Professional Documents
Culture Documents
UCSP - Q1 - Mod2 - Ethnocentrism and Cultural Relativism
UCSP - Q1 - Mod2 - Ethnocentrism and Cultural Relativism
Module in
Understanding
Culture, Society and
Politics
Quarter 1 _WEEK 3-4
What I Need to Know
This module was designed and written with you in mind. It is here to help you understand
culture, society, and politics. The scope of this module permits it to be used in many different
learning situations. The language used recognizes the diverse vocabulary level of the
students. The lessons are arranged to follow the standard sequence of the course. But the
order in which you read them can be changed to correspond with the textbook you are now
using.
1
What I Know
Directions: Choose the letter of the best answer and write it on a separate sheet of paper.
1. It assumes that each society has a unique and different form of culture that
cannot be judged into one’s own culture.
A. Ethnocentric View C. Historical Particularism
B. Cultural Relativism D. Participant Observation
2. James Rachel made a critical position about accepting cultural relativism.
Which among the following is NOT part of his claims about this perspective?
A. Moral progress is always questionable.
B. Objective criticism of one’s own culture is shallow.
C. Moral progress is slow because of acceptance of other’s culture.
D. Rightfulness of an action within a society is primarily determined by the moral
standards of that society.
3. American President Donald Trump made a “Pocahontas” joke at a ceremony honoring
Navajo native veterans. If were a cultural relativist, what advice would you give to Donald
Trump? Tell him that
A. different societies have different moral codes.
B. there are no moral truths that always holds for all people.
C. the moral code of a society determines what is right or wrong within the
society.
D. All of the above.
4. What strategy are you using when you take into account another person’s thoughts, values,
background, and perspectives while you interact with him/her?
A. Common Courtesy
B. Empathy
3
Lesson
Ethnocentrism and Cultural
1 Relativism
You learned the concepts and theories in Sociology, Anthropology, and
Political Science in the previous module. These new understandings will
equip you to have a better perspective on our society especially in dealing
with cultural and societal issues.
The idea of ethnocentrism and cultural relativism challenges the
pillars of anthropology and sociology in terms of universality and common
awareness. In this module, you will learn that reconciling ethnocentrism and
cultural relativism requires rigorous analysis in decision-making and critical
thinking.
What’s In
Loop-A-Term!
To prove your understanding from the past lesson, you should be ready to accomplish
this task. You may do the following.
Directions:
1. The 10 words listed below are hidden inside the grid. These words can run on all
possible directions – horizontally, vertically or diagonally.
2. Locate the words and circle them as you find them.
S N S C I T I L O P M S
E O D F C U L T U R E F
R R C D Q H A P A C H E
O M X I R E W O P C H I
M A N G E R S E S C J L
D R B N M T H O E G K E
S A G C M O Y R W J L B
K O L O E G A U G N A L
4
What’s New
Analyze the words and phrases listed inside the box as they will enable you to gain an
easier understanding and deeper appreciation of this lesson.
Figure 1. A new description of China, once called the region of Sina, by Ludovicus
Georgius (Courtesy of Wikimedia. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:CEM-
11-Chinae-nova-descriptio-2521.jpg
5
What is It
The concept of Ethnocentrism and Cultural Relativism has
been a critical issue of morality in our society for a long period of
time. With the complexities of these topics, it is helpful to analyze
the points of view of experts regarding this concern.
Ethnocentrism
Ethnocentrism is the view that one’s own cultural elements
such as norms, values, ideology, customs, and traditions are
dominant and superior to others (Brown, 2007).
William Graham Sumner (1906) coined the term ethnocentrism in his work Folkways
that served as the foundation in social analysis of every culture. According to his definition,
ethnocentrism is a technical name to see things in which one’s own cultural identity is the
center of everything over which all must be scaled, rated, and referred to. This perspective led
to conceited behavior and the belief of the superiority of one’s own group with great
prejudice to outsiders. While ethnocentrism takes universal stage, which propels cohesion
and continuity at all levels of social structure, it provides a rational explanation for attack
made on other culture or subculture in its extreme forms.
Sumner mentioned some characteristics of an individual with an ethnocentric view.
