A Review On Ceramic and Polymer Materials For Radome Applications

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

A Review on Ceramic and Polymer Materials for

Radome Applications

Surendra Kumar Dr. Pallavi Gupta


Department of Electronics and Communication Department of Electronics and Communication
Engineering, Sharda University Engineering, Sharda University
Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh- 201310, India Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh- 201310, India
Email:Surendra_kumar@celindia.co.in. Email: Pallavi.gupta2@sharda.ac.in

Abstract—The radome acronyms words radar and dome for used to minimize structural damage to the radome [3].
communication systems. Radome is protective cover for Antenna Material properties desirable for advanced missile radome
systems while preserving the microwave properties of the designs include [4]. A low and stable dielectric constant and
communication system. It provides protective interface between tangent loss at radio frequencies, high melting temperature, A
the missile tracking system and the atmosphere. New missile low coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE), high tensile
performance capabilities to cater speed mach4 to mach5, will strength, high fracture toughness. Electrical properties that
render conventional radome design standards inadequate and makers radome transparent like, dielectric constant and loss
lead to the experiment of new materials. Thus, interest in radome tangent of radome materials can vary significantly with
development is being renewed, and radome designers are being
temperature. Thermal and mechanical properties of the
challenged to advance the state of the art materials for radome
applications. Materials play an important role for design and
materials like Thermal conductivity, temperature coefficient of
high performance of the radome. This article explains some of expansion, tensile strength, fracture toughness also very wrt to
the important aspect of the radomes materials like ceramic and expose of high temperate exposure. Fracture toughness
polymers for high speed, high frequency and high performance together with a low CTE not only prevents stress failures but
radome applications. The ceramic and polymer composite will also precludes the formation and propagation of cracks
also be discussed radome applications. resulting from rain and dust impact (erosion environment).
The required properties for radome materials is given below [1]
Keywords—ceramics, plymers, composite, mircowave,
• Service temperature : Up to 1400C
I. INTRODUCTION
• Dielectric constant : < 9:0 (5.0 is best)
The primary function of a radome is to protect an antenna • Temperature variation : < 7:0% of dielectric constant to
system from the environments encountered in ground- based, 1260 degc
shipboard, airborne, and aerospace applications. It is also • Loss tangent to 1260C : < 0:1
important that a radome be designed to have minimum impact
on the electrical performance of enclosed antennas. Radomes • Bending strength (4 point) : > 35 MPa
are generally composed of low-loss dielectrics shells, with II. CERAMICS FOR RADOME APPLICATIONS
thickness comparable to the wavelength of operation. They are
shaped to cover the antenna and provide the internal volume It is widely recognized that ceramics are one of the most
necessary for mechanical antenna scanning. If needed for the promising structural materials for radome applications due to
application, they provide aerodynamic streamlining. Radomes its superior thermal and mechanical properties, such as high
are used with virtually all aperture-type airborne antennas [1]. chemical and thermal stability, good chemical inertness, high
Radome design is based on the materials and construction thermal conductivity, high hardness, low density, and low
needed to provide adequate safety margins and acceptable coefficient of thermal expansion. Despite the fact that
weight. Mechanical stresses are produced in radomes by ceramic often present brittle behavior, ceramics have been
aerodynamic loading due to airflow, acceleration forces, and developed to achieve quasi-ductile fracture behavior and
sudden thermal expansion due to aerodynamic heating. In high- maintain all other advantages at high temperatures. There are
speed radomes, thermal shock often causes the highest various types of radomes, depending on the conditions in
mechanical stresses. These stresses are greatest in the because which they are used. Inorganic wall materials come into their
high aerodynamic loads produce large bending moments, own, particularly when organic materials fail due to the loss
which often occur near the end of missile flight and after of strength at higher temperatures. Most organic materials are
exposure to significant heating [2]. not suitable at 250C and even the best can only survive a
short term at 500C [3]. In general, density, dielectric,
Other factors to be considered are humidity, blowing dust or mechanical, thermal, and environmental properties are those
sand, rain, ice, snow, and moisture build-up on the outer wall. of interest. Based on the type of raw material used in radome
Rain erosion is a severe problem in missile-radome operation fabrication, a brief comparison of some of the most common
and can be a limitation for aircraft radomes. Lightning strikes candidate radome materials are given in Table1. Fabrication,
to aircraft are common, so metallic lightning-diverter strips are

