing acts or omissions
of the Defendant CUBIC, the decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, suffered serious injuries which
35. At the time of her death, the Decedent, CHRISTINA LOPEZ, was survived by her
three adult daughters: America Moyeno, Olivia Christopher, and Josephine Klonowski, each of
whom has suffered significant losses of a personal and pecuniary nature, grief, sorrow, emotional
anguish, and the loss of affection, companionship, and society of the Decedent, as a result of her
death.
Estate of CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, prays for judgment against the Defendant, SABRIJA
CUBIC, in such an amount in excess of this Court’s jurisdictional requisite to fully and fairly
compensate the Estate for all losses compensable under the terms of the Wrongful Death Act.
17
Respectfully submitted,
18
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
Exhibit A
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY, ILLINOIS
COUNTY DEPARTMENT, LAW DIVISION
FILED DATE: 6/21/2022 12:38 PM 2022L005561
JOSEPHINE KLONOWSKI, as )
Special Administrator of the Estate of )
CHRISTINA LOPEZ, Deceased, )
)
Plaintiff, )
) No.
v. )
) JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NORTHEAST ILLINOIS REGIONAL )
COMMUTER RAILROAD CORPORATION )
d/b/a METRA, BNSF RAILWAY COMPANY, )
DEL’S MOVING, INC. d/b/a DEL’S MOVING )
& STORAGE, and SABRIJA S. CUBIC, )
)
Defendants. )
JURY DEMAND
Respectfully submitted,
2022L005561
Calendar, R
18364746
2022L005561