Ethnocentric persons -have a dominant cultural element which they see as superior
to other cultures;
view rigidly their own socio-economic, political, and cultural elements;
see their cultural elements as normal and acceptable to all;
consider in-group norms can be universalized;
discard out-group ethnicities and cultures;
believe that other cultures are inferior; and
look at other culture’s elements as inferior and unacceptable
It can be seen in Philippine society that ethnocentrism is still emerging. The sense of
identity seems to be a contributing reason for this. It goes deeper in our history that the
mixture of different cultures has created several identity marks
resulting in our diverse cultural heritage, both tangible and intangible. Also, our indigenous
culture can be categorized as old, non-advanced technology with no sense of modernity. After
the primitive age, we begin to be the melting pot of Western and Oriental cultures resulting in
a shaky and complex identity attributed to us today. With this characteristic, it is very
difficult to blend this type of indigenous culture to the fast-changing society.
6
Chin of (2016) made some observations on how to address this growing
concern on Filipino ethnocentrism.
1. Identify indigenous culture that truly reflects Filipino identity.
2. Eliminate foreign influences and stick to “home-grown" practices.
3. If we want to settle our identity, we must accept the good part of the foreign
influences that come to us.
Although colonization by the Spaniards, Americans, and Japanese has caused a shift
in several of our cultural, social, political, and economic policies, it made the Philippines a
single nation. Thus, the Philippines today stands strongly behind our acceptance of our
Filipino identity marked by our appreciation of foreign influences. Truly, it is difficult to do
away with these influences, because if we will totally disregard them, we will run the risk of
being left with nothing but purely our own native culture and tradition that may alienate us
from the globalized world. We need to acknowledge their part in the richness of the tapestry
that is the Filipino culture.
Cultural Relativism
Culture, just like a story, conveys different meanings and it can vary among the
people who created it. It poses a challenge to the idea that culture is the same for everyone.
Also, culture like a story has a life of its own. This notion rejects the concept of cultural
universality.
Cultural relativism refers to an
objective analysis of one’s own culture –
seeing and understanding of one’s beliefs and
traditions from his/her own point of view. It
also entails not to judge the practices of
others based on your own culture; hence,
respecting it in their own cultural context. For
example, you may find eating insects as an
unacceptable and a disgusting practice.
However, in Thailand, as well as parts of
Central
America like Mexico, it is considered a
delicacy. Instead of being prejudiced, one
can pose an interesting question like “Why do
some cultures eat fried insects?”
.
According to James Rachels (2003), the following claims have all been
made by cultural relativists:
1. Each society has a diverse set of moral conducts.
2. The rightfulness of an action within a society is primarily determined
by the moral standards of that society.
3. There is no objective standard that can be used as a basis of
comparison among societies.
4. The moral code of our own society is just part of a larger body of
morality and ethical standards.
5. High tolerance among all culture must be exercised always.
10
What’s More
18 September 2013
Quezon City – Koya… Ati… are a couple of dead giveaways that the speaker is
Bisaya (Visayan). Those from "down south," be it the Visayas or Mindanao group of islands,
who are living in Metropolitan Manila, take pains to hide their regional accent, lest they
become the butt of jokes. The famous Bisaya pronunciation is basically the switching of
vowel sounds: "e" to "I," "o" to "u," and vice versa — a very merry mix-up.
And since there are quite a lot of Visayans in greater Metro Manila, the accent is
heard almost everywhere every day. Tricycle drivers being interviewed by roving news
teams, senior executives chairing meetings, lawmakers at their filibustering best, salespeople
at the malls. In many a city scene, someone rolls the Visayan accent, and someone else
mimics it. Or giggles, at the least. The Bisaya sound is standard fare in radio, television, and
the movies — the stereotypical way of portraying housemaids or "hillbillies" who are new to
city life.
For Lisa, a housewife who has lived in the Land of Promise for more than 30 years,
moving to Manila in 1997 was one of the hardest adjustments she had ever made. Learning
the Tagalog language was tough for someone like her who was born and raised in Samal
Island province of Davao del Norte. She and her husband decided to move to the big city for
good to give their two daughters the good education they deserved. The moment they arrived
in Manila; her Mindanao twang suddenly needed a drastic makeover.
"Being a Bisaya in Manila was very challenging, especially during the first six
months. The traffic, pollution, and need to adjust to a new language that I wasn’t familiar with
were major difficulties. Every day I would get a headache from trying to converse in Tagalog
with my neighbors and people at the market. Honestly, I would have left the city the day after
we arrived were it not for my family," the Davao native explains.