978-1-7281-2577-0/19/$31.00
1 ©2019 IEEE

Authorized licensed use limited to: Indian Institute Of Technology Jammu. Downloaded on March 25,2022 at 20:00:35 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
a brief comparison of some of the most common candidate approximately 1000C and fused silica to 1300 C. Note that
radome materials are given in Table1. With the increase in for the slip-cast fused silica, there is essentially no change in
the speed of modern aircrafts, more superior properties of the dielectric constant up to 800 C, and that the change is only
radome materials are required. When radomes are used at 7.9 per cent at 1300 C [6].
high speeds i.e. Mach 3 to Mach 5 the required service The loss tangent, can be seen to be extremely low for all of
temperature upto1400C [6]. For higher speeds, ceramic the materials. Thus, silica is the most likely choice of
materials would be required, which normally include Al2O3, materials in applications where stable electrical properties at
slip-cast fused SiO2. It is generally agreed that a radome elevated temperatures are of prime concern. Now we will
material can undergo maximum change in dielectric constant discuss in detail the important ceramics for radome
of approximately 10 per cent and still be effective. Based on applications.
this value, alumina and Pyroceram 9606 can be used up to

Table1: Properties of the most common candidate radome materials [4]

A. Alumina B. Pyrocerm
The usage of alumina (Al2O3) in radomes has been Pyroceramic is a nonporous crystalline glass material with
extensively researched, and various forms of radomes made density of 2.42 gr/cm³. The mechanical strength and the
of this substance have been used in the missiles for speeds dielectric constant of pyroceramic do not change almost up to
above Mach 2 [7]. Based on the research findings of the 700, and its loss tangent at temperatures above 750C is 0.02.
Materials Research Center in the United States radomes made In comparison to Al2O3-based ceramics, Pyroceramic are
of Al2O3 with purity higher than 97% can withstand at more stable against temperature exposure. During flights at an
temperatures above 1760 C. Lucalox (a translucent altitude of 30 km and speed of Mach 5, the surface of
Aluminum Oxide invented by GE), which is 99.9% pure, is Pyroceramic reaches 700C.The first material that was
considered as one of the best substances based on the introduced as a pyroceramic was Pyroceram 9606
aluminum oxide. By adding a little magnesium oxide to (2MgO.2Al2O3.5SiO2, cordierite). This substance is a
Lucalox, the growth of grains in this substance is delayed and magnesium-aluminum silicate compound with high thermal
a high density material is achieved [8]. Al2O3-based shock resistance and resistance against corrosion and abrasion.
ceramics are waterproof and extremely resistant to dierent This material is more resistant against corrosion than fused
chemicals. The dielectric constant of pure aluminum oxide at silica; however dielectrically, it is not stable against
room temperature is 9.6, which drops considerably by raising temperature variations and cannot be used at speeds higher
the temperature to 800 degC. The loss tangent of this material than Mach5. Hallse et al. have shown that a material called
is between 5x10e-4 to 10x10e-4. However, Al2O3-based Pyroceram 9603 enjoys a better thermal performance, but its
materials undergo substantial contraction which depends on loss tangent is greater [2, 7].
the amounts of adhesive and applied pressure in the casting
phase.

Authorized licensed use limited to: Indian Institute Of Technology Jammu. Downloaded on March 25,2022 at 20:00:35 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
D. Boron Nitride
C. Fused Silica
Boron nitride is among the materials whose properties have
Fused silica radome manufacturers widely used fused silica or
been evaluated for high temperature microwave radome
quartz glass, which enjoys properties such as low thermal
usage [21]. Electrically both forms of material are suitable for
conductivity (0.8W/m.K), low thermal expansion coefficient
radome usage. The dense material has a dielectric constant of
(0.54-0.7*106/C), low density, suitable mechanical strength,
near 4.4 with a very low change of dielectric constant with
good resistance against thermal shock (no breakage after
temperature characteristic 0.3% per 100 C[4]. The less dense
more than 20 thermal shock cycles between 25C and 1000C),
material dielectric constant is near 3. Both materials have loss
and high electrical resistance [2,12,13]. Furthermore, the
tangents which are low. Mechanically the material is
fabrication of radomes using this material is done through slip
reasonably strong. At room temperature the flexural strength
casting, which is a simple process. The properties of some of
is near 100 MPa, but it falls off with temperature to near 30
the fused silica ceramics and composites that are reported by
MPa at 7500C [4]. It is its rather poor mechanical properties
different researchers are given in Table 2 [13].
comparative to Silicon Nitride for example which lessens this
Fused Density Dielectric Strength Forming material as a choice for radomes, for high temperatures.
Silica constant/ tand (MPa) method Thermally the expansion coefficient is high and its
Fused Silica 1.97 3.32/0.0012 54 CIPing conductivity is comparative to alumina. Various forms of
Fused Silica 1.97 3.32/0.0012 64 Slip Casting boron nitride have good thermal shock resistance. The
+2% Si3N4 1.96 - 37.13 Gel Casting material's rain resistance is poor due to its softness, and
+3% BN 1.85 - 45 Gel Casting would be another limiting factor in its choice for certain
+1% 2.1 3.18/ 40 Gel Casting environment operations.
Nano SiO2 0.00053
Table2: The properties of some of the fused silica E. Silicon Nitride
ceramics and composites [13] The need for having high-temperature materials for radomes
has attracted researchers’ attention to silicon nitride (Si3N4)
Compared to other materials, quartz ceramic is dielectrically
ceramics. This structurally important ceramic material has
more stable at higher temperature ranges and has a low loss
excellent mechanical and thermal properties for application in
tangent. The dielectric constant of this material remains high-temperature radomes [7, 16-18]. Si3N4 ceramic is one of
constant up to 800C and its loss tangent changes from 0.0002 the most promising inorganic radome materials combining
at 100C to 0.0014 at 800C. The thermal conductivity of wave permeability, good high temperature strength, heat
quartz glass increases from 1.8 W/(m.K) at the temperature insulation and corrosion resistance, good thermal shock
range of 20-100C to 2.7 W/(m.K) at the temperature range of resistance, and a hotspot in the radome research field for its
20-800C [2]. As a result of these properties, fused silica is excellent comprehensive performance [19, 20]. Addition of
also excellent structural and functional material in many certain oxides to the sintering of silicon nitride is a well-
different fields of application such as crucibles in metallurgy known method for producing dense ceramics for engineering
and polysilicon industry, thermal resistance materials in the The applications of Si3N4 depend on its molecular structure
aircraft industry, and high-temperature microwave- and properties such as space gap, permeation, thermal
transparent materials. Fused silica ceramics are commonly expansion, and hardness. These properties are themselves
made by fusion of pure silica sand with a silica content of influenced by the type, length and angle of molecular bonds,
approximately 99% [14, 15]. The properties of ceramics and the crystalline structure and system. The dielectric
based on fused silica are considerably lower than those of constants of -Si3N4 and -Si3N4, at room temperature, are 5.6
glass ceramics, and these properties are controlled by and 7.9, respectively, which are too high for the use of Si3N4
as a radome[12].
porosity.