Tagalog, on which Filipino, the national language, is based, is widely used on the
island of Luzon, particularly in the Metropolitan Manila area. Lisa's experience made her feel
that Bisaya was inferior to Tagalog. She was often misunderstood when buying an item at a
store, and she would often hear mocking comments about her quirky pronunciation. The most
disparaging remark she has ever heard is that Bisaya is “low-class” compared to Tagalog.
Perhaps this is because of the way TV portrays speakers of the language. But despite all the
discrimination she has endured, Lisa has maintained her equanimity among those who
ridiculed her language.
13
To learn Tagalog quickly, she tuned in to local radio stations and imitated the way
Tagalog was spoken. She read books and mingled with people to beef up her vocabulary. She
gained new friends who not only helped her adjust to the new language, but also assisted her
in coping with the stressful life in the city. In just six months, Lisa, who had spoken nothing
but Bisaya for more than 30 years before migrating to Manila, had managed to absorb the
new language and ditch her Visayan accent. She confesses, though, that the “funny” Visayan
accent still slips out from time to time. Nevertheless, she feels lucky and confident now about
her ability to communicate and switch back and forth between the two languages.
The truth is, no language is inferior or superior to another. Diversity is, after all, what
makes our country unique and attractive to many people around the world. Many Filipinos
are bilingual or even multilingual because the country boasts more than 100 languages or
dialects. We should all be proud of all of our languages.
Article 2:
Several Reasons Why Filipino Cuisine Is Among Least
Preferred Worldwide
By Jeline Malasig - March 20, 2019 -
6:03 PM
“We asked people which of 34 national cuisines they had tried and whether
they liked or disliked them, with Italian food being the most well-liked. The
cuisine received an average popularity score of 84% across the 24 nations
we studied,” Matthew Smith, a lead data journalist, reported. Other least favored
cuisines in the world are Saudia Arabian, Finnish and Peruvian.
14
Filipino cuisine is heavily influenced by different countries such as Spain, the United
States, China, India and other Southeast Asian nations. It is considered the original “Asian
fusion” before the concept existed, as stated by Smithsonian Magazine.
A food-oriented blog in July 2016 revealed various reasons as to why Filipino dishes
do not seem to appeal to foreigners despite international features about it. JP Anglo, a chef
and patron at Sara Kitchen, noted that “Pinoy ingredients are hard to come by outside of the
Philippines.” “You can’t get tuba, Batwan etc. overseas. Even the lemon grass tastes
different,” he shared. Myke Sarthou, a chef and cookbook author, attributed it to the
complexity of the cuisine as a whole.
According to him, Filipino cuisine does not merely mix and match ingredients and
different cooking methods of foreign dishes. One must also understand how the “perspectives
and philosophies” of various cultures blend as well. This makes the Filipino cuisine difficult
to describe in just a line or two, he said. Sarthou also claimed that the country lacks the
“marketing and business acumen” required to make local dishes popular in a global sense, as
well as the Philippines’ lack of support in the agricultural sector. “To make a cuisine shine
globally, it should be backed by a strong agricultural sector which is evidently weak in the
country,” the chef said.
A restaurant owner based in New York City attributed it to the Filipinos’ supposed
lack of entrepreneurial skills necessary to make the cuisine recognized in the international
market. “We were not raised to be entrepreneurs. We were raised to be doctors, lawyers —
risk-averse careers,” Nicole Ponseca said. She speculated that it might be due to the Filipinos’
sense of shame towards their own cuisine brought about by being heavily colonized for so
many centuries. “That’s why [some restaurants] give the ‘white-man menu’ [to customers]
because they think they’re not going to like dinuguan, which is a pork blood stew,” Ponseca
said. “It is because when you’re colonized over so many years, you don’t value your own
culture, even though we have so much pride,” she continued.
14
What I Can Do
Activity 3.4 World Ethnocentrism
Ethnocentrism is a worldview that can be observed in several countries. To see this,
do the following activity using the given guide questions.
Ethnocentric Views
Countries
Culture Society Politics
Japan
China
United Kingdom
3. Why do you think they have these ethnocentric practices? What benefit can
they get from doing these?
4. As a Filipino, what practices or values you are proud of that are worth sharing
with others?
5. How will you promote these values and practices?
15
Assessment
Activity 3.5 World Ethnocentrism
Multiple Choice. Choose the letter of the best answer. Write the chosen letter on a separate
sheet of paper.