III. POLYMERS FOR RADOME APPLICATIONS


Brief summary of the polymer based materials (including the these thermo set matrices can even withstand temperatures to
reinforcement fibers for composites) are provided in Table 2. the tune of 350°C–400°C, which is significantly higher than
Pure polymer based monolithic thermoplastic radomes were the capabilities offered by most common thermoplastics.
initially used for millimeter wave applications, which were Among the thermo set resins, epoxies are the real workhorses
subsequently replaced by advanced thermoplastics owing to for the aerospace industry. Further, the ε’ as well as tan δ
superior resistances to rain erosion, moisture absorption and values of these materials tend to increase further with increase
impact loads of the latter (refer Table 2 for details). However, in temperature. But, these problems are mitigated in some of
as reflected in the Table 2, it is the thermo set resins that are the special classes of polyester resins. But even then, either
most commonly used for all types of civilian and defense the epoxies or the polyesters can at best operate at a
radomes, mainly owing to their easier process ability, temperature of 150°C, which is often a major limitation for
improved mechanical properties and significantly lower many applications.
coefficients of thermal expansion (CTE). Further, some of

Authorized licensed use limited to: Indian Institute Of Technology Jammu. Downloaded on March 25,2022 at 20:00:35 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Materials/ Properties Nylon Teflon Polystyrene Rohacell Epoxy Polyimide Cyanate ester Aramid PEEK
Dielectric constant 3.1 2.1 2.6 1.04 2.8 3.2 3.3 3.8 3.2
Loss tangent 0.018 0.0003 0.012 0.0017 0.005 0.005 0.007 0.01 0.003
Thermal conductivity 0.24 0.25 0.030 0.030 0.221 0.12 0.18 0.04 0.43
(W/(m.K)
TCE (10e-6 cm/degC) 72 100 70 1.6 65 110 60 3.96 45
Tensile strength, MPa 47 25 34 1 600 72 80 3600 92
Flexural Strength, MPa 85 13.4 70 1.6 112 140 89 80 125
Table 2: Typical properties of the polymers for radome applications [7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 ]

IV. FUTURE ASPECTS OF CERAMICS AND POLYMER REFERENCES


COMPOSITES FOR RADOME APPLICATIONS [1] Microwave Processing of materials, National Academy Press 2101
Constitution Avenue, NW Box 285 Washington, D.C. 20055 800-624-
The effective thermal conductivity of a ceramics is strongly 6242 or 202-334-3313
affected by its composition, structure, intrinsic thermal [2] Medding, J.A.Non-destructive evaluation of zirconium phosphate
conductivities, and particle size, shape and interfacial thermal bonded silicon nitride radomes", M.Sc. Thesis, Virginia Polytechnic
Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia (1996)
resistance. The production cost of the ceramics is high. The
[3] M. Saeedi Heydaria; J. Ghezavatib, M. Abbasgholipourc and B.
brittleness and high processing temperature of ceramics lead Mohammad Alastic, Various types of ceramics used in radome: Scientia
to the difficulty in fabrication of complex shapes or machining Iranica B (2017) 24 (3), 1136
substrates during circuit fabrication. Most of the commonly [4] Cary, R., Avionic Radome Materials, DTIC Document, Royal Radar
used thermo set resins and their composites can withstand an Establishment Malvern (United Kingdom), pp. 13-(1974)
operational temperature of less than 150°C only. The ceramic [5] James b. Kouroupis, flight capabilities ofhig-speed-missileradome
radomes, on the other hand, have carved a niche for materials, lohns hopkills APL Technical Diges, Volume 13, 1992
themselves for conditions of temperatures in excess of 500°C, [6] F. Chen, Q. Shen, and L. Zhang. Electromagnetic optimal design and
but at the cost of higher weight and brittleness in the structure. preparation of broadband ceramic radome material with graded porous
This present scenario leaves a window of opportunity for the structure, Progress In Electromagnetic Research, Vol. 105, 445–461,
polymer composites to fill in the gap between 150°C–500°C, [7] Samudra Das Gupta, Polymer Matrix Composites for Electromagnetism
in Aircraft Structures” Journal of the Indian Institute of Science VOL
thereby offering lightweight high performance radomes for 95:3 Jul.–Sep. 2015
most supersonic airborne platforms. One of the most recently
[8] Microwave Processing of materials, National Academy Press 2101
explored resin systems to bridge this technology gap is the Constitution Avenue, NW Box 285 Washington, D.C. 20055 800-624-
cyanate ester resin systems.1–21 This new class of thermo set 6242 or 202 334-3313
resins cures by cyclotrimerization reaction between three [9] Michel SA Hollis, Parameterized design of Supersonic Radomes, ARL-
molecules of cyanate monomers to form polycyanurate TR-2418, 2001
containing triazine ring. A few properties, thermal and [10] http://www.rjchase.com/ptfe_handbook.pdf
dielectric of these resins vis-à-vis the other common resin [11] https://www.mep.co.jp/en/pdf/product/iupi_nova/p hysicality_04.pdf
systems as available from the literature are given in [12] M. Akinc, M. R. Kessler, Tailoring the toughness and CTE of high
determining the overall performance of the radomes built out temperature bisphenol!E cyanate ester (BECy), 26 December 2013
of their composites. Quartz is undoubtedly most suited for [13] http://www.dupont.com/content/dam/dupont/products-and-
high performance radomes owing to their very high silica services/fabrics-fibers-and
content, a feature that makes them extremely costly as well. onwovens/fibers/documents/Kevlar_Technical_Gui de.pdf
D-glass definitely stands out to be the second best choice, but [14] https://www.victrex.com/~/media/datasheets/victre x_tds_450g.pdf
they too have the problems of low strength and high cost. [15] http://www.mit.edu/~6.777/matprops/polyimide.ht m
Aramid (KevlarTM) fibers have low ε’ but high tan δ values. [16] L. S. Jayakumari , Synthesis and characterization of cyanate epoxy
composites Department of Rubber & High Performance Polymers, 19:
V. CONCLUSION 33–47, 2007 DOI: 10.1177/0954008306072147 21 August 2006)
[17] https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Mechanical- properties-of-Rohacell-
Ceramics, polymers and their Composite have been discussed foam-cores-1tbl1 229304758
in this review article for radome applications. A combination [18] Crone, G., Rudge, A. and Taylor, G. \Design and performance of
of polymers and ceramic fillers can effectively resolve the airborne radomes: A review", IEE Proceedings F (Communications,
Radar and Signal Processing), IET, pp. 451-464 (1981). 17.
processing cost as well as processing difficulties with
[19] Pavlov, V., Radome Materials, ONTI VIAM (All Union Institute for
balanced dielectric, magnetic thermal and mechanical Aircraft Materials), pp. 101-105 (1966)
properties. [20] Liu, Y., Cheng, L., Zhang, L., Xu, Y. and Liu, Y. “Design, preparation,
and structure of particle preformsforSi3N4(p)/Si3N4 radome composites
VI. ACKNOWLEDGMENT prepared using chemical vapour in ltration process", Journal of
University of Science and Technology Beijing, Mineral, Metallurgy,
The corresponding author gratefully acknowledges the support Material, 15(1), pp. 62- 66 (2008).
given by Sharda University and Central Electronics Limited
[21] Xu, J., Zhu, D., Luo, F., Zhou, W. and Li, P.Dielectric properties of
India. porous reaction-boned Si3N4 ceramics with controlled porosity and pore
size", Journal of Materials Science and Technology, pp 207-210 (2008)

Authorized licensed use limited to: Indian Institute Of Technology Jammu. Downloaded on March 25,2022 at 20:00:35 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like