1. What is an attempt to judge behavior according to its own cultural context?
A. Cultural Identity C. Culture Shock
B. Culture Indoctrination D. Culture Relativism
2. Which among the choices is true about the statements on Cultural Relativism?
3. Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar are said to be illegal immigrants and described as the
“world’s most persecuted people”. What kind of inequality is BEST described in this
situation?
A. Gender inequality, because it is characterized by having some people
deprived of privileges.
B. Social inequality, because they experience unequal access to various
resources and privileges.
C. Global inequality, because a discriminatory practice in the community can
cause a significant alarm in a global scale.
D. Ethnic minority inequality, because their civil, political, economic, social, and
cultural rights are violated due to discrimination based on their ethnicity.
4. Which among the following is NOT an original Filipino culture?
A. Eating pork adobo
B. Bayanihan practice
C. Dancing to K-POP songs
D. Watching Ramon Obusan’s shows.
5. Karen used to tease her newly transferred Mangyan classmate because of his kinky
hair and tanned skin. What kind of cultural view did Karen have?
A. Culture B. Cultural Relativism C. Ethnocentrism D. Society
6. In New Zealand, broadcasters refuse to stop using Maori language despite
complaints from English speakers. Respecting the language of others is MOST
significant because
A. it is used to understand each other.
B. it relates to a person’s interaction with others and the world.
C. it is the basic tool of communication and transmission of culture and is known
as the storehouse of culture.
D. it is attached to the people’s historical and cultural roots which served as their
identity as members of society.
16
7. Understanding female circumcision as a significant rite of passage for women as
opposed to a kind of mutilation is an example of _.
A. Agency C. Enlightenment
B. Cultural relativism D. Ethnocentrism
8. Learning to take the role of the other person gives one the ability to see the
perspective of the other before articulating or giving judgement. To do this, it is
MOST important to
A. study the cultural context where the action occurs. B.
look into the reasoning behind any cultural element.
C. determine the circumstances of place, time, and condition surrounding
it.
D. all of the above.
9. The feeling of stress and anxiety that most people experience when encountering a
culture different from their own is referred to as
.
A. Acculturation C. Ethnocentrism
B. Culture Shock D. Enculturation
10.Who coined the term ethnocentrism which served as the foundation in social analysis
of every culture?
A. Edward Tylor B. Emile Durkheim C. Max Weber D. William Sumner
Additional Activities
Activity 3.6 PINOY AKO! Pinoy Tayo! The Ethnocentric Encounters
We cannot avoid ethnocentric views and practices because of our diverse cultural
backgrounds and limited knowledge of the culture of others. You can clearly see some of
these common manifestations of ethnocentrism in your own community. To have a clear
grasp of this concept, you perform this task.
You may do the following:
1. Think of Filipino ethnocentric practices you have encountered in your
community or in your life.
2. You can present these observations through a semantic web.
3. Write your answer on a separate sheet of paper.
Filipino ethnocentrism
17
Activity 3.7 PINOY AKO! Pinoy Tayo! The Ethnocentric Encounters
Think About This!
References
Online Sources
Coping with the Bisaya Accent. (2013, Sept. 18). Retrieved from
http://www.ethnicgroupsphilippines.com/2013/09/18/coping-with-the- bisaya-accent/
Malasig, J. (2019, Mar 20). Several Reasons Why Filipino Cuisine is Among Least
Preferred Worldwide. Retrieved from
https://www.interaksyon.com/trends- spotlights/2019/03/20/146043/several-reasons-why-
filipino-cuisine-is- among-least-preferred-worldwide/
18
Becoming a member of society
1. Enculturation/Socialization
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
“THE HUMAN MIND AT BIRTH IS NOTHING BUT A BLANK STATE, OR TABULA RASA” - JOHN
LOCKE
SOCIALIZATION
• Lifelong process of social interaction through which people acquire their identities and necessary survival
skills in society.
• It is considered as the central process of social life and is also a process of member recruitment and
replacement.
• Enables the person to gradually become a self – aware and knowledgeable human being, and learn the ways,
values, rules, and culture of his / her society.
• Greatly influenced by the context of his /her respective society, and the social groups that he/she interact
Three Goals of Socialization
ENCULTURATION
• Process of being socialized into a specific culture. Individuals learn cultural symbols, norms, values, and
language by observing and interacting with family, friends, and the rest of society.
This process is characterized by Mead as the "I" and the "me. " The "me" is the social self and the "I" is the
response to the "me. " In other words, the "I" is the response of an individual to the attitudes of others, while
the "me" is the organized set of attitudes of others which an individual assumes.
Play
• The child takes different roles he/she observes in “adult” society and plays them out to gain an understanding
of the different social roles.
• The child learns to become both subject and object and begins to become able to build a self
Game
• The child must take the role of everyone else involved in the game.
• Organizations begin and definite personalities start to emerge
“The Generalized Other”
• The individual understands what kind of behavior is expected or appropriate in different social settings
The development of an individual’s distinct personality, which is regarded as a persisting entity in a particular
stage of life by which a person is recognized or known Identity FormationIdentity FormationIdentity
Formation
SELF CONCEPT
• The sum of a being’s knowledge and understanding of his/herself.
• Components: – Physical – Psychological – Social attributes
Cultural Identity
• The Identification with a certain ethnicity, usually on the basis of a presumed common genealogy or ancestry
National Identity
Is an ethical and philosophical concept whereby all humans divided into groups called nation.
Religious Identity
• Is the set of beliefs and practices generally held by an individual involving adherence to codified beliefs and
rituals
Norms
• Is a rule that guides the behavior of members of a society or group.
Things that exist in society independent of individuals and that shape our thoughts and behavior.
• Refers to what we perceive as normal, or what we think should be normal, regardless of whether it actually
is
Values
• Culturally defined standards that people use to decide what is desirable, good, and beautiful and that serve as
broad guidelines for social living.
• “We can deal with anyone, we need to know who the person is”
Status
• Social position a person takes on voluntarily that reflects personal identity and effort.
Role
Role Manipulation
Conformity involves the acceptance of the cultural goals and means of attaining those goals.
Deviance is a behavior that violates the standards of conduct or expectations or social norms of a group or
society. Alcoholics, gamblers, sex deviants, drug addicts or latecomers in the class are all classified as
deviants or deviant acts.
FORMS OF DEVIANCE
Ritualism is a concept developed by American sociologist Robert K. Merton as a part of his
structural strain theory. It refers to the common practice of going through the motions of daily life
even though one does not accept the goals or values that align with those practices.
Retreatism is the attitude of being resigned to the abandonment of an original goal or the means of
attaining it (as in political or cultural matters)
Rebellion is a special case wherein the individual rejects both the cultural goals and traditional means
of achieving them but actively attempts to replace both elements of the society with different goals
and means.
Innovation involves the acceptance of the goals of a culture but the rejection of the traditional and/or
legitimate means of attaining those goals. For example, a member of the Mafia values wealth but
employs alternative means of attaining his wealth; in this example, the Mafia member’s means would
be deviant.
Social Control involves teaching, persuading, and or forcing members and non-members of a group to
comply with and not deviate from its norms and expectations.
The idea of criminal behaviors are learned; criminals are considered conformists when they tend to conform to
the groups in which they associate themselves.
In other words, one may learn deviant behavior based on their association.
Gossip for social control in natural and artificial societies. In this work, we propose a theory of
gossip as a means for social control. Exercising social control roughly means to isolate and to punish
cheaters.
Social Ostracism increases social susceptibility. Ostracism, the act of ignoring and excluding, is a
universally applied tactic of social control. Individuals who detect ostracism often change their
behaviors to be readmitted into the group, even if it means becoming excessively socially susceptible
to influence
Law. Social control entails rules of behavior that should be followed by the members of society.
Some of the rules of conduct fall into the realm of good manners as the culture defines them. Other
rules of conduct are not optional and are enforced by-laws
Social control by the use of reward is known as positive reinforcement. In society and the laws and
regulations implemented by the government tend to focus on punishment or enforcing negative
sanctions to act as a deterrent as a means of social control.
Human Dignity refers to an individual or group's sense of self-respect and self-worth, physical and
psychological integrity and empowerment.
Bill of Rights
natural rights, civil rights, political rights, economic rights as well as rights of the accused before, during and
after trial.
Human rights
Are rights inherent to all human beings, whatever our nationality, place of residence, sex, national or ethnic
origin, color, religion, language, or any other status.
Common good, which benefits society as a whole, in contrast to the private good of individuals and sections
of society. In effect, the notion of the common good is a denial that society is and should be composed of
atomized individuals living in isolation from one another
Share: